Deer Management: Discussion (Resumed)
Witnesses said deer numbers are rising, with more collisions, farm damage and biodiversity pressure, especially in counties such as Kerry, Cork, Wicklow and Tipperary. The RSA reported that deer-related casualty collisions remain a small share of all crashes but material-damage collisions are increasing, with a seasonal peak from September to December; it also warned it will lose access to narrative collision data, making future monitoring harder. The CCMA called for better data-sharing, while FBD backed the national strategy and noted 466 deer-related claims since 2020. The NARGC argued for stronger culling coordination, a better venison market, cold-storage support and more TB testing, but said hunters need incentives and more joined-up backing to participate.
Contributions 124–253 of 253. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
-----once the initial period is completed.
Comment on this
Absolutely, and we will be looking at it with a view to implementing it elsewhere if it is successful. As well as that, there will probably be conditions under which it might work. It may not work everywhere, but under certain conditions it may be effective. We will be looking at that level of detail regarding the pilot.
Comment on this
In terms of the NARGC's presentation and some of the recommendations Mr. O'Connor mentioned, his second point was that "culls should be carried out on a more concentrated basis in conjunction with deer management unit ... co-ordinators". What kind of relationship would the NARGC say it and its membership have with the deer management unit under the farm relief services? It has been mentioned that we had a briefing from them last week and they are very open to working with gun and hunt clubs. That is the feedback I get from local clubs at home, but I cannot help but think that point is kind of saying we need further co-ordination and what exists there is not good enough.
Second, local shops that were not able to sell local venison due to rules and regulations were mentioned.
Will the witnesses speak a bit more about that? What are the regulatory changes? There are issues in relation to farm shop selling. The NARGC has 25,000 members. Does it have figures for the number of deer that are culled annually by its members? In relation to the open seasons order, which was extended in 2024, does the NARGC believe it should be further extended?
Comment on this
Regarding the open seasons order, we have to be very careful in what we say. The Senator raised several other points. On the relationship with deer management units, we welcomed from the very start the deer management strategy forum and the work it was doing. We engaged with it from the onset and we participated in its various committees. As Mr. O'Connor said, we offered assistance as it was rolled out, particularly in local areas, because this is where a lot of the problems arise. In an area where there are local deerstalkers, whether they are our members or not, they work with the farmers and control the numbers. All of those people have to be brought on this journey in the management of deer. Sometimes, that chain of thought can get lost in the process, and some people might be moving along at a quicker pace than others. Collaboration and engagement are vital at a local level. That is where we need to focus and ensure-----
Comment on this
Does Mr. Butler believe that is not happening?
Comment on this
It is not happening everywhere, although it is happening extremely well in some places. There are 15 deer management units around the country. Some of them are very actively involved and others not so much. That is for various reasons, but I am not going to go into those reasons here today. Suffice to say, collaboration and engagement with local deerstalkers are vital, irrespective of whether they are in a deer society, in our association or doing it privately. Everybody needs to be brought on board. That is the job of work that Farm Relief Services has to do. It has to bring everybody on board at a local level, identify where the problem is, create a solution to that problem and then analyse the results. It is a three-legged stool: identify where the problem is, create a solution for it and analyse the results.
That looks simple on paper and it should be simple in practice as well. However, in Ireland, we have a tendency to complicate things, especially where there is money involved. We need good, strong oversight and follow-through. As I said, what we tend to do in Ireland is jump at a problem, throw a heap of solutions at it, throw money at it and then walk away.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in and for their opening statements. Road safety is a big issue. If deer come out of a landowner’s or farmer’s land, who is responsible if there is an accident on the road?
Comment on this
At the moment, where incidents occur and if claims arise, they are paid out of the policyholder’s own policy. There is no right of recovery against third parties in that type of incident. Deer are part of wildlife.
Comment on this
Are we saying that the landowner is responsible?
Comment on this
No. In relation to the damage to the person's own vehicle, that is covered under their own policy as an accidental damage claim where that occurs.
Comment on this
The local authorities were mentioned. I presume the local authority has no say, high up or low down, as regards deer coming onto roads.
Comment on this
My understanding is that the legislation would have to change to pin the responsibility on the local authority. To be fair, I want to be clear I am not commenting from a legal perspective. I can only speak on insurance matters.
Comment on this
Who is responsible for putting up road signage to make people aware that there are deer in the area?
Comment on this
We are responsible for all road signage. We put up road signage in the public domain on an ongoing basis, where it is required.
Comment on this
Does the CCMA put up road signage to alert drivers and road users that there are deer in the area? Is it responsible for that on local and minor roads?
Comment on this
We are responsible for the signage. Where we are aware of a particular hazard regarding crossing deer or deer being present on a road, we would erect warning signage to that effect.
Comment on this
I cannot say it is on all roads but where we become aware of it, and the district engineer and the council make a judgment call that signage is warranted, the signage will then be erected.
Comment on this
That is very important. Regarding the deer management co-ordinators, does the CCMA work with them on where signage needs to go up in localities?
Comment on this
There is probably some contact between them in particular areas. I think there are 15 different areas in the country. I expect there would be contact between some of those and the local authority in areas where there is a particular issue. It may not be everywhere.
Comment on this
What we are saying is that if signage is needed in certain areas where there are black spots, the CCMA would be the responsible body to contact and it would see to getting it put up by the local authority. Is that correct or is it the CCMA that puts it up?
Comment on this
We would put it up ourselves as a road safety initiative, where we are of the view that it is beneficial.
Comment on this
That is very welcome. With regard to insurance for people who are ordered to shoot deer when they go onto a landowner’s property, I do not think we got a clear answer. Who exactly is responsible for the insurance if one of those people is injured on a landowner’s land?
Comment on this
I am sorry, I am not sure of the question. There are two distinct elements. We are happy to provide insurance to people engaged in hunting deer. If there is an incident on the land at a point in time, it is the circumstances of the incident that will pinpoint who is responsible for that incident. What we can say, from the insurance companies’ perspective, is that if we are insuring a farmer and the farmer is held responsible for an incident that occurs on his land, the policy will support and protect that farmer. The liability will only be determined at the point of the incident but if the farmer is held responsible, the insurance is there under the farm policy.
Comment on this
That is if the farmer is held responsible. However, if the farmer has nothing to do with this person going onto his land and an accident happens, how can the farmer be held responsible at that stage?
Comment on this
That is a legal matter as opposed to an insurance matter. It will not even come to us if the farmer is not held responsible.
Comment on this
We do not want to see landowners having concerns about people going onto their land to shoot or cull deer, which it is important to carry out.
Another concern that is still out there is TB. What is the update on the testing of deer for TB? There is that discussion. People feel that deer are responsible in certain locations for the spread of TB. What is the view of the witnesses?
Comment on this
I will take that question. The professional opinion remains very divided on what animals are carriers of TB and how it is initiated. Whether it is badgers or deer, it is definitely a shared responsibility. In relation to deer testing, which we covered earlier, NARGC members and other hunters who participate in the NARGC game meat handling certification are taught and qualified in how to inspect the carcass of a deer for signs of TB.
When a detection takes place it is then a legal requirement that the deer be reported to the regional veterinary office.
Comment on this
We all know that badgers are some of the main culprits, and there is no point in saying that they are not, but-----
Comment on this
-----we are not really sure about the deer.
Comment on this
In relation to whether a deer is carrying TB or not, we are fairly sure. It would be a very small percentage that would slip through the net. A very small percentage would get past a trained hunter. You have to undergo the trained hunter course to submit a venison deer carcase into the food chain.
Comment on this
To go back to road safety, is the number of accidents increasing or decreasing year by year?
Comment on this
There has been a year-on-year increase every year from 2019 right the way up to 2025.
Comment on this
In 2019, there were 122 material damage collisions involving deer. Last year, there were 262.
Comment on this
That is a fairly significant increase. I presume most of these accidents with deer happen on local and minor roads.
Comment on this
They are happening in particular in locations where there are high populations of deer.
Comment on this
I presume there have been no fatalities from deer collisions.
Comment on this
There have been no fatalities that we have recorded from 2019 up to 2025. There have been 41 injury collisions, of which 15 were serious injuries and 26 were minor.
Comment on this
It is a concern, as we all know, unfortunately. The good thing is there have not been fatalities. We should do everything as regards safety to make sure there will not be fatalities into the future and, if at all possible, to prevent deer from coming onto any type of a road. It is a big concern, especially by night.
Comment on this
The Road Safety Authority has a role in raising awareness. Something we will take away from this meeting will be to make our awareness efforts more targeted, and not only on social media. Maybe we should do targeted media in the likes of Kerry, Wicklow and other counties which the data shows are particularly impacted by this. That is something to take away from today's meeting.
Comment on this
The RSA can include east Clare in that.
Comment on this
It is a concern there as well. I thank the witnesses.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman. I will be precise about this. I will ask questions and I ask for straight answers so that I can get through them quickly because I want to stay within the time. Does the RSA believe that roaming deer pose a serious threat to road users, with the possibility of causing fatalities, serious and minor injuries on our roads? I ask for a "Yes" or "No" answer.
Comment on this
What engagement or concerns, if any, has the RSA raised with the Government or the line Minister with regard to the dangers and accident history caused by deer on our roads?
Comment on this
I am not aware. We would have regular contact, more so with the local authorities and the local road safety officers in terms of the data that we have and in terms of campaigns-----
Comment on this
There is no contact with the Government or line Ministers.
Comment on this
Nothing that has been sought from us and we have not been in contact.
Comment on this
The RSA did not seek any meetings whatsoever?
Comment on this
I have listened very carefully to the witnesses' answers about this but I am still going to ask this question because I believe there is under-reporting in a big way, and especially because of the statement that there have been no fatalities. That is actually incorrect-----
Comment on this
Does the RSA hold any statistics on the number of traffic collisions involving animal strikes, namely, by deer and, if not, why not? According to the RSA's new interactive map, there have been over 50,000 collisions on our roads since 2016. Do any of these involve animals?
Comment on this
Between 2019 and 2024, the RSA spent €26.2 million on media campaigns. Of that, just shy of €40,000 was spent on advertising where animals are involved regarding horse safety. Why does the RSA not do media campaigns around the dangers posed by deer on our roads? I remind everybody of the eye-watering money the RSA spends on media campaigns. In 2019, it was €4.16 million; in 2020, it was €2.67 million; in 2021, it was €4.35 million; in 2022, it was €4.91 million; and in 2024, the partial figure was €2.3 million. The amount of money the RSA is spending on media campaigns is frightening, and it does not ever mention a deer once. Out of all the millions going through, €40,000 is spent on horses. I ask it to comment on that.
Comment on this
Our role is in research but also in education and to carry out awareness campaigns. That is what we do. The cost of awareness campaigns is expensive. We target the killer behaviours, the behaviours that are most likely to kill or seriously injure people on our roads. These are drink driving, speeding and not wearing seatbelts. They are the major campaigns we do. This is not to say we do not do anything in terms of animals, in particular deer. We have worked with the local authorities and their road safety officers. We have engaged in social media campaigns as well. As my colleague Ms Coleman said, we can engage with the local authorities, in terms of the particular counties that are showing high levels of collisions with deer, on local media campaigns as well.
Comment on this
I want to note a point. It has been stated here that deer, according to the RSA, are causing accidents. They have caused deaths, even though there is under reporting about this because not half of the accidents are being reported. In the county that I represent, County Kerry, there are accident strikes every day in certain areas. They are going under-reported. By the RSA's own admission, it is a serious problem. At the same time, it is spending millions of taxpayers' money every year without once mentioning deer. The RSA, on two individual media campaigns alone, spent €1.7 million. One was the "Lose your Licence, Lose your Independence" campaign, while the other was the 30 km/h town song. Members will know the lovely song it used. Eye-watering money has been spent on a glorified tourism advert, but in no place whatsoever does the RSA ever emphasise the dangers posed by roaming deer on our roads. Before I came to the meeting, I listened twice to the 30 km/h song. I challenge anyone to listen to it before they go to bed tonight. It is more tourism related than related to safety. All of those millions are being spent and still the RSA does not see fit to mention roaming deer coming onto our roads. At the same time, the RSA comes before the committee today to say that, yes, it is a problem, but it will not spend money on it.
Comment on this
We have not said that we will not spend money on it.
Comment on this
The RSA is not spending money on it, unless it is going to change its policy after today. Actions speak louder than words. I have raised continuously that the RSA is spending millions and millions every year. The public does not even realise the number of RSA campaigns there are. If the RSA is doing 50 campaigns every year and spending €4.16 million on them, as it did in 2019, it is not being effective. The one thing it should be doing, but it does not seem to place any significance on it, is address the deer that are roaming on our roads.
I am caught for time but I want to ask another couple of questions. From records obtained through parliamentary questions, I have learned that the RSA spent more on a staycationing advert campaign in 2021, to the tune of over €80,000, than it has spent over six years on campaigns around the awareness of deer or any form of animal on our roads and potential threats to our road users. At this stage, and following on from today, in front of the excellent Chairman of this committee, will the RSA please commit to spend something on alerting people to deer coming onto the roads? It is going through money like snuff at a wake.
Comment on this
We can certainly look at it. As we said earlier, we will look at the particular locations where the collisions are occurring and work with the local authorities in terms of campaign activity.
Comment on this
I am very thankful to the Chairman. He knows where he comes from and he knows where I come from, and deer are a problem.
I very much welcome it if the RSA is committed to re-evaluating its media campaigns with a view to emphasising the real and potential dangers posed by roaming deer on our roads. I know of individuals affected by this issue, including a father and son. On one morning, the son hit a deer. The following morning, the father was driving the son to work and going on to work himself and he lost his car on the second morning. That was two strikes out of one house in two mornings. They were two honest-to-God people going to work. At the same time, in anything we hear out of the RSA, we never hear a mention of deer. It is not as though the RSA does not mention things. I would challenge anybody to google the RSA's campaigns that cost this State millions upon millions every year. I will tell you one thing: the RSA is keeping some media agencies fairly busy. There are some people making some money out of these media campaigns. I would highly question their effectiveness, with all due respect. Mr. Rowland knows I have been challenging this for a long time. People would actually want to wake up and start looking at what the RSA is doing with its budget. It is missing a big picture when it is not mentioning deer.
Comment on this
As I said, we will look at particular campaigns. To clarify, we are not re-evaluating our campaigns but we will look at activity in relation to deer and the local authorities where those collisions are recorded.
Comment on this
The RSA has the money. It is making up lovely songs and paying piles of people-----
Comment on this
-----piles of money. I ask it to look at the deer, please.
Comment on this
I welcome all the witnesses and thank them for coming here. It is very important. All the members have spoken about the damage and harm that deer are doing to people on the roads. Anything that compromises safety is terrible. I have a question in regard to an answer that we did not get here last week. As I have said, the safety of people driving on the roads is the first thing. We can add to that the damage and hurt they care causing farmers in spreading TB. I asked last week what percentage of deer are tested, and it was said that only 2% of deer were infected with TB when they were tested. The Department would not give us the figure. I am hurt about that. If it knows that 2% were infected, it should know the number of deer that were tested. It refused point blank to give us that figure. We are elected members here in this committee and we are entitled to that number. It should not be hidden from us. It was hidden deliberately, I would say to the Chair, because we did not get the answer. The Department of agriculture failed to give it to us. It would not be there at all if it were not for the farmers. There would be no need for a Department of agriculture.
Mr. O'Connor said something that is very central to where I live in County Kerry, where there is an awful prevalence of deer. They have taken over completely, particularly in south Kerry, where the forestry is hiding them. He said it would be better to have concentrated culling rather than doing a bit and coming back. I would like Mr. O'Connor to expand a bit on that because it seems sensible to me. In fact, I honestly think we will not deal with the problem we have in Kilgarvan and south Kerry without bringing in some big team. Maybe it has to be the Army. If we are to make the roads safer, the deer will have to be seen to. I do not know what is meant by "managing deer" but, to me, they have to be got rid of. They have to be shot and culled and that is it. Could Mr. O'Connor explain a bit in regard to what he said about concentrated culling?
Comment on this
We feel that concentrated culling would have multiple positive impacts on the control of deer. When you are shooting and controlling a large number of deer rapidly, it gives you a quick look at TB-affected deer in the area. It also allows you to expand your hunt area and to keep going until you are free from TB. Now you have controlled the area and you should have harvested enough TB-affected deer. If you need to eradicate in that area, you need to eradicate in that area. You cannot just leave a few because you think you are at a manageable population. If they have TB, you need to kill the deer, and that is just it. The concentrated cull would also be more beneficial to hunters. With a concentrated cull, you could land a temporary cold room in the area. That would give hunters their outlet and save them driving 100 miles with three deer in the back of the jeep for €80, when they are spending €120 on diesel.
Comment on this
I am conscious of the clock. In relation to the RSA, surely it must know the problem we have in Kerry. Has it any idea how serious it is and how dangerous the roads are? It was in the news about the Macroom bypass and the problems we have on several of the roads. Is the RSA not taking it seriously?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the question. We do take this seriously. The data show us it is less than 1% but in particular counties it is of major concern. Kerry, as we identified, is one of those counties. I was in Kerry recently with the local road safety officer and we work very closely with the local authorities. Our job is to produce research and education and awareness campaigns. We have given an undertaking there. We have done and continue to do campaigns during the rutting season but we have given an undertaking to look at the particular counties that are more affected to see if we can do local media campaigns in conjunction with the local road safety officer.
Comment on this
All right. A previous speaker said that he was glad there were no fatalities. I cannot agree with that because we know we have had fatalities. A mother of three young children lost her life in Ballydowney swerving from deer. A man from Kenmare lost his life coming down Moll's Gap. When he was coming into Muckross, he avoided deer and hit a tree. They are dead. Dead people cannot talk but we are fairly sure that is what happened to those two people. There are others I cannot bring to mind. People have been seriously injured. There are young fellas after paying for insurance to get on the road who are glad to be going to work in the mornings - it is not as if they are out at night - but the deer make flitters of their cars. This is happening in certain areas like Kilcummin. It is not all along the main roads. It is happening on the byroads and class 3 roads. It is happening there. The deer hop out over the ditches.
I cannot see any real way of dealing with it other than culling them. Almighty God, it has been said in Europe that sika deer are vermin. We cannot touch the red deer, which are the national herd. We cannot touch them but we still have to make our roads safe, even with them. They are treated as vermin now in Europe. Why should we be trying to spare or save them? The phrase "deer management" is alien to me. The only thing is to get rid of them. That is the gospel truth. I would not hurt a hair on anyone's head. I appreciate wild animals, but not when they are causing mayhem on our roads. We know what is being done with fellas who just want to have two pints and drive home on a country road. They are not even allowed to do that. We should have zero tolerance of deer on the road. The RSA should get behind this. It should be front and forward in getting rid of them completely out of the countryside for the safety of people's lives.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. We have the opportunity to allow members to ask a few more questions if they are minded to do so. Will we do four or five minutes?
Comment on this
The RSA data shows there were 41 injury collisions involving deer and avoidance of deer between 2019 and 2025 with non-fatal casualties. Does this suggest that deer are a low-impact road safety risk or is it that there is under-reporting or misclassification in the data?
Given the concentration of claims in counties such as Kerry, Cork and Wicklow, do representatives from FBD Insurance believe enough resources and co-ordination are currently in place at local level to manage deer populations effectively?
The CCMA has called for stronger data sharing between local authorities, the RSA, An Garda Síochána and the deer management units. What is currently preventing that co-ordination from happening effectively? The CCMA highlighted the impact of deer on biodiversity and native woodland regeneration, which is huge for every local authority including Laois. In the view of the CCMA, are deer populations now undermining the State's ability to meet its biodiversity and nature restoration targets?
Comment on this
I will take the question on data. The Garda records data and we report on the data the Garda records. We get regular daily downloads from the Garda in relation to the collisions data it records on its system. We interrogate that data to inform our interventions and to inform communications with committees like this one. The numbers that have been reported are the numbers that have been recorded by An Garda Síochána, so I cannot comment any more on that. There has been some reference in relation to fatalities. Certainly, it does not come up in our data that there have been fatalities between 2019 and 2025. The strongest thing that strikes me is the material-damage collisions, of which there were 1,382 during that period.
Comment on this
Coming back to whether enough is being done in relation to the management of deer, it is important the strategy is put in place because it is the number of deer that is the real issue here. It is at the heart of deer numbers on the roads. We need to manage that unsustainable number of deer we have in Ireland. It is about ensuring that project is successful going forward.
Comment on this
Mr. Rowland has outlined the process through which information is shared with the RSA, but we do not get that information.
Comment on this
We should and we need it in order to do all our various road safety projects. We are awaiting legislation to pass through the Oireachtas to allow that data to be shared with us, but we are waiting a couple of years now. It is a bit frustrating from our perspective that we do not have that information but are still awaiting it. We have no detailed information on the types of accidents that are occurring-----
Comment on this
That is something that is very clearly coming out of this meeting.
Comment on this
----or where they are happening.
In terms of biodiversity, an overpopulation of deer has a negative impact on biodiversity so it is important from our perspective that there is an appropriate population of deer, whatever that might be. It is not for us to decide and there are other agencies that are expert in that. It seems to us, from a biodiversity perspective, that there is an overpopulation of deer in certain areas and they are having a negative impact.
Comment on this
I will ask a question about TB testing. I have to compliment the NARGC as it is very proactive. When they shoot the deer, they try to get the Department to test them. They are testing negative. I count some years as being very high from the perspective of the number of deer shot and the number of deer proved to be positive. That is alarming as far as I am concerned. For farmers in every county, an outbreak of TB can be as a result of this because deer are showing up where they never were before. I recently spoke to a farmer who told me he was coming home one night and saw a deer across the road from his farm, and he had never seen a deer in his life before. His farm is a good bit, at least 15 miles, from the woods, so they are travelling more and more. Whether that is in search of food or what it is I do not know, but it is probably something to do with the overpopulation as well. From a TB point of view, it is alarming to think these are the statistics the NARGC got. I compliment it on the work it is doing because if it is helping to cull like that, it is preventing TB in some way. The one thing I am fearful of is the amount of travelling deer as a group do.
Comment on this
We are curtailed for time, but in relation to the deer population we have to ask what happened. Whether we like it or not, for three years deerstalkers in this country were not allowed to cull deer due to Covid. There was an explosion in the population of deer. Deer are wild animals. They are not domesticated animals. There was an explosion in population and they have seriously multiplied since. There are efforts being made to try to manage and curtail that. I like to hear people say they would like the population back to a sustainable level because that is what we want. I must take issue with Deputy Healy-Rae's assertion that deer are classified as vermin in Europe. They are not classified as vermin.
Comment on this
Sika deer are classified as an invasive species, but if we get into the nuts of bolts of invasive species I do not know where we are going to stop because there are a lot of invasive species. Deer have been here before the people in this House were here and, hopefully, they will be here long after that.
Comment on this
Yes, but I am talking about the people here currently.
Comment on this
I am talking about the people who are here currently. A sustainable population of deer is what I think we are all striving to achieve. However, I do not think any game species should be classified as vermin, especially given the good that deer and venison can provide to people in this country and other countries. Management is what it is all about.
Comment on this
Mr. Butler said the NARGC was in here before and that these conversations were had before. How long ago was that and were any commitments given in relation to data collection? From those conversations, is that where the Irish deer management strategy group came from?
Comment on this
It was, yes. Unfortunately, the previous recommendations that went to Government only went to the level of the recommendations going into the Departments. However, the management of deer and the management of nature is a complex issue in itself. As I said, it is overseen on this island by the National Parks and Wildlife Service.
The National Parks and Wildlife Service had a major independent review a number of years ago. One of the recommendations from that review was the setting up of a permanent forum for nature in Ireland. That commitment was brought to the Government and accepted by the Government. We have been given a number of dates for that forum to be set up on a permanent footing and each one of those dates in the last three years have been missed. The benefits of that forum being set up would not only be to ensure the recommendations coming from the deer management forum were acted upon and carried through, it would encompass the management of all species, birds and animals in Ireland, nature and their habitat. I urge this committee to push on the Minister responsible to put that permanent structured forum, which was an independent recommendation accepted by the Government, into place and into action. The key stakeholders would be on that permanent forum and they would advise the Minister of the day. The likes of that would ensure the slippage we have seen over the last number of years regarding how we manage crises and problems in nature and habitat does not happen again.
I am not saying it will completely wipe it out but it will go a long way towards ensuring that it is kept to fore, particularly in instances like this, where currently we have a problem with deer. There is no doubting that but I would imagine, given the proper resources and with the proper structures in place, in a number of years we will have a very manageable population of deer in Ireland and that is the way it should be.
Comment on this
My next question is for Mr. O'Connor. If I come across a deer that I suspect has TB, what is the format then?
Comment on this
The process then is that you contact your regional veterinary office and it is supposed to send a vet to the area to carry out an inspection. The vet will take away the deer carcass and carry out an inspection.
Comment on this
If the deer is found to have TB, what does the vet do then to cull the rest of the deer? Does the vet contact the NARGC and ask it to go into the area to wipe out or cull more animals?
Comment on this
Yes. I would imagine that a co-ordination plan would be put in place between the farmer who owns the land and the Department of agriculture and then the hunter would be brought on board to carry out the cull.
Comment on this
Instead of going to the NARGC to inform it of what has happened, will the vets and the Irish Government now go to the Irish deer management strategy group? If so, what will it do then? There are 15 units. Are they hunters, clerical staff or managers? Who do they go to to cull the deer?
Comment on this
They are managers. I am not 100% sure about who they go to. They can go to hunters but I suppose they can do a lot of it themselves. A lot of the deer management strategy group managers are hunters themselves and so are available to do a lot of the culling themselves.
On the TB testing, in the pilot project that I synopsised earlier, the farmer went to FRS about carrying out a cull on his farm. He told FRS that he wanted TB testing done on the animals that were shot but the FRS told him that it was not something it could facilitate. That is why he reverted to us to do it.
Comment on this
That is wrong. Control has to be done. I am struggling to see what these 15 deer management units are going to do that was not already being done. The data should have been collected long before now. They are telling us that we will not have data until September 2027.
Comment on this
They are saying that are going to start collecting data in September and it will be the following year before we get it. I am wondering how they are going to get it when I know that back in 2022, when they started this, they had only spoken to 1,500 people. I do not know what the figures for hunters were back then but now they are saying there are around 7,000 licensed hunters and yet they only spoke to 1,500. They were not even getting the people who were doing the work already on board. I do not like to see us putting money down a drain and the likes of TB, which is so important to farmers, not being taken on board. This should have been thought about long before now. This should have been done back in 2022 when they were given their job. They should have been told that part of their work was to try to eradicate TB and that deer have a part to play in that.
Comment on this
It is a fact that the sika deer, otherwise known as Jap deer, were imported in here some time in the last century. I do not know the date. They were not here before then. We always had the red deer. There is another issue that we have to be aware of as well. My daughter, Councillor Máire Healy-Rae, has raised the issue of Lyme disease several times with Kerry County Council and has also written to the Minister for Health about it. I would not wish it on anyone. A strong, powerful man who was playing football from Kerry cannot lift a balloon now and mothers with children cannot mind them. They cannot change their nappies and that is a fact. The deer are spreading that Lyme tick.
Mr. Butler said that we must manage the deer. There is only one way that I know to keep the deer off the roads and out of farms and that is to shoot them. If he knows of some other way of managing them, I want to hear about it. It is no good telling deer not to come down onto the road or into Paddy Mick's place above or Seán Murphy's place below. How can we manage them? To be realistic about it, we cannot manage them and that is why we are here talking for the last three hours. We were here last week as well. The fact is we cannot make it safe without shooting these deer. We are bound by the red deer. They are part of the national herd that has been here going way back. I do not know how far back but these deer will have to be cut away down all together. There is no way of managing them, to be honest. I am not being smart or anything but we will have to cut down the numbers. There is no way of catching them or bringing them home. I do not know of it anywhere. If Mr. Butler knows of it, let us get lorries, load them up and carry them away out of the place because we have enough of them anyway. Tim Herlihy in Rathmore and all of the farmers from west of Valentia island are robbed and broke because of the TB and it hurt the mental health of some people. That is a fact. The worst of it all is to lose someone. That is the worst but they can damage the cars of people who are going carefully to work, coming home from work or of young mothers taking their children to the doctor or whatever. We cannot have that. It might hurt some people to shoot them but the fact is that there is no other way of managing them unless we want to stun them, load them up and take them somewhere else, but where is that place? It is not practical to fence every ditch along every road from A to Z. That is not practical so I cannot see any other way apart from employing people, no matter who they are. We will have to get rid of them and make the roads safe. That is our duty. People are paying tax and insurance to go on the road and at least they should be able to travel the roads safely. We are here, elected by the people, and they are depending on us to do something that will be effective. The phrase "deer management" is driving me cuckoo because I know that I have failed to manage them even though I have fences up. I still have them but that is not the worst at all. The road is the serious thing. People are being killed and maimed on the roads and we will have to do something about that. If anyone wants to say anything more, I am happy to listen.
Comment on this
When I said manage the deer population, I did not rule out shooting them because I am a deer stalker myself. I shoot deer. Mr. O'Connor shoots deer. The word "management" refers to maintaining the population of deer at a sustainable or practical level in the country. The Deputy is highlighting problem areas in Kerry and that is where they want to put a serious management plan in place to cull those numbers, which includes shooting the deer. I do not have a problem with shooting deer. I am shooting deer all of my life. I have been shooting deer for over 50 years. It is part and parcel of my culture. It is not something I have a problem with. I was reared on the land and off the land. I have absolutely no problem with that aspect of it whatsoever. To me, vermin means rats and stuff like that.
Comment on this
They are called vermin by Europe as well. It was not me who thought up the word.
Comment on this
I firmly believe that the deer population can be managed.
Comment on this
We are getting tight on time. I am conscious that Deputy Aird wants to get in with a quick question. I have a couple of questions as well. Deputy Aird may proceed.
Comment on this
At the previous meeting, it was indicated that €3.6 million was allocated by the Department over four years, which amounts to €900,000 per year. That funding was awarded to FRS to come up with a plan, for want of a better word, for culling deer. Mr. O'Connor just said that FRS was asked out to come out and test deer for TB, after they were shot, but they refused to do it. I stand to be corrected but I understood from the discussion last week that, regarding the €3.6 million that was given by the Department for the culling of deer, the most important thing is that if culling were happening in County Laois today, for example, those deer would be tested for TB. That is the most important thing to do in order that we can eventually, having spent that money, build up a database showing the situation in the different areas throughout the country. I know there will be a problem with the Six Counties and having to go over and back across the Border. Be that as it may, I was hoping we would be able to say that Kerry has the highest level of TB among deer and Laois the lowest, or whatever it might be. It seems a fair expectation. Am I right in that?
Comment on this
All I would ask is what good is the data if we are not going to deal with the problem. Counting deer is only the biggest cod in the world because we know there will be 20% more if we go back tomorrow. We would be all the time counting them. We must do something reasonable, like pay for the bullets for the shooters. Some kind of funding must be put towards the shooting of the deer. Counting them and collecting data is all nonsense.
Comment on this
A sum of €3.6 million has been given. That is taxpayers' money.
Comment on this
We will try to get answers for the Deputies on that point. I am conscious of the people watching at home who were hoping their questions would be raised, including those who, over the past few days, sent in questions either directly to members or otherwise. Of the two questions addressed to me, one is for the local authorities, which are very involved with land purchase and building new roads. To what extend is wildlife management, including deer management, taken into account when new roads are being built? When the N22 from Macroom to Baile Bhuirne was being built, for instance, underpasses were built or modified to allow wildlife through. I am conscious that a vote is being called in the House. Will the witnesses indicate whether that practice was an exception? To what extent is wildlife, including deer, management taken into account when new roads are being built?
The second question raised with me is for the hunters. There is often a great deal of engagement with landowners regarding shooting because permissions and so on are being sought. There are a large number of people living in rural Ireland who are not landowners but who have an interest in when shooting is going on. They are conscious of the shots being fired at night in the wood beside them. They might walk about and meet groups of people with guns. They will see the headlight below in the field when a kill is being cleaned out, etc. They are often taken by surprise by all of that. Is there any communication with rural people when a shoot is going on in an area? Is there any possibility for signage to be put up to make people aware they will be hearing shots that night, or is the assumption that they will be taken by surprise and must grow accustomed to hearing shots and meeting groups of armed people and people with headlights in a field? Those two questions, which I address to the local authority and the hunting representatives, respectively, are questions people at home want to ensure are asked.
Comment on this
The consideration of impacts on wildlife, flora and fauna is fundamental to any road scheme the local authorities, TII, the NTA or anybody else might design. There is a particular requirement to consider the potential impact on designated sites and protected species. By "designated sites" I mean Natura 2000 sites, special areas of conservation, special protection areas and natural heritage areas. We must be sure before a scheme is put forward that those impacts are minimised to a level that they will not affect those species or those areas. Thereafter, we put forward the scheme, with mitigation if necessary, to An Bord Pleanála for approval. A full environmental impact assessment is prepared, as well as a Natura 2000 impact assessment. Those documents go into the public domain, are examined by the statutory authorities and eventually a decision is made by An Coimisúin Pleanála as to whether the scheme can go ahead.
Comment on this
Yes, that is a typical installation now, particularly on motorways and more substantial roads where there might be a barrier in the centre of the road. In those cases, we have to put in underpasses for wildlife, including badger passes and passes for all other small fauna in the area, to allow them to pass safely under the road, as they have passed for hundreds and thousands of years before the road was built. Those passageways go in on all the major road schemes and we must maintain them.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Kehoe. My other question was about communication with non-landowners in rural areas.
Comment on this
I am not sure I can answer the full extent of that question. Normal deer-stalking takes place in the early morning and late evening. If it is on private land, it is done with the permission of the landowner. From a courtesy perspective, if there are private dwellings within the surrounding area, those residents would be notified that deer-stalkers will be operating. That is not a legal requirement but it is what I do from a courtesy point of view. Shooting deer at night-time requires a special licence. It is not something I do or know much about. There is a special permission requirement under section 42 of the Wildlife Act to do it, with lots of additional steps to which the applicant must adhere. It is done under a special licence, which does not apply to normal deer-stalking or deer culling.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Butler. The division bells are ringing. One of the witnesses might quickly address Deputy Aird's question, or if they do not feel there is sufficient time to do so, they could send a response to the committee.
Comment on this
I asked about the €900,000 that is being given out every year for the next four years. Will the deer be tested?
Comment on this
I do not know what FRS's policy is on testing the deer.
Comment on this
It is not doing great engagement.
Comment on this
I will get back to the committee on that.
Comment on this
Will the witnesses write to the committee to address any other questions that remain unanswered? Members can likewise address any further questions they have to the secretariat. A vote has been called in the past few minutes. On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their participation and for the wealth of information they have shared.