Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›
Youth Unemployment
Youth unemployment has risen to about 12%, prompting concern about regional disadvantage, graduate hiring and barriers such as transport, housing and limited work experience. The Minister highlighted employment subsidies, training and apprenticeships, while both speakers supported stronger pathways into sustainable jobs and preparing young people for technological change.
I thank the Minister of State, Deputy Dillon, for taking this issue. He will be aware that the economy is doing well and, in general terms, we talk about the fact that we have full employment. However, I have a serious concern that the rate of youth unemployment is beginning to creep up again.
Youth unemployment is defined as unemployment among those aged between 15 and 24. It is now recorded at 11.5%. That is lower than the EU average but I still believe the reason it is at that rate must be a cause for concern. We need to examine the factors behind that and to examine in detail whether there are specific sectors of society and the economy where this is acute. The evidence, although it is not detailed, is that we have a number of urban pockets of disadvantage. It is particularly acute in some of the regions, especially along the Border, in the north west and in the midlands. There is a problem with recent graduates, especially in certain fields. Some of that relates to the experience trap but it is also evidence that we are not seeing the same level of graduate recruitment in certain areas as we did. I have a particular concern about this because it means young people do not have the experience of work that they should have but also that they may become increasingly alienated from the broader society. The rate in Ireland is 11.5% but the EU rate is 15.5%. In countries like Romania, the rate is 30% while in France and Italy the rate is now above 20%. In France there is obviously a particular concern about alienation among that young cohort. Something that particularly frightened me was that in the most recent polling in France voters aged 18 to 24 are turning to the populists as 45% of them said they would back Mélenchon in the next presidential election and 30% said they would back Le Pen. When groups of young people are not given the opportunity so many of us have had of a first job, of training, of an apprenticeship or of going into work as a graduate, then people become alienated.
What can we do to address this? The reasons people become unemployed are complex. To the Tánaiste's point, I agree work should always pay and people who are going to work should always be rewarded but it is not a simple matter that people are necessarily refusing employment. There has been a lot of very good work done on this by the National Youth Council of Ireland and youth organisations, including Gorey Youth Needs Group from my area. In resolving this issue, which we need to both tackle and get data on, it is critical to have the voices of young people. There are concerns for young people about transport costs and housing costs near employment. It is a challenge in rural areas. If the cost of going to a job is too significant, it may not make sense to take it up. There remains a concern about the number of hours given to some young people when it comes to employment. I am quite supportive of Mandate's campaign that everybody who is working should be guaranteed a reasonable number of hours in order to make that employment sustainable.
There is the danger of young people being stigmatised if they have been unemployed for a period and we have to address that. We need to look at what measures we can put in place to be able to provide the supports. I look forward to hearing the Minister of State's analysis and also to offering some solutions.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Byrne for raising this important issue. lreland’s labour market continues to perform strongly, with record employment of over 2.8 million people last year. This reflects the resilience of a strong economy and the success of government policies in supporting job creation, fostering innovation and providing opportunities across sectors for young people to begin exciting careers.
However, there has been a slowdown in momentum over the past year, consistent with an uncertain and volatile international macroeconomic environment, tighter monetary policy and a labour market that is close to capacity. It is often younger workers who feel the effects of economic uncertainty most acutely. The unemployment rate among those aged 15 to 24 has increased over the past year to approximately 12%, which is more than twice the economy-wide average. However, this increase remains modest and Ireland continues to perform well compared with our European peers. Having said that, it is really important we continue to focus on measures that help young people make the transition from education into sustainable employment.
The Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment works closely with other Departments on this issue, in particular with the Department of Social Protection through the implementation of Pathways to Work, the Government's strategy for employment services and labour market activation.
The Deputy referred to employment incentives. The Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment and its agencies will continue promoting employer awareness to encourage uptake of supports such as the work placement experience programme and the expanded JobsPlus subsidy scheme, whereby employers can receive financial support when recruiting eligible jobseekers, helping to reduce hiring costs while also creating opportunities for those with limited work experience.
With respect to PRSI, budget 2027 included an increase in the employer PRSI threshold from €552 to €600 per week, helping employers manage labour costs and support recruitment, particularly in sectors that employ significant numbers of younger workers. The Department of Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science leads on training and skills development which are equally important in addressing the challenges and through apprenticeships, Skillnet Ireland, SOLAS programmes, Springboard+ and Skills to Advance, the Government continues to invest in pathways that will continue to provide people with the skills required by a modern economy.
Comment on this
I welcome some of the moves on employers' PRSI. We should definitely give more incentives in that area to employers who decide to take on young people. Byrne's bookshops that operate in my home town and home county give good hours to young people but there is a huge cost on the PRSI side and we need to address it.
We need to look more generally. I am conscious that the Minister of State talked about work placements. If we look at the lowest rates of youth unemployment across Europe, they are in Germany and Czechia, where they are about 6.5% to 7.5%. As he knows, there is a far greater emphasis there on academic and vocational tracks in education. Young people get the opportunity to work in a company. Businesses, along with the trade unions, are involved in designing the training that goes into some of these job placements. Particularly given the transformational nature of AI and other new technologies in what is happening, it is critical that we have a programme in place whereby young people can get the necessary experience because frequently when they apply for a job they fall into what is called the experience trap and they do not get the opportunities to be able to progress.
We should look perhaps at summer programmes that will allow young people to be able to improve skills. We also need to look at further measures in SUSI, where young people are working. In fairness to the Minister, Deputy James Lawless, he has made a number of improvements there but it should not be a disincentive that if a young person wants to do additional work to gain money and experience that they should not be disadvantaged in terms of the SUSI grant. My overall point is that we should be concerned that we are starting to see the rate of youth unemployment creep up and I believe it should be a priority for the Minister of State’s Department.
Comment on this
I again thank Deputy Byrne for raising this important matter. As Minister of State with responsibility for employment, I acknowledge the concerns he has raised here this afternoon. Ireland continues to have a strong labour market, record employment and significant opportunities for young people. Our focus now is very much to give every young person the skills, experience and also the opportunity to secure a good quality job, build a career and build for a future in Ireland.
At the same, the Deputy mentioned AI. I do not think we can pretend that it is not changing the labour market; it is, but the challenge for the Government is not to resist the technological change but to ensure that young people are prepared and can benefit from it. That is why we are investing in skills, apprenticeships, lifelong learning and digital capability to ensure that young people are equipped to secure jobs into the future. When we talk to many young people, they do not want temporary schemes; they want real jobs and careers.
Part of that is ensuring that we have the pathways from education into employment and ensuring that employers have the confidence to hire young people. That is why we are supporting both businesses and workers in that regard. The best guarantee that any Government can give is that the economy continues to be supported through real and proper policy but also that creates opportunities.