We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate ›

Land Issues

Summary

Sorca Clarke highlighted Tailte Éireann’s large registration backlog and a first-time-buying couple unable to complete their purchase or draw down their mortgage because a scheme map application remained unresolved; she said the agency had provided no useful update on its status. Minister of State Kieran O’Donnell explained Tailte Éireann operates independently, pointed to its online application-progress report, and offered to follow up with the Department. The Ceann Comhairle noted recurring complaints about inadequate replies from the agency.

I thank the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, for taking this Topical Issue today. I am going to be very honest with him: I stand here, first, looking for his help and, second, in absolute frustration with Tailte Éireann. We know that at the end of October, there were over 70,000 land registry applications outstanding. More than 17,000 of them were lodged before this year. In May, Tailte Éireann's chief executive told the housing committee that clearing the arrears could take more than two years. This does not stop with home buyers. We know it affects property sales, farm transfers and business transactions. The Law Society has reported delays in obtaining copies of property documents. This is not a minor inconvenience; it is having real-life consequences for people simply trying to get on with their own lives.

I want to give the Minister of State a very specific example. I was recently contacted by constituents who are first-time buyers and who found themselves caught up in what I can only describe as an absolute nightmare. The application for approval for the development's scheme map was lodged with Tailte Éireann in September. Today, they can stand in the estate and look in the windows. The developer has given them access to the house so they can walk around their own future home but they cannot actually get the keys because of delays and that red tape. I have to put it to the Minister of State: I struggle to put into words the level of emotional toll this has taken on this couple. They were all set and ready to go. They had the date to sign on the dotted line and to get the keys for what would be their first family home, only to be told, "No, not today" and also, "We actually do not know when". To describe it as a kick in the teeth is the understatement of 2026. They have scrimped and saved up for the deposit. One of them has actually changed jobs from an entirely different county. They were so excited, and they should be. When you buy your first house, it should be an exciting time. They are distraught. They cannot draw down on the mortgage. The purchase cannot be completed. They have no keys and no indication of when this is going to change.

What I find incredibly frustrating is that this House was told in July that land registration generally happens after purchase and mortgage drawdown and should not delay the transaction. This is a scheme map application, the step before registering the individual sites.

The buyers’ lender is absolute that it will not allow the mortgage to be drawn down until this is completed. That is the difference between saying something should not cause delay and something actually causing delay.

My office contacted Tailte Éireann and looked for a realistic timeline in this regard. My initial reaction to the reply I received was, “Thank you, Sherlock”. I was told that the case was in a queue, but I already knew that. That is why I contacted Tailte Éireann in the first instance. Circular 25/2016 sets out a 15-day working day target for a substantive response to Oireachtas representation and requires departmental oversight of those standards. The reply I received was an exercise in copy and paste. It was not a substantive answer. It was a brush-off.

I am not excusing developers. If there is a problem with the maps that have been lodged or with the documentation, that is fine but tell me. I will hand it over to the solicitors and they can take it from there on behalf of the constituents.

I am looking for a solution. I need a resolution for this couple. It is grossly unfair. They are not asking for anything outside of information on where their case is in the queue. Tailte Éireann should not come back with another creative writing exercise telling them they are in a queue. That is the last thing they need to hear. What they need to hear is it is processing applications from July, that it has everything, and that it will be done in accordance with the rota and that it will be got to. If there is a problem, that is fine. Tell their solicitors what the problem is and allow them to take it forward. This couple went as far as installing an alarm in the property. That is how close they were. They were down to the 11th hour of walking out of the solicitor’s office or the developer’s meeting with a set of keys in their hands. Now, however, they do not have a clue what is going on.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Minister of State at the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage Fine Gael

I thank Deputy Clarke for raising this important matter, which I am taking on behalf of the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage, Deputy James Browne, and for giving me the opportunity to clarify the position on the allocation of folio numbers to new-build developments and the role of Tailte Éireann in that regard.

Tailte Éireann is an independent Government agency under the aegis of the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage. Tailte Éireann provides a property registration system, a property valuation service and national mapping and surveying infrastructure for the State. Under section 8(6) of the Tailte Éireann Act 2022, Tailte Éireann is independent in the performance of its functions. Neither the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage nor the Department have any function in decisions in this regard.

The provision of a new folio number by Tailte Éireann occurs on the completion of specific application types, mostly by way of first registration on the Land Registry or division of registered land by deed of transfer or lease. Where the parent property, such as a developer's land, is registered on the Land Registry and has a folio number, applications to transfer part of the property must be lodged by the new owners for registration. The Deputy provided some outline of that, but I ask her to provide a bit more as to where precisely it is at the moment.

A separate application is required for each site or property within any development, and each application is lodged by the new owners. These applications require a compliant map to be lodged, setting out the legal extent of boundary, which will result in a change to the registry map and a new folio number being provided for the relevant part of the property.

It may be noted that registration of or transfer of part comes at the end of the conveyancing process when all contracts and deeds have been executed between a developer and the purchaser, and after the owners are in occupation of their new homes. Any delay in the provision of a folio number in this case would, in the vast majority of cases, have no material impact on the new owner.

Where the property has not been registered on the Land Registry previously, an application for first registration is required. Applications for first registration of title account for approximately 12% of Tailte Éireann’s overall intake. First registration applications are often complex and diverse. The first registration process often identifies issues on title or missing deeds, prolonging processing of applications significantly. Once a title is registered, it is guaranteed under the State’s indemnification provisions. Each application must satisfy all legal requirements prior to proceeding to registration. On completion of the registered legal title, a new folio number is provided for the land in question.

It is not possible to determine whether any delay in a particular case is reasonable without knowing the history of progression of the case, or whether the application is in order to proceed to registration. In cases where any delay in registration could have a potential impact, Tailte Éireann makes every effort to expedite applications which are in order, where valid grounds exist and where doing so does not impose a conflict with regard to priority given to any prior lodged dealing. Lodging parties may contact Tailte Éireann in relation to a specific case by email at info@tailte.ie.

This is a very long answer and I will not reach the end of it. I understand the frustration of the Deputy’s constituents. It is their new home. It is fully understandable.

In respect of scheme map approvals for large developments and multistorey buildings, the introduction of scheme map approvals for large scale developments was introduced by Tailte Éireann as a means to speed up the process of registering individual housing units once the development was completed. The developer submits the plans for the estate or multistorey building to Tailte Éireann to create a draft layer on the map of the relevant plots or sites in expectation of applications subsequently being lodged. No change is made to the parent folio at this stage and no new folio numbers are provided. Prior approval of a scheme map is not a legal requirement in the conveyancing process. However, by drafting all sites in accordance with an approved scheme, it removes the need for each individual house in the development to have an engineer set out its boundary accurately for registration.

Only on receipt of a valid application by the new owner will a copy of the approved scheme map be enclosed. Finally-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Minister of State will have two further minutes to come back.

Comment on this

Yes, I will come back.

Comment on this

I appreciate there is more in the reply than he has the time to read.

Comment on this

The Deputy might just go through whether it is to do with the developer or with-----

Comment on this

That is what I was going to say because I happen to agree. The Minister of State’s reply stated, “…knowing the history of progression of the case and whether the application is [ordered] to proceed to registration”. I cannot even get to that point. What I am getting back is that the couple’s case is in a queue, but I already knew that. That is why I reached out to Tailte Éireann in the first place. I do not need another creative writing exercise, telling me they are in a queue in a different kind of way. I need to know where the case stands. Unless the couple can establish the point at which this application is, they cannot even look at making a case for an expedited application. They are hitting wall after wall. Their solicitor is telling them they cannot go ahead and the mortgage provider is saying they cannot draw down on this mortgage.

They know there is a folio number for the overall site. It is not even a big site. It is not multi-unit development. There are only about 12 houses in this development. It is a small development. They have a folio number for the overall site, but they do not have the individual jigsaw pieces, of which their houses is one piece, that make up the overall site. I am being generous when I say that both the couple and I are going in circles trying to find out exactly where this application is. As I said before, if it is a case of something missing, a mistake the developer made or something has not been signed that should have been, that is fine. Tailte Éireann should at least give them that information so that they can bring it back to the solicitors and they can move it forward. At this rate, who knows how long this could take. It could be next week or next year by the time this young couple have the keys of their home in their hands.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Clarke for raising this important matter, which I am taking on behalf of the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage, Deputy James Browne, and for giving me the opportunity to clarify the position on the allocation of folio numbers to new-build developments and the role of Tailte Éireann in that regard.

Tailte Éireann has published on its website a report of all applications on hand currently, by year of lodging. It may be of assistance to the Deputy. I will provide her with the link. The report is updated on a monthly basis and includes the progress made on all applications received from each year or quarter year. Significant progress has been made in all areas of registration to reduce processing times for applications. I am confident Tailte Éireann has the resources and procedures in place to further reduce processing times for all applications seeking the provision of a new folio number. I expect that their solicitors have made contact with the Land Registry. Obviously, I will provide the Deputy with that link so that she can see this information online. She could also write to the Department and the Minister, and we can follow up on with this particular matter.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

If it is of any consequence to both Members, Tailte Éireann is the subject of a lot of submissions to me under Standing Order No. 55 on the basis of inadequate answers. The Minister of State might take that back to the Minister.

Comment on this

They are exercises in creative writing.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

That concludes Topical Issues. We will have a sos for 40 minutes.

Comment on this