We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions ›

Social Welfare Benefits

Summary

Child Benefit remains €140 monthly, unchanged since 2016; the Minister defended prioritising targeted child supports and said all payments are under review, with work on a possible second-tier payment planned for 2027. Nolan argued families need greater help and criticised waste in school meals, while the Minister cited survey support for the universal programme and promised improvements.

6. Deputy Carol Nolan asked the Minister for Social Protection the reason the core universal monthly rate of child benefit has remained frozen at €140 per child; if he acknowledges that the baseline rate has not seen a structural increase since 2017; and his Department's assessment of the way in which this prolonged freeze has impacted middle and low-income families. [80316/26]

Comment on this

Figures revealed in parliamentary replies I received from the Minister's Department show that at the end of last year, 347,736 social protection recipients in this State were non-Irish nationals, that is, 17.6% of our entire multibillion-euro welfare apparatus. The habitual residence condition, HRC1, is supposed to be a statutory firewall that protects our non-contributory safety net from exploitation and welfare tourism.

Comment on this
David Maxwell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fine Gael

I am sorry, Deputy. That is not the question that is on the clár.

Comment on this

It is the child benefit one.

Comment on this

It is related to HRC1 assessments in the past 24 months.

Comment on this
David Maxwell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this
David Maxwell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fine Gael

The question I have on the clár looks for "the reason the core universal monthly rate of child benefit has remained frozen at €140 per child" and asks the Minister if he acknowledges that the baseline rate-----

Comment on this

I am sorry. This is the question I understood was-----

Comment on this
David Maxwell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fine Gael

Has the Minister got an answer to that question?

Comment on this

No, I do not have the answer with me. This is the question we were given. There was confusion over the Deputy's questions.

Comment on this

Okay. There is obviously confusion. Tá brón orm faoi sin.

Comment on this

I was given the question in relation to child benefit.

Comment on this
David Maxwell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fine Gael

Does the Deputy have her question on child benefit?

Comment on this

No, but I can manage without it.

Comment on this

I have an answer for the other one. It will be-----

Comment on this

That is fine. I will be putting in more parliamentary questions anyway; that is 100%.

On the child benefit, can the Minister give us a review of what is being done, and answer the question with regard to the universal rate?

Comment on this
David Maxwell An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Fine Gael

I am sorry about that, Deputy.

Comment on this

The Deputy will get a written response in relation to the habitual residence condition.

As the Deputy knows, child benefit is a universal, monthly payment made to all families with children up to the age of 16. It is paid to over 680,000 families in respect of almost 1.3 million children. The annual expenditure on the scheme in 2026 will exceed €2.2 billion. The payment is also paid in respect of children until their 19th birthday who are in full-time education, or who have a disability.

Since 2016, the rate of child benefit has been paid at €140 per month, with higher payments made in respect of twin and other multiple births. Based on research by the ESRI and the minimum essential standards of living study by the Vincentian Partnership for Social Justice, among others, our focus over recent years has been to target increases to payments to where they will deliver to families on low incomes and families reliant on social welfare payments.

Accordingly, we have implemented significant increases to child support payments, which are paid with most weekly social welfare payments. Compared to 2017, the rate for children under 12 has increased by 115% and for those over 12 it has increased by 182%. That means the payment rate in 2027 for children over 12 will be €84, compared to €29.80 in 2017.

Similarly, we have lifted the income threshold to access the working family payment by €284 per week, from €511 per week to €795 per week, compared to 2016. There are also the universal supports, such as the school meals programme, the free schoolbooks programme, the newborn baby grant and the free GP visit card for children. They give universal access and reduce the costs faced by parents. They should be considered in this context.

This targeted approach is more effective in reaching our child poverty ambitions. We will continue to keep all payments to children, including the universal payment, under review.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister’s response and the fact that there is a targeted approach, but families are currently finding it difficult with cost-of-living expenses and utility bills spiralling out of control because electricity companies have not been held to account. The increases are not enough. They are minimal. We need to see more measures to support families and children and ensure families are not left in a cycle of disadvantage for generations to come.

The Minister mentioned the school meals programme. I have spoken to many school principals and parents in this regard. It is an absolute disaster. There is a lot of waste. Reviews need to be carried out on the school meals programme. I am all for supporting families who need help, but I question the effectiveness of this programme. Should a targeted approach be taken, instead of having waste? I am hearing from school principals in my constituency that a lot of food is wasted and thrown out. I want to have a sensible approach and see families supported. Payments such as child benefit should increase for genuine applicants - I stress genuine applicants - in a targeted and fair way that matches the cost of living.

Comment on this

We are engaging and will be carrying out work throughout 2027 around a potential second-tier child benefit payment. It is complex work.

We carried out a comprehensive survey on the school meals programme, which I published in September. We contacted 600 school communities and some 80,000 parents participated in it. While there are challenges, it is certain that people see the scheme as a positive. There are challenges around waste but when issues such as absences are taken out, waste levels are as they were before the universal school meals programme was introduced.

As a former teacher, the Deputy will be aware that it is difficult for children. School lunches were always difficult. The universality of the schools meals programme is important. In any given classroom on any given day, we do not know what situation a child has come from. This may be their only chance to have a proper meal. We are making changes to the school meals programme to respond to that survey. Certainly, I look forward to engaging in this regard.

I also point out that the free schoolbooks programme, the school meals programme and the assistance available through the GP cards have all helped to reduce the cost of living for families. We will continue to focus on those supports.

Comment on this

To take up the whole point of the school meals programme, principals and teachers are clued into the needs of children in the school community. They are vigilant and they watch the children who need additional support and help. They should be commended for that. There is waste with the scheme. From speaking directly to school principals, I know there is dismay because they are finding it difficult to get an extension or resources for their school while, at the same time, they are seeing money wasted with the approach that has been taken. A better approach could be adopted in this regard.

Of course, we need to always help and assist children who are trapped in a cycle of disadvantage, whether it be through the schoolbooks programme, which I supported, or otherwise. I was one of those individuals who called for the free schoolbooks programme to be introduced. It is welcome.

Free GP cards are all well and good if we have the GPs, but we have a chronic shortage of them in rural Ireland. I have been raising this issue for a number of years. It is all well and good giving children free GP access, but there needs to be greater consultation with GPs because there is a chronic shortage.

Comment on this

To reiterate, we carried out a survey on the school meals programme. We surveyed some 2,420 teachers and principals, 740 schools, nearly 7,000 children and 86,637 parents. A total of 78% of the teachers said the meals were acceptable. The children were generally happy, and the parents were happy. There are issues around waste and nutrition, however. I have published a plan as to how we are addressing those issues. That work is under way in the interdepartmental group and will be completed before the start of the next academic year in September 2027. We could not run this programme without the engagement of the school communities, principals and teachers. Certainly, I will provide the results of the survey to the Deputy for her information and feedback. It provides a somewhat different story.

I totally understand the Deputy on the issue of rural GPs. We are trying to work on it. In our rural development policy, Our Rural Future, there are a range of different supports to get medical services into rural communities using the 420-odd hubs available for broadband connectivity. Certainly, GP access is an issue across the country, for both rural and urban communities. The Minister for Health, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, and the Minister for Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science, Deputy Lawless, are working hard to expand access to training and degree places so that we can have more GPs on the ground.

Comment on this