Garda numbers in south Tipperary
Healy says the new Garda divisions are dysfunctional and south Tipperary is short-staffed, citing a drop in local numbers and disproportionate allocations to Dublin and the east. The Taoiseach praises Gardaí, promises to relay the case for community policing to the Commissioner, says recruitment is recovering, and agrees the Minister will meet local representatives.
Public safety requires a modern, properly staffed, properly funded, properly resourced and fit-for-purpose structured Garda organisation, but despite the best efforts of gardaí on the ground - gardaí who are stretched to the limit - the Garda organisation is not delivering for the public. The new Garda divisions introduced by the former Commissioner are an unmitigated disaster. The Tipperary-Clare division is particularly unwieldy and dysfunctional, being 170 km from the west coast of Clare to Carrick-on-Suir, a journey of two and a half hours. Garda numbers are down in the area, retirements are up, and the community policing service has been decimated, as has the roads policing unit. In 2010, Ireland had 1,182 community gardaí. In 2026, we have 591. In 2010, Tipperary had 108 community gardaí but now the whole area of Clare and Tipperary has a grand total of 18. The Clonmel Garda district covers the town of Clonmel, with a population of about 20,000 and another 20,000 in the hinterland, including Fethard, Kilsheelan, Clerihan and Lisronagh. Increasingly, it covers areas with unmanned stations, like Kilsheelan, and stations that have been downgraded, like Carrick-on-Suir.
Clonmel Garda station is particularly badly affected. In 2024, we had 64 gardaí. In October of this year, after the attested gardaí, we now have 55, which is nine fewer than in 2024. This level of Garda numbers does not allow for Garda visibility. To see gardaí on the beat is now a rarity. Visibility and gardaí on the beat are vital for public safety. Gardaí themselves are being put at risk by the fact that they are going out to incidents on their own. We have had instances where gardaí on their own have been assaulted and had to be helped by members of the public. Our town centres are being abandoned to antisocial behaviour, drug use and drug dealing. The few community gardaí that we have do tremendous work but are overwhelmed and stretched to the limit.
Will the Government immediately and as a matter of urgency replace the nine gardaí positions that have been lost since 2024 and increase the number of community gardaí? Please do not tell me that we are getting a new Garda station,-----
Comment on this
-----which we are and it is very welcome, but a Garda station is bricks and mortar. What we need is feet on the beat, and we need them now.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Healy for raising what is a very important issue. First of all, I will take the opportunity to pay tribute to An Garda Síochána, which serves our country with great commitment and diligence-----
Comment on this
-----in looking after our people and our community and protecting them in the face of ever-growing challenges from technological threats across to the community Garda presence on our streets. We should always aspire to maintain the embeddedness that our gardaí have in our community, that sense of a community-based approach, which has stood us in good stead compared to many other political systems and polities across the world. In the context of the European Union Presidency, I want to pay particular tribute to An Garda Síochána for the work it has been doing.
We have been very focused on increasing the number of gardaí in the country. As the Deputy will know, there has been a constant and consistent recruitment and attestation of gardaí on a regular basis through Templemore. It is maxed out and at full capacity. The good news is that more people are applying than we can accommodate. We now have 14,825 sworn gardaí, which is the largest number in the history of the State, and 200 more will come out of Templemore in December. That will bring us to about 15,000. We have provided more funding in the Estimates for next year for further recruitment and training at Templemore. We acknowledge that the population has grown and we need to increase the number of gardaí. We acknowledge what the Deputy is saying about the need for more gardaí across the country. The Minister provides the resources, and the Commissioner has been deploying gardaí in accordance with his operational framework. He has identified areas. Obviously, the Garda will be in a position, as we continue to recruit, to add more gardaí to Tipperary and to places across the country. I love the way the Deputy says "do not tell me" the good news in advance so that he gets it out before I can say there is a new station at Clonmel.
Comment on this
That is what I was told the last time I raised this issue.
Comment on this
Skilfully done, Deputy, but we should acknowledge it at the same time. It does represent investment in Clonmel, which needs it, and there is no issue there.
We will refer to the Commissioner the Deputy's emphasis and prioritisation of community gardaí and the desire for more numbers on that front, and we will relay that back. Obviously, it is an operational decision for the Commissioner. He is leading well and I believe that the continued regular recruitment into Templemore and the continued regular attestations will incrementally increase the gardaí and we will increase deployment across the country.
Comment on this
With respect, the Taoiseach has not addressed any of the issues I have raised. The fact of the matter is that cities are being prioritised over rural areas, at the expense of rural areas. Garda management appears to be oblivious to the needs of the public in areas like south Tipperary. We only have to look at the recent allocation of new gardaí in October of this year. Of the 207 attested gardaí, 160 or almost 80% went to Dublin and the east, 25 went to Waterford city and the rest of the country shared 22 gardaí. I repeat that in Clonmel we have nine fewer gardaí than we had in 2024. That is not good enough. We are entitled in south Tipperary to a fair share of the Garda complement. I ask the Taoiseach to intervene with the Minister. We were promised a meeting with the Minister before the summer recess.
Comment on this
That did not happen. We have asked the Minister to meet us again, all three TDs.
Comment on this
I ask the Taoiseach to intervene with the Minister to get that meeting, please.
Comment on this
The Minister has no difficulty meeting with the Oireachtas representatives from south Tipperary.
Comment on this
I do not have his diary here with me. He will engage with the Deputy. The Commissioner and the management of An Garda Síochána are not oblivious to rural Ireland.
Comment on this
They are not oblivious to the needs of rural Ireland. There was an argument, if we are honest. The Deputy mentioned the 28 that have gone to Waterford. I think the way he has done it is having an impact in cities. I acknowledge that. We will get there in terms of Clonmel and south Tipperary.
Comment on this
We have had a reduction, not an increase.
Comment on this
Deputy, I will get you the Standing Orders for Leaders' Questions. Stop interrupting.
Comment on this
There has been very steady progress in the last 12 months. We know that because of Covid-19, Templemore closed. That was a significant pause in recruitment, and that was a problem. Now we are really catching up very quickly. Templemore is our training centre for An Garda Síochána. We have made a decision to maintain that. We will have substantial numbers coming out next year as well.