We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Climate, Environment and Energy

Ireland's Contribution to COP31: Discussion

Summary

Witnesses urged Ireland to use its EU Presidency role at COP31 to press for stronger climate action, including a fair increase in grant-based climate finance, support for adaptation and loss-and-damage funding, and a just transition that addresses debt burdens in vulnerable countries. They stressed that international leadership must match domestic action, calling for a fair fossil-fuel phase-out, no new fossil-fuel infrastructure and reduced energy demand. GIY’s Mick Kelly argued that climate resilience also requires rebuilding domestic food production, especially horticulture, and teaching food-growing skills in schools. The committee indicated it would write to the Taoiseach and relevant Ministers with its concerns.

Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We have no apologies.

Our session this morning runs from 12.30 p.m. to 2.30 p.m., and one item is on the clár, which is an engagement with witnesses on Ireland’s contribution to COP31 in terms of ambition, leadership and global climate action. The Conference of the Parties, COP, is the supreme decision-making body of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, UNFCCC. The annual meeting sees nearly 200 nations gather to negotiate climate action and review emission reduction progress. The COP31 meeting is taking place in Türkiye during Ireland’s Presidency of the Council of the EU. The Minister, Deputy Darragh O’Brien, has said that Ireland will provide strong and co-ordinated leadership for the EU at the conference.

I welcome the following witnesses to our session: from Trócaire, Ms Sinéad Loughran, climate justice and policy advocacy adviser; from Christian Aid, Mr. Seán McLoughlin, policy and advocacy officer; from ActionAid, Mr. Cillian Quinn, policy and programmes manager; from Maynooth University, emeritus Professor John Sweeney; and from Grow It Yourself, GIY, Mr. Mick Kelly, chief executive officer. They are all very welcome here today.

I remind everyone to ensure that their mobile phone is on silent mode or switched off. As is normal, before I invite opening statements, I advise of the following in relation to parliamentary privilege. Witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

In terms of the format of this meeting, I will invite the witnesses to make an opening statement to a maximum of five minutes. Once that statement has been delivered, I will then call on members of the committee, in the order that they indicate to me, to put their questions. They will each have an initial five minutes to engage with our witnesses. The five minutes is for both questions and answers. Therefore, it is essential for members to put their questions succinctly and witnesses to be succinct in their responses. Please note that the duration of this meeting is limited and, therefore, the times must be adhered to. I ask everybody to focus on their contributions, please.

We now take our first opening statement. I call Ms Loughran to make her opening statement on behalf of Trócaire.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

Gabhaim buíochas leis an gcomhchoiste as an gcuireadh chun an chruinnithe inniu. This COP31 meeting is the first time that the annual COP will take place with the knowledge that the Paris Agreement’s critical temperature limit of 1.5 °C will be breached significantly, and an optimistic scenario places expected peak temperature rise at 1.8 °C. As the United Nations Environment Programme, UNEP, outlines, this means significant risks and impacts around the world, including faster sea level rise, increased risk of ecosystem collapse, including coral reefs, more extreme heat and wildfires, profound changes to ice sheets, sea ice and glaciers, and increased risk of irreversible tipping points to global systems such as the west Antarctic and Greenland ice sheets, the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation, AMOC, and the Amazon rainforest. These are tipping points that would reshape the world forever.

It is in this context that the outcomes of COP31 and the ambition and actions of those most responsible for the climate crisis must be judged. The UNEP’s dire projections serve to highlight the failure of those most responsible to act and the urgent action required from those richer countries, including Ireland, and large corporations that have continuously failed to reduce emissions at the pace or scale needed and repeatedly failed to deliver climate finance or reparations to remedy this situation. The UNEP warning means that unprecedented climate action is needed to protect the poor and vulnerable, minimise harm to infrastructure and livelihoods, and support people and nature.

To continue this failure on climate obligations and to fail to course correct our policies, particularly here in Ireland, is to disregard the rights and existence of communities around the world and to continue to put their safety, their welfare and most fundamental human rights on hold. This inaction is reflected in the UNFCCC’s climate negotiations where, following a watered down inclusion of fossil fuels in the outcome of COP28, the final agreements of the last two COPs have failed to even mention the main driving force of climate breakdown.

Looking to COP31, the three formal presidency letters already issued have failed to mention fossil fuels even once. Meanwhile, the presence of fossil fuel lobbyists continues to outnumber the country delegations at COP. They outnumbered the combined delegations of the ten most climate-vulnerable countries in 2024 and outnumbered all other countries except the host country, Brazil, last year.

Similarly, action on climate finance has stalled. Developed states continue to undermine the climate finance needs of developing countries and have yet to meet inadequate international climate finance commitments. Ireland is part of this failure, having provided only a fraction of its fair share of climate finance. The fund for responding to loss and damage, almost four years after being agreed at COP27, is in real danger of running out of money within the next year. Existing finance would meet just a fraction of 1% of annual loss and damage finance needs. Developed states are attempting to further evade their climate finance obligations, distracting from the action required to raise new public grant-based finance by arguing that more states should be responsible for climate finance provision and ignoring their own historical responsibility for emissions.

Those who have not caused this crisis are being affected the worst by these stalemates. Across the global south, billions of people who have contributed the least to global emissions have faced escalating climate impacts for decades and experienced water stress, crop failures and food insecurity, displacement and escalating debt in the midst of climate breakdown.

The climate crisis is a deep human rights crisis and a crisis of injustice and inequality, affecting communities around the world and communities that Trócaire works with. In Guatemala, indigenous Mayan communities, who have lived sustainably and protected the Earth for countless generations, are facing insecurity and displacement as droughts and floods hit. As climate and environmental defenders organise to protect natural resources, they are being targeted and attacked by states and corporations.

Food insecurity is compounded by poverty, conflict, economic instability and repeated weather extremes being driven by climate change, particularly this year by a supercharged El Niño, which the World Food Programme estimates could push at least 49 million more people into acute food insecurity by the end of 2027. Agroecology must be prioritised and supported as a central approach to building efficient, resilient and socially just food systems and addressing rising food insecurity.

Justice and equity must inform the approach of states at COP31 and their commitment to act domestically with urgent science- and equity-based climate action. The UNFCCC stalemate inaction and, more importantly, the devastating impacts of climate change and the risks of inaction require every state to do more. In particular, it demands more of those who have caused and who continue to drive the climate crisis, and those in leadership positions.

Ireland has two very prominent leadership positions over the next year: through its role in the EU Presidency during COP31 and through its role as co-host with Tuvalu of the second transitioning away from fossil fuels, TAFF, conference process. However, it is not enough to engage in COP processes every year or to join international declarations without taking the necessary action at home that is urgently required. Ireland cannot credibly take leadership on a fossil fuel phase-out while simultaneously pushing new fossil fuel infrastructure and ever-expanding energy demand driven through the proliferation of data centres.

We are long past time on taking urgent action domestically, and in this context, recommendations to Ireland ahead of COP31 cannot be viewed in isolation from domestic action. Ireland and the EU’s climate action must reflect its fair share of action under a 1.5°C pathway in line with the principles of common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities, CBDR-RC, and equity, which are central to the Paris Agreement and the UNFCCC. They must increase domestic climate ambition, rejecting the inclusion of international credits in the post-2030 EU architecture. In Ireland, the proposed temperature neutrality approach to post-2030 carbon budgets must be rejected, with an independent peer review process of the proposals put forward. Taking immediate and fair corrective action to address a shortfall in action to 2030 in Ireland is also required, as is immediately halting plans for new fossil fuel infrastructure in Ireland, committing to no new fossil fuel infrastructure, including no liquefied natural gas, LNG, of any kind, and developing a schedule for an urgent and fair fossil fuel phase-out.

Ireland and the wider EU must reduce energy demand in line with domestic, including EU law, and international climate obligations and reject energy demand increases. Electrification targets must be set beyond that of the global targets, must not allow for additional or continued fossil fuel dependence and must displace fossil fuel use. Ireland must regulate to prohibit investments by Irish companies and Irish-based subsidiaries of multinational investment companies in the fossil fuel industry as part of an urgent fossil fuel phase-out. Ireland must announce new post-2025 climate finance plans and pledges to meet its fair share of international climate finance in public, grant-based form, including new pledges to the fund for responding to loss and damage, FRLD, which has only received a fraction of 1% of annual loss and damage finance needs. Ireland should support the establishment of a permanent agenda item on loss and damage finance. It is also critical to ensure that loss and damage gets the political attention it needs throughout the UNFCCC processes. Ireland and the wider EU must also engage and support an updated and timebound extension to the Sharm el-Sheikh joint work programme on the implementation of climate action supports that are focused on countries' needs and ensure the inclusive participation and benefit of smallholder farmers and rural communities most impacted by climate change. Ireland and the wider EU must also support the recognition of agroecology as a central approach to building efficient, resilient and socially just food systems and champion access to agricultural climate finance in support of just agricultural transitions that are locally and farmer centred. These are a summary of recommendations, but more details are available in the briefing I provided.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

I thank the committee for the invitation to speak today.

As an international aid and development organisation, we see that the climate crisis is profoundly unequal, as those who have contributed least to global emissions often face the greatest impacts with the fewest resources to respond.

In the interests of time, I will focus on three specific issues on the table at COP31 in Türkiye that the committee may wish to engage with the Government on: climate finance, adaptation finance and a just transition.

Climate finance will be one of the most consequential issues at COP31 and a key negotiating track. At its heart is a simple question: who should provide finance to respond to the climate crisis, and what should be prioritised? Alongside emissions reductions, a key pillar of the 2015 Paris Agreement was a commitment that the world’s wealthiest, highest-polluting countries would provide the resources needed to tackle the climate crisis. This reflects the “polluter pays” principle, designed to ensure that developing countries are not left to bear the brunt of a crisis they are least responsible for creating. Western countries, including Ireland, have fallen far short of this commitment.

COP31 will seek agreement on a new climate finance work programme. Developing countries want to protect the commitment to public, grant-based finance that does not add to existing debt burdens. Developed countries have generally favoured a broader discussion of Article 9 of the Paris Agreement, including private investment. Diluting this programme into another general discussion about attracting private investment would be a mistake, as it is public finance that pays for measures the private sector is unlikely to fund at scale, including flood defences, drought resilience, early warning systems and support for the poorest communities recovering from climate disasters.

Ireland should therefore support a COP31 agenda item on climate finance that protects core Paris Agreement commitments. This must include defending grant-based finance in the new $300 billion global target agreed at COP29, the responsibility of high-polluting wealthy countries and interim milestones before 2035. We must also seek to step up and provide our own fair share of existing targets, which best academic estimates put at approximately €500 million per year, more than double the current levels.

Looking a bit deeper, funding for climate adaptation is a key part of this finance. It helps countries prepare for and reduce climate impacts through, for example, coastal defences, irrigation systems and climate-resilient agriculture. COP31 agreed the political objective of tripling this finance but did not specify a baseline, financial figure or delivery roadmap. Based on tripling the intended $40 billion level for 2025, this implies at least $120 billion annually by 2035, but that figure is not explicit in the decision. COP31 must also resolve uncertainty on this issue. Ireland should therefore push the EU to support a clear baseline, an explicit financial target and a delivery roadmap, with milestones to assess progress. It should also ensure that adaptation finance is accessible, grant-based and does not add to already high-debt burdens. A commitment to triple finance means little if countries cannot determine what is being tripled or whether delivery is on track.

The third issue is a just transition. In Ireland, this phrase is understood to mean reskilling workers whose jobs depend on fossil fuels or peat extraction or protecting households from higher energy costs. However, in many poorer countries, millions of people still lack access to electricity. In these circumstances, a just transition is not simply about replacing one source of energy with another. It is also about expanding access to reliable, affordable and clean energy for the first time, charting a development path that does not rely on polluting fossil fuels.

A just transition also raises questions about the critical raw minerals needed for clean technologies. Demand for copper, lithium, nickel and cobalt will increase as the world builds more solar panels, wind turbines and electric vehicles. Without safeguards, this risks repeating old patterns of extraction, where minerals are exported while jobs, processing and economic value are created elsewhere. A genuinely just transition must therefore ensure that mineral extraction respects human and environmental rights, supports local development and creates meaningful economic opportunities in producing countries.

At COP30 in Belém, agreement was reached to develop a so-called just transition mechanism, but fundamental questions were left unresolved, including its functions, governance and operation. At COP31, Ireland should work to ensure that the mechanism is able to grapple with the thorny issues of energy access and critical raw materials and of helping developing countries access the finance, technology and capacity they need to implement a just transition nationally.

Climate change presents the co-operative international principles upon which the Irish State was founded with a new test. Can there be equal rights between peoples when those who contributed least to a crisis suffer first and worst? Can there be meaningful self-determination when decisions in wealthy economies determine whether another nation’s territory remains habitable? Can an international order be just if the victim is required to borrow to pay for destruction it did little to cause? Ireland must have a credible answer to these questions at COP31.

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

I thank the committee for the opportunity to speak today on behalf of ActionAid Ireland. We are an international women’s rights organisation that works with communities on the front lines of the climate crisis across more than 70 countries. A central part of our work is looking at the systems that drive poverty and inequality and how those systems shape people’s ability to respond to climate change and deny women their rights.

I want to focus on two closely connected issues: the debt crisis facing climate-vulnerable countries and the increasing reliance on private money as the answer to the climate finance gap within the EU.

Ireland has a crucial role at this year’s COP in shaping and leading the EU position. It gives Ireland an opportunity to show leadership. We already prioritise grants-based climate finance, but we must go further and challenge the unjust international financial system that pushes climate vulnerable countries further into debt. Climate leadership means very little if we are not addressing the simple fact that countries facing the worst impacts are forced to service debt rather than prepare for the next cyclone, drought or flood.

Debt is probably the clearest example of how the current financial system is failing climate vulnerable countries. Some 93.5% of the most climate-vulnerable countries are in or at significant risk of debt distress. ActionAid’s recent research looked at 65 of the countries most vulnerable to climate change. It found they are spending nearly 25 times more on debt repayments than on climate action, while debt servicing absorbs 65% of their combined government revenue. Debt repayments by the global south are nearly a shocking 225 times the grant-based climate finance received from the global north.

Malawi is a good example of how this becomes a vicious cycle. After numerous destructive cyclones, the country has had to borrow hundreds of millions of dollars to rebuild. For example, following Cyclone Freddy in 2023, the country had to borrow $120 million from the World Bank. That borrowing then creates higher repayments, which leaves less money available to prepare for the next disaster that hits and when it does, the country is forced to borrow again to recover. In 2026, around 70% of Malawi’s national budget was spent on debt repayments. That is money that cannot be spent strengthening resilience for the next cyclone that hits the country.

Another key point to highlight is the incredible inequality that exists within the debt system. For example, the US can borrow with an average interest rate of 2.8%, whereas for countries in sub-Saharan Africa this sits at about 9.8%. Ireland has a strong reputation for providing climate finance as grants rather than adding to countries’ debt burdens, and that is something we should be proud of. However, the impact of that finance is being undermined by a much bigger debt crisis around it. Ireland rightly positions itself as an ally of countries in the global south and of people experiencing inequality. This is demonstrated through our priorities for the EU presidency. However, if Ireland wants to live up to this, we need to bring debt into the climate space, as it is one of if not the defining issue these countries face.

The second issue I raise is the growing reliance on private finance as the answer to the climate finance gap. The attraction of private finance to address global problems including climate change is understandable. Guarantees, loans and blended finance offer an apparently attractive proposition to use public resources to mobilise additional private investment. The argument is that responsible private investment can create jobs, support infrastructure and contribute to economic development.

ActionAid’s report published earlier this year in partnership with Concord and Eurodad, entitled Blended Finance and the Illusion of Development, highlights the risk that blending tends to favour large, investment-driven projects aligned with investor requirements, while smaller local enterprises and community-led priorities struggle to access support. In short, private finance follows return. It tends to go to projects, sectors and countries where there is a potential return on investment. It does not favour contexts where the need is greatest. This type of finance is less likely to support communities facing drought in the Horn of Africa or flooding in south Asia. This research is based on evidence from more than 15 years of EU experience which shows that blended finance and guarantees operate within clear limits: they are driven by profitability and risk–return considerations, and consistently underperform when applied to the most pressing and transformational development and climate needs, particularly in least developed and fragile contexts. There is also a risk that the shift towards a focus on private finance encourages solutions to climate change that look attractive to investors but do little to address the climate crisis. Through research last year, we showed carbon markets and offsetting nearly always fail to provide any real climate benefit. Worse, they have a history of subjecting host communities to various abuses and human rights violations.

Private finance and debt are obviously linked. If climate finance increasingly comes through loans, guarantees and other instruments designed to bring in private capital, countries already under severe debt pressure can be pushed further into the same cycle. Paradoxically, that debt pressure even drives countries to expand fossil fuel extraction to try to raise revenue in order to service their debts. Ireland should continue to champion grant-based climate finance, particularly for adaptation, loss, damage and a just transition, and push for clear limits on how much public climate finance is channelled through blended and leverage-based instruments.

I want to finish by bringing this back to what these discussions mean in practice. Right now, my colleagues in Nepal are responding alongside communities to the catastrophic flooding seen last month - a disaster that was driven by climate change. These discussions matter for the thousands of families still searching through forests and mud for loved ones who have not yet been found five weeks on. COP matters for those families and for communities globally who are on the frontlines of the climate crisis. Ireland should use its role this COP to push for finance that has a real impact today for adaptation, loss, damage and a just transition. However, if that finance is to have the impact we need it to, we must also address the debt crisis that is stripping countries of their ability to respond to a crisis not of their making.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

This is a very timely meeting in view of the special position Ireland will hold in Antalya next month. COP is the supreme decision-making body of the UNFCCC and I begin by paying tribute to the pioneering work of a Member of these Houses, the late Professor Jim Dooge, who was very much involved in the early days of the formation of the UNFCCC and the IPCC. He was a statesman of great vision and ability. I worked with him on a number of occasions and can testify to his outstanding abilities as a scientist and diplomat. I have now attended 14 COPs in the primary capacity of an observer, so my impressions are coming from interactions with other national delegations with EU officials, Irish officials and participating ministers.

The positive aspect I see comes from Ireland’s favourable impression among many of the global south countries, in particular the small island developing states, SIDS. Ireland has been particularly favourable towards assisting those bodies and the climate stress countries of the LDCs in the Irish Aid countries of Africa and Asia. I agree with all my colleagues that this has not been sufficient or adequate. All the arguments they have made for increasing this are valid ones. One of the most positive impressions I got was from the professional approach of officials in the Department of foreign affairs, who have made a very strong mark on many of those smaller countries in supporting their efforts in loss and damage which will, as has been said by Mr. Quinn, assume centre stage in Turkey.

As part of the EU negotiating block, my impression is that in the past, Ireland has not really assumed a leading role. In the distant past, it has sheltered behind the intransigence of the United States and the UK. Of course, that is now gone so it is very much exposed as a country to what it says and does, and its commitment to climate and global action in Antalya. The mandate the Irish Government has in Antalya is central to implementing the mandate from the EU, as an objective chair and as somebody who is supposed to push the EU mandate in three or four areas.

Implementation over pledges is one of the key things one looks to the Irish Government to push for strongly at this particular event, as well as fossil fuel phase-out and a clear commitment to transition away from fossil fuels, building on the consensus of COP30 and fostering the transitioning away from fossil fuels, TAFF, process. We can generally assume COP will not come out with the kind of revolutionary changes it has failed to do for 30 years so far. However, we would look to the Irish Government to push for the Santa Marta process to be more active. The other aspects are clean energy and efficiency, with concrete actions like tripling renewable energy development, doubling energy efficiency, expanding electrification as has been said already, and of course, targeting major emitters. The EU will be arguing that large global emitters should carry a special responsibility for recovering the overshoot from 1.5°C.

I have given the committee a few examples of where there are problems in the Irish approach, which centre on signing up to pledges and then ignoring them at domestic level. We have seen various failures in that area, going all the way back to Paris and supposed attempts to keep temperatures rises to 1.5°C, but then failing in our emission reductions to make a concerted effort to do that. I draw attention also to the global methane pledge and the way in which that has not been made operational in any way within domestic policy, with an increase from 2005 to 2023 and only slight changes since then.

There is also the question of subsidies. Global subsidies were supposed to be phased out after COP28. I stress those are inefficient subsidies. I am not mentioning or commenting on essential subsidies needed for energy-stressed communities. However, untargeted subsidies are becoming increasingly apparent as something that do not reconcile with the COP process. The CSO estimates that subsidies to fossil fuels in Ireland were €4.7 billion in 2024. We added €750 million in June last year and another €270 million later last year. As the events of yesterday are reported we know that we are now adding €100 million in fossil fuel subsidies every month. I stress those are untargeted. That is considerable. If you add them up they are approximately €6 billion, which is approximately three times the size of the children's hospital and half the size of the education budget of this country.

We have to look closely at how the Irish negotiating team will reconcile some of those domestic inconsistencies with the need to be objective in pushing the EU mandate. Of course, I could give a list of other contradictions such as reneging on carbon taxation, setting aside domestic climate legislation, limiting access to justice and breaching our commitments to the EU and to the climate Act. All of that will be closely scrutinised and it is fair to say that other countries are very clear on what Ireland is doing and not doing in this area. They will be watching the position closely and any attempts to kick the can down the road will be scrutinised closely in Antalya.

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the invitation to speak today. I am the founder of Grow It Yourself, GIY. For almost 20 years, our work has been about reconnecting people with real food and helping people and communities to understand how food is grown, where it comes from and why that matters. I will make one central argument today. Food security is climate resilience. Ireland should make resilient food systems part of its contribution to COP31. Ireland is routinely described as one of the most food-secure countries in the world. In the most recent Global Food Security Index, we ranked second out of 113 countries. I believe that statistic gives us a false sense of security. Being a world-leading agricultural exporter is not the same thing as being able to feed ourselves. We have built an extraordinarily successful agricultural export economy in this country. Our total agrifood exports were worth €21.2 billion last year, with €12.3 billion of that relating to dairy, meat and livestock. There is nothing inherently wrong with exports. They support farmers and rural communities, but they represent an extraordinary contradiction at the heart of our food system.

While we export approximately 90% of the food we produce, independent research suggests that around four fifths of the calories we actually consume are imported. Approximately 83% of our fruit and vegetables comes from abroad. Our reality is that we rank second in the world for food security, while importing most of the food we actually eat. In a world of predictable weather and reliable supply chains, perhaps that model looks secure, and even logical. However, in a world of drought, floods, crop failures, geopolitical instability and disrupted supply chains, it makes us look dangerously vulnerable. Real food security must mean having the land, growers and skills to feed our own population. In the 1990s Ireland had more than 600 commercial field-scale vegetable growers. Today we have fewer than 70. Recent research by the farmer-led organisation Talamh Beo has identified an invisible network of more than 350 local food farms across Ireland with more than 200 of those involved in horticulture. These are smaller growers and market gardens supplying their communities through vegetable boxes, farmers’ markets and other supply chains. We need both. We need to protect and expand the commercial growers capable of producing significant volumes of Irish food. We should also be enabling hundreds more small-scale organic and regenerative growers, producing intensively on relatively small banks of land and feeding families in their own communities.

Do not let anyone tell us that Ireland does not have the land or the climate to become a serious horticultural producer again. Look at the Netherlands. It has less than half the land area of the Republic of Ireland, a broadly comparable climate, and yet its horticultural exports were worth €38 billion in 2025. The Dutch experience grew from necessity. After the catastrophic food shortages of the Second World War, the Netherlands made domestic food production a national priority and invested over decades in the research, skills, technology, infrastructure and growers it needed to do so. I believe Ireland needs its own strategic shift and "Dig for Victory" moment, not because we are at war, but because climate change is fundamentally altering the risks around how we feed ourselves. Ireland has already demonstrated that when policy, research, investment and markets align behind an agricultural sector, we can become world class. We need to bring some of that same ambition to the field, the orchard, the polytunnels and the market gardens.

Resilience is not just about what farmers grow; it is about what its citizens know. When people, particularly children, grow and cook food they learn about soil, seasons, weather, biodiversity and food waste. They understand what it takes to get food from seed to plate. These are not just nice gardening skills. They are critical resilience skills in an age of climate change. I ask Ireland to bring three propositions to COP31. First, put food security and resilient food systems and the strategic shift needed in our agriculture at the heart of climate adaptation. Second, champion the rebuilding of domestic horticulture and support established commercial growers alongside a new generation of smaller scale organic and regenerative producers by providing them with a universal basic income for local food farmers. Third, recognise that practical food education has a role, including the growing and cooking of it, as part of climate resilience. Give every child the opportunity to acquire those skills in schools. COP31 will rightly be about emissions, targets and climate finance. However, climate action must address a much more fundamental question. Can a country feed itself and its people in a changing climate? We cannot control the worsening droughts, floods and crop failures that are coming, but we can decide how vulnerable we are to them. A climate-resilient Ireland must be an Ireland that is able to feed itself.

Comment on this

I thank all of the witnesses who have shared their expertise. We are grateful for it. They have laid out a fairly stark picture. Professor Sweeney touched on the national and international picture. As we are talking about COP today, my first question is about the proliferation of corporate and fossil fuel lobbyists at COP, who clearly have more people and resources than any of the environmental NGOs working in the sector. A culture seems to have developed there. What, if anything, can be done to arrest that? How do you reduce the voice of industry on this global stage? How do they see that happening?

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

I thank the Deputy. It is certainly a massive problem, and the influence is growing every year. In 2024 in Baku, the combined total of the delegations from the ten most climate-vulnerable countries was lower than the number of fossil fuel lobbyists. It is not just fossil fuel lobbyists, but the distraction industries that go with it like carbon capture and storage, and everything that is trying to prop up the longevity of an industry clearly running out of road. There are definitely steps that can be taken in the transitioning away from fossil fuels process, which Ireland is co-hosting with Tuvalu next year. When Colombia initiated that process with the Netherlands last year it was clear that it wanted to keep that kind of corporate power out or at least be able to identify it from the beginning. A screening process was built into the application process.

COP is now reporting on the lobbyists that will be there, so there is a bit more transparency around it, but there is simply no reason for them to be there. When we look at the World Health Organization and the movement around tobacco bans, tobacco lobbyists were banned from that, so why are we involving fossil fuel lobbyists in a movement that very simply says we have no more space for fossil fuels, in a world facing climate catastrophe?

Comment on this

What could the Irish Presidency do about that in leading the EU delegation there?

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

We would want to see the same steps taken in the TAFF process next year with Tuvalu and to bring that even further along in the COP process. A number of international networks and organisations work quite closely on this, such as the Kick the Big Polluters Out campaign. This and other organisations have specific measures that they want to see countries, including Ireland, taking. They do not have access to the negotiations in the way we do. I can send on more details on those afterwards.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

Unfortunately, some countries include the fossil fuel lobbyists as part of their official delegations. That is what makes it rather difficult, because it interferes with the independence of countries to nominate their own delegates. It is important that they be called out, if at all possible, on that.

Comment on this

Professor Sweeney mentioned that we are subsidising fossil fuels in this country up to the value of about €6 billion every year. That is a staggering figure. Obviously, there are good reasons for targeted supports for low-income homes and people who are suffering from energy poverty. We all understand the reason for the interventions in that area, that is, because we are not decarbonising quickly enough and urgently enough in this country.

There has been a lot of talk nationally about the moves regarding carbon tax. For all the talk, it has taken about €43 off the cost of filling a home heating oil tank, which would cost about €1,500. It is not a massive reduction. It does seem like a regressive move from a climate perspective. Again, I can understand why these measures were taken, but are there other ways to crack this nut? What would the alternatives be? Even Fuels for Ireland advocated cutting excise duty rather than attacking carbon tax.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

There are many ways to crack the nut. The first thing is probably not to subsidise the Rolls-Royces and the mansions, which is effectively what an untargeted approach is doing. We could look at energy poverty more closely and allow energy credits for the energy-poor population and allow people to retrofit more easily than they do at the moment. We could even go for a more radical solution, such as transferable energy credits, in the form of a kind of ETS at a local level. This would favour the energy-poor population rather than those who can afford to buy their way out of trouble. It takes imagination and it is more about looking at a radical solution rather than a blanket approach. If we go down the road of subsidising fossil fuels to the extent of €7 billion, €8 billion or €9 billion per year, it takes away a lot of Government finance in the form of taxation from the taxpayer that could be used for more productive purposes.

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

When the fuel protests happened, there was a massive cultural opportunity to encourage people to switch to EVs. There was definitely an appetite for that at that time, which could have been tapped into. We see it in the sales of EVs this year going up significantly, but that could have been supported even further by diverting some of that funding into subsidies for EVs.

Comment on this

It is a huge picture in terms of what is happening. I want to come at a few of the areas. What Ireland and the EU will do is really important. Professor Sweeney talked about targeting major emitters and the implementation of pledges. When the EU Commissioner was before the committee last week, I was struck by the focus on China, yet there was an unwillingness to talk about the United States as a country not in the room. At previous COPs the EU has taken a position of almost using the failures of others to justify its own inaction, rather than seeing the need to step up in terms of the planetary situation and risk, when the United States is not at the table in the context of the Paris Agreement.

The fossil fuel piece and the Santa Marta process were mentioned. Are there mechanisms in that to limit imports of LNG from a country that is not part of the Paris Agreement? Can measures like that become a pressure point?

I welcome the crucial research on the debt piece. It sits alongside the issue of loss and damage. There is the debt that is owed in terms of loss and damage. There are arguments that it is not just loss and damage but climate debt and climate justice and it is grossly underfunded. It tends to focus on disasters, such as the flood in Nepal. This goes to Mr. Kelly as well. Let us consider a slower disaster whereby a country becomes uninhabitable and food production can no longer happen. Is that getting factored into or recognised in the loss and damage piece or is it just the crises and that cycle of crisis of extreme weather events that gets funded? Maybe Ireland can give leadership, like Denmark once did, on acknowledging that loss and damage is a debt. How important is that?

Ms Loughran mentioned the de-risking point and the private finance problem was mentioned, whereby we subsidise ExxonMobil or Shell. She might talk about who we are de-risking versus money from the ground up.

I do not have much more time but I have so many questions. On the Santa Marta process and the phase-out, what would meaningful progress on that look like for Ireland to deliver leadership on it? What does Ireland need to do to challenge the EU, in line with the obligation that climate finance needs to deliver?

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Okay, let us take that group of questions.

Comment on this

Sorry, I know it is a lot of questions.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

It is quite a lot to grasp, but I will do my best. The argument the Senator makes about pointing to China and the US is one that is made generally by the public. To me, it is a morally bankrupt argument. Either we should do the right thing or we should not, but we cannot point the finger at other countries if we are not performing ourselves.

On the impacts the Senator described, 36,000 people who died in Europe this summer would still be with us without the extra heat associated with climate change. That is quite significant. There were 2,000 or 3,000 such deaths in England and Wales. We do not really know how many we had in Ireland as result of the heatwaves this summer, but I would suspect the figure is in the hundreds.

In terms of economic losses, in the course of the summer we lost 6,800 sq. km of land in Europe from wildfires. This implies a loss of biodiversity, vegetation and productive landscapes. It is equivalent to the loss of counties Kildare, Dublin, Meath and Wicklow combined, which is considerable. The cost of extreme weather events for Europe this summer is €180 billion. That is equivalent to one third of the Irish economy. Even within Europe, we are talking about major impacts. We are not exclusively thinking of climate change as a Third World problem here. We have to recognise that.

The Senator is right; a radical approach by the Government at COP is necessary and it should make a stand on the Santa Marta process. It should say what we will do in Ireland as exemplars and climate champions, if we are going to call ourselves that. The Government should say what we will do to meet our own targets domestically, because we have not really demonstrated that. The graph at the end of my submission shows our failure over the past 30 years to do that. We have to lead by example.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

I will come in on the loss and damage fund and the Santa Marta process. In respect of Professor Sweeney’s point, the meaningful thing Ireland can do around the Santa Marta process is to commit to establishing no new fossil fuel infrastructure. Currently, we are ploughing ahead with fossil fuel infrastructure at break-neck speed. Another meaningful opportunity for Ireland is to support the call for a fossil fuel non-proliferation treaty and to ground everything around the Tuvalu process in the ambition being driven by the Pacific Islands over the past number of years, such as calls for a fossil fuel non-proliferation treaty and the advisory opinion of the International Criminal Court, ICJ, that was driven by those countries feeling the worst impacts of climate change. From an EU and Irish perspective, we could align climate action with the 1.5°C pathway because we are simply not taking our fair share of action.

The scale of inaction around finances to the loss and damage fund is staggering. Since the fund was agreed at COP27 and fully set up at COP28, less than 1% of the annual finance needs of the fund has been committed, less than that has been paid into the fund, and less again is available for the start-up phase of the fund. It is staggering to try to comprehend how poorly funded this is. As Professor Sweeney said, it is a distraction tactic. It cannot be underestimated how lacking in any semblance of credibility it is to point the finger at other countries that should be paying their contributions to climate finance when Ireland is part of the problem. Ireland’s contribution to the loss and damage fund is less than 1% of its annual fair share. We have not seen a pledge for 2026. We saw €12.5 million provided in 2024 and 2025, but that figure also included existing commitments already made to mitigation and adaptation finances. It is a case of robbing Peter to pay Paul whenever we are already failing to meet our fair share of climate finance obligations, including mitigation and adaptation finances.

Developed countries are not taking on board the opportunities they have to raise new public, grant-based sources of finance. Developed countries could do much more to raise that kind of finance. To go back to the subsidies piece, they could phase out subsidies that target fossil fuel production while ensuring supports are in place for communities, families and households to transition to clean energies. Aviation taxes have been non-existent. In Ireland, subsidies to aviation have increased since 2019. There is so much more that Ireland and developed states can do in this regard. It is not credible at all to point the finger at others to pay up when we are nowhere close to meeting our targets.

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

I thank the Senator for the question about climate debt. I did not touch on it earlier, but we carried out a report last year to determine who owes who and understand the figures in this regard. We estimate that approximately €107 trillion is owed by rich, polluting countries to lower income countries. That is from a history of colonialism and extractivism.

On the point about private finance, we looked at the European Fund for Sustainable Development, which tries to get guarantees from public money using private money. The OECD looked at it and found that approximately 50% of those funds go to middle-income countries. Only 12% is reaching low-income countries. That is the evidence in this regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

The Senator asked what Ireland needs to do and what positions within the EU need to be challenged. For example, developing the global goal on adaptation is an ongoing process that will feature at the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, UNFCCC, and COP this year. Essentially, it seeks to develop a similar framework to that secured as part of the Paris Agreement whereby a clear global target of 1.5°C will be agreed for adaptation. COP30 has adopted 59 indicators in this regard and set out a pathway forward. The talks in Bonn this year ended without agreement because the EU, essentially, refused to negotiate on including the commitment to triple adaptation finance in this global goal on adaptation. This is a concrete issue where Ireland should push the EU to accept that this was a commitment made and that it should be on the table at COP31. Otherwise, we risk reaching non-agreement again.

Similarly, with regard to the climate finance work programme I mentioned, developed countries in the EU have generally taken the position that it should be an overall Article 9 discussion, that is, a broad discussion on climate finance. Developing countries are asking that it focuses on Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement, which is central to direct transfers of finance from developed countries under the UNFCCC to developing countries. That is another specific area where the EU could be challenged.

Comment on this

I welcome our witnesses. The outcome of the session is to write to the Taoiseach and the relevant Ministers leading the EU delegation. The first message has to be to get our own house in order first.

I will direct my question to the witness with the most experience of the COPs, namely, Professor Sweeney. Ireland is going to be leading a disparate EU. There are many disparate governments across the EU. We might also see a shift to the right in Spain. What leadership approach is required in such a situation, because that delegation is going to be challenging from within? We have issues around the competitiveness fund, the move to simplification and the stripping away of environmental requirements. From an EU delegation point of view, we probably were seen as leaders at previous COPs, but now we seem to be moving into a laggard status. How does Professor Sweeney see that panning out?

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

It is a difficult situation. However, it is not unparallelled. In the past, Ireland often played the role of peacemaker at the various breakfast meetings that are held to try to adopt a unified EU position. Some of the EU countries had different agendas when it came to, for example, phasing out coal and oil. Ireland played that role quite successfully in the past. The Senator is correct that Ireland will have to play that role again this time around. It is going to be difficult, but I get the impression that the events of this summer have swung things a bit more once again towards the need for action. The blocks will not be quite as bad this time around as they were before some of the more recent elections, such as those in eastern Europe last year. It may not be as difficult to get people on board with a progressive agenda this year as we might have feared.

I take the point about the process of responsibility the Senator mentioned. One of the most poignant moments I experience every year at the COP is the Tuvaluan minister standing up with his mobile phone and showing pictures of his grandchildren. He asks the global community what he should tell them about the names they have given to towns, streets and hedges, about the ancestors buried in the graveyard that will be washed away and about the meaning of responsibility. For us in the First World, that is a hard question to address, but we must do so. That is why I hope the Irish Government will not be found wanting in the Santa Marta process. I hope it will say, “We are the people responsible. We are the people who have to take action. We have to change the way we do business here in order to ensure those grandchildren have a more sustainable future.”

Comment on this

I have a question for Ms Loughran. I thank her for providing the briefing document. It details the consistency of the Paris Agreement with financial flows. This shows Ireland in a poor light when it comes to funding and housing fossil fuel investments. Trócaire produced a good report in that regard not too long ago. How do we move away from that sort of financing? We are involved in the financing of genocide as well. These are significant challenges for Ireland to try to move away from, but the scale of it is staggering. It is something we feel strongly about.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

It is a significant output from Ireland. The Senator is correct that despite Ireland not being an exporter of fossil fuels, we play a significant role in the global fossil fuel industry. Mr. Quinn from Action Aid wrote the report along with Trócaire. It was a joint effort. Mr. Quinn should feel free to jump in on this discussion.

With regard to the angles from which Ireland should approach this, it should be based on our human rights obligations. When a COP was being held a few years ago, a number of UN special rapporteurs on human rights wrote to businesses ahead of the conference detailing how Saudi Aramco was engaging in fossil fuel exploration and expansion that was not in line with its human rights obligations, and pointing out that its financiers were not compliant with their human rights obligations.

The global fossil fuel industry is not necessarily based here in Ireland, but the financiers that support it are. Ireland has human rights obligations to uphold in ensuring that those financiers are being compliant with their humans rights obligations and ensuring that all financial flows, whether public or private, are consistent with the Paris Agreement goal of limiting the global temperature rise to 1.5°C. That is what the Veredas dialogue, in Article 2.1(c) of the Paris Agreement, outlines. There are very significant ways in which Ireland can and should take action on that, perhaps partly through the EU. There is no reason Ireland cannot start to do this as part of a domestic fossil fuel phase-out. There is no point in phasing out domestically if we are not also ending our complicity in this kind of exploitation and extraction throughout the world.

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

When we released that research, the response was generally to point out that the EU has regulations around this. Given what has just been said around the simplification agenda, the corporate sustainable due diligence directive-----

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

That has now been cut. The original directive had a review clause to look at investment managers, but because of the omnibus that review has been cut. Therefore, we need to take domestic action on this. We will be looking at doing that over the next while.

Comment on this

Gabhaim buíochas le gach duine atá i láthair agus a labhair inniu. My first questions are for Mr. Kelly. I agree with his comment that "Food security is climate resilience." He mentioned that Ireland was ranked second in the index. Does he know why they got that wrong? Where did that information come from?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

Yes. It is partly an affluence measure, in that we are able to buy food when we need to, and it is partly due to the fact that Ireland is a huge producer of cows, which are primarily exported. The massive environmental impacts that flow from that have not been discussed much today yet. Of the €21 billion of agrifood exports, between €12.5 billion and €13 billion relates to meat and dairy exports. That is the challenge.

Comment on this

Yes, I read that in the statement. Obviously, we depend heavily on imported food. I have been following the work done by Mr. Kelly. If the Government and those across from me accepted the argument, what are the practical things that we could do immediately to make us more food resilient?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

As I outlined in my statement, the first thing is to recognise that we have a problem. At the moment, we source our food and make our decisions on the basis of supply chains that are no longer guaranteed to be functional. We think about our food security on a European level, but we actually need to think about it on a nation level. What food can we produce to feed our population if those vulnerabilities come to light, which they will? Earlier this year, the fuel protests and all that went with them, such as the closing of ports, highlighted how vulnerable we are. The first thing is to recognise that we have an issue with the supply chains on which we, as a country, are reliant. Countries like Spain, from which we import huge amounts of vegetables and fruit, could become practically unfarmable. The first step is to recognise that issue. After that, we need to move to reset our agricultural system to make feeding ourselves as a nation a strategic priority. At the moment, our strategic priority in agriculture is about exports. We must also examine the horticultural sector and our ability to produce vegetables and fruit. The diet that all of the research tells us is the most climate friendly and best for our health is collapsing in front of our eyes. It is on the verge of collapse. If we do not do something to fix that, there will be no Irish fruit and vegetables available.

Comment on this

Yes. It is a stark situation for organic growers and the home-based production of Irish food. I know some of the statistics that Mr. Kelly has highlighted in his work.

I want to come back to something else mentioned by Mr. Kelly. There is a bigger opportunity in terms of schools. We have all seen the absolute disaster that the school meals programme has been. I would not give some of the stuff that is being fed to our children to a cat or dog. I would love to see children in primary school learn how to grow potatoes and plant beans, and learn about the three-sister method of planting. This would give them practical base skills for life. Carbon emissions can be reduced if we do not buy carrots that have been transported the entire way from New Zealand. Mr. Kelly has demonstrated through GIY how widely this can be done. We could work towards every primary school having an allotment or a place to grow food as a normal part of children's education. Such knowledge is something that children will use for their entire lives.

I would like to mention a study that was done in Belgium. A local authority gave households two live chickens a year as part of a food waste prevention programme. Their own survey reported a reduction of 30% to 40% in waste. Another benefit is that the chickens eat food scraps and families have a steady supply of eggs. Importantly, the initiative gets people into a fundamental habit of growing food and learning where their food comes from. Would Mr. Kelly like to see such a scheme rolled out as a pilot in primary schools? Has he already done work in that sense?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

Yes. GIY has sent food gardens to over 700 schools around Ireland so far and 95% of that is funded by philanthropy with very little Government support. This year, we submitted a pre-budget submission that sought funding for a national roll-out of that, which would cost €7 per child. This tiny investment would make sure there is a generation of Irish children and young people who understand how food is grown and how to produce it themselves. As I said, this is important not just as a nice gardening activity but also as a critical climate action. It is part of our food security and sovereignty as a nation to have our children and young people learning these kinds of resilience skills. We have the model; we just need Government ambition and funding to get that done.

The Deputy alluded to the school lunch programme. As the State intervenes in a very important way on a food poverty level to feed children in school, it has a massive opportunity - given the scale of the investment, which is €350 million per annum - to target that so that it supports local growers and local organic growers. The scheme can not only feed children and alleviate child poverty; it can also do some very heavy lifting in terms of resetting our agriculture system towards more local, organic regenerative farming and food.

Comment on this

I have worked with some schools and I have grown food myself. Mr. Kelly may have touched on the speed at which microgreens can be grown using vertical farming techniques. I would love to live in an Ireland where every school has a vertical farm and grows microgreens like broccoli and wheatgrass, and then the children drink a smoothie made from those microgreens. As Mr. Kelly will know, microgreens are seven or eight times as nutrient dense as other vegetables and need a lot less light and water. Is that something else Mr. Kelly would like to see interlinked with a school-based programme?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

Yes. We have constructed a food growing programme for schools around the academic year and teaching of the various different subjects. It works but we need Government support to make that happen at a national level. It is ready to be rolled out.

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

The programme just needs that support.

Comment on this

I thank the delegations for their resilience and hope. They keep coming in before every COP to talk to us. I have sat through a few of those meetings and I have to say it is hard to keep the hope up.

I read Mr. Kelly's opening statement with interest. I was quite shocked to learn that 80% of the calories we consume are imported. Many countries are dealing with global turbulence and global biodiversity loss. As ecosystem collapse is now much more of a threat, many governments are looking at this from a national security point of view. It is a massive issue that 80% of our calories are imported. As a population, we are hugely dependent on meat but we cannot live on meat alone.

Mr. Kelly also said that "83% of our fruit and vegetables comes from abroad." If any nation should know about not being reliant on just one crop or one food source, we should. Naturally, all countries will trade whatever they can grow or farm easily. Can Mr. Kelly tell me what we should be looking at, because 80% seems like a very high percentage? Recently, I looked at how the Netherlands has increased the amount of food that it grows and therefore does not have to import.

What impact could we see in Ireland if there was similar disruption to food supply as we have now with fuel because of the global breakdown of biodiversity generally? How seriously should we be taking this?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

We need to take it extremely seriously. The Deputy mentioned that other countries are looking at this. It is getting a lot of attention in the UK in particular because it has had its worst harvest on record, I think. Food security and even the creation of a department of food security is being considered there. We need to think about the same thing here. Unfortunately our focus is almost exclusively elsewhere. I noticed in the budget speeches yesterday that when agriculture was discussed, they talked about exports. There was no mention of the collapse of the horticulture sector. That is not to say that by default growing fruit and vegetables is more climate friendly; it generally has less emissions but it is not perfect by any stretch. We need to make sure we do not lose any more of the big commercial growers. This year we lost a carrot grower in County Kilkenny which grew 13% of the national carrot crop. For some vegetables, we are one or two growers away from not having any of our own supply any more. It is almost unspoken in the national media that this is happening.

The second thing-----

Comment on this

What should we target? We are at 80% at the moment. Should we be trying to get down to 50%? What kind of timescale should we follow from a national security point of view?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

Unfortunately it is a slow process because we are losing generational expertise all the time with these growers. They are often third- or fourth-generation growers. When they leave, they take that expertise with them. It is a big tanker to turn around. There are fruit and vegetables we obviously cannot grow but we have a very friendly environment currently - it is changing and we had three months of drought this summer. Generally speaking, we have a very friendly climate for growing food. I think a 60% or 70% target is realistic. It will take a long time to do that. In the short term, we need to stop the tide of loss in the sector and build community resilience. We have a network of small-scale growers like us, Green Earth Organics in the west and others feeding 250 or 300 families in their communities. That builds resilience in a system that is currently on the brink of collapse.

Comment on this

That is something the committee should look at as well. I have another question because it cannot just be about Ireland but that is really important.

As we have the European Presidency and we are going into COP31, with climate credits and carbon markets offsetting, the system is set up so that wealthy countries can pay for their own climate negligence. That is unfair. While Ireland is very good in that we give grants rather than loans, how can we use our position in Europe now with the EU Presidency to pressure other countries into following our example of grants and not loans?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

Like the Deputy said, we set a very good example by providing our climate finance in grants, and not loans. That is a key element of being in a strong negotiating position. We are putting our money where our mouth is in that regard. It comes back to reminding developed nations, as defined under the UNFCCC, of the agreements made in the past. For example, the UNFCCC recognises that developed countries should take the lead. We have spoken a lot about the 1.5°C limit, which will be overshot. We are heading for about 2.8°C under current policies. There is a clear link between mitigation and adaptation in that the meeting of mitigation targets by developing countries is dependent on developed countries also meeting, in good faith, their own commitments to the UNFCCC to provide financial resources, to provide technology transfer and perhaps to loosen intellectual property rights around renewables energy and energy efficiency to scale up these mitigation measures in the developing world.

Multiple things can be done, but the central point is Ireland should take a strong negotiating position and set out a principled negotiating position at the beginning of COP within the EU and call out where the EU position diverts from that, for example, around issues like the global goal on adaptation. Another example is the climate finance work programme, which currently does not even have an agenda item at COP, despite being agreed last year at COP30 in Belém in Brazil. There is no agenda item for this crucial piece of the negotiating track. There is a scenario where the first week of COP could be spent arguing about whether that should have a negotiating track. These are things Ireland needs to lead on and be clear in its position of solidarity with the least developed countries and small island states to which a lot of our adaptation finance goes in practical, real terms. It needs to be translated into a solid and principled negotiating position at the beginning of COP.

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

To add to what Mr. McLoughlin said and as he mentioned in his opening statement, practically, what Ireland can do - if the committee is writing to the Taoiseach for the Presidency - is focus the discussion on the climate finance work programme on Article 9.1 and not necessarily on Article 9.3 which is around mobilising private finance. That is what I would stress.

Comment on this

I thank our witnesses for joining us today. On overseas aid, the support and the position Ireland has taken in recent times, there have been mixed views domestically and around the world in what we see other countries doing in their approaches. Are the witnesses satisfied with accountability overseas in the implementation of plans, their effectiveness and how we follow up with them to ensure our hard-earned euros are being used effectively overseas?

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

My concern generally, which I tried to get across in my opening statement, relates to the private money coming in. The same level of accountability for money being spent unfortunately is not seen in the same way we see with public finance. I use the example of carbon markets. We are aware of examples from Kenya where there are massive human rights violations and land grabs by employees of those companies. On overseas development aid, Irish Aid does a really good job of holding us to account on reporting. I would not be concerned in that regard. My fear is the shift to private finance. We see it across the EU. Ireland has a massive role at the moment in terms of the multiannual financial framework. Part of that is the global Europe instrument, which is the money that will be used for overseas aid across Europe. European countries are pushing for that to be more about private finance as well. Ireland could resist that push. Grant-based public money is always more accountable and reaches the people we are trying to serve.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Quinn say there is a standardised reporting model?

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

Irish Aid is very strong on that.

Comment on this

Is it seen through the same lens across different jurisdictions?

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

It is fairly standard in terms of the EU budget and EU development aid.

Comment on this

When different states or jurisdictions make decisions to possibly cut overseas budgets, are they informed with the same information that we are informed with here at home?

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

I do not know.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

May I clarify the Deputy's question?

Comment on this

It is about ensuring there is consistency in the information. We might make a decision to increase the level of aid, whereas other countries might decide to reduce it. Are they informed and provided with the same information?

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

To come back to the core principles of us stepping up to our fair share of climate action and actually delivering on climate justice, Ireland has never reached its fair share of climate finance. In 2025, it is expected that Ireland will reach in €225 million in mitigation and adaptation finance but the fair share under the $100 billion goal, which expired in 2025, was €500 million per year.

Comment on this

I am more interested in the accuracy of the information that is being provided.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the Deputy talking about foreign aid in general?

Comment on this

Overseas aid and foreign aid.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Overseas aid in general, not just climate finance.

Comment on this

We can focus on climate finance if we wish, but in general from the witnesses' perspective.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

Part of the confusion as well with ODA and climate finance is that climate finance should also be new in addition to ODA but it is not. That is a real issue because it is taking from a very small budget. Again, for loss and damage the finance is coming from mitigation adaptation. I am not aware of any concerns that we should have. Where there are concerns, and where we should be trying to build in more access and availability for local communities and locally-based organisations, is in terms of the fund for responding to loss and damage. There is no rapid response mechanism built into that fund so the communities in Nepal, for example, cannot access that money right now despite the horrendous situation that has just occurred there. The principle of subsidiarity should be upheld across all climate finance, where those who are actually affected by the impacts and who actually need to access the finance have a role in being able to decide how that money is spent and in being able to access it directly without having to jump through bureaucratic loops and loopholes. As Mr. Quinn mentioned, there is no reason for us to believe that there are any kind of accountability issues.

Comment on this

I have one more question. I had an encounter when we were coming out of Covid when I met a six-year-old child who thought that Tesco made eggs, for obvious reasons. She saw them on the shelves and did not realise what chickens were. It just got me thinking about what we need to do in relation to vegetables and the whole food cycle. There is an opportunity in the area of community allotments. Mr. Kelly spoke about smaller producers and the larger firms and so on. Where would the witnesses see that lying? Is it a responsibility of local authority departments in how we could engage communities to get a process going from identifying land right through to conclusion? I have seen it at first hand in my constituency. There is frustration around trying to get a site, trying to maintain it, and then maybe the owner decides they want a change of use and we go back to square one. Has Mr. Kelly any thoughts on that, or has he seen a best practice model anywhere?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

It is a great question. The responsibility does lie at local authority level currently.

Comment on this

Should it though?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

It should but only if a good job is being done of making that land available. The evidence we are seeing is that this is not happening. It is very slow, as the Deputy said. Where I am from in Waterford there were allotments in Tramore that took ten years to get up and running. The Government has an obligation to make land available. Community Gardens Ireland is doing very important work in this space in lobbying the Government to make sure it honours commitments in that space. Maybe the way to address this is with a kind of double header, or two birds with one stone, with schools. If we are putting food gardens into schools, there are actually ways, and we have seen this happening ourselves with some of the gardens that we have provided for schools, where the schools invite parents and other people in the community to support them in the growing they are doing. That is a way to make that happen.

I agree with the Deputy that the connection children and young people have with food, how it is produced and where it comes from is lacking. We can see this playing out in statistics around the national diet where up to 47% of everything we eat is ultra-processed foods. This ties in to the figure for the number of our calories we are importing. A huge amount of what we eat now is coming from these big global food companies, with all of the climate change impact of that, never mind the health implications.

Comment on this

Professor Sweeney is a neighbour of mine in Maynooth. He has attended 14 COPs and he has identified the gaps,or a recurring gap, between commitments made at COP and the implementation at nation state level. Are there any good examples, or examples of countries that have made commitments at COP and followed through with them?

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

The table at the end of my submission shows countries that have made really good efforts. Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia have advantages in demographics that perhaps we do not have and in economic change. Quite clearly, the Nordic countries have gone down the road of taking this problem very seriously. They have done some very good work in reducing their emissions even at a time of economic growth. The EU has expanded its GDP by 70% since 1990, yet still managed to reduce its emissions by 37% over that period. It is not that it cannot be done; it is the will that really is lacking. It goes back to education to some extent as well. The previous discussion was about growing our food. The Deputy will be familiar with Maynooth University, which has a plan for student allotments on campus as part of the teacher education process. Those kinds of things are the seed capital, if you like, for the future as well. There are things that can be done. Countries are delivering. Ireland is, unfortunately, not delivering.

Senator Higgins made the point about the absence of some big countries and what they are not doing, countries like the United States, for example that will be absent. They have been absent before. What has the effect of that been? It has been to galvanise other countries into actually taking action themselves. Although the United States will not be in Antalya there will be many states there from the United States. There will be many progressive organisations seeking to do what the government is not doing in taking climate action. It is perhaps not fair to tar them all with one brush because there are things happening. The proof of the pudding is in the emissions reduction. That is where we are failing.

Comment on this

I thank the professor. We have a highly successful agricultural export sector and Mr. Kelly rightly identified that a lot of it is in beef and dairy but vegetables and fruit are exported as well. Mr. Kelly and Deputy Cronin both mentioned the volume of imported fruit, and then there are the ultra-processed foods coming in. A lot of it is market-led, with supply and demand of bananas, for example, which we cannot grow here, although I am sure we could in the future depending how things are going. How do we become resilient against the market in this instance where there is a drive and a demand for exotic fruits, as one example, or ultra-processed food? How do we try and diversify away from that? I have one other question for Mr. Kelly if the Chair will allow me after he has answered that one.

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

The Deputy is right to point out exotic fruits and so on, but I would not like to create the impression that this is the core problem here because it is not. We are actually importing 83% of our entire fruit and vegetables. This includes items we can grow really well here. The most extreme example of that is probably potatoes. Traditionally that has been exempt or has not suffered the problems that other types of fruit and vegetables have. Now, even this year, I have had phone calls from a lot of potato growers. It is a brilliant example of the market-led problem the Deputy is talking about where tastes are changing and people are starting to get interested in smaller salad potatoes and things that can be cooked in an air fryer. Supermarkets then respond to that and they are bringing in imported potatoes from the UK and other places. If we set a national ambition to become food secure ourselves, or as food secure as we can become, which is not to say we will never want to bring in coffee or bananas because of course we will, then we should not be importing the products we can produce very well here ourselves. That is the starting point. Supermarkets need to be held to account as well. A retail grower charter was brought in recently, which is welcome, but it does not have teeth. Supermarkets drive a lot of the problem.

Comment on this

I have one last question, and I apologise for putting a rush on Mr. Kelly. The horticulture sector presented in the audiovisual room last week. We are doing a lot in terms of re-wetting bogs and moving away from peat, but they were telling us about coconut coir and wood fibre. Coconut coir comes from the Far East. This is having an impact on the environment. Is there a sustainable way to move off peat onto wood fibre? Green compost is probably the best alternative.

What is he hearing from a lot of the people in GIY?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

It does not feel like a massive issue that needs solving. The solutions to it are relatively straightforward. Most of the organic growers I know, as well as us, were using peat-free composts manufactured in Ireland. That is a solvable issue within the bigger problem.

Comment on this

I know the questions have been asked, but I have one or two for Ms Loughran. The Trócaire COP briefing mentioned the expansion of data centres driving inaction on the fossil fuel phase-out. I ask her about that, and I ask the rest of the panel about greenhouse gas emissions and what Ireland should be doing about tackling those in the agriculture sector. What proposals do they have? The background for that is I met IFA representatives six months ago in the exhibition centre and they said the one thing they wanted was a proper environmental scheme. They felt there was not one.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

To the Deputy's first question on data centres driving inaction on fossil fuels, we have international obligations to reduce our energy demand to align with the 1.5°C pathway, under EU climate law and under our own national law. We know to meet our 2030 carbon budgets we must significantly reduce gas use. However, data centres have driven our energy demand to such an extent we will not even meet our EU energy efficiency directive target for 2030 a full ten years later in 2040. We will still have missed it. That is the extent of inaction we are taking in reducing our energy demand and that is actually driving our fossil fuel use. It means that the renewable energy that has become available to us in the past decade has been cannibalised by data centres, as the Climate Change Advisory Council has pointed out. It is creating this massive bubble of energy demand. Even if it were to be completely provided for by renewable energy in the future that is putting a serious strain on the resources we require from other parts of the world like critical raw materials and minerals. What that means for just transition if we are simply expanding our energy demand to this point far beyond our climate energy obligations for a 1.5°C pathway, never mind our EU targets, is that it simply cannot stack up with regard to land use and exploitation of resources and land throughout the world and potentially in Ireland. Our communities and societies as a whole are not getting the benefit of the renewable energy that has come online in the past ten years because that has been cannibalised, as the CCAC has said.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

The bottom line here is that the market is dictating what farmers do at the moment. The Teagasc annual farm income indicates that dairy farmers had an average income of €150,000. That is a multiple of what grain farmers and arable farmers achieved. Until we achieve a change in the structural supports for agriculture, it is natural to expect that farmers will go for the most profitable enterprises. We cannot go round the subject without questioning the way in which the Common Agricultural Policy is applied in Ireland and look for changes to support the kinds of agriculture we have been hearing about. Other big countries in Europe have managed to go down the beef and dairy route without increasing methane to the same extent as we have. We have taken a move away from the family farm towards intensive agriculture. I do not think a 500 cow farm is a family farm anymore. That is the thing we have to change if we want to get back to the kind of food independence we have been talking about.

I want to add one more thing about the supply chain. We have talked about the importance and critical nature of the supply chain in Ireland for food. We are now facing into an El Niño event, which will question the stability and reliability of many of those food products. It is often associated with a reduction in the monsoon in south Asia. We had one last summer so rice production will be adversely affected in many parts of Asia. We know coffee production is going to be adversely affected. We know cocoa production is going to be adversely affected. Those are things that make us even more vulnerable in the area of food security. We can buy our way out of them to some extent, but is that the way we want to go? What has been said about food security here really implies that we cannot find a technical fix to our methane emissions. We cannot achieve our obligations for 2030 simply by technical fixes in genetics or any other form. We have to change the overall structure of agriculture and favour the production of food calories other than through beef and dairy. A bit of a shift is needed here.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Mr. Quinn mentioned the area of debt. Debts and debt forgiveness are problems that have been around for a long time. Has the COP never grappled with them before?

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

It is not on the COP agenda as such. It has been discussed but it is not a firm agenda item.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Has it ever been?

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

Professor Sweeney would know better than I do.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

No, countries are loath to go down that road at all.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Food security was mentioned. Reading what was said about it, purchasing power was effectively the main measure for our food security, and that does not really stack up. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

Yes, it is as much a measure of the affluence of a country as it is of anything else. Obviously, we are producing vast quantities of food but more of it is for export. On that question, it is worth pointing out that in the context of €21.2 billion in food exports, the farm gate value of horticulture - vegetables and fruit - in Ireland is €650 million. It is dwarfed. With regard to how we reduce our greenhouse gas emissions it goes without saying that the production of fruit and vegetables has lower greenhouse gas emissions. It is better for our health and better for the environment. Depending on the vegetable it is between 1% and 3% of the greenhouse gas emissions of the production of beef. We should reset that balance. It is not that all exports are bad, but we need to be producing way more fruit and vegetables.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Who would be an exemplar in how you measure it? Is it one of the European countries? Who is considered an exemplar?

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

The Netherlands is probably one of the biggest horticulture producers in the world and I understand it is the biggest in the EU. However, it is focused on export of those fruit and vegetables. As an example of a country that was determined to feed itself and change its agriculture system to do that, and has a similar climate to ours, I would say they are the exemplar.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have a similar question for Mr. McLoughlin. He mentioned COP30 in Belém. Agreement was reached to develop a so-called just transition mechanism. Fundamental questions were left unresolved. How does that happen? That is a fundamental thing left unsaid and undefined as a result of COP.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

I will explain that by saying things happen slowly at COP. For example, a just transition work programme has been, and will be, ongoing for a number of years. When the fund for loss and damage was set up, it was established and then it was another process to get it actually operational to define how the governance structure and the fund will be administered. It is the same thing with the just transition mechanism. Last year the decision was made to develop the mechanism. That is as far as it has gotten. There have been no substantive decisions yet on governance and on exactly what that mechanism will look like at the end of the day. That is why I am now stressing that the delegation from the Irish Presidency should go to COP with a positive vision of what that should be.

It should be about connecting communities in developing countries that need a just transition around energy access and transition minerals, with the finance, technology and capacity to do that at the end of the day, rather than just creating a talking shop or a forum for dialogue. That is what I am getting at.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Forgive my ignorance of COP, but is there anything that happens in between?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

There are Bonn intersessionals, which happen in the middle of the year. It is a much smaller operation than COP in terms of delegations. Ireland would have sent a delegation to that this year. There was more progress made in just transition in discussions there, but the headline political decisions and agreements tend to happen at COP. The intersessionals are more of a technical negotiation around smaller ticket items.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Ms Loughran's submission is quite negative regarding COP generally. What I read from it is that she is negative in terms of the process, how it has worked and its failure to deliver. Would that be a fair assessment?

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

Yes. COP has failed to deliver the climate action we need. Equally, each state showing up to COP every year has failed to deliver the climate action they need to deliver. Ireland and the EU are part of that. They have not stepped up to take their fair share of action and they continue to under-deliver on inadequate targets. If we look at the EU, for example, the inclusion of international credits provides another way for the EU to dilute its action. With Ireland, we know that we are so far off on delivering an already inadequate target to 2030 that we will not align with our fair share of action. We are also facing into plans for new fossil fuel infrastructure.

To clarify the earlier point on the energy demand we will see post-2030, we have to reduce our energy demand significantly in order to 2030 to meet EU targets. The energy demand projections are showing this will not even be met by 2040. Those projections, which are completely out of sync with our energy and climate obligations, have been used to justify the approval of a strategic gas emergency reserve. Those expanded and inflated energy demand projections have been approved on that basis.

It is simply not in sync with our climate obligations to introduce new fossil fuel infrastructure. We have known for years from the IPCC and leading climate scientists that in order to stay within the 1.5°C limit, there can be no new fossil fuel infrastructure and the majority of known fossil fuels must stay in the ground. However, Ireland is facilitating fossil fuel infrastructure expansion.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I want to focus on COP for a second. Earlier, Ms Loughran's original submission states:

Looking to COP31, the three formal Presidency letters to country delegations setting out the mission and expectations for COP31 published so far have failed to mention “fossil fuels” even once.

What is happening that this is not coming through?

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

In the past day, there has been a call from the COP presidency for an end to fossil fuels but, again, that has not been communicated in the formal communications to country delegations. It is the fossil fuel interests that are coming out here. Australia is the second-largest exporter of coal. There is a report by 350.org on the connections between Turkey and Australia, especially in the context of the coal trade. That expanded to LNG trade this year. The first shipment of LNG from Australia to Turkey was delivered earlier this year.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Ms Loughran is saying that there are vested interests within COP.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

It is not just the vested interest of the fossil fuel lobbyists; it is also the states that are facilitating those vested interests and actively pursuing expansion within their own nations.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have to watch the clock, because I will get in trouble with the committee if I do not do so.

Can Professor Sweeney explain the Santa Marta process and what it involves? Before that, I just want to say that I will give members another 90 seconds each to come back in for a second round.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

The failure of COP is self-evident. It is a failure which you can trace back to the disastrous Copenhagen conference when the emergence of the BRICS countries - Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa - effectively undermined the actions that were proposed there. Essentially, the problem is the unanimity that is required. You cannot get a decision out of COP unless everybody agrees. As Ms Loughran said, since there are so many much vested interests among some of the oil-producing countries, they will not even mention fossil fuels in the communiqués issued at the end of the day.

Having said that, COP is the only multilateral forum that exists in this area. Supporting multilateralism is essential if we are to drive any kind of progress in tackling a global problem of this kind. However, it is fair to say that it has failed. That is why the Santa Marta process has become important. Essentially, that process is a coalition of the willing that has emerged. It involves countries that are willing to take action, independent of the blockers that exist at international level at COP. There is some hope if we can mobilise and get support for that at a larger scale. As the co-chairs in Ireland, we are not seeing much evidence of activity in that area. We are not seeing Ireland driving the process. We do not know if we are going to have a conference before Tuvalu, for example, and we do not know where it will be. That is why it is so important that we get collective action from the Irish Government at COP to drive the Santa Marta process forward.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is fair. Thank you. Members now have another 90 seconds each. We will begin with Senator Noonan. Before he starts, I just want to say that I will come back to all the witnesses at the end and ask for two specific priorities in the context of the Irish Presidency of the EU in the context of COP.

Comment on this

That was my question. I want to comment on the contributions we heard, particularly those of Mr. Kelly. There is a recommendation from Trócaire around the Sharm el-Sheikh joint work on implementation of climate action. We have spoken about a lot of high-level stuff here this afternoon. This goes back to E.F. Schumacher's Small Is Beautiful. We should be looking at the recommendations from Trócaire around supporting agroecology. It is not just about supporting an indigenous food-growing sector; it is also about supporting developing countries to meet their own requirements at a small, localised level. Ireland could show significant leadership in its Presidency. I just wanted to make that point. Mr. Kelly, Ms Loughran or Mr. Loughlin may wish to comment on that. It is critically important we look at small agricultural transitions and, this is something Irish Aid does very well, at supporting small agricultural projects in developing countries.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

Very briefly, and then I will let others come in, the support also has to be translated into financial support for agroecology and local and small-holder farmers, including women. They are quite often forgotten. A very small percentage of climate finance is actually going towards those efforts. That is absolutely critical, as is ensuring that it is in a grant-based public form and does not add any further debt burdens. I do not know if anybody else would like to come in on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

The two things are absolutely linked. Talamh Beo has called the network of small-scale local organic farmers in Ireland invisible, because it is practically invisible to the State. There are very few supports. Talamh Beo has called for a universal basic income for those growers. As well as supporting the big guys that can produce so much food, we also need to support those more resilient local food systems.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you. I call Senator Higgins. Apologies. I call Mr. McLoughlin. I did not see him offering.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

We have talked a lot about adaptation finance in this session and how it is currently not adequate. Unfortunately, it does not look like it will be certain countries. Even with the small adaptation finance that is currently available, these are the sort of impacts that can be had. Our partner, RCDSSS, worked with a woman, a small holder grower in India, and through that programme, the yields were doubled through climate adaptation measures. In addition, spending on pesticides was reduced by 90%. This meant an increase in income from €1.80 per month to about €11 or €13 per month. This is the material impact that can be had through the provision of climate adaptation finance, which is why it is so critical to increase it. It has impacts on the ground and makes the global agriculture system more resilient, at both local and global level.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Higgins is next.

Comment on this

Somebody mentioned Covid earlier. In a way, I was struck by the analogy of two issues that the witnesses have talked about, namely private finance and technology transfer. During Covid, billions of euro in public money went into the development of vaccines and then the intellectual property rights around those vaccines were used as a reason to block global access to them. Reference was made to the idea of public money being routed through private finance. If you are routing investment in climate adaptation through private finance, which has to deliver profits, is there a danger that you end up with an intellectual property argument which says though you have a technology that could help everybody, it does not get shared. The EU has held a very hard line on technology transfer, if I am right, in negotiations in the past. Will the witnesses comment on that?

On minerals, it is not only a case of who gets the critical minerals for renewables but also about competing for the digital transition. Is it not the case that in the context of the explosion in the number of new data centres, the companies involved are looking for the same minerals that are being sought in the context of renewables? Can anything be done to ensure that renewables are the priority globally in that regard?

As a post-colonial country, can Ireland maybe bring some of its understanding of climate change as colonialism into the mix at COP? Would that be useful?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

On the first element around technology transfer and the routing of public finance through private mechanisms and intellectual property, I do not know the specifics, but that would certainly occur to me as a danger. In terms of private finance, what we have mentioned here is that our primary concern with private finance is its inability to reach the countries and the locations that need it the most. It is consistently the case that the lowest income countries receive the least amount of finance, both public and private, but private finance is particularly difficult to attract to the least developed countries.

Current projections are for demand for raw materials to almost double by 2040. It is important to recognise that these are incredibly concentrated in specific areas. For example, Democratic Republic of Congo produces approximately 74% of mined cobalt, Indonesia produces 67% of mined nickel and China produces 69% of rare earth minerals. It is important to recognise that these deposits are incredibly concentrated and that access to them is controlled by a small number of countries, which are vulnerable to climate change, of course, and deserve a just transition. The issue around the tech industry's need for these critical raw materials is that it is definitely a competing demand source. Obviously, our position would be that there should be some mechanism to ensure that they are reserved for the renewable transition as much as possible. Furthermore, there are massive issues around a mineral boom carrying human rights risks as well. There were over 1,200 allegations of environmental abuse linked to transition mineral mining between 2010 and 2025, for example. In 2025 alone, 329 allegations were recorded on human rights grounds in respect of transition minerals. That is why something like just transition and an accountable robust just transition mechanism is so important in that regard.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their contributions. I have to say that we can sometimes feel incredibly deflated and helpless after a session like this - including us, as legislators - in the face the global challenges and headwinds involved and global forces working against us. It is a case of the struggle between capitalism versus our planetary boundaries. Ms Loughran put it very well when she spoke about more renewable energy not being an end in itself and of it leading to other issues when it comes to our energy use, our use of resources, etc. There are so many things we need to address here, but we cannot give up. With that in mind, the EU priorities for COP relate to pretty basic stuff like implementation and multilateralism. These are things that people might have taken as a given, as progress or as gains that were made previously. Should there be more ambition there on the part of Europe? Are we doing enough? This goes back, I suppose, to what the witnesses think our priorities should be for COP.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

I am happy to come in on that first. In terms of the EU's fair share, international credits are something the EU can take away from COP. It should not dilute its ambition any further, because already it is not going far enough in its 2040 target.

In terms of electrification, the priority that the COP presidency has placed on electrification does not translate to getting off fossil fuels in a corresponding way, which is a huge concern. Fossil fuel use could actually continue or the dependence on it could be locked in further. The EU has made a target for 2040 in terms of its electrification target, but that also does not go nearly far enough in the context of what the EU should be doing in terms of its fair share of action. There is a gap in terms of the EU wanting to talk about multilateralism but then not translating that into domestic action.

The Commissioner spoke last week about the EU carrying the burden. The EU has to carry the burden because it and its member states are so historically responsible for the climate crisis. It is not enough to say that right now, it is 6% of emissions. That completely disregards our historical contribution to the climate crisis and our obligation to pay up for that in terms of climate finance and in terms of our ambition and action at home between COPs.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does anyone else wish to comment? I will be bringing all of the witnesses back in at the end.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

I was at COP29 in Baku a couple of years ago. That was where the controversial $300 billion new collective quantified goal was agreed. The negotiations there were incredibly acrimonious. After that conclusion, I remember a climate expert saying to me that Baku was called the climate finance COP but that every COP from then on would also be a climate finance COP. The inability in the past to reach decisions that took scale and scope of the climate crisis seriously means that negotiations become sidetracked and acrimonious as a result of unresolved issues which have been ongoing for several years. That is where we are at present.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Mr. McLoughlin and call Deputy Cronin.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for a very interesting meeting. We sometimes think, "Oh no, this is going to be another one of these pre-COP meetings." However, this meeting has turned out to be really interesting. I thank the witnesses very much for that.

I want to focus on the expansion in the number of data centres. When they talk to their counterparts in other countries, are they as aware of the expansion in the number of these monstrous data centres? In the context of AI, there is an insatiable demand for more data centres. Does this need to be discussed at COP? Are other countries seeing Ireland as a cautionary tale? Is this something that the witnesses' counterparts see in the context of how difficult it is going to be for us to get off fossil fuels? The Commission for Regulation of Utilities has discussed the dangers involved, the reliance on the grid and the impact of brownouts and blackouts as a result. Is this something that the witnesses' counterparts in other countries are aware of?

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

In terms of civil society colleagues, there is an awareness of it. However, the scale is completed different at EU level, for example. The average rate of electricity consumption by data centres across EU member states is 2% to 3% per year, whereas we are-----

Comment on this

Twenty-four per cent.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

Yes, ten times the average and growing. That is hugely concerning. It comes back to the point that we cannot separate our somewhat vague targets on electrification, for example, from the rising energy demand that is being met by means of ongoing fossil fuel dependence. We have to talk about our climate obligations and energy use at the same time. Ireland's special role as a tech hub or financial hub in terms of the fossil fuel investments has to be taken into account. Something that has come across more and more in recent human rights guidance and in the ICJ's advisory opinion is that states have to take account of where private bodies are driving emissions or activities that are not in compliance with their climate obligations. It is definitely something that needs to be brought into it.

The fastest way to get to our renewable energy targets or our electrification targets is to actually reduce our energy demand, but we are doing the exact opposite and it is locking in our fossil fuel use as we go.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their opening statements. My apologies for focusing my questions to Mr. Kelly in the previous round, but I had to run to the Chamber.

If Ireland wants to show genuine leadership at COP31, are there any other practical things that we have not mentioned today that we are not doing that would have a giant outcome and squish our carbon emissions?

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

Following the TAFF process conference at Santa Marta, a number of countries have introduced fossil fuel phase-out plans and timelines. Major fossil fuel users such as France and Germany have already done this, so that could be a starting point. I know that the Government is pursuing a White Paper on decarbonising our electricity system but a fossil fuel phase-out plan is much broader. It tackles transport and home heating. Setting clear dates for when we are going to phase out oil and gas is a clear show of good faith on the international side of things and shows our leadership in that regard, if we want to move into a leadership position.

On accelerating the targets that we have set time and again, such as the 80% renewable electricity target by 2030, we are looking at probably hitting between 52% and 59% of that. The projection dropped down from last year. Making the national investments on climate that need to be made in order to meet those targets is another way of showing that we take the climate crisis seriously. Other measures include regulating to stop the flows through Ireland of private finance to invest in fossil fuels and stepping up on the international scene. A whole host of measures can be taken but it essentially boils down to keeping the promises and commitments that have already been made. That would be a fantastic start. A lot of the commitments we have made are quite strong, so just stepping up and meeting those commitments and promises would be a good starting point.

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

At COP, lots of things happen on the sidelines. When something is not on the agenda - I answered a question on debt - it does not mean that Ireland cannot lead an initiative, for example, on bringing a group of like-minded states together. What I would be speaking about is about debt and bringing that together. Next year, COP will be held in Ethiopia. Ethiopia is in massive debt distress and it definitely will be on the agenda then, so it makes sense for Ireland to do something now practically in bringing states together.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

One thing we have not mentioned this afternoon is aviation. This is an area where Ireland could take the lead. Aviation is growing very rapidly as a source of global emissions but a small step by Ireland could, for example, involve taxing private jet landings at Dublin, Cork and Shannon airports. France already does this. This kind of revenue is small change to some of the individuals concerned. I do not see why we are not going along that road to actually address those who can afford to pay for their pollution being charged a bit more for it. It would be a useful first step for Ireland to promote that at COP.

Comment on this

I mean this tongue in cheek, but it is fascinating to hear about COP visits to Baku, Ethiopia and Rio de Janeiro while at the same time we are talking about decarbonising and methane from cows. It does not really balance in my head. Has COP ever been held in a virtual format?

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

No. The logic of moving it around is to minimise travel by the participants, so it moves between continents on that basis, but it has never been held in a virtual format and I doubt very much whether that would be successful. One has have to have people around the table willing to make concessions in public to actually achieve things.

Comment on this

There is an environmental piece, an economic piece and a social piece and it is about making sure that formula some way balanced. When Professor Sweeney speaks about methane and the high-intensity farming that we need to reduce, what does he think will be the outcome of that? Will it just move to another jurisdiction, with the problem moved elsewhere in the world? How are we going to balance that in the time to come in terms of the message to our farmers?

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

It is a question of ethics and justice at a national level first and foremost.

Comment on this

While potentially importing beef from South America.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

I do not see that as essential in Ireland. I think we can cater for our own demand very well and for a modest export economy as well. What we are looking at here is a slight shift in priorities, not necessarily the demolition of the Irish agricultural system of beef and dairy. We can achieve that kind of restructuring to the benefit of the family farm system in Ireland and to the benefit of our own economic food security without necessarily going down the road of the destruction of our agricultural system or anything like that.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The last question is from me. What are two priorities for Ireland in the context of the EU Presidency and COP? I will start with Mr. Kelly.

Comment on this
Mr. Mick Kelly

I might make it simple and say I just have one priority, which is that we need a more resilient food system in this country. As I said at the beginning, there are practical ways to do that but the biggest thing that is needed is a mindset shift in government away from the focus on exports. Professor Sweeney just mentioned this. We have to be honest about what is happening to all of the dairy produce that is being produced in this country. Most of it is not ending up with children drinking glasses of milk. It is ending up in protein supplements and infant formula around the world. We need to get real about the fact that we were days away from dangerous insecurity in this country in recent times. The global supply chain is changing. It is really vulnerable. Our food system is so out of whack with the mood music globally around climate change and food security that we urgently need to reset our priorities and make feeding ourselves the number one priority when it comes to food.

Comment on this
Ms Sinéad Loughran

For the Irish Presidency during COP31, it is simply not enough to just engage or show up to these multilateral spaces. It is about is what it does in the time between. At COP, Ireland can announce new pledges for climate finance, and that must be public grant-based finance. Post 2025, we do not have any idea of what Ireland is going to do in terms of climate finance under the new collective quantified goal. What is of the utmost importance is urgently and significantly increasing the money going to the fund for responding to loss and damage. For developed states, including Ireland, to push the narrative or discussion to other countries coming in is simply disingenuous and lacking in any kind of semblance of credibility when we are so far off meeting our own targets. There are some references in the briefing document to where studies have been conducted to see what other countries might actually be considered eligible to provide climate finance. It is a very short list and it still will not take away from the obligations on those already obligated to pay.

A second point is around a fair share of climate action. Whatever Ireland and the wider EU see happening at COP, they have to amplify that and go further because their fair share of actions and their historical responsibility demand that they do more. That is across climate finance, electrification, fossil fuel phase-out and reducing energy demand.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McLoughlin

I will be brief because Ms Loughran has touched on much of it already. Regarding what I would ask the Government to do going into COP, there is a negotiating group called the small island developing states that is often referred to the moral centre of COP because the issues we are dealing with here are life and death for them. They come to COP trying to preserve the future of their nations. For example, the president of the Maldives said in 2021 that the difference between 1.5 degrees and 2 degrees was a death sentence for his country. Ireland should go into COP and not simply follow the tail of the EU. We need to take our own principled negotiating stance that we try to advocate for in the EU and then turn our language on climate justice and our good record on the provision of climate finance to the least developed countries into measurable negotiating positions and commitments. That means being clear about what Ireland will contribute itself, what it will advocate for in the EU and what outcomes it considers necessary on things like finance, adaptation, loss and damage, and just transition. It is essentially about turning promises into implementation.

Comment on this
Mr. Cillian Quinn

I will quickly go back to Senator Higgins’s question around postcolonial Ireland. The reason we are good at this is because of that history. Ireland is respected globally for its diplomacy in this area, which means there is potential for us to do this. I know it is trite, but we do punch above our weight in that space. That is just to add to what was said.

We have two core requests. The first concerns debt and using the sidelines of the COP to start bringing debt to the table. Regarding what an initiative like that would look like, when there is a climate disaster, there would be a moratorium on debt payments for at least five years. A country like Nepal, for example, would not be expected to pay back its $3 billion in debt this year following what happened a few weeks ago. In terms of private finance, to reiterate what we said already, the focus of the climate finance work programme should be on grant-based climate finance rather than on this idea that private finance can solve the problems.

I thank the committee.

Comment on this
Professor John Sweeney

Procrastination is the kiss of death for the COP. I would like to see a lot more being done in terms of practical steps in accountability and in meeting the nationally determined contributions, NDCs. Countries are very good at grandstanding at COP meetings. I would like to see the Government push for annual reporting systems to see, basically, who is delivering and who is not, and why. I would also like to see some kind of mechanism to push for sanctions against countries that are not actually delivering the goods they promised.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the witnesses for being here. We will be publishing all of the opening statements on our committee website. Is that okay? Great.

Comment on this