We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ó na Comhaltaí Eile - Other Members’ Questions

My question today is about the urgent need for legislation to address the role that exposure to extreme pornographic material is playing in normalising sexual violence and harmful sexual behaviour among young people. There is growing recognition across the world that violence and extreme pornography is both highly accessible and increasingly influential. It is shaping attitudes about sex, relationships and consent, particularly among young people. Research from the Sexual Exploitation Research and Policy, SERP, Institute in Ireland has identified our relationship between the consumption of extreme and violent pornography and acts of violence against women and girls. This should concern everybody in this Oireachtas.

If one looks at the front pages of many of the world's most popular pornography websites, one will see content that normalises degradation, humiliation, coercion and violence against women. The increasing availability of pornography depicting forceful strangulation and suffocation is really concerning. These are difficult subjects to talk about but we have to face up to them. Health professionals have repeatedly warned about the serious physical and psychological risks associated with these practices yet they are being presented and, indeed, spun online as a routine and even desirable part of a sexual relationship. Women's Aid has described mainstream pornography as providing a blueprint for the sexual, verbal and physical abuse of women by male intimate partners. Repeated exposure to violent pornography normalises the idea that aggression towards women is an acceptable part of sex.

Young people, in particular, are really vulnerable to these messages. The evidence from the SERP Institute is clear. Many young people are regularly consuming pornography before their first sexual experience with another person. For some, pornography then becomes the primary source of information about sex and relationships, shaping expectations long before they have developed the emotional maturity to critically assess what they are seeing online. Family psychotherapists, teachers and front-line organisations are now dealing with the consequences. They report that young people are presenting with skewed views of consent and intimacy. In what world is it normal or acceptable for teenagers to think that strangling, degrading or physically harming a partner is a normal part of a relationship?

It cannot be accepted that technology companies and pornography platforms are permitted to expose children and young people to increasingly extreme content with little meaningful regulation. Will the Government commit to bringing forward measures to introduce robust age verification for pornographic websites? Will the Government introduce specific offences relating to the production, distribution and promotion of violent pornography that normalises sexual violence and reinforces harmful misogynistic attitudes towards women?

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy very much for raising this very important issue. In short, the Government is responding in an affirmative way to the points he has raised. First of all, we have a zero-tolerance approach to domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. It is a scourge on our society. The level of violence against women is very serious. We want to ensure that all victims and survivors can access the support, protection and justice they require.

In July, the Minister, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan, secured Government approval to commence drafting additional heads of Bill for inclusion in the general scheme of the criminal law (sexual offences, domestic violence and international instruments) Bill. As the Deputy has asked for, this Bill will create offences relating to the possession, production and distribution of violent or extreme pornography, addressing a significant gap in Irish law. As the Deputy correctly said, such material is having a harmful impact, particularly on young people and in terms of the normal sexual development of young people. It is contributing to misogynistic attitudes but also to violence. These offences will take an objective approach. They will cover material that would appear, to a reasonable person, to depict extreme violence, abuse, necrophilia or bestiality. This will include where technology has been used to alter or generate the material. The Bill is on the priority for drafting list in the autumn legislative programme.

The Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, is also seeking to build consensus throughout the European Union on a co-ordinated criminal justice response to the harmful impact of extreme or violent pornography. The Minister hosted a productive discussion on tackling violent and extreme pornography among justice and home affairs ministers at the informal ministerial meeting held in Dublin in July as part of Ireland's Presidency of the Council of the European Union. Officials continue to engage with the European Commission on potential further co-operation in this area. Of course, the Government's response also includes regulatory and public education measures. That builds on the good progress in embedding awareness of the very harmful effects of pornography, digital safety and consent into curricular reform and on the development of a broader pornography literacy strategy. The Department of justice is working with Cuan to develop a more comprehensive, targeted and effective multi-agency cross-sectoral response. As the Deputy knows, the establishment of Cuan was a milestone development in terms of Government's response to gender-based violence. Cuan provides the leadership, oversight and accountability for delivery in terms of the broad programme, the third national zero-tolerance strategy and the detailed implementation plan's progress report.

Comment on this

I welcome the additional heads of Bill as outlined by the Minister. The Minister knows he has my full support in supporting and getting this legislation through and on the Statute Book. As the Taoiseach said, it is hugely important that young people have access to accurate information, that there are good role models for them and that there is evidence-based education on consent, respect and healthy relationships. I feel, at times, we have taken our eye off the ball on these pornography sites for too long and let them effectively capitalise on what is pretty lax regulation across the European Union on addictive commercial practices. We cannot let pornography become the default sex educator for a generation of young people in this country and across Europe. It is a public health issue that is distorting young people's views and understanding of consent, intimacy and healthy relationships. Once again, I would welcome co-operation across the European Union in this regard. Can I get some clarity on the overall timeframe in which the Government would see these changes being made and the Bill being enacted?

Comment on this

I agree with all the sentiments the Deputy has articulated. It is a very serious and worrying issue. The Minister has briefed Cabinet on this for quite some time in terms of the violent nature of this pornographic material. There is a clear relationship between that and sexual violence against women, particularly in terms of the younger demographic in our country and globally, as the Deputy said. We need to really articulate that publicly, as the Deputy is doing now. It is important that we have these conversations because this is a crisis facing society and facing our younger populations in general in terms of the potential exposure they have to this violent pornography. I am not sure whether we will get the Bill to Second Stage before the recess.

Comment on this

It is a priority.

Comment on this

It is a priority, as the Chief Whip has just informed me. Certainly, we would want this passed early in the new year.

Comment on this