Future Funding of Public Service Broadcasting: Discussion
Contributions 1–186 of 370. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I welcome from RTÉ, Ms Dee Forbes, director general, Ms Breda O'Keeffe, chief financial officer, Mr. Rory Coveney, director of strategy, and Ms Eimear Cusack, director of human resources; and from the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment, Ms Patricia Cronin, assistant secretary general, and Ms Triona Quill, principal officer.
Before we begin, I draw the attention of witnesses to the fact that by virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to this committee. However, if they are directed by the Chairman to cease giving evidence in relation to a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. Witnesses are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable. I also wish to advise the witnesses that any submissions or opening statements they make to the committee will be published on the committee website after the meeting.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
I remind members and witnesses to turn off their mobile phones or to switch them to flight mode as they will interfere with the television and broadcasting coverage.
I invite Ms Dee Forbes to make her opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for inviting us. The invitation came just before we made announcements on our revised strategy, but the indicated topics the committee asked us to discuss, around the future funding of public service media and the value for money of our indigenous and acquired programming, are important and timely considerations.
First, let me address the Report on the Future Funding of Public Service Broadcasting, published by this committee in November 2017. As members will recall, we welcomed not only the findings of this report but also the depth and breadth of the committee’s research, engagement and consideration of this topic. The report was based on original research, data analysis, a wide-ranging stakeholder consultation, a full day’s conference and debate, and substantial discussion and consideration by the committee members. The report made a number of clear and well-informed recommendations that were widely accepted and endorsed within the broader media sector.
In 2018, a decision was taken by the then Minister, Deputy Naughten, to set up yet another working group to look at the future funding of public service broadcasting, and the findings of that group were presented to the Minister, Deputy Bruton, earlier this year. In August 2019, the Minister, Deputy Bruton, made a formal statement in this regard, acknowledging the importance of the protection of public service broadcasting, stating:
Public service broadcasting is more important now than ever. Independent, objective reporting of domestic and international affairs is crucial.
He also acknowledged that audiences were increasingly moving online for their media consumption and that the licence fee system would need to adapt accordingly. However, the remedy proposed was that the licence fee collection would be put out to tender and that the term of contract would be for a five-year period. Given that the collecting agent would likely be contracted from 2021 onward, this would, in effect, delay the transition to a media charge for close to seven years from the point of announcement. That is completely untenable.
Evasion is now almost 13%, resulting in the loss of some €25 million per year. By virtue of outdated legislation, a further 11% of households, and the figure is growing, do not pay the television licence and yet can consume public service programming on their online devices. By way of example, for the recent Ireland v. Russia Rugby World Cup match, we had near equivalent viewership on the RTÉ Player live streaming as we had watching the match on RTÉ 2. This lag in legislation is resulting in a further loss of €20 million in public funding annually. Licence fee receipts are down against forecast for this year, and have been for the past number of months, making a difficult financial situation even more acute for us and for the industry. Ireland’s television licence system is irrevocably broken and is no longer capable of properly sustaining public service broadcasting or Ireland’s broader audiovisual and creative sector.
All that said, against this reality, RTÉ is clear that it must also take action to change to remain sustainable and relevant for Irish audiences. RTÉ has already made significant changes to the organisation in recent years, but the way media is being consumed by audiences everywhere is changing and we need to evolve even further if we are to meet audience needs effectively. The challenges that lie ahead are many and include the following. With regard to global trends, the media landscape worldwide is changing at a pace that has exceeded all forecasts. The rise of the media superpowers and the potential impact on dilution of national culture within a small country like Ireland should be a matter of real concern. The next challenge concerns audience shifts and patterns.
Audiences, especially younger people, are changing the way that they select and access media, and we need to meet these audiences where they expect to find us, especially in terms of our online services. Wide-ranging budget adjustments are required to stabilise RTÉ’s finances and ensure increased investment to deliver the type of service and content that we know our audiences want. This means creating greater efficiencies within the operating costs, new work practices, more efficient use of the regional studios and other pay-cost related measures. As I have said on a number of occasions, it is not possible for RTÉ to continue to operate from a position of deficit. We need to reduce projected costs by €60 million over the next three years. This is in addition to the reductions of 23% on operating costs achieved between 2008 and 2018. To be clear, many of these changes need to happen and will happen irrespective of licence fee reform. RTÉ’s programming and service choices will also need to be refreshed and be under constant review to ensure that these remain relevant and impactful for audiences. This leads me to this committee's secondary point of interest, namely, value for money and indigenous and acquired programming.
The current licence fee costs the equivalent of 44 cent per day, of which RTÉ receives the lions’ share, with the BAI's sound and vision scheme also receiving support. For this 44 cent per day, RTÉ delivers comprehensive local, national and international news in both English and Irish. We retain the largest network of regional correspondents of any media outlet in the country. We also provide dedicated reporting from London, Brussels and the US. RTÉ provides all Irish language television news for both RTÉ and TG4. In terms of investigative reporting, this year alone RTÉ has brought to public attention investigations into crèche standards and regulation, animal welfare issues within the greyhound industry, child sexual abuse allegations in certain scouting organisations, and challenges to the regulatory standards by some quarry companies and their impact on the Irish landscape.
We have covered essential national moments on a free-to-air basis, from the big wins at tournaments such as the Rugby World Cup in Japan, the GAA finals in Croke Park, the Irish women’s hockey win in Donnybrook and the women’s Rugby World Cup journey this summer.
Culture Night, Wexford Opera and next year’s Galway 2020 partnership are all testimony to our support and commitment to the promotion of national arts and culture, as is our ongoing RTÉ Supporting the Arts scheme, which promotes and supports approximately 150 arts and culture events throughout the country each year.
We can shine a spotlight on key public issues such as health and well-being with shows like "Ireland’s Fittest Family" and "Operation Transformation"; the value of family, community and the development and well-being of children through a series like "Raised by the Village"; or the recent focus on climate change with RTÉ 's climate week, culminating in a debate in this house with young people from every constituency in the country, which was a global first.
RTÉ hosts Ireland’s only national dedicated Irish language radio service, Raidió na Gaeltachta, and the strengthening of our broadcast partnership with TG4.
We offer a wide ranging celebration of music of all forms, from the Choice music partnership and the 2FM Rising initiative, the 2FM Studio 8 sessions, and Other Voices, all of which support and promote new young Irish acts. We provide support for traditional music through Ceili House on Radio 1 and the recently launched Irish Folk Awards, and for classical music through Lyric FM, and the RTÉ National Symphony Orchestra’s Music in the Classroom initiative, to name just a few.
We support discussion and debate, whether that is on any one of our radio services, which reach more than 2 million listeners each week, with audience participation programmes such as "Liveline" with Joe Duffy or "Claire Byrne Live", or the topical discussions that feature on flagship entertainment programmes such as "The Late Late Show". All of these programmes elevate awareness and engagement on the topics that matter most to Irish audiences every day. Beyond these, RTÉ provides many more moments of entertainment, celebration, revelation and reflection.
It is fair to say that aforementioned represents good value for 44 cent a day per household, especially in comparison with the subscription costs to other media services, none of which offers anywhere near this level of Irish perspective or output. In terms of value, it is also useful to compare RTÉ's spend and services with other international public service media providers. In terms of our nearest counterpart, BBC 1 costs were £1.106 billion and BBC 2 costs were £381 million, consuming the bulk of the £1.678 billion spent by BBC on its television output in 2018. All of RTÉ's services are delivered for less than the BBC spends on its secondary television channel. The total revenue available to the Norwegian public service media provider NRK is €600 million while the Finnish public broadcasting service YLE revenue in 2018 was €475 million. RTÉ is providing a public service offering of equivalence with much less revenue. There is no doubt that national media services are struggling with the haemorrhaging of commercial income to the large-scale digital players in particular. This should be a matter of concern for all of us. It is a false comparison to perceive RTÉ as being exempt from that struggle or well-off by comparison. Our remit is different, our responsibilities are greater, and our costs reflect that.
There will always be things that our audiences would like to see us offer more or less of, depending on personal tastes and interests, but in overall terms, RTÉ offers a broad range of services with good levels of cost efficiency. RTÉ has exercised significant cost control, resulting in its 2018 costs being almost 25% lower than a decade ago. While RTÉ’s costs in the past three years have increased by a modest 6%, this reflects increases in the cost of making programmes and in the cost of competitive rights, both of which outstrip typical inflation, as well as significant public service obligations. Cost efficiency is routinely scrutinised by our regulator, the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland, and on more than one occasion by NewERA. On each evaluation, the organisation has met the metrics and the standards that were set.
The following is the breakdown of acquired programming versus home-produced programming within RTÉ’s overall output and spend: in RTÉ One, the total spend on indigenous programming was €110.4 million and the spend on acquired programming, including a portion of spend to Irish acquisitions, was €14.7 million or approximately 12% of the overall spend. In RTÉ 2, the total spend on local programming was €42.2 million and the spend on acquired programming was €9.5 million or approximately 18% of the overall total of €51.7 million. RTÉ’s use of acquired programming within its schedules is considerably less than many other public service media organisations of equivalent scale. For example, the Swedish, Danish and Finnish public broadcasters feature international programming as more than 50% of their overall schedule. It is a criteria that the BAI tracks within its assessment of performance every year. On RTÉ One, the number of hours of local content was 76%, a little over the target of 75%. On RTÉ 2 it was just under 40% which was also within the target range. Acquired programming has an important role to play in all public service media schedules. It brings high-quality content of all types from around the world at a very competitive price. Integrating programming from other countries can add to the diversity of the schedule and enhance our perspective on the world. For a smaller country like Ireland, acquired programmes can help balance the running costs of individual service and enhance complementarity and choice within the overall live viewing offerings in particular.
As the RTÉ Player continues to evolve, we have been increasing the rights access to international programming and we have been increasing our video-on-demand access within all new negotiations, offering additional value and opportunity to view for our viewers, and this will continue as on-demand becomes ever more popular. In this way, some of the best content created on an international basis is made available on a free-to-air basis, to Irish audiences. However, it is indigenous Irish programming that ultimately is of most value in terms of helping to define the character and distinctiveness of national public service broadcasting, and it is the area in which we have ambitions to invest more in the years ahead. As noted in the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland's Mediatique report of 2017, the most recent comprehensive report on the overall national media market, expenditure on original Irish TV content is dominated by the public service broadcasters, led by RTÉ. Although some of the other commercial services such as Sky would have a larger overall spend on content offerings, only a very small percentage of this is on original Irish production. Investing in Irish programming is also the way in which RTÉ can most meaningfully contribute to the ambitions of the national audiovisual action plan and how it can help create real stimulus within the creative economy.
Ireland punches above its weight with regard to the talent that is available, internationally recognised independent production companies, BAFTA winning directors, and Academy Award winning animation. Over the years, RTÉ has been privileged to work with some of Ireland's finest actors, directors, writers, producers and independent companies. In 2018, RTÉ invested just over €40 million in the independent sector, but that pales in comparison with what our spend once was.
Apart from the impact on RTÉ, this sector has also been severely adversely affected by the moneys lost through Ireland's outdated and inefficient collection system. Although RTÉ remains the largest commissioner of indigenous Irish content, spend on this important element of national storytelling lags behind its potential. The real cost is the lost opportunity. The effects of this are threefold. The creative economy is deprived of much-needed stimulus. Public service broadcasters are a key investor in and showcase for independent production companies. Many of most talented programme makers, screenwriters, actors and comedians leave for the UK, US and beyond. It is a drain in talent that a small country like Ireland cannot afford. Perhaps most importantly, Irish audiences lose out. Indigenous programming and journalism suffer, repeats become a feature of schedules more than is desirable, and audiences switch off from national services in favour of international competitors, which means less engagement with national topics and national culture. Ultimately, this encapsulates the nub of the current position and what is at risk.
The challenges being faced are a serious threat to the future of public service broadcasting at a time when public service media, with a publicly owned national service to reflect Ireland's voice and identity, have never been more important. It has material consequences for the audiovisual, sports and cultural sectors of the country. RTÉ has a plan to address this, but unless there is commensurate policy and legislative action, then public service media will potentially be weakened irrevocably. Less than two weeks ago, "The Late Late Toy Show" attracted a live audience of more than 1.3 million viewers, or 1.7 million in total when one adds worldwide streaming. That show was about many things. It was a big show with brave voices, electric performances and a lot of fun. At its core were the stories and experiences of some remarkable Irish kids. The nation listened and we witnessed a huge outpouring of support for this incredible showcase of talent, diversity and inspiration. It showed yet again that coming together as a community is a big part of who we are. That is something that we should all fight for.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and members of the committee for inviting us to participate in today's meeting. I hope that today's exchange will be of benefit to the committee in its understanding of funding issues regarding public sector broadcasting. I will make a brief public statement and then, following contributions from RTÉ, Ms Triona Quill and I will be available to answer questions.
There have been significant changes in the broadcasting sector in the past decade. These include the rise of digital advertising via search engines and social media, advances in content streaming services, and changes in the way people access audiovisual content. While these changes have improved the accessibility and quality of content, recent developments such as disinformation highlight the importance of trusted and reliable sources of publicly available information. Both public and private broadcasters have been impacted by these developments with the impact on advertising revenues. Share of advertising spend in the digital sector has risen from 7% in 2007 to a current figure of 40% in an environment where it is estimated that Google and Facebook obtain 75% of all digital sector advertising spend. Changing advertising trends arising both from the recession and from Brexit have resulted in a decline of approximately 35% in commercial revenues available to Irish broadcasters since 2009, with media convergence and the resultant shift to digital advertising impacting heavily upon broadcasting and print media in particular.
The decline in advertising revenue, coupled with challenges with the TV licensing collection model, such as the unacceptably high evasion rate, currently running at nearly 13%, the exclusion of 10% of households that do not have a TV and the relatively high collection costs of 7%, is having a critical impact on RTÉ's revenues and has resulted in a position where the financial sustainability of the organisation is now under immediate threat.
To address its current financial position, RTÉ has put together a revised strategy to cover the next four years that will include a number of changes to its current portfolio. These include cost reduction, further land and asset sales, increased public funding, future-proofing its offering and offering live experiences with ticketed events. In recognition of the current financial situation at RTÉ, the Minister requested that NewERA evaluate the revised RTÉ strategy with a view to assessing RTÉ's feasibility. In its report, NewERA agreed that the current financial situation at the broadcaster is unsustainable. The Department is in ongoing contact with senior management in RTÉ regarding its financial position and proposals for reform. The detail of these matters is being considered by Department officials in conjunction with NewERA officials and colleagues from the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform, and the Minister intends to bring forward a memo on the matter shortly. That has been overtaken by events this morning, which I am happy to cover.
An additional €10 million in public funding has been allocated to RTÉ over the past two budgets. This includes an additional €8.6 million made available in budget 2019 through a combination of an increase in Exchequer funding for public service broadcasting, which replaced TG4's TV licence funding, and an increase in the amount paid by the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection for free TV licences. This builds on the increase in funding for public service broadcasting in 2018, funded through a €1.64 million increase in the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection's contribution for free TV licences. TG4 was allocated an additional €443,000 in Exchequer funding for 2019 in addition to the €2 million in current and capital funding that it received in 2018, bringing the total increase since the start of the five-year review period to almost €2.5 million. TG4 was also allocated a once-off capital grant of €985,000 in 2018 for its expenditure relating to Bliain na Gaeilge.
The increased contribution from the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection in both 2018 and 2019 also benefits An Post and the broadcasting fund. The broadcasting fund is a fund administered by the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland, BAI, that includes the sound and vision scheme, which supports high-quality programming on Irish culture, heritage and experience, programmes to improve adult literacy, and archiving schemes. It benefits the broadcasting sector as a whole, including independent production.
In its report published in November 2017, the Joint Committee on Communications, Climate Action and Environment recommended that Revenue collect the TV licence and the replacement of the current TV licence with a broadcasting charge. In response, the working group on the future funding of public service broadcasting was set up by a Government decision in July 2018 to examine options for the future funding of broadcasting. The key recommendations of its report are that the TV licence be put out to public tender as soon as the enabling legislation, the Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill, is enacted. It will be necessary to offer a fixed term contract of five years to make it feasible for the successful tenderer to invest in the database and collection improvements. Another recommendation is that at the end of the contract period, the licence fee should be replaced by a device-independent charge to support public service content on a sustainable basis. It was felt by the group that due to a number of issues surrounding the implementation of a device-independent charge, including owner-occupier liability, how to charge commercial premises, perception issues around collecting with the local property tax, and how the charge would be collected from social and local authority housing, an interim measure was needed to address the issue immediately. The Government has accepted the working group’s recommendations and is bringing forward an amendment to the Broadcasting Act that will enable the collection of the TV licence to be put out to public tender.
On 18 July 2019, the Government approved the publication of the Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill 2019 and tabled an amendment on Committee Stage to appoint an agent through a public procurement competition for the collection of the TV licence fee. The proposed amendments to the Broadcasting Act 2009 will allow for the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland to be part funded up to a maximum of 50% from TV licence receipts. It is intended that any consequent reductions in broadcasting levy contributions would be applied across the board by the BAI so that all broadcasters would benefit in equal proportion from the measure. It is proposed that doing this will provide scope to exempt smaller community radio stations from the broadcasting levy altogether. The Bill allows for the Minister to decide what percentage of the levy to fund from TV licence receipts. It will allow the BAI to accrue a level of working capital to meet its day-to-day expenses without the need to pursue a costly and burdensome borrowing facility and grant authority to the BAI to determine exemptions and deferrals to the levy depending on the qualifying income of individual broadcasters and the level of regulation they require.
It will give the BAI greater flexibility regarding which broadcasters are covered by the levy and to what extent. This will create a legislative environment by which new broadcasters, including, for example, any that might wish to relocate to the State after Brexit, can be levied appropriately, thereby contributing to the cost of their regulation. A number of broadcasters have relocated EU services to Ireland already in light of Brexit, the main ones being Sports Information Services, SIS, and SSBL which operates FreeSports. The BAI has licensed four section 71 contracts in the past ten months. The BAI remains in contact with a number of large UK-based broadcasters which are considering relocating to Ireland if a no-deal Brexit materialises.
The Bill also addresses a gap in the existing legislation whereby the holder of the section 70 contract is exempted from the requirement to apply for a licence for any additional services it chooses to offer. It seeks to ensure that any new services could not operate on an unregulated basis and clarifies that they would require a section 71 licence.
In order to further support community and local radio, the Bill will allow for the creation of a new funding scheme that would permit the granting of bursaries to journalists in these stations, which are the starting point for many journalists’ careers. It is intended that approximately €500,000 would be made available by the BAI to support 20 annual bursaries of €25,000 each.
The Bill repeals sections 103 and 251 of the Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000 as the public policy objectives for which they were introduced, mainly to support the roll-out of cable television services in Ireland, have been achieved. In addition, television services are now available over a wider range of platforms, including satellite, which do not benefit from a similar exemption. The proposed repeals have been agreed with the Minister for Business, Enterprise and Innovation.
The Bill went through Second Stage in the Dáil on 21 October and is expected to be brought to Committee Stage in the new year.
I hope that this has helped the committee in its consideration of these issues. Along with my colleague, Ms Quill, I look forward to answering any questions members may have.
Comment on this
I have a question for RTÉ. When RTÉ raises concerns about resourcing difficulties, members of the public will often highlight the high salaries paid to some of the stars within RTÉ. According to RTÉ's figures, one presenter earned more than €300,000 in 2016 for hosting two shows a week. That is well in excess of what the Taoiseach earns working, one could say, up to seven days a week. I know the salaries are subject to further cuts of 15%. I am conscious that a large amount of the funding RTÉ receives is taxpayers' money. Is it down to the popularity of the show or what metric does RTÉ use to decide salaries for its star presenters?
Comment on this
As the Chairman knows, RTÉ has a public service remit. It also has a commercial remit to commercialise the output we create and put to air. The role of our presenters is multifaceted. They present several shows depending on the individual. They are very important to RTÉ and are very important to the messages they have to deliver on a regular basis. I understand why this is a topic of conversation among the public. The role of presenting a show and being a broadcaster can be difficult. It is not something that everybody can do despite what the public might think. We highly value the contributions these people make to RTÉ and beyond. In the context of our current situation, we are addressing that with the presenters concerned. They will be subject to ongoing discussion for the future.
There is a market for presenters. On the basis of information we have received in recent months, five of the ten top-paid presenters are outside RTÉ. There is a bit of a myth that there is not a market. There is a market for presenters, which is quite competitive at the moment, both here and in the UK. Having said that, we recognise that given our financial situation, we need to address the matter. We are doing that by asking our key presenters to take a 15% cut, which is on top of the cut of in excess of 30% that they have taken in recent years.
Comment on this
There are many people, including other non-members, present who want to ask questions. I will bring them in, but I am conscious of time. I will let members of the committee speak first and give them ten minutes each. If they want to share their time with other Members of their party, they are very welcome to do that within the ten-minute slot. We will then see what time is available for our guest Members - I apologise for using that term.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Forbes and Ms Cronin for their presentations.
Ms Forbes gave a comprehensive outline of the position. Most people accept and recognise the challenge. My party absolutely supports public service broadcasting and we have done that. When Ms Forbes appeared before the committee about three years ago she challenged us to look at the licence fee funding model. The committee did that under the guidance of the Chairman and we presented that report, which is widely accepted as a blueprint for the funding of public service broadcasting into the future.
At that time, we challenged Ms Forbes to bring forward a plan. In her statement today she said:
Ultimately, this encapsulates, the nub of the current position and what is at risk. The challenges being faced are a serious threat to the future of public service broadcasting.
The reality is that they are the same challenges that effectively existed three and a half years ago. While there was an iteration of a plan that was supposed to set RTÉ back on to an even keel, we now have another plan. Further land may be sold, the RTÉ Guide may be sold and some art may also be sold. We are somewhat sceptical about what we are hearing. We had great belief in RTÉ when, three and a half years ago, it set out in a very direct way its desire to put a plan in place. What it has done to date has not worked. I do not put all that on Ms Forbes's shoulders. While this committee responded to her challenge, how the Government responded to that is another matter. I am on record over the Government failures in that regard. Is Ms Forbes happy with the level of transformation that has been achieved in her tenure?
Comment on this
There is a lot in the Deputy's question. When I started in RTÉ the first thing I did was to look at how the organisation is structured, knowing that we are facing major transformation in the industry, to determine whether RTÉ was positioned appropriately for that challenge, particularly as viewing habits were changing. With that in mind, we restructured the organisation. That process is under way and is working incredibly well in some areas, while in other areas it may not be working as well. That is typical of any reorganisation. Having said that, this was also put in place when we worked on our five-year strategy for the BAI.
Comment on this
I ask Ms Forbes to outline details of that restructuring so that people can understand what has happened over the past three and a half years.
Comment on this
Previously, RTÉ was separated into divisions covering radio, television and online. That worked really well for many years because it was all about the platform.
Comment on this
Is this the "one RTÉ" agenda Ms Forbes mentioned?
Comment on this
Exactly. This is where we moved to. Instead of thinking about the platform first, we really wanted to put the audience at the centre of the organisation. Audience habits have been changing and audiences now are not as bothered about where the content comes from. Instead, they want to be sure they can get it when they want it. In putting together the one RTÉ strategy we put all the documentary teams from television and radio together in one team, for example. Our content people now works across every platform. We are thinking about audience first and distribution platform second. It has meant that, for example, in something like arts and culture, which is a key remit of RTÉ, we have put together teams that typically would have worked separately and the results speak for themselves. Culture Night, which was really the domain of RTÉ radio until a few years ago, is now a major night and event for RTÉ across radio, television and online. That is the principle.
Comment on this
On a day-to-day level the silos still exist. We have radio, television-----
Comment on this
The platforms still exist and they always will. The thinking is what is changing within RTÉ. It is very important that we do not simply think of a programme as being on television or on radio. It could go across the pieces. That is the structural aspect.
It is also important to refer to the strategy we put in place for the next five years, which was submitted to the BAI in 2017. That strategy comprised our recommendations in light of what is coming and what the future will ask of us. That fell on deaf ears at Government level. The BAI endorsed the strategy but stated that it required an immediate €30 million in funding for RTÉ. I say this to answer the Deputy's question about what has not happened. We have been doing an awful lot within RTÉ to change and to pivot in the right direction for the audience. However, the public funding solution has not emerged.
Comment on this
Let us look at the funding issue. Ms Forbes talked about making savings of €60 million over the next three years. Can she detail the line items in the third year? Perhaps Ms O'Keeffe will have that information. I refer to the line items comprising that €60 million. Perhaps the witnesses can provide that for us at a later stage. I would like a breakdown of that €60 million.
Comment on this
In broad terms, we have said that we need to make savings of €60 million over the next three years, as the Deputy said. Approximately half of that needs to come from personnel costs.
Comment on this
What is the scale of that? We read about pay cuts, a pay freeze or a headcount reduction, to use that terrible term from the HR sector. What reduction in staffing are we talking about?
Comment on this
We expect that approximately 200 staff will leave RTÉ. That will partly arise from a voluntary redundancy scheme. A certain number will transfer under European Communities (Protection of Employees on Transfer of Undertakings) Regulations 2003, TUPE, with the RTÉ National Symphony Orchestra. As the Deputy may recall, the orchestra will transfer to the National Concert Hall.
Comment on this
So what is the number on the HR side in the third year?
Comment on this
Some 200 are hoping to leave. What is the cost saving in year three?
Comment on this
It will be between €9 million and €10 million.
Comment on this
Will that €10 million come from the elimination of 200 staff, or will that be the total savings?
Comment on this
There will be total savings of approximately €10 million.
Comment on this
As such there will be another €50 million in savings. Can the witnesses identify those savings?
Comment on this
The aim is to save about €60 million between content and service reductions.
Comment on this
Will that saving come from content?
Comment on this
It will mostly be content. We will have to make tough decisions in the next couple of years on questions such as sports rights that come up for renewal.
Comment on this
Then there is pay. Savings there need to come to approximately €10 million.
Comment on this
We already had that item. That was the first one. That accounts for €10 million, and €16 million will be saved in the area of content.
Comment on this
There are to be savings of €60 million over the next three years. By the third year, we are looking for savings of between €9 million and €10 million from personnel-related operating costs. That will include up to 200 staff, which, as Ms Forbes mentioned, will leave either through voluntary exits or transfer of undertakings. We are also seeking-----
Comment on this
I want the cumulative figure. Current revenues are €339 million or €340 million, which comprise commercial revenue and licence fees. The management wants to cut spending to €60 million below that figure by-----
Comment on this
The Deputy is mixing up per annum figures. The sum of €340 million is our annual revenue and is roughly our annual figure for costs. We are seeking-----
Comment on this
On average, does RTÉ want to save €20 million per year?
Comment on this
Yes. We want to cut roughly €20 million per annum, of which between €9 million and €10 million will come from reductions in content and services. Roughly the same amount will come from personnel-related operating costs. We are also looking at cutting non-personnel-related operating costs by running tighter procurement processes, changing our travel and subsistence policies and various other things. We have significantly reduced those costs over the year in the interest of maintaining employment. In those other areas of cost reduction, we have sought quite-----
Comment on this
As such, RTÉ will break even. Can management achieve that without any projected increase in revenue from the State, recognising that there will not be any change in licence fees based on the seven years-----
Comment on this
Our overall financial strategy is a three-strand approach. It is based on three pillars. We have outlined the cost reductions that RTÉ will make through changes to our content, services and cost base. Through this, we aim to achieve cost reductions of €60 million in the next three years. An important part of our financial strategy, which we mentioned earlier, is commercial revenue. It is important that any strategy we pursue stabilises that.
Comment on this
The Chairman is putting me under pressure.
Comment on this
I am trying to answer the question about the financial strategy. It is important that we shore up commercial revenue. It has decreased significantly this year as a result of Brexit. Shoring up and stabilising commercial revenue is a key part of our strategy. A couple of years ago we consolidated training, which was an important step. The third part of the strategy, which is of key importance, is securing additional public funding.
Comment on this
What additional funding is assumed in the strategy?
Comment on this
The increase we are calling for is in line with the recommendations of our regulator, the BAI. This was recommended in 2017.
Comment on this
That amounts to €90 million over three years.
Comment on this
The BAI recommended €30 million in immediate additional public funding for RTÉ per annum.
Comment on this
Ms O'Keeffe is saying that to achieve stability, in addition to savings of €20 million per year and, cumulatively, €60 million, the strategy is based on the expectation of getting an additional €90 million over that three years.
Comment on this
It is based on additional funding of €30 million per annum, of which €10 million was provided in 2018 and 2019, as Ms Cronin outlined. A further €10 million per annum in funding has been announced today, which is most welcome. We, therefore, need €10 million more per annum, amounting to €30 million over the next three years-----
Comment on this
That is, €10 million on top of the existing funding.
Comment on this
-----on top of what has been announced today.
Comment on this
I only have ten minutes, so I would like the answers to my questions to be as succinct as possible. I have a lot of questions to get through. I will start where Deputy Dooley started by saying that the members of this committee support public broadcasting. Anyone who supports public services should support public broadcasting. This committee did a very lengthy piece of work, which resulted in an all-party report supporting some of the measures called for in Ms Forbes's opening statement. Given the key recommendations of that report and the measures Ms Forbes is asking for, has the can essentially been kicked down the road for at least five years? Is that her view of the response of the Department and the Government?
Comment on this
As I said in my opening statement, the measures outlined by the Government are untenable, which is why we are here today. A delay of seven years is not feasible.
Comment on this
"Untenable" is one word. Is this kicking the can down the road?
Comment on this
One could say that, but it is certainly untenable from a financial point of view.
Comment on this
Turning to the Department, why were the recommendations in this committee's report ignored or pushed down the road for five or seven years? What was the logic of that decision?
Comment on this
The Oireachtas report was published and the Government decided to set up a group-----
Comment on this
I know about that. I am asking why we have not gotten answers.
Comment on this
If I could finish, to answer the Deputy's question-----
Comment on this
The Government decided to set up the group. Its work was informed by the work of this committee. We looked at various options, including the options the committee recommended. The report sets out various complexities that would arise from them. I can outline those if the Deputy likes, but the nub of the issue is that, based on our evaluations, we advised the Government that the best short-term approach was to put the TV licence fee collection out to tender. In the longer term, we recommended a device-independent charge.
Comment on this
We need to hear from the Minister. I wish to request that we invite him to appear at some point after today. These are policy decisions.
I would like to raise RTÉ's plan. Is this the plan that was submitted to the Department, or was supplementary information or a more detailed submission given to the Department?
Comment on this
A lot of detailed information was provided to the Department.
It was also the subject of reviews by PricewaterhouseCoopers, PwC, and NewERA. We worked with our internal teams to get to the strategy and the board asked that PwC examine the strategy. When that was presented to the Department, the Minister asked that NewERA examine it. There is significant-----
Comment on this
The Department received something more than the information we have.
Comment on this
All we have is the information we have.
Comment on this
Ms Forbes was put under robust questioning on "Morning Ireland" and "Drivetime", which was good. It struck me that the questions being asked related to the specifics of costings. The information I have mentions "strategy specifics" and there is a set of line items setting out what needs to be done, modified or reduced. No costings are provided, however. The RTÉ Guide was up for sale. How much would that have saved?
Comment on this
As the Deputy will appreciate, in putting together a plan for any organisation or business, there will be a great deal of confidential information. He should rest assured there are detailed costings behind all the measures but they are confidential-----
Comment on this
We do not have them. I am asking questions about them.
Comment on this
Ms Forbes stated they were confidential. I ask the Deputy to let her finish her response.
Comment on this
It is confidential information that we have to stand over as an organisation, and it has been verified. It is all included because otherwise, we would not be able to produce a strategy.
Comment on this
If any political party published a set of proposals to save €60 million, with no costings provided, and stated the information was confidential and could not be provided, we would be laughed out of the room by any RTÉ presenter. I seek a little more detail on the costs. I accept that Ms Forbes stated the information about the RTÉ Guide is commercially sensitive, but on the consequences of closing the RTÉ Lyric FM studio in Limerick, no costing has been provided, while to provide for savings from pay cuts, no costing has been provided. There is also no costing for reducing the staff headcount by 200. I do not see any line costings by which I can hold Ms Forbes to account, to ensure that the savings can be achieved and that the figure of €60 million adds up. If I were to present this to RTÉ as a strategy, and state that I would save €60 million but not how much each line item would cost, I would be laughed out of the room.
Comment on this
As my colleague outlined, we can quantify the €60 million in broad buckets. We have given the information in detail to the Department and NewERA has been across it all. I am happy to take the Deputy through some of the detail in a separate forum if he wishes. The €60 million is a combination of a number of factors. No one measure will return RTÉ to a financially stable position. As Ms O'Keeffe noted, a number of factors have to be at play. Public funding has to be reformed, our commercial revenue has to be stabilised and we have to cut our costs. All three elements have to come together to make the savings possible.
Comment on this
I accept that, but it is no good Ms Forbes appearing before the committee and stating she can furnish us with more detail at a later date. I had hoped that we would receive detailed breakdowns in advance of the meeting. On the €10 million in funding announced today, which is welcome, was there any quid pro quo agreed with the Department to reverse any of the decisions?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach stated earlier in the Dáil that he expected, given the announcement of the €10 million allocation today, the Lyric FM studio in Limerick not to close.
Comment on this
We heard about that on our way to the meeting but had not been aware in advance. We will need to see the statement and comment on it afterwards.
Comment on this
On the pay cut of 15% for the top presenters, how many presenters are there?
Comment on this
Seven are contracted. Those discussions are-----
Comment on this
RTÉ cannot unilaterally cut their pay-----
Comment on this
There will have to be a negotiation.
Comment on this
Is it possible that RTÉ will not be able to make the cuts, because of contractual issues?
Comment on this
We are dealing with each case individually. A number of the presenters have stated publicly that when asked to consider cuts, they have always done so. The negotiations are ongoing and we will make our best endeavours to get there. If we do not, we will have to find money elsewhere.
Comment on this
Exactly. I am trying to understand how RTÉ will achieve €60 million in savings. The RTÉ Guide sale has been reversed, perhaps for good reason, although I suspect it has been taken off the shelf only because of a lack of expressions of interest. Is it possible that if there was better interest, RTÉ might proceed with the sale? There is no guarantee that RTÉ will achieve the savings in pay, given that there will have to be negotiations, and it will have to discuss cuts with the trade unions. I am not in favour of job cuts because the people who will lose their jobs will not be the top presenters. They are ordinary workers on ordinary incomes and I have a great concern about that.
There are large holes in the strategy. Unless Ms Forbes is able to give me a full breakdown of where the €60 million savings can be achieved - not broad headings - it will not cut it in respect of accountability.
Comment on this
In fairness, this is the information I have been given.
Comment on this
In fairness, RTÉ has reduced its cost base by almost 25%. Between the years 2008 and 2013, inclusive, RTÉ delivered cuts of more than 30% in its cost base. NewERA conducted an efficiency review of RTÉ in 2015 and judged us to be efficient. The report, which the Deputy can read if he wishes, stated that we had delivered cost savings in excess of those of many other organisations. Undoubtedly, €20 million per annum will be very difficult, not least because of the work we have done to date, which has resulted in our cost base being 25% lower than it was in 2008. The Deputy is correct to express concern that achieving the savings will be challenging, but we have demonstrated an ability to save, together with our staff and management. It is not just we who have done it. Our staff were co-operative in taking pay reductions in 2008 and 2009.
Comment on this
I do not question what the organisation or Ms O'Keeffe has done in the past. I have listened to Ms Forbes on a number of occasions respond to questions and many people have asked questions about whether the savings can be achieved. We have a job to ask questions, such as whether the €60 million in savings can be achieved, but all I have received is a one-page document with no costings or line items. Broad, general headings do not cut it. It is not good enough that the detail was not given to us before the meeting. I ask that RTÉ forward to the committee, which is the line committee to which RTÉ is answerable, a bit more detail on how the €60 million in savings will be achieved. If some issues are commercially sensitive, that is fine. Staff at RTÉ will potentially lose their jobs, there are questions as to whether the top presenters will take the proposed 15% pay cut and there are concerns about Lyric FM. A presentation was made at Leinster House about people who have settled in Limerick with their families but will have to move. I accept that these are challenging times and that this is not a position that RTÉ wants to be in. While I support the allocation of additional funding to RTÉ and public broadcasting, I do not like being given a plan with no specifics and being told, in general terms, that the savings will be achieved. I would like to be provided with a bit more than one page and hope that following the meeting, our guests will provide us with a bit more detail than what we have been given.
Comment on this
On the point discussed by Deputy Cullinane, Ms Forbes stated seven persons are on contract and that RTÉ is in negotiation with them about pay reductions. She was not clear as to whether any of them has yet committed to a reduction. Have there been any commitments, aside from statements from them to the effect that they will go with the flow?
Comment on this
One discussion has been completed and the rest are ongoing. All the people concerned are under contract and, therefore, we will appeal to them to discuss the matter with us outside of their contracts. Moreover, on renewal, there will be further discussion. Both steps are being taken at the same time.
Comment on this
Ms Forbes stated there had been one settlement. What percentage reduction was achieved on that occasion?
Comment on this
It was in excess of 15%, but the figure relates to an individual contract and, therefore, we cannot discuss it.
Comment on this
How long remains on the contracts that have been provided for?
Comment on this
Ms Forbes referred to renegotiation on renewal. How far away from happening is that?
Comment on this
The contracts vary. Some are up for discussion now, while others will be up for discussion early next year. The majority will be addressed within the next number of months.
Comment on this
To what percentage will RTÉ agree as a reduction for those people when the renegotiation stage is reached?
What is the target? Is it 10%, 20% or 30%?
Comment on this
That is in addition to the 30% reduction that already has been taken since 2008 across the organisation on average.
Comment on this
I accept it could be wrong information but it has been suggested to me that the 30% figure, which is a global figure, included one particular person who left the organisation from whom credit was taken while the others were given the benefit of that. Is that correct?
Comment on this
No. How we evaluate the top ten is that we literally take the top ten earners in one year and compare them to the top ten in the comparative year. Those names can change. If a person leaves the organisation, for example, they would not be on the second list. They are replaced by somebody else in the top ten.
Comment on this
If a mega-earner leaves at the top, then the percentage reduction is distorted by that.
Comment on this
Well I would not say distorted but it is compared. We disclose top ten earnings.
Comment on this
One leaves but an 11th person comes in and changes the dynamic.
Comment on this
These percentages are easy to talk about. However, at some stage, even in global terms, we should have the actual amount of cash that this programme of renegotiation etc, will actually realise. Can that be done?
Comment on this
We publish the figures. They are in the public domain for anybody to make those comparisons. We are transparent around our top talent fees. Those figures can be compared at any point.
Comment on this
One settlement has been negotiated. Seven of the top ten people in question are contracted. Does that mean the other three are employees?
Comment on this
Are employees the subject of a reduction?
Comment on this
I thought the whole staff of RTÉ was getting a cut imposed on it.
Comment on this
The overall picture for staff is being discussed through the mechanisms of the unions. When we get further into that discussion, we will be in a better position to know exactly what will be affected in respect of different earners at different levels of our staff.
Comment on this
Ms Forbes agreed with Deputy Cullinane that the decision to put out to tender the television licence fee collection system could be described as either unsustainable or kicking it down the road.
I note the Department has stated there are difficulties with using the local property tax model because the landlord is usually the owner and is liable for it. With a bit of thought, the Department could have put in place a burden-sharing between the landlord and tenant. It does not take five years to work that out. I suggest that the Department has deliberately chosen, perhaps because of the electoral cycle, not to accept what this committee recommended. Instead, it has given itself a five to seven-year holiday from reality. It has decided to ignore the obvious proposition, which I among others have spoken about at this committee and elsewhere. There are simple collection mechanisms for every home, every hotel and business that uses communication, which the Revenue Commissioners could easily implement through local property tax, commercial rates or whatever.
Why has the Department said this is so complex that it needs several years to do it when it is just a case of the Department rolling up its sleeves? The Department has had months since the committee’s report on this issue was tendered to it. It could have come up with a positive decision as to what it wanted to do. I do not want to put Ms Cronin under too much pressure. However, the Minister should be here in my view to explain to the committee why our report has been shelved. The inference I am drawing is that it is political cowardice.
Comment on this
Is there any reason the committee's report was rejected?
Comment on this
The idea that it is too complicated to work out how the Revenue could collect this just does not stand up to reason. There is a finance Bill every year that deals with loopholes. Massive legislation is composed within months. I suggest this is a deliberate choice not to face up to this issue.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their presentations. I want to ask some direct questions. The local National Union of Jouralists, NUJ, branch in RTÉ had a proposal that all salaries in the organisation would be capped at €200,000. How much could be saved annually if that proposal was implemented?
Comment on this
We would certainly have to come back to the Deputy on that. I do not know offhand, if that was the case, what that would generate.
Comment on this
It is the case that the local NUJ branch in RTÉ put forward a proposal and voted that all salaries would be capped at €200,000. Ms Forbes must be aware of that. Has she worked out the figure that could be saved annually? It involves all salaries, not just the top ten earners but everybody, including the witnesses.
Comment on this
We will have to come back to the Deputy on that. The proposal was put out there. We were in consultation with our unions and staff before that. We are working on the principle that we have been discussing. That is where we are at the moment.
Comment on this
It would be helpful if we could get a costing on that.
Comment on this
We will happily come back to the Deputy on that.
Comment on this
Please. I have another direct question. How much will the proposed moving of Lyric FM out of Limerick save?
Comment on this
All of these changes are part of several things that would need to happen to stabilise RTÉ's finances. Picking out one or the other, while there are numbers attached to some, they are not as clean as the question would suggest. We must ensure that we can deliver services to the public more efficiently than we are doing. That is what is tied up in all of this. There is a complex set of circumstances at play here. The proposed move of Lyric FM is part of that. It is worth bearing in mind that we have excess capacity in Cork and Dublin. Part of the thinking was to ensure that excess capacity could be utilised while preserving the service to the public and, at the same time, reducing costs overall. That is the context of the Limerick discussion and why Lyric is one of those proposals. We have just been hearing-----
Comment on this
Ms Forbes, I only have ten minutes. That would not be an acceptable answer for the staff in Limerick, many of whom have settled and bought homes there on the understanding that this was to be where they would work. It is not good for the city of Limerick. This sort of rambling answer is not acceptable when I asked a direct question. There must be some idea of how much would be saved if Lyric was moved out of Limerick.
Comment on this
We are beginning discussions with staff in Limerick on Friday as to what exactly is at play. The exact number will depend on several matters. Again, I appreciate that this is upsetting for staff living in Limerick. That is why we must have the discussions with them as to what is at stake.
Comment on this
To have suggested the move in the first place means Ms Forbes must have some idea how much it would save, if anything.
Comment on this
It really depends on the final outcome and what the actual mix would be.
Comment on this
I am not getting an answer to that.
The cap placed on the level of contribution received from the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection in lieu of the free TV licence, as part of the household package, amounted to a reduction of €5 million in RTÉ’s funding for the first year and has subsequently risen. Has Ms Forbes calculated how much was lost by RTÉ with this measure? In another discussion on transport, one finds the full amount of free travel that Dublin Bus, Bus Éireann and others give to the public under the Department of Employment Affairs and Social Protection scheme does not come back to those companies. Has RTÉ calculated how much it has lost as a result of this?
Comment on this
If we do not have that information to hand, we can certainly come back to the committee with it.
Comment on this
I am really surprised that these figures are not available to us. These questions are very simple. I would like to get an answer. Would Ms Forbes agree that the entire subsistence in respect of the free TV licence should be reinstated to RTÉ?
Comment on this
It is not just a once-off. It will be reinstated-----
Comment on this
-----on a recurring basis.
Comment on this
The €10 million that has been announced today-----
Comment on this
While I do not have the detail of the calculation of that, I understand it relates to the free licences and will remove the cap that was put in place in 2010 on the free licences. It might not restore it completely, but it will restore it almost completely.
Comment on this
I do not think it is being restored completely. I have examined the figures and I think it falls far short of a complete restoration. I would like to get a definitive answer in this regard.
Comment on this
It is probably a matter for the Department to come back on the calculations.
Comment on this
I would like to refer to the recommendations this committee made to RTÉ to help with public broadcasting. We recommended that retransmission fees should be introduced for companies that enjoy the retransmission of RTÉ material. I am talking about a variety of pay-TV platforms, including Eir, Sky, Virgin Media and Vodafone. Has RTÉ done any work to try to claim retransmission fees from any of these companies?
Comment on this
That requires a change in the law. The current regime, under section 77 of the Broadcasting Act, would need to be adjusted to enable us to get fair value for the services we provide to platforms. That change has not happened. It is not included in the proposed amendments that are being brought forward by the Minister.
Comment on this
Is RTÉ lobbying the Minister for such a change?
Comment on this
RTÉ would like to see this happen.
Comment on this
I think that would be a sensible proposal. It would take the burden off. I do not know what Ms Forbes was referring to when she spoke about "Ireland's outdated and inefficient collection system". I assume she is in favour of Revenue being involved the collection of this money, as proposed by Senator McDowell. I voted against that proposal because I am not in favour of any more money being taken from people by Revenue. However, I am in favour of charges being put on social media platforms that gain significantly from advertising. People can watch RTÉ content on those platforms, but they do not have to pay anything in return. Approximately 80% of most advertising is gained by two companies - Google and Facebook. How would the witnesses respond to the introduction of some form of taxation on social media players to fund public broadcasting, which all of us are in favour of and want to defend?
Comment on this
The Deputy is right to point out that there is a divergence between the domestic players and the international ones. According to a European Broadcasting Union assessment of the market that was conducted earlier this year, the value of digital advertising increased from approximately €100 million in 2009 to almost €600 million in 2018. That money is going largely to two companies, namely, Facebook and Google, which are headquartered here. These massive global players are resident here. The audiovisual media services directive, which is due to be brought into Irish law by the end of next year, facilitates the possible introduction by Ireland or any member state of a system that would, in effect, place a levy on these entities. Such a fund could be used to create an Irish content fund that would invest in Irish programming. We would support such a measure because it would create a much-needed stimulus. I think it should be a contestable fund for Irish programme makers and Irish broadcasters of all hues, rather than for RTÉ alone. There is no doubt that there is an asymmetry between the amount of money that these companies are making here and their relative lack of investment in Irish programming.
Comment on this
I assume Mr. Coveney acknowledges that such a fund could plug a big hole in the finances of RTÉ and public broadcasting in general. If we were able to tax the digital media, it could save 200 jobs and prevent Lyric FM from being moved out of Limerick.
Comment on this
The question of how public broadcasting is funded is a separate one. In the context of the investment needed by the audiovisual sector in Ireland, this could provide a substantial stimulus and could support the creation of Irish programming. I am thinking particularly of expensive programmes that are hard to sustain in sectors like drama and animation, both of which have a good track record here but are starved of the investment they need.
Comment on this
I recently met some RTÉ pensioners in the context of the fight for the full reinstatement of the public sector pensions that were cut in 2008. Those pensioners, including people who worked in key roles in research and accounts, have not received an increase since 2008. Many of them are living on the breadline. Do the witnesses think anything can be done to reinstate or increase the pensions of former RTÉ staff?
Comment on this
The Deputy has made an important point about pensioners. I presume she is referring to the defined benefit scheme that has been closed to new entrants since the late 1980s. The scheme is in surplus, fortunately, because it has been well managed by the trustees and by the chair of the defined benefit superannuation scheme. It passes the minimum funding standards and the long-term valuation. It is in a relatively good place. As the sponsor, RTÉ recommended a modest increase for its pensioners. We submitted a recommendation to that effect. Under the regulations of the scheme, we cannot authorise any such increase for our pensioners. It has to be approved by the Minister.
Comment on this
Is the Minister holding it up?
Comment on this
It is approved by the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform and the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform has come back with questions. It needs to be assured that it is in order to pay this increase to pensioners. The Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment is engaging with the Department and with RTÉ on this issue at the moment.