Rates ruling on farm storage buildings
Collins warns that a High Court ruling on rates for Castlecor Potatoes’ storage buildings could have serious consequences for farmers and householders. Burke says the Government is assessing the judgment’s implications and will work to avoid unintended effects on farmers.
A recent landmark court decision against Castlecor Potatoes in favour of Tailte Éireann, the agency which carries out valuation for rates, has extremely serious implications for every farmer in this country, but also for every householder in urban and rural Ireland. In the case of Castlecor Potatoes, rates were applied to its storage housing at Castlecor's main yard. Castlecor appealed this to the Valuation Tribunal, which found in its favour. However, the tribunal accepted a request from Tailte Éireann to have the matter considered at the High Court, where the decision was reversed, meaning that Castlecor is again liable for rates on the building where it stores its potatoes and onions.
This has far-reaching implications for agriculture, as Tailte Éireann is on the hunt and farming is its next step. I am delighted the Minister of agriculture is there beside the Minister because he has to take this seriously as well. Many agri-stores that dry and store malting barley in their stores. Outside air - not heated or changed in any way - is mechanically blown through perforated plastic pipes on the floor of the grain store in order to keep the grain conditioned and preserved for the customers when they want it. Basically, it comes out the way it went in. There is no processing. The agri-stores that do this are currently facing a judgment by Tailte Éireann. They are seriously concerned after the Castlecor Potatoes judgment that they will be considered as processors and rates will be applied. It is now widely rumoured that the dairy farmer could well be the next target by Tailte Éireann if farm stores are to be wrongly considered rateable because they keep barley dry and the potato grower is considered rateable because he cold stores his potatoes. What about Tailte Éireann's next target, the dairy farmer, who cools his milk in a specialised cooling tank until his local co-op collects it?
What exactly is the Minister doing about this crisis? I am raising it weekly in the Dáil Business Committee, of which I am a member, to bring a debate on this issue to the House but I am not getting anywhere. As I said at the outset, if this is not resisted by the Government, it will skyrocket the price of food, which will hit already hard-pressed families who, as we speak, cannot afford the cost of food. I have no doubt that if the Government does not step in here, the cost of purchasing food in this country could in some cases end up costing double, as all the rates being applied will have to be passed on to the consumer. The Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, is the Minister for enterprise. Will the Government advise Tailte Éireann to immediately pause all rates proceedings against any farmer or farm store currently in its scope until the Government has taken the time to properly define the meaning of some of the words and terms in the rates Act that have brought the potential of rates taxes to the door of many farm families which, in turn, will have devastating consequences for all in this country? Will the Government act now and not leave each individual farmer or store to take costly legal cases against a State body, Tailte Éireann, which has the power of the State's finances from the hard-pressed taxpayer behind it?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Collins for this very important question. Obviously this has been a determination by the courts, which is hugely concerning for the Government. The Minister, Deputy Heydon, is in discussions with the Minister for housing, planning and local government in connection with the implications of the judgment and, critically, the precedent that it could potentially set. We are very much aware of the pressures affecting the farming community that are particularly acute in the horticulture sector and the tillage sector, which have seen very significant cost increases. The Government has come forward with a number of interventions to try to shore up costs and ensure we are reducing the impact of inflation we see on farms.
I am acutely aware of the whole impact of the farming and agri-community from an economic perspective, with about 300,000 people employed nationwide, and, critically, of the amount that farms bring to the national Exchequer. They are producing over €8 billion in direct agri output per annum, which is obviously very significant. We do not want to see any unintended consequences on foot of a judgment that has come from the Judiciary. Obviously, we are very respectful of any judgment. Potentially, it is up to us as a Government to act on the implications of the judgment, including whether that requires legislation or the Minister, Deputy Heydon, working with his colleagues. He is very much aware of this case. We will undertake to examine this and try to find a resolution.
As someone who comes from a farming background, I am aware of the challenges affecting the farming community. I mix every single week with farmers, particularly those on the tillage side, so I am aware that it is very challenging. We recently saw a new plant - a flour mill - which demonstrates how important the Government is taking its supply chains. Enterprise Ireland has put in a very significant investment, working with the Minister for agriculture in relation to it. It is a very exciting development, the purpose of which is to shore up the supply chains that are so important. I will endeavour to come back to the Deputy with a complete response when the Government has examined the court case. It has to examine the determination of the court case, the implications of it, and particularly the precedent that it potentially could set. We do not want inspectors calling out to farmers or those involved in horticulture and them having to try to fight with the State in relation to a rates valuation. That is not the intended spirit of the Government. This is something that we will try to resolve.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister very much. I appreciate his reply. I cannot understand why the Government has not blocked Tailte Éireann from attacking the farmers of this country at a time when the householders and farmers of this country are under immense pressure because they do not have the money. Neither can I understand why the Taoiseach, who lives in a neutral country, handed Volodymyr Zelenskyy €25 million of taxpayers' money yesterday. Our schools are being threatened. Some schools in west Cork spent 20 minutes dialling 999 for help and could not get it. On this issue of huge concern, the Minister is saying it should not have unintended consequences. He says the Government is looking at the determination of the courts. The bottom line is that Tailte Éireann is banging on the doors. The Government has the control. Tailte Éireann comes under the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, so will the Minister tell us here today that the Government will step in to deal with this Government's attack on agricultural products, which will in turn be an attack on the consumers of this country? Will the Government ask Tailte Éireann to wait until it has found out all the determinations and step aside from frightening the living life out of some people who are trying to make an income and provide food on our tables at an extraordinarily difficult time? That is what I want to hear. If the Government does that, it is quite acceptable and I will walk away happy.
Comment on this
Given that I come from a farming background, as does the Minister, Deputy Heydon, I can absolutely assure Deputy Collins that we are always on the side of farmers. We provide solutions and work with them to ensure there are no unintended consequences of State regulation. He can see from the various efforts we have made - from Mercosur, to the derogation, to working on CAP to try to get a resolution - that we are providing solutions every step of the way and working with people across Europe and across the farming community. This will be no different. As I said, this judgment was made in connection with a particular case. We have to examine that judgment. The Minister, Deputy Heydon, has already been briefed on it. He has been proactive and spoken with the Minister for housing, or should I say his Department, to try to see what the consequences would be of any precedents set by this case. The last thing the Government wants to see is unintended consequences to farmers having to be rated when heretofore they did not face those costs.