We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Military Honours

21. Deputy William Aird asked the Minister for Defence if she is aware of concerns raised by descendants of members of the Portlaoise volunteers regarding discrepancies in the State's roll of honour for participants in the 1916 Rising; and if her Department has examined claims that a number of volunteers who undertook service comparable to comrades who received official recognition were excluded from the roll of honour and other forms of recognition. [80106/26]

Comment on this
Helen McEntee Minister for Defence Fine Gael

I am aware that, from time to time, concerns have been raised by, or on behalf of, descendants and representative groups regarding individuals whom they believe should have received recognition equivalent to that afforded to other participants in the struggle for independence, including individuals from Portlaoise.

The Roll of Honour is a closed historical document held by the National Museum of Ireland.

The award of 1916 medals is based on long-established criteria, and on evidence that can be corroborated by official Department of Defence records.

The process by which applications and petitions or appeals under the Military Service Pensions Acts were made, investigated and verified concluded in 1958, and there is no statutory or other mechanism available now by which service can be investigated or verified.

You will appreciate with the passage of over 100 years since the events of the 1916 Rising and some 60 years since the winding up of the investigation process, it is no longer possible, in the absence of official Departmental records, to obtain the level of verification required for the posthumous award of 1916 medals or other recognition.

Furthermore, there is no provision under the relevant legislation for the Department to retrospectively revisit or alter the determinations made by the statutory bodies responsible for assessing qualifying military service.

I wish to emphasise that accounts of involvement by individuals in the 1916 Rising are not disputed by my Department; however, at this point in time it is not possible to obtain the standard of official verification necessary to prove the actual nature of the service.

The online Military Service Pensions Collection provides public access to records relating to applications for military service pensions and medals, where such applications were made.  This enables interested parties to view and examine the documentary evidence considered in individual cases.

Comment on this