Written answer
Compulsory Purchase Orders
320. Deputy John Connolly asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance whether any compensation paid to a person arising from the compulsory acquisition of that person's principal private residence by way of a compulsory purchase order is subject to taxation; if so, to specify which elements of such compensation are taxable, including compensation for the property itself, disturbance, severance, injurious affection, accommodation loss or other associated payments; the tax heads under which such compensation is taxed, including capital gains tax, income tax or any other tax; and the applicable rates of taxation. [78960/26]
Comment on this
I am informed by Revenue that the acquisition of a property by way of compulsory purchase order (CPO) comprises the disposal of that property for the purposes of Capital Gains Tax (CGT). Any chargeable gain arising on such a disposal is subject to CGT at 31%. The first €1,270 of total chargeable gains in respect of an individual in any year of assessment is exempt from CGT.
It is the amount of the chargeable gain, if any, arising on the disposal of an asset which is subject to CGT. In these circumstances, the chargeable gain is calculated as the difference between the proceeds received in respect of the property by way of CPO and the price paid for the property (or in certain circumstances, the market value at the time of acquisition). A deduction may be claimed for certain costs incurred in acquiring and disposing of the property such as stamp duty, legal fees, auctioneers’ fees.
For CGT purposes, the chargeable gain, if any, arising on the disposal of a property by way of CPO is deemed to accrue on the day on which the payment of the compensation amount is received by the person making the disposal. Any CGT liability arising in respect of such a disposal will be payable by reference to that date.
If the property acquired by way of CPO was occupied by the owner as his or her principal private residence (PPR), then full or partial relief from CGT will be available where a chargeable gain arises on the disposal of that property.
Section 604 of the Taxes Consolidation Act (TCA) 1997 provides relief from CGT on the disposal of one’s PPR. If the property is occupied by an individual as their PPR for all or part of their period of ownership, then full or partial relief from CGT will be available where a chargeable gain arises on the disposal of that property, including by way of CPO. The last 12 months of ownership of the PPR by the individual is treated as a period of occupation for the purpose of this relief.
Where the property was not occupied by the individual as their only or main residence throughout the period of ownership, only a proportion of the gain on the disposal is exempt. This proportion is the same proportion that the length of the period of owner-occupation (inclusive of the last 12 months of ownership) bears to the length of the period of ownership. The balance of the gain is chargeable to CGT in the normal manner.
Where property is acquired by way of CPO, the acquiring party may pay a premium over the market value of the property in question. The premium may comprise various elements, such as additional compensation for the property itself, disturbance payments for upheaval, inconvenience and personal disruption associated with the compulsory relocation and payments in return for the forfeiture or surrender of the property owner’s rights. The basis on which each of these payments are made will determine the tax treatment of such payments. As such, it is necessary to review each agreement which provides for the making of these payments so as to identify, in the context of the rights and obligations arising to the individual property owners under each agreement, what income may be received or may be deemed by the legislation to have been received by the property owner, or what asset or assets may be disposed of, or may be deemed by the legislation to have been disposed of, by the property owner as a result of entering the agreement. Once this has been established, the tax consequences of the receipt of such payments, to include any reliefs or exemptions which may be available, may be fully considered.
In the context of CGT, section 535 TCA 1997 provides that there is a deemed disposal of an asset where any capital sum is derived from an asset, including by means of compensation for any kind of damage or injury to an asset or for the loss, destruction or dissipation of an asset or moneys received for the forfeiture or surrender of rights. This is the case even if no asset is acquired by the person paying the capital sum. Depending on the terms of the agreement under which the compensation payments are made, such payments may comprise the disposal of an asset, distinct from the disposal of the residential property, in accordance with section 535 TCA 1997. Should this be the case, the asset deemed to be disposed of in accordance with section 535 TCA 1997 may not fall within the scope of PPR relief as provided for in section 604 TCA 1997.
The scope and nature of any other tax consequences which may arise on the making of compensation payments to a person arising from the compulsory acquisition of that person's PPR by way of a CPO will be determined by the terms and conditions of the agreement under which the payments are made.