We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

Tusla protected disclosure investigation

Summary

O’Flynn raises the treatment of former Tusla employee Ciarán Kenneally after his protected disclosure, arguing Tusla should not assess its own conduct. The Taoiseach says he lacks the case details, will seek Tusla’s account and respond, and notes the Government is reviewing whistleblowing legislation.

I want to raise the treatment of Mr. Ciarán Kenneally, a former Tusla employee who recently featured in The Irish Times. I have raised this matter in the House on several occasions. To refresh the Taoiseach's memory, in 2019 Mr. Kenneally made a protected disclosure about procurement and financial governance in Tusla. An independent investigation by RSM Ireland found the concerns were not upheld but, through a freedom of information request through my office, I obtained the financial audit from the same period, where 18 different instances of wrongdoing were recorded and 12 recommendations were made. It has been confirmed to me in writing that RSM Ireland has never seen that audit. Let us reflect on that. The independent investigator never saw the findings that were directly relevant to that particular investigation. Would it have changed the outcome? Who is to say? I think it may have.

Between 2018 and 2019, over €50,000 was recorded as "pocket money" in a ledger of the Tusla facility in Cork. I believe it deserves scrutiny when somebody records it as "pocket money". However, the man who raised concerns about this faced sustained campaigns directed at him personally and through his work life. In January of this year, a data protection commissioner found that Tusla unlawfully processed Mr. Kenneally's personal information and data by carrying out an unauthorised background check on him. When challenged about this, Tusla justified it on its own headed paper and claimed that it had concerns regarding his capability and capacity to interact with vulnerable children. Let us reflect on that. It is an extremely dangerous and serious accusation to make about anybody. Never once has any evidence been produced, nor has a document of accusation been produced. That is what they used as an excuse to carry out an unauthorised check. There has never been an apology or explanation and nobody has been held accountable.

In 2025, he made a second protected disclosure, raising his concerns at the highest level of Tusla management. Tusla has acknowledged his complaint but has not investigated it. Mr. Kenneally has spent years seeking answers under his protected disclosure but instead, he has been penalised. I am asking the Taoiseach to intervene with the Tusla commission to look for a full independent review of the case going back to January 2019. It must cover both disclosures, the audit finding withheld from RSM Ireland, and the DPC findings on allegations against him. Mr. Kenneally has suffered tremendously and this is still going on. Yesterday we saw another headline regarding Tusla. I not asking the Taoiseach to adjudicate, but to intervene.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy for raising the issue. I do not have the specifics of this case or indeed of the protected disclosure. As the Deputy knows, there are established procedures governing protected disclosures and set procedures for dealing with them. I will ask Tusla for its perspective on this case and the background to it. It goes back, I think, as far as 2018 and 2019. I cannot really comment on the assertions or points the Deputy has made because I do not have the requisite detailed background.

One of the challenges in more recent times is that, notwithstanding the fact that we have protected disclosures frameworks and procedures, invariably it seems that those who make protected disclosures do not seem to get either closure or adequate responses. This goes back since we brought in the Act of 2014 and did a major amendment in 2022. We are going to have a further statutory review of the Act in 2027 and public consultation will be carried out in advance of this. Fundamentally, it seems to me that right across the board, we are witnessing quite a number of protected disclosures being made and then those who have made them not at all being satisfied with how they have been progressed or with the responses. I am open to an overall review of it. My own view is that when disclosures are made, the existing structures should have the capacity and capability to deal with them comprehensively; to answer the questions that have been asked; if things were done wrongly, to apologise for that; and to make good. I will talk to Tusla in respect of this case and revert back at that stage.

Comment on this

I will write formally to the Taoiseach setting out the entire thing, and I will cc his Minister on it. The one thing we can agree on is that protected disclosures are perhaps not working the way they should. It has been highlighted by the EU Commission, which has written to the Government on three separate occasions regarding protected disclosures in this country. We can assert one thing from all this conversation we have had about Tusla over the last number of months: Tusla cannot be allowed mark its own homework at this stage. I will write formally to the Taoiseach. I am asking for a full investigation into this to cover from 2019 all the way up to 2025. The Taoiseach knows as well as I do that when somebody's name is taken and serious allegations are made, with absolutely no evidence at all, it destroys somebody's life. It has not only destroyed his life; it has destroyed his personal relationships with people and he has suffered financially. On the bullying that went on in that organisation against that particular whistleblower, I can draw the parallels across many whistleblowers. It needs to be addressed.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy for raising the issue. He has been briefed and has been involved in this and has pursued the issues through freedom of information and questions. I will engage with Tusla in respect of it and ascertain its perspective. We are reviewing the Act. We did amend the Act, giving effect to Directive (EU) 2019/1937, the whistleblowing directive. We are working on that. I will come back to the Deputy. The problem we face across the board is the question of who does the investigations. There are calls for public inquiries regularly now on a whole range of issues. We have to develop a system within the State so that existing organisations can adequately give closure and respond to people in situations like this.

Comment on this