Engagement with the Children's Residential and Aftercare Voluntary Association
CRAVA told the committee that Ireland’s residential and aftercare system is in crisis because of long-standing underplanning, underfunding and a split funding model that leaves voluntary providers covering full costs while private operators can profit from State placements. The witnesses said the 2022 expansion plan was not properly developed with the sector and could not work without capital funding, and warned that several voluntary organisations face severe financial pressure and possible closure. They called for an independent, fully costed review of alternative care, a multi-year capacity plan, fairer funding and pay parity, and much stronger aftercare so young people are not pushed into homelessness when they leave care. Members broadly accepted that the State must take responsibility for a joined-up, long-term solution.
Contributions 127–263 of 263. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I will cut Mr. Dignan off because I am strict with everybody else, so I had better be strict with myself. We will go into a second round. Do the witnesses need a refreshment break or anything like that? They are okay.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here. I am not sure what I am going to ask them because what we have heard is quite bleak. They have been very articulate in what we and the Government need to do. I do not have a whole lot left. The properties owned by the witnesses are expected to meet certain standards and be suitable for children. Are they inspected regularly? Following on from that, if major works are needed, do they have any access to funding for same?
Comment on this
We provide the properties for free to Tusla. Maintenance has been provided by the charities for a long time. In recent years, Tusla has provided some funding for repairs, but with ageing buildings, repairs can be great. When young people have trauma, they can cause property damage, which can vary the level of requirement of need to repair windows, doors and walls from damage. Varying levels of funding are required each year for the level of property maintenance that needs to be done. The requirements for the compliance side of things around health and safety like Legionnaire's disease, fire doors and all of that have gone through the roof and we are expected to comply, yet our funding has not changed to meet all of those requirements. That is where the squeeze is on. Every year, the value of what we receive is decreasing because of the cost of living and every other cost we are expected to meet.
Comment on this
Maintenance is going to become a bigger and bigger issue. To be fair, Tusla does its best where it can and it certainly helped Don Bosco with maintenance, but it does not have the funding either. Fundamentally, you have to look at what the State does. Does the State recognise, as Ms Maguire said, that all of these properties are provided free of charge to the State? There is no rent or lease on them. Tusla will support us where it can with maintenance, but it has a limited budget as well. The State needs to look at what it needs to do to support the voluntary sector appropriately. Insurance costs, which are increasing all the time, maintenance costs and our ability to increase our capital funding to purchase properties where we can support the State with increased capacity and resolve some of the issues there are all the fundamental issues that have not been addressed properly. They have not been discussed to the extent that they should have been. Tusla does its very best with a limited budget. As Mr. Hill said, we are not looking for billions of euro to address these issues effectively. It is not going to be a huge cost to the State, but it is going to be a cost to the State.
Comment on this
It does not matter how big or small a provider is. Compliance is compliance. A massive organisation has to be compliant, as does a small one. The cost is still there. It is getting harder and harder to meet compliance if a provider is under-resourced, as it takes away from everything else.
Comment on this
We have just had a building assessment on our service. A ten-year plan for its maintenance and upkeep is transparent. It is going to cost €500,000 to restore and maintain the buildings as they stand, never mind what it will cost ten years from now, given inflation, the cost of building and all that sort of stuff. There is a trajectory there for us to be able to work with it, the board of management to be able to assign and designate funding, and for us to map out with the funders a way of maintaining our service.
Comment on this
We have a building where we have to replace a roof. That has been assessed at between €250,000 and €500,000. I do not expect Tusla to pay that, and I do not think it would have that funding. We have to figure out how we do that. One of our properties is leased from the archdiocese. It is a fundamental thing that the church has properties that it is not using. I know that there is a to and fro between the State in terms of redress. There are models that could be used. The State and the church could agree that the church would not hand over the properties but could allow the use of properties by the State that were appropriate for care. The cost saving to the State to get those on a peppercorn rent from the church and giving them to the voluntary providers would address the issues of capacity, increasing bed numbers, closing special emergency arrangements, SEAs. There would be no huge cost there because the church would effectively be allowing the State to use the properties. It is being creative about it. We do not need to build new properties. There are enough properties around the State.
Comment on this
The properties are all in the community. The growth of residential care is on the outskirts of towns, outside of communities, whereas voluntary providers are actually right in the heart of it. They are part of the local schools, football clubs and hurling clubs. The community comes around it and it becomes normal to go to school, to play with the local football or hurling club, to do drama and stuff like that. They are some of the outcomes that can be achieved but that are very hard to measure because they are normality.
Comment on this
It is not just that we have to maintain our properties. We want to because we are providing a home for the children and young people we look after.
We are also providing a comfortable and safe place for our staff. It is fundamental to the child's and the staff's sense of well-being and safety that we have properties that are fit for purpose, comfortable and appropriate.
Comment on this
I am going to sum this up incredibly quickly. Seventy per cent of children are in private care. As good as the workforce may be, it is private capital that is making determinations on the basis of making money. At this point in time, a lot of the Children's Residential and Aftercare Voluntary Association's members are under severe pressure. Long term, if we got to the point of having a plan, and given the cost of buildings and whatever, on some level voluntary care organisations are not overly concerned once they get a building. It is not like they are looking to have a property portfolio.
Comment on this
I remember asking Bernard Gloster a question about disability residential services when he was still in the HSE. He told me that the best-case scenario was that the local authority would provide it and then disability service providers or, in this case, voluntary care organisations step in.
Comment on this
That is an important point. We do not want to own properties. We are happy to avail of the use of those properties over the long term.
Comment on this
Where there is a benefit to these because alongside making money, the organisations are building up a property portfolio in a sense. I will go back to the question that I asked previously. It relates to the complexity of issues that voluntary care organisations deal with. We are talking about a system that is not fit to deal with an awful lot of that because we have lost the high-level units. How does this work out or look like in reality?
Comment on this
Very simply, it is a residential care system for children under 18 and under 12 that is fit for purpose. The model that St. Bernard's has is specifically for children up to 12 years of age. We need a separate residential care model for children between 12 and 18 and an appropriate and fully funded aftercare model for young people between 18 and 21 or 23. However, within that, the mainstream residential model cannot be one-size-fits-all. A child with complex needs cannot be put in a residential house with three other children who are basically-----
Comment on this
That is 100% and that is what we want. We do not have it at the minute.
Comment on this
How is that working out? We see how that is working out in what we see sometimes in the public domain. It is the use of special emergency arrangements, SEAs, and all the rest of it.
Comment on this
That is a long-term plan. We will not do it tomorrow, but it is doable. If it is built on year on year by providing the proper capital, an overall plan that people are working towards and metrics that are measured year on year to examine if progress is being made in the right direction versus the number of kids in care and the needs identified, then it is very doable. The plan has to be built, however.
Comment on this
The plan must have equitable reach and distribution. Historically speaking, there has been no care in the west of Ireland between Galway and Donegal. We want to keep children as close as possible to their social networks and families, etc. They should not have to move from Donegal to Dublin to get care. We need a plan that takes account of all that, so children stay within their communities and get the care they need at the time they need it. Children will move out of care and stabilise. They might move into foster care or, hopefully, move back with their families. That is what the aim is all the time, but we have got to have a system that supports that.
Comment on this
Exactly. It is all about that. It is the reviewing of-----
Comment on this
Regarding the plan, it is about specialisation rather than standardisation. If we look at the specialisation of services, St. Bernard’s Children's Services and Smyly Trust Services are based on a therapeutic model that is built around attachment. We want the adults who stay to have a greater understanding, so the child attaches and can then repair.
Comment on this
The organisations have to do a hell of a lot of work with some of the children.
Comment on this
If we go down the standardisation route, which is the mainstream route, it is one fit that matches every kid and that is not it. Specialisation is the key to the plan.
Comment on this
There has been a consistency to everything the witnesses have said. On some level, it is hardly shocking unfortunately. I imagine the conversations that come up with Tusla is accepting Tusla is not having meetings with voluntary care organisations because it can offer nothing other than what the organisations already know. However, it is a different conversation that the witnesses are having with the Minister. Where is that going?
Comment on this
Our overarching objective when meeting the Minister was to tell her that we are in a crisis. The State has failed in its duty of care.
Comment on this
We have been referencing the current framework. We have not seen the new framework yet, but we are hoping that it has been built on the ombudsman's report. We hope that the inputs we got to make were not too many. The Department has an ambitious timeline, and we are looking forward to seeing the first draft when it comes, but it needs to be a long-term strategic plan with resources and metrics built into it to ensure that it is working. We will not know until we see it.
Comment on this
Without second-guessing it, what struck us was that there was a short-term action plan and a long-term vision, but you need a strategy to achieve a vision. You also need funding to get there. There was no mention of a budget, money or a strategic plan. Every organisation has its vision on its website. The vision is based on the ideal world. We may never reach that but we must have a plan to try to get us as close to it as we can. When this framework is developed, we hope there will be a strategic plan that is fully costed and realistic in terms of what can be achieved. There has to be a realistic timeline as well because, as I said and we all agreed, to achieve a system that is fit for purpose, it could take 10, 15 or 20 years, but it is worth doing. The earlier we start it, the earlier we will get there but we must have a commitment from the State to fulfil its duty of care to these children.
Comment on this
You have had promises but it is a plan with money.
Comment on this
It is horrifying to think that it could take 20 years and of all the children who will be missed in that time. To tell the truth, it is quite horrifying. Tusla is failing a lot of these children and only for the voluntary and the for-profit sectors, I hate to think where we would be today. I do not like the for-profit sector at all. There is one particular house in my area where-----
Comment on this
It is in my area and the children constantly go missing from it. It is in a residential area and the children constantly go missing from this particular house. That is why I am curious about the importance of staff continuity, the services provided and the relationships made with those children who come into residential units, as well as the importance of trying to get children into education. Children who go from house to house are sometimes not in education for up to two years and that is shocking. These children are 12, 13, 14 years of age and they have missed out on two years of education. They cannot get a placement and have to go somewhere. They are maybe going into the for-profit or voluntary sector. The service providers then have to deal with that child who does not have the capacity other children of the same age have and has to go back on their educational pathway.
Comment on this
That is a good point and a good example of why this is a cross-departmental issue. There is a lady named Tara, and I apologise that I am blanking on her surname, who did a piece of research on that. The idea is that if a young person is being moved, there should be a link from the Department of education that makes sure when the child moves, they land and have an education placement. What happens in reality is they move to us and then we start to try to find a local school or Youthreach and, the Deputy is right, time builds up. We do not have that structure so that when someone in care is moved, a place is identified and established immediately because it is urgent.
Comment on this
One of the biggest failings is the fact that there is a child, who is potentially in a school and has a wraparound service to make that school placement work in terms of support hours and SNA support, but when they come into us all of that is gone. We have to reapply for everything and therefore sometimes local schools are reluctant. They are managing their numbers and have their own demands. We are asking for a child to be admitted who, unfortunately, will not have the support hours until it is reapplied for, which could be in the next academic year. That is tough, yet that support and wraparound is just sustaining that placement for that child. That is a fundamental flaw that should be addressed.
Comment on this
To pick up a couple of Deputy Keogan's questions, I do not agree that Tusla is failing. It has been given an almost impossible task-----
Comment on this
-----and it does not have the staff, and that is not its fault.
Comment on this
It is just the system that is in there at this moment-----
Comment on this
Yes, and the Senator is right in what she says: without the private providers, where would we be?
Comment on this
The State did not take account of capacity-----
Comment on this
-----in building the voluntary sector. Without the private providers, we would have children in homeless accommodation, potentially.
Comment on this
It is really unfortunate that we are talking about a long-term plan but find ourselves in a situation where, while we might talk about a long-term plan, we may not be here for it. That is critical. When we talk about sustainability, long-term planning and all the challenges we face now, if we do not get the first step right in sustaining the voluntary providers, the plan will be very-----
Comment on this
I am an advocate of the English model, the local authority model. Bringing it back down to basics and back down to community is where this childcare should be. That is the model I would like to see in this country. It is the only model that will work, whereby children are kept within their own county, within their own community.
Comment on this
Just one thing based on what the Senator said: as regards the first part of the alternative care framework in the programme for Government, short-term actions to address the current crisis, part of those short-term actions is sustainability of the voluntary sector. It is very short term for us. As Mr. Power said, we and others may not be around too much longer unless the Government steps in to provide a proper source of funding, both capital funding and the full cost of our service plus cost recovery, because that is a short-term action for us. As Mr. Power said, we would love to say that we will work with all the stakeholders over the next 20 years. We will if we are still in existence, but some of us may not be.
Comment on this
Talking about capacity, the State should take a leap of faith and let the voluntary organisations grow, whatever it may be, whether it be capital funding, properties, resources or staffing.
Comment on this
Mr. Power's organisation has been around since the 1800s; mine has been around for 50 years. We would love to be around for another 50. The difficulty at the minute is that the biggest demand on us as a service is trying to recruit staff. The negative impact from being removed from the Department of Health social care salary scales has made it quite challenging for us to recruit staff the way we used to do. The uncertainty that has been added to the fact that potentially our pensions are being reviewed and our eligibility for the pension scheme, again, is making it challenging for us to recruit because the fundamental questions anybody would ask, as a new candidate interested in employment, would be, "What is your salary scale?" and "What is your pension scheme?", and we are having to say, "Well, we were a part of the Department of Health, we are now in an adopted WRC salary scale situation, and we hope to be able to offer you a pension but, again, that is not certain." That does not help.
Comment on this
Just to clarify that, I think when people look at this, generally they say the State or Tusla is having difficulties in recruiting staff and we are. It is not the same. Our challenges are based predominantly around paying pensions. For the State and other organisations, that is not the issue.
Comment on this
We have kind of touched on this already. As has been noted, where would we be if we did not have the commercial operators? In terms of the choices the State is making, given that CRAVA's statement recognises, and we all recognise, the historical deficit in planning and investment and the surge in recent years, is there a sense that it is felt that commercial operators can respond more quickly or more flexibly?
Comment on this
Effectively, it is the commercial operator's ability to respond quickly and be flexible. A private provider can purchase a property quite quickly and turn it around because it has the equity backing to do that. We would like to do that but we cannot because we have absolutely no funding. One of the things that have been particular to the private sector has been the ability to respond quickly because it is backed by private equity, the money is there, the finance is there and the private operators can scale up. The downside of-----
Comment on this
Ultimately, though, to be clear, a lot of that quick response was for what we now call SEAs. Because the capacity was allowed to dwindle down to a low level, that seems much more positive than it actually is. That is actually a negative consequence of previous policy decisions that have meant we have moved backwards in time and have-----
Comment on this
That was about recognising that the family setting was superior.
Comment on this
It was a policy mistake in allowing the number of State and voluntary residential services to get lower while-----
Comment on this
Yes, but what was the basis for that decision?
Comment on this
In and around 2013 or 2014, it was decided to reduce the number of residential services. The meitheal model and the preventative family support, PPFS, came in. The belief was that if we can get them at level 1 or level 2 before they get to a high crisis, we should not need residential services. We had three residential services in 2012; we went down to one because they closed two of our services. Residential was deemed as no longer needed because they were going to be able to put community-based services in situ to help these families not get into crisis.
Comment on this
That is a noble policy perspective, I would say.
Comment on this
It is a noble thing, but the reality is that there will always be children who will need residential care. It is a therapeutic intervention. It is not just the last resort, and that is where the focus needs to be. It is a planned intervention. We are a child and family service so we do a lot of work with families and we have worked really hard to get young people back to live with their families. That is always part of our questioning when they move in: when they can move home, or whether it is safe to move home. That should be the focus, whereas they are in residential care for this period of time. Whether they want to move on to a foster family, whether they will move on to an aftercare placement or back to the family, that should be part of it. It is a planned intervention, not a last resort. That needs to be a shift.
Comment on this
To come back to Deputy Connolly's point, the other fundamental there is that the profit-driven model is driven by profit. There is a clue in the name. When profits drop, there is always the potential that they will leave the market because the profit is not there. If a for-profit decides that it is losing profit here, that it is not making it and that it will do its business somewhere else, where do those children go?
As regards the core benefits, the voluntary services have been around, as Ms Stewart says, since the mid-19th century. We are always going to be there. Maybe it is to our detriment that the State feels that we will always be there, that it can rely on us and that, whatever it gives us, we will stay around. That is not true either. I know it was a concern with the Government in recent years, and it has been seen in the UK, that for-profits can come into the market very quickly to make a profit and can exit just as quickly if they are not making a profit.
Comment on this
It is intrinsic in relation to, say, profit-making out of children from a service point of view. I am not saying it is right or wrong but it is there. The capacity issue is greater.
Comment on this
To come back to that point about the flexibility of the commercial sector, they have equity and they can purchase properties at quick decisions. They are not grant aided by the State for those purchases, though.
Comment on this
The funding they get is purely for the current costs of operating the services.
Comment on this
One thing that was seen in the UK is that they do leverage significant debt. That is one thing that is particular to the private market, that they leverage a lot of debt to purchase properties. In addition, they have to pay dividends to the stakeholders, so their model is very different in that way. As with all entities backed with hedge fund private equity, that is one of the issues, that they are quite heavily in debt in the UK. That has been seen. There have been no surveys or analysis done of the market here that we know of.
Comment on this
The other thing, though, is that we should not underestimate the flexibility of the voluntary sector. Obviously, we would need funding to do it. If I think again of my own service, gosh, over the past 50 years we have provided short-term emergency, emergency, respite, and long-term and medium-term care. We now have our high-support care for under-12s. We provided aftercare at one point and disability care. We meet the demand that is faced-----
Comment on this
Just on that very question, if you recognise in a particular part of the country that there is a demand and you want to meet that demand, how do you start financing the purchase of a property?
Comment on this
But approved housing bodies have access to CALF funding and CAS funding. Can you do that?
Comment on this
-----and that model does not work because there is no ongoing maintenance money attached to it, but there is no under-18 version.
Comment on this
Neither of those sources are available to-----
Comment on this
We offered to purchase two houses but we needed support to upgrade them to residential care and we did not get a formal response.
Comment on this
Ms Maguire's organisation looked to the Department of children for that.
Comment on this
If Tusla or the Department of housing came to my organisation and said it had a house it felt would be suitable and could provide to us along with whatever small amount of funding is needed to upgrade it, we could recruit the staff to basically care for the four children in that. That is how flexible we can be. Our flexibility is not an inability due to the structure of the organisation; it is based on a lack of money to do it.
Comment on this
It falls to me to ask the final questions. I am conscious I cut Mr. Dignan off quite a bit during both rounds, so I will give him some time if he wants to summarise or if there is anything in particular he wants to get across before we finish.
Going back to for-profit versus not-for-profit, the witnesses have all spoken passionately about creating a home and the services they want to provide to continuing care even after funding ceases. Mr. Dignam spoke about upgrading buildings not because his organisation has to but because it wants to. One of the members of the secretariat and I were in Ohio where we visited a short-term care setting called Huckleberry House. The way it was laid out internally was beautiful. It really was a home from home in a short-term way. What does the home from home look like to the organisations? What is leading my question is that we have just published our report on child poverty and deprivation and one of the things the children spoke about - Senator Keogan has also encouraged this idea - was an activity card to allow the children to access music, arts, sport, leisure and extracurricular activities. What does a home from home look and feel like? Do children get access to those activities?
Comment on this
It looks like a home. Ours has a front room, a kitchen and bedrooms. Some of the houses are slightly bigger and might have a games room. Some are just houses in the community. The difference is there is probably a staff office, which would not be in a normal house. When houses are run well they are done with the young people. They could be sitting in house meetings so we can find out what kind of activities they are interested in as a group or individually and find hobbies and interests. As Mr. Power mentioned earlier, maybe they are in the local GAA or are into drama. It should feel more like a home than a youth club, for example. We have run youth clubs too but the structure of it is that it is the place where they live, not a service they are in.
Comment on this
We have a young person with us who is playing rugby in the local community. She has been on two trips, one to Portugal and one to Spain, to play in tournaments. This is a young person who had severe trauma as a young child and now feels part of a family and a community. She is getting ready to leave and we are seeing some of the trauma starting to come back because she is anxious as she does not know what is going to happen.
Comment on this
We involve the young people in the day-to-day running, like choosing the menu and helping with the shopping. It is very family-based. When you tell people we are based here and they say they never knew we existed, I think that is great. It means we look like everyone else and do not stand out in the community. We try to blend in so the kids do not feel stigmatised because they live in residential care. Their friends can come in. We wish they would do more, sometimes, because they are reluctant to join groups but they are-----
Comment on this
They do not call people staff. It is names.
Comment on this
Yes. We try to make it theirs. They paint their bedrooms.
Comment on this
When it is working really well any child who is in care would go to school and no child in that class would know that child was in care. They have their house to go back to with their own room. It is their own personal space. They decorate it as they wish. They are involved, as Ms Maguire said, in planning the day and cooking. They are involved in local clubs, etc. Effectively, they are living their life as a child. As Mr. Hill said, the only difference is there are professional staff in the parenting role there.
Comment on this
The Cathaoirleach's initial question struck me and it is still playing in my mind. I mean the difference between childcare and nursing homes she spoke about. My kids went to a private crèche. It cost me more than my flipping mortgage. The difference is they were my kids so if there was something wrong, they would tell me about it and I would address it. I have had elderly relatives in nursing homes and they have family around them. A child in care does not have that. Some might, but often they do not, so the values of the place the State is paying for them to be in are much more important than when your own kid is going to crèche because you will keep an eye on what is happening there and you will know how they feel when they come home. You will have a sense of how they are treated when they are there. That is missing for kids in care so it is probably more important that we have a values-led version and we do not commodify our children who are in need of State care.
Comment on this
A lot of our models of care are based around values, not around rules. We know these children struggle with rules so it is all values. We talk about trust and the building of trust. It is attaching to adults who care for you so you feel safe. That is the work. If you have the same adults coming in over and over again, as we do, then the work is successful and that leads to positive outcomes. That is the kid going to college and the kid going to work. At one stage we had four of our children working in Croke Park. They saw every concert for two years.
Comment on this
And the football matches as well, I hope.
Comment on this
With regard to the activity card the committee has recommended, let us say some of the young persons are travelling abroad for sport. How would that activity card benefit those children and what would the best activity card look like?
Comment on this
Is that if they are involved locally in sport and so on?
Comment on this
When the kids were in here they spoke about not being able to take part in the same activities as their peers, be that piano, soccer or going to concerts.
Comment on this
We focus on talents so if you are very good at it, we usually make it happen.
Comment on this
In our area, it sounds a tad institutional that the State would provide this card. It should just be the funding for the child to-----
Comment on this
It works very well as it is because effectively-----
Comment on this
How does that work? If I give a teenager €200, how do I know they are going to spend it on piano and soccer and not a vape? We have to understand how it would go to extracurricular activities.
Comment on this
The key worker will have sat down with them. We do not actually hand the young person the cash. It is like what I would do with my teenager if she wanted to join the swimming club. I did not hand her the money. I went over, we signed her up and she is doing the lessons. It is more like a parenting model than-----
Comment on this
They are dropped off to football matches and training and they are picked up by staff. When they have to pay something staff will pay it. Where we know they are capable, they will have their own pocket money and they can do what they like with that. It is to give them the ability to socialise, to become independent and to become self-reliant.
Comment on this
We have staff who turn up on their days off if there is a match to watch it. They have invested their time and they bring themselves to the work. That is the difference.
Comment on this
We are coming to the end. Did Senator Murphy O'Mahony want to come in on the second round?
Comment on this
Yes. I did not get in on any round yet.
Comment on this
I apologise for coming in and out of the meeting. I had to go back to the Seanad.
I thank all the witnesses for coming in and for the work they do. I assume at this stage most of the questions I had have been asked. I will talk to my colleagues about the replies. I want to raise one issue before we finish, namely, aftercare. When a young person leaves care there is often what is perceived to be a cliff edge. They are getting the care and then there is nothing. What specific reforms are needed to ensure people leaving care do not face this cliff edge?
Comment on this
To summarise, there are a couple of other things. The entitlement to aftercare should be based on the need of the young person, not some time-bound measurement of their time in care, as often kids are known to Tusla a lot more than they are actually in care. We have a young person who is in care who said aftercare sounds like you have stopped caring, so a better phrase, perhaps through-care, continuous care or something like that, is required. Aftercare should match up with our national youth policy age, meaning the young person should not be cut off at the age of 21 or 23. Ireland's national youth policies go to 25 and 26. Young people who have experienced a lot of trauma and have much fewer supports need a little more than what we are designing elsewhere. We have proposals we will happily share on the current review of the Child Care Act that looks at some of this stuff too.
Comment on this
It is about preplanning with the young person before they move into aftercare to make sure they transition smoothly.
Comment on this
Is it different for everyone? Is it specific to the person?
Comment on this
It is individual, yes. Under the current system, as Mr. Hill said, the cut-off age is 21 if you are not in education or training and 23 if you are. A lot of young people are not capable of engaging in education or training so we have to make allowances for that. Why should you be cut off at 21 because you are not in education or training? A lot of our own children do not choose education or training after 18 but they do not have to leave home. As Mr. Hill said, on a case-by-case basis, some young people need supports for longer. We have an outreach aftercare service in Don Bosco. These are young people who have aged out of aftercare but we still provide support within the community they are living in.
That will help them with their basic day-to-day needs such as filling in forms, job interviews and preparation for those in training. The cliff edge is the issue. We need to provide care on a needs basis beyond the ages of 21 and 23, where we can.
Comment on this
When you talk about the cliff edge, it is actually very scary for both the carer and the young adults under their care. We have been there when the plans have not been properly figured out. There are then struggles, such as the kid not knowing where he is going and there is anxiety for both the carer and the child. The question is what the next stage is and where they are going. That is a basic right.
Comment on this
We have had young people who have successfully gone home before the age of 18. By the time they turn 21, things may not have worked out so they may come back and ask what they should do then. They are nearly punished for successfully moving home and there are then no supports because they have managed to survive at home until they are 21. The relationship may have broken down and they may find themselves facing homelessness. That is a real difficulty for kids by whom we have done the right thing by getting them home. They have done the right thing and maintained it, but the cut-off point means there is no support.
Comment on this
I might just make one point. I know this is very obvious so it is not probably not worth saying, but we need to think about the cost to the State where we have failed children in care. In terms of mental health issues, addiction issues, the criminal justice system and homelessness, the cost is incomparably bigger than what it would cost to keep them in care and actually help them to develop and live independently. When a child goes into homelessness and might engage with addiction services, mental health services or the criminal justice system, the State pays multiples of what it would have cost to ensure that child had a proper care experience, in both residential care and aftercare. We often forget that.
Comment on this
I know it is not related to aftercare but we run a fostering support service. The focus of that is to try to sustain placements and keep young people in foster care. If that placement fails, the expenses related to that child may increase as they will potentially end up in residential care at a significant cost to the State. At the minute, the fostering support service, which we have offered for the past 11 years, is earmarked for closure. It is being reviewed to determine the cost efficiency of it. It consists of a small team of staff who have been providing fostering support to foster carers in south Tipperary, Carlow and Kilkenny for the past 11 years.
Obviously, there are significant concerns among the foster cares at the minute. They are wondering where, if that service goes, they will get the support. At this time, they are indicating they do not necessarily trust that that support will be available under the current delivery and provision of service within Tusla. It is a concern. Our belief is that we will possibly have placement breakdowns and that young people will again end up having to come into the residential care setting as a result. That could be avoided if appropriate support is provided to foster carers.
Comment on this
It is hugely important. It is also important that planning start early and that we do not wait until the person turns a certain age.
Comment on this
We know they will turn that age years before it happens, so we should start early. It is very important to think of the carer as well. We often just think of the person who is looked after but it obviously pulls at the carer's heartstrings as well. I thank the Cathaoirleach and I thank the witnesses for the great work they do.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. She is double-jobbing everywhere today so I thank her for coming back to us. Is there anything Mr. Dignan would like to say in the two minutes remaining?
Comment on this
I will just reiterate the key issues. We need to develop a system that provides the appropriate care for every child at an appropriate time. That takes planning and investment, which has been singularly lacking on behalf of the State over the past two, three or four decades. We really need to take it seriously now. If we act collectively now, we can develop, as Mr. Hill said, a system that will not cost the earth but will save lives, effectively. It will certainly enhance the life of every child and young person going through the care system. That is a particular court of young people because it is the only cohort where the State is the parent. The State has to act as a prudent parent and meet its duty of care. That takes planning, appropriate investment and a system that takes account of the needs of every child and young person going through the care system. We feel that is achievable. We simply need to sit together and begin to plan how we do that. That is notwithstanding the fact we know the Government has a plan in place, and we will await the outcome of that. However, we need a fundamental review of our system to see what the systemic failures are. That would be fundamental to any plan.
Comment on this
On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for coming in, not least given the volume of work they are doing on a daily basis. They are working extremely hard for the benefit of our most vulnerable children and adults. I think the witnesses can see across the board that we are all extremely passionate about these vulnerable children. We will all work on a cross-party basis to make a positive change.