Impact of Greenways, Railways and Roadways on Agriculture: Discussion (Resumed)
TII and local authority representatives defended greenways as public infrastructure that can justify CPOs, but said voluntary agreements should be the norm and compulsory acquisition only a last resort. Much of the exchange focused on complaints from landowners that consultation is too late, maps and preferred routes are published before meaningful engagement, and farm severance and biosecurity risks are not being avoided enough. Officials said the code of best practice requires staged consultation, public and individual engagement, and compensation or accommodation works where needed, and that the Department’s greenway strategy is under review. Several members called for a reset: use public land first, involve the Department of Agriculture more, and prioritise routes that minimise impact on farms.
Contributions 162–327 of 327. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I will, but I want to get the points over. More importantly, it is not about you or me.
It is the people who are watching this debate tonight. They want to understand the issues. I think I have articulated them pretty well myself, if I may say so. Perhaps we will start with Mr. O'Connor.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. I largely agree with him. For public lands, in the first instance, I agree. Private lands should only be through voluntary agreement. Certainly, our preference is always through voluntary agreement with CPO only as a last resort. The point I answered previously to another member of the committee around severance of land is that there is an acknowledgement from TII that perhaps the approach to date has been somewhat too rigid in trying to get the most efficient route. If we can skirt around a landowner's property, that should be something we look at more so than we have in the past. We see an opportunity to reset that as part of the overall strategic review the Department of Transport is undertaking. The Senator's themes and the broader interaction with other policy priorities is exactly where those issues should be highlighted again because we have that opportunity to revise the strategy over the next few months.
Comment on this
Could I just ask Mr. O'Connor to finish that one point on the mandatory requirement of the Department of agriculture to be involved.
Comment on this
We have this review of strategy, so I think the Department-----
Comment on this
Can. Mr. O'Connor say to this committee today that he personally supports that idea?
Comment on this
I am asking Mr. O'Connor directly.
Comment on this
It is a strategic review run by the Department of Transport, so I am happy to go back to the Department of Transport and encourage it.
Comment on this
Is Mr. O'Connor personally committed to it? Can he put on the record here that he is committed to that course?
Comment on this
That mandatory Department of agriculture involvement.
Comment on this
And Mr. O'Connor would support it - actively
Comment on this
I welcome our guests this afternoon. I thank them for their statements. I would like to speak about the south Kerry greenway, if I may. First, I want to call again on TII and the local authority to expedite payments to all landowners where agreements have been reached. The south Kerry greenway is along the old railway line. At the time, we were given little or no leeway to move either side. It was minimal. I acknowledge the funding that has been announced to date and the work that has been carried out. It is top class. We are already seeing the benefits in the three relatively short sections that have been opened and completed. It is important for the area, obviously.
We are talking again today about CPOs. I believe in it. Of course, not everyone will agree with me but, in our case, I do not think the south Kerry greenway would have happened only for the CPO. I fully understand the value of land to farmers especially. I want to call again today to expedite all outstanding agreements with regard to accommodation works and compensation. As I have said many times in the past, we must be generous because the greenway will be there forever. We will not. It will serve generations to come. The fact that it has taken years to reach agreement has not been helpful. I must say that, Chair. We are not going to get a big company or big factory to set up in our area in Glenbeigh or Cahersiveen or any part of Iveragh. This is a big plus for us going forward. It will create jobs. It will bring in people. We have seen the success of greenways elsewhere in counties Mayo and Waterford. We saw the section that was opened from Tralee to Fenit and how busy it is.
With regard to the issue of agreements and payments and all of that, I have raised it many times with Kerry County Council but equally so with the Minister, Deputy O'Brien. He, too, is anxious that agreements are reached and landowners are paid. I know there is legal work and all of that to be sorted. I referenced the funding announced to date. It is a huge vote of confidence in south Kerry and in the future of this particular region. It has been questioned with regard to value for money. I know that no two greenways are the same and they have different terrain and all of that. An estimate of €2 million per kilometre was given. Our greenway is over 30 km. The project cost is €72 million. It will rise, quite possibly. I think it is good value for money. If we do not have people, we have nothing. Tourism is hugely important to Kerry and south Kerry, in our case.
With regard to the CPO, there was a vote in Kerry County Council at the time. The vote was 24-8 or something like that. The vast majority of councillors voted for it. I keep making the point that it is hard for two or three people to agree to something, but in our case we had 138 landowners. It was almost impossible to get agreement. People asked me today about what would happen if they were trying to do a railway again. I would say it just would not happen. It is important that the landowner is satisfied because without the land and the landowner, we will not have a greenway. That is why I make the point about being generous, and it is not my first time saying that. The message from this meeting would be to complete agreements as soon as possible and be generous in the context of the accommodation works and the compensation.
Comment on this
I equally support what the Deputy said there and the huge potential of that project.
Comment on this
I would give the example the Deputy referred to in terms of getting all the landowners' agreement. We had that experience on Galway with the Clifden greenway, from Galway to Oughterard and Oughterard to Clifden, in terms of the benefits that will bring from a tourism point of view. There has been a lot of engagement with landowners in developing sections of that greenway. However, there have been a few points where we just were not able to get the agreement even though we had by far the vast amount of support from the local landowners. Our experience on the ground is not as negative as some of the experiences I am hearing here in terms of the opposition to greenways from landowners. Talking about the landowners, as Mr. O'Connor mentioned, we do work in terms of early engagement with landowners, route selection options and picking the preferred route. Then, when we pick the preferred route, we try to tweak that so that it has the least effect on landowners. We do get a lot of support from landowners with regard to the greenway. However, there always comes a point, and we have experienced that, when we do not get agreement from them all. In order to be able to deliver that infrastructure, which is very much welcomed in the broader society because of the broader economic opportunities that come from it and the community support and tourism support, it is the last piece of a tool we use to try to deliver that objective. As Mr. Kehoe mentioned, it does start from a development plan. That is subject to public consultation and a reserved function of our members. Therefore, we very much have broad support for it both from the community chamber of commerce elected representatives and farmers in terms of the delivery of the greenways.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for their submissions. I have a couple of quick issues. The witnesses mentioned a cost of approximately €2 million per kilometre. I know that is not set or anything, but how much of that is construction cost versus purchase cost? Has TII got a balance that it tries to find in respect of it? I know it varies from each one.
Comment on this
On average, of the total cost of 100%, about 65% is the cost of construction, about 10% is the planning and design and then there is another equal. Around 8% to 10% would be for the purchase of land as well.
Comment on this
I am not asking Ms Fitzpatrick to-----
Comment on this
On average when we are doing a CPO.
Comment on this
So, it is about €1.3 million per kilometre, on average, if it is 65%. If it is costing €2 million, €1.3 million of it is for construction.
Comment on this
On the construction of a roadway, if TII was to build a kilometre of roadway, what does that cost?
Comment on this
Just recently, because of inflation, etc., costs have gone really high.
A motorway costs about €30 million per kilometre to build.
Comment on this
On the issue of purchase, the public good has been mentioned several times. In the city of Dublin, there are vast areas with huge numbers of young people that have no sports facilities. The young people have no public grounds to play football on. Would it be appropriate for the State to compulsorily purchase land to give them a playground? Is there an instance of that happening?
Comment on this
Local authorities are empowered to acquire land for any purpose, once it is supported by an objective in the development plan. If there is a need identified in the development plan for community infrastructure, transport infrastructure or whatever it might be, we can seek to justify a compulsory purchase of the land required to deliver that, if we are not able to acquire that land by negotiation and agreement. That general provision is there in a number of Acts.
Comment on this
It is there and we use it from time to time, when necessary.
Comment on this
It may well be appropriate but usually it would be in circumstances where there is an essential need. In general, it would be used for something that is seen as essential.
Comment on this
Exactly. We would have to justify that in the application for the CPO that we would make to An Coimisiún Pleanála. It would have to be supported by an objective in the development plan.
Comment on this
One of the points raised was that greenways cost approximately €2 million per kilometre, of which approximately €1.3 million would be construction costs. What is TII's budget to develop greenways?
Comment on this
It varies slightly from year to year but it is approximately €60 million a year.
Comment on this
There is approximately 3,000 km of greenway at some point of development. Is that figure reasonably accurate?
Comment on this
I do not have a figure to hand. As I said in response to a previous question, there are approximately 60 projects at various stages of development.
Comment on this
Would the projects have an average distance of 20 km each or more?
Comment on this
They are between 20 km and 30 km, on average.
Comment on this
Three times six equals 18, which means the total is 1,800 km or more. Is that correct? We will say there are up to 2,000 km. A figure of 2,000 km at €2 million per kilometre amounts to €4 billion. Is that right? My head for figures is not as good as it used to be but I think it is in that ballpark.
Comment on this
The global point is that with the €60 million a year, there is only a subset of those projects we will be able to deliver in the medium term.
Comment on this
There is an opportunity over the next number of months, as the Department undertakes a strategic review of the approach to greenways, to look at whether we can focus on the delivery of a smaller cohort of projects in the medium term.
Comment on this
I am watching my time and it is very short. How much of that €60 million is spent on consultancy firms that are developing projects to get them ready for application? Would it be 10% or 40%?
Comment on this
It would be a proportion of that design element that we spoke of when giving the breakdown of costs.
Comment on this
A lot of consultancy firms are making an awful lot of money preparing applications for submission that do not have a snowball's chance in hell of ever getting anywhere because the money simply is not there to do them. There is an issue here because a huge amount of public money is being eaten up to draw up plans and put all sorts of proposals in place. A retired man who worked in a local authority told me that a proposal went to a consultancy firm to get an application for a greenway to go ahead. He said that he and two other local engineers talked about it for an hour one evening and concluded it would never happen. That conversation cost nothing but the consultancy firm got a couple of hundred thousand euro for doing the exactly same as the engineers, who knew the outcome because they had the experience on the ground. A huge amount of State money is being eaten up by consultancy firms to develop projects that will never happen. The figures Mr. O'Connor cited confirm that many of them can never happen. Does he understand my point from a public accounts perspective? This is not the public accounts committee but does Mr. O'Connor understand the point I am making? Does he accept it is something that needs to be a key part of any code that is being reviewed?
Comment on this
"Yes" is the short answer to that. We are the approving authority, so it is the local authorities that come up with proposals.
Comment on this
I accept the point and the opportunity now presents itself-----
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses back to the committee. Mr. O'Connor said TII currently has 60 projects but many of those projects, which will cost money, will never get done. I support the previous speaker in that regard. I am not against greenways. I am trying to get funding for one in Portlaoise that runs right along the bog, following an old line that was used for shunting peat into the mill. It is there and ready to go. It would cost very little money. That is a greenway that can stand up and go but so many of the proposals being put forward will never happen.
TII, which is using State money, should stand up and be counted on day one. It should say it is delighted with the proposal and it is a great project but that it will not happen. An awful lot of greenways being looked at are on old railway lines. The old railway lines have all been turned into practical farming land. There are even houses built on them. There are cows, paddocks, roadways and everything. It would take years to get to the end result. Can we just have a bit of joined-up thinking and common sense? That is all I would like. Those are my opening remarks.
It is easy for somebody to come in here - the said gentleman is gone now - and talk about CPOs and how they are very good and needed. I wonder if he was ever subject to a CPO because I was and I can tell him about CPOs. When someone goes out with a CPO in their back pocket, they are the winner on the day. Do not tell me anything else. The witnesses can give soft talk all they like. This happened to me and the person with the CPO is the winner on the day because they know they will get it.
I would like quick answers to these questions. Has Transport Infrastructure Ireland carried out a national farm safety assessment on greenways that pass through or join active farms? Has the Health and Safety Authority been formally consulted on the development of these routes? I would like a quick "Yes" or "No".
Comment on this
I do not know the direct answer to that. The projects are ultimately run by the local authorities.
Comment on this
I spent many years in a local authority. I will not tell Mr. O'Connor how long. Are local authorities obliged to undertake a farm specific safety assessment before selecting a preferred greenway route through agricultural land? It is "Yes" or "No".
Comment on this
Mr. O'Connor does not know that answer either; that is grand. Has Transport Infrastructure Ireland assessed the risks arising from the interactions between walkers, cyclists, children, dogs, e-scooter users and livestock such as cattle, sheep and horses?
Comment on this
This came up in an earlier question and what we can point to is that on the greenways that have opened to date, those interactions are happening without issue.
Comment on this
That is all right. Who is responsible for assessing whether proposed greenway fencing is suitable and safe for affected farms?
Comment on this
We are led by best practice and facilities that are already in place.
Comment on this
Who tells TII? Who does it get advice from? I am just asking Mr. O'Connor. He is the boss in TII.
Comment on this
We look at those facilities that are already in place and whether they are working. We also look at international best practice and how greenways have operated successfully in other countries.
Comment on this
TII does not have any problems with any greenway that is open? That is great news. There are no farming problems, no problems with dogs or e-scooters and no problems with anything else. Is that what Mr. O'Connor is telling me?
Comment on this
I am not saying there are not individual problems that arise from time to time but I am saying that, across the portfolio of greenways that are operating now, they are seen as very positive overall.
Comment on this
When something happens, who looks after it? Does it go back to the local authority-----
Comment on this
TII will be gone and it is impossible to get in contact with it. We could not even get it down to meetings in the local authority when I was on it.
Who determines whether fencing is stock-proof, bull-proof, stallion-proof or suitable for use alongside suckler cows with calves, sheep, lambs, horses and younger stock? Cattle are very dangerous, especially where there is a dog and a cow with a young calf. Does he realise that?
Comment on this
We design to best practice and we have encountered no issues with fencing to date.
Comment on this
Where does liability land if livestock breach fencing, jump or push through barriers and panic due to interactions with members of the public or cause injury?
Comment on this
Ultimately, when a greenway is built and operational it is in the ownership of the local authority. The local authority's public liability-----
Comment on this
Will the public liability cover the farmers who are affected if something happens as a result of a dog or something going through the fence and the cattle get out, stray onto the road and cause injury?
Who is responsible for that?
Comment on this
It is impossible to give a general answer to that, in fairness. When we deliver greenways, we deliver the stock-proof fencing that is appropriate along all the boundaries. We are then responsible for the maintenance of that fencing over time. Our public liability insurance extends to the route-----
Comment on this
That is grand. Mr. Kehoe is county manager in Westmeath. If a proposal comes forward and he knows in his heart and soul that it cannot be delivered, will he stop it in its tracks and say he would prefer it went somewhere else where it can be delivered on?
Comment on this
What we do all the time, and I think I speak for all my colleagues, is bring forward projects that we believe can and should be delivered. That would be in the context of county priorities. We also look at lots of different funding sources for delivery of greenways and not singly TII.
Comment on this
I am sorry for interrupting but-----
Comment on this
You only gave me 45 seconds and you gave everyone else a minute. I just want to ask one question.
Comment on this
I know, but you should be consistent, Chairman. You gave other people one-----
Comment on this
There are members who have not had the opportunity to speak yet and you had the benefit of the additional time at a previous meeting. Do not be greedy.
Comment on this
There are members who have not had an opportunity to speak yet. I have ten additional questions. We move on to Deputy Lawless, who has five minutes. That will leave a shorter period available to the three other members.
Comment on this
In relation to the Belclare to Murrisk greenway in County Mayo, which is west of Westport, it was recently announced that decision is going to be taken out of the hands of local councillors and will be made by An Coimisiún Pleanála. Why was that?
Comment on this
There is environmental screening that happens at this stage of the project. That is an assessment of the potential impacts on the environment. After that process was recently completed, it was determined that impacts on environmental sensitivities could not be ruled out. That means there is a higher bar in seeking planning consent and it, therefore, goes through An Coimisiún Pleanála.
Comment on this
Will it revert to the local authority or the members at a local level?
Comment on this
No, that determines the planning consent. The route through which planning is sought is determined by the potential impacts or the scale of the project. In this case, it is the potential impacts on the local environment.
Comment on this
I am trying to get my head around it. My understanding is that typically local councillors have a say in relation to a greenway project. Is that the case?
Comment on this
There is a process called the Part 8 process which stays with the council but that can only be utilised if a project screens out, that is, if it is determined there are not potential significant impacts on the environment. The trigger relates to environmental legislation and a sensitive environment so it needs to be assessed by a higher authority.
Comment on this
What is happening here is, because of the environmental aspect, the democratic process in terms of the local councillors is being circumvented. An Coimisiún Pleanála will then make the decision, irrespective of the will of the democratic mandate of the elected representatives.
Comment on this
I might give some additional information. I have been involved in projects for many years so I am aware of both processes. That was a change in the legislation that came through in 2012. Until 2012, a local authority would ultimately make the reserved function decision on projects that would screen in and screen out. However, legislation changed around the time of 2012, which meant that a project like Ms Flynn mentioned, where an independent ecological assessment of the project concluded it was not screened out, was seen as an important element of separation between project development to local authority both as an infrastructure element of a local authority and a planning element of it. The planning report going to the elected members was deemed to be changed in 2012 meaning projects such as that had to go to An Coimisiún Pleanála at that stage. That is why with even for a lot of the small projects we deal with, like OPW drainage schemes, which do not screen out, we are not permitted to adjudicate on them ourselves. They have to go to An Coimisiún Pleanála. That was a change of legislation around 2012.
Comment on this
Environmental grounds, irrespective that they are worth considering, should not mean the reserved function of the democratic mandate of the individual area should be circumvented. However, that appears to be the case here. That is very regrettable.
Comment on this
I am not aware of the Mayo project but I am sure if I looked at the development plan, as Mr. Kehoe mentioned earlier, that would have gone through a public consultation and have been subject to a reserved function. It is embedded within the development plan. It is just the intricacies around the application.
Comment on this
We need to get to the nuts of this. There is a reserved function in the development plan. However, if the environmental aspect hits a threshold, it triggers the oversight of An Coimisiún Pleanála, in which case, the reserved function is bypassed. Is that correct?
Comment on this
We are referring to the policy. The policy to develop a project is in the development plan and that is the reserved function of the members. When it comes to the actual delivery of the project, Part 8 allows for projects below a certain level to be dealt with through the local authority. In that context, the chief executive prepares a report and the members can either reject that report or amend it but they cannot approve it. The members do not actually have an approval process on a Part 8; they can only reject or amend it. If it is above a certain threshold from an environmental perspective, the project goes to An Coimisiún Pleanála for decision. That is the way the system is set up.
Comment on this
At that stage can the chief executive approve or reject it after An Coimisiún Pleanála?
Comment on this
We have gone past the time available to us. I have three more members who are interested in asking and I have ten questions of my own. Deputy Michael Healy-Rae has been patient.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. Compulsory purchase orders are a very contentious issue. Of that, there is no doubt. They leave a bad taste in everybody's mouth and in the projects that are undertaken. Tomorrow night, just to prove that fact, Jason Fleming of the Kerry IFA is hosting a very important meeting between the CEO of our local authority and the farmers who are not yet paid on the south Kerry greenway. It is awful to think there are farmers who have not been paid. The statistic was mentioned earlier and I was just doing the calculation quickly. According to TII, the farmers should be getting €200,000 per kilometre. That does not stack up. Somewhere along the line, those finances are a bit wrong.
Is TII actively considering making the greenway sustainability payment on the south Kerry greenway retrospective on the basis that the High Court action prevented the south Kerry greenway having its statutory consent in a timely manner? "Yes" or "No"?
Comment on this
That is a specific project and we have a proposal with the Department on that. We are waiting to hear back.
Comment on this
Can Mr. O'Connor let us know what the proposal is?
Comment on this
No, but I am certainly happy to confirm the position once we hear back.
Comment on this
The south Kerry greenway is exceptional in that it has an approved environmental impact assessment, appropriate assessment and compulsory purchase order that predate the code of practice, which did not have effective approval until after the code of practice was introduced. I recommend the TII should make the greenway sustainability payment payable for all landowners who have signed land agreements with Kerry County Council by December 2026. This initiative will have positive effects and will build further confidence in the code of practice without setting a precedent.
I have a specific question for Mr. Hynes. What is the length of the Waterford greenway?
Comment on this
It cost €20 million for the section from Dungarvan to the city boundary. There are other parts from the city boundary up through the North Quays developments, which were extra above that figure, which is the final-----
Comment on this
What will the cost be? Will it be €30 million?
Comment on this
The final 2 km into the city required balconies over the river-----
Comment on this
Just in monetary terms, how much money?
Comment on this
That 2 km stretch cost around €16 million. The initial greenway that we built back in 2016 to 2018-----
Comment on this
I am just interested in the money.
Comment on this
How much is the total amount of money?
Comment on this
The original 43 km were €20 million. The 2 km I spoke about there were approximately €16 million, and then there are further greenway works being done as part of the North Quays development and that is going to connect up with the South East Greenway.
Comment on this
I do not care where it is connecting to. I am interested in the money. I am on a clock, and I want to keep to it. Can Mr. Hynes not just give me a straight answer? He was in charge in it. How much-----
Comment on this
Could Mr. Hynes not have said to me at the beginning instead of eating up all my time? So, 45 km cost €35 million. In Kerry, we have 27 km and it cost €72 million. That is €2.6 million per km. There is a fair difference between them.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not comparing like with like. The original figure I gave him-----
Comment on this
Mr. Hynes is not taking any more of my time. We often hear about the great success of the Waterford greenway. Has it lived up to the reality of the greenway? Has it beaten expectations in terms of visitors and economic activity? I want a "yes" or "no" answer. Is Waterford County Council happy with it or not?
Comment on this
Does Mr. Hynes believe that the Waterford greenway was lucky, and is an outlier for greenways in that it did not have any of the issues with landowners as it was built relatively cheaply at the time?
Comment on this
We had a defined line. It was in public ownership. We had very good community engagement, plus landowner engagement. We did very good accommodation works for the landowners, and it was delivered very efficiently and effectively.
Comment on this
I presume all of the witnesses agree that the people in south Kerry should be paid.
Comment on this
Will the witnesses put on the record that they should be paid and paid immediately?
Comment on this
Is that in terms of the private owners where the proposed route is going to-----
Comment on this
Yes, those who are owed money. It does not make sense.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to again raise this issue. The witnesses say that a CPO should be a last resort. That did not happen in Kerry - I can tell them that - because there were only six or seven landowners outstanding after Christmas 2015, and TII still decided to go ahead with the CPO, notwithstanding the fact that only six or seven were outstanding. It could have been worked through, but that did not happen.
When TII has a CPO and it decides that it wants to take a man's land from here to there, before it goes in, can it not sign a contract and agree what the man or woman is going to get, what TII is taking, and the accommodation works? We have a scenario down in Kerry where there are cyclists and walkers going through a piece of land, and I wish them the best, but the landowner on the side of the ditch has not been paid. The landowner's farm is not screened off, and there are people writing about him on Facebook and giving out that his yard is this way and that way, and that it is not right. How would the witnesses like that? Are they happy with the way that it is going, and that the landowners are not getting paid first or that a payment is not agreed on? They do not know how much they are going to get yet.
Comment on this
I would like to reach agreement with the landowners at the earliest point possible in all of the projects. What we have tried to show in the appendix to our opening statement is that throughout the various steps involved in the CPO process, there is an ability to reach a voluntary agreement at every one of those steps. Where we see instances where a final transaction has not concluded, it is a result of both parties not agreeing a final position.
Comment on this
TII still goes in ahead and carries out work.
Comment on this
The arbitration process is available to bring that to a conclusion once both sides are willing to.
Comment on this
Mr. Kehoe said that councillors should agree the route in the first place. He said that councillors would have the role of agreeing the route in the first place. That did not happen in Kerry. All we were asked to vote on was whether there should be a CPO placed on the land. That is all. I was a county councillor at that time and Johnny Healy-Rae was as well and worked against it. We were two of the eight, but we were not asked anything else.
Comment on this
I cannot comment on what happened in Kerry, but what I said was that local authority members would approve the development plan, and the development plans would generally have an objective-----
Comment on this
That was only the notion of a greenway.
Comment on this
We had no role in deciding. I want to assure my friends here that we had no role in deciding the route of the greenway from Glenbeigh to Cahersiveen.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Connor said that TII would skirt around someone who had a problem. I had a man that time and he had one silage field. He offered that the council or whoever it was could go at the top or the bottom of his field. He had only the one field to cut for silage. TII went straight through the middle of it. That is what happened. The man is dead now, but his family is there, and they will never forgive or forget TII for it. That is the truth of it. There is a sour taste left in that family's mouth. His neighbours all said that he was a quiet and nice man. That is what happened and that is wrong. Mr. O'Connor said that TII would skirt around. That did not happen in Kerry, I can tell the witnesses that.
Another thing I want to remind them of is that when this greenway was built, it generally followed the railway from Glenbeigh to Reenard. It took two years to plan it and to build it. We were told the CPO would speed up the process in 2014 and early in 2015. It is longer that it has taken.
TII has to agree with people. People's property, whether it is a house or land, is theirs and it must be treated with respect. If it was me, they would not get through my one field. I can tell them that much.
Comment on this
I have been here many times before pleading for the landowner. Everybody wants to have a nice little walkway, but not at the cost of literally robbing land off people. There are serious concerns, and I have huge concerns, about the Cork-Kinsale route. There are many objectors to the route, and rightly so, because they are farmers. They have worked the land all their lives and there is the mental health pressures that TII has put them through by putting this right in front of them and literally giving them little or no choice in the matter. There has been very poor consultation. I have always been a believer in looking down the bottom of the road or taking away some of the ditch - there is no problem there - but it is bang right through the middle of fields, and while it is of no value to TII, it is of huge value to the landowner and the farmer who owns that land. The CPO has to be dropped and then negotiations will happen and walkways will then go through peacefully, but not with TII's carry-on of having the CPO weapon in its back pocket that is pulled out any time at all when it suits it.
I want to ask about accountability where landowners remain unpaid and are dissatisfied with accommodation works, including being left with severance issues, failed fencing or drainage, and continuing security or liability issues after a greenway is open. Is TII, the council, the consultant, the project liaison officer or the contractor accountable?
Comment on this
There are a couple of points there. The ownership of the greenway, once it is open, defaults back to the local authority, and in that instance its general public liability insurance would kick in. What was the other element of the Deputy's question?
Comment on this
I was talking about the CPOs, but I have another question too. Does TII have a register of unresolved land ownership issues on all greenways delivered or under construction, including delayed payments, compensation disputes, accommodation work disputes, fencing defects, drainage complaints, farm access problems, safety complaints and CPO-related delays? Has TII a register and where is that register-----
Comment on this
I am sure the local authorities have registers in relation to those problems.
Comment on this
-----and is it openly available to the public because it is a public issue? It is a public concern.
Comment on this
In terms of individual spots along the greenway, the local authorities would have information on that. I now recall the Deputy's earlier question. It was in relation to outstanding payments for landowners. As I said, as part of the CPO process, TII would like to reach voluntary agreements at the earliest point possible and make payment at the earliest point possible. Where it is necessary, TII is trying to ensure that those payments are prompt and at an appropriate level.
Comment on this
In a lot of situations that is not happening. Mr. O'Connor says that he would like to see it happen. We would all love to see it happening.
Comment on this
From a TII perspective, I can tell the Deputy today that we are absolutely open in the first instance, as are our local authority colleagues, to enter into negotiations with a view to a voluntary agreement and, if that is not possible, through the arbitration process.
Comment on this
I am going back to the question I asked first about the 25 km Cork-Kinsale route where there are major issues with landowners. Is TII going to proceed whether they like it or not?
Yes or no?
Comment on this
It is ultimately a matter for the local authority but, as I understand it in that instance, it is examining the various component parts of the greenway. We are obviously working closely-----
Comment on this
Yes or no? Is TII going to railroad ahead one way or the other? If a landowner says there is absolutely no way the greenway is going through his or her farm, is TII going to say, "Sorry, but it is."?
Comment on this
It is about the wider project that goes through the consultation process. Ultimately, that would go for planning permission and it would be a matter for An Coimisiún Pleanála.
Comment on this
I have been involved in a number of walkways in County Longford. First of all, there has to be engagement with the public, including the farmers or whoever owns the land. A CPO should never be mentioned in respect of any aspect. What areas does TII start with? Does it start with the design stage, whereby it presents the design to farmers and other landowners and talks to them about the route and how it works? Does it discuss whether there are rights of way, maybe for other people, that can be used? Such a right of way might not be used any longer and might be a passageway that allowed people to avail of turbary rights.
The last thing should be compulsory purchase. I have dealt with 75 landowners on a walkway from Drumlish to Ballinamuck that links two parishes. We had zero objections, all because we had public meetings and went out, with members of Longford County Council, to have one-on-one meetings with landowners. A landowner might have said he did not want the route in such a place but that it could go elsewhere, or asked whether it was possible that it could take a certain route. Engagement is key to delivering this. You get people's backs up when you mention CPOs.
What engagement has TII had on the walkways? It has referred to public consultation. Does it involve a meeting in the local parish to which all landowners have been invited in writing? Does it involve the local authority? Is that how it works?
Comment on this
The way the Senator has articulated it working in his case is exactly the way we would like to see it work.
On the matter of the concept, there is a development plan that identifies the opportunity to have, let us say, a greenway from A to B. That starts off with very broad public consultation around the corridor and then, ultimately, an emerging route, and then a more specific route. There is public consultation throughout. When there is a more specific likely route, that is when individual conversations with landowners are had. As the Senator said, they might say they do not really like what has been proposed but they might offer an alternative. That is exactly what I would like to see happening - real consultation.
Comment on this
I thank everyone. We have gone well past the time available for the meeting. I have ten questions myself and I understand that a number of other members also have questions that they would like to ask. What we will do is send those questions to the secretariat, which will forward them to the witnesses for a response.
I thank the witnesses for their participation in the meeting and the extensive discussion. We are looking forward to the responses to the other questions. Ahead of the ministerial meeting, I want a quick word with the members in private.