We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ar Pholasaí nó ar Reachtaíocht - Questions on Policy or Legislation

Online sharing of antisocial behaviour

Summary

Neville called for stronger laws on posting and sharing videos of antisocial behaviour, citing violent incidents in Kildare North. Burke agreed that platforms have obligations to protect victims and communities and discussed concerns about content moderation.

I welcome Ruby Boyle and Emily Quinn to the Visitor's Gallery. They are two transition year students who are with me for the week.

On a serious issue, I am calling on the Department of justice, alongside the Department of Culture, Communication and Sport to review and strengthen legislation on the sharing of antisocial behaviour on social media in Ireland. Recently, in my constituency of Kildare North, we have seen an increase in antisocial behaviour, which is being filmed, posted and shared on social media. Some of these videos have included violent attacks on young adults by people their own age, which are distributed around apps such as Snapchat and WhatsApp. I have recently met with three separate sets of parents and victims in relation to three different assaults. The most common point which they all raised was how difficult it was to move on from the incidents while the videos of the events continued to be shared online.

I have highlighted this matter with the Garda Commissioner at the Committee of Public Accounts and I now ask that Coimisiún na Meán, which falls under the Minister's new remit, reviews this matter and strengthens legislation to ensure, alongside gardaí, that these videos are taken down immediately and social media posts are brought to the Garda's attention as evidence later.

Comment on this

I acknowledge Ruby and Emily and wish them the very best in the work they are doing with him.

The Deputy raised a valid point. Social media companies have a significant obligation here to the victims of crime and communities not to keep content on their platforms that can be very distressing and can cause significant concern for criminal cases that result, in particular.. That is one thing I have mentioned and raised in connection with the number of job losses in some social media companies. Those who are involved in moderating content and providing key protections are being replaced, in many cases, by bots and artificial intelligence. I have seen some horrific cases in which victims of very serious crimes were given a response by an AI bot that looked for a death certificate or something that is deeply traumatic to families. That has to stop and we have to ensure we hold companies to account in that regard. We have to take a strong stance as a Government and we will not be behind in doing so.

Comment on this