Hemp Production: Discussion
Witnesses argued that industrial hemp should be treated as an agricultural fibre crop, not primarily as a drugs issue, with oversight moved from health/justice to the Department of Agriculture for clearer licensing and enforcement. They presented hemp as a fast-growing, low-input crop with strong potential for farm diversification, rural jobs, carbon sequestration and low-carbon construction materials such as hempcrete, insulation and boards. The main bottleneck identified was lack of domestic processing and decortication infrastructure, with several witnesses calling for State-backed pilots, funding and coordinated market activation. Members across parties were broadly supportive, saying the policy framework is holding back a sector that already has interested farmers and investors.
Contributions 121–249 of 249. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
There is also the factor of environmental, social and governance, ESG. Corporate sustainability reporting, CSR, for companies is becoming a big thing. Companies need to have a CSR report. Hemp is really good for that. We are also facing significant financial exposure regarding the €8 billion to €20 billion by 2030 if the European targets are missed.
Comment on this
I have a few more questions but my time is running out. Everything is positive here. It is all good. Farmers would love it because they would be getting a guaranteed price and all that but the bottom line is when will we see this industry in this country? Can anyone answer that?
Comment on this
We will see it, as I said earlier, when there is Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine oversight of industrial hemp and when we finally align with Europe. The EU framework is already in place - it is a plug-in. We do not have to reinvent the wheel and start from scratch with policy. It is there in Europe. If we align with that, that is when you build your industrial pathways from there outwards.
Comment on this
I asked the witnesses when we will see this in this country. When will we actually see this? They are growing it. When do they think it will happen?
Comment on this
We are growing it at the moment. We are ready to go; the farmers are there. We are ready to get the decortication. All we are waiting for is support from the Department of agriculture, Enterprise Ireland and different bodies like that. Once we have that, we are ready. We already have hemp sown. We are just waiting for the decortication.
Comment on this
We have farmers ready to sow it. We have farmers ringing us on a fairly regular basis asking how we are fixed, what is happening and whether there is any sign of this. We have buyers lined up to buy it. The decortication is where it needs to get going. We need to get the support to get the decortication going. If the decorticator is put in place, it will fall into place then because everything else is ready to go.
Comment on this
When will the decorticator will be put in place?
Comment on this
The witnesses think it will be this year.
Comment on this
We expect we will be decorticating next year’s crop.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for being here. It is great to see so many here on this issue. A question I have heard asked many times over the past five or six years is: why do we not have hemp in this country? I am not one bit surprised; I am sorry. I am very cynical sometimes but I am not one bit surprised that the same conversation is going on for ten years because I have learned through my time in this place and before that that everything goes at a snail’s pace in this country. I am hearing the witnesses say it is good for the environment, good for the farmers and everything is good but nothing seems to move. We have had forestry owners and land owners at the committee talking about things like ash dieback and how they were let down around that. They do not want to replant their forests but they could plant this and there would be a more or less guaranteed pension fund. Ninety days sounds like something somebody made up. Everything sounds so good and the products are brilliant.
How much are we actually growing now? That is probably hard to answer because it is very small and the witnesses do not want to say.
Comment on this
There were about 150 farmers across Ireland when we did the research three years ago. Today there is probably about 80 or 90 because they cannot get their product to market. There is everything from five acres to 90 acres. There is one farmer in Youghal doing 400 acres and has a very profitable business. There is a good mixture and people are very interested in it but it is about getting the whole thing going.
As a science and innovation centre, we are ready. We are looking at different products, certification of it and what we need to do to bring it to certification. Each product we bring to certification is in the region of 200,000 to 250,000. That is the reality when you go through all the different aspects of each of the products, so there is a real practical element to that. We see the products as there; they are done. Our thing is how we can get it to market and we need certification to get it to market.
Comment on this
The witnesses have said this has been done in other European countries. It is another surprise to me. We are in the EU and we usually follow trends from the EU. Why are they doing it and we are not? Does it come down to Government policy?
Comment on this
It does come down to Government policy. We are an European Digital Innovation, EDI, centre for Europe. Last week I was in Brussels. We got the agriculture and the construction committees together. We talked about this and how we progress this. Each of them has different certification across Europe. We, as a European country, need to adapt European certification. There are several different cases that we are having problems with at the moment, with different modern method of construction, MMC, houses that we cannot bring in here. Each of those projects use EU certification but they will not stand up here. It is the policy element. We need an action group to make this work. Over the past three years, we have been talking to all the Departments, we are out in Brussels and we are looking at all the different aspects of it. We need a policy group to actually make this work and bring it into the industry. The industry is ready for it. IGM does 1,200 houses in Monaghan.
They are mad to look at. They have done a huge amount of research already with TU Dublin on insulation using hemp. We have 70 modern methods of construction companies, and the number is growing. Each of them is looking for low-carbon insulation, using something we grow ourselves. The problem we have with insulation is that if the price of oil goes up, the cost of insulation goes up. Everything is added on.
Comment on this
Why cannot we grow our own insulation in 90 or 100 days to bring it into MMC? We need to do our own thing.
Comment on this
I am always saying that we are a small country, but we could be completely self-sustaining if we wanted to be. Whether energy, crops, or our own beef, we should not ever have to import from anywhere else if we do not want to. I cannot understand why feet are being dragged so much on this. It is ridiculous to hear this has been going on for ten years. I was not a Member of the Oireachtas ten years ago. The product hits climate targets and it suits the farmers.
Comment on this
It gives carbon credits to farmers as well.
Comment on this
They can register their farms on Pure Earth to see the carbon credits. The structures are in place, but we need to make them act.
Comment on this
Based on supply and demand and because the product is not produced in Ireland, I assume it is slightly more expensive than other products.
Comment on this
Importing something means it is going to be expensive. We have a product here and we are the exporter. For a whole market-----
Comment on this
In theory, if we got to 200,000 ha and it was being produced in this country, Future Cast would see that as being cheaper than importing.
Comment on this
Having Mr. Donoghue and his company looking at Ireland is an advantage. We need to support that. We have three industry companies here and we need to support them to develop.
Comment on this
Every articulated lorry load of product that comes into this country costs in the region of €4,000 to bring in from Europe. These companies are producing it locally, so that is €4,000 straight away-----
Comment on this
-----that is gone. Then there is the carbon and the whole environmental aspect.
Comment on this
It is also supporting indigenous Irish companies and producers.
Comment on this
I will add one thing. With the uptake agreements that we want to do with Irish farmers for 15,000 metric tonnes of hemp a year, we would want an agreement of at least five years. That aligns with the request as regards the licensing.
Comment on this
I cannot understand it. The licensing falls under the Department of Health. Is that because of the link between hemp and cannabis? The Department knows that we live in a country where it rains nearly every single day. Cannabis growers only ever get caught because their electricity bills are so high as a result of using lamps to grow the plants inside. A few people in houses around mine got caught. That does not include me.
Comment on this
On the demand side again, we have Mr. Donoghue who has referred to how much he wants. Chloe Donovan of Natural Building Systems could not make it today but she provided a briefing note indicating how much she gets, where she gets it and where she will get it.
Comment on this
Ms Donovan is getting it from France, but she said she would take it off Irish farmers in a heartbeat. She orders 20 tonnes.
Comment on this
How does it stand up to the likes of mould? I have heard it is better than what is-----
Comment on this
Mould lives in an acidic environment with a pH of between 4 and 8 and because the lime is mixed in with the hemp, the pH value is up at 12 or 13 on acidity. It is really difficult for fungus or any kind of bacteria to grow on the hemp.
Comment on this
It is ideal for the likes of retrofitting older houses.
Comment on this
It is perfect for the Irish climate because we have the same humidity as the Amazon rainforest. We just do not have the heat. It is damp, and the idea is that it keeps the damp out. It makes much more sense to work with our climate rather than trying to keep out the moisture. If we use this as a fabric for our buildings, we will get long-term healthy buildings.
Comment on this
Lime is going to be a big issue for the quarry industry. We have a limestone flour. We polish tarmacadam stone every day in every quarry around Ireland. That is a waste product, in one sense, which could be used here as a circularity product.
Comment on this
We need lime from Ireland to make the binder for the hemp, and that is going to require between 10,000 and 12,000 metric tonnes of lime every year. That will support another industry.
Comment on this
I thank everyone who presented for us today. We read all of their statements and submissions, and there is a tremendous similarity among them. It is all very positive. I have some questions I want to put, particularly to Mr. O'Hara. He spoke about following the science, and that is clearly critically important. He also touched on the whole area of research and development. We have to follow the science and I want to hear a little bit about research and development or the lack of it, and how it is progressing. What is the trajectory for it in terms of the product? This is very important.
This crosses two areas, the agriculture sector and, of course, the construction sector. This is the agriculture committee but we have a joint committee on housing, which is clearly preoccupied with the construction sector. I have been to Finland and other places where I have seen other modern methods of construction, and the potential here is in MMC. To target Mr. O'Hara for a few minutes, I ask him to briefly talk about the potential in that area. We sort of know what it is but given what he is saying, we should follow the science. I ask him to talk a bit about research and development too.
Certification is clearly an issue and there are enormous challenges around it. The committee needs to understand those, which may take some time and we do not have time today. I ask those involved in this area to furnish the commission with some written additional information on the certification, because that seems to be a fairly tricky and challenging issue. I ask Mr. O'Hara to answer some of those questions briefly and to give us an in-depth understanding of certification, maybe in a little memorandum afterwards.
Comment on this
We opened a new geologic materials science lab, funded by Enterprise Island to the tune of €3.2 million, last Friday. We have some of state-of-the-art equipment to develop research and development in many of the aspects we have shown here. Key to what we do are R&D project and key to R&D projects is an SME company, an industry company. We have some of the top scientists in our outfit. Globally, we have 75 PhDs working with our organisation. The key thing is identifying the product, industry or company, and also putting that science together in our R&D projects.
The first project funded was a machine design project with Enterprise Ireland. It took a huge amount. It is the first project involving hemp that was ever funded. Enterprise Ireland is quite open to looking at a lot of other projects. We showed it the different products last Friday. There was a full table of the different types. They were also shown to the Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, and the Minister of State, Deputy Harkin, who were told what this could mean for the industry. Every one of them needs certification. Some have European certification already. We can adapt that and it will not take nearly as much time. It would probably take between six and nine months to get European certification. For any of our new products, it will probably take two or two and a half years. We have to look at how we can get that timescale down. The NSAI has a great team. We work with them all. However, it needs extra help. There are 70 companies coming in for agrément certification. Only five of those use modern methods of construction.
It is taking a huge amount of time. We got funding to look at a national fire testing centre. We are looking at the planning permission and bringing it forward. We need that in Ireland. We do not have a national fire testing centre. Every one of these products is going to need fire testing. We have a small one in Jordanstown in Belfast, but everything goes out to the BRE Group. When we talk about certification, we look at fire testing, sound and fuse sticks. I was talking to Mr. Donoghue earlier. My background is in the US. In some of these high-rise blocks, down around engineering rooms, there is a need for lightweight sound protection, and there is a huge export market in this area. It is about that, but every one of these products needs certification. We need the support to bring these products forward. As I said, for each of these products, we are talking about between €150,000 to €250,000 to get certification.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Hara accepts that certification is the biggest challenge facing this sector. It is not growing it, harvesting it or any of that. We clearly have people who can do all of that and who are willing and ready to do so. Would Mr. O’Hara say that this is the biggest challenge? It is not insurmountable, but it is a challenge.
Comment on this
It is a very costly thing for each company to do. We need to support the companies to do it. It has to come from each SME company having to undertake their certification.
Comment on this
There are other options for certification routes. At the moment, we are discussing what is conventional, which is a private company developing a product and taking on the investment and time costs itself. It could take two and a half to three years and cost €150,000 to €250,000 to get a product certified for building use. As the Senator said, that is key. It is not a barrier but it is key. You cannot get in unless you have that.
However, there are other ways to do this, particularly in the context of lower technological solutions, like the hemp line mixture, etc. This can be done nationally by creating a standard. Anybody who then manufactures to that standard would be certified. That is the way it is done with concrete blocks in Ireland. I could set up a concrete block company tomorrow. I do not need to do one fire test. I just need to have my blocks manufactured to that standard and it is certified. That is a way of opening it.
Another sort of in-between route is what has been done in France, where the chambres d'associations has effectively developed a code, and anybody who manufactures and installs within that code gets certified. It is almost like a private brand, a little bit like a Bord Bia-type of brand. The French Government recognises that brand and the building control authorities recognise it. That is what has been done in France. I could go to France tomorrow, start a hemp construction company and get certified by that organisation for what I am trying to do. I would not need to do any fire tests. It has all been pre-done. Those are two other routes.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Daly very much. I just need to move on because I am conscious of my time to ask questions. The EPA carries a lot of clout about a lot of things. I would have thought this product was ticking a lot of boxes regarding things the EPA is concerned about in respect of carbon credits and a whole lot of other things. Is there any relationship or engagement with the EPA on any of these matters?
Comment on this
Not directly in my case. I will pass the question on to everyone else.
Comment on this
That is okay. I will move on. Turning to the Irish Green Building Council, IGBC, what is the involvement with that organisation?
Comment on this
In fairness, the Irish Green Building Council is very much behind this product. It is always pushing the product as well.
Comment on this
I will turn to Teagasc for a moment. It submitted a very interesting paper. It has a huge commitment in terms of farm diversification, so clearly it is behind this. We have heard about the challenges in the tillage sector. Its strategy goes from 2025 to 2030, I think. Teagasc is a valued and trusted organisation, with close links to the Department of agriculture and the Government. It has a strong remit and great credibility in this regard. What extra steps is it taking to push this on?
Comment on this
It has been a small part of my remit over the last number of years. I take a special interest in it because I like the crop. From the time we were growing it at Oak Park, I just really felt passionate about the crop in terms of what could be achieved through it. It was a bit frustrating in ways that there was no end market for it. We realised that it will grow very well and there are opportunities for it to replace other materials. Biocomposites and bioplastics can be produced from it. It ticks a lot of boxes from a sustainability perspective.
There is, however, that taboo associated with the crop. It is about trying to remove the taboo and create greater acceptance. One of the things I tried to do back in 2019, and again in 2025, was to run conferences in our food centre in Ashtown here in Dublin. It was about trying to remove that taboo and create a greater awareness within Government Departments. We invited people from Bord Bia, the Department of agriculture and various other bodies so they could hear from practitioners, such as the people in this room, and people who were trying to do things even on the food side. I know we are not dwelling on the food side here today and it is more about fibre insulation and those areas, but it is a multifunctional crop. The debate can sometimes get complex when we start talking about different areas and different things that can be produced from it, but there are low-hanging-fruit areas that can be focused on such as those we are talking about here today.
All I can do is to create that awareness of what can be achieved with this crop, create those industry links with Government Departments and have fact sheets on it. There is the potential to have it as part of research projects in the future if it is accepted, whether those projects are funded by the Department of agriculture or whoever else. Research projects can be generated around the crop, but there is a bit of a taboo around funding research in this area.
Comment on this
It is not just that there is a taboo about funding research projects in this area but that there is a lack of funding generally for research in Ireland. I call for greater research funding in the construction sector in particular. A new initiative, Construct Innovate, has been set up but the amount of funding is very small relative to that in other countries and to other sectors in this country. It is a multibillion-euro industry every year. We have a huge demand for housing, building infrastructure, etc. We need investment in facilities to enable testing of new materials and products coming to the market.
We do a lot of work with the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment for our own cement and changing the concrete standards. We are looking at doing that at the moment. We had a meeting similar to this one in-house in UCD on that subject and there was a claim that there was a total lack of funding of facilities to test new products. It is the major blockage in that industry. I hear the situation is exactly the same in this industry. There is a lack of funding of infrastructure and of research that can work alongside it.
Comment on this
In terms of the EPA, I wanted to mention that we had a couple of research projects co-funded by the EPA and the Irish Research Council, IRC. In general, in terms of plant science, there is an opportunity because research in genetics in respect of hemp is only about to get started. We in UCD are leading this research at the moment. I get invited to conferences in France, the UK, Germany and everywhere to talk about our research. This is also an opportunity for us to keep leading this type of research and to keep spearheading new breeding initiatives and new plant science-related initiatives involving hemp.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for coming in. It is one of the more interesting topics that we have discussed here. It is one of those good news stories except for the fact that it is not a good news story because it is not possible to get it over the line.
Starting with Teagasc, there seems to be a bit of a contradiction in the opening statement. It was said that it was shown "the crop can be grown with little or no requirement for plant protection products", but also that "if grown more widely pests and disease could become a problem". I ask the witnesses to explain that. Is there a risk?
Comment on this
If you mass-produce a crop anywhere, you do run the risk of disease exposure. It is the same with any crop. If you are only growing a small amount of the crop, there is less risk of infection.
There is less of a risk of infection when growing a small amount of the crop. At the moment, we do not see any issues with disease around the crop, but as a greater area of the crop is produced, there is potential for disease to take hold within a country. There is that risk.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Caslin talking about sizes of 20 or 30 acres, or thousands of acres? What does he mean by a small amount?
Comment on this
It could be diseases like sclerotinia, which affects oilseed rape, or different types of diseases that could manifest themselves within a crop over time. They do not seem to be an issue at the moment, but they can become an issue if they manifest themselves within a crop over a period of time.
Comment on this
Have we seen that kind of thing happening in France, where most of this is produced?
Comment on this
Yes. There are issues with a certain number of diseases and crops out there. We cannot say that a crop is completely safe. There are always risks with crops around harvest time as well. If a farmer does not get favourable weather, there is the risk that he or she will not be able to harvest the crop in a timely manner. This crop is generally harvested in September and October. If the weather is not playing ball at that time of the year, it is a risk. Those risks exist with every crop, essentially.
Comment on this
My father-in-law undertook some forestry at home. He harvested it some 35 years later. I worked out the calculations based on the figure of €350 for an acre of hemp. If the prices stayed the same and did not increase over the 35 years, it works out at €12,250 per acre if everything goes okay, which is pretty good. The only difference with forestry and hemp is that people are paid every year for it, whereas the harvest is at the end of the 35 years. If there are storms and so forth, there is also less risk because one crop may be lost, rather than every crop. It is possibly an easier and simpler option for some people.
France is producing 60% of our hemp in the EU. When it comes to the products we are getting in, are we getting them from France or where is the main place we import products from? I presume they are products that are complete. How many acres did the witnesses say were produced in Ireland? How many acres are we growing here?
Comment on this
Mr. O’Hara touched on the number of acres we have. From a European context, some 60% came from France between 2015 and 2022. The production then increased by more than 80%. Mr. O’Hara might have the number of acres grown specifically in Ireland.
Comment on this
A total of 45,000 ha is growing at the moment in France.
Comment on this
The way the hemp in France is processed is by decortication through a co-operative because farmers cannot do it themselves. It has been looked at and funding is in place for another decorticator in the co-operative in order to supply three manufacturing facilities within France.
Comment on this
What is the additional price we are paying for importing these products, compared with using them in France to build houses? Obviously, there is an additional cost as we are importing them. We will use timber-like products as an example.
Comment on this
I import hemp blocks. They are the main thing we work with. The price has doubled, maybe even more than that. Since Covid, there has also been an uptick in transportation costs and everything. The cost is double and then some.
Comment on this
It is great that it is produced in 90 to 100 days. It only needs babysitting for that length of time, and there is not even that much babysitting with the crop.
How has Europe managed to do this but we have not? Obviously, there is a licensing block. Did Europe have issues before getting off the ground? Have we learned anything from the issues it had? Are there any lessons we can take from how Europe got over certain hurdles that we can apply to the hurdles we face, such as our licensing issue?
Mr. Donoghue mentioned that there is a corporation in France. Obviously, for us, the price is the incentive. Is there anything we need to look for from the Government in this regard, such as grants? What did other European countries get from their governments? Can we learn anything from how those countries got their licences?
Comment on this
We can learn that the rest of them have plugged straight into that European or CAP framework, which has a threshold of 0.3% tetrahydrocannabinol, THC. The threshold in Ireland is 0.2% THC. As I said earlier, that is not a loose regulation; it is a controlled agriculture regulation. If we have concerns around public safety enforcement or misuse, that framework is in place. It should be treated as a practical guide and allow us to continue to manage hemp from early on. Anything outside of industrial use cases should fall within the drugs framework. Currently, it is the mismatch between us and Europe that is creating that uncertainty for a legitimate and viable production sector in Ireland. I can pass to someone else if other witnesses wish to comment further.
Comment on this
I have done a state-of-play research on these co-operatives across Europe and the materials in question. Germany and France are two industrialised nations, particularly the Rhineland, where there is a tradition of industrialised crop utilisation. Construction is not the sole focus in this regard; it is a sort of spin-off. They are supplying silicates and cellulose. They are extracting elements from these materials. They have that tradition. They also have a waste stream. They researched what could be done with the low-quality materials and fibres, and they found the construction sector was suitable for those lower-grade materials. That is where this began to develop about 30 years ago. They also produce miscanthus in significant volumes and extract material from that crop on an industrial scale.
While we can learn from Germany and France, the Netherlands is closer to us in being slightly more of a pasture economy and less industrialised. The way it is kicking-starting this, which is probably what we need to do, is through the multistate market activation team, which Mr. O’Hara mentioned, to represent all the supply chain; unlock all the barriers effectively and at the same time; generate demand and supply; and smooth out of the bureaucratic and investment barriers farmers are coming across, etc. We could learn a lot from the Netherlands, as well as from France and Germany. The reason they are so successful is that they are 30 years ahead and they have a tradition of industrial use of crops that we have lost. Maybe the linen and flax industries would be our closest examples. They are selling into the car market and chemical sectors, etc. The construction sector is just one of those streams.
Comment on this
Has anyone looked into this product compared with timber? Is it the same value or price to produce, or are we looking at a dearer product? Can we see ourselves getting to the stage where, in order to meet our targets and so forth, we are going to say to the construction industry that 10% or 20% of its products need to be sustainable with a low-carbon footprint? Do the witnesses think we will get to that stage?
Comment on this
I might pass that question to Mr. O’Hara.
Comment on this
I refer to incentivising the sector to do it.
Comment on this
The construction industry is the highest producing carbon sector, standing at 46%.
We looked at the life cycle analysis of hemp and the life cycle analysis of timber. We looked at the carbon emissions per tonne aspect. Hemp has an interesting products base. The two materials are not just equal. There is a difference. We see nine products that we make from the hemp plant. The hemp harvester that we designed takes up the root as well. It takes off the top of the root. Nine products come out of the hemp plant. They are not equal. Timber is timber, but it depends on whether it is Douglas fir, larch or Sitka spruce. They are different things. We can bring this material into the construction industry and get nine products out of it. Nine products would be in the box. That is how we see it and that is the value that we recognise.
Comment on this
Approximately 20 minutes remain. I will allow three minutes per member in a second round. We will move in the same order.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair. It has been an interesting discussion. I have a couple of points to raise. Under the CAP, hemp is a product or a crop. What payments are given in other European countries to farmers growing hemp? What level of subsidy do they receive, if any? How does that work? Has anyone done any research in that regard?
Comment on this
To be honest, I do not know. We did have subsidies for things such as miscanthus and they were pulled. I do not know. Some individual nations are involved, if not on a European level. The Netherlands is supporting it through this activation team. There is also a financial activation and it includes support for starting to grow. I do not know the figure.
Comment on this
I am sure there is the potential to within every country.
Comment on this
The supports are pretty much the same across Europe. Until recently, we were included in that. We get our basic income support for sustainability, BISS, payments and our area aid. That is pretty much across Europe-----
Comment on this
There is no specific payment for growing hemp as opposed to-----
Comment on this
There is not anymore. The support is in the construction industry other than the normal payment. It is treated as a normal crop as far as the farming side of things is concerned.
Comment on this
We have recently developed supports for the tillage sector. It may dovetail into those supports at a later date.
Mr. Donoghue mentioned a co-operative approach in France whereby farmers come together. How does that model work? How does it fit into the private business model that the witnesses have? I will also come to the issue of certification that Senator Boyhan mentioned earlier. We have the Irish Agrément Board. For all these end products, certification is needed for their use in buildings. The big issue we have is that architects are not going to recommend something for use in a building unless it has certification. That is a big issue that we need to sort out.
Comment on this
The co-operative model is that funds grow from the co-operative and the co-operative then buys the hemp. It processes the hemp. A factory in France produces the blocks that we use. It gets its hurd directly from the co-operative. It cannot buy directly from a farmer. The farmers are not involved in that particular part. I am not saying that is the best model but that is the way it works in France.
Comment on this
The farmers are shareholders in the co-operative.
Comment on this
Yes. For the machines they are using, as Mr. Morgan pointed out, if they are doing fibre and hurd at the same time, it is very expensive. Doing a small-scale thing and getting something going here is enough. Mr. Daly spoke about the low-hanging fruit in the context of construction materials and so on. That is the way to go.
The other point about certification is that we have spent the past six years or so doing certification. As Mr. O'Hara pointed out, it is very expensive. It is absolutely necessary. We got a three-hour fire rating for hemp. It is non-combustible. That cost a lot of money. We are just going through this in the United States.
I am not sure of standards here, but I assume they are harmonised with the European standards. Because there are already examples of products that have European standards, there are things such as equivalences that can be considered. We are looking at putting in for the agreement here to get some of the products that we want to get into the market prior to manufacturing. We want to be able to use those certifications. There are 40 certifications that we have with these products. I do not see it as an arduous process. It has to be done and paid for. Then again, if that cannot be done as a business, nobody is going to buy it.
Comment on this
I will go back to where I was in respect of licensing. I still think licensing is the issue. Mr. Caslin mentioned a taboo. We are going nowhere without the Department of agriculture. That is where the taboo starts. No public servant in the Department is going to grasp a nettle that is still on the list of controlled substances and is licensed under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1997 - end of story. We can talk about different varieties, but it is a member of the cannabis family. It has a THC content. It is where it is. We must get it out of there and over to agriculture. The Department of agriculture is not going to grasp it until it is in control of it. With the greatest of respect to public servants, no public servant is going to embrace a product that is dealt with under the Misuse of Drugs Act.
The witnesses have the Bill I drafted. I want them to come back to me on it. I admit that I am a beef farmer. I started out with it for the licensing of the protein. The witnesses are not going that far. They are of a different variety, but it is still industrial hemp. No matter the variety, it will have to come under the one licence. If we were talking about potatoes today, whether we were going to chip them, boil them, bake them or mash them, and whether they were Kerr's pink, golden wonder or records, there would still only be the one umbrella and they would still be potatoes. That is the problem we have here. It is not just because I have the work done, but I genuinely think that the first block, square one, is getting licensing into the Department of agriculture. I want the witnesses to help me on that. The draft Bill is there. I gave it to the witnesses. I know it is not the finished product. I know I was coming at the issue from a different angle. I was coming at it solely for the seed as a form of protein for feed. That is another option. If we get this business up and running, that is another option. The Bill includes five years, as the witnesses have mentioned. It includes transportation if someone is a grower and everything else. It needs tweaking, but we will get it up and running. That is the first step. I give the witnesses my word that I will bring it to the next level. However, I want them to come back to me because I want to get the legislation right when it goes in. I hope that when it goes in, the Department of agriculture will embrace it. We will know then if not. If the Department starts trying to give me a hard time and is not embracing it, we will know that we have a problem and need to go at it from another angle. I ask the witnesses to come back to me. I ask them to circulate the Bill among them. Producers, processors, academics and everybody who is anybody when it comes to this great story we have heard are here today. We have to get things moving and that is the place to start. I want the witnesses to circulate the Bill among them, cut it to shreds, copy and paste it, tear it up or come back and tell me that it is going in the wrong direction. I do not mind. If there is something with which they can come back, I ask them to do so and we will take it from there.
Comment on this
We absolutely will. In the past, I worked on and implemented the five D policy model that the Government had advised for designing a policy. The first D related to demand. We have seen in the room today that the demand is there. The Senator is describing the problem whereby the public servants will not go near it. That comes under the heading of "deepening". We have to deepen understanding and create the distinction between industrial hemp and illicit drugs.
The next step is the design. It is then up to the Civil Service to design this and consider what type of licensing it wants to come in. That is where we would integrate the Senator's Bill. The next D is around deciding. We must decide what way to implement. The final D relates to delivering. We will work closely with the Senator on that Bill and will use that model to have a good implementation timeline.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for coming. I had a chat with Mr. Morgan and he educated me on this issue. I stand to learn more about it as we go along. I will work with Senator Daly and anyone else on the committee. Senator Daly has taken the bull by the horns, so to speak. We will try to push this on. It is extremely important and the story is really good. However, the Senator is absolutely right that responsibility must be moved from the Department of Health to the Department of agriculture. That is the rate limiting step at this time.
That is what we need to get moving on. I thank all the witnesses. I asked Mr. Morgan to bring an array of experts. He has brought a stellar cast and there has been a very impressive turnout. I thank the witnesses again for coming here. I appreciate it.
Comment on this
As was said, we need to get this shifted from there. Whatever we can do for the witnesses we will do. This is a good news story.
In other countries, how long have they been using blocks for building houses or whatever?
Comment on this
The blocks have been the aftermath of the initial mixing and casting in situ. The blocks themselves have a lifespan of a couple of hundred years, which is an unbelievable length of time. The factory we work in is called IsoHemp and it has been in production for ten to 12 years. Its current factory can produce about 8,000 blocks a day.
Comment on this
Mr. Donoghue said you do not need mortar. Is it just the case that the blocks are made in such a way that they stack or-----
Comment on this
Yes. Mr. Donoghue's blocks click together. They almost push together like wood flooring.
Comment on this
Yes, that is what I was thinking. I was going to say like Lego, but they slot together.
Comment on this
There are other little blocks on the market that have very thin joints and that also involves lime. A way of looking at it is that you can build a house out of two ingredients: hemp and lime. You might have a little bit of lime along the joints for air tightness - it depends on the design - and then the plaster that goes on top of the blocks is also lime. That promotes natural paints. As we said, the blocks mitigate negative things like mould, dampness and all the problems that modern buildings have in abundance.
Comment on this
What kind of weight is in each block? Are they a similar size to our-----
Comment on this
We have ones measuring 600 mm by 300 mm by 300 mm. There are about 5.5 of them per square metre. There are different sizes of the solid blocks Mr. McDermott is talking about as well. There are different applications. Those types of blocks are best for the renovation stuff but also for new places, whereas the dry stacked, interlocking blocks are more for newer houses, new constructions and things like that.
Comment on this
They are simple to work with and fast.
Comment on this
That is right. We provide training, for example, in Australia as part of that certification. They have to do the training with us, even though it is easy. We have a huge list of people who want to do training. We are doing training in the US shortly for another building. Those sorts of things are creating employment opportunities and developing industries.
Comment on this
What kind of building work is going on in Ireland with hemp blocks?
Comment on this
We have conservation and bringing old buildings back to life with hemp, which is excellent for allowing the fabric to breathe. All these old stone buildings are being done up around the country. There is no damp proof course, DPC, so there is nothing to stop the moisture coming up from the ground. As hemp is hydroscopic, the blocks are being used to retrofit the inside and the outside of these buildings. Again, there is the lifespan of the product and there is the lifespan of a stone building or an old heritage building. We have been retrofitting old 1980s bungalows and brick houses. Then, because of the lightweight nature of the hempcrete, the design flexibility is off the charts, so you can really create incredible structures. A hemp house is about 80% lighter than a concrete block house so it gives you a chance to reduce your use of concrete in the foundations. It also gives you huge design flexibility with a lightweight structure, whether newbuild, retrofit or conservation, or even a music studio.
Comment on this
One second. I want to get Dr. Melzer in briefly. We have asked the questions that we want to get asked on this. I will do one quick round if anyone feels there are particular points they would like to raise before the meeting concludes. We will do one minute-----
Comment on this
Chair, may I say one thing before you do the round? Next week we will meet on this again and we will have the Department before us, so when today's witnesses are doing the next round, maybe there is a message they want to give to us for the officials from the Department.
Comment on this
To provide a little historical perspective, there was a professor at UCD about 100 years ago, George Sigerson, who was also a big supporter of the GAA. Back then he wrote a book, Cannabiculture in Ireland, so he was already seeing that industrial hemp was an opportunity for Ireland to grow an industrial crop and to support the local economy. This is not really a new idea; it has been around for a long time. It is our opportunity to grasp it now.
Comment on this
We will start with the back and go around anticlockwise and then the front row anticlockwise.
Comment on this
I will keep this quick. As Senator Daly said, the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine will be in here next week. My ask, and indeed for the wider group for the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, would be to have a Department-led industrial hemp fibre pathway. As we mentioned, it is a matter of taking the specific strains out of the HPRA's hands and allowing the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine oversight. I am not suggesting throwing the HPRA's and the Department of justice's books out the window. They should still be retained for appropriate roles in a controlled drugs policy and enforcement setting.
There is a lot happening this year with the European Presidency and there will be the Global Bioeconomy Summit in October as well. It is an opportunity for us to align with Europe, using that 0.3% THC framework. As I said earlier, it is a plug-in. We can adapt with that and, if there are any concerns, as I said, around public safety or misuse, refer back to that framework and work with our European counterparts to make sure we have a model that works and aligns with the rest of Europe.
Comment on this
Just to clear up something from earlier, the hemp we are growing has a 90-day to 100-day cycle. We have a frost-resistant variety at the moment that we are sowing. That will grow. We hope to get that in most years by mid-April the way we will harvest it before 1 August. Harvesting before 1 August takes most of the risk out of the weather because you still have the long days for the drying. It is just to make sure we have that. We will not let it go anywhere near seed or flower. This is like oats when it is green, before the heads shoot out of it. That is what we intend to do.
Comment on this
An activation group with the members who are here and the four Departments, that is, the Department of Health, the Department of justice, the Department of agriculture and the Department of housing is what we need to get. The expertise that is here in the Department of housing, UCD, TUS and the SMEs is the key point.
Comment on this
I agree with that. Collaboration is vital here and I would be happy to help out.
Comment on this
On that, despite the blocks that are before us with hemp, there are a lot of people here who still continue to work with it, despite the barriers. That tells you something.
We talk about value chain development. The value chain is pretty much here in the room from the farmer all the way to the researchers, the people who want to manufacture it and the end user. They are all here in the room. That is proof of what you are looking for as well.
Comment on this
From working with hemp over the past ten years and meeting designers and architects, and seeing their faces light up when they hear about this product and when they hear that there is somebody actually doing it, the biggest barrier we have is price point. The architects are doing their best. The designers are trying to convince customers that this is what they need to go forward with. Oftentimes the only reason they pull back from this is the cost, so if we have a homegrown supply chain, we really feel like this will grow exponentially and really quickly. The Irish customer will then get something of such high quality. That is what we would love to see - that end customer getting something long-lasting. That would be really good.
Comment on this
It has been great being here today and being part of the group. We look forward to all this getting cleared up. We are ready to go. We are ready to put up our money, buy off the farmers and that sort of thing. We are ready to learn. It is not just about us. It is about working with everybody. It is a whole collaborative thing. What do they say? How many people does it take to make a village? The time is now. There is enough evidence out there to show that this is a goer. We know from our global experience that it is consumer demand that is driving our market. People want it slow, and doing the regulations and stuff, but people still want it. That is something we are very excited about.
I thank the committee.
Comment on this
I will reinforce what Mr. O'Hara said about a market or sector development activation team or group that draws across all the Departments and some of the key agencies, such as the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, SEAI, Enterprise Ireland, etc. This touches on a whole range of areas.
Comment on this
I repeat that, as a building material, hemp is low carbon and breathable. It is an insulating product with a thermal mass or thermal storage quality. It is unique and highly appropriate for the Irish environment. There is certainly a market there.
Comment on this
It is not a crop that we should be afraid of. We should embrace the crop. We should look at more research around the crop, too. We could possibly look at a strategy around the crop, as the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs did in the UK. It developed a number of years ago a strategy for hemp and its potential in the UK. Perhaps that could be considered for this country.
There are some roadblocks. I like the work that Senator Daly is doing in developing the Bill. That is something we should all be looking at. There is also the multi-annual licence. If, say, Mr. Donoghue has a proposal for a five-year contract, he should not have to be going for a licence every year and reapplying year on year. He should be a part of that project. A five-year licence would make a lot of sense in that situation. There are these kinds of roadblocks. You can get an annual licence today. There is not that much restriction on getting a licence to grow hemp, but some people find it a bit of an ordeal. Perhaps it would be better if the industry had a multi-annual licence. We must identify roadblocks. Perhaps developing a strategy could open up this whole area. We could see where the roadblocks were and identify ways of getting over them.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe go léir as an bplé cuimsitheach. Is ábhar é seo a mbeimid ag filleadh air arís leis an Roinn talmhaíochta an tseachtain seo chugainn
I thank the witnesses for contributing. It has been an insightful discussion. It is a topic to which we will return, particularly with the Department next week.