We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Climate Action

Supporting a Just Transition: Discussion (Resumed)

Contributions 187–392 of 392. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Dr. John MacNamara

It is difficult to state a simple number per hectare or tonnes per hectare. There are figures on fully cut away land. Approximately six tonnes per hectare per year in emissions flow from the site. A definitive saving number, however, will take a little longer to work out, notwithstanding that the removal of the emissions will be achieved before sequestration begins.

Comment on this
Mr. Senan Colleran

We have big ambitions in the whole renewables space, including in solar energy. In principle, putting solar panels on these lands is a good idea but, although it has connection agreements, it would need the agreement of residents and planning permission. Our focus is first on finishing out the operation towards the end of 2020. We want to concentrate on our people in the stations and to make sure they get a just transition as we move away from peat. These options will then come back to the table for consideration in future. We have big ambitions to lead the transition to a low-carbon future in Ireland across transport, heating, and energy generation. All of that is in the mix.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

There were two questions. The first related to action 110, which is about engaging with stakeholders to develop a roadmap on land use. That is for delivery in the fourth quarter. It is certainly not part of the 15% from the third quarter. It is primarily being led by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. I would need to check the status of this action with the Department.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Carroll's Department involved in the consultation process on the ending of horticultural peat extraction?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

We engage with the Department of Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht generally in respect of the peatlands strategy. Peat harvesting specifically for horticultural use would be, in the first instance, a matter for the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and the Department of Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht.

Comment on this

I will conclude on this point. As I said at our meeting with the local area education and training board and others last week, I believe we should be honest with people. By the middle of the next decade we will face fines of several hundred million euro a year as a result of changes in legislation with regard to how we account for peat. The likelihood of any form of horticultural peat extraction continuing by the middle of the next decade is close to zero. We should be honest with workers and communities in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Horticultural peat will be key to Bord na Móna decarbonising. It is probably the last piece of the equation. In the next 18 months we will reduce our horticultural peat sales by 50% as we transition to non-peat based horticultural products. We already have large contracts signed with some of our big customers. This is all part of the journey. Bord na Móna is involved in a climate change process. Our ambition it to lead the way in this regard and not to be dragged along kicking and screaming.

Comment on this

I have a number of questions. I will put them to specific delegations rather than asking everyone because time will not allow for answers from everyone. My first question is for Bord na Móna. Rewetting of bogs is under way. For example, the bog at Abbeyleix is being rehabilitated. Do the witnesses see Bord na Móna being directly involved in the enhanced rehabilitation of bogs in the future? I am not totally au fait with this. I am not a scientist but it is reported that sphagnum has huge potential to absorb carbon. Is Bord na Móna actively looking at that? What does the science say? My understanding is that the PSO can be used for that.

My second question for Bord na Móna relates to the future of the Derrinlough facility. It is successful and efficient. It is the last plant standing. I was more familiar with the facility at Mount Lucas but that went a number of years ago. The change coming in 2024 under EU regulations and the carbon tax may have an impact on Derrinlough. Has Bord na Móna looked at the potential for mixing other raw material with peat? Could a briquette made from an alternative to peat be produced at the plant?

With regard to the just transition, the unions were before the committee earlier. In the ESB's presentation, it said that it welcomed the appointment of the just transition commissioner, who will have a vital role in ensuring a co-ordinated and effective approach to the just transition. That would indicate that the ESB sees the need for some type of forum if one is going to have a co-ordinated and effective approach to the just transition for communities and workers. I do not want to put words in the witnesses' mouths, but that is what they seem to be indicating. Is Bord na Móna willing to participate and be a major player in a just transition forum for the midlands? Such a forum would bring together Bord na Móna, the ESB, workers' representatives and other key stakeholders such as Coillte to bring about this just transition. There are a number of parts involved. There are different parties in the room today. Last week we had other groups here and earlier today we had the unions in. Having sat through these hearings asking questions, I cannot help think that two representatives from each of the groups we are meeting should be brought together in a single forum. What is Bord na Móna's view of that proposal? Would it make sense?

Has Bord na Móna carried out a skills audit in respect of the workers who are facing transition or losing their jobs? I am sorry for the length of my contribution but horticultural peat is an issue of huge concern to me. I refer to Coolnacart, the Cashel bogs, and the plant at Kilberry but specifically the plant at Coolnamona. Some composting is going on there. That is what Bord na Móna has told me previously. In all the talk around just transition, there has been no mention of jobs. What is in the future for that plant? What is the timescale? Can the plant be redeployed for alternative uses? Those are my questions for Bord na Móna.

Comment on this
Dr. John MacNamara

I thank the Deputy. He spoke about the opportunities around enhanced rehabilitation. This goes back to the response I gave to Deputy Eamon Ryan in that there are a range of different ecosystems across our bogs. These will require a range of different interventions, including wetland engineering, targeted cultivation of specific seed types and, as the Deputy mentioned, the inoculation of sphagnum in bog areas, where appropriate. We are in a good position in that respect as we have a peatlands team that consists of ecologists, engineers, operatives and back office support. Our team can go out to assess the different bog areas and to see what potential there is for sphagnum inoculation. It will not be possible everywhere. There will be different interventions based on the ecosystems present. The first step is assessment, then an engineering plan is drawn up, which the operatives then implement over time.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

On the other topics the Deputy brought up, the skills audit is well under way. When the announcement was made on 8 November that the two stations would not proceed, we had all the third parties on site to begin that process. We have now completed a skills audit of approximately 150 people. We have had very good participation from the employees. They have signed up to a number of training programmes we are providing. We are working with the local regional training boards to provide these. That is ongoing and is in a good way.

With regard to the just transition commissioner, we welcome his appointment and will work closely with him. The Deputy suggested all the relevant people should be brought together in one room. We are part of the regional transition forum set up last year when Bord na Móna first announced this restructuring. Everybody is in that room, including the local representatives, Deputies, unions, the education and training boards, ESB representatives, and Bord na Móna representatives. That forum works well and we should build on it.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Donnellan comment on the Derrinlough question?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

I had already covered it. We plan to keep it going for the foreseeable future and a decision will be taken circa 2024 or 2025. On whether we will look to introduce other sustainable materials-----

Comment on this

That is the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

------we have done much work on that. Up to now, we have not found a solution that will work. It is not something we have given up on and we will continue to work on that. The challenge is that peat is a very economical source of fuel whereas alternatives would be much more expensive. The question then is whether they could be marketed and a return made on them. We have done much work on it. It is still a work in progress. We have not given up on it.

Comment on this

There was a question about Coolnamona.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

I will need to come back to the Deputy about that.

Comment on this

Okay. I have one last question for Bord na Móna. On the Edenderry plant and the PSO levy, at the moment, I understand that there is a PSO subsidy for 30% biomass. Does that need to be changed? What type of stocks in terms of peat on the bogs are on hand? Does the 30% need to increase?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

If we were to go 100% biomass, then clearly the 30% would need to be increased. We are engaging with the Department on that. The decision must be made in the coming 12 months as to what type of planning will be sought, whether it will be 100% biomass or if we will continue with a co-firing option. That will determine that, but we will definitely pursue that option.

On the biomass, we carry a regular inventory of about three to four months at any given time. Most of that is indigenous, so much of that is material that is drying. We do not put it into the power station until it has a certain moisture level. We have different levels of peat inventories by bog and region. For example, for the Edenderry power plant we have about 18 months of peat in front of it, it is the same for Derrinlough, and for horticulture we have about six months of peat in front of it. They are in keeping with our inventory levels. They are determined particularly by whether we anticipate the weather will go with us or against us in the harvesting season.

Comment on this

On the retrofit programme, has the ESB looked at the option of a green bond or a pay-and-save scheme? The ESB representatives have answered some questions on the future of the power stations, but in terms of the use of the sites, the grid connection location and water extraction licences that the company has, there are many things and a lot of departure there, so to speak, for something else to be moved in. Has the ESB looked at the option of either biomass or perhaps replacing it with a new biogas facility? Obviously, it would be of a smaller scale, but it is whether it is being looked at for purposes like that or as a staging post or transmission station for solar power. I would like a brief answer on the just transition forum. What planning is the ESB doing now for the just transition for its workers who will be losing their jobs?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

I will take parts of those questions and pass some of them to my colleagues. In terms of engaging with our staff, as I said earlier, there are about 80 staff employed between the two stations. We expect a significant number - a majority - will seek redeployment. We have a number of depots in the region and we expect to redeploy these highly skilled people if they opt for it. We will offer retraining and reskilling programmes. Some may opt for a severance programme that we will develop in the coming weeks and months, but I expect a majority to be reassigned in the broader ESB business. Having spoken to these people last week, the indication is that many will take that up and we will be glad to have them.

Comment on this
Mr. Peter O'Shea

I will come in on the green bond. In the year gone by, the ESB raised a very significant green bond in the financial markets to utilise across the various parts of our business for green activities. I think it is a different question the Deputy was asking. I think he was asking about retrofitting and how money might be raised for retrofit schemes either on an individual or collective basis. To be honest, that requires some degree of policy and legislation to enable it in the Irish market. There were examples in the United Kingdom of a green deal. It was not overly successful, but I believe it came to the market at a difficult time. I would not discount it but it is not a place that the ESB sees itself being in in the first instance. It is a broader than the ESB.

Comment on this

I have one question for the Department. On retrofitting, much of what is left is external because the easy ones, the internal work, and I can see them around the midlands, have been done. Many of the ones left are the harder, older ones that require external wrap-around. There have been problems in England, Scotland and Wales with ones done under the British energy saving scheme. Problems have cropped up with several hundred homes in terms of moisture penetration because it is wrapping with a soft fabric in a wet climate, and they depend on the texture on the outside.

Comment on this

What is the question?

Comment on this

Has that been looked at to see if there are lessons that can be learned from that? We want to try to get this scheme right. A number of pilot schemes are on the way, and I pass one on Kildare Street coming to the Houses every day, and I can see it being done. Has the Department looked at that? Ireland is wetter than England, so there is significant potential for that to cause problems in the extremely wet climate that we have. We want to try to get this right. Has that been looked at and examined?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Armstrong

The SEAI, is responsible for the grant scheme for the private sector, but the works are carried out in accordance with the building regulations. Part D of the building regulations requires that external insulation systems are third-party certified, which is typically National Standards Authority of Ireland, NSAI, Agrément certified in Ireland. That would test external wall insulation systems for all parts of the building regulations, including severe weather exposure. All the materials would have been tested for that. The NSAI operates a database of materials that have been tested, and there would be trained installers. The authority would audit the installer schemes for those systems. The grant scheme would require that the works be carried out in accordance with building regulations, and the NSAI would operate a certification system to ensure that they are in accordance with the building regulations.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Bríd Smith for swapping with me as our Private Members' business slot is just beginning in the Seanad. Specifically around a just transition forum, the actual proposal for such a forum that we heard from ICTU was that the Workplace Relations Commission would act as chairman to a stakeholder forum that would allow for addressing these issues. Potentially this could act as a model because we know that we are going to have to see many transitions in many sectors, and it could be an opportunity to have a stakeholder forum framed not as dispute resolution but as a meeting of stakeholders. I would like to ask Bord na Móna specifically if it is the case, as we understand it at the moment, that the company is not willing to meet in a stakeholder forum chaired by the Workplace Relations Commission. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Let me answer that in a number of ways.

Comment on this

I have limited time, so perhaps Mr. Donnellan could answer it tightly, because I do have many follow-up questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

A number of months ago the belief was that Bord na Móna was coming to an end and it was going to lay off 2,000 employees and that it was going to leave at Christmas, that the pensions were going to be raided and there was no future for the midlands. The suggestion then was that we needed a Workplace Relations Commission forum to deal with all that. This is the first test of decarbonisation and we need a forum to deal with that. We have put in place a plan that means that is not going happen. There will be no compulsory redundancy and there will be redeployment, there is a company that is in growth, that is financially stable, the pensions are in a good place. We have an industrial relations mechanism for dealing with such matter that works well.

We, in Bord na Móna, do not see the upside of us being used as some sort of forum to determine how just transition issues are managed in the future. We have asked the unions what issues they want to discuss and they say they want to discuss pensions, what is happening with the third parties like the ESB, and security of employment. These are issues where the answers are clear and we can deal with them through the current industrial relations forums. We would have no issue with a wider forum to talk about just transition, like we have in the midlands with the county councils and all of the different stakeholders, but we do not see any upside to a Bord na Móna forum.

Comment on this

A case was made quite strongly for this. We have just transition funds. This is in a just transition frame, regardless of whether Bord na Móna and ESB like to be at the forefront. They are at the forefront of how we model this as a State. From my perspective it is something we need to look at beyond the existing industrial relations framework. I ask the Department, if it comes in later as a major stakeholder, whether it believes there is an opportunity or need for that commission or stakeholder forum, chaired possibly by the WRC.

Mr. Donnellan specifically mentioned redeployment, namely, 210 redeployment opportunities, and between 200 and 600 of what he called new jobs. Why are the 200 to 600 jobs framed as new jobs rather than redeployment? Will they be the same quality of jobs? If somebody has been working for 20 or 30 years with Bord na Móna, is it the case that the company is inviting him or her to apply for these new jobs rather than redeploying that person? There are 210 redeployment opportunities, 100 new direct jobs in renewable energy assets, 100 new jobs in recycling, and 150 to 300 in various green businesses. Why have these been framed as new jobs rather than redeployment?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

The 210 redeployment jobs are for people who are directly impacted by the closure of the power stations. These are people who will not have work next year and will be redeployed by us. The other jobs that we call new jobs are for people we will probably have to hire. There are 100 people who will be hired in direct jobs in renewable energy, where we have a big pipeline of renewable energy projects to build out. We had 20 people in that group and have upped it now to 44. We have hired the balance externally. Some of them will come internally, if they have the skill sets, and some will come externally. It is not a question that we have more people to redeploy.

As we get down the road to the potential new jobs in the green businesses, herbs and aquaculture, our plan is that when we finish with the rehabilitation, circa 2024 or 2025, a number of people will have retired, and some who may wish to stay with the company will be redeployed to those new opportunities.

Comment on this

As to those new jobs that people are going into at the moment, some of which are internal, are those jobs with commensurate rights and experience? We have concerns that people will be transitioning to short-term contracts from what were previously long-term contracts or long-term employment.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Nobody who we will deploy will go from a permanent contract-----

Comment on this

No, I am not talking about redeployment, but those who have gone into, as Mr Donnellan has described them, new jobs.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Anybody who is in Bord na Móna who moves to one of these new jobs will not suffer from short-term contracts or anything like that. If that person was a full-time employee and he or she moves to one of these jobs, that person is still a full-time employee. If the person is a seasonal employee, he or she will remain a seasonal employee. That person will not be going from being a full-time employee to one who has a short-term contract. That is not the case.

Comment on this

Of the 210 redeployment opportunities in rewetting and rehabilitation of Bord na Móna lands at the moment, we have heard that there are negotiations ongoing with the European Commission. That is around an enhancement beyond what the company needs to do as per the EPA baseline. Is it the intention that regardless of how protracted the European Commission negotiations might be on that PSO, those 210 workers will be kept in employment long enough to fulfil the company's initial EPA obligations to allow enhanced rehabilitation funding to come online?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Those 210 jobs are guaranteed. This has been communicated to our employees. We will be going out to all of the affected employees next week to tell them where those areas are, and this is something that we are committed to doing. These are solid, 100% plans. Those 210 people will have those redeployment opportunities and we are already in discussions with them. This is a given.

Comment on this

There is a concern in relation to that. The other thing mentioned by Mr. Donnellan was a limited number of new applications for the voluntary redundancy scheme. We have heard a concern that all older workers have had difficulty in being allowed to take voluntary redundancy. If we are looking at this collectively, which is our job as a committee, we have to look at the overall workplace. We want to know that older workers can take those voluntary redundancy schemes in order that we do not have voluntary redundancy for younger workers who are then put into the employment system to start training again. Will Mr Donnellan kindly comment on that, please?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

I will comment on that because there has been much commentary about it. The best just transition that we can provide is a job, a full-time pensionable job, which Bord na Móna has provided for the past 80 years. We have opened up a limited voluntary redundancy scheme. The decision on who is accepted is a key one based on business needs and skill sets, which are the two criteria used. In the previous programme which we ran last year, 35% of the people who got voluntary redundancy were over 60. I would like to nail that myth that people are being discriminated against because of their age.

Comment on this

Mr. Donnellan mentioned 35%.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Yes, 35% of the people who got voluntary redundancy were over 60. It is not based on age but on business criteria and skill sets. The best just transition we can provide to people is a job until they retire so that they can then draw their pension. We would not accept that that is in any way discriminatory.

Comment on this

The Senator will have to be quick.

Comment on this

I had addressed a question to the Department.

Comment on this

Please repeat it again.

Comment on this

It was a question to the Department on the need for a stakeholder forum chaired by the Workplace Relations Commission that would allow us to address the issues.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator and call Mr. Carroll to speak.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

The first thing to say is that the just transition commissioner has only just been appointed by the Government and the terms of reference for his operation published. That includes engagement with all relevant stakeholders, Bord na Móna and ESB included, as well as trade unions and worker representatives. As part of the terms of reference, the commissioner can make recommendations on the essential elements of a just transition for workers and communities, including any additional actions or measures deemed appropriate, together with optimal structures and processes to support co-ordinated and effective delivery of the just transition. The just transition commissioner will report quarterly to the Government. I would not like to pre-empt the work that the just transition commissioner will do.

Comment on this

The commissioner does not have a specific role in terms of workers' rights or negotiating around particular cohorts of workers, as I understand it.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

This is not specified in the terms of reference.

Comment on this

There is a disjointedness there.

Comment on this

I call Deputy Bríd Smith to speak now.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman, all who are in attendance and all of the witnesses for their presentations. I will start with Mr Donnellan of Bord na Móna. With all due respect, how long is Mr Donnellan with Bord na Móna?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

I am with the company almost two years.

Comment on this

Has he ever been involved in any just transition programme in any other workplace before?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Yes, I was involved twice before.

Comment on this

Will he tell the committee where these were?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

These were in France.

Comment on this

Were they in the carbon industry?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

No, they were in technology and telecommunications industries where there was major restructuring and displacement of employees.

Comment on this

Mr Donnellan is familiar, then, with the whole notion of the importance of just transition for both workers and communities.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Sure. Absolutely.

Comment on this

Mr. Donnellan said to us that he did not want to go to the Workplace Relations Commission because he does not want to be seen to be used as a forum to manage just transition in the future. How come then he is willing to engage with the just transition commissioner?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

As I said earlier, the view on Bord na Móna was that it was coming to an end and we needed to have a forum to decide how it was going to end. Nothing is further from the truth. Today, we have a number of forums to deal with what is happening under just transition.

In July we signed a just transition agreement, which outlines in detail how reskilling and redeployment will be catered for. Some pay incentives were provided in return for that. We clearly have a record on that.

A midlands forum was set up last year specifically to deal with the just transition. The midlands forum is composed of all the local councils, Deputies, the ESB, the training boards, the union representatives and us. The Minister has announced a just transition commissioner to co-ordinate. We do not see the need for a third forum along the lines of industrial relations when we believe from an industrial relations point of view, we have mechanisms in place that work.

Comment on this

It is mainly men who work in the company. Some of them have 35 or 40 years' experience with Bord na Móna as opposed to Mr. Donnellan's two. They have consistently worked in an arena where a group of unions represented their interests. I believe Mr. Donnellan is familiar with that group of unions because Bord na Móna signed a collective agreement in June or July 2019. A number of issues remain outstanding - I am sure Mr. Donnellan is familiar with all this. Issues relating to retirement age, seasonal working arrangements, flexible ways of working and the training and upskilling of workers are in dispute with the group of unions. If there is a dispute with unions in a company where people have 30 or 40 years of service, there is a structure there where the unions go to a State apparatus, known as the Workplace Relations Commission. I am not trying to lecture Mr. Donnellan; I am just trying to spell it out. Why is Bord na Móna refusing to go to the Workplace Relations Commission when four or five key issues affecting workers with a long service are outstanding?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Irrespective of whether I have been in the company for two years or 32 years, I have 35 years' experience of in-depth industrial relations-----

Comment on this

I am making the comparison with those who have worked there for 40 years.

Comment on this

Please, Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

-----in all sectors. An industrial relations mechanism was put in place in the company in 2016 which was voted for by the majority of the workers. That industrial relations mechanism means that if there is any issue relating to pensions, retirement age, skilling etc., in the first instance the employee and the union sit down together to try to find a resolution. If they cannot find a resolution - up to now we have found a resolution of 95% of issues we have had - they then go to what is called a joint industrial relations commission. There is a third party appointed by the Workplace Relations Commission who then adjudicates. If any party remains unhappy at that stage, we then go to the Workplace Relations Commission. If any party at that stage is not happy, we then go to the Labour Court, which is binding. We use the full suite of industrial relations options, including the WRC, and we have no issue with that mechanism.

Comment on this

Why does Bord na Móna therefore have a problem in going to the Workplace Relations Commission on the outstanding issues in that agreement which I have just listed?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We have no problem going to the Workplace Relations Commission on the outstanding issues, provided it follows due process. First, there is an internal attempt with a certain period laid down for how long that should last. If there is no resolution, the matter goes to the JIRC and if there is no resolution there, it goes to the WRC. If f there is no resolution at the WRC, it then goes to the Labour Court. That is a collective agreement we have. We are honour bound to it and we will follow it.

Comment on this

I may be wrong and I do not have a trade union official sitting beside me to advise me. My information is that the agreement that was signed in June was broken by Bord na Móna when it laid off 150 workers in Mount Dillon. That was not part of the collective agreement that was signed. Once they were laid off, Bord na Móna was immediately into a disputatious situation.

In the wider picture, I believe Mr. Donnellan would acknowledge, as everybody else in the country does, that the just transition challenge for Bord na Móna is the litmus test for future just transition in the country. Bord na Móna would not want to be used as a forum to manage just transition for the future. I ask Mr. Donnellan to explain to me why not when his company is the litmus test for that.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We are fully committed to just transition and we have laid out our plans. The best just transition we can provide to anyone is a good permanent pensionable job.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

If I can finish-----

Comment on this

The definition of just transition includes much more.

Comment on this

The Deputy must allow Mr. Donnellan to finish and let him answer the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Two forums have been set up to deal with just transition. The midland forum, which I mentioned, has all parties involved: the unions-----

Comment on this

I understand. Mr. Donnellan told me all that.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We have the appointment of a just transition commissioner with whom we will engage.

Comment on this

Yes, but Bord na Móna-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

I would like to finish. The Deputy referred to Mount Dillon. We did not lay off 150 workers. One of the stations in Mount Dillon went offline. All the permanent workers were kept online. The seasonal workers were sent home, but that does not impact them financially one bit. Seasonal workers in Bord na Móna are guaranteed a set number of days in a year and we honour those days. We sent them home at the time, but we have since called them back. If by the end of the year we have not called them back, they will be fully paid for those days. Therefore, there is no financial impact on those employees.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Donnellan agree with me that there is clearly a dispute about how this is being handled between Bord na Móna and the workers as represented by the group of unions?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

I cannot accept that. A few months ago, there were two schools of thought for Bord na Móna. One school of thought was that Bord na Móna is coming to an end and we should maximise redundancy, maximise pensions and pull up the drawbridge. That was the stated position of a number of people. Our board has four worker directors, elected by the employees. We asked them to go and talk to the employees in the company to ascertain what they wanted. They came back to us and distinctly said the feedback from the employees was that they wanted their jobs for as long as possible. They were not about redundancy and maximising pension. That is the route we have followed.

Comment on this

Has Mr. Donnellan ever discussed with the Minister the possibility of attending a just transition forum in the Workplace Relations Commission?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Yes, I have.

Comment on this

What was Mr. Donnellan's response to him? Has he requested Mr. Donnellan to do so?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

He did not request me to do so. We had a debate about the pros and cons of it. I have given the company's clear position.

Comment on this

Is it the same position Mr. Donnellan has just given me.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

Pretty much, yes.

Comment on this

Why did Bord na Móna reduce its bank debt by €50 million last year when it knew it was facing this challenge with workers being laid off and seasonal workers' hours being changed?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We went through a significant restructuring last year to ensure the company was financially stable and resilient to be able to deal with the challenges we knew were coming. Bord na Móna had some private placement debt which it had taken out a number of years ago in the days of very high interest rates based on some renewable energy assets that we had built. We were obliged to pay back the loan last year. If we did not did not pay it back, the assets would have been taken.

Comment on this

I believe Mr. Donnellan told us earlier that Bord na Móna is in a very healthy state with pensions and everything else guaranteed.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

The pensions-----

Comment on this

Was it absolutely imperative to spend that €50 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We did not spend the €50 million. We repaid a loan that was due. If we did not do it, we would have been in default and the assets would have been seized.

Comment on this

Therefore, Bord na Móna chose to give back the €50 million to the banks, rather than-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We did not choose-----

Comment on this

-----ring-fence it for the troubles that were facing the midlands.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Donnellan to finally respond before the end of the-----

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

It is clear that we had debt on an asset that needed to be repaid. The company was obliged to do it and it did. The company has restructured itself and is in a very strong financial position to meet all its financial requirements in respect of pensions and redundancy payments. On 16 October, we announced a planned investment of €1.6 billion. I do not see where there is an issue.

Comment on this

I call Deputy Nolan.

Comment on this

I want to make a request of Mr. Donnellan. At the end of this meeting, I plan to make a proposal to the committee to make a recommendation to the Minister that Bord na Móna attend a just transition forum in the Workplace Relations Commission. I am asking Mr. Donnellan to do that, with all due respect to him and his board. It is not just for him and his board, but for the future of the midlands and the future of how just transition progresses for workers and communities.

Comment on this

I call Deputy Nolan.

Comment on this

It would be the decent thing to do.

Comment on this

The Deputy is out of time.

Comment on this

I do not think it would break the board.

Comment on this

The Deputy has made her point.

Comment on this

It would be the sensible and decent thing to do.

Comment on this

The Deputy is out of time. I call Deputy Nolan.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Donnellan respond to what I have just said?

Comment on this

I think he has responded pretty comprehensively a number of times during that interaction. I call Deputy Nolan.

Comment on this

I wish to pose questions to the Bord na Móna and ESB representatives. The workers and communities are front and centre of all we do here. We need to be mindful that people are shocked and in grief over how things happened so suddenly. As I have pointed out in the Dáil, other European regions seem to have been given a longer period of transition.

It is shameful the State pushes populism ahead of workers' rights and communities. I have said that to the Minister quite openly. My concern is with the workers at this time. I welcome the statement by Mr. Dollard from the ESB that he believed most of the 80 workers affected would take the redeployment option. That is fantastic and clear cut. The Bord na Móna workers are not so fortunate, however, and more of them are affected.

From the complaints that I have heard from workers, I sense that there is no ongoing communication. The workers seem to be very much in the dark and confused about what is happening. There are definitely issues with the redundancy packages and seasonal workers. What level of communication is taking place with those workers? I ask that the company engage in ongoing communication with the workers and more outreach because many of the problems arise from the communication issue.

Bord na Móna has drawn up a plan for offering redundancy packages. Were any of the elements of the plans used in the coal mining region of northern Spain or in Germany where the transition will last until 2038 taken on board? It is paramount that the workers are treated well when it comes to redundancy packages. These are loyal workers, many of whom have worked in the company for 30 years. The company has been very good and it is important that the workers receive fair play. I hope the new jobs that come on stream are guaranteed. I am sceptical about the retrofitting plan as I do not believe that work is guaranteed. As the trade unions have pointed out, there is a tender process involved. I am worried about that element. I appeal to the company to ensure the redundancy packages are fair and comparable with those that have been offered to workers elsewhere in Europe who are in this position. What happens here will be used a litmus test, certainly in this country. We have to get this right, be fair and ensure that our workers are not treated differently from workers elsewhere in Europe.

I did not pick up any clarity with regard to the power plant in Edenderry, although I may have missed something. I heard the answer with regard to the plant in Derrinlough.

Comment on this

The witnesses have less than two minutes to reply.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We answered the question on Edenderry earlier. The plant has planning permission until the end of 2023. Our plan is to resubmit a planning application for a life after that time. We believe that application would have a reasonable chance, notwithstanding that it will be subject to approval by An Bord Pleanála and all that goes with that. We believe that we have a reasonable chance of continuing. That is our current plan.

Regarding redundancy, our preference is for people to have jobs and employment in order that we have no compulsory redundancy. Therefore, anyone who wants a job can have a job and anyone who wants to stay in his or her job can do so. The reason we have offered limited voluntary redundancy is that we had a previous scheme that was oversubscribed and a number of people expressed to us a desire to return to college, start up their own company or change career. We are facilitating those people and the current scheme is oversubscribed. The terms are reasonably generous as redundancy schemes go.

We have considered in detail what has been done in Spain and other areas and we believe our redundancy scheme is pretty comparable. The circumstances abroad, especially in Spain, which Dr. McNamara can talk about, are totally different.

On the Deputy's point about communications, we do a lot of work on communication with employees. I have personally addressed all of the employees in the company in the past two weeks. Our head of energy will meet all of the employees next week. I agree with Deputy Nolan that there has been a great deal of uncertainty about the decision on the power plants and what would happen. There was speculation in some quarters that 1,000 or 2,000 people would be laid off. We have responded to that in the past few weeks and clarified the matter. I agree with the Deputy that we now need to clarify the position at an individual level and explain to each of the workers whether they will be eligible for one of the 210 redeployment jobs. I anticipate that people will know by 16 December whether they will have a redeployment job or qualify for voluntary redundancy.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Fitzmaurice and the committee for facilitating me. The just transition was announced in the budget. I represent Littleton in County Tipperary where the plant was closed last year. I wrote to the relevant Minister and contacted his Department pointing out that Littleton must be part of this process because no Government can discriminate against people in a part of Tipperary where a factory closed recently. I played a central role in bringing the Sabrina Manufacturing Group to the area. This company is working with Bord na Móna and I acknowledge all of the work that it has done. I did some work for it today coming in here. I hope its engineers will arrive soon and the company will open with its first 40 jobs here. In reply to a parliamentary question, the Minister indicated that he would accept a submission to have Littleton made part of the just transition, including the just transition fund. I accept and welcome that statement. I will bring people in the area together in the coming days and weeks. Do we make submissions to the just transition commissioner who has been appointed or is there another process that we can avail of? What advice can the witnesses give me on this issue? People living in the area around Littleton deserve to be treated the same as the other communities involved by this Government and any future Government. What is the practical process involved in this?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

As the Deputy is aware, the just transition commissioner has only been appointed and the terms of reference settled. The budget announced the allocations. The Minister signalled, in response to a parliamentary question, that he is open to a submission as to how the funds might assist workers affected by the ending of peat harvesting for power generation. In terms of the practical details, we will have to work out how that will be done in the coming weeks.

Comment on this

I ask that those be communicated to me.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

We will do that.

Comment on this

We will proceed with the forum and then pick up on the matter with the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

We will communicate to the Deputy how to make a submission.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Carroll for being constructive.

Comment on this

I will allow the witnesses time to note my questions. A sum of €20 million has been ring-fenced for retrofitting in the midlands. How are the midlands defined? Will the money be ring-fenced to be used in certain counties?

I do not accept that the Department is still considering the recent judgment on horticulture because it was issued two months ago. Is new legislation being introduced on peat given that there are between 3,000 and 4,000 jobs in the sector?

We heard that 80,000 social houses had been retrofitted. Is Mr. Armstrong telling me that 80,000 houses are not using oil or gas at the moment? My understanding is that this retrofitting involved a bit of insulation. I do not see householders changing to air, water or anything like that. Will Mr. Armstrong confirm the position?

Mr. Carroll referred to reductions in Ireland's greenhouse gas emissions generated by transport, etc. My next question requires a straight "Yes" or "No" answer. I have done some research on this issue. The closure of the two plants by Bord na Móna and the ESB will not reduce Ireland's emissions because the companies trade on the European emissions trading system. In addition, it will not change our emissions from agriculture, transport and energy when we come to add them up. I want that clarified.

Mr. Carroll referred to €5 million allocated to the National Parks and Wildlife Service. Was he referring to the 12 bogs that the National Parks and Wildlife Service is currently working on because that work has been budgeted for already? That money came through the EU LIFE fund. Is this an additional €5 million?

When did the ESB inform the Minister of the closures? Will Mr. Dollard confirm that he will be able to redeploy all employees in the 15 places he named, between skills places and depots, including a number in the west of Ireland, if they wish to do so? I know they will be given an option if they wish to take redundancy. If they wish to be redeployed, from what I understand Mr. Dollard is saying, the ESB will be able to redeploy them.

Emissions credits were given by Europe for the tonnages that the ESB was using. My understanding is that the ESB has to cut down on emissions as it goes. If it stops at the end of 2020, we know, from when I spoke to the witnesses before, that the credits the ESB has are worth €26 a tonne on the market. Will there be a large windfall of money on the tonnage that the ESB has if another big conglomerate in another part of Europe requires credits? Why, under the same regulations, has Bord na Móna been able to get planning permission to use biomass and peat when the ESB could not have a second go at it? I note when the ESB talked about its reasoning, it was climate, commercial and planning reasons. Where do social and economic reasons come in for the people in rural parts of Ireland? Did the ESB not take trying to help them into account?

Will Mr. Donnellan tell me the number of full and part-time employees that Bord na Móna has at present? He said that Bord na Móna would be able to employ 210 and that there would be limited redundancies. Can he guarantee the rest of them for the next seven years? He talked about new ideas. When I met Mr. Donnellan two years ago, he gave us a lovely glossy document and told us about how there were goals for 2025 and 2027. I know that things have changed. Can he give a clear path to the rest of the workers?

Everyone on the committee needs to get real about restoration. The national park statistics indicate that €5 million covers about 17 diggers for 240 days. We need to be realistic that some of Bord na Móna's bogs could not be restored for the simple reason that they have gone beyond restoring.

Comment on this

I have to bring in the witnesses, Deputy.

Comment on this

They are degraded raised bogs. People are codding themselves about much of this.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

I will take the questions in sequence if I can. We informed the Minister the day before the decision was made. We will be capable of reassigning all the workers who expressed a wish.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

I expect to see strong interest in reassignment. The Deputy talked about social and economic considerations in planning. The industry and our business are going through a significant transition, as are energy players across Europe. We saw those plants as being really important for our future and also for generating income for the economy. We understood the social and economic considerations, having operated the site. We are disappointed, having put a lot of effort into the planning application. Notwithstanding that, we cannot see how there is any way around this, considering the planning, commercial and climate issues. Those plants do not have any further future and I do not say that with anything other than regret.

Comment on this

What about the funding for the emissions?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

A number of years ago, companies such as the ESB were giving carbon allowances for free. I do not know when exactly that stopped but it was five or six years, off the top of my head. When we sell electricity forward on the market, we have to buy carbon on the market ourselves. We do not hold allowances. There will be no windfall gain to the ESB whatsoever with regard to carbon.

Comment on this

What will the saving be?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

There will be no saving.

Comment on this

If the ESB is buying forward, there has to be a saving.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

We will produce the electricity in other plants, so we will still consume carbon.

Comment on this

The ESB will not be buying the carbon credits, so what is the saving?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

We may not be but equally we will not be selling the electricity.

Comment on this

The ESB will be selling the electricity because it will be generating it in a different way. What is the saving if the ESB is not buying the carbon credit?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

There will be no saving because all the plants compete and there is a margin. One plant is competing against the other and marks it against its competitors too, so I would expect no saving.

Comment on this

I will bring in Mr. Carroll from the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

The closing of the peat plants, on an economy-wide basis, will reduce our emissions. The estimate is that 1.25 million tonnes of carbon will be saved each year. Emissions will reduce by 9 million tonnes cumulatively up to 2027.

Comment on this

I asked if it is included in our targets. It is not because I have heard Mr. Carroll answer the question already.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

I think there is a distinction to be drawn between how EU targets are framed and an economy-wide approach to decarbonising. The EU regime is divided into two sectors, the emissions trading system, ETS, which is a cap on trade, where electricity falls on the non-ETS which covers other sectors. It would not be correct to say that it does not reduce our emissions on an economy-wide basis.

Comment on this

Let us make it simpler. It has no bearing on Ireland's targets under agriculture, energy and transport.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

It has a bearing on the decarbonisation of our energy system. It obviously does not have a bearing on agriculture targets. The ETS is an EU-wide policy mechanism to reduce emissions in large industry and electricity generation. The EU has a target to reduce emissions in the ETS, which contributes to this and reduces emissions on an economy-wide basis in Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We have approximately 1,600 employees, of whom 400 are seasonal and half are in non-peat related businesses, so they are currently not affected by anything to do with peat. Approximately 400 are affected by the closure of the two power stations. We are redeploying 210 of those to rehabilitation and some to other new businesses. We have opened a voluntary redundancy scheme in which we are targeting between 150 and 180. If we do not get that many, we will redeploy the rest, but we are oversubscribed for that.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Armstrong

The midlands retrofitting project has been developed by the retrofitting task force. The final boundary or area to be included has not been finalised yet. Some work has been done with the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment and the Department of Housing, Planning and Local Government in this area. I understand that further advice is required from the Attorney General's office to progress this further so those are all the details I have.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Armstrong saying that, even though it is announced, we do not know what the transition fund for what we are calling the midlands is?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán Armstrong

We know what the core counties are likely to be. The full scope of the area has not been decided. The final boundary will be decided based on the economic stimulus required for the region and the clusters of the houses that will be identified to put together. At this stage, exactly what those counties are has not been finalised by the task force.

Comment on this

I apologise for being late. I was in the House too, trying to put a tax incentive in place for Bord na Móna and the ESB. I will be brief because I am going back into the House again.

Comment on this

Mr. Armstrong referred to the midlands scheme. It must include Roscommon and east Galway, where Bord na Móna sites adjoin the two powers stations. Have any shallow retrofits not gone ahead as a result of rent arrears? Local authorities previously used that policy to penalise people who were in arrears. Those people were in fuel poverty and could not access the retrofit. Can Mr. Armstrong assure us that families in fuel or other poverty will not be penalised in the context of the deep retrofit?

I point out to the officials from the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment that representatives from the SEAI appeared before the committee last week. I specifically asked what the SEAI will do to try to get contractors in the midlands to start doing some of this work. It seems seemed a fairly sensible question to ask. The representatives stated that it had nothing to do with the SEAI. Will the latter be directed to engage with contractors across the midland counties to ensure that there are sufficient local contractors to carry out the work?

Mr. Goodwin will be aware that the ESB decision not to resubmit a planning application will change the energy mix. It will impact on grid stability, particularly in the north west, and demand for electricity in the Dublin area. The only renewables on the grid are wind and solar and some hydro. Biomass will go off the grid in 2023 if the plant in Edenderry ceases production. Is Mr. Goodwin concerned that the removal of biomass could significantly constrict our energy mix?

What are the ESB's plans for retaining the plants in Lanesborough and Shannonbridge? We do not want a repeat of the mistake made in decommissioning the sugar plants in Carlow and Mallow. All our bioethanol is being imported because we have no way of processing it here.

Will Mr. Donnellan outline the status of bioenergy within Bord na Móna? As he is aware, in 2017 the Government decided to establish a supply chain for biomass into Lanesborough and Shannonbridge. There seems to have been a deficiency in that regard in the planning application that was submitted by the ESB. The decision of An Bord Pleanála that no imported biomass can be used for power generation has a significant impact on the development of a biomass industry because in order to encourage farmers to grow biomass, there must be demand for the product. One cannot meet demand without importing biomass in the short term. We have the ability to grow and deliver a significant amount of biomass, which would have climate benefits as well as economic benefits across the midlands. As the decision of An Bord Pleanála has not been appealed and no new planning application submitted, the decision effectively shuts down our biomass sector.

I apologise in advance if I return to the Dáil before the witnesses finish replying. I will see their responses in the Official Report.

Comment on this

The witnesses have two minutes to respond to the Deputy's questions. If any of the questions were answered already, it is not necessary to address them again.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

On retrofitting, several things are going on in parallel. A task force is in place to design the new aggregated retrofitting model.

On the just transition, €20 million has been ring-fenced and targeted at the midlands. There is another €6 million in the just transition fund for the retraining and reskilling of workers. A key objective of the just transition aspect of the climate action plan, as well as the plan more widely, is to identify and exploit opportunities, such as through the ambition to retrofit half a million houses by 2030. The pieces are in place to achieve the type of goal the Deputy is talking about.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Goodwin

On the energy mix, we have been assured by EirGrid that the closure of the plants will not impact on the stability of the grid and that it can be operated without them. The removal of peat from the energy mix will reduce it, but the use of peat in electricity generation was coming to an end anyway in light of climate change.

Comment on this

Was it EirGrid that stated there was a need for Grid West and Grid Link?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Goodwin

EirGrid is the transmission system operator.

Comment on this

It told us they were needed and then stated they were not.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Goodwin

There are other tools for ensuring the appropriate level of electricity generation, including capacity auctions. On EirGrid, there are several tools in place to ensure security of supply.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Dollard

Regarding the future of the plants, we are very disappointed that our application was not successful. We saw those plants as part of our transition into a different future. However, our planning application was unsuccessful. The nature of that failure in the planning process means that there is no future for the current configuration on those sites. That gives me no pleasure, but it is the case. The existing planning permission for the site requires us to dismantle it within two years of the end of operation of the plant, which will be at the end of next year. We will be obliged to have dismantled the station by the end of 2022. We will seek other uses for electricity infrastructure. It is an important site and we will seek to pursue other opportunities for it but the current plant and infrastructure will have to be dismantled under current planning.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Benson

On arrears, local authorities pick the houses to be retrofitted. We generally do not have sight of the reasons why a house might be excluded.

Comment on this

Is it not a moral issue that those in fuel poverty are the ones who do not have the retrofit carried out?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Benson

I will finish the point I was making. I am aware, as all present probably are, that local authorities previously refused to carry out maintenance as a result of non-payment of rent. It is a somewhat counter-intuitive approach. The houses are owned by the local authorities and they do not wish for fabric degradation to occur. We will take the Deputy's point on board. It can be a stipulation of the scheme that rent arrears will not be a consideration.

On Roscommon, my colleague has dealt with the issues relating to the midlands. We will take back the Deputy's strong views in that regard.

Comment on this
Dr. John MacNamara

On imported biomass and biomass in general, without getting into the detail of the decision relating to the ESB, imported biomass is not outlawed. A very clear definition or schema was introduced in June 2018 in the recently recast renewables directive which laid down very specific and objective criteria that biomass must meet in order to be deemed sustainable. It is also necessary to meet EU timber regulations and the very strict phytosanitary conditions set by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. In essence, biomass and sustainable biomass are effectively the same thing, irrespective of their origin, as long as they meet the sustainability criteria set out in the EU directive.

Comment on this

That is not what is in the decision of An Bord Pleanála which will set the precedent because it has been allowed to stand.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. They are only doing their jobs. It is difficult for me to stomach what I have heard at this meeting regarding what is happening in the midlands, especially because, although I have always believed the climate changed, I do not subscribe to the reasons being given for that. The decision to close many of these plants within a year as a result of the ruling of An Bord Pleanála, rather than eight or nine years as was supposed to be the case, is one of the worst decisions in recent times.

Shannonbridge and Lanesborough and all of Littleton are gone. There are still thousands of acres of bogland left. My grandmother used to say wilful waste makes woeful want. We do not have coal reserves, we do not have gold reserves, we do not have oil reserves like many other countries have, but we had a little bit of bog and I thought that it should be used for as long as it was there. That is not the case now. I am amazed when I hear the way the people are being bought, but the people realise it on the ground. The people of the midlands will realise it very shortly because it is one thing to say one will have jobs for bog rehabilitation for 210 people. How long will those last? As I understand it, rehabilitation could just mean closing drains, turning off pumps and letting more water in and stopping it going out.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

We anticipate that the first phase of rehabilitation, which is 55,000 ha., will take about four years. Keep in mind that Bord na Móna has ownership of only 5% of the peatlands of Ireland. The potential beyond Bord na Móna, with the National Parks and Wildlife Service, and other peatlands, is immense, but the current plan that we have in front of us is 210 jobs over four years and potentially longer. The potential for rehabilitation is huge.

Comment on this

How are those in the service industry, the little shops, the filling stations or whatever, going to survive after the jobs are shut down? The other thing that I am amazed at is that no one here knows the definition of the boundaries of the places that are going to get assistance. It is amazing that no one here can define that in spite of the fact that the Government is bragging and blowing up here in the chambers every day that such a fund is available and no recognition is given, even in the recent budget, to the fact that the stations are closing down six or seven years sooner than they were supposed to because of the Bord Pleanála decision. All of this is a desperate reaction to the Greens winning a few extra seats in the council and European elections and the fact that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael want to be greener than the Greens. It is the people in the midlands who will be affected. I know that people from Kerry, including my own father-in-law, came up working in Bord na Móna back in the 1930s and 1940s. My own brother worked for Bord na Móna in later years. I know what the jobs mean to those people and to all the other people who work there. What will happen to the briquette operation and the moss peat? There was endless opportunity to continue that, as I understand it.

Comment on this

I am conscious of the Deputy's time. Are his questions about peat briquettes and moss peat?

Comment on this

I will just ask the other ones. What is going to supply the grid if, as we say, the wind slows down? Are we going to be able to store the electricity from the wind farms? I am not sure that we can. One talks about reskilling workers but for what? What are the jobs that one is talking about? What jobs are we going to put people into? It is fine to say they will be reskilled, but what jobs do we have for them? I want to know. That is the question I have been asking. The retrofitting of houses is grand and we would all like that for everyone. Is it just buying people to get them off one's back so that they will not complain too much? I think this is terrible, and when we actually hear that the Chinese are drawing coal from Poland and they cannot stack it quickly enough on the land so are stacking it in the sea. This is what is happening in Ireland, closing down whatever bit of fuel and energy that we had of our own, set up in the 1930s and 1940s by politicians who would be turning in their graves if they could see what was going on in our country.

Comment on this

Your time is up, Deputy Healy-Rae, but I am just conscious that you raised a number of issues there. I do not know if we can do it all within a minute.

Comment on this
Mr. Tom Donnellan

I will do it in less than a minute. Deputy Healy-Rae asked a lot of very important questions. We have in the middle of Offaly a place called Mount Lucas, to which I invite the committee and where they can see first-hand what we are doing in rehabilitation, our new jobs, our skills and our training. I sincerely invite the committee at their convenience to come and visit it and get a feel for the substance beyond the words.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Donnellan. I call Deputy Dooley.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair and I apologise to the guests, because like Deputy Naughton I was caught in the Dáil on a health debate earlier, but I did get a chance to read some of the stuff, and I am reasonably familiar with some of the issues. I am not going to rehearse matters because I assume a lot of the questions have been asked. I was here for the ICTU presentation, and there seemed to be some concerns expressed there which I am sure have already been put to the committee, so maybe Mr. Carroll, to try to help us understand, would outline how he sees from a policy perspective the just transition commissioner being able to navigate those potentially choppy waters between all sides - the powers, the terms of reference and what ultimate control the commissioner will have. I have not had an opportunity to discuss this with him although he is somebody I have known by reputation and on a personal basis for a number of years. He certainly has the capacity to do it if he has the appropriate powers and the wherewithal, because to get a just transition, it clearly requires somebody with power and authority to bring all the sides together.

On the Bord na Móna side, it does not affect my constituency other than people who travel from my constituency to the location in question. I know others have addressed that matter. On the ESB side and around the just transition, I have been in touch with the ESB in the past about what role it would play, particularly in the decision to reduce activity at Moneypoint. I think it is well established now that an arrangement is in place where 100 workers over a relatively short period will leave the operation. While that might work from the company's perspective, it has a really devastating impact on the communities that are served by it. Of course, it was done in a collaborative way and people made lifestyle decisions and maybe are reasonably happy with what package they have gotten. If one takes them out of a community, that is a loss to the community because the spending power is very significant in the west Clare area.

It is also recognised that Moneypoint was a good employer of contractors, and we have seen over the past 12 months many of those contracts come to an end. There are a number of sole suppliers in that region as well, so it is often presented as only 100 workers there and that they are well managed, well looked after and sorted out, but it is greater than that. There really is an important function to try to establish this just transition. We must consider how we can protect the communities against that loss of income and how can we find replacement enterprises; it has to be more than just money. That is why I would like to hear from the ESB. Does ESB have any ideas around how it can utilise the existing site? This goes back to what Deputy Healy-Rae said in some respects. There is a lot of talk about the potential for the capture of offshore wind off the west coast of Ireland, so I am not going to reiterate for the ESB the value of its own asset because it knows the value of the interconnector lines between Moneypoint and Dublin and how difficult it would be to get those in place across the country now. That site is an important asset.

The deep harbour is an important asset. Does the ESB have a vision, or a process around which it is developing such a vision, to establish a position in the Atlantic Ocean to capture wind energy?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Carroll

As Deputy Dooley will know, the just transition commissioner has just been appointed and the terms of reference have been published. They include engaging with all the relevant stakeholders, including Bord na Móna, the ESB, the trade unions and workers' representatives, local community organisations and so on. There is a long list published in the terms of reference. The commissioner, having engaged with the stakeholders and taking account of good practice elsewhere - domestically and internationally - is to make recommendations about the essential elements of a just transition for workers and communities, including through the measures announced in the budget, implementation of other actions under way, including under Project Ireland 2040, and any additional actions and measures deemed appropriate, as well as optimal structures and processes to support a co-ordinated approach. The commissioner will report quarterly to the Government, through the Minister. In the first instance, having just been appointed, we must give him a chance to set about doing this work and see what recommendations he chooses to make, having engaged in the way envisaged in the terms of reference. The commissioner will be supported by a secretariat both in the midlands transition team and by the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment.

Comment on this
Mr. Senan Colleran

Deputy Dooley asked a range of questions about Moneypoint, which I will try to cover in my response. The Government's 2015 White Paper on energy policy for Ireland set out that the ESB would transition away from coal by 2025. That decision was driven by two factors, one of which was the need to tackle climate change by recognising that coal has higher carbon than other fuels. In the past 12 months, Moneypoint has seen a radical change in its operation. It now has a running regime of about 10% of what it used to have. That is driven by two main factors, one of which is the price of carbon in the energy emissions trading scheme. That price has increased fourfold or fivefold in the past five months. A second factor is the penetration of wind in the system. Moneypoint's operation has swiftly changed, as have revenues. Recognising this fact, we started engaging with our staff and their unions earlier this year. We have gone through a process where we are aligning Moneypoint's resources with a future running regime. This is Moneypoint's best chance of continuing in operation until 2025.

We are currently considering options for the period after 2025. There are a range of options, all of which must be commercial and environmentally viable. Offshore wind is definitely a possibility and has huge potential for Ireland. We understand that the marine planning and development management Bill, which will be introduced later this year, will facilitate this. It is also worth noting that Moneypoint, as a coal burning station, has provided significant security of supply to the State for more than 30 years. At any point in time, there is enough coal in the yards to run a full load for two months generating approximately 900 MW. We are focused on working with our staff to ensure that our new plan will be put in place and will help the station to survive and continue in operation until 2025.

Comment on this

I acknowledge that a sunset of 2025 was introduced for the plant in 2015. It was not expected that there would be a significant shift in employment terms as early as 2019. The expectation was that the company had four or five years to transition and get a plan together. That transition period has not been provided and I accept that commercial reality. Now that the bus has effectively stopped, it is time to get a plan in place. I question the idea that something has to be commercially viable. The ESB is a fantastic company. ESB international has developed technologies ahead of others, whether in laying lines under the sea or developing technologies for fixing those lines. The company has been way ahead of others. I would like to think the ESB was also advancing the case in terms of research and development and not looking purely at investment in a commercial venture. At some point, the capture of wind in the Atlantic Ocean will be commercially viable. Is the ESB investing money in research and development in nascent technologies and new ideas for the capture of wind or is it taking a suck it and see approach? Is it waiting for commercially viable developments elsewhere in the world at which point it will push these technologies out into the Atlantic Ocean? Is the ESB looking at the real potential of making Ireland an industry leader in the capture of offshore wind in deep waters?

Comment on this
Mr. Senan Colleran

Deputy Dooley is correct. The Moneypoint site has huge offshore wind potential and that is part of our plans. We are definitely looking at that. What we have done at Moneypoint is secure 86 jobs locally. The plant is still a large ratepayer and good employer in west Clare. We are very committed to Moneypoint, our people there and west Clare.

Comment on this

We have to conclude. I thank the witnesses for what has been a very good engagement this afternoon. Deputy Smith wanted to raise a matter before we adjourn.

Comment on this

I want to table a motion. I do not know where I stand given the number of members who are still here.

Comment on this

It is a proposal. Is that correct?

Comment on this

Yes, it is a proposal that the committee write to the Minister after this meeting with regard to Bord na Móna workers and their communities in just transition and request that he instruct Bord na Móna management to engage fully with the Workplace Relations Commission on a forum for just transition without delay and with immediate effect.

Comment on this

Mr. Donnellan outlined that the WRC is part of the whole industrial relations process.

Comment on this

I am also aware that the Minister could do this.

Comment on this

I have an open mind on the proposal. This is not meant to be a partisan, political statement but I regularly sit in the Dáil Chamber where motions are passed instructing the Government and Ministers to do all sorts of things which are not done.

Comment on this

Deputy Dooley's party still puts motions and we still support them.

Comment on this

I am happy to support the proposal.

Comment on this

It is a proposal to the Minister. Mr. Donnellan outlined the process. It was not the case that he was against working with the Workplace Relations Commission but as part of an industrial relations process.

Comment on this

We must not forget what we heard in the first half of today's meeting.

Comment on this

Just to be clear, while the WRC has an industrial relations role, the proposal relates not to the dispute mechanism but to the WRC acting as a chair to seek an agreement and stakeholder building space. It was an advisory discussion, not a dispute mechanism. While Mr. Donnellan spoke of dispute mechanisms and negotiations, what was being described was a forum. The latter is slightly different.

Comment on this

To some extent, this is a bit like Hamlet without the prince. Maybe we should have the just transition commissioner before the committee before making a decision. We should not jump the gun. We had a good discussion and we heard both sides. I would like to hear from Kieran Mulvey to find out where he is at because we do not want to hamstring him either. Mr. Mulvey will be charged with making all of this happen. With no disrespect to Deputy Smith, I propose that we have the just transition commissioner before the committee, have a dialogue with him and then decide how to arm him with whatever it is he needs.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Smith agreeable to that proposal?

Comment on this

No. I want to put the proposal I outlined when representatives of ICTU were here. I questioned them and the members heard their answers. An instruction needs to be issued to the board of Bord na Móna to engage with the process of a just transition forum which the WRC chair has already indicated he is in favour of and willing to engage with.

Comment on this

Is it procedurally possible to do that given that Deputy Smith is proposing an action that was not on our agenda?

The committee has not had a formal opportunity to consider the proposal, which arises from interaction at this meeting. Are we procedurally enabled to do this? It should also be taken into account that only four members are still present. Is it accurate to say that the committee was asked to consider this proposal if members were not here to do so? Could we defer making a decision on this until next week?

Comment on this

We could defer it until the private session of next week's meeting.

Comment on this

We could then have a proper discussion on it.

Comment on this

We will deal with the proposal next Wednesday at 2 p.m., if members are agreeable to that. We will all be present at that time and we can draft something.

Comment on this

I would like to indicate-----

Comment on this

If fairness, many members are not here.

Comment on this

In fairness, it was indicated earlier when many members were here.

Comment on this

The proposal was not made formally. People are gone now so, to be fair to them, can we defer the matter until the private session next week?

Comment on this

I cannot really object if it is to come before the committee next Wednesday.

Comment on this

It is more democratic that way.

Comment on this

It is unfortunate because every delay in this matter is regrettable but I cannot really object because the point Deputy Corcoran Kennedy makes is correct; there is hardly anyone here.

Comment on this

We will be dealing with it.

Comment on this

It is unfortunate that members did not stay.

Comment on this

I would like-----

Comment on this

When I stepped out, I indicated my support. Others could have done that.

Comment on this