General Scheme of the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025: Discussion (Resumed)
Former Defence Forces officers backed the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025, especially the proposed new overseas taskings for evacuation, counter-narcotics and diplomatic protection, and the increase in the troop threshold for government-approved deployments from 12 to 50. They argued that the triple lock weakens Irish sovereignty, can block timely humanitarian and peacekeeping responses, and leaves Ireland hostage to Security Council vetoes. Several witnesses said future deployments may need to rely more on regional bodies such as the EU, OSCE or African Union, though they acknowledged a UN Security Council mandate remains preferable. Some also supported tighter safeguards, including Attorney General advice, committee scrutiny and legal protections for suspensions, while stressing commanders will obey only lawful orders.
Contributions 127–264 of 264. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
All I can say is that the legislation the committee is discussing here today has the Department's footprints on it, so I am wondering why it has put the figure of 50 down in this legislation if what Senator Clonan has said is the case. I am surprised by the disconnect between the requirement to put 50 into the Bill and Senator Clonan's assertion that he has been told otherwise.
Comment on this
I am equally surprised by it. In fact, I would have raised it to 120. The number of 50 seems quite arbitrary.
Comment on this
It is very important so that Irish people understand our international service as peacekeeping, whether that be with the UN, the EU or Partnership for Peace. It is becoming clear to me that in the absence of a UN Security Council resolution the vast majority of future operations will be peace enforcement, which is quite a different thing-----
Comment on this
-----and under international command. That is a very significant-----
Comment on this
Every mission is under international command except for the Irish personnel. The actual unit is commanded by Irish-----
Comment on this
But if they are in location and part of a broader formation they are de facto under a higher command. They cannot operate in-----
Comment on this
The force commander can task but the Irish Defence Forces person who has command and control determines how that is done in line with our Constitution and in line with-----
Comment on this
On that word "task", it is the function of command to task. That is the operational environment.
Comment on this
A huge thank you to Major General O'Brien, Major General Brennan, Colonel Doyle and Dr. Berry for their time here today. It is incredible to think that, making a quick calculation, we have close on 150 years of military experience on the other side of the room today. It is wonderful to have that depth of experience to help inform us and to help us understand what is being put before us as part of the proposed defence (amendment) Bill 2025.
I would like to talk about professionalism. Professionalism in the Irish Defence Forces is mentioned in several places in the witnesses' statements. In particular, Colonel Doyle spoke of the many compliments he received from ambassadors and diplomats when he was in the United Nations HQ in New York on the professionalism and humanity of Irish UN peacekeepers. Professionalism is not something that just occurs naturally, it is something that has to be within the system of the Defence Forces. I would like to look at the level of safeguarding and the level of checks and balances within the Defence Forces and why we are calling for more scrutiny in that regard if we are getting rid of the triple lock, which is the requirement for the Irish State to ask permission from the US, the UK, France, Russia and China. Why do we have to ask them where to send our troops when we have the level of professionalism which no doubt we have within the Defence Forces?
People listening to this debate at home and the people I meet on the street are concerned about our young people. They are concerned that if we get rid of the UN mandate, the third part of our triple lock, we would be sending our young men and women soldiers abroad to fight. There is mention of war fighting. Is there a difference between a professional military peacekeeper or peace enforcer and a professional soldier?
Comment on this
Let us consider the larger countries that have large armies. We have often said that if some of those go abroad, they have to unlearn combat and they have to learn about peace. The only time Irish troops have gone abroad is for peace and that is why we have been doing it continuously since 1948 when we went to Lebanon. It is why we are continuing to do it. We have a very good reputation. We are very well trained. Part of my job as Chief of Staff was to look at the standards of armies that were sending battalions to various peacekeeping missions. We would send a team of United Nations officers from New York to that country to have a look at the standard of their armies. Were they well equipped? Were they well trained? Were they aware of what peacekeeping was about? In many circumstances the United Nations would have preferred to have gone with another country that was better trained, better equipped and better able to do the job. When the Security Council or the United Nations looks for 10,000 troops, for example, they go to the member states - General O'Brien has talked about the 190-plus countries that are members - and they look for a contribution for military forces to go out on the ground. For the period I was in New York we never got the requisite number of professional, qualified troops to fulfil the mission. If the Security Council said it wanted 10,000 troops, it never got the full 10,000. That is because some of the standards of various armies differ but we in Ireland have the advantage that we only know about peacekeeping and we are good at it.
Comment on this
I will add to that. I will share my experience of Kosovo. I was a company commander in a battle group commanded by a Finnish colonel. We were professional soldiers and the Finnish and Swedish contingent were reservists.
I found the workload for my troops increased steadily month by month because the battlegroup commander was more confident in the ability of the Irish troops, who were professional soldiers, to deliver the objectives he required, while the Finnish troops, although good people, did not have the professional training our people had. Our workload increased accordingly.
Comment on this
To echo some of my colleagues' views, professionalism is about standards. As I said before, the ultimate safeguard that had not been mentioned until today is the standard of professionalism in the Defence Forces. That is a layer of safeguarding. We have a judge advocate general branch, which advises the Chief of Staff. As my colleagues also mentioned, military advice is an excellent safeguard.
As for whether, if we move away and interact with other organisations, we will be conducting warfighting, I would say absolutely not. The OSCE, for instance, is an unarmed monitor force. That is even below the threshold of the UN. The UN generally deploys with weapons, whereas the OCSE does not. There is also a complete difference between peace enforcement and warfighting. One is about separation of parties, using minimum force if necessary, and the other is about defeating an enemy and seizing its capital city. Any kind of comparison between those two things is completely misinformed.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Berry. We are talking about the military advice and the quality of that military advice was mentioned previously. While I know it has not happened to date, I wish to talk about a hypothetical situation, because such situations are often discussed here. Hypothetically, we could have gone to Iraq. Hypothetically, if we did not have the triple lock and a mission was proposed, but if the military advice was against taking part in it because it was not right for us at that moment and the Minister or the Department chose not to listen to that advice, could the military commanders be vocal about that?
Comment on this
I was in that space for four years, providing military advice to the Minister. Our job is a conductive operation for the Defence Forces. In doing that role, my job was to provide military advice. It was up to the Minister to decide whether the military advice was acceptable.
For example, when we redeployed to the Golan Heights after having had to leave due to the 2013 civil war, military advice was provided. Supplementary advice had to be provided to the Minister before he could make a final decision on approximately four or five different occasions. There can be to-ing and fro-ing. While advice is given to the Minister and the Department, it is ultimately the decision of the Minister and the Government at the end of the day.
Comment on this
In New York, when we gave military advice, they never went against it. If they went against the advice, we would have identified risks and explained the reasons we did not want them to go to a certain place or do a certain thing or whatever. We would then, after discussions, mitigate those risks.
Comment on this
I thank all of the witnesses for their contributions and presentations this morning. It is clear a significant amount of military experience is present in the room. While we have heard previously from academics, the practitioners of a field are probably more important than the academics. A lot of weight should be given to what the witnesses have said and the evidence they have given to the committee this morning.
I have a number of questions, which are broadly framed. Professor Tonra mentioned a legal review being part of an additional safeguard against the deployment of troops. One of the questions I have in this regard relates to emergency situations where Irish citizens need to be removed, such as in Kabul. Would a legal review be a practical proposition in such circumstances where there is an urgency to get citizens rescued, for example?
Comment on this
I can come in on that. The legal review Professor Tonra is proposing relates only to peacekeeping and peace enforcement missions. It has nothing to do with sovereign, national operations. Even as the law stands, there are eight exemptions to the triple lock. This legislation proposes three additional exemptions, namely, evacuation operations, counter-narcotic operations and security operations and close protection for our embassies overseas. The legal review Professor Tonra is proposing relates only to international peacekeeping operations. It does not concern sovereign, national Defence Forces operations. It would not apply, if that answers the Deputy's question.
Comment on this
Some of the narrative in respect of what is proposed claims our neutrality and triple lock will be removed and that, accordingly, young Irish women and men will be engaged in imperialist combat around the world. What do the witnesses have to say about that?
Comment on this
Dr. Brennan has a lot of experience interacting with both the UN and the Government. Does he trust that no Irish Government would run headlong into such a scenario?
Comment on this
While I know the other Deputy did not agree with me, I gave the example that since 1958, there have been more than 120 conflicts and the Government has been very careful about where it deployed. I am talking about the period between 1958 and 2002, when the triple lock came into force. There were approximately 120 conflicts, both interstate and intrastate. The Government never made any kneejerk reaction during that time in getting involved in any kind of conflict. The conflict in the Balkans in the nineties is one such example. I still make the point that a mature Government would continue to exercise constraint in this regard.
This comes back to the military advice and the maturity of the military commanders who bring that advice to the Government. It is always based on risk and the danger to the troops involved, as well as the environment they are going into and whether we have the capability to deliver the outcomes that may be required. These are all considerations. The Deputy’s fears are not well founded. That is my opinion.
Comment on this
I understand, but the Deputy is expressing those fears on behalf of others.
Comment on this
Yes. Neutrality has been part of our core. It is one of those things that gives us international appeal for our peacekeeping troops. This is something that has been said. If we found some kind of legal wording to amend the Constitution to add in a wording that prevented us from becoming aligned to military alliances other than the UN, such as NATO – there seems to be a lot of hostility from the pro-neutrality side in respect of NATO in particular - would that hamper our international ability to deploy peacekeeping troops?
Comment on this
It probably would affect us in the context of the availability and number of troops. We have a small Army and we are doing all sorts of jobs all over the place. If a decision is made, however, you just go with it. Other than that, it is quite logical to me.
Comment on this
I hang out with different people but no one I know is concerned about neutrality being disrupted because of potentially taking away the triple lock. Everyone who has listened to the debates in recent weeks will be reassured of that. To inform the committee, in UN headquarters no one is aware or cares that Ireland is neutral. How Ireland operates and whether it will go on a mission is Ireland's decision. In fact, it is not solely Ireland's decision, but it is of no consequence.
Comment on this
Like my colleagues, I welcome the four witnesses. I thank them for their insightful contributions. As Deputy Callaghan has pointed out, we have 150 years of military experience in this room. I thank the witnesses most sincerely.
I hope I can be forgiven for welcoming especially former Deputy, Dr. Cathal Berry. He was an excellent Member of the Dáil and I had the honour of serving with him for five years on the Joint Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defence. I do not know if a better representative of the armed forces exists and it is good to see him. We are not going to keep him much longer from opening the patio doors and jumping into the sea I can see behind him.
Comment on this
The UNIFIL mission in Lebanon is due to expire on 31 August of this year. As has been pointed out, if that mandate is not renewed then we will have no option but to leave that mission. I believe that a phased withdrawal would be terribly regrettable. I agree with the witnesses that it is an incentive for the majority of young people who join the Defence Forces an opportunity to serve overseas. Not alone is it the experience that the incentive is about, it is an opportunity for young men and women to make an extra few pounds to progress themselves in life and we should not take our eye off that ball either.
On the mandate, 345 Irish troops serve in Lebanon at the moment out of a force of approximately 10,500 troops. Is that correct?
Comment on this
As I remember, 10,500 troops is the establishment figure that we are allowed to have but the number is more like 7,500 troops at the moment.
Comment on this
The strength of the force at the moment is under 8,000.
Comment on this
What is the total number of troops for the UNIFIL mission in Lebanon?
Comment on this
Is the Senator talking about the Irish context?
Comment on this
No. What is the total combined number of troops who come from dozens of countries?
Comment on this
It is 10,000 international troops from 40 different countries.
Comment on this
Yes, that was my understanding. So Ireland's contribution to that at present is 345 troops and, as has been said, there would have to be a phased withdrawal of those troops from the mission.
Comment on this
That would be terribly regrettable. All four witnesses have been commanding officers. Have they ever felt hampered by the absence of any policy on suspension to date? All four can comment on that.
Comment on this
Suspension as provided for in the Bill. As Dr. Berry said in his opening statement, "Turning to human resource matters, I welcome the Bill’s proposal to provide powers of suspension to the Chief of Staff under certain circumstances." Has there been any direct policy on suspension to date and what were the guidelines?
Comment on this
Is the Senator is talking about Part 4 of the general scheme?
Comment on this
I have some experience on this and I have been a practitioner of human resource management, HRM, in the Defence Forces, strictly in my role. Very briefly, all members of the Defence Forces are governed by the Defence Act and the Defence Forces regulations. That is our gospel. That is what commanders use. Obviously people thought that the Chief of Staff had the power of suspension a number of months ago. The Chief of Staff does not have that. It is a positive step that the provision will now be introduced because it will put the Chief of Staff on a par with the Garda Commissioner and he can suspend people from duty. There are various reasons I will not go into that but the provision is a positive step.
To answer the Senator's question, this is not in vogue at the moment. Until such time as the Bill is passed, the Chief of Staff does not have the power to suspend people as of now.
Comment on this
I can talk about my experience of one person who was found to have failed a random drug test. All I could do was make sure that that person did not carry a weapon for the year that it took me to discharge him because of the lengths of appeals lodged by that person. He got every opportunity and due process took a year.
While we found work that he could do - there is always work for unarmed people - he also put a burden on the people who were there to do his work as well.
Comment on this
Ms O'Brien felt hampered by the fact that she could not take things further.
Comment on this
I do not know if the drug issue would have come under this and due process must be observed. As Dr. Berry has mentioned, it is very important that there is due process. With a drug issue, there are varying degrees of discipline issues that have regard to that.
Comment on this
To answer the specific question, the Defence Forces have an excellent culture and value system. Like any human organisation, there are isolated cases and there is a very small number of people who think those values and culture does not apply to them. It is very important, as the major general said, that the same powers given to the Garda Commissioner are also given to the Chief of Staff so that if we come across an isolated case, the legislation is very specific. This must be for very serious cases that would involve imprisonment of up to five years. We are talking about very serious cases where it is in the national interest, the public interest and the interest of the Defence Forces that this person be suspended on full pay pending the outcome of any trial. I think that is the appropriate way of doing business. The key word I would use here is "balance". The regulations have yet to be produced and will be once the primary legislation is signed off on. The regulations have to be very careful from well-being and proportionality points of view. I welcome the principle and look forward to seeing the regulations in due course.
Comment on this
All members who have been present in the room have spoken and I thank them for their contributions. I will now give five minutes to our non-member, Senator Higgins.
Comment on this
Is it possible for me to make a brief comment before the non-members, even for two minutes?
Comment on this
The non-member has been here a long time.
Comment on this
I am taking a list for short questions. On that list I have Senator Craughwell and Senator Clonan.
Comment on this
Like others, I thank the witnesses. I want to pick up on a couple of the points that have come in. The first one is an apples and oranges scenario as the issue is mixed up a little bit. On Deputy Smith's point, the key point is that it is not a question of whether a General Assembly resolution is binding. The question is whether a General Assembly resolution allows us, in terms of our 2006 Act, which sets out that we can act in relation to it. It is a question of whether it is permissive for us under our legislation, not whether it is binding. Of course a NATO or EU mission would not have a Security Council imprimatur either. If we remove the triple lock, we will be operating without the Security Council in any case on any mission. We have had strong overpowering UN resolutions on issues such as Gaza. Should we aim to have a UN resolution as a collective interpretation of international law and the UN Charter as a guidance point for a mission that might be operating outside a UN Security Council mandate?
The standard of Irish command has been emphasised and Ms O'Brien mentioned the caveats that were attached to Irish participation. Some of that has changed. The 2021 Act allows the Minister to delegate the power of command and control to the head of an international force in a way that previously was not possible. Is that not the case? Does not that bring a slightly different question in terms of how we ensure that particular Irish experience and expertise of command that we may have had before?
Specifically, the focus has been on peacekeeping. I know that is where the expertise of the witnesses and that of Ireland lies.
However, the legislation also provides for strengthening international security. What do the witnesses understand “strengthening international security” to mean that is different from peacekeeping or peace enforcement and different from the eight exemptions? What kinds of missions do they see under “strengthening international security”? Is there anything that excludes?
Comment on this
One of the most critical distinctions between the two bodies – the General Assembly and the Security Council – is the Security Council’s exclusive right to authorise the use of force under Chapter 7. The Security Council has the power to determine when the use of force is necessary to maintain or restore international peace and security. This authority allows the council to authorise military interventions, no-fly zones and other coercive measures that require the deployment of military assets.
Comment on this
Because of time, I was really looking for the General Assembly powers, but we might come back on that.
Comment on this
The General Assembly does not have those powers.
Comment on this
We will come back to it, but the 2006 Act allows Ireland to act on the basis of the General Assembly.
Comment on this
I want to come in on the other questions if I can.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for those excellent questions. First of all, I agree with her. It is absolutely desirable that a UN Security Council resolution is provided-----
Comment on this
I am speaking to the General Assembly now.
Comment on this
Yes, and it is not that. A second tier would be the General Assembly, and that does meet the threshold for Irish law, as the Senator quite rightly said. That is the desirable one.
Second, on delegation of command, what the legislation says is that the Minister can delegate operational control to an international commander but not command. There are no Irish troops under command of any non-Irish officer anywhere in the world. They have operational control over Irish troops but not command. Operational control is a level below that of command.
Finally, the Senator asked a question on maintaining national security. My interpretation of that is very similar to Article 52 of Chapter 8, which are activities that are consistent with the purposes and principles of the United Nations.
I hope that answered the Senator’s three questions - as succinctly as I could.
Comment on this
I wish to elaborate on one aspect of the second question with my personal experience of it. I have a document with me. It is a directive signed by the then Minister for Defence, dated December 2008. It states that the first commander is operationally responsible for the performance of all functions assigned to the force. This was handed to me by the Chief of Staff. It lists exactly what the force commander is responsible for and what I am responsible for. I will not go into details because it is quite an expansive document. Critically, the first commander I was operating under in Chad had operational command. We had to obey all lawful orders issued by him and his subordinates. We had to carry out any instructions in relation to training operations. It is contained in the document. There were caveats that we have spoken about already. Dr. Berry is right. It is operationally responsible. They do not have operational command. I had command of the unit.
Comment on this
I want to go to Ms O'Brien. It did change somewhat in 2021.
Comment on this
I do not have anything else to add to what has been said already.
Comment on this
A core question was about strengthening international security. What is that if it is not peacekeeping or peace enforcement?
Comment on this
Our mere presence in western Chad strengthened the security environment but also was one of the critical enablers for the Chadian National Army to build up its strength to take over the responsibilities of the UN force that followed on.
Comment on this
But as a separate function, separate from peacekeeping.
Comment on this
It is provided for separately from peacekeeping in the legislation.
Comment on this
Apologies. I would be happy if there is any written piece or anything on that because it is a core question.
Comment on this
Can the Senator elaborate slightly on her last point again? I just want to get-----
Comment on this
In the legislation, it mentions strengthening international security as a purpose for deployment separately from peacekeeping or peace enforcement and the eight or extended list of exemptions. What does that cover that was not covered by peacekeeping or peace enforcement?
Comment on this
That is the question. What does it cover? Maybe the witnesses could submit to the committee what it covers in response.
Comment on this
All I can think of is it is political imperative at that juncture to bring forward initiatives to strengthen international security.
Comment on this
Impartiality was mentioned. Does it include, for example, conflicts on the basis of interests, including the security of interests?
Comment on this
I do not know enough about it to say. I would say that would be up to Government to decide. I think an example would be a training mission. It could be a police mission or a nation mission.
Comment on this
I have to cut it at that, sorry. Senator Craughwell can ask one short, sharp question.
Comment on this
I want to raise three short, sharp issues. I need three things cleared up. The first is directed to Major General O’Brien. On the issue of defence attachés, which covers the expansion of roles, it was suggested by the Department of Defence that a defence attaché could be a civilian. Is she aware of any civilian anywhere who is acting as a defence attaché?
Comment on this
Absolutely not. If there was a defence attaché who was a civilian, they would not be in the setting that I was in in New York. They would not be welcomed into that environment because they do not understand the complexities of the military environment. It is a no-go.
Comment on this
Major General Brennan, in his submission, referred to Defence Forces regulations and Defence Forces legislation. Is it the case that the Defence Forces are ultimately subordinate to the Department of Defence? Regarding things like suspensions, we had a very high-profile case of a soldier who had to be put on gardening leave, or whatever you want to call it. The commander on the ground had no choice because the regulations did not provide for it. Am I correct?
Comment on this
Yes, but I will clarify the Senator’s first position. The Defence Forces are responsible operationally. They are not subordinate to the Department operationally. They are for all other matters in relation to policy. To answer his question, that is correct. I know the case in question. They did not have the authority to suspend any individual, notwithstanding the furore that was created in the media and so on about that.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. Senator Tom Clonan is next, and he will be followed by Deputy Ó Laoghaire.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Higgins for deferring to me earlier.
Disagreement is the most powerful engine for arriving at the truth, so please do not construct disagreement as any kind of hostility or disrespect. I am saying this with absolute respect.
First, to Dr. Berry’s assertion that peace enforcement and war fighting are different things, he said war fighting is about seizing cities, invading and so on. I put it to the witnesses that that is what the United Nations did in Korea. We have to be very careful. Something approximate to that happened with both Operation Enduring Freedom and the International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan. That evolved into a war fighting, full spectrum combat operation. Therefore, I am concerned about mission creep. Would the witnesses share those concerns in an environment where future missions outside of the UN Security Council and triple lock will more likely be peace enforcement?
My second question is in regard to military advice and successive Governments taking military advice. We see the Defence Forces, through no fault of their own, on their knees in our lifetime and on our watch. We can only put one ship to sea, we have no maritime or ground capabilities and we have nothing in the air domain. Would the witnesses trust that community of decision-makers to send any number of Irish troops anywhere in the world at any time in the future to any conflict?
Comment on this
On the Senator’s last question, as has been emphasised on numerous occasions, the process is governed by military advice given to the Minister and the Government, and that military advice is founded on the risk associated with what is involved. I am quite confident going forward that military advice by successive general staffs to the Minister and to the Government will continue to be sound.
On the Senator’s first question-----
Comment on this
Sorry. I know the advice is sound, but would Mr. Brennan be confident that the Government would follow it, given what has happened-----
Comment on this
Notwithstanding what has happened-----
Comment on this
Why do I say that? In my four years as deputy chief of staff (operations), there was a 100% track record of Government taking our advice, notwithstanding on a couple occasions we had to elaborate on the advice.
On the second thing, when we deploy overseas, as the Senator well knows, we deploy with a certain capability. Within those capabilities, we deliver operational outputs. If a war situation developed very quickly, in many instances, we would not have the emergency capability to actually deal with that situation. If it became a Korea, which the Senator referenced, or a Ukraine situation, we are not deployed to deal with that situation.
Peace enforcement brings with it a certain amount of military hardware and rules of engagement that allow us to complete our mission successfully. Chad was a perfect example of that and Kosovo continues to be a perfect example.
Comment on this
I thank our witnesses. They have been insightful. I would like to clarify something. There was an exchange between Senator Clonan and Mr. Brennan about the 50-member limit and why it exists at all. The legislation as it is framed has two different categories to be conscious of. There were always two different categories-----
Comment on this
-----in legal terms under the Defence Act. I forget the phrase, but the legislation referred to international forces.
Comment on this
There were deployments on international missions and deployments other than those. That is what is anticipated in this legislation. For that first category, there was a limit of 12 that will now be increased to 50. For the second category, which has now been clarified, and that is welcome, in respect of drug interdiction, humanitarian evacuation and so on, the limit of 12 did not exist and the limit of 50 did not exist.
Comment on this
I am coming to the question. There did still seem to be some difficulty and I do not understand what it was. The Department of Defence officials told us that the triple lock did not prevent those deployments. What did, other than resources? What legal obstacles existed? The Department of Defence is saying that the triple lock was not the issue.
Comment on this
In respect of, for example, the NATO-led Kosovo force, KFOR, mission, we are always restricted to having 12 members in situ on a continuous basis. That remains the case. I will defer to Dr. Berry, who wants to add to that.
Comment on this
The Deputy asks an excellent question. An ultraconservative interpretation of the law is what limited the deployment to Kabul to 12 personnel. Legally, there is absolutely no impediment. We could have sent 100 if we wanted to but it was limited to 12 because that was the interpretation of whoever interpreted the law as it stood. The Deputy is 100% right in his assertion, as was Senator Clonan. For those eight exemptions and the additional three, there is no ceiling. The only limit that exists is logistical and the numerical strength of the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
I want to go back to our professionalism. My question is for all of the witnesses. With deployment restricted to 12 members, in their experience or knowledge, have there been cases where a team of 12 professionally trained Irish soldiers have gone abroad and had to request help, support and equipment from other forces to carry out their work?
Comment on this
Three and a half years ago at the Kabul evacuation, we deployed approximately 12 personnel but could not deploy aircraft because we did not have the aircraft. Even if we did, the five or six aircrew required would have pushed us over the threshold of 12. While there was no legal requirement for a maximum of 12 people, the ubersafe interpretation of the law as it stood meant that the deployment was capped at 12. I hope that answers the Deputy's question.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. From a safety and security point of view, or even a welfare point of view, for our soldiers, would it be better for more than 12 people to go abroad on any mission? I imagine there will not be time for rest periods if there are just 12 members.
Comment on this
Operationally, I know from my experience that when we speak about sending that number of people abroad, if we are sending 12 people to Kosovo, they are headquarters appointments. They are not operationally active in the field. The same is true of our military observers in the United Nations Truce Supervision Organization, UNTSO, in which Mr. Doyle served. They operate individually as distinct from as a unit. The minimum number of people we would ever deploy overseas is a platoon. For example, we deployed a platoon of rangers to Liberia. I ask Dr. Berry to correct me if I am wrong, but we also deployed a platoon of rangers to East Timor.
That is the minimum number. It provides a command and control structure along with supporting assets for that particular sub-unit to deliver whatever operational outputs are demanded of it by the force commander.
Comment on this
For Deputies Callaghan and Ó Laoghaire and Senator Clonan, I will say something about the 50-member cap. I have an understanding of why there is going to be an increase from 12 to 50 for international forces. I was put on standby approximately 20 years ago to go to Baghdad. I was put on standby at 7 p.m., or 19:00 hours, during the summer for deployment at 07:00 hours in the morning. It would be impossible for a quorum of the Dáil to be assembled in that limited time before deployment. When it comes to a peacekeeping operation, if a small initial entry force can be deployed, it can stop a major catastrophe from developing. It is about the speed of deployment and not requiring a Dáil resolution for a small group of people, bearing in mind that it may not be possible to assemble the Dáil in such a short period. I hope that helps the committee's deliberations.
Comment on this
In UN headquarters, Ireland would not have been selected if we knew there was a possible delay. From a UN perspective, we would not have selected an Irish force to do that job because of the restrictions. We can get troops to go without that kind of consideration.
Comment on this
It did prevent us from being involved in things that we could have been involved in or would have been professionally able to be involved in.
Comment on this
Perhaps I will put a question myself. I thank the witnesses for their contributions. We at this committee are trying to make the best decisions but have severe time constraints in respect of the pre-legislative scrutiny of this Bill. Mr. Brennan said he was surprised by the public reaction and how the public has misinterpreted what the removal of the triple lock is all about. Does that not lend itself to the possibility of having a referendum or a wider forum where all of that could be discussed so that people fully understand what this legislation is all about?
Comment on this
That is a decision for politicians and the Government. I defer to them to make a proper judgment in that regard.
Irish people have a great fondness for Irish peacekeepers but sometimes do not fully understand the role we play overseas. They see us in our blue berets, blue flak jackets and white vehicles. When I was in Kosovo, we had none of that gear. We were in our national uniforms and were doing our jobs as if we were at home in Ireland. The same was true in Chad. Working with the UN and working with the European Union force, from the particular point of view of the people who are there, is no different.
If I could have one moment, I will share a comment with the committee. I visited a refugee camp on Christmas Day 2008 and on that occasion, I met a number of the refugees who had come out of Sudan. The Janjaweed militia had killed hundreds of people and destroyed families. I met one of the women who had survived that particular incident. I will always remember what she said to me through an interpreter. Talking about the Irish soldiers, she said that their presence restored her faith in men in uniform. I will leave it at that.
Comment on this
Does this not present an opportunity for that to be communicated to people so they reach a better understanding and are fully behind whatever legislation is decided at the end of the day? There is a forum there. Does Dr. Berry want to comment on that?
Comment on this
That is an excellent point. If anything has been achieved over the past five years, it is that we have normalised the discussion of the topic of defence. If you brought up the subject five years ago, you were labelled as a warmonger. These hearings before the committee are very important. More informed commentary in the Dáil is also important. The reason that many of the public are misinformed is because we have not had the discussion. While the committee is time constrained at the moment in respect of this legislation, there is no difficulty later in the year or next year having a more broad discussion with testimony from various witnesses, if that would help the public's understanding.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Berry.
On behalf of the committee I once again thank the witnesses for their time and for the material they circulated to the committee in advance of the meeting. I also thank them for their service to the country. It is very evident from their statements and the contributions they made today that they have a thorough knowledge and have made huge contributions. I thank them on behalf of the committee for that. It is great to see a woman from the west as well.
The select committee will meet tomorrow to consider the 2025 Revised Estimates for the defence Vote group.