We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›

Public Transport

Summary

Transport Minister Darragh O’Brien defended the 15% fare increase, arguing that population growth and 140 new or enhanced services would sustain passenger growth in 2027, despite NTA scenarios predicting declines. He said he would ask the NTA to check the fare difference between Athenry–Galway and a comparable Dublin route.

99. Deputy Pa Daly asked the Minister for Transport further to his comments made in Dáil Éireann, if he still believes public passenger numbers will grow in 2027 despite the budget scenario he received from the NTA that projected that the fare hike will lead to a decline in passenger numbers (details supplied); and the analysis he or his Department carried out to evidence the claims he made in Dáil Éireann regarding an increase in passenger numbers next year. [80081/26]

Comment on this

In reaching the decision on its recent fare determination, the NTA considered a range of factors in consultation with my Department, including passenger affordability, operating costs, inflationary pressures, investment requirements, Government policy objectives and the long-term sustainability of the public transport network. The Deputy will appreciate that the 15% fare adjustment is being implemented against a backdrop of strong and sustained growth in public transport usage. A record 363.5 million passenger journeys were made on TFI services in 2025, with the NTA reporting further growth of approximately 5.3% in the early part of this year. Funding has also been provided to support continued expansion of the network. As I mentioned, there will be a record €1 billion-plus in PSO services for next year and a further 140 new and enhanced services.

The NTA applies detailed statistical analysis of fare elasticity to assess the impact of fare changes on passenger demand. Despite any demand elasticity effects arising from the fare increase, it has advised that steady passenger growth is expected to continue throughout 2027, reflecting the continued strength of underlying demand for public transport services in a country with a growing population.

I think that the remarks at the joint Oireachtas committee were based on a European study and were not specific to Ireland. I expect passenger numbers to grow next year because we are growing the services. We are going to put another 140 in place across road, rail, rural and urban so unless no one uses them, which I do not imagine will happen, passengers numbers will grow next year. I will predict that here. If in early 2028 that has not happened, I will be absolutely shocked because the projections for this year are very strong. There will be new services and additional capacity next year. If people want to use public transport, they will.

Comment on this

The Minister made those remarks before about how steady passenger growth was expected to continue in 2027. It was recently revealed that, in August, the NTA published a budget scenario for the Department projecting a decline in passenger numbers in 2027 as a result of the planned fare increases. In particular, it predicted a 1% drop in passengers on Dublin Bus, Luas and Bus Éireann PSO routes and other PSO services. It also predicted a 3% drop in rail passenger users and those availing of the rural transport programme next year. That is the exact opposite of what the Minister claimed before and again today when he already had the NTA analysis.

This is happening at a time when we should be encouraging people to use public transport. It beggars belief that the Government would make a decision that it knows will make it more difficult and less likely for people to use public transport when it increases fares. The Government is also making it more expensive for people to drive a car when it comes to fuel, insurance, toll hikes and so on. Will the Minister acknowledge that this fare hike is going to have a negative impact on commuters and will make it less likely for them to travel?

Comment on this

I know that Deputy O'Hara would love that to be the case and he probably dreams that, next year, there will be a reduction in public transport usage because that would give him and his colleagues an opportunity to come to the Dáil and cry and shout about it. We should all have a responsibility in here to work together to improve services across public transport, health and housing - the whole lot. They can either choose to do that or choose to hope and pray that there will be a reduction in demand, which there will not be. There absolutely will not be. We have a growing population. Look at the new homes being built, which is never recognised by Sinn Féin's housing spokesperson, who is more and more removed from the debate, should I say. It is acknowledged that we have a growing population, growing communities and a growing public transport network, which will lead to growing numbers of people using public transport. We will see that for 2026 when we get the end-of-year figures. I expect the Deputy will come into the House and welcome that further increase in public transport usage.

Comment on this

It is clear that the Minister does not want to acknowledge the findings of the NTA's analysis, analysis he requested from the NTA. I have raised many cases many times, for example, the previous question about overcrowding, capacity issues on bus and rail services, how difficult it is for people who have to travel on these services day in, day out, and who rely on them, and the struggles they face just to get to work, school and so on. The Government is going to make it even more expensive for them. They are going to have to pay more for the privilege of having to rely on, in many cases, substandard services. That is not fair on commuters; that is the bottom line. This analysis from the NTA suggests that it will result in fewer people relying on public transport. That is not good enough from the Government.

On the issue of fares, I want to mention that rail passengers between Athenry and Galway pay €5.10 each way for a 20-minute train journey when a commuter travelling between Clonsilla and Connolly Station in Dublin, a journey of roughly 30 minutes, can travel for approximately €2.60 each way. Athenry to Galway is a commuter route. There is a clear discrepancy between fares in Galway and Dublin. Is the Government willing to look at that?

Comment on this

We can get into predictions. The Deputy got into predictions and NTA projections. That does not take into account the growing population and growing number of services. We are going to bring in 140 new services next year. If you do the basic, simple maths and look at the capacity on those new services, that will be a significant increase, dealing with the demand and issues on certain lines and routes that the Deputy, as well as Government and other Opposition colleagues, have raised. We are endeavouring to address that. Let us look forward positively instead of trying to score points all the time.

The Deputy, to be fair, raised specific issues in his constituency. The NTA sets fares. That is the legal position. It makes the fare determinations. I assume the Deputy has raised that directly with the NTA. If he has not, I certainly will raise it on his behalf and get it to see if there is an anomaly. I am sure that there is not but if he has not raised it already, we will take a note of that from this morning.

Comment on this