We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›

Bus Services

Summary

Richard Boyd Barrett called for an urgent review of Dún Laoghaire bus services, citing ghost buses, unanswered complaints, driver shortages and punishing rosters. Minister Darragh O’Brien said the NTA would keep routes under review, improve tracking and examine complaint handling, and pledged to follow up on the specific services raised.

101. Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett asked the Minister for Transport if he will commission a review of the bus services in the Dún Laoghaire area, including but not limited to the 4, L25, E1 and E2 routes. [80527/26]

Comment on this

I am asking for an urgent review of bus services in the greater Dún Laoghaire area, including the 4, L25, E1 and E2 routes but not limited to those routes, because of the ongoing problem of the ghost bus. The bus is coming, coming and coming and then it is just gone. It keeps happening. When you try to make complaints to Transport for Ireland, it tells you it is taking them seriously but it does nothing, closes them and there is no response. I have multiple complaints about these buses. I have some explanation of the reasons, which I will go through.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy. The Dublin area bus network, including services operating in Dún Laoghaire, is being revised as part of the BusConnects Dublin redesign programme. In 2025, phase 6A of the BusConnects redesign programme was implemented, with new routes being introduced across Dún Laoghaire, including the E1 and E2 routes that the Deputy mentioned, as well as revisions to route 4. The E1 and E2 routes, which operate at a high frequency and also operate overnight, are the busiest routes in the Dublin area network.

The National Transport Authority, NTA, has confirmed that in preparing for the introduction of the new B-spine services, the latest information on passenger demand will be taken into account prior to the implementation of these services. Aside from passenger usage data and trends, the NTA will also collate information pertaining to housing development and utilise this information further with regard to further network changes that might be required to support increased demand and improve access to public services. The NTA also monitors demand and service performance across the Dublin area network. We get complaints and it is important that they are acted on. That includes taking into account requirements for the provision of additional capacity on additional services. I am aware that the NTA carried out a further review of capacity requirements using autumn 2026 passenger numbers.

Under the budget I mentioned earlier, we are investing over €1 billion in public transport services. It is actually closer to €1.6 billion, but the PSO is over €1 billion. That will enable us to improve existing routes, capacity and frequency and to roll out about 140 new and improved services. The NTA has confirmed that future capacity enhancements will be prioritised on the basis of identified need, taking account of overall available funding. The NTA has confirmed it will continue to keep the performance of routes operating across Dún Laoghaire under review. I am interested to hear the experiences of the Deputy's constituents this morning.

Comment on this

Quite a lot of money is being spent, but what it is supposed to achieve is not happening. The NTA's contract with Capita for the TFI contact centre, which handles passenger complaints, is worth €42 million. When you complain to them, they tell you they will do something and they do absolutely nothing. That costs €42 million and it is not working. A further €68 million has been spent on a contract with Trapeze on tracking systems for buses in Dublin Bus which has not been implemented. It is not tracking the buses. It has been rolled out in Waterford but it is not happening in Dublin, even though the money has been spent. What is really happening? First, there are not enough bus drivers. That is why buses get cancelled. Second, the rosters that bus drivers are being asked to drive are completely punishing. A bus driver used to have one route and now, they have four routes. There are split shifts. There are route times that are completely unrealistic. There is a PressIt box system which says you are too early and you need to slow down. They will slow you down if you are too early but if you are late, they will take the bus off.

Comment on this

The Deputy needs to slow down a little bit. We will get to the points.

Comment on this

Time is running out. Our time system is working.

Comment on this

I know that. The Deputy mentioned the automated vehicle location, AVL, system, which has been rolled out. It is fully operational in Waterford and it will be rolled out further. That will make a massive difference because it is a big frustration for people. They look at the app and think the bus is arriving in three or four minutes, but it does not or it just disappears. That is not acceptable. That is a priority for me. I get the Deputy and he makes a fair point on that.

The TFI complaints structure, whereby complaints are lodged and then trickle down or are passed down to the actual bus or train operators, is something we are looking at.

There are issues in this. If a passenger lodges a complaint or a TD does so on their behalf or on behalf of constituents it needs to be responded to. I am telling Deputy Boyd Barrett straight that sometimes the lead time between a complaint being made and a response being given is not acceptable. This is something we have identified, and it has been raised here, and we are looking at it. AVL will make a massive difference for passengers. I will come back on additional services in the supplementary reply.

Comment on this

In some cases the people making complaints are told their complaint is being escalated but that is the end of the story, or there is no response at all. A lot of money is being spent. This is outrageous and something has to be done. Bus drivers are being punished for an understaffed system with unrealistic route times. A bus is told to slow down because it is ahead of time but if it hits traffic further down the road it is taken off the road because we have a system of fines that punishes the operator if it is ahead of time. It is only interested in when the bus starts the route. This does not make any sense. There are also punishing rosters. There are split shifts for people who are on four buses, with bus drivers shifting around three or four different buses. The bus drivers are under pressure and, therefore, young people say they do not want to be a bus driver because the job is so punishing. This means operators are having difficulty holding on to people. We need to treat bus drivers properly, we need realistic route times, and we need to address many other issues.

Comment on this

We do need lots of things but we had 365 million public passenger journeys in 2025. We are seeing a further increase this year and there will be a further increase next year. We are investing to improve services and to provide additionality. AVL will make a big difference because it is real-time data. If passengers plan their journey and arrive at a bus stop when they expect the bus to arrive they could miss the bus if it arrives five minutes early. It has to be balanced. We also need cross-city routes. We need to utilise the stock better, which is being done, so that a bus does not run on one route and then a driver will be sitting in town waiting for an hour or an hour and a half to come back on the same route. This is about route planning and it is one of the things being done now by the NTA.

Comment on this

The route plans are not realistic.

Comment on this

I have met bus drivers and I have been in the depots. I was recently in Inchicore with Deputy Shane Moynihan, seeing what is being done in the control room and the real-time data coming out. This is being worked on. The points Deputy Boyd Barrett made about specific routes and services in Dún Laoghaire are being looked at. I will keep an eye on them and we will revert to Deputy Boyd Barrett.

Comment on this