We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›

Crime Prevention

Summary

Repeated arson and vandalism of Dublin playgrounds prompted calls for stronger prevention, CCTV and data on parental supervision orders. The Minister condemned the attacks, cited new community safety partnerships and antisocial-behaviour order powers, and said section 111 of the Children Act is under review, while acknowledging the lack of court data.

I thank the Minister of State for taking this matter. I want to raise the growing problem of arson and serious vandalism affecting playgrounds and public amenities on the northside of Dublin. Since October 2025, there have been seven serious arson attacks on playground facilities in Dublin Bay North. There were two attacks on the same playground in Kilmore, two on McAuley Park, two in Darndale Park and the destruction of newly installed eco-toilets in St. Anne's Park. The McAuley Park playground was newly installed following a campaign by local residents. It was built perhaps 12 to 18 months ago and has been attacked twice. I acknowledge and thank my colleague, Councillor Clodagh Ní Mhuirí, who has been raising this on the local community safety partnership and is working closely with Dublin City Council and local residents in responding to the issues.

There comes a point when it gets very frustrating. We cannot be expected to clean up the mess again and again and move on. It is hard to get into the mindset of people who would do this. It is not a class issue as facilities throughout Dublin Bay North are being attacked again and again. They are built for communities and for people and families to use. It is very hard to understand why people would attack, burn and damage facilities and put them beyond repair. We need a stronger focus on prevention. I have spoken to An Garda Síochána about a number of these incidents. It has to investigate all of them but it is up against it. The incidents often happen at night, when there are no lights and no witnesses, so they are really hard to follow up. There is a fair bit of support within Fine Gael for CCTV to be used as part of a solution in this area. I find it hard to understand why local authorities are not more to the forefront on CCTV. They tend to be reluctant to get involved. I believe they have the frameworks to do so but they are slow to get involved.

On a related topic, we should also look at whether existing legislative provisions relating to parental responsibility are being well used. The Oireachtas has provided for parental supervision orders and compensation orders for a particular reason. I asked the Minister for justice about the use of these orders and he was very helpful. He followed up with the Courts Service but its response stated that court statistics are not compiled in such a way as to provide the information sought. The Courts Service further advised that this information can only be obtained by the examination of individual court files in court offices around the country, which would require the expenditure of a disproportionate amount of staff time. We do not seem to know about this and it does not seem to be a priority for the Courts Service. This is a real pity. We should gather this information and understand at the very least whether the orders are in use, whether they are effective and how many orders are being made.

I am sure this is also a problem on the southside of Dublin. I have heard of incidents in Sean Moore Park and other places. What can we do regarding CCTV? Can we get more data on supervision and compensation orders? Are there other things we can do to work with local authorities to try to deal with this?

Comment on this
Catherine Ardagh Minister of State at the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration Fianna Fáil

These acts of vandalism are not limited to the northside. We see them in all our constituencies, especially in the urban constituencies of Dublin. I thank Deputy Ó Muirí for raising the issue today.

Playgrounds have an essential role in our communities. They are not just facilities for young people across Dublin and the country; they are central hubs for social development where children can make sense of the world around them and people of all ages and backgrounds can meet and build a sense of place and community. When I see a vandalised playground, perhaps on my social media feed, my heart drops. It is gut-wrenching for us to see a playground, where we might have attended the opening a few weeks earlier, being vandalised. We need to ensure that we get to the bottom of this and that it does not become an everyday incident.

Every playground, park and public space represents considerable investment, not only in financial terms but also in terms of time and effort from the community, local authorities, their staff and the contractors who build these facilities in our communities. Setting playgrounds or parks alight is not a fun thing to do. It is a sign of disrespect for the local community and a lack of pride in where people come from. This vandalism is not only unacceptable; it is reprehensible. I am conscious of the concern arising from a number of recent incidents affecting community facilities in Deputy Ó Muirí's constituency and the impact these incidents have had on local residents.

I assure the House that An Garda Síochána will and does investigate these incidents thoroughly. However, ensuring a safe environment in our communities, including those in north Dublin, is not solely a policing issue. This is why the Government is supporting the new local community safety partnerships, which bring together local authorities, gardaí, community organisations and residents to identify and address local safety concerns. The National Strategy for Improving Community Safety 2026-2030, which was published this week, marks a significant milestone in how we approach community safety in Ireland. The Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration attended the launch. For the first time, we have a dedicated national framework to assist the Government, public services, local authorities, businesses and community organisations to come together to deliver safer communities. It will help ensure that everyone, regardless of who they are or where they live, can feel safe, supported and connected within their community.

The launch of the strategy marks the next chapter in the evolution of community safety in Ireland and is a key element of the new community safety infrastructure established under the Policing, Security and Community Safety Act. Each of the 36 local community safety partnerships supported by the strategy is developing a local community safety plan based on priorities identified by local communities. I understand the inaugural meeting of the Dublin Central local community safety partnership was held on 21 January this year. Partnerships such as this reflect the principles of the communities themselves. By bringing together people with local knowledge, public services and community leadership, we can develop responses tailored to local needs and focused on prevention as well as enforcement.

Deputy Ó Muirí raised the issue of parental supervision orders under section 111 of the Children Act 2001. Youth justice falls within my remit. As part of the youth justice strategy for 2027, we are looking to modernise the Children Act 2001. A review is under way with the Attorney General, especially concerning section 111, regarding the use and efficacy of parental supervision orders. I thank Deputy Ó Muirí again for raising the matter.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that a review is under way. How will it be executed effectively if there is no access to the data? It is very important that the Courts Service tracks and makes this data available to the Minister of State, and as a Minister of State, Deputy Ardagh, can look for this data. There is a lot of verbiage in what I got back from the Courts Service but access to the underlying data is vital.

We cannot accept the normalisation of the destruction of public facilities. I cannot accept it. It is just not normal for people to go out and burn down playgrounds. It is not normal for them to burn toilet facilities. It does not matter where, northside or southside, we cannot accept it.

I am going to keep raising this. I know that the local authority is frustrated because it gets the tail end and has to pay for all the damage to be repaired. It is doing it two or three times after successive arson attacks on facilities. Local authorities are effectively reliant on the community to work with them to protect the facilities. It is just really difficult. An Garda Síochána then has an investigative responsibility. As the Minister of State will know, these attacks happen in the dark of night when gardaí are not around. It is really difficult for An Garda Síochána to get prosecutions. I just want to make sure that this issue gets the priority it deserves at Government level and that it is front and centre in the review. We must find a way to move people away from doing this and to make them understand it is just not acceptable or normal, that communities are being affected and that public resources are going down the drain again and again. The local authorities are very frustrated. The local community partnerships can play a big role. Time will tell how this works out.

Comment on this

I note the Deputy's points on the collection of data. It is probably fair to say that a negligible number of supervision orders have been made by the courts.

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

That is the anecdotal information but we do not have the data. We cannot make decisions anywhere without data. I take the Deputy's point. I am aware of a number of serious incidents, including incidents of arson, at playgrounds in the Deputy's constituency. These include recent unpleasant events where play equipment was burned and destroyed. That is absolutely unacceptable. It is understandable that the local families who use these facilities are upset. Those responsible have shown total indifference to the local community, which relies on facilities like playgrounds.

As the Deputy is aware, the Garda Commissioner is responsible for operational policing matters, including Garda investigations and the distribution and stationing of Garda personnel throughout the State. The Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration is unable to intervene in these independent functions. However, new powers introduced this year under the criminal law and civil law Act 2026 will make it easier for the Garda to apply to court for antisocial behaviour orders in respect of adults and children. The Act reduces the minimum rank of garda who may apply for such an order from superintendent to inspector. This will bring increased flexibility to the making of such applications. Furthermore, the steady increase in Garda numbers should ensure that authorities are in a better position than before to deploy the required resources to investigate crimes, whether arson or vandalism. There are now 14,825 gardaí. This is the highest number in the history of our State. As of the end of September 2026, there were 792 serving Garda members assigned to the metropolitan region north division, which operates in the Deputy's constituency. This is an increase from 766. The Minister for justice has also been assured by the Commissioner that Garda management keeps the distribution of resources under continual review in the context of crime trends and policing priorities.

Comment on this