We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Written answer

Pension Provisions

64. Deputy Conor D. McGuinness asked the Minister for Social Protection whether he will agree to meet with a group (details supplied) who were excluded from previous pension settlements, to discuss their circumstances and the possibility of a resolution. [78597/26]

Comment on this
Dara Calleary Minister for Social Protection Fianna Fáil

This issue relates to a group of former workers who left the service of Waterford Crystal between 1990 and 1992 under a redundancy arrangement. At the time of the redundancy, the workers received a refund of their pension contributions relating to their service in the relevant company pension schemes up to that time. As a result, they then ceased to be members of the pension scheme and no longer had any rights or entitlements under the schemes.

Separately, in 2010, a legal action was taken by a group of former Waterford Crystal workers against the State following the insolvency of the Waterford Crystal Factory and Staff pension schemes. The case (known as the Hogan case) related to the failure of the State to transpose into Irish law the provisions of the Insolvency Protection Directive. The Directive requires Member States to ensure that necessary measures are taken to protect employees' occupational pension scheme benefits where an employer becomes insolvent.

In 2015, a mediated settlement was reached between the parties to that legal action. The mediated settlement applied to all persons who were members of the Waterford Crystal Staff and Factory pension schemes on the date of wind-up of the schemes (31st March 2009). In total, 1,774 scheme members are covered by the agreement. The total costs to the Exchequer arising from the mediated agreement were estimated at €253 million.

No member of the schemes with preserved benefits on the date of wind-up was excluded from the mediated settlement in respect of their preserved benefits.

Those former employees of Waterford Crystal who previously took redundancy and received refunds of pension contributions were not eligible to be included in the mediated settlement as they had no preserved benefits in the schemes on the date of wind up.

Following a meeting with some of those affected in September 2024, the former Taoiseach requested the Attorney General to review the claims being made by the former workers, including the allegations around the failure of the employer and trustees to provide leaving service options. The Attorney General, and an independent Senior Counsel, advised that there is no basis on which the State could be obliged to compensate the persons concerned or otherwise intervene. Following receipt of the advice of the Attorney General, I wrote to the group representing the former workers to inform them of the position.

There is no basis to meet with this group or to intervene in relation to a matter, which is concluded from the perspective of my Department.

Comment on this