We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ar Pholasaí nó ar Reachtaíocht - Questions on Policy or Legislation

Celia de Jesus flood death and housing standards

Summary

Murphy said Celia de Jesus’s death in a flooded, unauthorised basement apartment also reflected planning and tenant-protection failures. Burke expressed sympathy, undertook to relay the request to the Justice Minister and noted subsequent changes to planning law.

October marked 15 years since Celia de Jesus drowned in the 2011 flood. She was trapped in the basement apartment she was renting. Since then, her death has been characterised as death by misadventure caused by the flood but it was not just the flood that killed her. It was a breach of planning law and a failure by the local authority to protect tenants such as her from substandard housing conditions.

The landlord had never obtained planning permission to divide the basement of their property into two rental units. Her unit was later described as "not of a habitable standard", and bars were put on her small window, making escape impossible when she could not open the door. Breaches of planning law and the failure of the local authority and her landlord to protect tenants had as much to do with Celia's death as the flood. We need an apology from the State, a public statement on the full circumstances of her death and an immediate review of the coroner's report and its final verdict.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy very much. I absolutely understand the huge concern about this very important issue, and my sympathy goes out to Celia's family. It is obviously a very difficult circumstance for anyone to pass away. I will relay the Deputy's comments to the Minister for justice regarding what the Deputy is asking for. I also put on record that there have been significant changes in planning law since that date for the better in connection with flood plains and regulations. A lot of things happened two decades ago in construction that should not have happened, quite frankly, and, hopefully, we are in a better place now to protect citizens in the future.

Comment on this