Report of Independent Working Group on Salmon: Ministerial Presentation.
Contributions 132–280 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Can I ask the Chairman to take responses to the questions asked by Senator Dardis and me? We have been asked to go to the Curtin committee soon.
Comment on this
Will Mr. White address the issue of seal predation? I am sure the committee is anxious to know if he consulted the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government. What plans does it have in this regard? Poaching is an important issue. Has Mr. White referred to fisheries officers? Do they operate on river banks?
Comment on this
I will respond first to Senator Finucane. We endorse his broad point about the responsibility of local authorities for the other causes that affect salmon, such as pollution and poor water quality. We stressed in our report that if the State is going to the hardship, from its point of view, of ending mixed stock fishing and paying out substantial sums of money, it makes no sense to do one part of the job only. We have made this point in discussions with the Minister of State, Deputy Browne, and the Minister, Deputy Noel Dempsey. In the interest of salmon, this policy must be accompanied by a renewed approach to the water directives and to the restoration of habitats to complete the job. That follows from what we said in the committee.
We touched on the issue of seals, cormorants, etc. One of the points that have been made is that drift-net fishing attracts seals because the fish are caught by their gills in the drift-nets. If drift-nets are no longer in use, that obvious source of salmon is gone. It is clear that there needs to be a review of the effect of cormorants and seals from the point of view of completing the report.
Beyond that, what is absolutely stunning when one first addresses this issue is that the marine survival rate for salmon is only 10% or less. What we have stressed in the report is the need for Ireland to become engaged with others in getting to the bottom of why this is so. There are indications that changes in temperature have affected the feeding habits and migration patterns of salmon. A 90% fatality rate for salmon crossing the Atlantic is significant but it does not take away the responsibility from us. This goes back to the scientific advice to do the bit we are expected to do and which the international community expects us to do.
Comment on this
To be clear, did Mr. White have a discussion with the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government about seal predation?
Comment on this
Not specifically, although we are aware of the situation relating to the status of seals. We are also aware of the scientific advice that it is a potential source of predation, but we did not go further down that road. The essence of our philosophy is that Ireland needs to move beyond the rivers, take an interest in the sources of predation and follow this through by taking an interest, with others, in getting to the bottom of why there is a 90% mortality rate for salmon that leave rivers.
Comment on this
While I accept this is a fine document, it cannot be taken in isolation. We have to put all the pieces of the jigsaw together if we want to be seen to do the right thing vis-à-vis the rest of Europe in regard to salmon.
Comment on this
We agree with Senator Finucane. Basically, Ireland would then be in a much stronger moral position because if we have complied with the international requirements and can say we have ended mixed stock fishing, essentially, that will give us a moral platform to argue for greater collaboration and initiatives in getting to the bottom of the sources of the marine mortality of the salmon.
Comment on this
Does Mr. White agree with recommendation No. 5 in our report recommending that the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government prepare a report on seal predation on salmon stocks, from the point of view of completeness?
Comment on this
Yes, that would be very much in keeping with the spirit of our approach. To be fair to drift-net fishermen, they are aware that they are not the only problem and they will point to other sources. It is correct that we should follow through this initiative by getting to the bottom of the other sources of salmon mortality. We support the spirit of the committee's recommendations.
Comment on this
We will inquire from the Department what progress it is making on this report that was recommended by an Oireachtas committee.
Comment on this
For the record, responsibility for seals falls within the national parks and wildlife service of the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government. The group met Dr. Marnell of the national parks and wildlife service as part of its meeting with the standing scientific committee. The integration of phased service is in that context, under the auspices of the standing scientific committee which includes the national parks and wildlife service, which is responsible for the management of seals.
Comment on this
Are Mr. Keatinge or Dr. Ó Maoileidigh aware of any report carried out by the national parks and wildlife service?
Comment on this
I am not aware of any report in preparation.
Comment on this
We would probably have heard about it through the committee. However, I will check.
Comment on this
To respond to Senator Finucane, by the time we completed our report in August, we did not have the data for this year. Angling data do not become available until the following year when the logbooks are returned. We would have a high degree of confidence in the preliminary scientific advice we received. It follows logically on last year's scientific advice. There would be a 99% confidence level that the advice would be sustained.
Senator Dardis made a point that is often left out of the equation. If nothing happens, we are on a trajectory to an almost catastrophic decline and minimal fish. There are serious implications for drift-net fishermen if nothing happens. In effect, a hardship scheme will compensate them before they get to that point.
The other point the Senator mentioned has not really been discussed either, namely, the potential for the tourism industry in coastal communities from a revival of salmon. We were very impressed by the presentation made to us by Fáilte Éireann. There is evidence that Irish anglers are travelling to Russia and other countries to pursue angling. Ireland has significant potential, which is of the order of €100 million in revenue from 110,000 international game anglers. That is roughly twice the number that comes here. We foresee the revival of traditional international tourism angling which has declined in recent years. Given its potential to contribute to rural communities, that is an important part of the future.
Senator Dardis asked about rod anglers being allowed to sell fish. The issue is that if there is a potential surplus of 40,000 fish, largely in rivers and to some extent in the estuaries, how does one get access to it? In paragraph 3.2, we set out certain principles. We came to the logical conclusion that since anglers are an important part of the fishing community along the rivers, if one is going to get access to the surplus fish in those rivers, in some way one would have to introduce a different form of licence for anglers. That would entail a repeal of what was the situation up to 2001 when rod anglers could fish. All we have done is set out a series of principles to deal with that issue.
The other question concerned the voluntary buy-out and draft-net fishing. In the case of drift-net fishermen, no issue arises in that mixed stock fishing must end, as Mr. Malone and I have said repeatedly. This is not necessarily the case in respect of draft-net fishing. Circumstances will differ from river to river and from estuary to estuary.
Comment on this
That is the point exactly. If the numbers in the rivers are below the conservation level, how can there be a voluntary buy-out?
Comment on this
It does not have to be compulsory and there is a case for a choice. The fishermen can make a rational choice based on their assessment of whether they are better off taking the package or holding on and resuming operations when the rivers recover in two, three, five or ten years. We believe they are perfectly capable of making that choice. Given that the choice will vary in respect of different waters——
Comment on this
If they exercise the choice and take the money, what will be their capacity to return to operations later?
Comment on this
I compliment the three authors of the report. I acknowledge the work that went into it, regardless of whether I like the results. Mr. Keatinge mentioned the input of Bord Iascaigh Mhara regarding salmon in Dunmore East. He will be pleased to hear I have heard much good comment on this input and on how it has helped develop the product.
Deputy Broughan has outlined that the Labour Party is not in favour of a compulsory buy-out. Let us focus on the method of calculation of the hardship payment. Over a long period, but mostly in recent days, I have heard many reports that the fishermen and their families feel they have been under attack for a long time and that the recent decision is the final attack. The fishermen in my area have been making two major points. The fact that they are at the end of the line in a mixed stock fishery means there are fewer fish entering their area. All the calculations that have been made are relative to this.
For instance, after the tag system was introduced in 2001, the fairness of the calculation process was questioned. Everything that has occurred since then has been related to the baseline figure of the catch in 2001. The fishermen in my area say that because there were fewer fish in their area, they were catching fewer and that they therefore started from a position of weakness. It was not that they did not have the capacity to catch the fish but that the fish were not coming to them.
It was also put to me by the fishermen that the method of distribution of tags in the southern fisheries area does not replicate that which obtained in all other fisheries areas. The fishermen in the southern area alleged that the method of distribution in other fisheries board areas offered scope to fishermen to beef up their returns. Did the independent group come across evidence that would substantiate the view that the method of distribution of the tags could influence the entries in the logbooks at the end of the day? As the tags were used in some areas, more were issued, but in some areas the tags given out to the fishermen were divided among themselves, thus affording scope to beef up returns, which would have a bearing on the value of payments.
I was interested to hear that if the numbers of fish increase in the four rivers mentioned by Mr. Malone, drift-netting could be reintroduced. Would this not militate against the smaller operators? Mr. Keatinge stated that approximately half the people who are drift-netting at present will remain fishing. Half will not and will have to decommission their nets if they accept the hardship package. If they want to return, they will face an immediate problem because they will have to buy nets and reorganise.
From what I have heard I believe this issue has not been considered in depth. If fishermen can return to drift-netting in the estuaries, it should be introduced in such as way as not to militate against the smaller operators. In the drift-netting sector 80% of the fish are caught by 20% of the licenceholders. The smaller operators, the inshore men, will say they had a major problem competing with the larger boats because they could not fish when the weather was bad. This has a knock-on effect in terms of the calculation of the package on offer.
The compulsory concept is wrong as many fishermen will go voluntarily if the money is right. To kick out people who have felt under attack for a long time is not the best approach. There is a great need for an approach that will take into consideration the views of the fishermen concerned. In particular, there is a need to address the issues of concern to the people I represent. It is all right for Mr. White to say there is only one way to make calculations, that is, on the basis of catch, but if the system has militated against those in a particular area, this must surely be taken into account when offering the hardship package. The hardship experienced by those in the south east because operators in other areas had opportunities to catch stocks before they went to that region should be taken into consideration.
Comment on this
That comment needs to be addressed. A decision was made by the Government today and I want to plead the case of those in my area who will be forced out of the industry, but certainly not in less favourable conditions than other fishermen throughout the country. I do not disagree with my colleague Deputy Broughan and the Chairman's interpretation was never part of what I said.
Comment on this
I spent two hours speaking to two of the authors of the report last Tuesday and outlined to them the perspectives of the drift-net fishermen and anglers. I spent some hours on Wednesday offering my thoughts, albeit of a more political nature, to both the Minister and Minister of State. I have sat through two hours of this committee's deliberations and listened to the answers to many of the questions raised. However, I am disappointed that decisions were taken before this meeting took place. It is important for the Parliament to have a valuable input which can be taken on board and influence policy.
Senator Dardis said he felt sorry for the drift-net fishermen on account of the their hardship, which made it sound as if he still believed they would experience hardship. Salmon is being valued at €23 when the average salmon caught was worth €41 this year and last year according to those fishermen I spoke to, and Donegal salmon is not the most expensive. I did not want to see consideration of hardship after this decision. I favoured voluntary buy-out and set aside.
I have been through other changes in the fishing industry in the recent past and while I accept the environmental argument on stock decline, there are other factors influencing it. There are other ways of dealing with declining stocks. Fishermen in my constituency in Greencastle Harbour argued for many years about cod, pointing to areas where there was codling that could have been conserved. That could have developed and cod stocks would have been properly preserved. No one listened, however, and they could not do it unilaterally. If others could fish it, why would they not fish it?
If this were agriculture we would introduce the rural environment protection scheme, REPS, and set-aside grants, with money being invested in keeping people in the profession they know. We would not just abandon them. I was at a discussion of a wind farm on the Foyle and one of the selling points was that the salmon could swim round the bases of the wind turbines and become a tourist attraction. I have some scary thoughts about the expertise in that realm.
Did the buy-out work in Canada? What do I say to the 74 year old who has been working in this industry for 47 years and will now get a couple of thousand euro to leave it? Global warming was mentioned and I think there is a later run of salmon.
The number of tags a person received dictated the number of fish caught. We were given grants to improve or buy boats and we changed rules on nets, but now we are telling fishermen they cannot fish. Is the compensation, which is probably not enough for the loss of fish, really going to compensate people who are being told the boats they bought or upgraded are now no use to them and the nets cannot be used? Are we going to compensate the crew men and business people? There are those who say the business people use only farmed salmon.
I am from an area with the best salmon and there are those who say the Foyle area is not affected by this, but people see this as a starting point for what will happen in the Foyle. If the Foyle is closed down for drift-netting, the Government might not be in a position to offer compensation. If the Foyle Fisheries Commission does the same to drift-netting as we have done, who will provide for the buy-out there? We should not advocate this for the Foyle Fisheries Commission. I am far from being an advocate for the commission but I stood among the reed beds in the Foyle and I saw the development work it was doing there that we should have been doing.
The Minister said he agreed with Deputy Eamon Ryan that we should invest more money in research and protection than we did in the stock and fishermen. I disagree. I watched what happened in the Foyle fisheries and listened as other rivers begged us for protection and pollution measures and interventions but it did not happen. If this is how it must be, can BIM tell us it has succeeded in Greencastle and similar places, where the loss of the three Fs — fishing, farming and Fruit of the Loom — have caused severe problems? Has it been successful in other coastal communities?
Greencastle is a pertinent example because it has been hit by the days at sea directive and other European legislation. It will be on the fringes of this decision from a boat building and maintenance point of view and the local supermarkets and ancillary jobs will be affected. BIM has the experience of trying to put these coastal communities back together. We can look at what might happen in the future but I would like to look at the present where there are opportunities. Difficulties have been faced already.
The fishermen are full of ideas and they want to stay in fishing. It is not all doom and gloom if they get the help they need. If there is enough money, I am putting my bid in for my area. We have been through this with other species so we offer an example the Minister could examine. I am also putting in a bid because this does not affect one of the main rivers, the Foyle. If this happens on the Foyle, an idea that should not be promoted, will we ensure there is compensation?
The whole argument has been made. There are other influences. If something similar happened in agriculture, we would have looked at the causes and decided how to re-evaluate the problem before the death knell was sounded. We have jumped over interim solutions to go the whole hog. It reminds me of cod and other species. There is a problem but best practice should have let us see if there was an interim solution that could then be re-evaluated. This is a difficult day for my community.
Comment on this
I thank the committee and the independent salmon group for their patience. This has been a long day for everyone.
I congratulate the Minister and the Minister of State on their courage in commissioning this report. I am more interested in conserving jobs than anything else. The environment should be conserved but not at the expense of jobs. There must be a certain number of jobs lost here but is it not a fact that if the report had not been commissioned and its findings had not been implemented, the communities Deputy Keaveney and Deputy Ferris are talking about would die anyway? Salmon fishing is a goner if the report's findings are not implemented. The Minister and the Minister of State had the courage to try to solve the problem.
I sympathise with Deputy Keaveney and those in my area and that of the Minister of State. The community support scheme is vital and will require a RAPID-type approach. The local communities come up with schemes for RAPID funding. Mr. Padraic White might have some comments on replacement industries such as aquaculture. Might it be "aquaculture" or is that the wrong word to use? Something must be put in place sensitively and the €5 million must be used for real job creation whether fish processing or whatever. I would be interested in hearing Mr. White's view of this, given his experience with the IDA.
The sum of €30 million sounds large but I have met fishermen in Wexford who receive only €2,200. Their licences have been in their families for generations. They may not have been using them as much as they should have but that could be due to ill health or growing old. A commercial bank in Wexford recently conducted a survey on the sum of money children receive to celebrate their Confirmation. The result was an average of €1,700. The bank repeated the survey because it did not believe this could be correct.
For someone who holds his grandfather's licence, €2,200 is not a realistic figure. Will the Minister of State consider some minimum payment to people in that situation, which would exceed €2,200? I agree with Deputy Keaveney's point that if one offered that sum to a farmer the IFA would knock the place down rather than accept it. There is a case to be examined in this respect.
Comment on this
I am and I will be brief. I have been associated with the Oireachtas Joint Committee on European Affairs for 20 years during which I learned something about the angling industry and the fishing industry in general.
Some questions have not been satisfactorily answered. I compliment the working group and the report but it is a self-serving report. One can reach only one conclusion on reading it, as surely as the hanging follows the sentence.
I feel sad and sorry for the traditional net fishermen who featured on television over the past few months. A few talked about the work at length and how it had progressed over the years. They claimed there were other reasons for the problems. While I accept they would say that they made a reasonably good case. My colleague mentioned possible pollution of the riverbeds. We know about the transatlantic crossing and the wastage there but there must be another factor at work.
My constituency colleague, Senator Dardis, has left but he is a Moy fisherman. I was born in that catchment area and recall the debate about the cleaning of the river Moy. Prior to that thousands of acres were flooded every year through June and July and all through the winter. One could go boating on them. From high land one could see the flooding stretch for 20 or 30 miles. In places such as Castlebar and Turlough there was water on both sides of the road. When the area was drained and changed it was said the fish stocks would never return but that was wrong. They came back better than before. All the scientific evidence presented at the time was wrong.
I know the river Liffey quite well and years ago I asked why it could not be cleaned. It is filled with all kinds of debris such as branches that have collected and formed natural pools. If we continue in this way there will be no rivers because they will all be choked up. There should be a greater emphasis on cleaning the rivers. Otherwise, there will be no fishing at all, for tourists or anybody else.
There has been a catastrophic decline in salmon stocks and the graph on page 3 of the presentation is dramatic but there is something wrong with it that I cannot understand. Can someone explain how we know the stocks have degenerated to that level? According to the salmon fishermen along the rivers Suir and Nore, in 1925 they were reasonable, in 1945 they hit rock bottom, between 1945 and 1965 they rose and they increased dramatically in 1965. Suddenly between 1965 and 1975 they rose to an inexplicably high level. What was the scientific reason for that? There must be some explanation.
I have lived in rural areas all my life and feel that I have as good a knowledge as anybody else about the life of rivers and lakes and so on but I cannot understand how between 1975 and 1980 the stocks plummeted again. How are they counted? The discrepancy ranges from 1,400 to 200. Can some scientist explain this? I am sceptical about such a change in a short space of time. In 1981 the stock rose to 1,000 and by 2005 it fell to the bottom again. This is not conclusive evidence but it is feeding in to the decision on complete cessation. The science, however, does not stand up.
When did Canada and Norway ban drift-netting? Why is the North of Ireland left out of the map of Ireland? It is the first time I have seen the teddy bear without its head. I would like to see some reference to fishing in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
We are lucky it is because the rest of the map is chopped off. Tourism is marketed jointly between the North and the South.
The figures for the catches run from 1925 to 1990. Why do they stop there? Why do they not continue to 2005 as in the graph for the stock? Is this not a self-serving exercise? Between 1930 and 1965 the graph rose and fell slightly in respect of drift-netting but it remained within one band. At the same time rod fishing continued along a narrow band on the bottom without any dramatic change one way or the other. Is it expected that the band will suddenly go skywards? I do not think it will. There is no evidence to show what will happen there.
Drift-netting catches shot up suddenly in 1969 or 1970 and remained there until 1980 then started to fall again, the theory being that there were no more fish. Reference is made to the EU habitats directive with which we must comply. If we comply to the same extent on the agricultural issues as on this one we will have the same debate on agriculture five years from now. The scene is already set. This is the death knell for the fishing industry.
People in coastal towns get an emotional return as well as an economic living from fishing. I do not agree with those who disobey the law but there are genuine people who are helpful to the ecological system. Sadly, there are signs of serious problems. It is very well for us to say the people in coastal areas have many other things to do. That is like eating cake which Marie Antoinette was very good at. We know what happened to her.
For example, a year ago there was a debate on Common Agricultural Policy reform and the sugar beet industry subsequently went down the tubes because it was not compatible with European Union law. It was claimed all subsidies were to be withdrawn but the French sugar industry did not go down the tubes. In Australia, farm supports have been reintroduced. These are contrasts to our slavish compliance with EU directives. As for the bureaucrats in Brussels standing for election, as John Wayne said, "That'll be the day". Unless we recognise that we have a role to play and we need to elbow the people we are dealing with in Brussels, we will be flushed down the river. If we do not, people will be coming to look at how we live in our natural habitat.
Comment on this
This year the Department, the Marine Institute and the fisheries boards have operated a salmon gradation system with the national parks and wildlife service. The committee's recommendation was taken on board. The tagging system was introduced in 2001 but there were some teething problems at the beginning. District committees were established comprising fishermen and fisheries boards. The allocation of tags was the fishermen's call. It operated well and there were no complaints about it.
Deputy Keaveney raised the issue of funding. There is a €25 million hardship fund and the €5 million coastal communities fund. The latter will be worked through the Department of Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs through Leader, RAPID and CLÁR programmes. Most of this funding will be going to the west. Up to €1.5 million a year will be allocated for river rehabilitation and €4 million for extra enforcement. There is no point in implementing the regime proposed by the three wise men unless we increase the numbers involved in enforcement. Additional funding of €25 million for the fisheries boards will bring the total budget to €60 million.
Deputy Tony Dempsey, like me, lives on the banks of the River Slaney and we are both aware of the emotive issues between anglers and drift-net men. The reality is that we have a third of the salmon catch that we had 20 years ago. That is why Mr. White's committee was established to examine the scientific figures for 2007. It was claimed there was much interference from the Department and the Ministers when the three wise men were compiling their report. I met them when their committee was first established and I have not seen them since. Their report is independent and I thank them for it.
Comment on this
With regard to the Foyle, the habitats directive will apply to the Foyle drift net fishery where it captures mixed stocks of salmon and other river catchments do not meet conservation limits.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Shea raised the method of calculation. It is a fair argument that further along the chain there could be more disadvantage. Any compensation or alleviating hardship method must relate to the income generated and the volume of fish caught. In 2001 in Waterford, the catch by drift netters was three times the figure in 2005. I feel we are helping the people involved by taking a historic approach. It is those areas that stand to benefit most from the measures.
When one considers the rivers in this region, they are all below their conservation limit. The only way the stock will recover is if salmon come back to spawn in numbers. Deputy Durkan is correct in saying that there are a range of issues — some in and some out of our control — such as water pollution, the quality of the rivers and their maintenance.
Comment on this
A considerable effort is taking place regarding the enhancement of water quality. Water quality is measured by the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA. The figures from the EPA show it is improving. A series of measures have been introduced.
Comment on this
I have been here the same time and I have other responsibilities just as well as the Chairman has.
Comment on this
I am well aware of the responsibilities of the Chair so I do not need a lecture about it. I asked a question and it can be answered or we can have a row about it.
Comment on this
Deputy Durkan can come in at the end when the delegation has finished its presentation.
Comment on this
We are back in public session. I ask that Mr. Malone, Mr. White and Mr. Keatinge address the Chair when responding to questions. If I need to take any interjection from a member, I will allow it. The witnesses need not address members directly.
Comment on this
It is just that certain tiny matters have arisen that we feel could be teased out a little more.
Comment on this
I am in no hurry, Deputy. I have until tomorrow evening, as I said to members last week when we were going through a Bill. We will follow the rules and Standing Orders.
Comment on this
I am the current arbiter of Standing Orders. Mr. Malone had the floor and was answering some of the questions that the four members had raised.
Comment on this
It might be best if I start at the beginning again. The first question raised by Deputy O'Shea concerned the method of calculation and the point at which there might be difficulties for people in the eastern part of the country as one moves around the coast and further down the run of the salmon. That argument can be made, but the basis of our approach, which we feel was fair, was that it related to the volume of fish caught. We took a five-year period, and my specific point regarding Waterford, in which Deputy O'Shea is clearly interested, is that if one goes back to 2001, one sees that the drift-net catch was three times the 2005 level. Our strong argument is that, by taking a five-year average, we were giving everyone——
Comment on this
I do not believe that the same drop in fish numbers, down by as much as a third, would be reflected in other areas. The stock did not stand at a third for too many of them.
Comment on this
I can show the Deputy the figures for Cork, which were down by a third. I accept that Kerry is different, but one must relate it in some way to a loss of income.
Comment on this
Did the independent salmon group give any consideration to going further back, for example, seven or ten years?
Comment on this
We examined various options, but the point was that one had to take some sort of period. I made the point that in schemes of which I have previous experience one took a three-year average, since that allows a good year, a bad one and an average one. We went further, taking five years. We took the average and multiplied by six, so it was something to which we gave a fair amount of consideration. We saw it as a very important element of our work and feel that we produced a fair and reasonable solution. Clearly, one has any number of options if one goes back ten or 20 years, but going back five years was a reasonable approach that achieved a fair outcome for everyone.
The other point that is important to bear in mind is that we had a reference period. The tagging system started then, and if one went back beyond that, one was into slightly more difficult territory.
The method of distribution of tags has been dealt with by the Minister of State, Deputy Browne.
Comment on this
When the group was compiling the report, did anything come to its notice that might have caused it concern regarding how tags were distributed?
Comment on this
No. No concern was ever expressed regarding any issue in that regard.
Comment on this
What was said as regards tags? I have been informed that one can buy ten tags in one district and that there is no centralised data recording system. The same fisherman can go to a different area and buy ten more tags without the authorities being aware that he already had used ten tags previously on a different river. There is widespread abuse of the tag system.
Comment on this
Mr. Malone, without interruption, please. I know the Deputy was seeking clarification.
Comment on this
This point was brought to our attention. As regards angling tags, we are recommending in the report a centralised data system. We have taken that point on board.
Comment on this
On that point, since we are talking about conservation, will the centralised computer technology be in place in the current year, from January?
Comment on this
Mr. Malone might consider that question, and we shall come back to it. We shall move to the answers to the other questions, or I shall be in trouble with the members. We shall hear Mr. Malone without interruption. I appreciate that these interjections are intended to elicit more information based on the questions that were asked.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Shea asked about the return to drift-netting in estuaries if individual rivers exceed their conservation limits. The reality indicates that there will not be a return to drift-netting. If one looks in particular at the rivers in areas Deputy O'Shea is interested in, the conservation limits and the situation that prevails there at the moment, it will be a serious challenge to achieve sustained recovery in all of them. That was an important point in our approach to drift-netting. I explained earlier the difficulty of mixed stock fishing. Our approach was also coloured in this regard when it comes to draft-netting. This normally takes place at estuaries and is a different type of fishing to drift-netting, as I am sure the members are aware.
Our decision to leave some options for the draft-netting community was based on the fact that if people felt that they were on a river which was above its sustainable limit or there was a fairly real prospect it would be, in the short-term, then they might want to continue drift-netting. That was explained——
Comment on this
On that very point, and I promise not to interject again, Mr. Malone has referred to drift-netting on the river. Is that what he meant?
Comment on this
Am I right in my interpretation of this report, that drift-netting can continue on the River Blackwater because it is above its conservation limit?
Comment on this
My understanding today from the Minister was that drift-netting was out, but draft-netting was allowed. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Despite the fact that it is above its conservation limit, drift-netting is still banned on the River Blackwater? That is contrary to what this——-
Comment on this
We are buying out all the drift-netting. We have gone through that four or five times today.
Comment on this
I am perfectly prepared to move quickly, but in fairness——
Comment on this
The question was raised about the value of a licence by a number of Deputies. A licence is something that is given by the Minister, as part of the regulatory framework. We felt it was equitable, however, that even people who caught no fish should be given six times the value of the licence. We feel, bearing in mind that there was no fishing activity, that this is a generous proposition.
Deputy Keaveney raised the question as to the value of salmon at today's prices. When we were doing the calculations over the five-year period — which showed a series of values along the line — we included the value she mentioned, €45, in the calculation for 2005.
Comment on this
That is where one runs into trouble. If one takes that value, one then multiplies it by the number of fish caught in 2005, which is substantially less than what was caught in the earlier years. The overall catch halved in the five-year period——
Comment on this
We discussed before the point made by Deputy Keaveney and others the preference for a voluntary scheme. We have explained our views on that and there is not much point in going through it again. We were aware of buy-out schemes in other countries such as Norway, Canada and Scotland and we acquainted ourselves with what was happening internationally.
Comment on this
I shall ask Dr. Ó Maoileidigh to elaborate on that, but perhaps I can get through my series of questions first. As regards whether nets will be decommissioned, the short answer is "Yes". If there is a buy-out scheme, then in the interest of the protection of public money, some degree of clarity or certainty is required to ensure what is being bought out actually happens.
Comment on this
Nets will be decommissioned — I believe that is the term.
Comment on this
Does decommissioning mean taken out of use or is it a matter of being paid for having taken equipment out of use?
Comment on this
Deputy Keaveney should be aware that I am trying to get to the bottom of this matter as the room must be vacated.
Comment on this
I know, but I asked whether there would be money for boats and nets and that is all.
Comment on this
I am trying to get the answer. Will Mr. Malone continue, without interruption, please?
Comment on this
What is happening means that drift-netting and drift-net licences will be no more. The licence is the statutory instrument in that regard.
Comment on this
On that specific question, this report deals with salmon drift-netting. Those registered as licensed fishermen are obviously not required to decommission their boats. The salmon nets will no longer be of use to them.
Comment on this
That is not true. They are members of the inshore fisheries sector. They fish crab and lobster for ten months of the year. The challenge for us is to manage the other two months, June and July, and provide alternative opportunities that do not necessitate an unnecessary increase in crab, lobster, shrimp and so on, the other stock that they already pursue. Out of the 877, some 350 are inshore registered fishermen. The remainder have boats. There is nothing in the report which suggests they have to dismantle, throw away or burn those boats. That has nothing to do with this. They can keep the boats for recreational purposes, but the 350 registered inshore fishermen, hopefully, will continue to operate in that sector and BIM will continue to work with them.
Comment on this
To complete the answer, currently the decommissioning scheme that is available through the Department applies to vessels over 18 m. This is on foot of the Padraic White report from last year. Vessels under 18 m. will be dealt with in the Noel Cawley review, which will be reporting in due course to the Minister. It is exploring whether there is a need for a vessel decommissioning scheme as distinct from a salmon net issue, which is completely separate. In the event that there is a decommissioning scheme for vessels under 18 m., which would apply throughout the inshore sector, that would be in addition to any measures being discussed here. It is an entirely separate matter.
Comment on this
I must answer the question about the effects of the measures that stopped the nets in Canada. Like Ireland, Canada has a number of different sea-fishing areas such as Quebec, Labrador, Newfoundland, the inner Bay of Fundy and so on. There are different areas with different biology. Not all of them instantly met their conservation limits and it will be similar here. In most of those areas they stopped the further decline of salmon stocks and that is what we will do in many areas here. Since they closed their fisheries in 1990, they have not seen what they would have liked to see, but it could have been worse.
Comment on this
Dr. Ó Maoileidigh will comment on the more scientific aspects. The first question Deputy Durkan asked was about the zig-zag effect on the graph. The same thought occurred to me when I looked at it for the first time. I wondered whether it was cyclical because cycles can occur. The answer that convinced me was that this was gone well beyond the cycle. I am not a scientist, but if there was a cyclical dimension, the graph would have turned a long time ago.
The intensity of drift-netting definitely increased in the 1970s when there were more licences. The style of drift-netting also changed in the 1970s with the introduction of monofilament nets.
Comment on this
Did the Canadians have the same peak that we had?
There is a Dáil vote now. On behalf of the Labour Party, I thank the three wise men for their efforts on this interesting and emotional subject.
Comment on this
Deputy Durkan made the point that there were other factors and other issues, and we accept that fully.
Comment on this
Why have we not acted on those other issues? Why was the cleaning and scouring of rivers for spawning beds not regarded as a priority alongside this?
Comment on this
We can only deal in the report with what we found when we began our work earlier this year. We set out clearly our vision for the future, which is the totality of individual river management. We accept the points made by Deputy Durkan about the spawning beds, the quality of the water, the management of the individual river and the counters. We are hopefully entering a new era and this will raise huge challenges for the regional fisheries boards.
Comment on this
There is a contradiction in the two graphs. One of the graphs shows the fish stocks going up and down until 2005. At some stages they went as low as they are now. That is incontrovertible. They zig-zagged from 1925 until 1965 and then went up rapidly. They then went down towards the bottom, went up again and now they are on the bottom again. The other graph deals with catches. The witnesses correctly state that drift-netting went up dramatically in the 1970s, as did the tonnage. However, in 1980 it went back down again. There is a contradiction in the two graphs and whatever scientific evidence exists, the two graphs should be coterminous as they should have gone to either 1990 or 2005 in both cases. We could then measure them accurately against one another. It is unfair to present them to us in their current format.
Comment on this
The recent data available to the group come from the Central Fisheries Board and they are the data we see on page 43 and figure 7.2, which starts from the 1970s. In our research, we found a paper from 1983 which is the first reference in the reference section. It is a submission from the sectoral consultative committee on the fishing industry. It provided catch data in the period from 1926 until 1980. We could have done what we did on page 9, which is to blend the two graphs but show them in different colours to indicate their different data series. We presented them separately on page 42 and page 43, but figure 7.1 and figure 7.2 are continuous, which means we can read one after the other.
Comment on this
We will continue because if we stop we will be here until 8 p.m. I apologise to the clerk, his staff and the editorial staff for the lateness of the meeting. For completeness, we must have the response to the four sets of questions. Has Mr. Malone completed them?
Comment on this
Deputy Tony Dempsey addressed one question to me about the community support scheme. He asked for my thoughts, given my background in IDA Ireland. We advocate that this should be implemented in a liberal and creative fashion. We see this as an opportunity for the communities affected to develop constructive ideas. There are two different kinds of promoters. The first kind are groups of ex-fishermen who could come together and form a co-operative. The other group would be an entrepreneurial community which could see a business opportunity and the merit in having a significant workforce from the fishing community. We were all very impressed with our visit to Dingle and Ballydavid.
The case was made to us that drift-netters in many areas are gaeilgeóirí and are part of the fabric of their community. If there are any ideas, there should be some mechanism to help them. There will be a surplus of fish in the south west and the west and if enterprises were formed that met these criteria, one could envisage the possibility of access to that surplus by those enterprises. That is just one of a number of possibilities. The overriding view of our group is that this should be operated in a positive, creative and liberal way, in response to proposals from the communities.
Comment on this
I have not asked any question today, other than by way of clarification. Is section 3.2 a proposal that rod-caught fish be sold to the commercial processing sector? I am not sure if this is workable. The commercial processing sector, especially the smoking sector, want sea-caught fish. It has been made clear by all leading smokers that it was not acceptable, for reasons of food safety, to deal with freshwater fish. Mr. Peter Dunn of the Irish Fish Processors and Exporters Association stated to this committee on 5 April 2005:
My company had a very serious incident involving a large consignment of draft-net fish that had to be returned due to water quality problems. A certain percentage of the fish were musty. It is reflective of the problem of water quality that must be addressed in the context of the debate on wild salmon. Our only source of the right type of fish for smoking is drift-netting. If drift-netting were abolished, as some people would like, it would mean the end of the smoked salmon business, which would not be the right course to adopt.
For the record, did the independent salmon group read the entire transcripts of the hearings the committee undertook in April 2005? I have a copy of the transcripts with me. During those hearings Mr. Dunn told the committee: "Our only source of the right type of fish for smoking is drift-netting. If drift-netting were abolished ... it would mean the end of the smoked salmon business". The independent salmon group recommended that the Government ban commercial drift-net fishing and give the resources to rod anglers who would then be able to sell salmon. It is suggesting one fishery be stopped and handed over to another. The processor states the only source of the right type of fish for smoking is drift-net fishing.
Did individual members of the consultative group — I will not call the group anything other than the independent consultative group; I am not sure from where the other term came — read the transcript of the committee meeting of 5 April 2005? Does the group attach significance to what the processors have stated? Does it think it is okay to hand over the traditional rights of the netman to the rodman? Does it consider it in the public good to use Exchequer funds to transfer the resource from the net fisherman to the rod angler in this case?
Comment on this
We read the transcripts of meetings of this committee and we all have a copy of the report, to which we paid considerable attention in the course of our deliberations. We support the setting up of a mechanism involving the range of stakeholders, including fish processors, hotels, restaurants and various interest groups.
It is not a question of transferring free gratis a resource from drift-net fishermen to any other group. What we have clearly stated in the principles set out in paragraph 3.2 is that the surplus should be used for the public good and that those who gain access to it should pay for it. It comes down to a market choice. If the processors regard the fish caught by draft net as inferior, that is their choice. However, my understanding is that draft-net fishermen currently supply fish to the various outlets, including——
Comment on this
Yes, that would be the case.
With regard to a point touched on by the Chairman, the effect on the salmon is influenced by the quality of the environment. A central part of our report is that equal attention should be paid to improving the habitat, water quality and so forth. However, ultimately, the structure we have created will mean that if the stakeholders want the fish, they will have to pay for access to them in some way. If the fish processors regard fish caught by rod angling as unacceptable, that is their choice.
Comment on this
Water quality has been mentioned a number of times at this meeting. It is an important issue if we are to preserve the fish smoking industry.
I thank the group for attending. The lesson I have learned from this meeting — I also learned it before we produced our report — is that unless we stop overfishing, we are facing a sunset industry. This applies to the fisheries of the world, not just in Ireland. A major food resource could be lost unless all countries together introduce conservation measures.
I thank the members of the independent salmon group; the Minister, Deputy Noel Dempsey, and the Minister of State, Deputy Browne, for attending. I particularly thank the Minister of State for taking on board this issue when he took office. He embraced the report of the committee and set up the three-person independent salmon group to do what we recommended, namely, to formulate a policy with a number of recommendations. On behalf of the committee, I record our appreciation of the Minister of State's efforts.
The meeting was a little boisterous but that will happen on occasion as members try to get their points across. I understand this and I am well able to cope. Unless I get the nod from above to resign from the Chair, or the nod from above to go up above, I will be in the Chair until the 29th Dáil adjourns. I call the Vice Chairman, Deputy Perry.
Comment on this
I compliment the Chairman on doing an excellent job. He is well able to deal with boisterous behaviour. I also compliment the independent salmon group which received a clear mandate which did not allow for any deviation. It has done an excellent job under its terms of reference and there was no ambiguity about what had to be done.
I know of Mr. White's other report on the south east and have no doubt that all of us will agree that other coastal communities, whether in Donegal, the south west or the regions, also need help. We know of Mr. White's experience with the IDA. The only concern I have with the €5 million fund is that it could be dispersed among funders. It is a pity the fund was not ring-fenced and benchmarked with respect to the effectiveness of its implementation. If the €5 million is dispersed among four or five semi-State bodies, it could become lost, which is an issue Mr. White might consider. Deputy Tony Dempsey referred to community employment schemes and how a scheme could be initiated for designated coastal communities, which might provide a better return for the money provided.
For every action there will be a reaction. There is a huge responsibility with regard to what happens from this point. I have concerns, given the many reports involved and the issues which arise with regard to the provision of funding. I am concerned that despite 21st century technology, we cannot embrace a comprehensive tagging system for anglers that would clearly identify them with a PIN number and prevent wide-scale abuse. If we are concerned about the conservation of salmon stocks and that some people are taking a big hit, it is important that we have the necessary technology in place. I am astonished this is not happening. If we intend to spend €30 million, what is another €1 million or €2 million to install a system that would deal with the control systems required across the board? It does not make sense that one segment has to pay the ultimate price.
Time will tell how effective this will be but at least a decision has been made. I will pursue the other obligations with regard to the Farrell Grant Sparks report on inland fisheries and the Central Fisheries Board. There is much work to be done to deliver this policy. I intend to focus the Fine Gael position on how funding will be spent on aquaculture and the development of inland waterways, lakes and rivers. This is only the beginning.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy who is a well respected member of the committee and, as Vice Chairman, has contributed greatly to its work.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman and his officials for staying with the programme all afternoon. This is an emotive issue and I am aware that all members, especially the Opposition spokespersons, were eager to make a contribution. They did so in a forthright fashion. It is up to us in the Department to ensure their suggestions are implemented and enforced. Like Deputy Perry, I hope the €5 million to which he referred will be ring-fenced for the benefit of coastal communities.
The Department is working on the tagging system. Angling, tagging and licensing are done through dealers and fisheries boards so it will take time and effort to ensure all the processes are computerised.
I thank Dr. Ó Maoileidigh, Mr. Keatinge, Mr. White, Mr. Malone and Professor Tom Collins, who was unable to attend the meeting, for their work and commitment over many months. We asked them to do a job independently and we did not interfere or hound them every day or week. I thank them for their report. The coming days and weeks will be difficult, but the decision has been made by the Government and everybody must live with that.