We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food

Technological Innovation in Agriculture: Discussion

Summary

GlasPort Bio presented GasAbate, a slurry additive and monitoring system it says can substantially reduce methane, ammonia and hydrogen sulphide emissions while preserving slurry nutrients. Its representatives said wider uptake depends on financial support and formal recognition of verified reductions in national emissions accounting, with costs shared across the supply chain. Nofence outlined virtual fencing’s potential to save labour and support targeted grazing, conservation and animal monitoring, and sought TAMS funding for cattle, sheep and goat collars and continued or expanded ACRES support. Members questioned both technologies’ evidence, costs, reliability and practical benefits.

Before I begin, I will go through privilege with the witnesses.

Witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they give to a committee. This means that a witness has a full defence in any defamation action for anything said at a committee meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and may be directed to cease giving evidence on an issue at the Chair's direction. Witnesses should follow the direction of the Chair in this regard and are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that, as is reasonable, no adverse commentary should be made as against an identifiable third person or entity.

Witnesses who are to give evidence from a location outside the parliamentary precincts are asked to note that they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as witnesses giving evidence from within the parliamentary precincts, and it may be considered appropriate to take legal advice on the matter. Privilege against defamation does not apply to the publication by witnesses outside of the proceedings of any matters arising from them.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise, or make charges against either a person outside the House or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Parliamentary privilege is considered to apply to the utterances of members participating online in a committee meeting, where their participation is from within the parliamentary precincts. Members may not participate online in a public meeting from outside the parliamentary precincts. Any attempt to do so will result in the member having their online access removed. All the members taking part, up to now, are present in the room.

The agenda for today's meeting is technological innovation in agriculture. We have two groups who are going to talk to the committee. From GlastPort Bio we have Mr. Justin McCarthy, CEO; Professor Vincent O'Flaherty, co-founder; and Dr. Ruairi Friel, co-founder.

From Nofence we have Mr. Benjamin Mazin, Mr. John Maher and Mr. Patrick McKenna.

Their statements have been circulated to members. They have had an opportunity to read over them. I will give the witnesses five minutes to go through their statements before proceeding to questions and answers with members. It is important to recognise that the object of today's meeting is for members to gain an understanding and knowledge of the potential benefits of technological innovation in the agriculture sector. It is not to be treated as an opportunity for product endorsement.

I call Mr. McCarthy to make his opening statement on behalf of GlasPort Bio.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the opportunity to appear before them today.

GlasPort Bio is an Irish agricultural technology company based in Galway focused on developing science-based solutions that help farmers to reduce emissions while improving farm efficiency and productivity. Since our foundation, our objective has been very simple: to develop technologies that are scientifically robust, independently validated and practical for farmers while delivering meaningful environmental improvements without creating additional workload on farmers. I would like to briefly tell the committee about one of those technologies, GasAbate, and then discuss what we believe is one of the most important challenges facing agricultural innovation in Ireland - not innovation itself but the adoption and scaling of that innovation.

GasAbate is a manure management technology designed to reduce emissions arising from stored slurry. It is deployed directly within slurry storage systems and works continuously during the slurry storage period. Unlike many mitigation measures, which require additional labour, infrastructure changes, management interventions or changed management practice, GasAbate operates within the existing farm system and requires minimal additional input from the farmer. The results are significant. Independent validation has demonstrated that GasAbate can reduce methane emissions from stored manure by up to 78%, reduce ammonia emissions by up to 50% and reduce hydrogen sulphide emissions by up to 80%. These outcomes matter for several reasons. Methane is a powerful greenhouse gas and reducing agricultural methane emissions is essential if Ireland and Europe are to achieve their climate ambitions. Ammonia emissions contribute to air quality challenges and are increasingly becoming a regulatory focus. Hydrogen sulphide is a significant health and safety concern during slurry agitation and handling.

However, the benefits extend beyond emissions reductions alone. Farmers using GasAbate will benefit from reduced odour, reduced agitation requirements and improved nutrient retention in the slurry. In practical terms, this means farmers can retain more of the fertiliser value already present in their slurry while simultaneously reducing environmental loss. This is an important point. The future of agricultural technology cannot be about asking farmers to carry additional burdens. Technologies must deliver environmental benefits while also making commercial and practical sense at farm level.

We are proud that the work we do is gaining international recognition. GasAbate became the first manure management technology to receive independent third-party assurance from the Carbon Trust. This was a significant milestone, providing external validation of both the science and performance of the technology. Through our engagement with leading European dairy processors and food manufacturers along with EU research institutions, our technology will be commercially deployed across eight member states in 2027.

Only this week GasAbate was approved by Arla, the largest dairy processor in Europe with over 11,000 farmers across members states. Through its €550 million sustainability programme, it will incentivise the roll-out of GasAbate across its farms. We are very proud of this but these achievements have not happened by accident. They are the result of years of research, development and investment. Throughout this journey, GlasPort Bio has benefited from support through Irish and European innovation programmes, including initiatives through Enterprise Ireland such as the disruptive technologies innovation fund and the European Innovation Council. These programmes are critically important because they help companies like us to move innovative ideas from concept through to commercialisation.

However, today, we believe a new challenge is emerging. Ireland has become increasingly effective at supporting innovation but we now need to become equally effective at supporting its adoption. Developing a technology is one challenge; deploying that technology across thousands of individual farms is another. The reality is that technologies that reduce emissions often involve an additional cost at farm level yet many of the benefits generated are societal benefits, including climate mitigation, improved air quality and progress towards our national emissions reduction targets.

In other sectors, we already recognise this principle. We support the installation of heat pumps, we support homeowners in improving energy efficiency and we support the transition from internal combustion vehicles to electric vehicles. We do so because we recognise the benefits of these transitions extend well beyond the individual making the investment. Agriculture should be viewed through the same lens. If Ireland is serious about accelerating agricultural emissions reduction while maintaining a vibrant and competitive farming sector, then we must create clear adoption pathways for proven technologies.

This is where support mechanisms such as the targeted agricultural modernisation schemes become critically important. Strategic grant support coupled with clear regulatory pathways and recognition frameworks can help to bridge the gap between innovation and widespread adoption, which is needed. They can help to ensure that farmers are not expected to shoulder the full cost of delivering benefits that accrue to society as a whole. The cost benefit of agricultural decarbonisation must be shared across the entire supply chain. This must be supported by regulatory and financial frameworks that enable investment and adoption while ensuring the emission reductions achieved are fully recognised in national and sectoral emissions accounting.

On this latter point, establishing a clear pathway for recognition of emerging technologies such as GasAbate within national and sectoral emissions accounting is every bit as important as providing direct financial support. To date, we have engaged extensively with leading dairy processors across Ireland and many of the main procurers of Irish dairy produce. We now have almost 40 installations active across the country.

However, moving from early adoption to deployment at scale will require a mechanism for sharing the costs across the supply chain and formal recognition of emission reductions delivered by the technology so that processors can account for those benefits within their supply chains and emission reduction strategies. Without both, there is a real risk that proven emissions reductions can be delivered on farm but neither the farmer nor the processor receive adequate recognition or economic value for delivering them.

Our ambition at GlasPort Bio extends beyond the development of any single technology. We want Ireland not only to be recognised as a world leader in sustainable food production but also in the development and export of agricultural innovation. We have the opportunity to demonstrate that environmental sustainability, food security and farm profitability are not competing objectives as is often portrayed. With the right technologies and the right policy supports, they can be achieved together.

Our goal is simple: help farmers produce more sustainable food for a growing global population while ensuring that doing so does not cost the earth. I thank members for their time.

Comment on this
William Aird An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Mr. McCarthy. We will now go to Nofence. I call Mr. Mazin.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee on behalf of Nofence for the invitation to appear today. I am public affairs managers at Nofence. I am joined by Mr. John Maher who represents Nofence in Ireland and Mr. Patrick McKenna, a cattle farmer in County Monaghan who uses Nofence for conservation grazing.

Nofence was the first company to bring a virtual fencing system to market in 2018. It now has over 10,000 customers, including more than 250 farmers in Ireland. We have one collar for cattle and another for sheep and goats. As members know, livestock farmers must attend to their animals every day of the year. Labour is scarce, the workload is heavy, fencing, feed and fuel are increasingly expensive and margins are tight.

These pressures help to explain why only 4.3% of Irish farm holders are under 35. If generational renewal in livestock farming fails and grazing declines, land will increasingly be abandoned and wildfire risk will grow. Rural communities will lose a key part of their identity, together with an activity that is still crucial for the economy and for food security. Young farmers today have more options than previous generations and farming needs to be more compatible with the work-life balance they expect.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

We believe virtual fencing is part of that solution. When the technology is implemented, farmers gain more time, more control and more confidence in how they run their operation. With Nofence, farmers can manage grazing boundaries from an app on their phone, so they can move stock to fresh grass more efficiently and flexibly without putting up and taking down temporary fencing.

The same collar flags animals that escape, stop moving or come into heat, so any problems or veterinary issues are detected earlier. Farmers can see where their animals are at all times and can even take a day away from the farm if needed, knowing they will be alerted if something needs attention. As a result, virtual fencing reduces several of the main costs for livestock farmers, such as physical fencing, supplementary feeds, fuel and time that would normally be spent checking and moving stock. Farmers often tell us that once they start using it, they cannot imagine going back to a world without virtual fencing.

Nofence also provides a key tool for land management. It is used for targeted grazing in wildfire prevention projects, by farmers building grazing service businesses and by conservation groups, bringing back grazing that protects biodiversity. The system also records where livestock have grazed, which can give result-based schemes such as the agri-climate rural environment scheme, ACRES, evidence of the work done. Ireland's farmers have experience of this. Virtual fencing collars for cattle are already funded as a landscape action under ACRES co-operation. As the Irish Farmers Journal reported in July, virtual fencing is improving grazing in the Burren and on the Aran Islands. Most of the farmers in the Burren pilot that preceded the landscape action were under 40 years old.

Public support, however, is uneven. ACRES landscape actions fund collars only for cattle and only for farmers in the eight co-operation zones. Elsewhere, TAMS 3 funds physical fencing but not virtual fencing, which discourages farmers from choosing more innovative options. We therefore welcome the Minister, Deputy Heydon’s, statement in March that virtual fencing will be considered in any future review of TAMS investments.

Today, we ask the committee to consider three points. First, we ask that virtual fencing be included in TAMS as its own investment category, covering cattle as well as sheep and goats. We know that many farmers are calling for this as they often ask us when the technology will be included in the scheme. Second, we ask that the virtual fencing landscape action under ACRES co-operation be extended to sheep and goats. Well-managed targeted grazing with small ruminants can be excellent for land management and wildfire prevention. Virtual fencing makes it viable at scale. Third, we ask that virtual fencing remains a landscape action in the scheme that replaces ACRES under the next CAP.

Other administrations already fund virtual fencing through their main investment schemes. In Northern Ireland, the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs new sustainable farming investment scheme funds collars for cattle, sheep and goats at 40%. In Scotland, the government's new guidance for the 2026 future farming investment covering costs from 50% to 100% published this week makes collars for cattle, sheep and goats eligible and scores virtual fencing the highest in its grazing and grassland management category. Sweden, Spain, the United States, Norway, Australia and Canada also fund virtual fencing widely.

In Ireland and in other countries, we are seeing virtual fencing change how livestock farms are run, and bring younger farmers and new energy into the sector. We ask policymakers to recognise this opportunity and help Irish farmers make the most of it.

We are happy to take any questions and respond to any comments.

Comment on this

There is no doubt that farming today is unrecognisable from farming 30 or 40 years ago. Farmers are always interested and keen to use different technological advances to not necessarily replace them but support them in doing their work, freeing up time for work, family or whatever priorities they have. I thank the witnesses for their overview on the various technologies. I will now open it to the floor. Six members are offering and we will do six-minute slots starting with Deputy Aird.

Comment on this

Are we taking both witnesses together?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Mr. McCarthy stated that GasAbate can reduce methane emissions from stored manure by up to 78%, reduce ammonia emissions by up to 50% and reduce hydrogen sulphide emissions by up to 80%. I ask him or his colleagues to outline the independent validation process behind these figures and explain how these have performed under commercial farm conditions in Ireland.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

From the outset of GlastPort Bio in 2018, we set out our stall that every claim we make and every result that we publicise would be open to the public and fully scrutinised. All the research trials we have done have been carried out often independently, for example with Teagasc, the Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute, AFBI, and potential commercial partners. We then publicise those results to make them public. There is a peer review process in science where independent scientists review the work and the experiments to confirm they are valid and robust in that sense.

Comment on this

My next question is for Nofence. I am very excited about this, which could be revolutionary, and I hope it is fully embraced. When we got our first battery fence at home, I remember my father giving out stink to us and saying, "Where are you going with that? That piece of wire isn't going to keep back anything." Electric fencing was revolutionary in Irish farming. There could be five or six strands of barbed wire and a bull could go through it but with one string of electric fencing he would go up, look at it and walk back. It was revolutionary and I think this will be revolutionary as well. Creosote stakes were taken off the market because they were polluting the ground. With this, there will be no fencing and it beggars belief. There is no question it will happen. In years to come there will be no fencing in fields and it will be all this virtual fencing. It will be fantastic because farmers will be able to look at their cattle, count their cattle and know when they need to be moved. It will take a bit of time to get used to but it will be great. Why should virtual fencing be eligible for grant aid under TAMS? I may have already answered that question.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

As Mr. Mazin mentioned, it is labour saving. It saves farmers going out into fields, setting up reels, going around every year, repairing fences and putting up fences. All this has changed and the farmer can now manage his fences and set up boundaries all from the app on his phone.

Comment on this

Could sheep farmers benefit from the technology for upland grazing, especially with commonage management and wildfire prevention?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

That is a big area where we are hoping it will help. We have spoken with many farmers. Some farmers in the west are using our collars on commonage areas where they previously had trouble with sheep crossing roads and not being able to find their sheep because they were being chased by predators across these areas.

Now farmers just look on the app on their phone. Their sheep are contained from going onto roads. They can look on the app on the phone, see where the sheep are and easily go and find the sheep on commonage across thousands of acres.

Comment on this

What assessment has been carried out for the potential of savings from virtual events? A farmer will not have to travel as often. Will a collar identify and tell a farmer whether an animal is sick or needs attention?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

The collars are constantly developing. At the minute, the collars record reduced activity. It will notify the farmer is a cow or sheep is lame or if they are sick. It is tracking their daily movement on the collar. It is building up an average daily move. If the animal's activity is reduced, it will notify the farmer. There is heat protection on the collars as well.

Comment on this

In agriculture, habitats and all that is a huge area at the moment. How can virtual fencing support more targeted grazing practices that protect sensitive habitats, reduce livestock access to vulnerable watercourses and help efforts to meet Ireland's water quality and environmental objectives?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

One of the big challenges in Ireland's agriculture is improving water quality. With this, farmers can now use the collars to keep animals contained and fenced away from watercourses, as well as endangered habitats and stuff like that. On the app, they can draw exclusion zones in areas for breeding and nesting areas in commonage and protect species from these areas while the animals graze around all these areas and keep the birds protected from it.

Comment on this

I have more questions that I might ask in the second round. Mr. McCarthy highlighted the importance of ensuring that emissions reductions delivered by technologies such as GasAbate are recognised in the national and sectoral emissions accounting. What specific changes are required from the Government or State agencies to enable this recognition that comes back to us as farmers?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

We need to be very clear on this. Farmers will not pay for a technology that reduces a gas that they cannot see or smell - methane. The reduction in methane is a societal benefit, in the same way it is a societal benefit if we take people out of diesel engine cars and put them into electric cars. For our technology to be recognised and scaled, there needs to be a regulatory pathway that recognises the peer review signs that Professor O'Flaherty spoke about in making sure that the emission reduction achieved from our technology can be accounted within the national inventory. When we need to achieve a 25% target in terms of our emissions for agriculture, farmers would use the technology such as GasAbate or other technologies to get it recognised. That is an essential part of the relationship with the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA. The agency recognises this technology within its national inventory. Instead of a farmer being X, it is actually X minus 78%. That is the first part. That helps our corporate clients bring it into their supply chains. The other part of that is reducing the capital costs and the ongoing cost to farmers. It delivers a societal benefit, so that benefit should be shared across the supply chain not just with the farmer, but sit with on the regulatory capacity and the processors that actually take and sell that product. That can be verified and validated within the market as well.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in and for their opening statements. I have questions for GlastPort Bio. I thank them for their presentation. I hear regularly from farmers that they are willing to invest in new technology where they can see a clear benefit, but they need certainty, naturally enough. The system and the science behind it sounds great. If I were a farmer, I would be thinking about it. It is great and reduces methane by 78%, which is fabulous, but if I spend hard-earned cash on it, will that reduction count for anything for me in future regulation such as carbon schemes, persistent targets, CAP supports, eco-schemes or national climate targets?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

The Deputy's question is totally in line with the previous question. We fully accept, and it should be accepted, that the cost burden of reducing the environmental footprint of food production should not remain on the sector that is operating at the lowest margin: the farmer. If we are going to scale these technologies and validate these technologies, we need to use the mechanisms and the policy approach that shares the cost out. We are very proud of the fact that farmers want our technology. That is a fantastic place to be. If you are going to adopt these technologies, the farmer must pull the chain and the regulation must push it. If the regulation is pushing and the farmer is pushing it in the opposite direction, it is not going to go anywhere. All of the farmers that have our technology, and it is a matter of public record, talk about reduced agitation, less odour and believing in the science that we are bringing forward showing a reduction in a chemical fertiliser requirement. It also talks to water quality and whatnot. They also want to be on the right side of regulation.

They look to the Netherlands and see the draconian regulations being placed on Dutch farmers today where they are being forced out of production. That is what scares the agricultural industry, not just at farm level but throughout processing level around making future investments as will the cows be there, will be the beef be there in terms of them maintaining those investments. This is about an industry-wide approach and allowing these technologies that the cost burden does not sit with farmers. From my perspective, the policy position should be simple. If an Irish farmer invests in a technology that demonstrates that it reduces the carbon footprint of food, and we can independently verify that, we should find a policy way of recognising and rewarding that farmer. That is why we are here today to say there is an urgent need not only to support the investment in research and development in Ireland, but also support the next wave of scaling out onto farms.

Comment on this

In the opening statement, it was stated that the development of technology is one challenge, but deploying that technology across thousands of farms in another. Is that going to be an issue going forward as regards the deployment across farms in Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

Not if we have the right policy landscape. What we take great pride in is we are not telling a farmer what they have been doing for the past 30 years is wrong. We are telling a farmer that he has a large tank of nutrients there. Every day he stores that, a lot of those nutrients, whether it is methane, ammonia or hydrogen sulfide, which are valuable crop nutrients, are disappearing out of that. If they put in our technology, it retains that. It also delivers a real regulatory benefit. It will allow farmers to maintain production. It will allow Irish farmers, as they should be, to grow their productive capacity while reducing their environmental footprint.

Comment on this

It would be a fabulous system going forward, if it can be sold to the farmers and if it comes as a cost they can afford.

Going back to the virtual fencing, there were 10,000 customers in Norway. Someone mentioned 250 in Ireland. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

There are over 10,000 customers globally.

Comment on this

In Norway.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

In the world.

Comment on this

There are 250 in Ireland. I presume it is along the west coast.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

A lot of it is along the west coast. A lot of farmers have availed of the ACRES grant, which is in eight regional areas across Ireland, but is predominantly along the west coast. A lot of the areas are upland commonage areas. That is where the groundwork is. There are over 2,000 cattle collars and over 1,000 sheep and doe collars across Ireland.

Comment on this

The Burren in my county of Clare was mentioned. Is virtual fencing being used there?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

We do. A lot of farmers down there are using it. We had over 75 applicants up to July 2026 who applied for the collars through the Burren and the Aran Islands.

Comment on this

That is fabulous. Is there a company that sets up this for the farmers? How do the collars work?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

It is a pretty simple system. Basically, the farmer orders the collars and they are delivered to the farmer. The farmer downloads an app on the phone. He puts the collars onto the animals in a crush, and draws out his paddocks and virtual fence boundaries onto the app on his phone. He then puts the animals out into a paddock, which is a training paddock, for seven days. This is where the animals get trained up onto the system. He draws his virtual fence boundary around the perimeter of the field. Over those seven days, the virtual fence boundary is moved so that the animals get used to and become accustomed to the audio cue and the mild pulse that they get after, as well as the invisible boundary after that. After the seven days, the animals have been trained up onto the system. The farmer can then upload the collars or wherever he wants to put the cows into whichever field he has. The collars will automatically be uploaded to that virtual fence boundary. That will keep them contained within that field. The farmer has collars and the app on his phone. Nothing else is needed.

Comment on this

There are three different types of collar. One for goats, one for sheep and one for other animals.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

There is a cattle collar and the sheep and goat collar is the same.

Comment on this

The sheep and goat collar is the same. Going back to training in new animals, if they have been trained in once and we let other animals in with them, will the new animals be trained in for seven days as well?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

You train in the other animals before you upload them to the animals that are already trained onto the system.

What we have found is that when new animals join the group and with the existing animals that are trained up, herd mentality kicks in. There is a leader in each group or herd, which might be an animal that is always pushing the boundary. Once the other animals hear that animal get the audio cue, they know they are near the boundary, and they do not even push the boundary themselves. After the training period, 96% of the time is audio cue only. Once the animal hears that audio cue, she knows she is near the boundary, and she will turn around because she stays in the pasture.

Comment on this

The whole lot is controlled by an app on the phone.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Yes.

Comment on this

It is as simple as that.

Comment on this

No more breaking out of cattle.

Comment on this

I call Deputy Newsome Drennan.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I will start with the GasAbate. How long is it in operation?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

We started the commercialisation journey 12 to 14 months ago. By the end of this year, we will have 100 installs across eight to ten member states across Europe.

Comment on this

Will the witnesses explain how more fertiliser value is retained?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Normally during storage, the nutrients in the slurry are being decomposed and lost to the atmosphere as gases. What GasAbate does is it pauses that decomposition process and therefore retains the nutrients and carbon value in the slurry. That applies to its value for anaerobic digestion as much as it does for agriculture. A study was published just this year by Queen's University Belfast based on a pig slurry trial. We are seeing dry matter yield from a grass experiment increase by 21% compared with normal storage slurry. The impact from a fertilising point of view is very significant. That is not only because we are retaining the nutrients in the slurry, but it also the slower biodegradation when it goes onto land. It means that it much better available to plants and less likely to run off into water.

Comment on this

What is it exactly? Does it go down into the slurry tank? How does it work?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Our installation is a network of pipes that are installed. It does not have to be a new tank. It can be retrofitted into an existing tank. It is a fully automatic dosing system for liquid. It goes in at about three to four litres per tonne of slurry. The system has a number of sensors. It knows how much slurry is in the tank, when to dose and how much to dose. Farmer essentially does not have to do anything.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Yes, it is ongoing intermittently. Depending on the temperature and the time of year, it could be once every one or two weeks that it gets its little dose in of the formulation.

Comment on this

There is less harm then when the farmer goes to activate and put out the slurry.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

That risk from a health and safety point of view, and we see farm fatalities still throughout the EU every year, is removed. We then have the ease of agitation, and the slurry is a lot easier to take out of the tank by the farmer.

Comment on this

Regarding the farms that it is installed in, was that a trial? Did they pay for that themselves? How long are they using that? With methane and all the measurements, were measurements done the year before how much methane was being produced? Have any follow-up measurements been done to see how good it is? If so and there is proof there for it, is that something that should be looking for part funding from the environment Department if it is going to help us meet our targets?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Absolutely. My colleagues have mentioned the same thing. For the technologies that are going to be supported - and we hope that they are - not only should they be deployed, but they have to be capable of recording the data to show that not only are they in the farm, but they are doing what they are supposed to do. Our system captures that data and records it. Regarding the demonstrations, the first farm we went on to was the Shinagh Estates dairy farm in west Cork. We are on farm now for four years. They supported trials. We were looking at what happened before and after. For the papers that we have published, we have to have trials running side by side. There will be tanks with one that is treated and one that is not. We are measuring and recording the emissions all the time. Similar with the slurry afterwards for its value and anaerobic digestion or its fertiliser value, we have to have that direct comparison for the papers. Regarding the farms, it is absolutely possible to go out and quantify the impact of the insulation.

Comment on this

Everything comes down to cost.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

Very much so. To add to what Professor O'Flaherty said in relation to scientific efficacy because it is a key point, being able to have one's technology scientifically robust, being able to monitor and verify its use on the farm and being able to say that there is no residual impact is a very important part for farmers that we are not going to damage their soils. Our active ingredient has shown scientifically to break down into oxygen and water. We do not just do those trials ourselves. We have given our technology to the largest food manufacturers globally and the largest diary processors. They take it independently and verify it.

On the cost side, we are looking at 0.5 cent a litre for a typical Irish dairy farm to make the technology cost neutral. One thing I wish to point out is that typically TAMS is a capital cost support. It supports the initial capital cost on farms. A lot more technologies have a level of capital costs and then a recurring revenue theme to them. What we call our measure, record and verification, MRV, system is a fully auditable and remote system that the farmer does not need to touch. That typically costs between €12,500 and €15,000 to put onto a farm. For some larger farms, it may be a little bit more. Typically, the reoccurring revenue of the solution and the additive is between 0.4 and 0.5 of a cent per litre of every litre of milk produced depending on the yield of the cow.

Comment on this

The initial cost is a one-off.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

That is a one-off and then it is a reoccurring additive cost. That is where there is probably a technical issue around TAMS because TAMS only supports capital measures. It is not designed to support reoccurring revenue measures on farms.

Comment on this

Before I go to the next speaker, I have one or two very quick questions because I am trying to get my head around what might be in the technology or how it might work on the ground. The collars are on the livestock out on the hill. Is there a signal going from the collar to a satellite or to a phone network or to where?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Both. The satellite and the GPS keep the animals contained within the virtual boundary. Each collar has a subscriber identity module, SIM, in it. In Ireland, it reports to Three, Eir or Vodafone. That is where it updates the collar's live location and the tracking of the animal.

Comment on this

Do the collars require recharging? Is it a one-off cost in getting set up? If a farmer is using a satellite or phone network, is there a cost to engage with the satellite or phone network?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Our cattle collar has a double-sided solar panel. They will come charged. Once the collars are out on pasture, it will be constantly charged from the solar panel. With the new collars that we have, they will keep charged basically all year round. We still supply a charger. If a farmer wants to charge his collars and maybe he has them taken off the animals if they are in the shed and wants a quick recharge, the charger will charge them back up. There are two options. Generally, a solar panel keeps them charged all year round.

On the costing, there is a fixed cost for the hardware. That is when the farmer buys the collar. He owns the collar. The first year is included in the initial price. After that, there is a subscription. That is where the farmer pays for the workings of the app, using the app, using the satellite and any software updates that come within the company. It is automatically added.

Comment on this

Does the user own the satellite? Does they have certainty with the satellite? Can somebody switch it off as we have seen with other technology? We know, for example, that GPS moves. The owner of GPS has the capability of making changes on that. I am trying to figure out regarding field boundaries. Can they move if the GPS owner wishes to move them?

I typically associate fencing with keeping out rather than keeping in. One farmer's livestock will have collar, and their neighbours will not have collars unless they are subscribers. Will the fence keep out other livestock from a farmer's land or how do they manage?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

On the satellite question, the system uses different satellite constellations that it can connect to. If one goes down, it can connect to another one. That is extremely rare. In any case, if there was to be a massive outage or something like that, there are emergency options whereby the farmer can go to the farm and connect to the collar by Bluetooth and take any necessary measures that way.

Comment on this

I am thinking of Bluetooth because I would use a headset and Bluetooth and my phone is quite close. On the hill, there are several miles between my phone and the Bluetooth device. What is the range? I would normally associate my headset with the phone being in another part of the house rather than being several miles away from me.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

I think the Bluetooth range is a few hundred metres. It is quite a lot right now.

Comment on this

What about the idea of fencing?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

Right now, it keeps the animals that wear the collars contained in the fence. It does not keep animals that are outside in or out.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

On that, it is important to note that if an animal ever escapes or a predator come in, the fact that there is no physical boundary, especially with sheep and dog attacks, allows animals to escape. Farmers will get an immediate notification on their phones telling them there are escapees. They will know there is something wrong and can check the app to see exactly where the animals are if they are in a mountain area or something like that. Farmers can then readjust boundaries to say that animals will be contained again.

From the outside in, if an animal escapes it can come back into the pasture and does not receive any audio cue at all. It is a one-way system on the way out when the animal receives an audio cue. If an animal ever escapes and wants to come back to the rest of the herd, she can walk straight back through the boundary and the farmer will get a notification on their phone telling them that the animal has returned to pasture. The animal is then reset back into the contained pasture.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. It is very impressive technology. The future is definitely very interesting. Virtual fencing is particularly interesting and will revolutionise farming in the future. In terms of value for money, how does that compare with conventional farming over a five- or ten-year period? Where does it benchmark currently?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

That depends on the characteristics of the farm. There is a series of important cost savings that a farmer can achieve. One is physical fencing, which is quite expensive. There is electric fencing. Feed can be very expensive. Farmers can access new pastures and manage their pastures more efficiently. The whole idea is that we do not want to implement a system to do the same management farmers were doing before, but rather improve it.

Comment on this

Mr. Mazin referred to rotational grazing.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

Yes, rotational grazing and this kind of thing.

Comment on this

How do the economics of this compare over a five- or ten-year period, rotational grazing aside?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

We have done some modelling and have calculated that the net saving after implementation can range from €70 to €110 per year per cow.

Comment on this

Nofence is currently operating in Ireland. Can it replace boundary fencing in its entirety? Is that currently happening under the existing technology?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

As I said, farmers are using it in commonage areas as boundary fencing to keep animals contained and off roads. Those farmers are based on the Wild Atlantic Way and had trouble with tourist traffic and so on. A farmer told us it is the best thing ever. He received numerous phone calls throughout the day telling him his sheep were on the road and were being knocked down by cars. He now has them contained and does not have to worry about them at all. Mr. McKenna has used our collars for five years and is the proof of the pudding.

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick McKenna

Yes, I have used it on Sliabh Beagh, which is an upland area in north County Monaghan. It is invaluable. Since EU directives on birds came in 20 years ago, physical fencing is prohibited in the relevant SPAs and SACs. The only way we can do fire mitigation and conservation grazing in that area is by using Nofence and collars. I have used them for four or five years and find them invaluable.

Comment on this

Going back to rotational grazing, strip grazing and so on, how accurate is the GPS? How precise can it be within a large paddock and those divided into smaller paddocks?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

We are using it on our farm at the moment for strip grazing on replacement heifers. On our farm, the system works within a metre. It can vary. Farmers use it to graze scrub in dense forestry. The boundary there can vary from 2 m to 4 m, but the farmer has to adjust for that. Dense forestry can sometimes cause an issue. In pastures and strip grazing, it works within a metre. Automated moves are tracked on the collars. A farmer can schedule a boundary move by an acre each day or whatever. It allows farmers to farm like that.

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick McKenna

My experience is that it works within 1 m. Last week on the farm I looked at the app and the cattle were about 1 m from the roadway. The app showed they were 1 m from the roadway.

Comment on this

In terms of reliability and charging, going back to the question from the Chair, can solar power them all year round, even in the winter?

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick McKenna

My experience this year has been that I have had cattle grazing for three months. They went up with 100% charge. When I look at the app I can see how much charge is on each collar. The last day I looked at the app, the collars has a charge of 97% or 95%. The lowest was 87%. They are constantly charging. I am using a collar I purchased five years ago, which was the initial collar. The collar being sold now, and for which funding under TAMS is being sought, is a dual solar panel collar. Mine has a single solar panel but the new collars have a dual solar panel. I imagine the charge would be 95% to 100% most of the time.

Comment on this

In terms of reliability and the signal, if the network goes down, what happens? It is operated on a phone network.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Yes. The collars we have now have satellite capability. Farmers with areas of no coverage or signal use satellite and that is how the live update and tracking of animals comes from satellite capability. If a farmer has any signal at all, it will work.

Comment on this

In many respects, there is an immediate benefit for the farmer. With this technology, it appears that the benefit is for the environment, State and future generations. Is there a significant direct payoff for the farmer? It was mentioned that there is a fertiliser benefit and so on. What is the return on investment from a farmers' perspective, without current funding?

Comment on this
Mr. John McCarthy

The Deputy's point on the State benefit is where a lot of this lies. IFAC and the Climate Change Advisory Council have referred to our failure to hit climate legislation costing the State between €8 billion and €26 billion. This is primarily where this technology sits. There is a cost to this, but there is also a cost to doing nothing, as IFAC has clearly identified to the State.

To get people out of diesel engine cars and into electric cars, the State, based on our figures, is currently paying about €770 per tonne of carbon abated. To roll out heat pumps into households costs about €170 per tonne of carbon abated. If our technology was grant aided by 60%, it would be €15 per tonne of carbon abated to protect our largest indigenous sector in rural Ireland, that is, our food exports. That is where the benefit to the State lies.

On the benefit to farmers, to initiate these initial technologies and in terms of scaling, the vast bulk of the alleviation of the cost of our technology needs to be delivered to them through a sustainability payment. All of the co-ops currently have sustainability payments and schemes. Arla has €550 million it pays back to farmers for adopting sustainability measures.

That is what they will use as a lever to drive our technology out on the farms. We do not come here to say that we think the farmer should pay for our technology; actually, it is the opposite. That is always a very funny sales proposition to take but the vast value of our technology goes back to the farmer. We do believe that farmers will adopt our technology positively and it will be a non-transitory technology in that it will stay on farms and deliver the emission reductions every year because there will be a real tangible benefit to the farmer at probably around 30% of the overall cost of the technology to the farmer from reduced agitation.

Comment on this

I had to leave to vote. I hate this scenario because I could be repeating something that was addressed while I was away. The question I was waiting to ask was about GasAbate. The witnesses tore off into the benefits of it and kept referring to it as technology. I know what it is, but for somebody who is watching, what is it? Is it an additive? Is it a food additive? Is it a gadget? Is it equipment? Maybe the witnesses have answered that while I was away, but I was very conscious of the fact that before I went it was just referred to as technology. There was an assumption that we would all know exactly what it is, and they gave us the benefits but what actually is it? If it has been asked while I was away, we can move on.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

No, it would be useful to summarise it. We touched on some of the characteristics. Essentially, it is two things: It is an additive that is dosed into the slurry in a very small volume, 3 litres or 4 litres per tonne of slurry, and it is also the control system and the data acquisition box to monitor that the thing is being implemented correctly and to work out how much should be dosed. The slurry tank is instrumented so we know how much slurry is in there and we can ensure we are dosing correctly. The machine self-reports so when the tank needs to be replaced it sends out that signal and we capture that data on the farm. It is not only the additive that is the bit that goes into the slurry, but the overall impact is the additive plus the sort of really robust auditable implementation of the measure. It is the two things together that form GasAbate.

In terms of what the additive is, we use a solution that causes a chemical reaction in the slurry and it generates oxygen and water and nothing else.

Comment on this

When that additive goes into the tank, is there a need for agitation or can it do its job going into a fairly solid tank of slurry?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

It does indeed. Yes. It self-disperses in the slurry tank. We have installed on outdoor lagoons and big tanks of up to 5,000 cu. m or 6,000 cu. m, as well as underfloor slatted tanks. One of the benefits around the agitation is because we are introducing the additive at the base, it does stir up, it self-disperses in the slurry, and that means you do not get that sort of caking of the slurry. One farmer said that it was the first time he saw the bottom of the tank in years after emptying the slurry out after the application. One of the key benefits is that you do not have that dead zone in the tanks and all of the slurry volume is available.

Comment on this

Without getting over-scientific, we will stick to methane for a second, because I have a reason for that. In terms of the reduction, where does the methane go? It might sound like a contradictory sort of question but what I am coming at is if I have a tank of slurry and I use the additive, and I get the methane reduction we are talking about, I assume then, if I got the opportunity to send the slurry to an anaerobic digester or biomethane centre, it would be pointless, or does it still have the value once it goes there? If so, where is the methane in the interim?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Where the methane comes from is we have proteins, sugars and other materials in the slurry and microbes in the slurry attack that, break it down and produce the gas. What we do is we stop the last bit - the gas production - so that the proteins, organic acids and the other composition in the slurry stay there but because we do not have any residual carryover - it is only oxygen and water - when we take the slurry and go to the anaerobic digester, we essentially have the biogas value of fresh slurry. We are not adding anything; we are preserving the nature of the fresh slurry. We are stopping it decomposing to the gas. That is exactly what we do. Under normal circumstances, we would have this decomposition over time, with the nutrients and the carbon being lost - the carbon dioxide and methane. We stop that. It is maybe a little bit analogous to a food preservation idea - to stop the biodegradation, such that when you then put it into your biogas plant, you retain the value.

Comment on this

And the smell is being reduced.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Hugely.

Comment on this

Even when it is agitated. If I am treating my tank over the winter, when the spring comes I agitate and spread it and the smell is gone.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Yes. One of the outputs of the work published by the Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute in Northern Ireland, was that it looked at the emissions upon agitation, which is a really important health and safety impact. We saw that we did not just prevent the emissions during the storage, but that when it was mixed, we also prevented that plume of emissions that can be very dangerous upon agitation. That is an important benefit.

Comment on this

In a roundabout sort of way, I have got to what I was going to say. We have a lot of problems with biogas anaerobic digesters because of smell. If we combine this technology with the slurry, that is a reduction of smell at the anaerobic digester end as well.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Hugely so.

Comment on this

Is it not something we should be looking at where we have objections to anaerobic digestion that one of the planning conditions would be that the slurry would need to be treated with something like this? That would reduce the smell.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

Where we also see that is an area we have not talked about. We are also active in the pig sector. We have a large-scale pig farm down in Waterford with 550 sows, with all progeny taken through to finish, where all of the slurry is treated with GasAbate. Thanks to a grant that we got from the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, SEAI, that farmer has also backed in an anaerobic digester into that farm where the stored pig slurry is going into an anaerobic digester. Typically, as Professor O'Flaherty said, pig slurry is not seen as a good feedstock for anaerobic digestion, AD, because when it is stored in warm temperatures, all the biomethane disappears. We stop that biomethane from being produced but then when it goes into an anaerobic digester, we get the increased yield.

Comment on this

I am sorry, Chair, I need just one second. I am sorry I did not get to the other witnesses. I agree with Deputy Aird. It is a revolutionary idea. They are preaching to the converted. I do not need to ask more. I had one question and it was kind of covered, as I came in when Deputy Lawless was asking questions.

I got a robotic lawnmower during the year. For the first time, three days ago, it refused to go out in the morning because of the fog. If the system is on a phone signal, that is not going to be an issue for the collars. I was thinking of it. I wondered if I had collars today, if the cattle would be gone west because they could not get the signal because of the foggy morning. I heard the answer to Deputy Lawless that it is on a phone signal, which answered my question, as such. That is the only issue I would have raised.

Comment on this

The Senator has an automatic lawnmover now. He wore out his wife.

Comment on this

I am too busy. I am here. I am too busy to be mowing the lawn.

Comment on this

I thank both witnesses for their opening statements. I have a couple of questions The first is in regard to the additive and what they are doing with the slurry. I take it that they are mainly targeting it at the larger, more intensive farming such as dairy and that type of enterprise. In that context, if we take a 300-cow dairy farm, a large portion of the gases that are going to be emitted from it will be emitted from the slurry, but a large portion of gases are also emitted by the cattle grazing when they are belching and feeding outside of that. Could the witnesses give us a breakdown of what percentage of the gases emitted from a farm of that nature would be from the slurry portion of it?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

We would probably be targeting maybe 11% or 12% - that type of ballpark in terms of the methane impact. What we would be doing is targeting, let us say, 80% of that. In terms of the overall greenhouse gas reduction target, let us say if it is 25%, we are in the zone of targeting 8% or 9% of that.

Comment on this

So it is 8% or 9% of the overall gas that we produce.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

Yes, of the overall footprint.

Comment on this

It could be somewhat misleading for people to think that they are getting rid of 70% of all the gases produced on the farm. They are not. The witnesses have not suggested that, but it is important to clarify that.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

The accessible target for us is that sort of figure.

Comment on this

That sort of figure.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

To put that into context, for a typical 100-cow dairy farm in an Irish context where there is grazing, the Deputy was quite right in his opening statement. Where our technology would have a major impact is where cows are in all year round because there would be about 30 tonnes of manure per cow and it could be upwards of 20% of their overall emissions. In a typical Irish scenario, it would be less. As Professor O'Flaherty said, it would be 11% or 12% for a typical Irish farm. We have farms in west Cork with 50 or 60 cows, but for a typical 100-cow farm we are taking about 40 tonnes of carbon out of their supply, which is equivalent to taking nine to ten cars off the road. That is to give the Deputy some context.

On the Continent, where cattle are kept in all the time, it would have a much bigger impact than on the model of farming we have in Ireland.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

We are probably taking about 350 kg to 400 kg of carbon out of a typical Irish grass-based dairy. When we go to Europe, we are taking about 1.4 tonnes out for an intensive dairy system, just by the sheer fact that there is more slurry on those farms.

Comment on this

Deputy Lawless asked an interesting question. The production of the gases is being inhibited through an additive. The gases are then available later if they go into biodigestion. When they are spread on the land, are they then open to be produced? What happens then? I would like to get at the idea that the gas is preserved, we stop it from being released in the slurry tank but when it is spread, does nature release it again?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

That is an excellent point. The amount of methane that is produced from soil application is very low. The reason for that is during the spreading process, there is exposure to oxygen, much as we have in the slurry tank with the GasAbate system. That stops the methane being produced. From a methane point of view, we do not risk swapping the source of the pollution by using the GasAbate technology. When the slurry goes out onto the land, it is broken down in the soil. That is important because that is where the nutrients become available for the plant and grass growth. When we think about the greenhouse gas footprint or the methane footprint, there is not a risk in that sense. We know from Irish and international studies that the bulk of the methane emission from the slurry comes during storage.

Comment on this

The additive costs approximately 0.5 cent per litre of milk that is produced on a dairy farm. The cost would probably be prohibitive on a beef farm, for instance. We know from Teagasc reports every year that there is a vast difference between the two in the level of profitability. Deputy Aird will be much more attuned to this than me, but I know from listening to dairy farmers that when the price of milk goes up even by 0.5 cent or 1 cent, it is a big thing. The additive seems quite expensive from that point of view. I am not saying it is prohibitive. If the benefit is there, it is there. We just need an assessment as to what the benefit is and how much value for money it provides.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

In all these emission reduction technologies, it comes down to the cost per tonne of carbon abated, whether we are taking carbon out from transport, energy or agriculture. We would be very cost-effective per tonne of carbon abated out of the atmosphere. That is where valourisation comes in, from a national and public policy perspective. Typically, Irish co-ops today have between 0.5 cent and 1 cent per litre of sustainability bonus payments for different measures and whatnot. We would sit within that. I agree with the Deputy's point that it is not going to work for a farmer to use our technology without being valourised, without getting acknowledgement for it, whether it be from a meat factory or a dairy processor. We should be clear on that. It is the same in respect of a lot of other emission reduction technologies. The biggest gain of our technology is reducing a gas that a farmer cannot see or smell.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. I have met the guys from Nofence previously. It is a great job, especially for dairy farmers. I know there is debate about the outside and inside element. Under TB rules, farmers are supposed to have a fence so that cattle cannot go in or out. Unless their neighbour is at it, it could be a problem. For dairy farmers strip grazing, they can do their screen every day, is it the ideal thing, or for other farmers if they are handling sheep the same way, or cattle. If we were to add this system up in price, putting in a proper fence with sheep wire and barbed wire, how much dearer or cheaper would it be over time?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Our system comes with a ten-year warranty so it is a long-term investment. The one thing about using our collars as fencing is that they are mobile. The farmer can move the collars from field to field and set up all the pastures. With fencing----

Comment on this

When a farmer fences his land, it costs him a lot of money. There is a good TAMS grant for sheep wire and barbed wire and the stakes, and there is 20 years if they do it. If we put like with like, how does it work out over that period?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

In the case of cattle calculations, taking everything into account, we have fencing but also cost reductions through feed and, potentially, fuel, because the farmer may have to spend less time looking for the sheep. We calculated that the cost reduction, for cattle in this case, would be €70 to €110 net savings per cow per year.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Mazin.

My next question is for the GasAbate representatives. Can they give me an outline? Do we put in a 4 inch pipe and it blows it out? How does it send the stuff out? Is there a pump sending air around? I want a vision of how it works. If a farmer has that system, does he have to agitate the slurry?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

It is not a 4 inch pipe but a narrow set of pipes that are going in with a distribution nozzle, maybe over 4 m or 5 m.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

They are at the base of the tank. We can retrofit, go in half full or whatever, but it is on the floor of a typical slatted tank. Every 4 m or 5 m there is a distribution nozzle. The liquid is pumped in.

Comment on this

Like the chlorine pump, to put it simply.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

That is not a million miles off. It is a slower dose system but conceptually the Deputy is on the right track. It goes into the nozzle and self-disperses up through the slurry. Outside, there is a manifold that will split the dose along the pumping line, a dosing pump and a set of monitors that are linked to sensors, the slurry volume depth and so on. The whole thing sits in a----

Comment on this

Will one rig-out do, if someone had three or four slatted tanks in different places? There are other systems a farmer might need, including a second unit. Will one pumping unit do the lot with a pipe system covering the rest?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

In many cases, yes. We have not been on two farms that were the same since we started this game. We cannot be absolute. Sometimes there are very big differences between the tanks. In general, if we have four, five, six or seven tanks in a reasonable farmyard-size area, one system will do.

Comment on this

Does the farmer have to agitate?

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

No. In general, the feedback from the farms we are on is that if farmers are agitating, they are doing so for a fraction of the time they used to. There is really significant feedback from farmers in that regard.

Comment on this

Mr. McCarthy will probably have the figures on this. We are talking about 100 cows so that is 12 to 15 bales with six or seven cows to the bale. What is it costing? Have the witnesses talked to the Department about TAMS? My reading of TAMS is that the officials are struggling to give grants even for solar and things at the moment. There is new technology on weighing scales now that will tell the weight of the cattle. Every time TAMS comes out, they put out something for new technologies like these but the figures are staying the same. The scale the grant is on, €1,500 or whatever, is not for something that costs €10,000. What sort of reception have the witnesses got there and what are the options?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

It is a very good question. There are 400 measures in TAMS today and not one of them is related to emissions reduction technology. One of the big challenges agriculture faces is not actually captured within TAMS.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

Not one. That is from a reply that we got. I would extend that further. As the Deputy knows better than anyone, we are spending a huge amount rightly supporting farmers and putting in new slurry tanks. There is a direct correlation between the time slurry is stored and the volumes of slurry stored, and our emissions from manure.

It is incredible we are not putting the technology, whether it is ours or anyone else's, into the new tanks. It seems a real disconnect. If we are grant-aiding the construction of a tank, we should also be grant-aiding the implementation of a proven, scientifically-verified technology to reduce the emissions of what is going into that tank. We are in the process of applying for what the Deputy said, which is the reach out for new technologies to go into TAMS. I hope we will see a more joined-up approach to emissions reduction.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman for accommodating me. I am not a member of the committee but we are allowed to come in at times. I will probably only be about three minutes.

I am a farmer. For transparency, I have Nofence collars on the farm so I thought I should contribute. I am a suckler farmer in County Clare and we have a few goats as well. I got the collars for the goats as an experiment. I have always been into technology and when there is a new iPhone or laptop, I probably want it. I decided to give it a go. The collars were not too expensive and if they worked, they worked. They were absolutely transformative, especially with the goats. They were pets and they were a bit of fun on the farm. The children breed them. We are in the organic scheme and we can send the goats to a particular area to get them working on the nettles or briars because they are not very interested in the grass. It is incredible.

The cattle do not have collars but two weeks ago I was at a county final and for the first time in years the phone rang and the neighbours said my cattle were all on the road. This had not happened in yonks but it is a disaster. I have looked at TAMS over the years and there are incredible grants for bovine electric fencing. Applicants can get barbed wire fencing if they combine it with sheep mesh but standard three-strand stock-proof barbed wire fencing is not covered by TAMS. Not everyone is on lovely Golden Vale land with linear hedgerows that can keep the cattle in. I farm pasture but there are 100 acres of commonage mountain I have to put cattle on each year. Believe it or not, for the past three consecutive years, I have lost cattle on the mountain. People will say that can happen with sheep up in the Kerry mountains but it can happen anywhere because there are bog-holes, drains and gaps and you do not know where the hell they are. Some of them come down in fantastic condition and some come down with all sorts of things wrong with them. It is a bit of pot luck. This would be transformative for farmers on really marginal land but especially those who have got to send their cattle off pasture onto the hillside during the year. It is a no-brainer. The really fabulous thing is that sometimes one or two need to be isolated. I might want to bring three or four down because they are in heat and I want to get the AI man or whatever. I can isolate them and start bringing them down so they will be near enough to the gate rather than half a mile up the top of the hill. It is incredible.

I have made the point to the Minister that it is wrong that the most basic thing for all farms, which is that they are stock-proofed so there are not livestock in the roads in this day and age, is not in TAMS. That is a major flaw. Stockproof fencing needs to be in TAMS. We have every sort of gadget and gizmo to hold ankles, ribs and necks when cattle are in a crush system but we do not have the most basic thing at all. I am an advocate for it and I am really just here to say that, but where are the witnesses at in terms of timelines? I think it is next March TAMS gets overhauled again so where are things at generally with these talks?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

We have submitted a response to the call for evidence the Department has opened. We support virtual fencing becoming eligible within TAMS 3. If we wait until the next version of TAMS, that is going to be more time during which Irish farmers are going to have limited access to the technology. In the worst-case scenario we really want to see it in the next version of TAMS. I am aware the Deputy asked a question about this of the Minister some months ago and I thank him for that. TAMS currently funds things such as heat detection devices, livestock monitoring systems, electric fencing and fence energisers. Our virtual fencing collars perform all the functions of those items. Our collars detect heat now and they contain and monitor animals. One of the policy goals is to simplify TAMS and this is a way of doing it. Over time more and more functions will be included in the technology so the potential is very big in that sense.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Mazin for that.

I did not go into the biogas but I sit on other committees and often great witnesses come in and we listen to them and go out informed. However, it does not get actioned afterwards. If I may make a suggestion as a non-member, it would be great if this committee wrote to the Minister supporting what we are hearing so this can be stitched into policy. It would be a good action for the committee to write so this can be taken on by the Minister. Thank you, Minister - I am pre-empting maybe the coming years for you. I meant thank you, Chairman, for letting me in.

Comment on this

Thank you. We have time for a second round with the same rota and six minutes each.

Comment on this

It has been answered to Deputy Fitzmaurice but are the witnesses telling me there will be no agitating? If there is no agitating on farms, that should be the number one thing going forward because the number one thing in the yard at home is the agitator. I have a lot of transition year students who are doing agriculture and I tell them it is the most disliked thing in our yard. I hate it. It is the most dangerous thing I use because I do not know when then gas comes off it. That alone solves all the problems I have regarding this one.

I want to read out all the questions I have for both sides and then we will see what time we have left. I put a lot of work into this. While the technology appears to offer environmental and operational benefits, what are the main barriers preventing wider uptake among farmers and what role could schemes such as TAMS play in overcoming those? The witnesses argued the costs and benefits or agricultural decarbonisation should be shared across the supply chain. How do they believe processors, retailers and the Government should contribute to the cost of adopting emissions-reduction technology on farms? GlasPort Bio expects commercial deployment across eight EU member states by 2027. What lessons can Ireland learn from other countries about the adoption of agricultural and climate technologies? What policy measures would help ensure Irish farmers are not left behind?

I have questions for Nofence as well. How can virtual fencing help farmers manage livestock in mountainous and coastal areas where difficult terrain, remote commonage and exposure to the elements can make traditional fences costly or impractical? Mr. McKenna might answer that in a second. How could the expanded use of virtual fencing on targeted high-risk areas assist with the growing threat of wildfires on Irish hills and uplands? What advantage does virtual fencing offer as a practical tool for sustainable land management? With only 4.3% of Irish farm holders under 35 years of age, what role do the witnesses believe labour-saving technologies such as virtual fencing can play in attracting younger people into farming and improving farmers' work-life balance? Can the witnesses provide further detail on grant supports offered for virtual fencing in other jurisdictions?

I have only three and a half minutes so I will split it between both companies.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

I hope I touch on all the Deputy's points in my answer. On the retailers, it goes exactly to the point he makes; for technology like this to have an impact and to scale, the cost burden and the policy landscape needs to share the dividends right across the supply chain, that is, from the farm to the processor to the food manufacturer and from a regulatory point of view.

From a regulatory point of view, it is critical the technology is recognised for its reductions when we are calculating the emission-reduction targets for Irish agriculture. That is one of the biggest challenges we are facing by 2030. We have a legally binding commitment to get to 25% and we are sitting at about 4.2%. We are in a very difficult position. Processors are going for planning permission and suddenly we are falling well foul of those targets.

That is a real issue. We need to amolish this argument that the way to achieve those targets is to keep less cows or produce less.

Comment on this

That is not going to happen.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

That is a fallacy. What have we learned? This is what we have learned from our roll-out across Europe. We have only started it since the start of this year. We have been in a lab and a test tube since 2018. We just started our commercial deployment in the past 12 to 18 months. The key thing we have learned is that if we make a technology attractive to farmers, farmers will want that technology. However, making it attractive is having that regulatory and cost aspect. Farmers love the fact, as the Deputy talked about, of the agitation and the odour. Neighbours are not giving out anymore. For pig farmers, that is a huge planning application point of view. I hope I have covered everything and not taken too much of the guys' time.

Comment on this

That is grand.

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick McKenna

On the conservation of wildfires, they are both two sides of the same sword, if the Deputy knows what I mean. I am doing conservation grazing on Sliabh Beagh, which I am doing up there courtesy of An Taisce, but I am also doing wildfire mitigation. Under the ACRES co-operation, I am doing targeted molinia grazing. Molinia is the grass that grows very rapidly during the summer. At the end of the summer then, it dies off and turns into a tinder about a foot and a half high and lays there all winter. Come springtime, that tinder is sitting on the mountain ready to go on fire. Someone might come up and have a barbecue or go fishing and throw a cigarette out of a window and bang, the whole mountain burns. Thousands of acres burn. What we are doing is targeting areas close to car parks and lakes where there are a lot of people and a lot of tourists with the possibility of people lighting a fire or staying overnight. We graze those areas, particularly in the south west where the prevailing wind comes from. We graze those areas. We try to graze that molinia grass off, particularly in July, August and September, so that we are left with a nice sward of greener grass and that tinder burden does not endure then over the winter.

The second side of it is that molinia grass and that burden of tinder that is left over the winter degrades the habitat. On Sliabh Beagh, the protected species is the hen harrier. The hen harrier is up in the air looking down on this carpet of tinder and it cannot see through it. It cannot predate in those areas. The cattle get in there. I used to take the cattle up there. They create small pathways through that. Little areas of scrub are left but we also have level ground for the little voles and other little animals the hen harrier feeds on. It will see them scooting about. It does not have this blanket of tinder. That is the conservation aspect of it. We are doing two things. We are reducing the wildfire risk but we are also improving the habitat for the hen harrier. That is the strategy we are using on Sliabh Beagh.

Comment on this

Mr. McKenna put his money in his pocket. Would he tell other farmers to do the same?

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick McKenna

Yes, 100%. Deputy Crowe, who just left, endorsed it and I would endorse it wholeheartedly. I find it invaluable.

Comment on this

That is fair enough. Fair play to Mr. McKenna.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy. I call Deputy Newsome Drennan.

Comment on this

No offence; I have met the witnesses and spoken to them. It is a brilliant idea. Some of us will need training when it does get rolled out. It will be quite valuable for horses as well. We train the foals to avoid the electric wire. We would lead them up to it. It is dangerous but, anyway, we would lead the horses up to it-----

Comment on this

I swear to God, this is what we did. We would lead the foals up to the electric wire and they would get a little shock. They would be inquisitive and they would tip it. That would teach them not to go back again. However, older horses with rugs on would go through the electric fence because the rug was breaking the electric shock. With this, it does not matter if they are wearing a rug or not. It would be brilliant if it was rolled out there as well.

On the idea of sheep going missing, how long is it? We know there are a lot of sheep getting robbed. If the collar was gone off a sheep or lamb or whatever, how long is it? After how long does it detect an animal is laying down with the collar on. It alerts people that they are not moving or laying down for a long time.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

With regard to no movement, it is four hours of no movement of the animal. Then, the farmer gets a notification saying, "No movement". With regard to reduced activity, the animal is still moving but its activity has reduced in comparison to its average daily movement. With regard to theft, we get a lot of inquiries from farmers in the west about sheep theft, which is a big problem. Where we see with this is that the minute the sheep or cattle or whichever cross the boundary, the farmer will be notified of escapees. As I said, the farmer looks at the app on his phone. If they are gone, wherever the collars are, he or she can track that exact location down to wherever. If they are harmed or whatever, he or she can track the exact location of the collars.

Comment on this

That is brilliant. If the network is down, that is obviously an issue. Our dog did not wear a dog collar for the final couple of years of his life because he knew not to go out unless we were down there and called him out. Animals are quite clever. We do not give them enough credit. Obviously, if farmers are strip grazing and moving animals, that is a little bit different. If the network is down, we are in a bit of bother.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

The containment actually works through satellite. If the mobile network is down, the app will not be connected to the collars but the containment - the fence - will still be maintained through satellite. That is how our system has always worked but now with our new cattle collar, when the mobile network is down, we have a fallback option, which is also satellite, such as Starlink and these kinds of systems, whereby the collar will be able to connect with the phone and the app even where there is zero mobile coverage or the network is down.

Comment on this

That is perfect. For off-farm work, let us face it, especially with suckler farming, it is not practical unless people have a huge farm. It is not practical to not have a job off farm. It will be absolutely brilliant that people can track their cattle on their phones. It will be brilliant.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

One of the things we have seen is that 43% of farmers have off-farm jobs. That is a lot of our customers. It allows them to get closer tracking and monitoring of the animals because a lot of these farmers may be suckler farmers and like to maybe AI their animals. With the heat detection now on the collars as well and watch mode, it notifies the farmers of animals that have come into heat so then, when they go home in the evenings from the off-farm jobs, they can bring in those animals for heat collection and calving collection as well.

Comment on this

That alone will save where people are bringing in cattle and injecting them to come into heat. That will save money, time and effort. It is more natural as well. It is very good. I will back the witnesses 100% on this.

In what other areas would the witnesses like to see that grant? Would they like to see it at 40 % or more or a bigger grant for a smaller few collars and then the more collars they get, the lesser the grant? What is proposed?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

We see examples that go from 40%, which is normally the lowest that governments have been giving. We have seen examples of up to 80% and 90%. The more support that is given, the more help the farmer gets. The main challenge right now is that physical fencing is covered while virtual fencing is not, so even where farmers want to adopt the digital solution, not just as a containment but for all the other benefits, they are currently disincentivised to do so. Even so, 250 farmers in Ireland have implemented it already. If we were to go into the TAMS, it would become a mainstream technology in Irish farming. In Norway, where there have been grants and where we have been present, obviously, for the longest, since 2018, around half of farmers use virtual fencing.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Newsome Drennan. I call Deputy Lawless.

Comment on this

I am very impressed. I have been researching and studying virtual fencing for a while.

I will certainly support this. I come from County Mayo, which has a lot of commonage, including uplands and so on. Mr. McKenna spoke well about how it is happening. The National Parks and Wildlife Service, NPWS, has different trials at the moment, in Nephin in particular. Is Nofence working with the NPWS? Is the NPWS currently using Nofence collars? How is it going in the commonage trials?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Yes, it is currently using our sheep and goat collars and cattle collars and it has bought a lot more collars in recent weeks so it will continue to use our collars. We have been inundated in recent weeks with a big order from the NPWS.

Comment on this

What is the biggest barrier to adoption?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

For a lot of farms, margins are tight. The interest is massive but farmers need support with a grant like TAMS to adopt this technology because they can see the benefits of it for their farms. It not only does virtual fencing. It allows farmers to get closer monitoring of the animals regarding heat detection and it is going towards more precision livestock management regarding calving detection and automated moves. There are a lot more benefits. Farmers can see the benefits, but margins are tight on farms and farmers need financial support to invest in it.

Comment on this

Cost is the primary barrier.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

I just wanted to mention a few examples of grants. This week, the Scottish Government announced that its mainstream TAMS-equivalent grant will include virtual fencing. It will cover between 50% and 100% depending on the farm type. North of the Border, the government has also made virtual fencing eligible. It will cover 40%. In Sweden, it is 40%. In Spain it is between 50% and 90%, depending on the autonomous community.

Comment on this

Is that of the price?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

That is how much of the price of the collar the governments will cover.

Comment on this

It is 50%.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

It is a minimum of 50% in Scotland. In Northern Ireland, it is 40%. Members should take into account that this is the hardware cost, that is, the upfront cost, which covers the hardware and first year of the subscription. From the second year onwards, the ongoing subscription is normally not eligible under these grants, with the exception of the United States of America. The United States pays for the ongoing costs, but it is an exception. The subscription cost is normally paid by the farmer.

Comment on this

In the submission, there is a comparison table of the different grants.

Comment on this

Do the witnesses see boundary fencing being replaced entirely by these fences in the future? Are there issues of public liability and insurance if an animal were to break out onto a road and so on? Have they researched that? Where does public liability insurance fall?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

We still recommend at the moment that farmers have their boundaries physically fenced for TB and so on. Our virtual fence has a 99.7% containment rate, but regarding roads and public liability, we still recommend a physical fence.

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

The truth is it also depends on the country. Some countries have in their law that there has to be a physical boundary. Other countries do not have that and many farmers do not use physical fences at all and rely only on virtual fences. I have seen farmers use it next to roads and it be effective. I can see a future where a lot of physical fencing is removed. From a conservation angle, that can be interesting in certain areas of particular natural value.

Comment on this

The GlasPort Bio request regarding TAMS is different. Where does it see the support coming from? What is its request of the Government? I do not think it is TAMS.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

It is probably TAMS for the capital expenditure, such as the hardware going into the tanks.

Comment on this

That is the piping system and the mechanisms to monitor the system.

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

Yes, and the auditable-----

Comment on this

How much is that?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

It depends on the size of farm. As was said, farms are different as regards the number of tanks, but we are probably talking about between €12,500 and €15,000 for a typical Irish farm. For some of the very big farms we are doing, it is substantially more than that. The problem is that TAMS can only cover capital costs, but more technologies that are emerging have a recurring revenue element to the solution and that cannot be covered under the schemes. Our request of the Government is the funding of the capital expenditure under TAMS and a recognition of the measures, that there is a societal benefit to reducing methane in food production and, in the same way as support is given to society to get into electric cars, there should be a mechanism for the cost burden under environmental schemes.

Comment on this

What is the cost of the actual-----

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

It works out at about 0.5 cent per litre for a dairy farm and €1.80 to €2 per pig slaughtered for intensive dairy and pigs.

Our other request is regulatory recognition because, as Professor O'Flaherty said, we have a deeply peer reviewed technology. We did not come to the committee with a finger in the air. There is a lot of independent and peer-reviewed research from across Europe of our technology. It has been validated by leading food processors at this stage, but it is a gas farmers cannot see or smell. We need support. If this technology is to scale to allow it to achieve our emissions reduction target, it needs to be recognised and accounted for in national inventory. We are asking for both, for TAMS for the cost side and regulatory recognition, so the likes of Nestlé and Danone, which buy Irish dairy produce, can make robust claims about their scope 3 emissions, so they can say they are taking produce from Irish dairy farms whose emissions are X, Y or Z. That is what the likes of those companies ask us, whether we are recognised in Ireland. We are recognised by Arla. We are not recognised in Ireland and that is a challenge to scaling.

Comment on this

I will talk about virtual fencing. For many people, it is for commonage, open mountains and areas like that in particular. For dairy farms, strip grazing is the obvious solution. On a lot of farms, people already have fences up. Certainly, the boundary fence is in place. The issue with commonages is farmers often come together to fence off areas of commonage because they are dangerous. Can this set areas so that the animals will not go near them at all? I accept what Mr. McKenna said about keeping down grasses and fire prevention and so on. We have steered away from keeping cattle on uplands traditionally and we need to look at it again in that context because it has a major role to play in fire prevention and conservation. I would like to get the witnesses' views on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick McKenna

On the first point, any area can be excluded on the app. If there is a lake - there are a few lakes on some of my grounds - I can exclude it. I can create a riparian zone around a lake that the cattle cannot get into.

On the second point, the problem with the uplands in Ireland is that since the birds directive came in, physical fencing is not permitted on a lot of them. People cannot put up new fencing there. They can repair older fencing, but new fencing is prohibited. This is where Nofence is stopping the desertion of those areas. They have become dead zones. The idea is to protect hen harriers, grouse, curlews and so on, but those animals cannot predate where the ground is covered by a layer of tinder. Nofence allows those areas to be cultivated again.

The app is hugely interactive. I have it on my phone so anyone who wants to can take a look at it after the session. It will appeal to young people. It is a hugely appealing app. There are a lot of features on it and it is being upgraded all the time. I can take the app out and spend five or ten minutes looking at new features and studying all the features.

The Deputy made the point about no movement. I look at the app once an hour. I have cattle up on Sliabh Beagh at the minute, and if an animal is not moving, I will notice it or I will get a notification. Cattle are herd animals. Of the half dozen cattle I have on Sliabh Beagh, if one of them is away from the group, any farther than, say, 50 m or 60 m, I will be looking at it. Long before I get the notification from Mr. Maher, I will be going up there to see why the animal is not moving. That is another point and another benefit.

Comment on this

The vet can be got before there is an issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick McKenna

Yes.

Comment on this

I am conscious that the witnesses are from commercial companies. We have to be aware of that because the committee cannot promote any products, but basically, we are talking about the concept here. Are there many other providers of virtual fencing in Ireland doing similar work?

Comment on this
Mr. Benjamin Mazin

Yes, there are at least three and globally there are six or seven, so we are not the only option under TAMS.

Comment on this

This is my final point on the virtual fencing. There is a cost for the collar, and then an ongoing cost every year or whatever, to sign up. What is the ballpark figure for this? I do not need the exact number, but what kind of numbers are we talking about?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

It depends, because there is a tiered system. It is around €45 per collar, per year but it can be as low as €30 per collar, per year. There is a monthly payment option as well. A lot of farmers using commonage might only need the collars for four or five months of the year, so then they would only pay €3.50 per collar, per month. They can turn off the collar in the app and then they do not get charged. It charges by however long the farmer is using the collar for. It is at the farmer's discretion.

Comment on this

It is a pay-as-you-go system for that.

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Basically, yes.

Comment on this

Is it the same price for cattle as for sheep?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Yes.

Comment on this

Is it the same price across the board?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

Yes.

Comment on this

Regarding slurry and GasAbate, Mr. McCarthy's company is a private one. Are there many other companies doing similar work in this field?

Comment on this
Mr. Justin McCarthy

Yes, there are other technologies out there, such as acidification and aeration. They all do different things in different ways. The Deputy's point is a very good one. It is not about asking Government to pick a winner in this space, but rather asking Government to create the landscape that allows technologies to win, whatever that technology may be. We are really passionate about independent scientific validation. That is a key point. Measuring environmental impacts practically at farm level and cost effectiveness are essential. Those are the parameters and standards we are asking Government to set. We are asking to be told the standards we have to meet to allow us to get onto the national inventory and we will meet them. However, the challenge is that we do not have that pathway.

Comment on this
Professor Vincent O'Flaherty

In general, thinking about the challenges Irish farming will face, we are tackling particular challenges and we have talked about specific ones today. Outside of that, the bar for competitiveness for our farmers versus other EU farming systems is increasing all the time. There are demands to be able to provide auditable data to really show that we are having an impact, be it on biodiversity or fire safety. That is what these types of technologies can do for the farmer as well. It is about future-proofing, making sure that we are resilient and ready to compete with the best.

Comment on this

What is the NPWS using the collars for?

Comment on this
Mr. John Maher

It is using them with farmers and in different areas for conservation around the country, such as the Burren in Clare. It is using them for targeted grazing and habitat management.

Comment on this

I thank everyone for their contributions today.

Comment on this