We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›

Road Tolls

Summary

Paula Butterly warned that proposed January 2027 toll increases, especially on the M1, could raise costs for hauliers, businesses, commuters and consumers, and called for an assessment of their impact. Neale Richmond said toll-setting rests with TII under existing rules and toll revenue supports road maintenance; he offered no commitment to prevent the increases, but suggested seeking a meeting with the Transport Minister.

Today, I want to discuss with the Minister of State an issue we cannot deny is a hot topic at the moment. I refer to the proposed toll increases in January, particularly those on the M1 corridor between Dublin and Belfast. This increase is going to have a huge impact on local hauliers and hauliers across Ireland, as well as on the goods that transit up and down the country, particularly between Belfast and Dublin, and on the cost of business. I appreciate everything Government has been introducing to tackle the cost-of-living crisis at its core - at the cost - rather than at the end by simply giving away vouchers willy-nilly to people. That does not do anything but put an inflationary pressure on the cost of living. As we see inflation creeping up again and again, we have to continue to have the eye on the ball and be aware of where the potential increases could come down the line across the supply chain.

Outside of the people who manufacture the goods, those who transport them are at the core of this debate. It is worth reminding people how food gets to their tables and how goods get into their fridges, cupboards and wardrobes. They are transported by our hauliers, including a considerable number of them in County Louth. The people who transport goods from the factory or farm to the supermarket shelves are the ones who are currently being impacted by the rising costs. We have done whatever we can to help them to reduce those costs, or at least to keep a lid on them right now. Quite frankly, adding an additional cost in the form of increased tolls is absurd at this moment in time. It is also unnecessary. We should not be allowing Transport Infrastructure Ireland, TII, to impose this on the hauliers when we have not done a financial impact assessment on the cost of business and on the supply chain.

Have we looked at that in the Department? Have we looked at the indirect consequences of these toll increases being imposed on hauliers? It is also an issue that affects commuters at the end of the day. The M1 motorway toll at Drogheda, which is the only tolled town in the country, is causing congestion. On top of the traffic congestion and gridlock in Drogheda every single day, it is proposed to add the burden of an increase in the bill to travel to work. That is clearly unfair to all the commuters. Nevertheless, the core of the topic here today is the impact on businesses. As a party that believes in supporting businesses, we have to look at every penny, dime and cent that could eventually impact them. They cannot absorb that forever. At some stage, they will have to pass that on. Who will they pass it on to but the consumer? The consumer is then faced with an increased cost of commuting to work, as well as the increased cost of their food, their clothes and everything else they put into a press or cupboard at home. I ask the Minister of State to analyse this and look at its potential impact to see if we can avoid putting in place these increases in January 2027.

Comment on this

From the outset, I acknowledge and thank Deputy Butterly not only for raising this but also for her consistent engagement on this issue and her advocacy for those directly and indirectly affected. It would also be remiss of me not to also acknowledge the Ceann Comhairle's own past in this area.

The Minister for Transport has responsibility for overall policy and Exchequer funding for the national roads programme. Once funding arrangements have been put in place with TII under the Roads Acts 1993 to 2015, and in line with the national development plan, the operation and management of individual national roads is a matter for TII in conjunction with the local authorities concerned.

Therefore, matters relating to the day-to-day operations regarding national roads, including toll roads, are within the remit of TII.

There are 11 toll roads in the State, of which ten are on the national road network. Of the ten tolls on the national road network, two are essentially public tolls: the M50 and the Dublin tunnel. Revenue from these tolls is collected directly for TII by operating companies under contract to TII. These revenues are invested by TII in the operation and maintenance of the national road network.

The other eight roads are public-private partnership, PPP, roads, which were constructed and are now operated and maintained under long-term contracts with TII. Revenue generated by these roads is collected by the public-private partnership company and is used to repay loans arising from the construction of the road and to fund ongoing operations and maintenance activities. In addition, some toll revenue generated on these roads passes to TII through revenue-sharing mechanisms.

On the framework for setting tolls, toll by-laws for each individual road set out the basis for calculating maximum tolls each year. Maximum tolls are calculated for each vehicle category. TII calculates the maximum tolls for the Dublin tunnel and the M50 and decides the actual tolls that should apply. The PPP companies calculate the maximum tolls for the eight PPP concession schemes and propose the actual tolls that should apply. The mechanism for these calculations is set out in the individual toll by-law and is based on the consumer price index. Actual tolls charged may not exceed the calculated maximum toll for each scheme.

There is no formal consultative role for the Minister when it comes to tolls. It is a matter for TII. Therefore, any analysis, as the Deputy has advocated, would be a matter for TII. It is important to note that TII does not have the right to unilaterally change the basis on which PPP toll rates are revised. It is also important to point out that many major new road developments in the last 25 years were funded through PPPs, meaning that the funding for the building and maintenance of the road came from both the Government and private businesses. These private businesses then charge for vehicles to use the roads that they have helped to build, via tolling. This has allowed for the rapid expansion of our motorway network.

Furthermore, it is an investment priority to ensure that the existing motorway and national road networks, which have been greatly enhanced over the past two decades, are maintained to a high level to ensure quality levels of service, accessibility and connectivity to transport users. In recent years, inflation has had a particular impact on the construction industry. This is particularly felt in relation to products such as bitumen which are used in road pavement repair, meaning the cost of the protection and renewal of the existing network has increased significantly. As such, toll revenue continues to play a vital role in the upkeep of our road network.

This does not for an instant dismiss the very real concerns that Deputy Butterly has raised today on behalf of so many road users, crucially with regard to the second-phase impact that any increase to tolls would have on homes, businesses and communities around the country. These decisions are not taken lightly or without justification. As I said, TII has used its calculator method, which it is able to do with the PPP companies, and has proceeded on this basis for the first time in quite some time with the proposed increases. That aside, I completely empathise with the points being made by Deputy Butterly.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for that comprehensive reply setting out who is responsible for the setting of the tolls. While he noted that the Minister does not have a formal role to play in this matter, I am a great believer that there are more ways than one to skin a cat. While TII is responsible for the setting of the tolls and the policy, at the end of the day the Minister is the Minister for Transport and I believe that there are ways to encourage TII to take on board the pressures that hauliers are under.

Let us remind ourselves that these are not multinational companies; they are family-owned businesses. Many of the hauliers I know in Dundalk, Ardee and Drogheda are family-owned. They are father-and-son or father-to-daughter businesses and they employ vital people in my area where that is essential to the local economy. While TII will have done its analysis - I have not clearly understood exactly what that analysis is - I will go back to my first question. While it was looking at the inflation of construction work costs, etc., at the same time did it carry out an analysis of the impact this could have, indirectly and directly, on consumers at the end of the day? Those consumers jump into their cars at all hours of the morning to commute to work, and are strung out as they try to manage everything. Now they find that it is going to cost them more to go to work and come home from work. On top of that, it is probably going to cost them even more for a week's groceries. I ask the Minister of State where his informal powers would lie to engage with TII.

Comment on this

I am very grateful to Deputy Butterly. As she will be aware, over the past 25 years the Government has invested heavily in our national road network, with an extensive motorway system now in place. The motorway network has seen an almost tenfold expansion since 2000. As part of the programme for Government, there are commitments for increased funding for new roads and the protection and renewal of the existing network.

It is the intention of the Government, as part of the €24.3 billion to be allocated to transport under the sectoral investment plan for transport, to increase investment in road networks and road safety to €9.7 billion during the 2026 to 2030 period. In 2026, approximately €800 million in Exchequer funding has been allocated for national roads. This has enabled the continued construction of the N5 Ballaghaderreen to Scramogue, N28 Cork to Ringaskiddy and Adare bypass projects.

In addition, this funding has allowed multiple major projects at an earlier stage of the project life cycle to progress. These projects include the Galway city ring road, which is the first road project in the State to be designed as critical infrastructure. Other projects such as the Limerick to Foynes project, the N20-M20 Cork to Limerick project, the Donegal TEN-T project and the Slane bypass, have also progressed this year.

Exchequer funding has also been used to invest in the protection and renewal of the existing national road network. This investment, which is supplemented by toll revenue, helps to ensure that our road infrastructure is kept to a high standard and that safety levels can be improved on the network. The Government wishes to see the national road network, into which there has been so much public investment in recent decades, safeguarded for future generations. Toll revenue, therefore, is an essential component in achieving this.

While I acknowledge the Deputy's appeal for information on what informal influence the Minister could have over the process, it would be a little bit remiss of me to speculate on what, if any, informal process a Minister of State might follow in a very much parallel Department to the Department of foreign affairs. However, I encourage the Deputy to perhaps seek a deputation meeting with the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, or the Minister of State, Deputy Canney. I have no doubt that our colleague, the Minister of State, Deputy Buttimer, will be able to facilitate such a meeting on the specifics of toll increases before January.

Comment on this