Ceisteanna Eile - Other Questions ›
Road Tolls
Minister Darragh O’Brien said he cannot stop TII’s planned toll increases, which are capped by CPI and fund motorway maintenance and safety; he acknowledged the cost to motorists. Sinn Féin deputies urged cancellation, arguing tolls add to living costs without reducing congestion; the Minister did not address the requested impact review.
109. Deputy Pa Daly asked the Minister for Transport if he has considered proceeding with the planned toll hikes in January 2027; the review that has been carried out on the impact of toll hikes on reducing congestion; and if consideration has been given on their impact on the cost of living. [80164/26]
Comment on this
We had a good debate on this and, in fairness, Sinn Féin used its Private Members' time on it. I got an opportunity to explain the legal position. I do not set the tolls. I do not increase, decrease or stop them. It is not a matter for me but we know that the toll revenue across the motorway network, which has grown substantially since the early 2000s with all our major cities connected, is really important for the maintenance of those roads and to keep them safe. A mechanism for doing that is tolling. Nobody loves tolls. Toll increases of ten cent, while in monetary terms are relatively small, for continued use on the motorways are an expense for motorists and businesses but that money is invested in ensuring the roads are maintained and safe, and that the road surfaces themselves are up to standard. We have seen significant inflation in the past two or three years as well around materials for roads and for services that are provided.
There are very clear criteria set as to what the permitted toll increases are. They cannot go above the consumer price index, CPI, and they have not. The Dublin Port tunnel is critical infrastructure, particularly for heavy goods vehicles, HGVs, and goods coming in and from the island. It is very important that the Dublin Port tunnel be protected for the HGV route, too.
I am conscious there is a cost to people. No one likes increasing costs but the legal position - I want to be very clear on this - is that I cannot step in and tell Transport Infrastructure Ireland, TII, that it cannot apply these increases. We are contracted to it.
On the piece of work we are doing, I will come back in on a supplementary reply.
Comment on this
These increases have a significant impact on drivers who rely on the motorway network. They do not reduce congestion or change the behaviour of people who rely on these roads to get to work, school and so on. However, they are very good news for the private tolling companies and there is an issue regarding how these contracts that were signed, which are very lucrative for these companies and gave a very bad deal to the taxpayer. They are punishing drivers who are already dealing with significant increases to the cost of fuel and so on. We also have the increase in the cost of public transport fares. It seems that the Government is determined to hit everyone every which way. No matter who you are or which way you travel, you are going to be paying more money for your commute come 1 January.
Before the last general election campaign - and this is what the Minister did not address during the Private Members' business the other evening - he said that these toll increases should be scrapped. In the Dáil last year, he said the toll increases were far too high, but he has allowed them to go ahead anyway. The reality is that as his predecessor did back in 2023, he can stop these increases from proceeding, and that is what he should do.
Comment on this
When tolls were paused before at a different time, they had to be paid for by the Exchequer out of central funds. We do not just pull money out of a tree, which I know is the basis of Sinn Féin economic policy.
The reality as well in the context of public transport usage is that over a quarter of our population can use public transport for free, and I have expanded that to all children up to and including the age of eight. We have expanded, with the Minister, Deputy Calleary, the companion pass for those people who have special needs or disabilities, and for our seniors. We are one of very few countries that does that. It important to state that nearly 1.5 million people have the ability to travel for free.
I am very conscious about the price of fares in particular. We have done fare comparisons across sister cities in the EU and Britain. Even with the fare adjustment brought forward by the NTA, our fares compare very favourably and are cheaper than most.
Comment on this
The reality is the Minister can stop the hikes, as he admitted. In regard to the cost-of-living crisis, they are making people's lives more difficult. It is the wrong call. People from Galway travelling to Dublin have to pass through two tolls, or three if they are going to Dublin Airport. All of those costs really add up.
On the subject of roads and congestion, we have a real problem in Athenry. The next section of the Athenry ring road, which I have raised with the Minister previously, will be really important in tackling that congestion. I met with the Minister's officials a few months ago on this. I was concerned with the feedback I got from them on the potential cost of the road. It seemed that the Department did not really have a willingness to proceed with this project. The project has been stalled for some time, which is concerning for people in Athenry. We need this road project. It is critical infrastructure for enabling housing delivery and taking congestion and traffic out of the town but what is being talked about now is a reduced or shortened road project. Can the Minister look into this and ensure this full road project proceeds?
Comment on this
We have had a good discussion. I know the Deputy is clear that we are investing, through the public service obligation, PSO, and the fares, in new routes. Additional capacity, which he has understandably called for in public transport services in his own area, gives us the ability to do that across the country.
It is not to plug a gap or to come into central coffers. It will go directly into new and improved routes and services. It will be for the provision of those services.
The Deputy raised the next phase of the ring road in Athenry. Deputy Albert Dolan and others have raised it too. Over the coming weeks, we will be looking at road allocations for next year across our regional, rural and national network. I have already asked officials for a report on a number of projects. They will be taken in the round. I thank the Deputy for raising it in the Chamber this morning.
Comment on this
No. I am taking Question No. 112, which is in my name.
Comment on this
That is the question regarding the NTA. That is not Question No. 110.
Comment on this
It is the one about County Galway.
Comment on this
Deputy Ó Murchú is arriving into the Chamber.
Comment on this
I am not as fit as I thought I was.
Comment on this
God, the Deputy is correct; he is not.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis an Leas-Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
The bus was on time. It was how long it took me to run from the bus was the problem.
Comment on this
The Deputy should get help from his friend behind him. Deputy Donnelly is a great runner.
Comment on this
I am giving the Deputy a chance to recover.
Comment on this
In fairness, it will take me about 40 seconds to read my question.