We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›

Social Welfare Payments

Summary

The Minister said the living alone allowance is restricted to people living alone, while fuel allowance can cease if a returning adult family member does not meet permitted household criteria; he defended targeting but agreed to examine Deputy Wall’s cases. Wall argued that low-paid or part-time relatives returning home should not leave older people without fuel support.

4. Deputy Mark Wall asked the Minister for Social Protection if he is aware that older people accessing payments such as the living alone allowance and fuel allowance are now losing such payments due to a family member having to move back home; and the steps he is taking to address the issue. [78258/26]

Comment on this

I raised this matter with the Minister during the debate on the Social Welfare Bill the other evening. Could he comment on it now?

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Wall. He has raised this matter consistently.

The living alone allowance is paid to people who receive a qualifying social welfare payment and live alone. The purpose of the payment is to recognise that a person living alone must meet the cost of running and maintaining a household from a single income. Allowing the payment to continue where an adult family member has returned to live in the home would fundamentally alter the nature of the payment and could raise questions of equity and fairness with respect to other two-adult households to whom a living alone allowance would not be available.

The position with fuel allowance is different. A person does not automatically lose fuel allowance when a family member moves into the household. However, fuel allowance is a household-based payment, where the qualifying criteria target scarce resources to those households most in need. Where a returning family member is not in receipt of a qualifying social welfare payment, entitlement to the payment may cease. Disregarding the status of a household member when determining entitlement would, again, significantly change the household-based and targeted nature of the scheme.

I would have to consider any changes to the qualifying conditions of either scheme as part of the policy and budgetary process. I would also point out that in the recent budget, the means test for the fuel allowance for a single person over the age of 66 years increased from €534 per week to €640.80. We anticipate that between 8,000 and 10,000 extra people may qualify. As I have done previously, I encourage all Deputies to examine their constituency cases. I have noticed in my own office many people who were previously excluded from the fuel allowance who now qualify for it.

Comment on this

I take the Minister's point on the living alone allowance, but unfortunately, I cannot take his point on the fuel allowance. I gave the example here the other night of a young lady of 24 years of age who had come back to live in the family home and was working part-time for three days a week. Her father is on a disability payment and they have lost the fuel allowance. I can provide the details to the Minister and his Department. I get a lot of these cases, and I cannot understand why, in a housing emergency, we are disallowing families fuel allowance when there is no other option for their family member but to come home. Otherwise, it would be up to the State to provide accommodation. It has thankfully gone up to €43 per week, but for a single person in my area, if a housing assistance payment, HAP, were provided, it would be €700 per month. The figures do not add up. The Government is saying that it will give someone €700 if they stay out of the family home but it will not give their parents €43 per week if they go under their roof. That is the reason I have raised this and will continue to raise it. In many cases, this is wrong.

Comment on this

Fuel allowance is not automatically withdrawn because a family member moves into the house. However, it may affect entitlement because the fuel allowance has a household composition and a means condition. The scheme specifies who may live with a claimant without affecting entitlement, and there are many options there. This can include, for example, a spouse or a partner, dependent children or another person who is receiving qualifying social welfare payments or may qualify in their own right. If an adult family member moves in and does not come within one of the permitted household categories, the claimant may no longer satisfy the household composition condition. That may arise where an adult child is in employment. I will look at the Deputy's case, but there could also be a situation where somebody in a very well-paid job moves in for a period. It is about how we come to balance that kind of situation, where the household income goes well beyond the means test.

Each case is considered on individual circumstances, and the broad change the Deputy is suggesting would be a major change to the fuel allowance scheme and may potentially undermine the targeted nature of the scheme. I do not want to do that. However, we certainly want to assist households that are under pressure and I do not want anybody to lose their benefit as a consequence.

Comment on this

Maybe it is just the constituents I have in Kildare South, but I have a number of examples of people whom the Government has rightly targeted with fuel allowance who are now losing this payment. It is probably right of me to send those on to the Minister and his Department to show exactly what is happening. I have that case of a person from a clinic in Kildare town last Monday, but it is just one of many examples that I have. These people do not have the family member coming back on large wages. In many cases, including the one I have cited, they are part-time wages. That particular person was going to college.

It is time to look at such cases because these families are losing out on their benefits. In most of the cases that I am dealing with, they need the fuel allowance. If they have a family member come back who is not on the substantial wages that the Minister mentioned, then they lose out. That is the targeted measure that the Minister mentioned and that I am looking for to take care of those people.

I will send on those examples to the Minister, and maybe then the Government could look at the type of person I am dealing with through my clinics.

Comment on this

Absolutely, we will look at those examples. In budget 2026, I expanded eligibility for the fuel allowance by some 50,000 families to include those on the working family payment. In budget 2027, we expanded the means test for single people over 66 from €534 to €640.80 per week. This could make another 10,000 people eligible. I am certainly interested in expanding the scheme, but doing so on a targeted basis that ensures the aim of the scheme is still respected. We also have to protect the viability of my overall budget.

I will look at the cases, in particular the engagement with HAP and other issues. However, it is important that we ensure that the scheme remains targeted and we keep its targeted and direct nature. The more targeted it is, the more resources I have to increase it annually.

Comment on this