We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›

Hospital Staff

Summary

Deputy Aird challenged the lack of contracts and start dates for 36 newly qualified nurses awaiting posts at Portlaoise, Mullingar and Tullamore, questioning recruitment controls and agency spending. Minister of State Murnane O’Connor said there is no recruitment embargo, cited approval for the graduate posts requested by the Dublin and midlands region, but gave no specific dates for the 36 nurses. She undertook to seek an answer from the HSE and Department and to raise a frozen Laois occupational therapist vacancy.

I am raising the concerns of 36 newly qualified nurses who have completed their university education, undertaken clinical placements and obtained professional registration. They are still waiting for contracts and commencement dates for positions at the midlands regional hospitals in Portlaoise, Mullingar and Tullamore. These graduates completed their HSE recruitment process in June. They are qualified, registered and ready to work but they are unclear about when they can begin their careers. How has this situation been allowed to arise? In February 2024, the HSE announced that nursing and midwifery graduates would be offered permanent employment following completion of their courses and their placements. That commitment was reinforced through engagement with the unions in 2025. These graduates had every reason to expect a clear route to employment. Some have signed rental agreements and made financial commitments in anticipation of starting work.

I appreciate that the HSE operates within an allocated budget. However, financial controls must be aligned with workforce planning and the safe delivery of healthcare. It is unacceptable that recruitment campaigns proceed without clear commencement dates. There is also the question of value for money. If the midlands hospitals have nursing vacancies, they are relying on agency nurses while qualified graduates are waiting for permanent employment. Can the HSE explain why permanent appointments cannot proceed and whether agency expenditure represents the best use of public funds? I also want clarity on accountability. Under the HSE regional structure, responsibility for staffing and budgets has been devolved to health regions. If hospitals are identifying staffing needs but cannot make appointments due to financial restrictions, who has the authority to resolve this problem?

The Minister's statement on 15 October indicated that there is no general recruitment embargo but there are strengthened controls in four health regions. What controls affect graduate nurses' appointments to the three midlands hospitals? It is welcome that 974 graduate nurses and midwifes nationally have confirmed start days. I welcome that approximately 834 are expected to commence before the end of the year. That is progress, but it does not address the circumstances of these 36 graduates. I am asking the Minister of State to address these matters directly. First, can she immediately clarify to me when these 36 graduates will be offered contracts and commencement dates? Second, will she ask the HSE to provide a breakdown of approved and funded vacancies at Portlaoise, Tullamore and Mullingar?

Third, what safeguards will be introduced to ensure future graduate recruitment campaigns are properly aligned with funding posts and working requirements?

We want nurses to build their careers in Ireland and make a contribution to our health service. We cannot invest in training healthcare professionals and then force them to find employment abroad. These graduates deserve certainty about when they can begin their careers. I have asked the Minister of State questions and would appreciate the answers.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Aird for the opportunity to address the House on staffing matters within the HSE, particularly the issue of contracts for graduate nurses and midwives. I am taking this Topical Issue on behalf of the Minister for Health, Deputy Carroll MacNeill. The Deputy can be assured I will take his concerns back to her.

The HSE knows how many nurses and midwives are due to graduate each year, and must plan its recruitment accordingly. Retaining these graduate nurses and midwives is essential to the future of the health service and continues to be a priority for the Minister. However, recruitment must also be strategic, matching graduates to the services and locations where the need is greatest while being aware of the impact on the overall pay bill. The latest data provided by the HSE indicates that nationally, there are 1,375 graduate nurses and midwives, of whom 1,145 have been offered positions to date, with more than 1,000 accepting. This equates to a national offer rate of 83%.

The Deputy’s health region, the Dublin and midlands region, has advised there are 105 graduate nurses and midwives, of whom 97 have been offered positions and 88 have accepted. This means that more than 92% of graduates in the region have received an employment offer. In addition, the Department issued approval last week for the recruitment of all remaining graduate nurses and midwives included in the submission received from the Dublin and midlands region. This approval was granted in response to the applications received the previous week.

There is no recruitment embargo in the HSE, and recruitment has not been stopped. Strengthened recruitment controls are in place in four regions, including Dublin and the midlands, to ensure that appointments are affordable, properly prioritised, and directed to areas of greatest patient need and service need. I was concerned to hear recent reports that offers made to newly qualified nurses were subsequently withdrawn or delayed. The Deputy raised this issue. This is not acceptable and is not how we should be treating our graduates. The HSE must make every effort to provide employment opportunities for nursing and midwifery graduates but it is important that offers are made in the right locations with the necessary approvals in place.

A key part of this strategic approach must be to prioritise direct recruitment into services where vacancies are being filled through sustained agency usage. Nationally, agency expenditure was €536 million in the eight months to the end of August, 11.7% above budget limits. Recruiting graduates directly into roles currently being filled through agency staffing would help retain newly qualified professionals in the public health service, build a more stable permanent workforce, support safe care and service capacity, and deliver better value for the overall pay bill.

This is against a backdrop of sustained investment in the health workforce. HSE staffing has increased by almost 30,000 whole-time equivalents since December 2020, with nursing and midwifery accounting for a substantial share of that growth, up 9,924 over the same period. The priority must now be to build on that investment by retaining graduate nurses and midwives, strengthening the permanent workforce, and reducing reliance on agency staffing, while ensuring recruitment remains aligned with service need and the overall pay bill.

The Department is engaging closely with the HSE to monitor the recruitment of graduate nurses and midwives. While individual appointments, contracts and commencement dates are operational matters for the HSE, the Department expects these decisions to be processed promptly and graduates to be given clear and timely information regarding an employment offer.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for her response, but I must bring my question back to the immediate circumstances of the 36 new nursing graduates. These are qualified, registered nurses who have completed their training and successfully progressed through the HSE recruitment process. Their question is simple: when will they start work? I refute what the Minister of State has said. I am too long on the road to accept it. These 36 nurses are out there and still do not have contracts of employment. I need specific answers from the Minister of State about Portlaoise, Tullamore and Mullingar. Can she confirm that the HSE will urgently review the 36 cases, identify the approved and funded vacancies and provide realistic commencement dates? I also want transparency around staffing costs. Are these hospitals paying for agency nurses while qualified graduates are waiting to take up permanent positions? If so, is that financially justifiable?

There is a wider lesson here. The HSE knows how many nursing students are completing their courses each year. Workforce needs are predictable. I am not asking for appointments to unfunded posts. I am suggesting that graduate recruitment must be properly co-ordinated with hospital staffing requirements and available funding.

I also raise the position of a children's occupational therapist in County Laois, which has been vacant for three years and has been frozen yet again. This position was recruited and accepted, but the offer has now been withdrawn by the HSE. In a week where two families from County Laois have already approached me about occupational therapy services for their children, I find this situation to be totally unacceptable. I am asking the Minister of State to investigate this vacancy as a matter of urgency and to revert to me on behalf of the children of County Laois.

Comment on this

I again thank the Deputy for raising this important issue. It is important for us to get out the information. Retaining newly qualified nurses and midwives is essential to the future of the health services and remains a clear priority. The latest figures show that 83% of graduates nationally have received employment offers and more than 1,000 have accepted them. Work is continuing to offer posts to the remaining graduates and to confirm start dates. I will read this out to the Deputy again. There is no-----

Comment on this

There is no point in reading it back.

Comment on this

-----recruitment embargo.

Comment on this

What about the 36?

Comment on this

Recruitment has not stopped.

Comment on this

The Department issued approval last week to recruit all graduate nurses and midwives that the Dublin and midlands regions have requested. That is the information I am giving here.

Comment on this

What does the Minister of State mean by "requested"? There are still 36 nurses there with no offer.

Comment on this
Mattie McGrath An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Independent

The Minister of State without interruption.

Comment on this

Last week there were decisions-----

Comment on this

You know-----

Comment on this
Mattie McGrath An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Independent

Please, a Theachta.

Comment on this

Those 36 nurses are still unemployed.

Comment on this
Mattie McGrath An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Independent

Please.

Comment on this

Last week, decisions were made in that regard. I understand. I know. My daughter is a nurse so I understand.

Comment on this

I confirmed that this morning, to be fair.

Comment on this
Mattie McGrath An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Independent

Speak through the Chair, please.

Comment on this

I confirmed it this morning.

Comment on this

Yes, I am right.

Comment on this

He needs that information. As I said, the HSE must make every effort to provide employment opportunities for graduates. As I said, last week, all graduate nurses and midwives that the Dublin and midlands regions have requested have been sorted. With regard to the 36 nurses the Deputy has asked about specifically, I will ensure he gets an answer from the HSE and the Department of Health. The Deputy also spoke about an occupational therapist. I will certainly bring back that issue to the Minister and the HSE.

I thank the Deputy. All of us must appreciate the great work that our nurses and staff do. It is important for us. The Deputy can be sure, and I can say this on my behalf and on the behalf of the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, that all of us in the Department of Health are committed to getting this sorted.

Comment on this

Is the Minister of State saying to me-----

Comment on this

I will come back to the Deputy.

Comment on this

-----that she will come back to me about the 36 nurses?

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State.

Comment on this