We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›

Public Transport

Summary

Deputies highlighted severe overcrowding and safety concerns on commuter and intercity trains, calling for more carriages on Kildare and Waterford routes and an earlier Waterford service. The Minister cited increased public transport funding and said new trains would begin entering service in 2027, with Irish Rail currently using all available trains.

I am glad the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, is here for this discussion. The roads are congested. The N7 is bumper to bumper. Journey times have doubled from Portlaoise to Dublin. We are supposed to be reducing our carbon emissions but we need to give people options. At the moment the option is using trains or buses but the problem is that the trains are packed. Trains from Ballybrophy, Portlaoise and Portarlington going to Dublin are full. It is a success story in a way, in that there are crowds of people on the platforms in Portlaoise, Ballybrophy and Portarlington when there used to be half a dozen going back a few short years ago. The number of passengers has increased dramatically. However, the number of carriages has reduced. One train that used to have five carriages now has three carriages. We have fewer carriages. People are standing in corridors and sitting on the floor. That is okay for a short trip. I heard a Minister say recently that we can expect that across Europe. That is okay on commuter trains within a city or wherever for ten minutes or half an hour or on the London tube but when a passenger is there for hours like that, it is not good enough and it is unsafe. People with disabilities are struggling. For people who have a guide dog with them or for people in wheelchairs, it is really difficult. We need to be giving people a little bit of safety and comfort.

I want the Minister of State to focus on this. I know he takes public transport seriously. I welcome that he has focused in on it since he has taken over as Minister for State but he needs to give this a razor-like sharpness. Is money approved for new carriages? How many new carriages will there be? When will see those new carriages on the tracks?

The CEO of Iarnród Éireann, Mary Constine, said that everything the body has is rolling - everything that is fit to roll. Are there carriages that need to be reconditioned that can be used in the short term? What can be done? Do not tell me that it is an operational matter. Everything is an operational matter but the Government writes the cheque. The Government needs to ensure that all resources that we have are being utilised.

Comment on this

I, too, am glad to see the Minister of State in front of us today. I have been raising this for the past number of months. I have engaged with the Minister of State previously on this. Over the past number of weeks, more and more commuters are coming to me daily. More and more commuters are experiencing hardship and overcrowding on our commuter lines. It is growing daily. Some of the stories that I have put on the record of this Dáil are horrific. Today, I want to put more stories on the record of real life experiences. One commuter said:

I am 20 weeks pregnant and struggling to get a seat, often left standing in the carriages. I have had two episodes now where I have had to get off the train because I felt dizzy and I felt faint due to the claustrophobic and warm nature of the trains.

That is just one example. The next example stated:

I travelled to Dublin Heuston five days a week. The majority of the time I stand on my way to and from where I begin in Newbridge. Yesterday, I did experience an episode where I felt like collapsing. I was absolutely drained before the working day even began. This is followed by the same experience on the train that I take home.

This is happening on a daily basis on the lines that go through my county of Kildare.

I have questions for the Minister of State. When will see proper health and safety introduced on these lines? As my colleague asked, when are going to see new carriages? From all the parliamentary questions that I put down, I am informed that a number of carriages will be freed up in the middle of next year. What we need to see are those carriages coming onto the Waterford line and the lines going through County Kildare because it is an issue with so many commuters at the moment. When can we see an early train on the Waterford line so that people can get into work on time? I put on the record here before, and I am going to do it again, that a doctor working in St. James's Hospital who gets the train from hometown from Athy each morning cannot get into work for 8 a.m.

That is unacceptable in this day and age and needs to change.

Comment on this
Seán Canney Minister of State at the Department of Transport Independent

I thank the Deputies for raising the issue of overcrowding on mainline rail, Luas and some bus services, in addition to the ongoing overcrowding on train lines serving Kildare South, including the Waterford, Limerick, Galway, Athlone, Portlaoise and Kilkenny lines. Deputy Stanley will not agree with my response. I have responsibility for transport but my officials are not involved in day-to-day operations. That does not mean that we are not taking responsibility. The statutory responsibility for securing public transport services rests with the National Transport Authority, NTA. It works with the public transport operators which deliver the services. That said, I want to reassure the Deputies that the Government is strongly committed to providing all citizens with reliable and realistic sustainable mobility options, and public transport plays a key role in the delivery of this goal.

To support this objective, in budget 2026 the Department of Transport secured €940 million for public service obligation, PSO, and TFI Local Link services, an increase from €658 million in 2025. As announced in this year's budget, we are investing over €1 billion in public transport services that people rely on every day, with €1.042 billion allocated to PSO services across our bus, light rail and heavy rail networks. This represents an 11% increase in the PSO. The funding is about more than maintaining existing services and will also support the continued expansion and enhancement of our public transport network, with almost 140 new and enhanced services in the planning pipeline for 2027 across our flagship programmes such as Connecting Ireland, BusConnects and new town services. Separately, this investment includes almost €60 million in capital funding to maintain and renew our rail assets, including essential rolling stock and equipment to keep our rail network safe, reliable and fit for the future.

I understand the Deputies want to discuss overcrowding on public transport services. I would like to inform the Deputies that the NTA and Irish Rail have established a working group to jointly plan and implement changes and enhancements to the rail timetable. As part of the planning process, the NTA has also run public consultations to gauge the public response to changes to services and inform the demand for, and priority of, future potential enhancements. Iarnród Éireann saw record passenger numbers in 2025 of over 55 million passenger journeys, a figure that is growing further in 2026. To address this, it has confirmed to the Department it currently operates all available trains on a daily basis, outside of the required maintenance cycles to ensure reliability and to deal with any repairs which may be taking place. It is maximising use of their rolling stock to meet demand and will continue to monitor passenger loadings.

Irish Rail confirmed it recognises that this is creating pressure on capacity on some services at the busiest times at present. While its trains are busy, they are designed to safely accommodate full loading at our busiest times, although it appreciates this can be uncomfortable. In addition, it is pleased to advise that new trains will begin entering the system in 2027, which will provide extra capacity on the network.

To date, 285 new DART carriages have been ordered and Irish Rail has confirmed that the first order of 95 carriages will directly benefit the Drogheda line, with 65 battery electric carriages and the existing DART+ line. However, this will also allow Intercity and commuter trains currently operating on the Drogheda line to be used on other routes around the network, including commuter routes. Their deployment will be subject to review with, and the approval of, the NTA, subject to demand and infrastructure capacity at the time. This process will be repeated with the introduction of a further 90 battery electric carriages, freeing up existing trains, while the remaining 100 electric carriages will ultimately replace the original DART fleet, which has been in operation since 1984.

Comment on this

It is welcome that new carriages have been ordered but it is just one statistic from working groups in Iarnród Éireann and the NTA. Ultimately, the Minister writes the cheque and the more convoluted the process is the further it gets away from everybody, including those of us in here. The Minister of State needs to ensure that there has been delivery on the money that has been provided. I welcome that there is extra funding but we are trying to get people off the roads and onto rail, and make it easier for them to do so. The Minister of State has to make sure this happens and the process is followed through on. Sometimes the doors of the Luas trams will not close because so many people are trying to squeeze onto them. It is not a safe situation.

I ask the Minister of State again to look at the situation with higher fares. He may say that fares have to be increased, but 15% in the month of January when the bills start coming in on top of everything else is excessive. I ask for the Minister of State's Department to go back and look at that again.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for his reply. I want to draw his attention to what he said to us. He said that the trains were designed to safely accommodate full loading at the busiest times. I have given the Minister of State examples of people standing on top of one another. If one of those trains stops urgently, what is going to happen to those people? These are the questions I am being asked. That is why I am asking the Minister of State to address the health and safety issues that are on these trains, which are so overcrowded.

Labour has introduced a Bill on remote working to try to allow more people to work remotely. That is a solution that the Government needs to look at. I will repeat that we need to see extra carriages being put onto those trains on the Waterford line to allow early trains and to remove the burden on the current number of carriages. There are plenty of houses being built in south Kildare, but we do not have the facilities for them. We need to see those carriages installed as quickly as possible.

I appeal to the Minister of State to look at the health and safety issues. I appeal to him to try to get those carriages on that line from Waterford, Carlow and Athy to Dublin as quickly as possible.

Comment on this

What we are talking about here is pressure on our rail lines. It just shows how important the rail network is and how it has been growing over the years. Twenty years ago, we were closing rail lines. Now, we are opening them up. We need to invest in the carriages to make sure that people have a good experience and continue using public transport. That is what we are doing. From next year, we will have additional carriages coming on stream. Additional carriages will be going onto the commuter lines and the intercity lines because we are bringing in more new carriages. This is a good news story.

I say to people that I understand the pressure they are under when they are in these carriages, which are packed. I see more students using the rail network, which is why there are peak times for them as well. If we get students using rail and they get used to it and have a good experience, they will probably never have to buy a car. That is the end goal. We have to keep working at it.

I thank the Deputies for their contributions today and for their support in making sure Irish Rail continues to do its work safely.

Comment on this