Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›
Artificial Intelligence
Deputies warned that generative AI is using artists’ work, voices and likenesses without consent or payment, threatening creative livelihoods, and called for stronger protections and representation in AI governance. The Minister of State outlined ongoing EU copyright reviews and consultations, with measures expected in 2027, and said Ireland would work with European partners; no immediate national legislation was promised.
I mí Iúil, d'aontaigh an Teach seo rún de chuid Shinn Féin a d'athnaigh an chontúirt agus an bhagairt atá ag an intleacht shaorga, IS, d'ealaíontóirí agus d’aon duine atá ag obair sna earnálacha cruthaitheachta. Dar le Danny O’Donoghue ón mbanna ceoil The Script, tá an intleacht shaorga tar éis cóipcheart a ghoid ar scála tionsclaíoch. Sin a dúirt sé ag seisiún eolais sa seomra closamhairc an mhí seo caite. Rinne ceithre chomhlacht camchóipeáil ar 125 amhrán de chuid The Script agus 20 milliún amhrán eile chun samhail IS a thraenáil, gan aon chead nó gan aon íocaíocht. Bhí air teacht isteach faoi dhó toisc nach bhfuil aon rud á dhéanamh ag an Rialtas.
Masla a bhí ann, mar sin, nuair a d’eagraigh an Rialtas comhdháil ar an intleacht shaorga mar chuid d’Uachtaránacht na hÉireann ar an gComhairle Eorpach le gairid, agus gan aon ionadaíocht ansin ó na tionscail cruthaitheachta. Bhí deis ag Éirinn ról ceannasaíochta a thógáil maidir le sábháilteacht IS ach tá an deis sin ligthe le sruth agus ealaíontóirí ligthe síos. Tá an intleacht shaorga cheana féin ag dul in iomaíocht le healaíontóirí agus tionchar diúltach aige ar a gcumas airgead a thuilleadh. Mar sin, tá práinn ag baint leis an tsaincheist seo. Tá mé tar éis scata comhfhreagras a fháil maidir leis seo le gairid, agus déarfainn go bhfuil se faighte ag an Aire freisin. Chuir an léachtóir ag IADT, Karima Dillon El-Toukhy, in iúl ag an seisiún eolais sa seomra closamhairc go raibh an-amhras ar a mic léinn – glúin na n-ealaíontóirí atá ag teacht aníos – faona gcumas beatha a shaothrú dóibh féin i margadh lán d’ábhar ginte ag IS.
Ba mhaith liom freagra ón Aire Stáit inniu maidir leis an dul chun cinn atá déanta. An féidir leis geallúint a thabhairt do phobal na n-ealaíontóirí go dtabharfar isteach reachtaíocht a chinntíonn trédhearcacht, toiliú, córas ceadúnais agus luach saothair féaráilte gan a thuilleadh moille? Tá dualgas orainn todhchaí a chinntiú don chruthaitheacht. Caithfidh muid cosaint a thabhairt do dhaonnacht na healaíona agus sláine ár n-ealaíontóirí.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for taking this issue today. As he is very much aware, the topic of AI has become part of everyday discourse, whether in the mainstream media or being discussed in almost every talk show on the planet. In the last couple of weeks, from Australia to Denmark, the general populace is beginning to realise the immediate threat that AI is to artists around the world and is seeking positive action through legislation and regulation. In fact, Australia's official music charts and Australian Recording Industry Association, ARIA, awards have banned all AI-generated songs to protect human creators, while Denmark has introduced the right to your own likeness Bill, which gives individual performers and artists the legal ownership of their own faces, voices and physical traits.
Here in Ireland, generative AI capabilities are limitless when it comes to using, copying and scraping original artists' work, such as musicians, writers, animators, composers, actors and other artists. An example of this is fresh in the news, where Danny O'Donoghue, lead singer with The Script, called on the Government to protect the music industry from unauthorised use by AI companies and platforms. He said that more than 120 songs by The Script appeared in AI training datasets without the knowledge or consent of the band and without any remuneration or compensation.
This is the kernel of the issue. Ireland is the central hub for European AI technology. We are lucky to have a nation that produces exceptionally talented world-class artists, musicians and local artists who add to our unique connection to our culture and Irishness, but they need protection. They need to have representation on the board of the AI office. They need protection from AI-generated content that uses their talent, image and work without their consent. I believe that the Government needs to introduce a bill like Denmark's. Will the Minister of State consider exploring this option?
Comment on this
I thank Deputies Ní Raghallaigh and Mythen for raising this important issue today. As they know, the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment is leading on the implementation of the EU Artificial Intelligence Act and has policy responsibility for copyright law in Ireland. The protection of copyright is a key concern for the creative and cultural sector, as they rightly outlined here this morning. In its report of February 2025, the AI Advisory Council was of the view that it was imperative that the Government consider whether Ireland's copyright laws and licensing regimes were equipped to address AI disruption.
Leadership on Ireland's national strategy on artificial intelligence rests with the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment and the Minister of State with responsibility for trade promotion, artificial intelligence and digital transformation. At present, the European Commission is reviewing the 2019 copyright in the digital Single Market directive, including the text and data mining exception.
A consultation was held with the relevant stakeholders, which was circulated by the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment to stakeholders in Ireland, and a national submission has been made by the Department as well. A final report will be published by the European Commission in mid-2027. The Department of Culture, Communications and Sport will continue to work closely with colleagues in the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment as it leads on the development of Ireland's copyright legislative regime.
In parallel to the review, the European Commission is considering future measures to strengthen the position of creators and creative industries in the online and Al environment. The aim is to ensure that creators can better control the use of their works and enforce their rights, while supporting innovation and the development of Al technologies.
The European Commission is currently gathering feedback from stakeholders through a targeted consultation, which was open until 10 November, to gather their views on challenges and options to address them related to the use of copyright-protected content in generative Al, including on the issue of deepfakes or impersonations, which extends beyond copyright law. New measures are expected to be tabled by the European Commission in mid-2027. The EU has committed to the development of an Al strategy for the cultural and creative sectors, which will be delivered next year. It will play an important role in ensuring that culture and creative sectors have the tools and support to navigate the changes to the sector brought about by Al.
A number of Irish arts representative organisations have contributed to the recent call for evidence, which will shape the development of this strategy. It is clear in these submissions that artists want to see their rights respected and greatly worry about the impact of Al on their sector. It is important that Irish organisations continue to participate in EU consultation processes to ensure that the views of Irish creatives are represented.
As part of our Presidency, Ireland is facilitating discussions on copyright at working party level. This includes consideration of possible technical solutions to the challenge of ensuring an effective means for rights holders to exercise their right to opt out from the text and data mining, TDM, exception for fair remuneration for those in the cultural and creative sectors in licensing their content for Al uses and to facilitate Al providers’ access to high-quality training data to support AI-driven innovation. In Ireland's role as the chair of the Education, Youth, Culture and Sport Council under the EU Presidency, we are also working closely with European partners to prioritise action on Al in the new European work plan for culture.
I hope that clarifies the current position in relation to the work that is necessary, how it is being co-ordinated at European level and the importance, due to that we are operating in a Single Market in the European environment, of that action happening at European level and of it being strong enough to protect our creatives in terms of what they have produced previously and what they produce into the future.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for his reply. It is understandable that it is difficult to bring these big tech companies and platforms to heel, considering the number of billions of euro they give to the coffers each year. However, we must work with other countries and be willing to use the best practices, particularly when it comes to regulation and legislation, like Denmark and the music awards of Australia. Artists must be protected. It is simple. The Government must step up and do this. In the Minister of State's remit, he can act. He can include representation of the arts sector on the AI Advisory Council and include the sector in the membership of the AI Office. He can ensure that no State funding for art is spent on content produced by generative AI. Through the Presidency of the Council of the European Union, he can influence the ongoing review of the text and data mining exception to the copyright and digital Single Market directive's Articles 3 and 4. This text can be strengthened to protect individual artists and their right to their own image, voice and intellectual property.
Has the Government engaged with the review or contributed or provided any suggestive changes to the directive? If so, will the Minister of State any content of the full text? If not-----
Comment on this
Deputy Mythen is taking it.
Comment on this
Leanfaidh mé ar aghaidh ón méid a bhí le rá ag an Teachta Mythen. If not, when will this be done? Gabhaim buíochas leis an Aire Stáit as an gceist seo a thógáil inniu. Tá muid an-bhuíoch as seo. Is ábhar thar a bheith tábhachtach é. I thank the Minister of State for his reply thus far. I hope he will defend the copyrights and preserve the livelihoods of our creative communities and our unique relationship with our artists.
Comment on this
This is a matter of great concern to creatives across the country. It is a real challenge, one that we must collectively work with our partners across Europe to ensure it is addressed and that the creative work of our artists is protected. As recommended by the 2025 report of the national Al Advisory Council, entitled "The Impact of Al on Ireland's Creative Sector", the overarching objective must be to protect our creatives and ensure meaningful artistic freedom while fostering innovation and the potential of Al for the creative and cultural sector. The EU joint declaration, Europe for Culture, Culture for Europe, states:
The ethical, sustainable and responsible use, development and governance of [Al] systems should foster human creativity through a fair human-centric and rights-based approach. It should: respect cultural rights, accessibility, inclusivity and cultural diversity; promote and contribute to the discoverability and visibility of European, national and local content; foster competitiveness; counter digital divides; and foster digital inclusion.
These important principles will guide our work in the months ahead.
Regarding the role of State bodies, the Arts Council is engaging with the arts sector and monitoring national and European policy and regulation to understand the diverse implications of these technologies across the arts to inform future advice for the sector.
As to screen industries, Screen Ireland has not prescribed or outlined what tools filmmakers can or cannot use for their storytelling, whether that is shooting on film, using CG animation or, potentially, the use of generative Al at some point in the filmmaking process. For ethical and sustainability reasons, transparency is of the utmost importance, along with evidence of compliance with copyright law. As a next step, Screen Ireland is looking to develop an acceptable use policy on the use of generative Al in projects funded by the agency.
In my initial response, I outlined the various consultations going on at European level and the expectation in relation to progress next year to help address this issue. It is something collectively across the House that we will all be very much committed to and want to see being as robust as possible in terms of protecting the creative rights of our artists.