Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›
Telecommunications Infrastructure
Michael Cahill pressed for action on widespread mobile blackspots in Kerry, stressing risks to residents and emergency response. Charlie McConalogue cited operators’ investment and ComReg’s coverage map, and said he would pass Cahill’s concerns to departmental officials and ComReg, but gave no timeline for eliminating blackspots.
I raise the matter of mobile phone black spots in County Kerry. This is not the first time that I have raised this issue in the House. We all accept that mobile phones now play a major part in the social and working lives of the vast majority of our citizens. We become more reliant on them as the weeks and months roll by. Are works planned to improve mobile phone coverage in County Kerry and, indeed, all over Ireland in those black spots that we all come across them in our daily lives? These black spots, for whatever reason, be it mountain, shade or otherwise, continue to interrupt the social and business lives of our citizens if they are only passing through them, but more particularly and deeply if they happen to live within these black spot boundaries. This issue must be addressed, especially to allow us to deal with emergencies. I am aware of several incidents in such areas over a number of years now in my county. It is not good enough and not acceptable. We need to have this addressed as soon as possible.
There are several locations where mobile coverage is either non-existent or subject to regular interruption. These include the Tralee to Dingle road, Camp, Annascaul, Glencar, Gneeveguilla, the Black Valley, Ballintleave, Curraheen near the Kerry Bog Village in my own parish of Glenbeigh, Mountain Stage, Dromaclaurig and Ballinskelligs, to name just a few. These areas suffer regularly due to an unfulfilled mobile phone service. There are also areas around Kenmare and Kilcummin.
I should mention the three peninsulas of Dingle, Iveragh and Beara. Could the Minister clarify whether the Department has plans to deal with this issue? Can we get timelines for the delivery of 100% mobile telephone coverage for all of Kerry and, indeed, Ireland?
As I mentioned, I raised this issue with the Tánaiste previously and, indeed, with others. I have raised Dromid, Waterville, and Glencuttane, which is just outside the town of Killorglin. There is very poor reception - in fact, zero reception - in these areas. I have raised Ballintleave and Glenbeigh, between the Red Fox Inn, the Kerry Bog Village and Curraheen National School in my parish, Inch and Annascaul, especially along the coast road where the road rises to Annascaul village, between Camp and Annascaul and between Loo Bridge and Kilgarvan. The list goes on and on. There is a particularly bad area between Mountain Stage on the Ring of Kerry road and Kells. I mention the Foilmore area. I have been contacted by emergency services in regard to that particular area in the past. North, south, east, west and, indeed, mid Kerry all have blackspots. In a previous response, the Tánaiste stated that the Minister for communications had a blackspots task force, which was going to look at these areas. I have heard absolutely nothing back and I would like to see action on this.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Cahill for raising the important issue of mobile reception and blackspots in County Kerry. It is not specific to County Kerry and there are similar challenges in my county of Donegal and some other areas, which have large geographies. It is well recognised by all of us how important telecommunications services are for citizens in so many aspects of our daily lives. Access to high-quality telecommunication services is also of crucial importance in the context of supporting current and future development of enterprise in urban and rural areas.
Ireland's level of connectivity to support digital activity has improved significantly in recent years. The digital economy and society index is a composite index summarising relevant indicators on Europe's digital performance, and Ireland ranked fifth in 2026 among EU countries compared to 11th in 2019. Ireland now ranks second in the EU for basic digital skills and fifth for generative AI adoption.
The continued investment by commercial operators and the State through the national broadband plan will ensure that Ireland is set to become an EU leader in connectivity in the second half of this decade. The availability of mobile phone coverage is primarily a matter for mobile phone network operators operating on a commercial basis in a liberalised market. They are regulated by the Commission for Communications Regulation, ComReg, and are assessed against the terms of their licences.
Mobile network operators continuously modify their network coverage across rural and urban areas to cater for ever-increasing traffic volumes. However, the quality of network coverage is not uniform across the country, and many factors will affect how well mobile radio signals propagate from base stations to users' phones. For example, signals weaken significantly the further one is from a mobile phone mast, the terrain and physical environment can block or weaken signals, thick concrete, steel and energy efficient low e-glass can also stop signals entering a building and network congestion can be caused when too many people in one area are using phones simultaneously. Of course, storms and heavy moisture in the air can affect and attenuate the transmission of mobile phone signals. Handsets and user handling can also be a factor.
Mobile coverage obligations are set out in licences granted by the independent regulator, ComReg, to mobile operators. ComReg advises that the current minimum coverage obligations in those licences are being exceeded considerably by all operators. Capital investment by telecommunications operators over the past eight years was in the order of €5 billion for fixed and mobile services. This has significantly enhanced the availability of services, voice and data, throughout Ireland, including in rural areas.
Telecommunication operators have committed to continuing investment programmes in the coming years. In 2022, ComReg ran a multi-band spectrum award to assign rights of use in four spectrum bands. The award comprised 470 MHz of spectrum and represents a 46% increase in the harmonised spectrum assigned for the provision of wireless broadband services. This significantly enabled the market to provide improved services to meet increasing consumer demand for mobile data and for new services.
To assist consumers in choosing the network provider that best meets their needs for where they live, work and travel, ComReg has developed a national outdoor coverage map. This map, which is available on the ComReg website, provides consumers with very clear information of where operators have good 2G, 3G, 4G and 5G coverage. While this will not be of assistance where there is an absolute blackspot, it is something that could be of use to people in different areas. They could look at the website and assess in terms of the map which operators are providing what level of service in different areas.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State. I was in Listowel last Friday, which was a special day, in that it was an acknowledgement of the rollout of broadband to all of Kerry. I want to acknowledge the work that has been done. It is great that we can say that.
I know all about ComReg; I have written to it for many years, as have my colleagues in Kerry, including when I was a member of Kerry County Council. We feel let down in regard to its work. I mentioned a long list of specific locations. It is all very well when there is no accident or emergency or a tragedy. I have come across cases where people have been trapped in cars and cannot contact anyone because there is no mobile phone reception.
I know of plenty of places where there are people living in isolated areas, especially elderly people, and if they fall or they need help, they cannot contact anyone. In this day and age, that is simply not good enough. I ask the Minister of State to raise this with his colleague, the Minister for communications, and address this major issue. As I mentioned at the outset, it is not just an issue in my county; it is happening all over the country.
We are going into 2027 and it is simply not good enough. I raise this in the interests of health, well-being and, especially, safety. I thank the Minister of State for his response but this has to be addressed. I will keep raising this matter here until such time as the people of my county, Kerry, get the service they deserve.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for raising this and for his advocacy on behalf of those areas in County Kerry which have poor or no mobile phone coverage. I will highlight the points the Deputy has made to officials in the communications section in my Department regarding his experience relating to mobile coverage and ensure it is communicated to ComReg for its information.
We all know the massive investment the Government has made in the national broadband plan, which commits to bringing broadband services of a high quality to every residential premises, home and business in the country. It can often be the case that when one walks in the door of a building, one is connected again because of the investment the Government has made through online and broadband call services. There can be that challenge, in that until one goes into a premises and connects to its Wi-Fi, one may not have mobile coverage. That is certainly a challenge. Government investment has made a massive difference throughout the country in ensuring every premises is connected and has voice and data communication to the rest of the world and person to person.
The issue Deputy Cahill has raised, regarding the capacity for mobile services, is a fair one. While there is no doubt that from an overall point of view all the information indicates that as a country we are performing well and are high up in the league, that is little consolation if one is in an area where one does not have good coverage. I thank the Deputy for raising this issue again today. I will highlight his contribution today and the importance of it.