We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions

HSE deficit and health-service funding

Summary

Bacik says promised oversight and budget controls have failed as the HSE faces a deficit exceeding €1 billion, arguing that the service is under-resourced. The Taoiseach cites major increases in health spending and staffing, including a supplementary budget, and defends the need for budget controls.

This was supposed to be a landmark year for the reform of our health service. The Minister for Health had promised rigorous oversight, transparent reporting, population-based funding, savings of €181 million and no supplementary health budgets. It turns out those so-called promises were the stuff of fantasy. In reality, hospitals are in chaos and the HSE is plunging into a deficit of more than €1 billion, which is potentially the second largest in its history. The Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, claimed the HSE broke even last year but it actually recorded a massive deficit then, even with a supplementary budget, too. Now, we know that next year's health budget will be swallowed up before it can deliver any of the improvements patients need.

Those improvements are needed badly. Professor Matthew Sadlier of the IMO gave a startling interview on "Morning Ireland" yesterday. He warned of sharp rises in pressure in our hospitals. Almost 1 million people are already languishing on waiting list and the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation has warned that accident and emergency departments face a dire situation this winter, with admissions already up on last year. Shockingly, 2,900 nursing and midwifery posts are currently vacant and yet the Government tells us the health service is overstaffed. This is Orwellian doublespeak, especially for the many patients languishing on trolleys and for any of us with a family member in hospital. We know those patients receiving care on trolleys face a higher mortality risk than those who are treated in hospital beds. In a month's time, we all fear that chairs could sit empty at Christmas dinners around the country because of terrible failings in health and short staffing.

My thoughts are with hospital patients but also with healthcare workers. Because of the Government's recruitment freeze and spending restrictions, they are forced to work in impossible circumstances and they know they are working under unsafe conditions. They know their patients might get sicker because of staffing pressures. To add insult to injury, it seems they are being gaslit by the Government. At Cork University Hospital, we saw the double counting of staff who moved from agency contracts to HSE contracts. The same people were carrying out the same work at the same hospital but were counted twice for the purpose of fictional staffing figures.

It is time for honestly in healthcare. Tomorrow morning, the Labour Party will bring a motion to the Dáil calling on the Taoiseach to tell the truth on health spending and health staffing. We are demanding an honest, multi-annual funding plan, based on the actual needs of patients and the health service. We are calling for a supplementary estimate to meet the actual cost of health services this year. Why is the Taoiseach systematically under-resourcing our hospitals and will he support our Labour Party motion tomorrow?

Comment on this

We have no issue with telling the truth about the exponential growth in public funding in the health service over the past five to six years. The spend has broken all records. We need a debate, not just on spend, spend and spend. We need to make sure we prioritise and get good outcomes from the spending. Equally, that is an important debate to have. The Government passed a supplementary budget for health today.

Comment on this

About time.

Comment on this

It was a very substantial one, over and above what was provided. Health funding will have risen by about €13.7 billion, or 88%, between 2019 and 2027. The overall 2027 health allocation is €29.1 billion, comprising €27.4 billion current spend and €1.7 billion capital. The workforce has grown by 31%, or 31,544 whole-time equivalents, to over 133,000, currently. Those are the facts.

Comment on this

What do we have to show for it?

Comment on this

By any yardstick, that is a very significant expansion of our health service. The population has grown. Demand has increased. Pressures on the hospitals have increased, particularly as our population is ageing and growing on an ongoing basis. We have recruited about 11,125 additional nurses and about 5,000 additional health and social care professionals. In our hospitals, spending has gone up by about 52% and staffing by 33% since the start of 2020. There is no argument that there has not been a very significant increase in spending.

As I have said, we have had significant population growth. We have increased acuity and complexity among presenting patients and there has been a sustained rise in demand for urgent and emergency care. Emergency department attendances by the end of August this year have gone up 7.2%. It went up 9.8% for those aged over-75. We fully accept that but that, in itself, does not explain what was the HSE overspend.

To be fair, for any deficit in any year, some of that is because of demand-led schemes. Some of that is down to structural pressures, such as drugs, pensions, State claims and demand across community health schemes, which have to be met. That always leads to the necessity for a supplementary budget. There are other areas, from pay to agency overtime and so on, which are outside of that. Basically, no one could disagree that we have to have some framework in terms of public expenditure and spending within the health service. The Deputy says there has been a freeze. There has been no freeze. A total of 400 whole-time equivalents have been recruited in September of this year alone.

Comment on this

We absolutely agree with the Taoiseach that we need an honest framework for health spending. The problem is his framework is not honest. It is fictional. What he says happens every year is overspending. The Taoiseach says the health service is overspending. What we say and what patients and healthcare workers say, and what they see, is underfunding. The Government is under-resourcing the health service and then accusing hospital managers of overspending. It is not adding up, either way. These budgets that the Taoiseach presents us with are fictional because you need supplementary budgets every year to meet what he has acknowledged are the increased pressures on hospitals. The increased pressures are being felt everywhere and being felt most of all by patients who are not receiving the care they need. Just this morning, I heard from a distressed woman whose 87-year-old sister was admitted to St. Vincent's hospital in my constituency on Saturday night. By yesterday evening, she still had not heard from her. The previous time she was admitted to hospital, the same patient spent months in turmoil because they could not discharge her. For two thirds of this year, more than 500 patients who were medically fit to leave hospitals had nowhere to go. Delayed discharging is costing more than €20 million a month and yet the Taoiseach persists in saying that hospitals are overspending. They are patently being underfunded and we need to fix this.

Comment on this

That is not the case, actually.

Comment on this

It is the case.

Comment on this

The Deputy talked about limits and so on. Staffing in the HSE increased by almost 400 whole-time equivalents in September of this year, bringing the net increase in staff for the first nine months of the year to 4,000 whole-time equivalents. That is the net figure after departures. It is not simply the number of people recruited. There has been a net increase of 4,000 in the first nine months of the year. Recruitment has not stopped. At the end of September, we were at 133,000 plus whole-time equivalents. The number of nurses and midwives increased by 992 in the first nine months of 2026. Those are the facts.

As I said earlier, you get supplementary budgets and it is a substantial supplementary budget this year. A lot of it is demand-led schemes, although not all of it, and about 65% is spent on structural demands that are ongoing within the public health service. When I came back in in 2020 during the pandemic, we dramatically increased the base of health spend. We actually dealt with all of the supplementaries. We were told to gave another €1 billion. Does the Deputy remember that? We did.

Comment on this

The vacant posts-----

Comment on this

The Deputy needs to be a bit more honest herself. In Opposition, I understand the rigours of trying to control budgets is not an appetising prospect but the Government has to have some framework.

Comment on this