Horticultural Peat: Discussion
Growing Media Ireland argued that Irish horticulture still needs a limited, regulated supply of domestic peat during the transition to alternatives, warning that the current consent system is slow, inconsistent and leaving small producers in limbo. Witnesses said the new aggregation rules could wrongly fold small sub-30 ha sites into larger historical complexes, pushing them over thresholds and threatening closures, jobs and food production. Senators largely backed the case for a workable pathway, with several questioning EPA figures on peat volumes and imports, and noting that many reported “peat” exports are mixed products. The committee heard calls for a national process for sub-30 ha sites, clear local authority guidance and an interdepartmental working group to get a decision-making system in place.
Contributions 242–497 of 497. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Will the EPA send a memo to the committee? We need to be clear about that relationship and who initiated it.
Comment on this
What did the Minister do? Did he give a direction to the OPR? I want clarity on this. Dr. Ryan has committed to furnishing the committee with that detail. Is that correct?
Comment on this
That is great. Dr. Ryan is aware of the section 63 declarations. What are the EPA's intentions? Is it to move on? It has identified the concerns. It is highly critical of the local authorities. It has powers under this section 63 declaration. Is it going to exercise those powers? If so, when? Will Dr. Ryan outline a timeline? Will he also explain the import and significance of the section 63 declarations?
Comment on this
It is quite an involved section in terms of how we exercise our section 63 powers. What we have done to date is that we have provided the local authorities with all the intelligence that we have, and we have looked for their reaction to it. We were not particular happy with that so we issued a draft direction. That direction was for their comment, and it included-----
Comment on this
I am sorry; I want to stop Dr. Ryan there. Did the EPA get a response from the local authorities it contacted on that?
Comment on this
We can move on. We do not want a history lesson. We read too, and we read the report. Going back to section 63, when is the EPA going to proceed with those section 63 declarations?
Comment on this
Because it is an enforcement issue and I need some regulatory discretion around that.
Comment on this
Hang on. Dr. Ryan is painting a dreadful picture. The EPA has powers. Let us not go back to the local authority. He is telling us that the local authorities are not stepping up to the plate.
Comment on this
The EPA has been empowered with these declarations. It can exercise them. Is the EPA going to exercise them? Do not tell us that the agency is going to think more into it. Dr. Ryan has suggested that there are serious shortcomings with everybody bar the EPA. When will the agency proceed with the section 63 declarations, which are in its power?
Comment on this
I am not going to tell the committee specific details. We need to retain that regulatory discretion as an independent enforcement authority but we are assessing all of the responses. We expected that the local authorities would step up and take the responsibilities without us issuing a formal declaration. That is the next step. It is a legally binding declaration, and we will use it, if we need to.
Comment on this
I will finish on this point because time has run out. This is the important issue. The EPA has come here and made serious claims in relation to local authorities and other enforcement agencies. The EPA has the power under this section 63 declaration but it has not used it. It is also not exercising all the powers that it has within its own gift. This is the Oireachtas committee. We are not someone sitting at the side of a bar. This is the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food, therefore I thought the witnesses would have been more equipped to tell us about the section 63 declarations. Will the EPA furnish the committee with details about the process around the declarations and when it intends to do something? Dr. Ryan cannot be critical of everybody else on one hand, when he has not exercised the suite of powers and functions he has within his office. I will leave it at that. I do not want a response.
Comment on this
Before I go to Deputy Lawless, I have one brief point that I want to clarify with Dr. Ryan. He said that EPA will use them when it sees the need.
Comment on this
They are the enforcement tools provided by the Oireachtas to allow us to escalate-----
Comment on this
I have not asked the question. Dr. Ryan says that the EPA will use them when it feels they are needed. What threshold or trigger would prod the agency to use them?
Comment on this
There are two things. The first is that we are still assessing the responses from the local authorities. The other is that we are looking at some procedural issues in terms of fair procedures and due notice, so that if we use that very strong power, we do it once and we do it effectively. It is due diligence. This is no disrespect to the committee, Chair or any of his colleagues, but we need to do this in a logical, thoughtful and stepwise fashion.
Comment on this
Are any of the witnesses involved in any fashion with an environmental NGO, lobby or campaign group?
Comment on this
I am struck by Dr. Ryan's language around intelligence. As a regulator, I expected him to be a little bit more impartial on the whole thing.
I am just surprised. The side Dr. Ryan is coming down on seems very clear in terms of his comments today and in the context of RTÉ-----
Comment on this
Sure, but it is important to ask the question.
Comment on this
To clarify for the Deputy, and in the interests of full transparency, the intelligence we receive comes from a wide variety of sources. Some of those sources would be NGOs.
Comment on this
Can Dr. Ryan name those NGOs? What involvement does the EPA have with them? How regularly does it meet with those NGOs?
Comment on this
Is it voluntary or is the EPA seeking assistance from NGOs regarding this matter?
Comment on this
We are not seeking assistance from NGOs in relation to any of this. It is voluntary.
Comment on this
Friends of the Irish Environment would be one. We can look at all those sources and furnish their names to the committee if that is of interest. Where it is individuals and local people, we certainly would not be furnishing their names. We would protect them-----
Comment on this
That is fine, but I would appreciate it if Dr. Ryan could furnish the names of the NGOs with which the EPA has voluntary involvement.
The report mentions 370,000 tonnes of peat valued at €40 million being extracted in Ireland and exported. The previous group we had in outlined that this is actually not the case. It was stated that between 40% to 60% of that was peat and that, as a result, the valuation is totally incorrect. What have the witnesses got to say about that?
Comment on this
We rely for our information from the Central Statistics Office, which is an accredited and internationally recognised organisation and State agency-----
Comment on this
Yes, but with regard to CSO data and the labelling of product that is exported, the EPA would be aware that the product is labelled as one item. It would be well aware that peat would not make up 100% of the 370,000 tonnes.
Comment on this
We have not looked behind that. People have made that argument but a percentage has not been substantiated.
Comment on this
Yes, but the frustration is that the EPA has quoted this figure as fact when it is not fact; it is actually fiction. It is incorrect. It is a headline figure, but the data behind that is not reflected in what the EPA has indicated. This is what I am getting in the context of the involvement of NGOs. That is a major oversight on the EPA's part. The EPA is a regulator and an impartial body. It is meant to regulate but it is coming down on one side in this debate. That is clearly evident in relation to that statement.
Prior to the legislation being introduced, the EPA lost a case in Longford. The Environment (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act was then introduced and passed. What involvement had the EPA in relation to that legislation?
Comment on this
This was the amendment to section 99H, which sets out our injunctive powers under the Act. Those powers were amended in that miscellaneous provisions legislation. The need for that amendment arose as a direct result of the Court of Appeal judgment in the Harte Peat case. It was designed to give us stronger powers in relation to activities that clearly involved in splitting projects in order to try to get below the 50 ha threshold and take them out of our jurisdiction.
Comment on this
My question was not answered. What involvement had the EPA in respect of the legislation?
Comment on this
I was all over it, definitely. I was very much involved in promoting it to the Department.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their opening statement and subsequent contributions. One thing that struck me was that the group we had before us in the previous session, Growing Media Ireland, acknowledged that there is a need for regulation. It wants want to have a system that works and is fair, equitable and can provide regulation for the industry to allow its members to know where they stand. The problem Growing Media Ireland has, more than anything else, is that the system in place now does not work because people do not know where they stand and they cannot have matters brought to a conclusion.
I know the industry quite well. I grew mushrooms for many years, and I know the need for peat in that industry. Peat holds water very well and is needed in an awful lot of industries of this nature. People talk about whether the EPA is biased. Obviously, the EPA is biased towards the environment because it is the its job to protect the environment. Protecting our peatlands and maintaining them is a major part of that. I acknowledge that. However, we also have to protect our horticulture sector and our food industry. We need to have a medium to grow product on. One of those core mediums is peat. The harvesting of peat over the years was, to a large extent, to burn it, but that has practically been phased out now. A small portion of it, which I feel we will probably always need, is a portion of peat to be milled for the horticulture and agriculture sectors. Would the witnesses acknowledge that this is always going to be required?
Comment on this
I would accept the Deputy's expertise on that, but-----
Comment on this
Dr. Ryan acknowledges that the extraction of peat will always be required at some level. I know that the use of peat is diminishing and will probably continue to do so.
Comment on this
It is not that I do not understand the question; I am only-----
Comment on this
I will refine the question. People are concerned that in its ambition to protect the environment, the EPA may overstep the mark and may actually kill the horticulture industry. Will Dr. Ryan confirm that this is not the EPA's intention?
Comment on this
We do not want to close down any industry or for anybody to lose their jobs. What we are concerned with primarily is that where material is required for any of those sectors, it is obtained from a legal source.
Comment on this
It is about protecting the environment, but we are biased on the side of the law-----
Comment on this
The problem is that the law seems to be extremely difficult to get through for the people. In its report, the EPA outlined all of the people involved in illegal activities, as the EPA refers to them. I am not going to dispute that with Dr. Ryan, but we have people coming before this committee who are producing a product that is needed by an industry. They want to comply, but the system refuses to allow them to do so. They are being beaten up for that. Does Dr. Ryan acknowledge that? Does he acknowledge that the system is not working for those people? I am not saying that it is Dr. Ryan's fault, but does he acknowledge it?
Comment on this
If somebody makes an application and it takes four years to get a result-----
Comment on this
If that is the case, it is a policy matter-----
Comment on this
If it is, then it is a policy matter that has to be resolved at that level. However, I cannot draw that conclusion. I am looking at the regulations that are before us and trying to enforce them and ensure that local authorities enforce them as well.
Comment on this
On local authorities, Dr. Ryan mentioned that only one local authority, namely Longford County Council, has put in place a draft direction for a county-wide system to do that.
Comment on this
Dr. Ryan is singling out Longford as doing a good job in that regard. Is that what I should take from that?
Comment on this
At the same time, many of the others are getting applications for planning permission from people who wish to have a system to mill peat on areas of less than 30 ha. They are going for planning permission and are waiting and waiting. It is not really a case of whether they have a system that is county-wide to observe what is happening. The issue is that where they receive applications for specific tasks that people want to carry, they are not being dealt with. Dr. Ryan says that the EPA wants to ensure that people's livelihoods are maintained and that there is a system that works, but has the EPA got a role to play in ensuring that the system works? Can it stand back, wash its hands and say "Nothing to do with us"? Does Dr. Ryan understand why people are frustrated with that notion?
Comment on this
As I said, our job is to enforce the regulations that are in front of us. We have a specific jurisdiction for activities-----
Comment on this
Is it not also the EPA's job to ensure that those regulations are effective?
Comment on this
There is an issue of them being effective with regard to the regulation that is there. People's only way of having an industry that will work within the regulations is to apply for planning permission, with the appropriate environmental assessments and screening done. If people do this but the system does not allow them to proceed, then the regulations which the EPA wants to see enforced are not effective.
Comment on this
I cannot draw that conclusion. What I do know is that widescale illegal peat harvesting is taking place. There is a very active export market with 375,000 tonnes leaving this country last year-----
Comment on this
Yes and Dr. Ryan listed the counties this is happening in.
Comment on this
-----and none of it is being permitted or authorised. This is what we are faced with.
Comment on this
They are applying for the permits and cannot get authorisation.
Comment on this
On the issue of people waiting for licences, we have to look after our food security. At the moment peat is the best growing material for our food. An alternative needs to be worked on at a faster pace and we get that, but meanwhile people who do everything right when looking for their planning and licences still face a delay when it goes to An Coimisiún Pleanála. Does the EPA have any act or part in anything to do with this? Does it have to give a report? Does An Coimisiún Pleanála come to the EPA for any information on this? Does it have absolutely nothing to do with it?
Comment on this
The consent process has two stages. Somebody who wants a licence from the EPA needs planning permission so they need to go-----
Comment on this
I am talking about under 30 ha. As far as I was aware the EPA had nothing to do with this. Am I wrong in saying that?
Comment on this
No, the Deputy is correct but it is a planning matter. Where we get involved is-----
Comment on this
When it goes to An Coimisiún Pleanála?
Comment on this
No. Under section 63 of the Environmental Protection Agency Act, our general oversight role of local authorities is where we get involved.
Comment on this
So the EPA has a part in all licences.
Comment on this
We have no part in the planning permission aspect.
Comment on this
But the EPA has input. When it is asked questions, it has an input regarding how the proposal will affect the environment, so it does have a part to play.
Comment on this
Exactly, the EPA has a part to play in it. That is what I am getting at.
Comment on this
The EPA gives its information and the local authority decides whether it goes to An Coimisiún Pleanála or to give a licence. The local authority uses the information the EPA has given it to make its decisions. What I am saying is that the EPA has a part to play in it, not on whether the licence is given but it has a part to play in it. This is what I am getting at. Other than Bord na Móna, does anybody else have a licence for over 50 ha?
Comment on this
No, and there are no applications before us at present.
Comment on this
It has its licence, which it has not used since 2020.
Comment on this
Why would it still need a licence then?
Comment on this
Does it apply for it every year?
Comment on this
No, it is a continuous licence. This is the value of regulation in this area. There are licence conditions that remain operative. There are aftercare requirements in terms of rehabilitation of sites that were previously active. In contrast, for the types of activities we are talking about which are going on illegally, there is no aftercare. Operators are just gouging out peat and leaving exposed marl and lakes of water without any aftercare.
Comment on this
Is aftercare part of a licence?
Comment on this
Who pays the cost of that in the few we have been speaking about? Is it the taxpayer?
Comment on this
Bord na Móna holds all of those licences and it can-----
Comment on this
No, who pays the cost of the rehabilitation of the site?
Comment on this
Bord na Móna has responsibility for that and responsibility for the cost. I presume it draws on funds that are available to assist it with this.
Comment on this
Taxpayers' money, of course. On the NGOs, can the EPA tell me 100% that all of the NGOs that are giving it information are coming to it freely with no exchange of money whatsoever and that it is free information?
Comment on this
The EPA knows the sites where there is illegal activity. How long have they been in operation?
Comment on this
We have been doing these investigations for a number of years and some of them-----
Comment on this
What are we talking about?
Comment on this
These are still operating illegally since 2012. Who is paying the EPA to do a job that is not getting done? If people are doing things illegally, why are they not being prosecuted? All I hear lately is local government getting a serious slap on the wrist with regard to housing. Why can the EPA not use its weight to sort it out?
Comment on this
With regard to the 2012 site, it has been subject to a number of High Court injunctions by us. It is not a case that we are not taking any action. We have taken action-----
Comment on this
Activity has ceased on that site and peat extraction is no longer-----
Comment on this
I would need to check the date but we can get this information for the Deputy.
Comment on this
Was it ten years ago or five years ago?
Comment on this
It was not ten years ago. I would say it is since 2019 or 2020.
Comment on this
Will the witnesses clarify, with regard to the NGOs that are co-operating with the EPA, what is in it for them. What is the quid pro quo?
Comment on this
Yes, I agree with Dr. Ryan that they are clearly not. What is the quid pro quo? What is in it for them? Why are they co-operating with the EPA?
Comment on this
The Cathaoirleach would have to ask them. We do not take any information we get on face value. We do our own investigations and we pass the information we have to the local authorities. It is for them then to verify the veracity of these issues. We are satisfied that we have identified 44 sites with regard to enforcement.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee. I was a councillor on Longford County Council and I want to declare that my brother is the environmental officer in Longford County Council. Between 2019 and 2022, the EPA was informed that the sites in Abbeylara, Legan, Ardagh and Newtown Forbes were not active and they were closed but its report states they were active. It is very hurtful for me as someone who was a councillor to read this report when the EPA was notified by the council that they were not active. It has in its report that they were active. Will the EPA withdraw this here today? The witnesses know they were not active. The EPA was notified by the council that these sites were not active. I was a councillor at that time. I will leave that with the witnesses and I will come back to it.
Peat extraction and peat harvesting are not illegal but, unfortunately, the rules and regulations on it make it impossible. The previous witnesses before the committee included a representative from Klasmann-Deilmann Ireland Limited, which has a 250 ha site but it will not invest in it because it does not know what rules and regulations apply to it.
On supports, Bord na Móna got just transition funding to support workers who left this sector. What supports are there for our harvesters in the horticultural sector? We are going to lose them. What supports are there? Have we thought about this?
Comment on this
That is not something I can speak to. Our primary concern is the enforcement of the environmental laws that are there. Operators need to be operating within the regulations. This means that they either need to have a permit at certain hectare sizes or planning permission and a licence from us.
Comment on this
Dr. Ryan is saying that the EPA expects the local authorities to do its job for it. Yet there is no person in the local authority that can make that decision because there are no supports there for the local authorities. Will Dr. Ryan accept that? Who makes that decision? Who is qualified within a local authority to make the decision? The local authorities have notified the EPA that there is nobody.
Comment on this
The local authorities’ bread-and-butter is planning permission, and this comes down to planning.
Comment on this
It is about licensing. Is Dr. Ryan aware of the Department of agriculture's policy report?
Comment on this
Can the Senator expand on that point? It may be something that we-----
Comment on this
The Minister for agriculture, Deputy Martin Heydon, brought out a report where he said he would like to see one local authority given the powers and infrastructure to be the pilot for the whole of Ireland. Every other county would feed information into that report and that one local authority. Dr. Ryan said a minute ago that Longford was the leader. Did the EPA go to the Longford local authority and ask it if it would be the pilot local authority for the whole of Ireland? It is damning what we are after hearing already about the council. Has the EPA been with the local authority?
Comment on this
We engage with it quite regularly. The idea of a county council being an exemplar in this area and promoting best practice among other county councils is a very good idea.
Comment on this
We are going to have differences from every local authority, so one local authority will have to be picked to lead this initiative, if that is the case. Is that right? Would that be what the EPA would like to see?
Comment on this
Hold on. A good example to highlight is always instructive to other local authorities. I did draw attention in my opening statement to the commencement of part of the new planning Act that will see the setting up of a regional enforcement authority. The Department of housing has taken an initiative in that regard. It is just at the commencement stage and there is a long way to go, but we support that as well.
Comment on this
What timeframe are we looking at from when somebody puts in a licence application now? What timeframe are we looking at? We do not have a timeframe and this is why they are not being implemented. What timeframe do we have from the local authorities?
Comment on this
I do not know what the local authority timeframe is.
Comment on this
We can supply that to the committee. New statutory timeframes are coming in, but there is no doubt that it does take some time. It could be up to 12 months.
Comment on this
It can always depend on the quality of the application, but we would work to expedite those matters as quickly and efficiently as is possible.
Comment on this
I would like a response to my first question. It was regarding the report from Longford notifying the EPA that the sites were closed from 2019 to 2022.
Comment on this
I can talk to that now, if need be, or it may take some time.
Comment on this
In County Longford, we are aware of five sites of interest. Our understanding is that three of them are operational. Peat is being extracted from three of them. The details of where they are located are in the document, along with the maps of the peatlands, which the committee already has. The sites are LD1, LD3 and LD5 in the document. I can talk to them individually if the committee wishes, we can talk about them collectively or we can give the committee information afterwards.
Comment on this
That is fine. I will talk to the witnesses afterwards. It is LD1, LD3 and LD5.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their opening statement. It was mentioned that 370,000 tonnes of peat were exported in 2025. How was that figure arrived at? Where did it come from? Does the EPA know where that peat was sent to? Is a licence needed to export and is it possible to prevent it?
Comment on this
That figure was provided by the Central Statistics Office, CSO. In terms of where the peat was exported to, we know 43% was exported to Northern Ireland, 28% was exported to Great Britain, 6% was exported to the Netherlands, 6% was exported to Israel, 5% was exported to South Africa, and the rest consisted of small amounts and percentages. It is predominantly being exported to Northern Ireland and Great Britain. Those figures are provided, as I said, by the Central Statistics Office. That is the data it provided to us.
Comment on this
That is the situation. It was also mentioned that 30,000 tonnes were imported. Why would this have been the case?
Comment on this
Regarding the figure we have in terms of importation, most of that, 94%, is coming through Northern Ireland, and 5% came from the Netherlands. I stress again that this data was provided by the Central Statistics Office.
Comment on this
It was also said that there were 38 large-scale peat extraction sites the EPA considered to be operating illegally. From the discourse here, I would say another six have been traced. The blame is again being put on the local authorities and that it is nearly their responsibility. We all know that local authorities are struggling with funds now. What can be done in this situation? Can the witnesses outline the reason the EPA thinks the local authorities are not stepping up to the mark?
Comment on this
The 38 sites have been discussed. Most of those are of interest in terms of enforcement, as we mentioned. We have written to the local authorities to ask them to provide detailed information on those sites. That is an ongoing process, as we said.
There are reasons, as Dr. Ryan outlined, for the establishment of a body as a regional authority. That is being proposed by the Department. Issues have been articulated back through the local authorities in terms of resourcing, as the Deputy mentioned. Financial constraints and technical abilities are some of the reasons given by the local authorities in terms of their inability to carry out some of their current enforcement functions.
Comment on this
In fairness to the local authorities, and I was involved in one in County Clare for 20 years, they have an awful lot on their plates. As was said, there are issues with staff and resources. Is this putting extra pressure down on top of the local authorities? Is it extra pressure that needs to be put on the local authorities?
Comment on this
As we mentioned earlier, these are issues in relation to planning, and planning is a very strong discipline within local authorities. As we mentioned earlier as well, it is about ensuring that the regulations and the proper planning process are adhered to in terms of this operation. That is our primary goal in relation to it. We hope that the local authorities will prioritise the resources in this respect.
Comment on this
I can tell Mr. Cullinane that they have enough on their plates to be doing now without looking into issues like this. Again, that is up to the local authorities themselves, but I know the pressure that local authorities are under in respect of resources and whatever the case may be. In fairness, it is not easy for them.
Comment on this
My questions will need just "Yes" or "No" answers. In the EPA’s view, where specifically are the enforcement gaps preventing this framework from operating effectively? I am referring to the planning aspects concerning sites being under 30 ha and over 50 ha.
Comment on this
The responses we are getting from local authorities, as Mr. Cullinane pointed out, refer to a lack of resources, the complexity of the law and doubts as to whether they would be successful.
Some suggest that we are overstepping the mark in our oversight role.
Comment on this
What trends emerged from the 226 inspections that the EPA carried out? Has the level of unauthorised peat extraction increased or decreased over this period?
Comment on this
We found that a lot of unregulated peat extraction was taking place across the country, particularly in those seven counties. If we look at the make-up of what is happening-----
Comment on this
Some sites have definitely stopped as a result of the EPA actions. More have come on board. While some have ceased, more are active that we were not aware of before.
Comment on this
What additional resources, expertise or legislative powers do local authorities require to effectively discharge their responsibilities?
Comment on this
We take a view that, at the moment, they have significant powers under the planning Acts, particularly under section 160 of the planning Act, which is the injunctive power. The new amendment to section 99H of the EPA Act just brings the EPA Act in line with that. They have those enforcement powers. The Department of housing has commenced part of the new planning Acts with a view to regional enforcement and that is a welcome direction, but, right now, individual local authorities, acting alone, have significant powers to support the law in this area.
Comment on this
The EPA's 2025 report referred to a number of peat extraction sites, which industry representatives claim included historical areas where harvesting had already ceased. How confident is the EPA that its public figures accurately reflect extraction activity rather than historical activity?
Comment on this
The report identified 38 sites of interest to us at the time. We have found six additional sites since the report was issued and extraction is ongoing on a number of those, including this year. That is the overall global picture of peat extraction on sites of interest.
Comment on this
The EPA cites CSO expert data showing approximately 370,000 tonnes of peat exports in 2025. Given that the customs classification includes blended growing media products containing imported materials such as bark and wood fibre, can the EPA state with certainty how much of that figure represents Irish horticultural peat?
Comment on this
That came up earlier. The figures we quoted are from the CSO. We accept that the CSO categorises it as peat.
Comment on this
I am asking about the stuff that came in and the stuff that went out. The EPA is talking about the stuff that went out of the country. How much blended stuff is included in that?
Comment on this
We do not know the breakdown. The CSO does not provide that figure. We have asked for it.
Comment on this
The EPA is doing so much enforcing that it should know that before it takes the steps it is taking at the moment.
Does the EPA accept that uncertainty around regulation may be contributing to non-compliance?
Comment on this
We cannot speak about the minds of these operators.
Comment on this
What reforms would the EPA support to create greater clarity while maintaining environmental protections?
Comment on this
The planning process is well established. The licensing process is well established. We are primarily concerned with compliance with the current regulations and regulatory framework.
Comment on this
The EPA has focused heavily on enforcement. Does it accept that successive Governments' reports have recommended mechanisms to maintain a limited domestic supply of horticultural peat during transition to alternatives? How should those recommendations be reconciled with the current enforcement approach?
Comment on this
The EPA will not answer then. Will there be a second round?
Comment on this
The Cathaoirleach will not let us in a second time.
Comment on this
As a farmer, I had a huge nervousness about looking at the EPA today. Would the witnesses believe that? I am being straight with them and say that quite publicly. I can see now why people in the community are terrified, people who have to deal with the likes of this. It is awful. That is all I will say.
Comment on this
I will start with a little friendly advice. If the witnesses are giving a presentation to the committee again, they should not use the word "intelligence" because just over 100 years ago, we had the Cairo gang, which terrorised Dublin on the basis of intelligence by ransacking houses and killing innocent people. I am certainly not linking the EPA with that gang, but the word "intelligence" strikes at the hearts of Irish people, so I would not use it again.
I will ask some quickfire questions. What names are on LD1, LD3 and LD5? They are the three sites Dr. Henry mentioned.
Comment on this
Will Dr. Henry just tell me the names of them because I do not have much time?
Comment on this
LD1 is Clooniher and Annaghcooleen, County Longford.
Comment on this
It is not given in the package the Senator has.
Comment on this
Dr. Henry must know. The EPA has intelligence from all over the country and it listened to Growing Media Ireland when it was before the committee, so Dr. Henry knows who owns that site.
Comment on this
It is Derrymore, Trillickacurry and Ballymakeegan, County Longford.
Comment on this
Does Derrymore Peat own all of that?
Comment on this
Okay. Who owns the third one or where is it located?
Comment on this
It is in a townland called Cloonfore, County Longford.
Comment on this
Dr. Henry knows who owns it and heard Growing Media Ireland state who owns it. He knows that Bord na Móna is not operational in peat extraction and the EPA still says that peat extraction is going on there. That is fine.
What is the difference between taking information from the environmental group that the EPA actively engages with and from Growing Media Ireland, which the EPA will not take information from? What validates that group such that the EPA can accept what the group tells the EPA? Dr. Henry will say that the EPA investigates it, but there is nothing to differentiate that group from Growing Media Ireland, which was here and gave a passionate defence of the industry. What elevates Friends of the Irish Environment above Growing Media Ireland?
Comment on this
Nothing, except that the EPA is absolutely committed to closing down this industry.
Comment on this
I have to refute that. That is not what we are about.
Comment on this
Everything the EPA has said and all its actions over the past few years would substantiate that.
I take it there is a peat division in the EPA.
Comment on this
There is an office of enforcement and it comes under that-----
Comment on this
There is a peat division. How many people does it have? Dr. Henry works largely in peat. How many other people work with Dr. Henry in what I would call the peat division? Dr. Ryan knows this. He is the head of the EPA. He knows what his staff are doing. How many people are working on the closure? Dr. Ryan says that the EPA is not, but how many people are working on the closure of the peat industry?
Comment on this
No one is working on the closure of the peat industry.
Comment on this
How many people are working on the peat industry?
Comment on this
The people who are working in enforcement in peat-----
Comment on this
The Senator is looking at them and occasionally, we bring in people to fly drones.
Comment on this
If only the three witnesses are working on it, that might explain why the EPA is so flawed. It put out a press statement in the summer. Dr. Ryan tells me that only three people in the EPA work on it. I want to check that again. No one else in the EPA works on it.
Comment on this
As Dr. Ryan pointed out, our role is enforcement of the licences and peat extraction licences are included in that. Inspectors are delegated and assigned to different tasks in the-----
Comment on this
At the moment, there are probably three. It depends whether we need to-----
Comment on this
How many more staff, such as support and ancillary staff, are there?
Comment on this
Perhaps the best thing is that we get a breakdown-----
Comment on this
What I am trying to get to is that CO2 emissions from horticultural peat harvesting in 2025 were less than one day's airline flights from Dublin to London.
I imagine the witnesses are three highly paid officials and have ancillary staff and back-up staff. In the past year in relation to legal fees and everything else, how much have they spent on this? They have brought in expertise. How much, specifically, have they spent on these cases?
Comment on this
That is information we can furnish to the committee. We do not have it to hand.
Comment on this
You will have a good idea. You are head of the-----
Comment on this
No, I do not. I would only be guessing. I do not want to-----
Comment on this
Okay. Well, I will say it is north of €5 million. Dr. Ryan can dispute it when he comes back. He is after telling us that, on the whim of an environmental group, he has gone after family businesses and spent €5 million-plus to close them and put them out of business. He will tell me he is not putting them out of business but-----
Comment on this
It is a correct one. Now we will go-----
Comment on this
One final one, it is very important. I will only take 30 seconds.
Comment on this
You will not. I need to move on to Deputy Healy-Rae. I think there was some point about the numbers that Dr. Ryan wanted to make.
Comment on this
I think Dr. Henry has clarified it. There are other inspectors working on the approval of rehabilitation plans and that. We will furnish the committee with a full accounting of individuals involved.
Comment on this
It is not easy to frighten me but with what has happened here today with this group and the last group, I am frightened alive. The EPA has lost a lot of credibility. I never thought it would accept informers' evidence or people who have a gripe against people working and who would go to these depths to ensure the horticulture industry will be totally wiped out. I have nothing against the three men here. I do not know any of them but if this is the way the EPA is operating, God help anyone who is trying to do anything or to employ people.
The figure of 350 tonnes was given by the CSO. Who weighed that? How much of it is water? These are allegations and stories like you would hear in - I do not know where you would hear them.
As to the independent nature of the EPA, it is employed by the State to protect our environment but it is depending on NGOs - or informers, as I call them. I said it before the witnesses came in. Some of these informers call themselves the people of the earth or whatever. Nothing could be further from the truth. They are getting paid out of taxpayers' money to object and do this work.
I do not know who said this "intelligence" operated 100 years ago when we were trying to gain our freedom. It is sorrowful to think this is going on now in order to put people out of work - individuals and companies.
Comment on this
The NGOs are being paid by the State. I did not say it was by the EPA. We got a list of them and of the amount each of them got. I railed against it and we will have to rail further against it. It is not fair. The people who are trying to survive and to create jobs do not get funding for anything. They are paying taxes and those taxes are funding these NGOs and environmental people. It is very wrong.
Explain to me about the 10 ha and the 30 ha. If I own 10 ha and the fella alongside me owns 50 ha, is it all measured together? If I am only using ten, is the ground of the fella alongside me included in my application?
Comment on this
Yes, if I am milling for vegetables or whatever. I have 10 ha here and this fella has 50 ha. Is it all being taken into consideration? Is it an area or is it what an individual owns?
Comment on this
Our understanding is your neighbour with 50 ha has to apply separately to you, Deputy.
Comment on this
Is the EPA not including his 50 with my ten when I am applying?
Comment on this
God, you would want to know that. There is a big difference.
Comment on this
It is the past and future issue that we were told about.
Comment on this
I do not know. This is terrible what we have heard this evening, including from the horticulturists. They are expecting to get clarity, are waiting two years for an answer and it has not come yet. That is most unfortunate. They will close down along with the rest of them.
I am after hearing that the Environmental Protection Agency we prided ourselves on is accepting intelligence and information from informers. It is terrible. I am only elected here to represent people and to do no harm to anyone. What is going on is totally wrong. Those environmentalists are getting funding to keep them going and to close other people down.
Comment on this
Thank you, Deputy. We have covered a lot. Clearly, peat and horticulture inspire strong views from the environmental, gardening and regulatory sides and from every side. A number of questions remain unanswered for which the witnesses have agreed details will be sent on to the committee so we can take a further look at it. Once the transcript is available, we can send it on and the witnesses will be able to have a look at it. I thank them for their input. If there are one or two quick points they want to make, the opportunity is there. If not, they will be writing to us anyway. I thank them on behalf of the committee for answering and for participating in today's meeting.
Tá an coiste an-bhuíoch as an gcomhoibriú agus as an eolas ar fad. Nuair atá breis eolais ar fáil, iarraim ar na finnéithe é a sheoladh ar aghaidh chuig an gcoiste.