We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Climate, Environment and Energy

Regulation and Enforcement of Solid Fuel Use: Discussion

Summary

Solid Fuel Merchants Ireland backed stronger environmental standards but said weak enforcement is allowing non-compliant coal, largely brought across the Border, to undercut lawful businesses and evade taxes. It welcomed the Air Pollution (Amendment) Act 2026 and called for a joint enforcement task force, a national registration system and adequate resources, arguing these could recover lost revenue and reduce pollution. Members raised the North-South regulatory gap, the scale of illegal sales, and the impact of rising carbon taxes on households and merchants. SFMI said the transition to cleaner heating must be fair, noting many households still rely on solid fuels.

Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Apologies have been received from Teachtaí Dála Malcolm Byrne, Réada Cronin, Pa Daly agus Naoise Ó Cearúil and Seanadóirí Noel O'Donovan and Malcolm Noonan. We have a number of members joining us online via MS Teams.

The first part of today's session is an engagement with witnesses on the regulation and enforcement of solid fuel use in Ireland. This meeting gives members the opportunity to engage with stakeholders in the solid fuel sector on the continued use of illegal solid fuel. The burning of solid fuels is a known contributor to an increase in fine particulate matter, PM2.5, which is associated with heart disease, strokes and severe respiratory problems. The Environmental Protection Agency, EPA, has recently reported that PM2.5 continues to cause around 1,500 premature deaths in Ireland every year, despite overall compliance with European standards.

From Solid Fuel Merchants Ireland, SFMI, I welcome Mr. Colin Ahern, Ms Nessa Duffy, and Mr. Niall McGuinness.

I remind everyone to ensure that their mobile phones are on silent mode or switched off.

Before I invite Mr. Ahern to deliver the opening statement, I advise the following in relation to parliamentary privilege. Witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

In terms of how the meeting will run, I will invite the witness to make an opening statement of a maximum of five minutes. Once that statement has been delivered, I will call members of the committee in the order in which they indicate to me to put their questions. We operate a rota system that gives each member an initial five minutes to engage with our witnesses. Please note that the five minutes are for a quick question-and-answer session. It is essential, therefore, that both members and witnesses be succinct. The meeting is of limited duration, so please try to keep to time. I ask everybody to be focused in their contributions.

I now invite Mr. Colin Ahern to make the opening statement on behalf of SFMI.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

I thank the committee for the invitation to appear before it today on behalf of Solid Fuel Merchants Ireland. I am joined by my SFMI colleague Nessa Duffy of The Harbour Trading Company in Bray and Niall McGuinness, former managing director of Homefire, one of Ireland's leading distributors of solid fuels. Niall joins us to bring a supplier's perspective on the increasingly unfavourable business environment facing our sector. Homefire's planned closure of its manufacturing and distribution facility in Foynes, County Limerick, with up to 30 jobs at risk, brings these pressures into sharp focus. They arise from a combination of factors including rising costs, carbon taxation, declining sales and increased competition. Across the sector, inadequate enforcement compounds these challenges by allowing illegal and non-compliant operators to undercut legitimate businesses. Niall's attendance today underlines what is at stake: Irish jobs, investment and the viability of businesses that comply with the law.

SFMI represents independent, often family-run businesses supplying solid fuels to households and communities throughout Ireland. Our members provide an essential service, particularly in rural areas, where many households continue to rely on solid fuels for their home heating needs.

I want to make our position clear from the outset. We support stronger environmental regulation, cleaner fuels and robust enforcement of the law. However, regulation is only as effective as the enforcement behind it. For too long, legitimate solid fuel merchants have been required to meet increasingly stringent environmental standards, pay carbon taxes and invest in compliant products, while illegal operators continue to undermine the market.

We are particularly concerned about the continued movement of illegal and non-compliant solid fuels into the State from outside this jurisdiction. These products can evade carbon taxes, bypass environmental standards and enter the domestic market through unregulated supply and distribution channels. This is not simply a problem for our industry; it is a problem for the Exchequer, public health and the environment. Every bag of illegally traded fuel sold without the appropriate taxes being paid represents lost revenue to the State. Every non-compliant product sold undermines businesses that have invested in meeting the law. When high-sulphur or excessively smoky fuels are burned, they release harmful pollutants, contributing to air quality problems experienced in many of our towns and villages, particularly during the winter months. We cannot be serious about improving air quality while allowing non-compliant fuel to circulate in the marketplace.

Our members see the consequences of inadequate enforcement at first hand. In our March 2026 member survey, 88% of respondents reported that enforcement activity in their areas was rare or non-existent. The same percentage said illegal sellers were significantly undercutting their businesses, while 94% believed existing enforcement powers were insufficient. These findings demonstrate the challenges facing legitimate retailers. SFMI therefore welcomed the signing into law of the Air Pollution (Amendment) Act 2026 by the President on 18 June. We believe this legislation represents an important step towards strengthening Ireland's response to air pollution and tackling the illegal supply of non-compliant solid fuels. In particular, we welcome the enhanced enforcement powers available to local authorities and the provisions to strengthen requirements regarding the labelling, registration and advertising of solid fuels. These are measures SFMI has consistently advocated.

We understand that officials in the Department are now developing the secondary legislation required to commence these new provisions, with regulations intended to be published in advance of the 2027-28 heating season. We look forward to this work being completed as quickly as possible. It is important that retailers and suppliers have sufficient notice of any new requirements. Equally, we cannot afford unnecessary delays in bringing these enforcement measures into operation.

The real test of this legislation will be how effectively it is implemented, resourced and enforced.

SFMI is calling for three practical actions. The first is the establishment of a dedicated joint fuel enforcement task force, bringing together Revenue, An Garda Síochána, local authorities and the EPA. This would facilitate intelligence sharing, co-ordinated inspections and targeted action against illegal supply networks. The second is the introduction of a comprehensive national registration and compliance system, covering solid fuel producers, transporters and retailers. Every legitimate operator should be identifiable and accountable, with clear traceability of the fuels being placed on the market. The third is meaningful and sustained investment in enforcement. We cannot expect local authorities to tackle organised illegal fuel trading without the personnel, equipment and resources to do so. We look forward to clarity on the financial allocations for 2027 and the resources that will be made available to support implementation.

There is also an important question of fairness. With further carbon tax increases scheduled for May 2027, the price advantage enjoyed by those evading taxation could widen considerably unless enforcement improves. That risks punishing compliant businesses and encouraging consumers towards cheaper and potentially more pollutant products. We recognise the need to transition towards cleaner home heating. Our members are already adapting, investing in low-smoke products and exploring lower carbon alternatives, but the transition must be fair, particularly for rural households that do not yet have affordable or practical alternatives to solid fuels.

We are not asking the Government to weaken environmental standards but to enforce the standards it has already introduced. Compliant merchants should not be placed at a commercial disadvantage for obeying the law. Consumers deserve confidence in the fuels they purchase and communities deserve protection from avoidable air pollution. The State now has a stronger legislative framework and it must ensure that framework delivers real enforcement on the ground. SFMI and our partners stand ready to work constructively with the Government, the regulators and this committee, as we have always sought to do, to achieve that objective. Clean air, fair competition and effective enforcement must go hand in hand.

We look forward to taking some of the committee's questions.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Mr. Ahern. A number of members are online. Will they please indicate when they want to ask questions? We will take members, as usual, in the order in which they indicate.

Comment on this

I am happy to come in now, unless anyone online wants to come in before me. I thank the witnesses for coming in today. My Sinn Féin colleagues are not here and they usually say we should take an all-Ireland approach to every issue, but it does seem that there is a regulatory gap here between what is happening in our jurisdiction and in the North of Ireland. Has the SFMI made any efforts to lobby for change in the North? Is there a regulatory gap and has the organisation looked to bridge that gap with the Northern Ireland Executive or the UK Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

I thank the Deputy for the question. Personally I have not, although we have mentioned in numerous committee meetings and meetings with the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, and the former Minister, Eamon Ryan, that we have issues with product coming in from Northern Ireland. There have been discussions on setting up a group to address these issues North and South, but I do not know exactly where we are with that. We have raised it numerous times.

Comment on this

It just strikes me as an obvious solution here given that there seem to be genuine differences and potentially unfairness arising as a result of the Border and the two regulatory regimes. Aside from enforcement on this side of the Border, it would seem to make sense to try to raise standards everywhere. Perhaps this is something we can go back to the Minister with to see what steps are being taken at Government level to eradicate the differences between the two regimes, which appear to present a lot of the issues Mr. Ahern is pointing to.

He spoke about setting up a task force. There seems to be a little overlap with what we have been doing as a committee in looking at illegal peat extraction and those kinds of activities. I am wary of setting up task forces for everything. Has SFMI done any calculations of what setting up a task force like this might cost the Exchequer?

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Duffy

Yes. We have estimated a cost of about €6 million to €9 million for a joint task force. To be honest, the bones of it are probably already there. At the moment, we do have multi-agency stops on the roads and so on, where we might have social welfare, An Garda Síochána and Revenue, but it is disjointed. They each have their own role to play but it is just not specific. We find sometimes that smoky coal is not actually on the contraband list, so it is not looked for. We would hope to see it on the contraband list with the likes of alcohol, drugs and whatever else. We have also looked at EPA registration as part of a joint task force. Again, the EPA already has a register for suppliers. We would estimate a cost of about €3 million to €5 million for the registration. The Act also allows for three registers. The supplier register is already there but we would look for a merchant register and a transport register, which would bring in the likes of couriers and people who transport the goods by road, mostly across the Border.

Comment on this

I presume the witnesses have given a bit of thought to where the task force would focus its attention. What sort of levels of importation are we looking at? What are the thresholds? Presumably someone going across and getting a small amount for personal use is not what the organisation is aiming at here.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

No, that is not what we are aiming at here. This would be the whole benefit of having a joint task force. It would be about sharing intelligence and targeting resources, focus and inspections. We need some high-profile seizures and fines as well to follow. That would send out a clear message.

Comment on this

There are a few different figures for the value of what is crossing the Border. Mr. Ahern said it is costing the Exchequer between €11 million and €15 million per year. Is that the latest figure? A press release previously quoted maybe €77 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

With regard to the €11 million to €15 million figure, we carried out an economic report of the sector in 2023 because there was very little information available to us, and that was a safe estimate. We gathered that from our members and from talking to suppliers to the trade. Between €11 million and €15 million was a safe estimate. We believe it to be an awful lot worse at the moment. If we look across any social platforms at the amount of coal that is available for sale, and at what is being experienced at our level with all our members dealing with it on a daily basis, we feel it is an awful lot worse and has really accelerated in the last year or year and a half.

Comment on this

If the task force is to cost €6 million to €9 million, therefore, it would pay for itself.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We believe it would very quickly pay for itself.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have just a couple of questions from my side. What fuel are we talking about here? Are we talking about coal? Are there other fuels as well or is it just coal?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

It is all coal. It is bituminous coal and smokeless coal that is high in sulphur and high in smoke levels. To give some indication, a recent EPA report of samples gathered in the marketplace showed a 70% failure rate on the sulphur levels. That gives an indication of how much illegal product is in the marketplace.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will come back to that. Is this a North-South issue exclusively, in Mr. Ahern's view, or are there other routes in? Is coal coming through the ports illegally or is it coming in in other ways? Is it just North-South?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We believe it to be North-South.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Are the regulations different in that jurisdiction from here in terms of environmental quality, air quality, etc.? Is the stuff that is coming in here actually legal in the other jurisdiction but illegal here because of its quality?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Exactly, yes.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

So, it would be legal in the North of Ireland or the United Kingdom.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Yes. That is the problem our members have. It is not a fair transition because we have to deal with this problem on a daily basis. It is costing our sector jobs. It is costing livelihoods. We just cannot compete with this product coming in. It is not a fair transition for us and we are doing everything we have been asked to do. We are implementing Government policy at ground level. It is a major issue for us.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It sounds like some work has been done to put a figure on the scale and size of it. What is the latest in terms of the size of the problem? I do not mean just the value. What tonnage or scale are we talking about? Do the witnesses have a sense of that? Has any work been done on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall McGuinness

No, it is off the record. It is not on any Excel sheet. You are basically guessing. Based on the amount being sold online, we can imagine it is into the tens of thousands of tonnes.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Would the witnesses have a sense of how much of the market it constitutes?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall McGuinness

Of the total market?

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall McGuinness

I would imagine the solid fuel market in Ireland at this stage is probably 150,000 tonnes to 200,000 tonnes. Again, we are seeing it not only with couriers; we are now seeing 40 ft trailers crossing the Border and stopping. People are sharing a 40 ft trailer out of factories and all the things that go with it. It is impossible for anybody to put a figure on it.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Ms Duffy mentioned contraband and said this should be classified as contraband, which would help. Why has it not? Is there any reason it has not?

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Duffy

I am not really sure what the reason is but at the end of the day it is an illegal product. There is a ban on bituminous coal. It is banned, in the same way that smuggling drugs, fireworks, red diesel, alcohol and cigarettes is banned. They are all looked for as illegal products. Bituminous coal is an illegal product. It should be on the list just as the other illegal products are, but we find that it is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

It is illegal to commercially sell that product in the country at the moment under the regulations introduced in 2022. However, it is in the marketplace. That will give an indication of what is happening.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I presume the enforcement authority since 2022 has been the local authorities. They have the primary responsibility for enforcement. Is there any evidence of enforcement activity - court cases, actions, seizures - by the local authorities?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Not that we are aware of. Some local authorities have been very proactive. Some of them have been completely inactive. Some of our members, even on our committee, have not received inspections in the last three or four years. It is a major issue. We met the local enforcement implementation group, LEIG, in 2023 about issues that were affecting the sector and about how we could help and work together to address these issues. The environmental inspectors are responsible for illegal dumping, litter, water and solid fuel. There is a major resource issue and a major funding issue as well. This is with no disrespect to any local authority, which are all trying to do their best, but we need a task force and a lot of focus on local authorities to help them to address this issue.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Can a local authority easily identify this material? If they find it, what are the means by which they would identify it?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Bituminous coal is a different shape from smokeless coal, so it is very easily identifiable visually. Smokeless coal has to be sent away for sampling. At the moment, our sampling goes out of the country, so there is the lead time in getting results back and the costs associated with it. Going back to the sampling process, the EPA's latest report has identified 70% of product that was tested to be over the legal limit of 2% sulphur, which gives the committee an indication. At one stage, maybe two years ago when sampling was done, it was close to 85%. We have a huge problem with illegal product in the marketplace as well.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does anybody online want to come in?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We actually have some coal here in case the members want to have a look at it. Ms Duffy has it here.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Go for it.

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Duffy

This is a sample of what an inspector would see if somebody was stopped at the side of the road. It is a lignite nugget. It is round, has a definite shape and has "L" stamped on it. That is one constituent part. The other part is what we call an ovoid. They are made like fairy cakes. They are all pressed into a uniform shape. Again, you cannot straight away tell the smoke content, the particulates and so on, but you would have a fair idea that it was an ovoid and you could look further.

The illegal coal, on the other hand, is slate shaped. It can be all different shapes and sizes. It looks and feels different. It is like having differently shaped rocks. The others are a uniform shape. If somebody was stopped at the side of the road and a bag was looked into, it would be fairly straightforward to identify it immediately. It either looks all the same or it all looks different. Straight away you could told if it was the illegal variety.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

You could tell visually.

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Duffy

Yes. Also, similar to, say, a drug test where they put a piece of powder into the bag and it changes colour, if you were to burn the piece of coal with something like a Bunsen burner, smokeless coal will burn blue or clear, whereas bituminous coal will have a heavy yellow or grey smoke. You could very quickly tell which was the right coal. You might not be able to determine, say, its sulphur content, but your inspection would determine whether to send it for further testing.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Deputy Heneghan was indicating earlier.

Comment on this

Deputy Clendennen can go first if he likes. I am just on the way down to the committee room now.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Heneghan. I appreciate him looking out for me.

I welcome our witnesses. Apologies if this has been picked up already. I am joining late because I had to speak in the Chamber. I come from a constituency where there is a large dependence on fossil fuels in general. There are towns with 80% to 90% reliance. Obviously, if customers are reliant on them, someone has to be supplying that. How do the witnesses foresee that sector and ecosystem evolving over the next number of years? I know they have an ongoing issue around enforcement and that competition as such. How do they see that evolving over the next five, ten or 15 years?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We know we have to change and we have been changing. There is a demand for solid fuels, as the Deputy says. Close to 700,000 houses use solid fuel weekly. Between 180,000 and 200,000 of those houses use it as their primary source of heating. Regardless of what we think of solid fuel, there is a massive demand for it at the moment and there will be for the next five, ten to 15 years. The first thing we should do is regulate the market by enforcing the regulations that are in place. I refer to the sulphur limit, the smoke limit and ensuring the proper product is being used and burned. When we get to that point, we can all transition too. We can start decarbonising our product offering. We can start burning biomass and cleaner fuels and work closely with the Government to ensure we all transition together.

At the moment, however, unless we address this issue of the illegal high-sulphur product, there will be very few legitimate fuel merchants left within the sector over the next two or three years, and that is where we have serious issues. We will then be facing black-market activity and high sulphur and smoke levels. Residents of some towns in different areas around the country are getting text alerts about smoke issues. That is a clear indication of the level of illegal product in the marketplace. Unless we address this with the proper funding in place for enforcement of regulation, either we will work very well together over the next five or ten years or there will be nothing but illegal product in the marketplace. At the end of the day, people will still need to heat their homes.

Comment on this

There have been measures relating to legislation and enforcement, but Mr. Ahern talked about investment in enforcement. What investment does he feel is necessary, on a practical level?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

A task force has to be put in place. I can say straight out that very little enforcement of regulation is happening at the moment, given the amount of product that is available on social media and coming into the market. That is why we need a task force, with the EPA, Revenue, An Garda Síochána and local authorities sharing intelligence, going out there and inspecting, stopping, seizing and fining.

That is where we need to get if we are really serious about addressing the issues and removing illegal products from the marketplace.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Ahern think the customer pays any regard to whether it is legal or contraband? Is it solely driven by price or accessibility to the product?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

I would say it is solely driven by price at the moment given the current cost-of-living crisis. A lot of people are under pressure out there. We never blame customers at any stage. It is important that everyone is aware of that. However, the set of rules that apply to legitimate fuel merchants do not apply to everyone else in the sector. Realistically, this product should not be available for sale in the marketplace. We have to deal with a product that has a big price differential at the moment. The difference between ours and the product coming into the marketplace at the moment is that we are selling compliant fuel and paying carbon tax, VAT and everything else. The product coming into the marketplace is not compliant and is €7.60 to €8 a bag cheaper because no carbon tax is applied to it.

Comment on this

How much is a bag?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

On average, it is €28 a bag.

Comment on this

So, it is €28 versus €36.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

No, we are selling a bag for €28. When we can see product being offered for €20 or €22 a bag, it highlights a problem and it should raise red flags.

Comment on this

I understand what Mr. Ahern is saying and the need for it, but how do we approach this without instilling fear? We have seen what has happened with turf cutting. Domestic harvesters of turf can still do that. How do we approach this in a sensitive way without giving the message that the likes of coal and other solid fuels are being cut off from consumers?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

It is pretty hard. How can we approach it from a legitimate fuel merchant's point of view? This was forced on us in 2022 and we had to accept it immediately. If we are not looking at forcing this on end users as well, it is a major issue for us. We are now at a stage where we cannot compete. As I said, the end user has never been an issue. We know there is a problem with the cost of living and they care about the price they pay for product. However, our sector has been hit with these rules and regulations, which has put us at a serious disadvantage. Even though we talk about the sensitivity of the end user, legitimate fuel merchants are under huge pressure.

Comment on this

From a suppliers' perspective and who they are competing with in terms of non-compliance, does Mr. Ahern have any estimate of their potential profits?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We could not answer that. We will forward it on if we can, but at the moment we would not have details on the profits of suppliers of illegal product. Sorry.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Ahern and Ms Duffy for coming in. I apologise for missing part of the meeting earlier; I was between two speaking slots. From what I have heard today, it sounds a bit unfair to businesses and consumers. In plain terms, how much of the solid fuel being burned in Irish homes this winter does Mr. Ahern believe is illegal? How much money is the State losing as a result?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

As I said, we could not give an indication of how much is being lost. Our 2023 economic report estimated it to be between €11 million and €15 million. We believe it has got far worse in the last year and a half and has accelerated based on the amount of activity on social media offering product with no carbon tax or VAT, and the number of lorries coming into our areas daily. We deal with committee members' constituents on a daily basis. We and our members know exactly what is happening on the ground. There is a huge amount of product. We believe it is far worse than reported but we do not have a figure. It is very hard to quantify the value or volume of that, but we know it is substantial.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. If any other industry was losing a quarter of its market share to illegal product, there would immediately be a task force. It is very alarming that it is hard to distinguish how much is being lost.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We cannot quantify the volume on the market but we are asking the State to establish the full scale of illegal activity in the marketplace. That is what should be done. The Exchequer is losing millions upon millions every year and we all know it is there.

Comment on this

That money could be used.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

It could indeed.

Comment on this

From 1 May, a family burning legal coal or briquettes will pay higher carbon tax than a family burning kerosene or gas. What will that do to the price gap between legal and illegal fuel?

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Duffy

On the ground, it comes down to price and what people can afford. We have seen neighbours join forces to buy a pallet of fuel. They can be seen all over the place - a pallet with black wrap around it. It will come across the Border and a courier will drop it off. There is no carbon tax and lower VAT on it. The difference is probably about €10 when carbon tax and VAT are factored in. It is a no-brainer for the person in the house. It is very difficult for legitimate merchants to compete with that. It pushes people further towards unscrupulous sellers, illegal fuel or maybe fuel that is not of the best quality. Legitimate merchants sell the correct fuel. They sell proper smokeless coal and logs below the maximum permissible moisture content. If the price gap widens more, it will make it much more unfair on legitimate sellers.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

It is very unfair that we will be given a double hit next year. As I have said, we are on the front line with vulnerable, low-income households that depend solely on solid fuels. At the moment carbon tax is €7.60 on a 40 kg bag. With a double hit next year, carbon tax will be €9.40 a bag. Without the proper regulation and enforcement in place, it will widen the gap for illegal activity. As Ms Duffy just mentioned, we will see an awful lot more illegal activity, more polluting products in the marketplace, problems for the health system, problems for the Exchequer and problems for the local environment.

Comment on this

I know Mr. Ahern made the comparison to cigarettes. Increasing the tax on fuel or cigarettes does not cut emissions or reduce harm. It actually just pushes people to the smuggler. Is Mr. Ahern asking for a task force?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Correct. We are asking for a task force involving the EPA, the Garda Síochána and local authorities with the resources for targeted inspections, intelligence sharing, fines and seizures.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Ahern have estimates for how much that would cost in relation to how much is being spent?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We have estimates and it is between €6 million and €9 million, and we have communicated that. Our 2023 economic report pointed to a loss to the Exchequer of between €11 million and €15 million through illegal activity. It would pay for itself very quickly. The health and environmental benefits would be huge.

Comment on this

There is an unfairness at the heart of this and it is encouraging to hear the witnesses talk about the future of the industry and the transition to a greener way of doing things. I would like to know a bit more about how smoky coal is brought in and sold here. Mr. Ahern has sent us some photos of how it is advertised. Some of the companies potentially appear to be based here in Ireland, including Thurles Fuels. Is it sold directly to customers? If I go on the internet or call one of these companies, is it sold directly to me as an end user? Does any of it go to retailers?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

The majority would be social media. People can order online. It comes in via couriers and local companies. Some people sell it for cash. It is widespread. The Deputy can go onto any social media platform on his phone or laptop after this meeting and look for coal for sale. He will get illegal coal, free of carbon tax and VAT, delivered to his house in two days' time. There are no inspections, no enforcement, no penalties and no convictions. It is a no-brainer for illegal activity to continue unless things change.

Comment on this

Some of the companies selling the illegal coal are based in the Republic of Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Some of the companies selling the product are in Ireland as well, but given that some local authorities are completely inactive on inspections and enforcement, these companies have no fear about selling the coal and they will continue.

Comment on this

This is very interesting. Is it Mr. Ahern's sense that the majority of it is coming via Northern Ireland or is sold from Northern Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

A large percentage comes from Northern Ireland. A large percentage is coming in and being stored and delivered by couriers. We have the issue of carbon tax fraud. When a product comes into the State from Northern Ireland, it should be subject to carbon tax and VAT but it is not.

Comment on this

Given the location of the sellers and where the contraband is coming from, does Mr. Ahern think the task force would benefit from input from the equivalent authorities in Northern Ireland, such as the equivalent of the EPA in the North? Would this be useful?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Yes, I think intelligence sharing would be useful.

Comment on this

Customs and excise staff were not mentioned in the opening statement with regard to the task force.

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Duffy

Not specifically, but absolutely they should be involved. We would see this as being part of the remit of the local authority, whether it be its enforcement arm, an enforcement officer or customs and excise personnel.

Comment on this

I would imagine that if contraband product was being imported into the State-----

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

It is not deemed to be contraband at the moment. This is why Revenue is involved but not customs and excise staff. Revenue is the arm and it will incorporate customs and excise, but it is not deemed to be contraband.

Comment on this

From the perspective of selling it on social media, nothing is being breached. People are well within their rights to sell it, apart from the fact that they are not complying with the taxes.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

They are bringing an illegal product into the market that we cannot commercially sell. The product coming into this jurisdiction is in breach. Bituminous coal has been banned for commercial sale since 2022 so it cannot come into the country. It has sulphur levels of 2% and smoke levels of 10%. If these limits are breached the products cannot be burned in the country but they are coming into the country. What is coming into the country is in breach. We are in a different jurisdiction and if we are not properly enforcing what we should be doing, we will have major issues.

Comment on this

If there was a contraband classification, there would be an immediate structure for enforcement with regard to customs and excise.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

That is what I am getting at.

Comment on this

The classification of the product as contraband would probably be the easiest fix.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

That is the way to do it.

Comment on this

It would have a domino effect with regard to social media platforms being in a position to sell it. Is there a heat map showing which local authorities are underperforming or which are the most problematic areas? Is the problem widespread and consistent?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Where would we start? I do not want to pick out specific local authorities but historically it was a Border issue. Since the new rules and regulations were introduced in 2022, it has become a countrywide issue. It is happening everywhere. Some local authorities are very proactive and some are not. We can forward this information to the committee after this meeting. I am very mindful, having spoken to the AILG and environmental inspectors that they are underresourced and under funding pressure. I would be very mindful about naming local authorities here, if that is okay.

Comment on this

I do not think it is a case of naming them to shame them; it is a case of being in a position to identify-----

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We have a fair idea and we can circulate the information after the meeting.

Comment on this

It would identify where the problem needs to be tackled. In theory, the 80:20 rule may apply and if we get the 80% we could deal with a large part of the problem. From my perspective, classifying the product as contraband would be major progress.

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Duffy

Mr. Ahern mentioned that we have spoken to the AILG and the remit of these staff might also cover waste or being dog wardens or litter wardens. Solid fuel would be way down the list. In all fairness, local authorities do not have the personnel. We cannot really expect a guy or a girl to stand at the entrance to an estate in a high-visibility jacket with a torch on a Friday evening when somebody is coming to sell stuff they should not be selling. It is not going to happen.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

To give an indication of percentages, the EPA's 2025 local authority performance report found that only 9% of environmental enforcement resources were allocated to air and noise.

Comment on this

There are probably several strands to this. One is the detail or intelligence on where the largest demand is across the country and another is where the activity is with regard to each local authority. If SFMI has this information it might share it.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Was SFMI engaged or consulted on the Air Pollution (Amendment) Act 2026 and the regulations? Did it feed into this process?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We did, yes. We spoke to people after our meeting with the then Minister, Eamon Ryan, in 2023 and we have been in constant communication with the EPA and the Department. We have worked very closely together over the past number of years, for which we are very grateful.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The members of SFMI are supportive of the national registration and compliance system, which is within the ambit of the legislation.

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Duffy

Quite a few of our members are already registered with the EPA. I am in an area which has been smokeless for about 20 years. Before bituminous coal was banned countrywide, sellers had to register with the EPA. As such, many of our members are already registered with the EPA.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Do the witnesses have anything to add to the discussion and to what we have heard?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall McGuinness

Mr. Ahern addressed in his opening statement that the Homefire facility at Foynes is being decommissioned, with the loss of the jobs associated with production of the Homefire brand. Obviously, this is deeply unfortunate but job losses in the industry are not limited to just those at Foynes. They are happening throughout the country in many small independent retailers and traders. I am here in a private capacity to lend my personal support to Irish retailers who are not able to compete with what is happening in the marketplace at present. It is my view that there should be a fair transition and what is happening at the moment is far from fair.

I have spoken to many traders and retailers and they feel abandoned by what is happening. Nobody has to take my word for it or even the word of the merchants' association. A ten-minute search online will tell everybody all they need to know. When we see people competing and dropping prices online, it tells us everything we need to know. If this is allowed to continue, we will never reach the 2030 air standards that are being set and there will not be a merchants' association in 2030 for anybody to negotiate with. This is all I would like to say. I am saying this in a personal capacity. I have known many of these merchants for many years and they are very fine people who have tried to do the right thing. This is what I would like to add.

Comment on this

SFMI's analysis refers to this costing the Exchequer €11 million to €15 million and that a task force would cost €6 million to €9 million. This represents savings for the State. It would involve a lot of resources. I do not know whether it is financially advisable or possible to enforce. How will the task force work? Will it check every car or every lorryload going through?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We are not looking at cars or individual purchases; we are looking at 40-foot lorries coming in on a daily basis. This is what we are really looking at and this is where the win would be for the committee.

Comment on this

Are people are not just going to the North themselves to buy this product?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Not everyone is.

Comment on this

Has SFMI done an analysis or a breakdown of this?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We do not have analysis. The loss to the Exchequer from us losing business on which we pay all of our carbon taxes and VAT is quite substantial. We believe it to be an awful lot more now than €15 million. It is quite substantial.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall McGuinness

In fairness to Mr. Ahern and Solid Fuel Merchants Ireland, I do not think they are talking about anybody from Dundalk who goes across the Border and buys two bags of low smoke fuel. I do not think that has ever been anybody's intention. That has happened and will always happen.

Comment on this

Mr. Ahern is trying to get at the big hitters and the people coming down with lorries.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall McGuinness

That is exactly it.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

That is exactly it.

Comment on this

That makes more sense.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

That is who we cannot compete with. We just cannot compete anymore.

Comment on this

One hundred per cent, and I understand that now. It was just for clarification and people who are watching this. Mr. Ahern will be going for the big lorries. Are there any shiploads coming in as well?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Not that we are aware of. We are not aware of it coming into any ports in the Republic anyway.

Comment on this

What Mr. Ahern is really saying is that the unification of Ireland would really sort this out.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall McGuinness

Very quickly.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Whose standards would apply?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

From a representative body point of view, we want to do what is right. We are responsible business owners. We are not climate change deniers by any means. We know we have to change and that is why we have engaged with governments since 2022. Even though we are having huge problems in the sector, we are still willing to be a proactive partner with the Government to address a lot of these issues we are facing in the sector.

Comment on this

Mr. Ahern makes a very valid point and it is in the statement as well about the €4,500 it would cost for the lab in the UK. If we had a lab here, that would be a lot more enforceable.

On the enforcement, it is unfair and especially if it is something that happened before this for people who are using their own peat and bogs. You can look at the overall carbon emissions of importing from other countries. Do the witnesses think there could be something done in relation to that and for people to have their own small source of turf or is that something they want us to discuss today?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We have not been able to sell turf since 2022, but from my own point of view it makes no sense to me that we have banned peat production in this country and we are allowing peat to be imported into this country. At a time when we have a lot of uncertainty and volatility in the marketplace, we should become self-sufficient. From my own point of view and the business point of view, if you are going to stop people selling it, you do not allow it to be imported either. If you look at our industry, we have now stopped a very profitable industry in this country. We are importing briquettes from Germany.

Comment on this

Are we importing them from Poland as well?

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

Yes, they are coming in but the main one is Germany. There are a lot of briquettes coming in.

Comment on this

That is something we touch on at this committee in terms of the overall global carbon emission. It is robbing Peter to pay Paul in that sense. Obviously, I was not elected at the time and neither was the Teachta but that is something that should be examined in that sense of small-scale production. I know the large scale would not be something I would be favourable towards but the smaller scale is.

Comment on this
Mr. Colin Ahern

We need to become self-sufficient. That is what we need to do in this country.

Comment on this
Naoise Ó Muirí An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will publish the opening statement on the committee's webpage, is that agreed? Agreed. On behalf of the committee, I thank everyone for taking part in our meeting today.

Comment on this