Criminal Justice (Unborn Victims of Crime) Bill 2026: First Stage
Carol Nolan introduced a Bill to recognize deaths or serious harm to unborn children caused by criminal acts as offences, including manslaughter where appropriate, at all stages of gestation; she said it would not affect the 2018 termination law. The Bill was unopposed, and its Second Stage was assigned to Private Members’ time.
No. 108 of 2026 ›
I move:
That leave be granted to introduce a Bill entitled an Act to provide for criminal justice in respect of certain offences causing the death of an unborn child; and to provide for related matters.
I sincerely thank my co-sponsors who made it possible for me to bring this Bill forward. The tragic death of baby Jax Aylward in 2024 gripped the sympathy of many in this country and in the House.
At just 31 weeks of pregnancy, unborn baby Jax and his mother, Saoirse, were the victims of a road traffic collision caused by dangerous driving by a Ukrainian national who has since been sentenced to six months in jail. This case prompted the welcome move by Deputies Emer Currie and Barry Ward to introduce a Bill known as Jax's Law, this September. Although that particular Bill is a step in the right direction, its proposal still falls short of the kind of comprehensive law reform that is required. Over the past few years, we have seen multiple cases of pregnant women whose babies have died due to violence. In April 2021, in Dublin city centre, a pregnant woman in her third trimester miscarried following an attack by a criminal known to her, who hit her repeatedly. In December 2022, we learned of the harrowing case of the murder of Natalie McNally in Lurgan. She was 15 weeks pregnant and was murdered by her partner, Stephen McCullagh. In June 2025, in County Down, Sarah Montgomery who was 34 weeks pregnant with a baby boy was murdered. In each of these cases, there was not just a single victim, there were two victims, each with equal humanity and an accompanying right to have justice served under the law.
The Bill aims to provide a more robust protection in law to ensure justice is served for both women and unborn babies who are the victims of violence. In addition to covering the death or serious bodily harm to an unborn child through careless or dangerous driving, the Bill also covers circumstances where a person kills an unborn child unlawfully while intending to kill or cause serious injury to the mother or to someone else other than the unborn child. Furthermore, it applies to all stages of gestation. The Road Traffic (Amendment) (Jax's Law) Bill 2026, introduced earlier this year excludes children before 23 weeks gestation and, unfortunately, dehumanises the unborn child by affirming that "the provisions of this Act shall not be construed to confer personhood on any unborn child". I do not believe that this is in keeping with the spirit of the Bill.
Jax's Law was proposed as a response to a tragic taking of unborn life. We should apply the same principle across the board for unborn children who suffer violence at all stages of life and development. It is important for both parents and babies that their status as legitimate victims should be fully recognised. This Bill has been carefully drafted to ensure that unborn victims of violence have their rights respected. However, it is also important to stress that this law, if enacted, would not impact on the operation of the Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Act, 2018. This Bill is about recognising the inherent humanity of unborn children and vindicating their rights. They cannot speak for themselves, but they are entitled to justice when their lives are impacted or ended by violent acts, whether intentional or unintentional. The purpose of the Bill is to ensure that the law has the scope to impose appropriate and proportionate penalties where an unborn child loses their life as a result of a criminal act. Importantly, the Bill does not classify such an offence as murder. Rather, it provides for the death of an unborn child to be recognised as manslaughter, where the circumstances warrant it. The sentencing provisions for manslaughter offer considerable flexibility, ranging from a fine to life imprisonment. This allows the courts to take account of the particular circumstances of each individual case, including the seriousness of the offence, the level of culpability of the perpetrator, and any relevant personal circumstances. In doing so, the Bill seeks to ensure that penalties are proportionate and reflective of the gravity of the harm caused. The Bill is important to ensure justice for victims of violence for mothers and unborn children and I commend it to the House.
Comment on this
Since this is a Private Members' Bill, Second Stage must, under Standing Orders, be taken in Private Members' time.
Comment on this
I move: "That the Bill be taken in Private Members' time."