We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Triple lock and UN peacekeeping mandate

Summary

McDonald argues that removing the UN mandate risks Irish neutrality, legality and troop safety, and calls for a referendum. The Taoiseach rejects her account, says no deployment decision or proposal exists, and rules out a partisan role in Lebanon, while supporting the Lebanese Government.

Dismantling the triple lock carries the most profound implications for this country for generations to come. The Government's plan to deploy Irish troops without a United Nations mandate is destructive and dangerous. The United Nations mandate is the mechanism that has made Irish peacekeeping so effective over the years. It is the UN mandate that legally defines Irish deployments as bona fide peacekeeping efforts. It is that which ensures conformity with international law. The United Nations mandate frames our peacekeeping work as a military neutral. The UN mandate has protected Irish troops, often in the face of sustained hostility and danger, as they carried out their duties wearing the blue helmet and under the Irish flag. Now, the Government wants to throw all of that away and undo generations of honourable work.

The Government has concocted all sorts of false rationales for its actions, but none of it bears up to scrutiny and the Minister for foreign affairs has now revealed the real motives for its actions: the Government wants to get rid of the triple lock to allow the deployment of Irish soldiers on an EU-led mission to Lebanon. This would not be a peacekeeping mission, but a partisan intervention in one of the most fraught and dangerous parts of our world. The Government wants to change Ireland's role from peacekeeper in Lebanon, where our brave soldiers held the line against illegal Israeli incursion, where they acted as a buffer between parties to the conflict and where they protected civilian life, to instead deploy them as part of an EU mission to act in the interests of Israel in disarming Hezbollah, placing our soldiers as partisans and in the way of danger to advance Israeli interests. This will be a mission led by the very EU governments that actively arm and support Israel's genocide in Palestine.

The Government's plan is to scrap the triple lock and fall into line with Europe's NATO members. That is dangerous and makes a mockery of our neutrality. This is not what the Irish people want or support, in my strong opinion. The Irish people were given not just an assurance, but a solemn guarantee by the parties in government that the triple lock and the United Nations mandate would underwrite our military neutrality, our independent foreign policy and our absolute conformity with international law, and that, crucially, they would avoid any slippery slope for Ireland into European defence arrangements and military adventures. That guarantee was the demand of the Irish people in return for passing the Nice and Lisbon referendums. It was the price demanded by the Irish people for further European integration then and now.

The triple lock was a solemn commitment to the Irish people and now the Government wants to ditch it without the democratic permission of the Irish people. The Government wants to deploy Irish soldiers on a partisan, Israel-friendly mission along with soldiers from the very countries arming Israeli genocide, and to do so without the democratic consent or permission of the Irish people. That is despicable. It the Government is set on this destructive course of action, then the very minimum it must do is seek the permission and democratic consent of the Irish people first and put this question to a referendum.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I dtús báire, ní aontaím in aon chor leis an Teachta. Is dochreidte an méid atá ráite aici ar maidin. Níl an Teachta ag insint na fírinne in aon chor. Is uafásach go ndúirt sí anseo inniu go bhfuil muidne ag iarraidh Óglaigh na hÉireann a chur ar an taobh céanna le hIosrael. Tá sé sin dochreidte.

Deputy McDonald is getting more desperate by the day, and she is going low. To endeavour to create the impression and narrative that somehow Irish military personnel would be deployed in favour of Israel in Lebanon is a despicable, outrageous distortion of truth and of the narrative. Sinn Féin seems to think it can get away with falsehoods week after week in relation to a litany of issues.

Ireland has a very proud record of peacekeeping. My party, Fianna Fáil, when in government in the 1960s, began the very first peacekeeping mission. We are very proud of it. Our major role internationally has been defined by the peacekeeping heroics of many generations of Irish soldiers. We want to continue that mission of peacekeeping.

The Deputy talked about a UN mandate. We know the UN Security Council is dysfunctional. Instead of a UN mandate, she is saying it has to have a Russian mandate.

Comment on this

Russia is on the Security Council.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Deputy McDonald.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I will deal with this. Deputies should afford the same courtesy to each Member of the House. No interruptions, please.

Comment on this

If we insist on a Security Council mandate in today's world, we are saying we are insisting on a Russian mandate. We know that in Africa, in the Sahel and elsewhere, Russia has deployed the Wagner Group and other groups to manipulate governments, take down governments in Niger and other places and extract the very valuable minerals and resources from those countries. Is that who we want to endorse whether or not we go on a peacekeeping mission? The great republican party opposite believes the United Kingdom should have a veto on whether we participate. We have very good relations with the United Kingdom but I think independent foreign policy should mean we give ourselves greater flexibility in terms of being able to be involved in peacekeeping, monitoring and so on.

In relation to Lebanon, I find it extraordinary that Deputy McDonald would have the brass neck to come in here and say that, somehow, we now want to get involved in supporting Israel. Let us reflect on what has happened. We have been in Lebanon since the 1970s. Who is taking us out of Lebanon? It is the United States and Israel, which did not want the continuation of UNIFIL. We have played a very noble role in Lebanon; yes, as the Deputy said, as a buffer between Israel and Hezbollah. By the way, Hezbollah has murdered some of our soldiers in the past. It has been responsible for the killing of Irish soldiers. Do not lose sight of that either. We have been peacekeepers there and we wanted to continue with UNIFIL because the danger with UNIFIL ending is that the eyes and ears of the world will be taken out of southern Lebanon in particular. Why is UNIFIL being stopped? Why are Irish troops coming home in December and the next group that goes will basically be winding up the operation in Lebanon? It is because the Security Council could not and would not sanction the continuation of UNIFIL because of the position of the United State and Israel. That is the fundamental flaw in the Deputy's presentation.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is very well aware that peacekeeping missions are mandated by the UN, and the UN alone. A European force does not enjoy, nor should it enjoy, that discretion. It is utterly despicable and utterly outrageous that any Irish Government would seek to place Irish soldiers in direct harm's way in a partisan manner in the middle of a complex, protracted and dangerous civil war, explicitly with the mandate to disarm one party to that conflict - in this case, Hezbollah. Yes, Hezbollah has taken Irish soldiers' lives and so, too, has the Israel Defense Forces. Ireland should not be taking Israel's part, particularly at a time when it is executing a genocide of the Palestinian people, and doing the bidding of Israel in Lebanon. It is as simple as that.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you, Deputy, your time is up.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is convinced by his argument and he has come in and rehearsed it.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

We are sticking to our time. The Taoiseach, please.

Comment on this

He should put the question to the people in a referendum.

Comment on this

We will not be placing Irish troops in harm's way in Lebanon, either in disarming Hezbollah or whatever. That is a falsehood. We will not be doing that.

No government has made any decision. No proposal has come to the Government and we have made no decision in relation to it. Either way, there will not be a proposal coming forward to the Government that we would have any partisan role other than that we would support the Lebanese Government in terms of training and so on because the Lebanese Government-----

Comment on this

That is a contradiction in terms.

Comment on this

-----needs to be strengthened and it needs support. No one has argued against that. I do not know whether Sinn Féin is now against that as well.

Comment on this

Are you not listening to your own Minister for foreign affairs?

Comment on this

We support Lebanese sovereignty and territorial integrity. Israel is violating the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Lebanon and has undermined its capacity to grow and develop. We will not be in any way involved in the false narrative Deputy McDonald has articulated this morning.

Comment on this

It is not a false narrative.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The next speaker is Deputy Hearne. He is on his feet.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach stopped short as his waffle-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Respect, Deputy.

Comment on this

-----only has certain parameters.

Comment on this