Referendum on changing the triple lock
McDonald argues that weakening the triple lock requires a referendum, citing Brian Cowen’s earlier commitment and the importance of the UN mandate to Irish neutrality and peacekeeping. The Taoiseach says neutrality remains unchanged and that referendums are held to amend the Constitution, while defending the Government’s approach amid challenges over his past position and the Security Council’s role.
I welcome everyone in the Gallery but mention in particular the college students from Ballymote, County Sligo, who attend a former college of Deputy Eamon Scanlon, of whom they are guests. They are most welcome.
Comment on this
Sa bhliain 2002, dúirt Brian Cowen, a bhí mar Aire ag an am, nach mbeadh aon athrú ar an nglas triarach gan reifreann a chur ar na daoine. Cén fáth go bhfuil an Taoiseach ag briseadh an ghealltanais seo anois?
In 2013, the Taoiseach told this House the triple lock was "at the core of our neutrality". He said the push to weaken it was part of a wider effort by "a wing of Fine Gael to erode neutrality" and he was unequivocal at that time. He said, "My party and I completely reject this." Now he is doing the very thing he once condemned.
During the Lisbon treaty referendum, the Irish people were given legally binding assurances that the treaty would not affect Ireland's military neutrality. As Minister for Foreign Affairs, he helped to secure those assurances. The declaration accompanying Ireland's ratification reaffirmed the triple lock. Overseas deployment required UN authorisation, Government agreement and Dáil approval.
Of course, he was not the first Fianna Fáil Minister for Foreign Affairs to make such a commitment. In 2002, ahead of the second Nice referendum, the then Minister for Foreign Affairs, Brian Cowen, assured this House that "there will be no change to [the triple lock] unless the people first give their assent in a referendum." Now, as Taoiseach, Deputy Martin is walking away from these solemn commitments. He cannot ask people to trust assurances on neutrality and then discard the safeguards that gave them practical force. He cannot tear out that safeguard and insult the intelligence of the Irish people by claiming that nothing is changing.
This is a fundamental breach of trust and reports suggest it is not even a settled position within the Taoiseach's own party. His own colleagues, members of his parliamentary party, have described what he is doing as "a fundamental change in Fianna Fáil policy". If they are advising the Taoiseach to stop this, it is because they are listening to the Irish people in a way he simply is not.
Do not take the Irish people for fools. The proposed EU mission in Lebanon shows exactly what is at stake. It is not a peacekeeping mission. On RTÉ's "This Week" on 25 October the Minister, Deputy McEntee, said Irish troops should join an EU mission in Lebanon, that the role was likely to involve peace enforcement and, crucially, that Ireland could not take part in this mission unless the triple lock was changed - in other words, an EU mission without UN authorisation.
In other words, it would not be a peacekeeping mission at all but something very different.
What the Taoiseach is proposing is no mere technical adjustment. It is a fundamental change to Ireland's foreign and defence policy. The Government wants to remove the triple lock so it can deploy Irish troops on missions without a UN mandate. The Government cannot break its word, remove the triple lock and fundamentally undermine Irish neutrality without at least first asking the Irish people. If the Taoiseach is sure that he is right and that the Irish people would support this course of action, he should put it to them and let them decide. We need a referendum on this question.
Comment on this
Fundamentally, ní aontaím in aon chor leis an méid atá ráite ag an Teachta maidir le neodracht na tíre. Níl aon amhras ach go bhfuil an Rialtas taobh thiar den pholasaí a bhaineann le neodracht na tíre. Nílimid chun é sin a athrú in aon chor. Tá a fhios ag an Teachta é sin. Gach aon bhliain agus i rith na mblianta, tá Sinn Féin ag rá go bhfuil deireadh le polasaí na neodrachta ach níor tharla aon deireadh leis an bpolasaí sin. Bhí Sinn Féin aiféalach 50 bliain ó shin agus tá sé aiféalach i mbliana.
Over 50-odd years, the Deputy's party and movement have declared that Irish neutrality was at an end. In 1972, they said the same. It was quite extraordinary commentary at that time. They said that if we joined the European Union, it would be the end of Irish neutrality. Every single EU treaty was to be the end of Irish neutrality. There was going to be conscription, just like the Deputy is saying now.
It was all false and all proven to be false subsequently. No Irish soldier ever joined a European army. After all the treaties and after joining the European Union, we never joined NATO. That did not stop the Deputy's party saying it, though, during every single referendum on a European Union treaty. Sinn Féin opposed every one of them because it is fundamentally anti-European Union. Then it accuses the European Union of being militarist, when it is not. It is the biggest peacekeeping project in the history of the 20th and 21st centuries. That is why the European Union came together, but the Deputy's party opposed it and continues to oppose it.
I take issue with some of what the Deputy has said, some of what she said last week and some of what she has said on social media, where she blatantly told a false narrative and an untruth when she was saying that Irish soldiers will end up on the side of Israel. That is endangering Irish troops who are currently on a United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon, UNIFIL, peacekeeping mission.
Comment on this
Did the Taoiseach tell Kaja Kallas that?
Comment on this
We have been down the middle as peacekeepers and Irish soldiers have lost their lives. Unnecessarily creating false narratives of that kind endangers soldiers who are currently on a UNIFIL peacekeeping mission-----
Comment on this
Did the Taoiseach say that to Kaja Kallas?
Comment on this
-----and Deputy McDonald should desist from doing that.
What happened in 2002? We had a referendum to amend the Constitution and inserted Article 29.4.9°, which reads:
The State shall not adopt a decision taken by the European Council to establish a common defence pursuant to Article 1.2 of the Treaty referred to in subsection 7° of this section where that common defence would include the State.
So we cannot join any European army. We cannot be part of any European defence pact because the Constitution prohibits it. The only way we could be part of that would be to seek the deletion or amendment of that Article 29.4.9°. Sinn Féin has ignored that for the entirety of this debate.
The world has changed very significantly for the worst because of the rogue behaviour of members of the UN Security Council that Sinn Féin wants us to defer to. In essence, it is saying Russia, which has violated every principle of the UN Charter, should be the decision-makers in respect of where Irish peacekeepers go in future. That is the de facto reality right now. There is no point in the Deputy nodding her head-----
Comment on this
I was shaking my head. This is nodding and this is shaking.
Comment on this
-----because the UN Security Council has Russia as a member. UNIFIL is ending. Why? Because the United States, under pressure from Israel, wanted it to cease. We have been peacekeepers in Lebanon since the 1970s.
That has come to an end because of another member of the UN Security Council.
Comment on this
The only decision-makers on this question, a question as fundamental as this, are the Irish people.
Comment on this
That is why the Government should go to a referendum. In 2002, the Taoiseach's predecessor Brian Cowen acknowledged this. Let me repeat, "there will be no change to [the triple lock] unless the people first give their assent in a referendum." That is the correct and democratic position. That is the position that recognises the importance of this issue to Irish people. The triple lock is fundamental to our foreign and defence policy. The Taoiseach knows this. That is why it was introduced in the first instance. He knows that removing the need for a UN mandate transforms entirely the nature of the deployments of our soldiers and of Irish neutrality itself. If anybody is proposing a course of action that will put Irish lives at risk and Irish soldiers in danger, it is the Taoiseach and not I.
Comment on this
Let us have the debate where it needs to happen-----
Comment on this
----among the Irish people. Have a referendum and allow them to make the democratic call.
Comment on this
We have never had a referendum that does not involve either adding to, deleting from or amending the Irish Constitution. That is when we have referendums - to amend, delete from or add to the Irish Constitution. We then have, under our Constitution, a parliamentary democracy. That is the basic, fundamental tenet of how we operate our democracy. We are not Switzerland; we do not have referendums on issues per se where we are not adding to, removing from or amending the Constitution. That is a clear point.
Comment on this
That was not Brian Cowen's view.
Comment on this
That was not the Taoiseach's predecessor's view.
Comment on this
The Security Council will not sanction any significant new measures and has in our peacekeeping missions. Look at Russia-----
Comment on this
There are substantial peacekeeping mandates still in place. That is rubbish.
Comment on this
-----with the Sahel in Africa, where the Wagner Group has been deployed by Russia to exploit for the benefit of Russia.
Comment on this
No, I want you to keep your word.