We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Children and Equality

Gender Equality, Family Rights and Expanding Inclusion Policies for Families: Discussion

Summary

Witnesses called for a public, accessible childcare system, better-paid and extended family leave, and equal leave for children in one-parent families, alongside tailored education and employment support for lone parents. IHREC urged faster delivery of gender-equality recommendations, stronger equality laws and accountability, while raising concerns about resources and Cuan’s independence and policy role in tackling violence against women. Members questioned childcare provision, poverty, maintenance, employment barriers, gender quotas and how advocacy organisations represent differing views; no formal decisions were made.

Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Apologies have been received from Senators Bradley and Murphy O'Mahony. This meeting is to discuss gender equality, family rights and expanding inclusion policies for families. In recognition of, and to coincide with, European Gender Equality Week, the committee decided to examine this topic as part of its work programme.

We are delighted to be joined this morning by Ms Corrinne Hasson, executive director, and Ms Alex Richardson, senior policy co-ordinator, from the National Women's Council of Ireland, NWCI; Dr. Iris Elliott, head of policy and research, and Nicole Moore, research and policy officer, from the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission, IHREC; and Ms Karen Kiernan, chief executive officer, and Ms Aolish Gormley, policy and advocacy co-ordinator, from One Family.

Before we begin, I have a few housekeeping matters that I am obliged to go through. As we have a couple of members online, I remind them that the MS Teams chat function should only be used to make the team on site aware of any technical issues or urgent matters that might arise. I also remind members of the constitutional requirement to be present within the confines of the Leinster House complex to participate in public meetings.

In advance of inviting our witnesses to deliver their opening statement, I advise them of the following in relation to parliamentary privilege. Witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation that they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

The witnesses will each have three minutes' speaking time to deliver their opening statements. There are little clocks underneath the screens. The opening statements will then be followed by a question-and-answer session with members. I will call the witnesses in the following order: Ms Corrinne Hasson, Dr. Iris Elliott and Ms Karen Kiernan. I invite Ms Corrinne Hasson to deliver her opening statement.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

I thank the committee very much for the invitation to speak here. The National Women's Council of Ireland believes in a feminist Ireland, one that is just, caring and where everyone can thrive. However, it is our position that a caring society cannot be created without women's equal participation in all spheres of life. Women deserve full, meaningful lives with the autonomy and choice to pursue education, employment, leadership, family and a rich social life. However, these ideals will never be achieved if we do not look at the gendered stereotypes underpinning care responsibilities today.

Research from the Economic and Social Research Institute, ESRI, and the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission, IHREC, has found that a little over half of eligible fathers take paternity leave. Ireland is the only country in the EU that does not link family leave benefits to income, but instead pays a very low flat rate of €299 per week. Bulgaria and Germany offer generous pay-related approaches of between around 80% and 100% of an individual's salary for at least the first two months following childbirth. Ireland also has the largest gap in Europe between adequately paid family leave and guaranteed education for children. This has serious implications for women, often forcing them to leave work, reduce their hours or accept fewer senior roles. This particularly affects lone parents and other marginalised groups. On the other hand, Germany has no gap between family leave and childcare entitlement, as children have a legal right to early childhood education from the age of one.

Other critical policy reforms are needed beyond family leave that we must consider if we are to secure true gender equality in Ireland. Our early childhood education and care system requires massive structural reform. The Together for Public alliance, led by the NWCI, calls for a public system of childcare where the Government delivers the provision of care directly.

The continued expansion of private, profit-driven care has led to huge issues in affordability, access, inclusion and quality service provision. Transforming Ireland's early childhood education and care system from a market-led to a public model is critical to ensuring access for all women, families and children. Despite reductions in childcare fees, demand far outweighs supply. This is compounded by regional variations in access for children aged under two, with childcare deserts in various parts of the country causing additional barriers for many marginalised families. The most recent data from Pobal shows that there are more than 40,000 children on waiting lists - 46,000 children, to be precise - for full day care across the country.

What do we need to change? We need to enshrine in legislation the right of children to early years education from birth. We need to move towards a public model of care. We need to offer flexible and fair work conditions for women. We need to protect the well-being and safety of families in Ireland by encouraging all parents to take up equal care responsibilities. We need pay-related and extended family leave policies. We need to empower women across the social, political, economic and cultural spheres of life. We need a feminist, caring and equal Ireland. I thank the committee.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

I thank the committee for the opportunity to address it today.

Ireland has made important progress in advancing gender equality in recent years, particularly through the work of the Citizens’ Assembly on Gender Equality and the subsequent recommendations of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Gender Equality. Together, these processes provide a robust evidence base and a clear roadmap for achieving substantiative equality for women and girls. Five years on from the citizens' assembly's final report, however, there remains a significant challenge. Ireland has a strong tradition of participatory democracy and the citizens' assembly’s recommendations reflected extensive public engagement and expert evidence. Where recommendations are not advanced within a reasonable timeframe, there is a risk of a democratic deficit emerging between public participation and policy delivery. We believe it is important that the State provide clear, transparent reporting on progress against the assembly's recommendations and the implementation actions subsequently identified by the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Gender Equality.

Gender equality is also a matter of international human rights compliance. Following Ireland's examination in 2025, the UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women, CEDAW, identified a number of priority areas requiring urgent action. Of particular significance was the committee's recommendation that Ireland expedite the drafting and enactment of the Equality (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill and ensure that equality legislation reflects the full range of internationally recognised grounds of discrimination, including forms of discrimination affecting women and girls. CEDAW also highlighted the need for temporary special measures, including gender quotas and measurable targets, to address the persistent under-representation of women in areas such as local government, academia, the private sector and corporate leadership, while also improving outcomes for Traveller, Roma, migrant, disabled and rural women.

These recommendations should not be viewed as separate from domestic policy priorities. Rather, they provide an important framework for strengthening Ireland's equality architecture and ensuring that legislative reform keeps pace with evolving national and international standards. In that regard, the committee has a particularly important role to play. Progressing reform of equality legislation, including the transposition of EU directives on pay transparency and standards for equality bodies, represents a significant opportunity to strengthen protections for women and girls and enhance the effectiveness of Ireland's equality framework.

Economic equality also remains central to achieving substantive gender equality. Women continue to experience lower lifetime earnings, a significant pension gap, occupational segregation and disproportionate responsibility for unpaid care. These are not only social issues; they are economic issues that affect participation, independence and long-term financial security. The commission's work on human rights and equality budgeting demonstrates the importance of assessing how public expenditure decisions affect different groups in practice. Budgetary and policy decisions should be designed and evaluated through an equality and human rights lens to ensure that commitments to gender equality translate into measurable outcomes.

Our message today is, therefore, straightforward. The evidence base already exists. The citizens' assembly, the joint committee and international human rights mechanisms have all identified the reforms required. The challenge now is to strengthen legislative protections, accelerate implementation and ensure accountability for delivery. While the time allowed for this opening statement does not allow me to go into further detail, today we can also answer questions on violence against women and girls, gender stereotypes, childcare and parental leave.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

One Family welcomes the opportunity to address the Joint Committee on Children and Equality. We believe there cannot be gender equality without equality for all families. Every child should have the same opportunity to thrive and should not have fewer rights, opportunities or security because of the family structure they are born into. Too often, the challenges faced by lone parents are treated as individual failings, rather than understood in the context of systems that fail to adequately reflect their caring responsibilities and circumstances.

Ireland has a shameful history of how we treated unmarried mothers and their children, a history rooted in misogyny, stigma and institutionalisation. We rightly speak of how far we have come as a society but have we really moved beyond the inequalities that shaped our history or have we merely improved our rhetoric without addressing the structural barriers that remain? One Family sees these barriers affecting the thousands of families we support every year, preventing them from providing for their children and reaching their full potential.

Today we will focus on three areas: pathways to sustainable employment, parental leave and childcare. There is obviously a common theme among the organisations. Education can play an important role in addressing child and family poverty.

Lone parents need targeted, tailored and meaningful support to overcome barriers to education and employment, and to progress from social welfare into sustainable careers and financial independence. Housing costs, inadequate childcare and social welfare policies that prioritise a "work first" approach all conspire to make employment financially and practically difficult. We have the New Futures employability programme and we can see what happens when we invest in parents with tailored support. This specialist bridging programme has an average 75% progression rate for graduates into education, training or employment, much higher than mainstream programmes. However, it does not have sustainable funding, or any Government funding, at the moment. We believe that investing in a programme like New Futures means investing in gender equality, reducing economic inequality and ensuring that women and mothers are not disadvantaged.

There is an ongoing issue around parental leave entitlements because the leave follows the parents, not the child. Children in one-parent families have less paid time with their parent, which clearly does not make sense. Other European countries go beyond the minimum requirements to address this. There are examples of what can be done. Not every child has two parents available to share leave.

Childcare is equally essential to enabling lone parents to work or pursue education. Without it, caring responsibilities are a direct barrier to economic independence. There are existing strategies, such as the national strategy for women and girls and the roadmap for social inclusion, which recognise the need to address barriers to women's labour market participation, promote a fairer share of care and tackle poverty among one-parent families. Achieving the programme for Government's child poverty target requires a focus on one-parent families because, unfortunately, that is where most poor children live. We await the Department of Social Protection's pathways to work report to see how these commitments will be translated into properly resourced services and programmes. The challenge is to deliver meaningful change that reflects the diversity of family life in Ireland today, rather than paying lip service to equality.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank all our witnesses for their opening statements. It is proposed to publish the opening statements to the Oireachtas website. Is that agreed? Agreed. I will ask the Leas-Chathaoirleach to fill in for me for a couple of minutes. Members will each have seven minutes' speaking time, which must include responses from the witnesses. I ask members to adhere strictly to the agenda topic under consideration at the meeting. Deputy Kerrane is next.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their opening statements and the documents they have provided to us. I will begin with the National Women's Council of Ireland's point on childcare and the great difficulties that exist, not just with cost and affordability but actually getting a place. There was a reference to childcare deserts. That is a very good way of putting it. Could we have an update on the alliance the NWCI is leading on this matter and on getting to a public model? Where is the campaign at and what are our next steps in supporting it?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

We just met with the alliance on Monday. Ms Richardson leads the alliance so she might jump in as well. We had a post-budget meeting. We have done a huge amount of work. The National Women's Council of Ireland has been calling for a public model of childcare for well over 20 years now. It is something we have been pushing for. We were delighted earlier this year when there was an announcement that we were going to have eight State-led facilities. Then we discovered that it was more that the buildings were going to be bought; it was more about the capital. For the campaign, we are going to reassess some of our terminology and what we are calling for. We are really looking into what State-led provision means. Our education system works well. Every child has a right to an education. There is no reason that we cannot bring that down into early years education and care.

There are over 50 members now in the alliance, and that includes childcare providers who are also asking for this public model of childcare. We have had a few new people following the budget. Their disappointment in the budget has made them want to join the Together for Public alliance. Again, it is still pushing with our same message that we want a public model of childcare. It has to be about accessibility, affordability and also quality of service provision. We hear stories of parents who are not happy with where their children are, but they keep them there because they have nowhere else to put them. If their children are not in there, the parents do not get to go to work. Ms Richardson might like to jump in to speak about the alliance.

Comment on this
Ms Alex Richardson

I lead on the Together for Public Alliance. As we said, it has over 50 members at present, ranging from academics and trade unions to educators and providers. That really shows the scope and breadth of the issue we have at hand. One of the levers we hope to pull in reflection of the budget is this family leave piece. Advocating for greater income relation and extension would be a key understanding or lever to relieve the crisis in terms of the under-1s, which is acute at present. As the Deputy said, there are particular deserts that feel this most.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Richardson. That is really important and it is something we need to continue to push on with. I thank her for her work on that.

My next question, which is directed to One Family, relates to the additional difficulties faced by one-parent families. Judging by the data from the survey on income and living conditions, SILC, every year, while the data is always behind, one-parent families are always high across the board in terms of the risk of deprivation and consistent poverty. There are obvious issues. I have done a lot of work previously on maintenance and the difficulties whereby it is court, court, court and it is always to the lone parent to go back around in circles. There was some progress made with that.

When the former Member Heather Humphreys was Minister, I shadowed her, and the greatest frustration following the introduction of parent's leave and benefit was the fact a baby in a one-parent family will get the nine weeks but a baby with two parents will get double that. Every time I raised it, I was told it was a European issue, and that was the easy out. Are we making any progress nationally on that issue to ensure that the tiny number of babies who will be born into a one-parent family will have that equal time with a parent that others do with two parents?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

I thank the Deputy. No, we are not making any progress. This was raised again recently by Members of the Oireachtas. It is an issue that has come from the Department of Children, Disability and Equality. There does not seem to have been any progress. It was brought in as a gender equality measure to ensure that fathers have paid access and time with their children, which is brilliant. In fact, if the two parents have spouses, they can have up to four times as much, depending on the number of parents there are. A lone parent, however, gets only the minimum nine weeks. That does not make sense when we know that most poor children are living in one-parent families and if people are parenting on their own, it is so much more difficult financially, mentally and emotionally and having to get up in the middle of the night. It does not make sense. There are other models, as the Deputy referenced, such as from Iceland and Norway, where they have more innovative ways of distributing the leave, either to another party or where a certain amount of leave can be taken by either parent, or perhaps there is a grandparent or somebody else. There seems to be protective view in Ireland that there is a fear that this will not be used properly but, actually, that is not good enough for babies in one-parent families. We cannot have that as a reason, so we are still calling for something innovative beyond the bare minimum to be done. As the Deputy said, it is not a huge number of people.

Comment on this

No, and the fact that it is done in other countries shows that it can be done if the will is there

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

Of course it can be done.

Comment on this

Iin relation to maintenance, for the vast majority of one-parent families who are led by women, all research shows that where maintenance is actually paid, not just on a piece of paper somewhere, it does support and assist in lifting children out of poverty. Obviously, we had that situation previously whereby, whether it was paid or not, it was taken as being paid. We have the household means test. There are still difficulties with maintenance not being part of the household means test for the one-parent family payment, but it remains the case that in other Departments, such as the Department of housing, it is taken as means. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

Yes. There has been huge progress, with the Department of Social Protection doing really positive things and now not charging maintenance, but we still see it in secondary benefits. Other Departments, such as the Departments of Health and housing and even childcare, still take account of child maintenance whether it is paid or not. The onus is on the parent to keep going back to court and, obviously, the courts are overrun and understaffed. There are huge difficulties there. It can look like people are receiving a payment when, in fact, they are not. Then there is what the Departments can do to equalise and ameliorate that. Ultimately, we believe we need some kind of system or structure to manage child maintenance assessment and collection in Ireland and enforcement around it. In the meantime, however, the minimum the State can do is stop penalising people who are not actually receiving it.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Kiernan.

Comment on this
Aisling Dempsey An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I have lots of questions but hopefully we will have time for a second round. Violence against women is obviously a major issue and, unfortunately, it is increasing. Hopefully, if I were to try to be positive, it is an issue that we are just becoming more aware of such that there are more reports of it.

I am interested all of the witnesses' views on Cuan, which was introduced by the former Minister for justice, Deputy McEntee, and continues under the current Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan. There is a women's refuge in Meath that is hugely significant for the community. It is brilliant to have it. The refuge is very supportive of Cuan and its zero tolerance programme, which is running across County Meath. What more can we do? What is being done right under Cuan and what more do we need? I note that funding was mentioned as an issue in some of the opening statements.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

At the National Women's Council we work quite a lot with Cuan. The Deputy mentioned its national strategy, Zero Tolerance, which will be coming to an end this year. We have just done a consultation with all of our members for Cuan to feed into the fourth national strategy. As a membership organisation with over 200 members, we have a real cross-section of society that we can bring together to talk about all of the different forms of violence against women, including domestic and sexual violence, trafficking and forced marriage, to really make sure that the voices of women and the experiences of what is happening on the ground are being brought into the consultation.

Cuan has a huge challenge ahead of it. We have heard the figures and we know there are areas of the country that do not have refuges. There is so much to be done. Cuan has been there less than two years, so it is still in its infancy. The big test for Cuan will be the next national strategy, the fourth one, because Cuan will be behind its creation and implementation.

The Deputy mentioned funding and I can strongly advocate for more funding in the area of violence against women across services, supports and advocacy organisations. Last year, Cuan and Community Foundation Ireland funded the National Women's Council to look at survivor structures of engagement. That report made a number of recommendations around how we bring to the fore the voices and the lived experiences of women who have gone through different challenges and of the family members of women who are no longer with us. It is important to make sure that their lived experience shapes policy, services and everything we do. Cuan is doing everything it can to take those strides but the funding is an issue. There was an extra €5.3 million in the budget, but that is nowhere near enough. We need to have as much engagement as possible and to make sure that advocacy organisations and services are engaged with and brought to the fore as much as possible.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

I thank the Deputy for the question. IHREC engaged in legislative observations when Cuan was being established. While we welcome its establishment, we see that there are persistent issues with its mandate, specifically the fact that the independence of Cuan is not sufficient in terms of reporting structures into the Minister. We are also concerned that there is not an adequate policy function. Although it is welcome that there is a strong research, public communications and service function around Cuan's work, the idea that it would have evidence and service engagement functions but not have a strong policy function, and certainly not an independent policy function, is of serious concern to the commission. With legislative observations we always look to see how things play out in practice and we register those concerns, as we did when the legislation to establish Cuan was moving through the Houses.

As the representative from the National Women's Council has said, the next national strategy on domestic, sexual and gender-based violence is going to be critical. Ireland is committed to achieving the human rights standards of the Istanbul Convention through the GREVIO mechanism. We deeply regret the lack of ambition in the last strategy in terms of the number of refuge placements and support services, which do not meet the bare minimum of the Council of Europe's standards. We will continue to monitor that. What will be useful to the work of this committee is next year's GREVIO, which oversees the Istanbul Convention. It will be doing its first thematic evaluation of Ireland and that will run throughout the year. Interestingly, it has chosen the theme of building trust.

To the point that the National Women's Council made about the importance of lived experience and the voices of women, men and children who have been impacted by domestic, sexual or gender-based violence and also the families of people who, sadly, have lost loved ones as a result of this violence, that will be key to understanding whether those key experts in the experience of violence trust the system that Ireland has put in place.

We continue to be highly concerned about the lack of resource going to the violence sector and to services, support and policy interventions. We are also deeply concerned about the rising rates of femicide, both in Ireland and in Northern Ireland. We consider that that has a particular need for action.

We benefit from having recommendations from the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women, CEDAW, around how Ireland can improve its performance in supporting and preventing the experience of violence. We too have specific recommendations in that area.

To the Leas-Chathaoirleach's point on Cuan and the framework on human rights and the realisation of human rights, those would be my main points.

Comment on this
Aisling Dempsey An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I thank Dr. Elliott.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach for her question. One Family provides direct services to child and adult survivors of domestic abuse. Unfortunately, when somebody leave an abusive relationship, they become a lone parent or someone who is sharing parenting, and what we see is that abuse can continue for many years through family courts and through child access and maintenance. Everything can be weaponised. This is a really complex issue that the Department of justice has started to look at. Some work was done around the intersection of private family law cases, public childcare cases and criminal cases, because that is really difficult. The kinds of challenges that people are facing daily and weekly are incredible, even when they leave.

We also have many service users who have had to go back to relationships because they have nowhere to live or their children have had to go back. Sorry, I know my time has expired but I can say more.

Comment on this
Aisling Dempsey An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I hate when I am in the Chair. I thank Ms Kiernan for that.

Comment on this

The witnesses are all very welcome here today. I will start off with One Family, Ms Gormley and Ms Kiernan. I have to commend them on the work they do for families and lone parents throughout the country. Everyone recognises the practical assistance and advocacy they provide for people who are facing challenging issues every day, and I really appreciate the work they do.

One issue that has been raised with me concerns the interaction between caring responsibilities, social welfare supports and access to education. In some cases, people feel they are caught between maintaining an allowance and pursuing education or training that could improve their long-term employment prospects. In Ms Kiernan's experience, are there barriers within the current system that discourage carers or lone parents from taking up education and skilled development opportunities, and if so, what changes would make a difference?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

I thank the Senator. We mentioned that in our experience, the Department of Social Protection has a work-first approach to activating lone parents who are on social welfare. Unfortunately, if you look at the statistics, there are lower educational levels among lone parents, for whatever reason, than other people and where there is investment in the education and the well-being of mothers, their children do much better, as longitudinal studies show. We have been looking for the time and the specialist courses that lone parents can have access to nationally, not just wherever we can get money, either from Europe or from philanthropy, to run New Futures, but where the State will invest in those programmes so that parents across the country can have access. That means they can have time to move into higher and further education and ultimately build sustainable careers, move off social welfare, become net tax contributors and lift their children out of poverty.

Comment on this

At present, if a lone parent of a child, possibly with a disability, is getting the carer's allowance, am I correct in saying they cannot access education programmes without losing that payment?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

I am going to admit I am not the most technically minded person on the intricacies of social welfare because it is incredibly confusing, but we often see that somebody cannot access a payment if they are on another payment.

Comment on this

That really inhibits the person. The child might be in school for five or six hours of that day. That inhibits the ability of mother living on her own to pursue the route to education.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

It may do. What every family need to do is maximise their income in whatever way is sensible. We know that lots of parents have dropped income and tried to survive on less to get through education, but sometimes that is not possible. Where there is not a support or a second parent for childcare and someone is relying on college, that is difficult. Some of the recommendations we have to increase access to education are to increase the cost-of-education allowance for parents and to exclude child maintenance from means testing for the SUSI grant, the student assistance fund and the national childcare scheme. There are practical things. There is not a clear pathway for lone parents to education.

Comment on this

There is no point increasing an education allowance if they cannot access it. If you are getting a carer's allowance and you are a lone parent, you cannot access education. You are not allowed to access education while you are getting a carer's allowance. Increasing an education allowance might be good for a lone parent who is on their own and does not have a child with additional needs, but it does not really serve a purpose for a lone parent who may have a child with additional needs where that parent needs to be at home most of the time outside of school.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

Does the Senator mean a domiciliary care allowance?

Comment on this

Yes. Ms Kiernan spoke about the importance of helping lone parents to access employment, education and financial independence. In her view, what are the biggest practical obstacles preventing lone parents from making that transition? Is it childcare, housing costs, welfare design, access to education or something else? If the Government could address only one issue, what would she prioritise?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

All of those things. Childcare is a universal issue. It is out-of-school care. It is quality childcare that you want your child to go into and that you can find locally. That is a massive challenge and it requires massive investment. Nearly 60% of all families in homeless and emergency accommodation are one-parent families. That is not an accident; it is by design. It is practically impossible in Ireland to pay for your childcare and housing costs on a low income or one income. We have designed Ireland to be difficult, and it is very difficult.

Comment on this

I have only two minutes left and want to go back to human trafficking in this country, which is not talked about or given the time it needs, in particular the online prostitution services offered in this country. What have these organisations done about that? We have 3,000 to 4,000 women every day offered on websites. What have the organisations present done to try to get websites that illegally offer those services banned in this country? What has the National Women's Council done to represent those women?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

We have done a lot on sex for rent in the online space. A couple of years ago, we put together a report to show the intersection between housing, homelessness and violence against women. The big thing that came up at the time was sex for rent. Women were often leaving domestic violence situations-----

Comment on this

I am talking about the online escort services that are available in this country and the websites that are prostituting women throughout this country. Many of them will have been trafficked into this country. What has the NWCI done to help them and to prevent that happening in this country?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

I was explaining that our first port of call has been sex for rent. We had that legislation changed this year. We are going back to assess our next port of call. The big thing is that we are trying to hold the tech companies to account for many different things, but we find that the biggest challenge. That is where we need the support of the Government behind us in the area of algorithms, what is allowed and what is being viewed as okay. A lot of those sites are deemed appropriate and are not in breach of anything. We need to hold the data protection-----

Comment on this

How is it appropriate if it is illegal in this country?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

They find ways around it. That is the problem. We need to have better legislation to make sure we can hold them to account. Legislation is there but they are still allowed to go through with this. They still get through gaps. There is a dark web. We need to hold the tech companies to account for still allowing this to happen. On the sex for rent legislation I mentioned earlier, websites are still allowing those ads to go up. Again, it goes back to big tech.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses and thank them for their opening statements. I will concentrate on structural barriers and employment opportunities for women.

We can see that women are still blighted by low pay. I would like to get the witnesses' opinions about how employment legislation would change that. During Covid, if people could work from home, they worked from home. Our employment legislation is holding a lot of people back because they can request the right to work from home but they may not be able to work from home. I wonder about the impact that might have on women returning to the workforce and also the effect of women being stuck in low-paid jobs. Is this an issue? I ask Ms Kiernan and Ms Gormley to start. Are these structural barriers that we can address with legislation?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

That is somewhat linked to childcare and out-of-school care being accessible. For many parents and carers - because there is a huge overlap in the needs of people who are doing that unseen and unacknowledged work - there can be huge advantages to being able to work flexibly or remotely, from home, or for themselves.

For people who are moving from social welfare into a career, there are not always clear supports, particularly for those who are self-employed. There is not tapering and the kind of thing we want to see. The Department of Social Protection had an engagement earlier this year on working-age payment and what that could look like in the future. There is a lot of thinking to be done on that. Presumably what makes sense is to follow Government policy of dropping child poverty levels drastically. That means increasing income into people’s homes and looking at where the poorest children are. Many of them are in one-parent families. That means we need to look at how to get more income into the pockets and homes of one-parent families. That involves increasing access to education, employment, housing, childcare and all of the big, structural things that everyone struggles with.

Comment on this

We need to include housing when measuring poverty. Housing costs are overlooked. They are not included in the measurements.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

That is such an important point. Louise Bayliss from the Society of St. Vincent De Paul did a really interesting analysis on this. Poverty levels post housing costs are massive for lone parents. Parents pay top-ups all the time, and have done so for years and years, and there is nothing to bridge that gap. One of the things we said is needed is an additional needs payment. Nobody necessarily wants to put more money into landlords' pockets, through the rental accommodation scheme, RAS, housing assistance payments, HAP, and whatever other system, but if that is what is there for people and those temporary solutions are now long-term, the next stage will be people living in hotels and bed and breakfast accommodation, where many of our service users are living. They really struggle. Their children’s development is impacted and they are impacted in terms of their mental and physical health. It is not good for anybody. We are talking about long-term investment in a strategy of supporting people to balance parenting, caring and work and not expecting parents, mothers and women to do everything.

Comment on this

We need to include housing. The way we are measuring poverty has to be a big issue in our discussions. Do Dr. Elliott or Ms Hasson want to add anything further? Particularly around employment, if the legislation was changed regarding the right to work from home, or remote and flexible working, the impact that might have in terms of women returning to the workforce, but also women in better-paying jobs returning to the workforce, could be significant.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

Ms Richardson is going to come in on that.

Comment on this
Ms Alex Richardson

The career and maternal penalisation mothers still experience is a huge structural barrier. I row in behind Ms Kiernan and say that public childcare would be an initial level we could pull. The State could also take over responsibility for educators’ wages. That would be huge.

We need to look again at family leave policy. It needs to be pay-related and extended. This would give women the choice to not be forced into or have the burden of care - of unpaid work - put on them but to engage with the workforce, and non-precarious work also. The care provided by women should be valued, whether it is in the public or private realm. These are really big policy levers which directly speak to this and would give women a choice. That is what this is. Caring in the home is fabulous and people should have the right to do that but they should also have the choice not to do it, regardless of their gender or role in the household.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

I thank the Senator for the question. In terms of the work of this committee, progressing the equality (miscellaneous provisions) Bill is important. It will strengthen the architecture around employment law in the State. The EU directive on pay transparency is another piece of European legislation that this State has failed to transpose. We should also transpose the EU directive on standards for equality bodies, which will strengthen the work of IHREC and the powers that it has in this space.

At the policy tier, it is disappointing that the Roadmap for Social Inclusion 2026-2030 has no specific actions on gender equality in the labour market. There is an opportunity to revisit that.

In terms of the experiences of particular groups of women and girls, we must look at the employment commitments across all of the equality strategies - not only the national strategy for women and girls but also the national Traveller and Roma integration strategy, the human rights disability strategy and the LGBTIQ strategy so that we strengthen the legislative framework and access to justice and the labour market.

We have a strong focus on decent work. As our colleagues have said, the focus can be on activation but IHREC has-----

Comment on this

Making work pay, yes.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

IHREC has always focused on decent work. We conducted a research report with the Economic and Social Research Institute. It identified six dimensions of decent work in Ireland. It was consensus-based across different social partners. We would stress the importance of decent work and not just activation.

Comment on this

I know I am running out of time. I will come in for the second round.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Apologies for my absence, but I was asking an oral question in the Dáil Chamber. I hope my questions have not already been asked. I will come first to One Family and ask about its new futures employability programme. I note it has a 75% progression rate. How many people have gone through the programme? It has been a success. Will the witnesses outline what the programme entails? What is the nature of the programme? What are the requirements to access it? What supports are provided to participants, especially lone parents?

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

I thank the Cathaoirleach for the question. We have been running the new futures employability programme for approximately 20 years. Hundreds of parents have gone through it. We have delivered it in different ways. We now have an e-course. We can deliver it online or in person. That was a response to the Covid-19 pandemic. It also means that we can deliver the course to parents around the country.

Part of the reason is how it has been funded. It has tended to be funded through pilot EU funding over three-year periods. To avoid no funding and staff lay-offs, a philanthropic donor came in two and a half years ago to fund its next iteration. That was welcome. We now have funding in place until next year through another philanthropic donor and through the gender-equality EIST funding, which has just been rolled out by the Department of equality. That is a much shorter period than it should have been.

What is different about new futures is that we, in One Family, understand lone parents, shared parenting and the whole context. People get employability and personal development supports but they also have access to other things, such as parenting support, information, a help line and therapy if they need it. The key parts are personal development, constructive challenge, one-to-one key working support and fairly standard employability support. What we are now looking at doing, through the next funding we have, is piloting with local employment services, which are Government-funded, to engage with people on the jobseekers' transition allowance. We will partner. We will do our part and they will do their part, and we will see what the outcomes are like. A progression rate of 75% to further or higher education, training or employment is incredibly high by anyone's standards.

We have people who are very distant from the labour market as well as some who are quite close. Active addiction can be an issue. We have people who are actively homeless. We have people with major challenges. We sometimes partner with other specialist organisations to support them. However, these people are motivated. They are not being made do it and it is not mandatory. These people are hugely ambitious for themselves and their children and they want to get out of the trap they are in. Does that answer the Cathaoirleach's question?

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes. Is it a ten-module course over a year?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

Sorry. Yes, it runs over eight months so it is kind of an academic year. We would start bringing people in and recruiting them and then it would be over two terms on two to three mornings a week, obviously when the children are in school. There would be key working throughout that period. There would be parent mentoring or other wraparound supports as needed. What we are going to do is halve that time when we are working with the LÉAS next year to see how that goes.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Great.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

We need a way in for funding and we are waiting to see about the pathways to work scheme. Apparently that is finalised so we will see what is in there. Lone parents around the country need something like this specialist programme to help them get to the next stage.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you. I move to the National Women's Council. I am going to play devil's advocate a little. I would like to see us moving closer to a public model and I note your big campaign, Together for Public. When we are talking about female entrepreneurship and different things, in rural Ireland especially a lot of private businesses are run by women. What do you see that future model looking like? Is there still that choice and that availability of private providers, who often are female entrepreneurs? You get my angle.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

Yes, and to be fair we get that quite a lot. I want to call out that we have childcare providers in the Together for Public alliance. They are saying they would like access to the Government paying the wages and all the different supports and services out there and then they would be happy to move over to this model. There are a lot of people saying they would really appreciate and welcome this because of the stress and pressures, especially people in the individual rural ones. Some of the bigger ones making huge profits are not so interested but the smaller ones are really finding it difficult to keep the lights on. A lot of the baby rooms have been closed in those services as well because they do not have the staff. They would also be happy for the Government to come in and support with paying of the wages.

Whenever we think about our education and health systems, there are private options there. It is not ideal and not something we should want in Ireland. It should be one level for everyone, but it is not to dismiss that they are there. Having a public model of childcare, which is the dream or the goal, would still mean there were probably certain areas where we have these deserts where there is some sort of private model still out there.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes and that is important in terms of the way our childminding has evolved. At the moment there are a lot of women who worked, had children and left the workforce and went back to childminding as a kind of back to education. They have turned into wonderful very small providers and people are a bit nervous when we start talking about the public model. They are nervous we are trying to get rid of the neighbours who are providing childcare to two or three children.

Turning to IHREC in the minute I have left, we are trying to transpose the directives as quickly as we possibly can and putting pressure on when we can about the two you brought up. Will you outline for us again in practical terms the real difference they will make on the ground for gender equality when they are transposed - in 36 seconds?

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

Yes. With the pay transparency directive we will have an approach across Europe which is about improving transparency around not only the advertised jobs but the recruitment process and also across promotion and women having a career in different sectors. The standards directives for equality bodies will give us a whole range of different powers to do with monitoring and reporting on equality in the State. It will give us data and this committee has, in a very welcome way, always been very evidence-based and data-driven and it will strengthen that. It will also improve access to justice in terms of the information people have and people's awareness of their rights. Also, looking at specific groups, including reasonable accommodation for disabled people in terms of access to provision. The standards for equality bodies are quite comprehensive. They enhance the powers of IHREC as the national equality body but ultimately they are part of the wider architecture so we can have the equality (miscellaneous provisions) Bill, the pay transparency directive and the standards for equality bodies. That is an architecture that is modern, up-to-date and strong enough to advance gender equality.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Go raibh maith agat. You did very well there in a minute and a half.

We are now moving to the second round. I will start again with Deputy Dempsey.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. My question is again for the National Women's Council. It relates to political gender quotas. I find them to be quite a blunt instrument. I am sure that, possibly, they were not implemented in the way the council's members would have expected or hoped. What can we do now that they are there? What do the witnesses suggest would be a way of improving that system while ensuring we have enough women in politics?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

At the National Women's Council we have a gender quota alliance with a mix of other organisations that agree we should have quotas. At the minute there is a slight concern out there that people do not agree that we need to have quotas. Research is out there to show that when they are there and used properly, they work. We get the representation that we want. There is also a piece around keeping the foot on the pedal. We have to keep advocating for it. What we need to see is more engagement. It is hard when there are no elections coming up to engage with particular bodies. We are at the stage now - we are a couple of years out - to start the engagement and to show the importance of having diversity within our systems. Whenever we talk about gender quotas we are also now talking about having nested quotas. It is not just about having women but having a representation of who the women are in Ireland in public bodies. At the minute there is a bit of a lull in terms of gender quotas just because there are no elections coming up, but we still have the alliance. Part of that is research done by See Her Elected and Women for Election around the numbers that we need to have in terms of the nested quotas. We are going to use that to now start lobbying going forward. The lull is a concern because whenever we hear of quotas we think that these women do not deserve to be there, so there is a challenge that we need to meet to make sure that people realise that women have every right to be in this room at these tables and having these conversations.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Hasson. I will leave it there because I have a question to the Minister.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Our line Minister is in for oral questions this morning, so there can be a bit of a conflict of schedules.

Comment on this

I have a question for the National Women's Council. In its statement it speaks about the ambition of building a feminist Ireland. I would like to explore what exactly that means. There is no single feminist viewpoint. Many women who would describe themselves as feminist would disagree with the National Women's Council on significant issues. I am one of them. I include questions around gender identity, self-identification and the balance between sex-based rights and gender-based rights. Equally, there are many women who take more traditional views on family life, care and motherhood and who may not identify as feminists at all. Given that diversity of opinion, how does the women's council distinguish between advocating for the interests of women generally and advocating for one particular strand of feminist thought? When it comes before this committee and presents policy recommendations in the name of women, what does it do to ensure that women who disagree with its organisation's position, including dissenting feminists and women with more traditional viewpoints, are genuinely heard and represented? Are these women heard and represented by the National Women's Council?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

I thank Senator Keogan very much for her question. I thank her for her honesty as well. It is much appreciated. I will go back to the fact that we are a membership-based organisation. We have over 200 members in the National Women's Council. That goes from grassroots organisations, other civil society members, NGOs, right up to the unions. We take our mandate from our members. Every year we have an AGM and motions are brought forward. This year we had 21, which is quite a large number. We listen to our members. They are the people that we advocate for and to whom we are beholden. We also use the information that we are taking from the voices of women on the ground to bring it to the Government, to lobby and to get into policy. I mean the national strategy for women and girls and the next domestic, sexual and gender-based violence, DSGBV, strategy that we spoke about earlier. A huge part of our work is looking at the members and what they want us to do, but also by looking at equality. Essentially, we feel the work of the National Women's Council is to progress equality for everybody in Ireland. In our opening statement we talk about men being allowed to take up more paternity leave and having it related to their pay because we want an equal Ireland for everyone.

In terms of the people who do not agree with us, everybody has a right to an opinion.

We take everybody's voices on board, but our mandate is from our members. They are the people who we will listen to the most.

On traditional views, there has been a lot of talk about the tradwife influencer movement. That came up very strongly a couple months ago. If a woman wants to be at home raising her children, she should also be supported to do that. We are very strong about that. Today, we are talking about our leave policies, extending leave and increasing support for women to stay at home to raise their children. Our issue with the tradwife influencer movement is that there are women out there who are making a lot of money telling other women to stay at home and to not have jobs and not have financial independence. I would be concerned about that. However, if a woman wants to stay at home to raise children-----

Comment on this

Does Ms Hasson think a child would thrive better with the mother at home?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

Children thrive in all sorts of circumstances. Children need love, care and nourishment. We call out that we would love to have a parent at home for the first year of a child's life. A lot of our policies call out for that first year because that is important. There are a lot of women in Ireland right now who cannot do that because financially they cannot afford to-----

Comment on this

It is driven financially.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

For some people, it is but not for everyone. I think-----

Comment on this

Would Ms Hasson say it is for the majority of women?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

I do not have figures on that to hand. I can look into what evidence we would have for that. It is definitely a factor. I have friends with children who would have loved to have stayed off work but could not afford to do so. I also have friends who were looking forward to getting back to work and contributing in the way that they wanted to contribute. Children do not necessarily need that for long periods. Children thrive whenever they have loving adults around them, whether that be parents, foster parents or whatever the case may be. As regards our organisation, we see our role as one of advancing equality in Ireland and listening to our members as well.

Comment on this

I have not seen the National Women's Council of Ireland since the family and care referendums, in which it promoted a yes-yes vote. The electorate decisively rejected those proposals. What lessons did the organisation learn from that result? Did it lead to any reflection that there may be a substantial gap between the priorities of professional advocacy organisations and the priorities of many women, carers and families? Does it consider that the public simply got it wrong? Ms Hasson is telling us that the National Women's Council of Ireland represents over 200 members. Did the unions get it wrong? Did every organisation in the country get it wrong? Her organisation used public money at the time to promote that message.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

Lots of organisations were either on the yes-yes or the no-no side and everybody learned a lot. We have spoken about it before-----

Comment on this

There were no organisations on the no-no side and very few people on the no-no side, particularly that used money public money, taxpayers' money. The National Women's Council of Ireland was one of the organisations that promoted a yes-yes vote.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

Absolutely.

Comment on this

It used public money to do that.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

For us, we felt-----

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does the Senator want to allow Ms Hasson to answer? There is only a minute left. Go ahead, Ms Hasson.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

-----at the time that the yes-yes vote was about equality and ensuring that both a mother and-or a father-----

Comment on this

Did the public get it wrong?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

The wording did not help. We believe that the core of that campaign was about equality.

Comment on this

The public got it wrong - 75% of them.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

That is absolutely not what I am saying.

Comment on this

The NWCI's members got it wrong then. Somebody got it wrong. The 200 organisations that the National Women's Council of Ireland seems to represent were fully behind it on the yes-yes campaign. Is that what Ms Hasson is saying?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

A lot of them were and I am-----

Comment on this

A lot of them were.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

Yes.

Comment on this

Were there people who were not with the organisation?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

I was not there at the time but possibly. We went to our members, asked them what they wanted us to vote for and they said yes-yes. Our belief at the time was that it was about equality. As an organisation that is here to promote equality, that is what we believed at the time and what we advocated for.

Comment on this

Thank God, the public got it right.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We move to Senator Cosgrove.

Comment on this

I will talk about what we can do as a committee and how we can work with the organisations present on a public model of childcare. The Labour Party was the first political party to call for a public model of childcare. We can consistently see that there is a move towards a corporatisation of childcare. I am glad Ms Hasson brought up the issue. Everyone wants the State to intervene as regards paying the wages of childcare workers. Wages are not going up for childcare workers and the price of childcare is not coming down for parents.

Huge profits are being made. It is completely wrong that there should be any profit, let alone massive profits, in the provision of any type of care.

How can we as a committee support the work the witnesses do? Do we need to reform county childcare committees? How can we work to ensure the current model does not result in out-of-control costs? In effect, there is a movement of State and public money into the hands of multinational, billion-euro corporations. I refer to the sell-off to larger corporations. What safeguards do we need to have to ensure this cannot continue? What role can the committee play in that regard?

I am not talking about small providers. We have previously discussed incorporating small providers in a model of State care in order to stop profits from going out of control or there being a corporatisation of childcare. How can the committee support the witnesses in their role?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

The disappointment we had with the budget this year was that it was adding more subsidies and increases to a system that is not working. We are calling for structural reform. It would be absolutely fantastic to have the backing of the committee on that.

I am glad the Senator mentioned wages. In Ireland, six in ten low-paid workers are women, a lot of whom are in caring roles and work in caring facilities. As the Senator mentioned, their wages are not increasing. They will get a small amount this year, which everybody was told to be extremely delighted with, but that does not help. They are in precarious positions. The turnover in crèches is high, and that is not the fault of the managers of those crèches. Rather, it is because they cannot offer the conditions they would like to offer. The State should take on wages, as is the case with teachers, and staff should receive increases, better hours and proper training. Teachers get days to go and have training, and we expect our teachers to be trained and supported. We do not have that in early years education. A lot of people, mostly women, are taking time in the evenings and at weekends to educate and upskill themselves.

Childcare committees around the country need support. For the committee to get behind the State delivering all elements of childcare and early years education would be a significant support because it should be seen as social infrastructure and as important as our education system for primary and secondary level. It should be as important as housing and all of the other systems we have, but right now it is not.

Comment on this
Ms Alex Richardson

As the Senator said, market-led systems struggle with affordability, retention, recruitment, inclusion and equal access because profit, rather than the well-being of children, is at the centre in childcare. I would like to offer some practical realities of what we hope a public model would look like. Private, women-led small setting providers and community not-for-profit services are essential infrastructure for tackling the lack of places and affordability issues at present. This could be done by looking to education and training boards and local authorities, which are fantastic and want to become more deeply involved.

The new State-led provision from the Government is a great step forward, but we would like to see it as a direction of travel towards a public model and having the State take a direct and enthusiastic role in delivering these provisions. Alongside the remit and work of the new forward planning unit in the Department, which should be strengthened and broadened to help with the public model, further integration of provision into community planning across all Departments is crucial. A whole-of-government approach is required. It is feasible. It is done in other countries with the same wealth and of the same size as Ireland. We would appreciate support for that.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

We are focused on childcare, but IHREC's policy statement on care published a couple of years ago spoke to other forms of care which also impact gender equality in terms of the different groups of women who are in receipt of different types of care, for example, disabled women who wish to participate independently in society, and the discussion around the squeezed middle. Women of certain ages and stages in their lives require family care rather than childcare. We need to be aware of that. IHREC has consistently said that the market is not delivering what is essentially a public good.

When we raised this with CEDAW, that was very much what that committee was saying about a public model of childcare. Our recommendation is that we should have a very detailed and adequately resourced roadmap for this transition because we have found, when having conversations about gender equality in Ireland, that these are the perpetual issues. We talked today about work, violence and care, which are issues we have been talking about for decades. It concerns me that we continue to talk about them for-----

Comment on this

That is something that could really change the dynamics.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

At this stage, because of the expertise of our colleagues in the National Women's Council and One Family, the evidence is there. It is there from the citizens' assembly. It is there from the Oireachtas gender equality committee. It is there from CEDAW. Everybody is saying we need to move towards a public model, but we need to have a very detailed roadmap so it does not continue to be put on the long finger. That would be our main message.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

We totally support a public model. We are a member of the Together for Public alliance. It is a basic necessity for people who are parenting on their own to have access to childcare and out-of-school care that is of good quality and is accessible. Until recently, my colleague Ms Gormley was one of those small, private providers.

Comment on this

I can testify to the wonderful work Ms Gormley does.

Comment on this
Ms Aolish Gormley

As a rural early years provider for ten years, I have heard everything today, including what Ms Hasson said about the lack of recognition for those in the sector. I left the sector because there was not a recognition of the importance of early childhood education equivalent to that for primary and secondary education, which is really unfortunate. We talk about days when early years providers are not paid. They do not get the time off to train and upskill. They do not get the same allowances as teachers, nor do they get the same recognition. Ultimately, I would have stayed in the sector had the State taken over and taken responsibility for paying our wages.

Comment on this

I apologise, as I have two committees at the same time on a Thursday, so it is always tricky. In terms of gender equality, I am very much of the view that we have to bring men with us on this journey and we have to do a better job of articulating to men why equality benefits them as well. The rate of take-up of paternity leave is just over 50%, and we know it is a lot less for parent's leave. I still believe that many men do not know they are eligible for parent's leave. The pay-related payment is also a part of that, but that is for both women and men.

I have repeatedly asked the Ministers for Social Protection and children to do more in this space in terms of awareness campaigns, and also include pay-related payments linked to pay for both parents. What do the witnesses think we can do to encourage men to take up their paternity leave but also their parent's leave? It was good to see the Tánaiste take paternity leave recently. That sends an important signal, but we need to do so much more. We know in industries such as construction that taking paternity leave is just not culturally acceptable. We know that men in more senior positions in a lot of organisations do not take it, and that then sets the example for people further down the line. I would like to hear the witnesses' views on that.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

I agree with everything Deputy Boland said. The National Women's Council has members that are men's groups. That was not always the case. Again, it is about the recognition that men need to be in the conversation and brought on the journey. To call out the Tánaiste, I agree absolutely that people should lead by example in that they should not have policies in place which they do not make use of, so that was great to see.

Paternity benefit is only €299 a week. A big thing we have heard people say is that they could not afford to go down to that, whereas we know women do so for many weeks when they take maternity leave. Financially, there needs to be change but it is more about a cultural shift.

There is research from other countries showing that where men have taken more of their leave, or just taken their leave, women actually have better health outcomes because there is more support for them at home and because men really see the value of the care work they do. We need more research to show the benefits for both men and women of parental leave, alongside policy and legislative changes around the finances. We see that in countries where men take more leave, there are better outcomes for families in general.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

I thank the Deputy for her question. We are talking about gender equality. That involves looking at equality between men and women but also how gender equality benefits men and boys as well as women and girls. It is really important to look at where there are opportunities to address stereotypes. The national strategy for women and girls has a whole stream of work around stereotypes. I would very much support investment in, and enhancement of, that effort. IHREC is preparing to launch our new education work in schools and we are very much part of the conversation in terms of starting early and in the arenas in which boys and girls are engaged with each other.

Our colleagues in the National Women's Council of Ireland touched on the fact that as much as we talk about the structural barriers to women and girls achieving equality, men also face those sorts of structural barriers. On the Deputy's point, we have had some movement in terms of parental leave and paternity leave but it is also about the structural environment in which men are working, the financial pressures on men, etc. In that regard, I would very much look to, for example, our policy statement on business and human rights. As well as dealing with barriers facing women, it is about removing structural barriers to enable men to access information about what they are entitled to and changing environments where men are in a way that supports them to engage in gender equality. There are multiple levels at which men and boys can be supported and those would be the points on which I would focus.

I always point to the need to advance the equality (miscellaneous provisions) Bill in order to strengthen the architecture for equality in the State. IHREC has a Your Sights service, which involves a whole programme of work that includes outreach across the country to inform men and boys of their rights and entitlements and how they can access them and also to enable us, as the national equality and human rights institution, to hear from boys and men about the barriers they face. We are very open to hearing that and then seeking to address it in the work we are doing, including research, policy, legal cases, etc. I again thank the Deputy for her question.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

It is interesting that in separated families, it becomes really clear that there are gender roles and parenting roles at play. In One Family, we work with mams and dads in all kinds of different situations and we take a very child-centred point of view. There really is not any policy that supports shared parenting in Ireland and there really is not any good research in this area. We have done the only national survey on shared parenting. A little bit of information has come through in the Growing Up in Ireland study. We really do not understand the landscape.

We have a single person child carer credit. It used to be the case, when the tax credit had a different name, that each parent received it; now only one gets it. That has caused huge conflict between parents and has actually taken money away from children. It is often the case that children of separated parents live in two homes, with two bedrooms, two sets of possessions and so on, and that costs their parents money. The change in the tax credit hugely disadvantaged a lot of dads and we would like to see that change reversed.

One of the unexpected outcomes from Nordic countries that have very good parental and paternal leave is that because dads had to take the leave, it became culturally acceptable to do so and very common to see dads spending time with very young children. If those families separated, it became an unexpected outcome that children spent half the time with each parent. That outcome was not by design but, rather, the result of the positive difference in terms of the level of confidence and cultural competence acquired by dads. We are way behind on that in Ireland.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I am sorry for being late. Like Deputy Boland, I am a member of another committee that is sitting today. I really appreciate the witnesses being here and I am glad to participate in the discussion. On Ms Kiernan's final point about the Nordic model of parental leave, does it cater for different levels of remuneration as per the salary of the individual who takes the leave?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

I do not know. I could not tell the Deputy that at the moment. The way it certainly was when I did a visit to Sweden was that it was almost full salary for a year between parents. It was very much from a child-centred and gender-equality point of view, and then it had positive knock-on effects. It meant it did not cost as much money to have a child as it does in Ireland.

Comment on this

I see the logic in the differential rates of parental leave per salary, but I have some concern that it also compounds economic disadvantage and economic inequality, and that people who are taking time from their employer to care for their children should all be remunerated equally. I understand the point that it possibly is a barrier to some people taking parental leave.

I am going to take the opportunity presented by the IHREC to ask some questions on the current scourge we have of violence against women. It is deeply concerning to me, particularly the level of femicide we are encountering across the island at the moment. I scratch my head as to what is causing or generating it. We really have to do something more to intervene to try to stop it. Have the witnesses any insight into what is causing it?

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

In previous discussions we talked about the issue of femicide, both in Ireland and on the island, and the growing concern about the effectiveness of the prevention of that and the response and the learning from it. We certainly think there needs to be more data and research around that, including reviews of femicide and familicide, to understand what some of the dynamics are. One of the things I mentioned was that Ireland will have a thematic review on violence against women and girls under the Council of Europe next year. That is an opportunity to have a bit of focus on femicide and familicide and to understand what is going on in Ireland. No more than any other area of violence against women and girls, it is complex. There are many different factors. The main focus for us is on prevention and support for women. We also talked about support for families and social networks where femicide has taken place. An increasing number of people have been impacted by femicide.

Comment on this

A related point is the apparent increasing prevalence in the level of domestic violence. Are the State's response and the preventative measures it is taking sufficient?

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

Our view is that if we are seeing increases in domestic violence and femicide then the actions are not sufficient. We talked earlier about the opportunity for the development of the fourth national strategy on domestic and gender-based violence and to be ambitious around that. We should also look at the role of the public body with responsibility in terms of Cuan's independence, its policy function and resources to it. At a very basic level we need to be investing more in support services and refuge accommodation. Women and families in those situations need to be able to get to a place of safety and get there urgently. What we have in Ireland is the potential in terms of the identification of who the key stakeholders and key actors are in this area. What we need now is an evidence-based and well-resourced response around violence against women and girls, and against men as well. That clearly is not fully working at the moment. The other thing I mentioned is that the Council of Europe focus will be on building trust. That is the whole area of how we build trust within Irish society, so that when women, children and men seek support they will actually be supported and it will be responded to.

Comment on this

One issue raised in the One Family opening statement is the greater level of child poverty among one-parent families.

What suggestions or proposals do the witnesses have for the Government to try to address this?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

It is to target children living in one-parent families either through specific childcare measures, such as the child support payment, education supports or indeed the payments. There are also far higher rates of homelessness. It is a fact that it is very difficult to be a parent on one income or a low income and pay for childcare and housing in Ireland. These were always the two biggest costs before the cost-of-living crisis. It is really difficult to manage those things on an average, low or social welfare income. Targeting is what many anti-poverty organisations, such as ours, would be saying. We are not seeing that reflected in policies or practices around identifying where most of the poor children are living, which is in one-parent families. The question is how their parents can be supported. If a person does not have childcare, out-of-school care or housing, it is practically impossible to move forward in life from poverty to a sustainable career.

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

Violence against women and domestic violence are being massively compounded by the housing crisis. We mentioned the lack of refuge spaces. Even if we had refuges in every county, which we absolutely need and we advocate for, it would not be enough. Where do women and their children go after they have to leave the refuge? Some of them are only allowed to stay for two or three weeks. We also know that the most difficult and dangerous time for a woman is whenever she is about to leave or whenever she unfortunately has to return home. We have heard of many cases from our members where women have had to return home after being in a refuge and things became extremely violent at that stage. The National Women's Council is doing a lot of work. This month we are launching a legal analysis done by Mercy Law about housing pathways for victim-survivors of domestic violence. We see that as being a real support to get women out of those homes safely and permanently.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It falls to me again. Tradwives came up earlier. I am conscious that there are row-backs against them in many countries around the world. I always think of those videos from Afghanistan in the sixties and seventies that show women working, wearing swimsuits and living the life we are living, and now they are almost invisible in society and not able to go to school. We see the row-back on reproductive rights even in America, which was seen as such a progressive country. I wish that the tradwife social media trend had been called something different. We are so proud of our Irish mammies here. We want to celebrate mammies who want to stay at home. We need to do more to support women who want to stay at home and enable them to do it financially for as long as they need to. That is important. We want to keep the traditions like the brown bread, the stew, the apple pies and all the things we are losing. How do we manage to celebrate that and not conflate it with this tradwife social media trend in terms of the vulnerability of financial dependence on partners?

Lucky you if you get a loving and respectful partner who makes mutual decisions. However, when someone puts themselves in the position of not having any financial income, they are then financially dependent on a partner who could potentially turn violent or engage in coercive control. They might also engage in infidelity and if a person does not have their own income, they are extremely vulnerable. Unequal decision-making is being promoted by some of these social media content creators around trying to go back to a family vote, but of course that family vote would not be the woman voting. It would only be the man voting and would that be an equal decision vote? It is crazy stuff.

Ms Hasson highlighted that many of these women who are encouraging women to become financially dependent on their husbands are making money from the posts. I think it is 42% of the celebration we want to see of homemaking and the tradition of staying at home with children versus sixty-something per cent of those content creators who are being paid to promote that content and the dangerous algorithm that makes the problem worse. I might search for how to plan a wonderful day as a stay-at-home mam for my three-year-old and very quickly the algorithm brings me to content about completely submitting to my husband and not having many friends.

How do we combat the dangerous sides of the tradwife phenomenon without people feeling like we are targeting the traditional wife or homemaker? Do the witnesses have any thoughts on this?

Comment on this
Ms Corrinne Hasson

I agree with absolutely everything the Cathaoirleach has said. As I mentioned, the terminology is probably the worst because it is "tradwife" and "traditional wife". We always refer to "tradwife influencers" because that is what they are; they are content creators who are there to make money. As the Cathaoirleach mentioned, somebody in America recently called for women to lose the right to vote. These are not women who are promoting traditional Irish mammies, so to speak. A lot of it is about awareness. It is a bit like the manosphere. It is about awareness of what these terms actually mean and what they mean for young people. We also have to look behind it in that some young women are looking at the pressures of life and thinking that this would probably be a good enough life to fall into. It is about looking at the core of why young women are attracted to this kind of lifestyle.

A lot of it comes from the fact that, particularly in Ireland, we are struggling with the housing crisis. Those in well-paid jobs are struggling. When looking at society as a whole, and what we are presenting to young people, men and women in Ireland, terminology is important. When the action plan for the national strategy for women and girls was launched back in August a lot of people felt that it was an attack on the traditional wife. Some work was done to combat this but not enough. There is work to be done by the Department and the committee to make sure whatever campaign there may be going forward really looks at the terminology and the impact it has on young women and young men. Dr. Elliott mentioned education and getting to our young people at a very early age, using age-appropriate language to explain equality and explain what some of these movements actually mean and the impact it might have on them.

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

Over the years, some of the debates I and One Family have been involved in have pitted a traditional stay-at-home mother against financial independence or State supports for women in a broader sense. That is our older version of it in Ireland. What the Cathaoirleach is speaking about is a newer online version that has been primarily imported. What many of us want is choice for parents and women so they can do their best to support their children in whatever circumstance they are in. When you put lone parents into the frame, the whole thing explodes. The Cathaoirleach is absolutely right; it is dangerous for somebody in a vulnerable relationship to leave. They have far less choice and fewer options. They and their children are more likely to continue to experience abuse over a prolonged period of time. This is dangerous so it has to be seen in a public health frame as well as an issue of equality and understanding how the internet gives us messages.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We have moved so far in accepting there are different types of families and what different families look like. When we look at lone families, blended families or whatever a family looks like, whatever about the risk to women, there is a risk to children in terms of shame if we go back to an idea of what a family must look like and anything else is wrong. There are many different types of families, whether families of widows or widowers or blended families. It is a worrying trend.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

There is a digital media ecosystem, which includes the tradwife influencer but also the manosphere, that is monetised and poorly regulated. We have benefited from engagement with other public bodies, such as Coimisiún na Meán, which are very focused on looking at areas such as media literacy and how regulation can be strengthened. It is clear that this ecosystem is having social and real-life consequences, and this toxicity is contrary to equality and human rights. It is something we are very engaged in and very aware of.

To reflect on the citizens' assembly five years ago and on the Oireachtas joint committee, and the developments over the past five years, there has been the growth of digital media and AI and the lack of regulation.

There is probably also a lack of management of the growing influence of business on the public sphere, which we have articulated in our policy statement on business.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I had better cut myself off because I might cut off the members. I have two members online who can put their hand up if they want to come in for a question. The members in the room may also want a third question. I call Senator Keogan.

Comment on this

Coimisiún na Meán has a role in relation to regulation, whether it be on websites or elsewhere. I would love the organisations to advocate for the abolition of websites for human trafficking in this country as much as they would for the abolition of the tradwife algorithms that appear as well. I think the first one is slightly more important. The trafficking of women in this country is more important than dealing with the tradwife. I do not think that is a thing at all in this country.

In relation to the numbers for single parents, whether it be mothers or fathers, we are looking at 186,500 mother families and 33,000 father families. Therefore, one in four children in this country lives in a single-parent household, which is higher than the EU average of one in seven. Why is that?

Comment on this
Ms Karen Kiernan

Why is it higher? It is similar to Britain. We have a similar demographic in that respect. Those figures are from the census and do not reflect shared parenting. I would wonder how the families are counted in other countries, and whether people re-partner at higher rates, because divorce happens quicker and there are higher remarriage rates in other countries. That might be masking it a bit. Some analysis would need to be done to explain that. Nonetheless, it is a very common family form, with one in four families with children and 25% of children. When we are talking about issues like poverty and family equality, we are talking about a lot of people in Ireland.

Comment on this

I have a question for the panel as a whole. All of the organisations have advocated for policy changes over many years, and Governments have introduced a range of measures in areas such as childcare subsidies, parental leave, workplace rights and income supports. What evidence do the organisations have that the measures already introduced have made a positive difference? Where can we point to clear improvements in outcomes for women, carers or lone-parent families? Where do the witnesses think the evidence shows that current policies are still falling short?

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

I will revert to the Senator's point on human trafficking. I want to flag that IHREC is the EU national rapporteur on human trafficking, so we very much welcome the Senator’s focus on that area. We will revert to her about the specific questions that she raised. This whole area of people being trafficked into Ireland, but also trafficked within Ireland and sexually exploited, is a really current and important area of work. It certainly does speak to areas such as online regulation and a range of different things, so we very much welcome the Senator’s focus on that.

Comment on this

The number of gardaí working in that section at this moment in time is 16 for the entire country. It is tiny.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

We would be happy to engage with the Senator on that. I am conscious that during the EU Presidency, Ireland is hosting the European network of national rapporteurs, so there will be a focus on that area in the next month.

Regarding the whole range of different areas around gender equality, we still need more data and evidence, but I would say that the data and evidence have definitely improved to help us understand the issues facing gender equality, the barriers to it and the effectiveness of interventions in a changing world. The fact that we now have a national equality data strategy is very important. I think there has been movement on a number of the issues. The main comment from IHREC is that this improvement needs to be accelerated. Of course, as I said in my opening statement, given the establishment of Cuan and the fact that we are about to have a fourth national strategy on domestic, sexual and gender-based violence, there is a whole range of different elements around gender equality where we can see progress. I think it is important that in the context of rehearsing some of the real challenges around gender equality, we do not lose the wins.

In terms of areas we have particular concerns about, and we have talked about violence against women, the whole area of political representation of women in all areas of local and national government is relevant. One of the areas we raised with the Dáil committee was the fact that Ireland is so low in terms of the number of women in the Dáil, Seanad and Cabinet. It was very shocking to us how deteriorated that situation of political representation has become in Ireland. That is the area we would say is an opportunity for us to really take action because we have several years until the next national election.

Comment on this
Ms Alex Richardson

I welcome the reflection on some positives for women and gender equality in Ireland. I pre-emptively prepped some facts and figures for us to reflect on. Ireland ranked sixth in the index of the European Institute for Gender Equality for 2025. This is an increase of 7.8 points since 2020. We sit well above the wider EU average. We rank first in the EU in terms of our education system. Women are nearly three fourths of graduates in health, humanities and the arts. We rank fourth in the EU for women in senior management roles, which is great to see. We already reflected on women in business in terms of childcare. Our gender pay gap sits between 8% and 12%, which is also massively below the EU average. That is really great to see but more work is needed, as we have already discussed at length today. We will keep banging the drum around care, the recognition of unpaid labour as necessary for paid labour, the need to look at family leave policy again, as well as childcare and moving towards that public model.

Comment on this

What is not talked about very much is violence within the gay community. While we focus on violence against women, a lot of violence goes unreported within the gay community as well. Dr. Elliott might know the statistics. One in four men in a gay relationship in this country experience violence in it.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

It is really important when we are talking about violence in Irish society that we are as inclusive in the conversation as possible. As a national equality body, we sit on monitoring committees for all of the equality strategies and that includes the LGBTIQ strategy. I thank the Senator for raising that as a matter of concern. I do not have the data to hand, but it goes back to what I already said about the importance of disaggregated data by all the equality groups and, in terms of violence against any group in Irish society, where that appears. It is very important that An Garda Síochána breaks down its status so we can see who it has contact with. It is very important that the Courts Service does that as well, along with the support services.

Comment on this

Are the support services there in respect of domestic violence within the LGBT community?

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

That is what I want to come back to specifically in terms of a comment and recommendation. More generally, what we have noted is the lack of support services, tailored support services and those different pathways, so people are aware that they are experiencing violence and have information about how to find safety and protection in order to move forward. I thank the Senator for her question.

Comment on this

Due to time constraints, Dr. Elliott was interrupted while making a point about business in relation to the Cathaoirleach’s own question.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

In relation to my question.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

What question was that?

Comment on this

It was an issue regarding tech business and the impact of technology, the web and the manosphere. A point was being made about the role of business in that.

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

If we look at the work of the citizens' assembly and the joint Oireachtas committee approximately five years ago and what has changed in the world, it is very much the development of new technologies and AI frontier technologies. It is also how they have been used by a poorly regulated business environment to undermine gender equality and influence public discourse in a toxic manner. We published a policy statement on business and human rights earlier this year. It is a whole programme of work we are doing.

Where there is something like an intersection of mandates, that is why we work with organisations, for example, Coimisiún na Meán, to look at how we regulate business. It is disappointing that during the EU Presidency and AI summit, there was a distinct lack of any discussion around human rights and equality. What we in IHREC are looking for is a genuine conversation about the benefits of business in this space but also the need to regulate for the public good. I say that because under the EU AI Act, IHREC is one of the fundamental rights bodies, as are Coimisiún na Meán and the Electoral Commission. There are a number of us. That is a space in terms of the work of this committee because the context has changed significantly since the Citizens' Assembly on Gender Equality. That is a gap I see. That is what I was going to say. I thank the Deputy for the opportunity to say it.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will return to Senator Keogan's point on trafficking. I welcome that there is going to be a focus on it next month. Ruhama representatives were in very recently following publication of its most recent document. I would like to get a sense of what is needed more in terms of awareness and enforcement, or whether both are needed equally. Traditionally we thought of trafficking as women used for sexual exploitation. That is still a huge cohort of people who are trafficked, but the ordinary person at home who goes in to get their nails done in a salon that has just popped up and is cash only, where the person doing their nails maybe does not speak English, would not necessarily think of the potential that that person has been trafficked. It is often a similar situation in vape shops. Those are two of the common areas where we hear about people being trafficked.

The craziest statistic regarding escort websites that often show victims of trafficking is that the time of their highest boost is around agricultural shows and the busiest times are between lunchtime and 5 p.m. to 7 p.m. The ordinary person at home is horrified when they hear about things like that happening in Ireland. What are the witnesses’ thoughts on what more is needed in terms of awareness and enforcement, or are they needed equally? What can citizens do when they are in a place such as a vape shop? If a person is going to an escort website to book somebody, he or she has to have a fair assumption that that person might be trafficked. That is on his or her own conscience. However, what can the person going into a nail salon or a vape shop do to help him or her understand if the person serving them is a victim of trafficking?

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

The Cathaoirleach is absolutely correct. I touched on trafficking into Ireland but it happens within Ireland as well. People are moved within the country. Obviously, we share a border with Northern Ireland so there is trafficking across the Border and us having a land border with the UK is of concern in terms of the wider European Union. Public awareness and information about what trafficking actually involves is really important. Recently, we published our report on child trafficking, which has thankfully gained a lot of publicity, but there is the whole area of labour exploitation and where that is. As the Cathaoirleach said, it apples to service economies, such as car washes, nail bars and vape shops. We have also heard of cases of labour exploitation, for example, in agricultural and fishing work.

There is value in having public awareness around the diversity of trafficking. I am from Northern Ireland where there was a big public awareness push around trafficking in relation to things like car washes and nail bars and certainly the public conversation then changed around that. In terms of work that needs to be done, we can share information from our national anti-human trafficking rapporteur team but a real concern is the weakening of both the legislative and service framework around victims of human trafficking. Ireland has not transposed the anti-human trafficking amended directive and an infringement process was recently initiated by the European Commission. The list is starting to be quite long regarding non-transposition in this area but more widely there is concern around the lack of a strong national preventative mechanism in Ireland. I appreciate this is more for the justice committee.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I think I am probably veering slightly out of my own-----

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

In terms of this discussion about having a gender lens, IHREC has always taken the position that human trafficking is a form of gender-based violence so it is very relevant to this discussion. Probably the best thing is for us to follow up in terms of the relevance of issues around human trafficking for this committee and then for the committee to consider how it would like to take that forward with our human trafficking team.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

There is often a blurring of lines in this committee whether it is equality, education or justice. We go where we can.

In relation to care, we talked a lot today about childcare. I am conscious that we also have an ageing population. It is one thing pushing forward with paternity leave and trying to get to a point of equal leave perhaps but with the cultural piece around care being traditionally seen as a female job, we could move forward in childcare but then go backwards in relation to our ageing population and care duties, unpaid in many cases, falling back mainly on females. What are the thoughts of the witnesses on that?

Comment on this
Dr. Iris Elliott

I referred earlier to our policy statement on the whole scope of care. I thank the Cathaoirleach for raising the issue of care for older populations. There are also the rights of older people to live independently and to continue to be members of and contribute to society as they age. That includes the increase in disability and acquired disability in later life and the importance of personal assistants etc so that people can live independently.

IHREC will be the co-ordinating mechanism under the Optional Protocol to the Convention Against Torture. To the Chair's earlier point, somebody's perception of that may be that it is about police stations, prisons and all the rest but it includes things like residential care homes and social care facilities. Ireland is the last European member state not to have ratified that optional protocol. Therefore, we are not in a position to ensure older people and people living in other types of residential care are protected. That is a particular issue we want to see as part of a very broad conversation around care provision and care support across the life span.

Comment on this
Ms Alex Richardson

I feel like we have said this a lot today but care has to be viewed as an essential social and economic infrastructure. As the Chair said, burdening women with the care responsibility and removing choice is consistent across Irish culture at present still and limits their access to social, economic, political and wider life. We are currently doing some lobbying with the European Women's Lobby around the EU care strategy which is upcoming in 2027. That will have a lot of principles around embedding this politically within member states and ensuring we look to removing this feminised understanding of who must do care, and seeing it as a political and member state issue across the international system. That is a piece of work we are doing at the moment. We can update the committee on that in the future.

Comment on this
Keira Keogh An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the witnesses for their robust engagement. I know they will forward lots of details to us after this meeting. We were delighted to have them in on this important topic. I hope we can see some movement on the directives very soon. We are pushing for that. This will not be the end of this conversation.

That brings us to the conclusion of our meeting. The joint committee now stands adjourned until Thursday, 12 November at 9.30 a.m., all going well.

Comment on this