We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Defence and National Security

Building National Resilience and National Emergency Planning: Discussion

Summary

Officials outlined work to strengthen resilience through critical-infrastructure planning, public preparedness campaigns, regular emergency exercises and closer cross-border co-operation. Civil Defence reported rising volunteer numbers and investment in training and equipment, while noting that volunteer availability and time off for emergency call-outs remain challenges. The fire and emergency management directorate described its role in supporting local fire services and coordinating national responses to severe weather. Members also sought clarity on responsibility for urgent threats such as drones; the Office of Emergency Planning said risks are assessed and lead agencies assigned, but did not address specific incidents.

Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The joint committee is holding two public sessions this morning to discuss building national resilience and national emergency planning. In the first session we are joined by the following: from the Department of Defence, Mr. Kealan McMoreland, principal officer; Ms Sandra Murphy, assistant principal officer; Ms Aisling McQuaid, assistant principal officer; and Mr. Graeme Towell, assistant principal officer; from Civil Defence, Ms Cep Carty, principal officer; and Mr. Paul Brophy, assistant principal officer; and from the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, Mr. Keith Leonard, national director, national directorate for fire and emergency management; and Mr. Derek Whelan, senior fire adviser. On behalf of the committee, you are all very welcome.

The format of the meeting is that I will first invite Civil Defence to make its opening statement and then the national directorate for fire and emergency management. The opening statements will be followed by questions from members of the committee.

As we have two public sessions this morning, each member has a seven-minute slot to ask questions and for the witnesses to respond. I ask members to adhere to the time.

I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where he or she is not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any member participating via MS Teams to formally confirm prior to making his or her contribution to the meeting that he or she is on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.

Both members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

I invite Ms Carty to make the opening statement for the Civil Defence.

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

I am pleased to be here with the committee today as head of Civil Defence branch within the Department of Defence, to provide it with an update on Civil Defence operations, particularly in the context of national resilience and emergency response. I am joined by my colleague, Paul Brophy.

The Civil Defence branch of the Department of Defence and the 28 Civil Defence units have had a busy 12 months across the State, both in continuing business as usual support for the principal response agencies and local communities, and in preparing for future challenges. It is appropriate that we are here with our colleagues from the Office of Emergency Planning and the national directorate for fire and emergency management, given the close working relationships we have with both and their importance as key stakeholders in informing Civil Defence activities.

Civil Defence is Ireland's largest volunteer emergency response organisation. It has a vital role as a support to the principal response agencies during emergencies. Our track record in recent years, during multiple extreme weather events, the Covid-19 pandemic and the Ukrainian refugee crisis, all evidence our capacity and capability in this supporting role. Our presence and capabilities in every county across the State helps to enhance local resilience, providing a direct link with local communities.

We are very alert to the changing weather patterns affecting Ireland. In 2025, we had 414 taskings related to climactic or severe weather events, many involving prolonged responses. Overall planning on a national scale is the preserve of other bodies, but Civil Defence has key roles within those national structures and plans. For example, in the event of significant flooding, individual Civil Defence units may be tasked with several duties before, during and after the flood event, ranging from the use of our technical communications expertise to map at-risk areas and assess the level of impact right through to the deployment of volunteers with the appropriate training in swift-water flood and pump-response activities, adverse weather driving and welfare checks for vulnerable people. We have similarly been tasked to provide support to the fire and rescue services with wildfire response.

We have also undertaken significant work to enhance our rest centre capability in the past year, with significant investment in centrally procured key equipment and training for our rest centre teams. Welfare has always been a key aspect of Civil Defence capabilities and while this has evolved over decades to adapt to the latest threats and challenges, it remains a significant role for us. In the aftermath of extreme weather events and particularly where transport and communications are disrupted, we can provide limited transport capabilities for medical priorities.

The Covid pandemic had a very significant negative impact on volunteer numbers generally in the voluntary sector. Civil Defence was no different. Volunteering with Civil Defence can be challenging and, at unit level, our Civil Defence officers work hard to ensure that they recruit volunteers who understand the required level of commitment. The investment in training and upskilling is significant but we are slowly restoring volunteer numbers. Since January 2025, we have grown the number of active and probationary volunteers by 24% and we continue to target further growth. This is done through social media and radio recruitment campaigns and targeted bus shelter campaigns which were rolled out by the Department to raise the profile of the modern Civil Defence and to supplement local unit recruitment which traditionally happens through open days, operational visibility and word of mouth.

While the Civil Defence is proud of the significant resources at its disposal, and the range of its capabilities is extensive, it is nonetheless a volunteer organisation and dependent on volunteer availability in each area at any point in time. This is inevitably a limiting factor and, therefore, the resource must be deployed to best effect. To mitigate this limitation, our units are increasingly responding on a multi-unit basis and it is not unusual to see neighbouring units assisting a lead unit with a response.

It is also important that we appreciate and retain our existing Civil Defence volunteers. A recently published ranks and promotions policy gives transparency to the process of promoting volunteers who show the required leadership skills and commitment to their unit. We host annual ceremonies at local level to recognise training accomplishments and long service milestones. Last June, the Minister of State at the Department of Defence presented medals to volunteers from across the country marking 30, 40 and 50 years of service.

Training is a large and integral part of the Civil Defence organisation. From the initial minimum training standards required of every volunteer, to specialised areas such as medical training, boating, drone operation and search training, reaching and maintaining training standards is fundamental to ensuring the Civil Defence can respond to the multiple challenges faced each year. As the committee will hear from the other witnesses this morning, co-operation is a keystone of emergency response and is prioritised accordingly.

In addition to Civil Defence membership of the Government task force, we routinely participate in local and regional exercises across the State to ensure working together becomes second nature. Flexibility is built into the Civil Defence’s co-operation with other organisations and extreme circumstances may result in unforeseen new partnerships when required. One example of this was in the aftermath of Storm Éowyn last year, when several Civil Defence drone teams worked closely with ESB Networks to assist in the identification of fallen and damaged powerlines. More recently, my colleague, Mr. Brophy, and some other members of our branch worked with the Office of the Government Chief Information Officer in the area of mission critical communications and resilience.

National resilience is built locally, and the Civil Defence is well situated to play a strong partnership role at local and national levels. A stronger whole-of-society approach can assist in withstanding and recovering from the increasingly complex emergencies of the future. Like all organisations, the Civil Defence has limited resources and its volunteer basis, while a strength, also brings with it the constraints I mentioned. Growing our volunteer base, ensuring the relevant training, policies, procedures and equipment are in place and continuing to work closely with our colleagues in the room today will help us to play our role in the broader national emergency response.

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

I thank Deputies and Senators for the opportunity to appear before the committee today to provide an update on the work of the Office of Emergency Planning since we last met. We discovered it has been almost a year, to the day, since we were last before the committee so we have some positive outcomes from the past 12 months to share. I am joined by my colleague: Mr. Graeme Towell, who works on critical infrastructure; Ms Aisling McQuaid, who deals with the Government task force and risk; and Ms Sandra Murphy, who deals with preparedness and resilience.

The period under review has been one of significant progress for emergency planning, resilience and preparedness across the government. A major priority in the past 12 months has been the successful implementation of the European Union critical entities resilience framework. In March 2026, the Minister published the National Strategy on the Resilience of Critical Entities 2026-2029, establishing a national vision for protecting the essential services upon which society depends and strengthening resilience across 11 critical sectors. To support implementation of the regulations, we have established two important governance structures. The competent authority forum brings together the authorities responsible for oversight of critical sectors, while the public administration forum supports collaboration across Government Departments in their role as providers of essential services. Together, these forums are strengthening co-ordination, information sharing and resilience planning across the public sector and critical infrastructure community.

Another significant achievement has been the launch of the "Be Emergency Ready" campaign. This included both the publication of the national preparedness booklet and the creation of a dedicated preparedness website providing practical guidance for households and communities. The campaign seeks to empower citizens to take simple preparedness measures, strengthen community resilience and encourage a broader culture of preparedness across our society. The campaign has been delivered in close partnership with local authorities from which the committee will hear later on today and other stakeholders, recognising that resilience is strongest when it is built collaboratively and at community level.

The office also continued its work to strengthen Ireland's understanding of risk. During the year, a revised national risk assessment for Ireland was published, building in the requirements of the critical entities resilience regulations. Further building on this work, a comprehensive review of the national risk assessment process is now under way. This review includes engagement with Government Departments, agencies, academia, industry and other subject matter experts through a series of structured focus groups designed to ensure that Ireland's risk assessment methodology remains robust, evidence based and forward looking.

As part of our EU Presidency commitments, in partnership with our Department of housing colleagues, we hosted a workshop in Dublin bringing together civil protection, resilience and critical infrastructure experts from across EU member states. The workshop focused on cascading risks affecting critical infrastructure, particularly those arising from severe weather events, and explored how greater co-operation, scientific expertise and emerging technologies can support resilience across Europe. Recognising the increasingly blurred boundaries between traditional emergencies, cyber incidents, hostile state activity, disinformation and attacks on critical infrastructure, the Department has also placed a growing emphasis on preparedness for hybrid threats. This includes the successful delivery of exercise PÚCA which brought together a broad range of Government Departments, agencies and external expertise to test national-level co-ordination arrangements in a complex hybrid operating environment.

The Department has also strengthened international co-operation through the signing of a co-operation protocol on resilience and emergency planning with the United Kingdom. This protocol reflects the strong and long-standing relationship between both Administrations. It provides an enhanced framework for information sharing, mutual learning and co-operation on issues of common concern. Given the shared risks facing these islands particularly in areas such as severe weather, critical infrastructure resilience, supply chain disruption and societal preparedness, this partnership represents an important contribution to collective resilience.

The common thread running through all of these initiatives is the recognition that resilience is no longer solely about responding effectively to emergencies; it is about understanding risk, protecting critical services, strengthening societal preparedness and building trusted partnerships throughout the public sector and its architecture.

I look forward to engaging with the committee and answering any questions members may have.

Comment on this
Mr. Keith Leonard

I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the opportunity to discuss the contribution of the national directorate for fire and emergency management, NDFEM, to building national resilience and national emergency planning.

Before I turn to my opening remarks, I want to acknowledge the devastating fire in Waterford on Tuesday. Our thoughts are with the English family and all those affected across the community by this shocking event. I would also like to pay tribute to the firefighters and emergency responders who attended the scene. Their response reflects the professionalism, skill and commitment members of our fire service demonstrate every day in the service of their communities often in the most difficult of circumstances. Incidents such as this underline the critical importance of the fire service and the dedication of those who serve within in. On behalf of the Minister, Deputy Browne, and the Department, I wish to record our sincere appreciation for their efforts.

I am here today in my role as national director of the national directorate for fire and emergency management within the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage. I understand that the committee will hear separately on the wider role of the Office of Emergency Planning and on the responsibilities and operational role of local government. I will therefore focus my opening remarks on the specific contribution of the national directorate to Ireland's national resilience and emergency management arrangements.

The NDFEM's primary role is to provide national policy leadership, oversight and support for local authority fire services. Complementing this core function, the NDFEM also contributes to national emergency management through its responsibilities for inter-agency co-ordination arrangements, engagement with the EU civil protection mechanism and the co-ordination of responses to severe weather emergencies.

A cornerstone of fire service policy is keeping communities safe, KCS, setting norms, standards and objectives across the sector. Operational responsibility for fire services rests with local authorities. The directorate fosters an integrated model of leadership that supports local authorities in providing safe and effective fire services.

Resilience within the fire service is understood as the capacity to withstand, adapt to and recover from extraordinary shocks such as pandemics or extreme weather emergencies while maintaining life-saving emergency response capacity. Investment is also an important part of building resilience. Through the current national development plan programme, the Department supports investment in fire stations, fleet, equipment, learning and development and resilience measures across the fire service sector.

The second important aspect of our work is the co-ordinated approach to emergency management among the principal response agencies. The strategic emergency management framework, published by the Department of Defence, provides the overarching structure for managing emergencies at national level, designating lead Government Department responsibility for 50 emergency scenarios. Under these arrangements, the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, through the NDFEM, leads national co-ordination in response to severe weather emergencies. Where circumstances require it, the NDFEM activates and operates the relevant co-ordination structures, including the national emergency co-ordination group.

Resilience also has an important international dimension. The NDFEM is Ireland's national focal point for the EU Union civil protection mechanism, UCPM, on behalf of Departments. From the NDFEM perspective, our focus is therefore on strengthening resilience within our area of responsibility to ensure that we are as prepared as possible for all future emergencies.

I hope that provides a useful overview of the NDFEM's contribution to national resilience and emergency management. I thank the committee again for the opportunity to attend today and I look forward to members' questions and to the wider discussion.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I too, on behalf of the committee, want to extend my sympathy to the family of Philip and Kim English and their two sons on that absolutely tragic event. I commend the fire officers and emergency services that were involved and wish An Garda Síochána success in holding the people responsible for this to account. It is beyond devastating for any of us to imagine what that family and the community are suffering at this particular time.

I will now go to members who have seven minutes each. We will start with Senator Clonan.

Comment on this

I reiterate Mr. Leonard’s praise of the fire services and our deepest sympathies to the families and the whole community involved in this horrific incident. I want to apologise in advance as I have to go at 10 a.m. and I have the Order of Business after that, but I will try to get back in before the witnesses leave.

Can Ms Carty say how many active voluntary personnel the Civil Defence has, roughly speaking?

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

We have about 2,200 at the moment. That has increased from about 1,700 or 1,800 over the past few years.

Comment on this

How many permanent staff does it have?

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

Is that permanent staff in the Department of defence?

Comment on this

No, in Civil Defence. Apologies.

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

In Civil Defence across the country we would have about 50 permanent staff.

Comment on this

This is an open question for everyone. Obviously, we have a rapidly evolving threat environment. What is the principal threat for the Republic?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

We conduct the national risk assessment on a three-year rolling basis as a result of Decision No. 1313/2013/EU on the Union civil protection mechanism. That risk assessment, last published in 2023, identifies 22 key risks. The top risks are still pandemic, antimicrobial-resistant infection is still up there, then cyberattack and disruption to critical supply chain. We have also risk-assessed damage to subsea infrastructure, which is another key risk, loss of electricity and gas and disruption to oil supply, so they are all covered. We have started the 2026 revision of the national risk assessment. We have completed seven expert focus groups to date. We examined 30 key risks and we aim to publish the national risk matrix before the end of the year which will be an update on the 2023 risk assessment.

Comment on this

Evidenced-based risk assessment was mentioned and Mr. Leonard mentioned our capacity to understand risk and protect critical infrastructure and our citizens. I congratulate them on Exercise Púca.

Going from the hypothetical to the actual, a number of years ago, Dublin Airport was closed several times due to the presence in the vicinity of small consumer drones. These were hobby drones that were maybe the size of my hand or a little larger. When drones from hobby drones to larger industrial-grade drones have been sighted near airports throughout Europe, airspace has been closed and notifications issued to aircraft and airmen. That is the language that they use. During President Zelenskyy's visit, a number of military-grade or industrial-grade drones were sighted on the flight pathway into Dublin Airport and were observed operating in that vicinity for a considerable period of time. This committee was told that the aviation authorities were not informed of this. They received no notification and as a consequence, nobody - pilots, air crew, airlines, civil aviation authorities or Dublin Airport - was informed of this. However, recently this year, we have had two large drones sighted that were reported to the civil aviation authorities. They were referred to respectively in the media as the black drone and the red drone, both of which were observed by pilots. I think they were both Aer Lingus pilots. On those occasions, unlike our European counterparts, who issue a notification to aircraft, the civil aviation authorities were informed but the decision they took was to inform An Garda Síochána. Do the witnesses think that this was the correct response?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

I might come in on that from a national risk perspective. To reassure the Senator, the national risk assessment does take account and we are examining disruptive use of drones this year as a key risk. It was examined in 2023.

Comment on this

Could I ask whether that was the correct-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask the Senator to bear in mind that the witnesses were not invited here to discuss the investigation.

Comment on this

These are not ongoing investigations. I am curious to find out if the witnesses think that this was the correct decision to make.

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

We need to clearly distinguish the boundary between civil protection resilience and national security and security and defence so-----

Comment on this

With the Office of Emergency Planning's interest in evidence-based risk assessment, understanding risk and protecting critical infrastructure, I was surprised by the response. Whether drones are spotted in Leipzig or Copenhagen, our European partners close airspace. When Cyprus had the Presidency of the European Union before us, it closed the airspace for several weeks because of sightings of drones. Is there something in the environment here that makes us different or less vulnerable to drones? Is it something in the air?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

We are not in a position to comment on that because it is not our area of expertise. That would have to be a matter for the Irish Aviation Authority, AirNav Ireland and An Garda Síochána. It is not an issue for-----

Comment on this

Does the Office of Emergency Planning discuss drone threats as part of its risk assessment, including the 20?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

We will be examining disruptive use.

Comment on this

Are drone threats listed in its top 20?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

Yes, in 2022 and 2023.

Comment on this

What is the action that the office recommended in its 2023-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

We will risk assess impact and likelihood based on expert opinion. Depending on the reasonable worst-case scenario, a lead Department is assigned responsibility for mitigation, preparedness and response.

Comment on this

Therefore, was that carried out when these drones were sighted?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

In 2023, which was before these sightings-----

Comment on this

That is what it set out as its best practice response to a drone sighting.

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

Correct and in 2026-----

Comment on this

Was that best practice response that the office set out in its 2023 risk assessment carried out?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

We do not identify response. What we do is assess the risk, its impact and its likelihood based on reasonable worst-case scenarios. We then assign lead Government Department responsibility based on the reasonable worst-case scenario and the policyholder for that particular risk. It is responsible for planning, preparing, mitigating, responding and recovering from the specific risk.

Comment on this

If Mr. McMoreland recalls the film "Ghostbusters", "Who will we call? Ghostbusters".

I am confused, having heard the evidence, about what happens in the event of a drone being sighted in our airspace.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Senator Clonan, your time is up.

Comment on this

I do not hear any coherent response to that but I thank the officials very much for their evidence. I really appreciate it.

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

A Chathaoirligh, it is very important to point out there is a coherent response. Again, we carry out the risk assessment and then the responsibility is assigned, so there is responsibility assigned.

Comment on this

But no action was taken.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. I am moving on to Senator Wilson because we are very tight for time.

Comment on this

The officials are all very welcome. I thank them for their presentations and the work they do on all of our behalf. I join you, a Chathaoirligh, as well as Mr. Leonard and colleagues in expressing my sympathies to the English family and paying tribute to the emergency services involved in this horrific tragedy.

I have a few small questions. Mr. McMoreland used the term "collective resilience". Maybe his colleagues could comment on it as well. He mentioned that in the context of his dealings with the United Kingdom and the co-operation with it, especially in relation to the Six Counties. Will all three of the officials outline how their co-operation with our colleagues in the Six Counties works? Maybe they could give us an example in that regard.

I have a question specifically for Ms Carty on the funding of the Civil Defence. I pay tribute to it as it is an excellent organisation and, as she pointed out, entirely voluntary. I am glad she mentioned the numbers have increased in recent years because it was my understanding they had decreased. I thank her for clarifying that. How many of the 28 units have their own purpose-built headquarters? On the funding of same, quite a large proportion of the funding onus lies upon the local authorities when it should lie entirely within the Department of Defence. I am interested to hear Ms Carty's comments in that regard.

I notice the tender for the emergency alert system has not been mentioned in any of the contributions here. Maybe we could have an update on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

I might start and then hand over to Mr. Leonard to talk about some of the operational co-operation that happens between North and South. I thank the Senator for his question. I reassure him there is now strong co-operation between the office of emergency planning in the Department of Defence and the civil contingencies division in the Northern Ireland Executive Office, which is our equivalent in Northern Ireland. That co-operation has evolved into an all-island disaster risk reduction conference that happens annually. It brings together policy experts, academics, operational experts in emergency planning preparedness and resilience into a single forum. We workshop gaps that may exist at the strategic-horizontal level across our governments, respecting both jurisdictions but ensuring our policies have some form of alignment when it comes to protecting our citizens in Border counties. That is just the top line of that and Mr. Leonard might be able to add some context on the operational side.

The Senator mentioned emergency alerts and I will take that as well before I hand over. I reassure him the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport has established an expert group to look at developing a tender for what is going to be called IE alerts. The office of emergency planning and the Department of the Taoiseach are both feeding in to that process and a decision has been made that the office of emergency planning in the Department of Defence will be responsible for the system when it becomes active.

Comment on this

Will the alert system be nationwide or cover 32 counties? Maybe that is something to look at. Also, can it be localised?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

It would be wrong to pre-empt what the tender is going to say but it will be the most modern system that is available for purchase by the State.

Comment on this
Mr. Keith Leonard

I might give the Senator an overview of the cross-Border piece between fire services. We have done a lot of work and are working very closely on a number of pieces. The first is urban search and rescue. A number of our colleagues from the fire service are now receiving training from the Northern Ireland Fire and Rescue Service on urban search and rescue response. We have the same interoperable equipment for urban search and rescue and we are using the same process and procedures. We hope to effectively have an all-island response for any future urban search and rescue emergencies that may occur.

Similarly, on high-capacity pumping, we have integrated and aligned our equipment with our colleagues in Northern Ireland. We have a colleague in Northern Ireland who is assisting us at the moment in training on high-capacity pumping and bringing their experience to bear, which is very helpful. There is also a cross-Border emergency management group established with representatives from agencies on both sides of the Border to look at cross-Border communications, risk assessment, risk management and protocols for activation and sharing resources.

Fire Safety Week has been launched this week. We launched that as a joint initiative between ourselves and the Northern Ireland Fire and Rescue Service. We work very closely to develop the campaign and to roll out a campaign on fire safety across Ireland. They are some of the key pieces for us.

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

I might come in on a few items. The Senator mentioned collective resilience. It is important to stress that Civil Defence is very much involved in that and we work very closely with the OEP and the national directorate. An example of that would be in the new community centre-rest centre initiative, where we have all worked together to make sure there is provision in the event of a flood or a fire or evacuation requirements. Collective resilience is very much to the forefront of our thinking in everything we do in training right now.

In regard to all-island co-operation, we have also recently signed an affiliation with the Association of Lowland Search and Rescue in the UK, which will see us operating to the same standards as the search entities in Northern Ireland and working very closely with them. We will continue to look for other opportunities on a Six Counties basis.

On the funding, I feel the split of funding is reasonable at the moment. It is a legislative requirement of the local authorities to make provision for premises in their local authority area. Much of the services that are provided are in response locally. It is reasonable that there would be provision for accommodation from the local authority. It is very important to call out that we have had about a 20% increase in funding over the past five years and we will continue to seek more. We provide operational grant funding for fleet, equipment and work wear and personal protective equipment funding directly from the Department. I feel the split is reasonable at the moment and where new premises are put in place, we provide fit-out funding for them as well.

The Senator's final question was on the premises themselves. Out of the 28 local authorities, I would say that about 18 of them have modern premises. Of the remaining ten, there are at least two or three that are actively exploring new opportunities or in the process of refurbishing and moving to new premises. Then there is a very small number, possibly two or three across the country, that do not have any direct path at the moment. We are working with those local authorities to make sure something is put in place. That is the position.

Comment on this

I thank everybody for being here today. I would also like to be to associated with the votes and remarks of sympathy for the English family in Waterford, and also for the fire and emergency services who attended the scene, a scene I cannot even begin to imagine.

Civil Defence provides an enormously beneficial service to our communities, one we probably do not realise we need, whether it is at a community event and something happens, or in an emergency. We should commend the volunteers who step forward to help out in those situations. I am thinking about the risk environment we are currently operating in and I am trying to suggest or find ways to support the great work Civil Defence is doing, which has been outlined, in a very challenging and continually evolving situation.

Has consideration been given to creating a cyberdefence body, whether made up of civilians or intertwined with cyberdefence as part of our Defence Forces reservists? Would that be beneficial? I will leave that question open.

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

I thank the Deputy for the question. It strays slightly outside our remit, but I am still comfortable answering it. First, we analyse cyberattack as a risk on the national risk assessment. The lead agency for that is the National Cyber Security Centre and the lead Department is the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration. On defence, the new joint cyberdefence command has been established in the Defence Forces and is ramping up to its full operational capacity. I do not have to hand the details of the date for that full operational capacity, but we can revert to the committee in writing, if that is okay.

Comment on this

Perfect. Could a cyberdefence authority or organisation like that work with the organisations that are already involved?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

I think it does. The joint cyberdefence command is very closely aligned with the National Cyber Security Centre, so I am confident that they are working hand in glove.

Comment on this

That is very reassuring. I thank Mr. McMoreland. I will move on to how our emergency plans work and whether they are stress-tested. Mr. McMoreland mentioned Operation PÚCA. Are exercises like that, or desktop exercises, conducted frequently?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

We have at least two national exercises a year, if not more. For example, we had a major transportation exercise, we have radiological exercises and we recently had Exercise Cathal, which was a major national exercise simulating a long-term power outage. Exercise PÚCA was a complex hybrid incident that we simulated in the National Emergency Co-ordination Centre last year. This year, there is what we call EU PACE IR26, which I will translate for the committee. It is the Parallel and Coordinated Exercise Integrated Resolve 2026, which is an EU-wide hybrid exercise that looks at hybrid incidents affecting multiple member states. This year, we will play a role in that. We will examine a hybrid incident in Ireland and how the strategic or Government level will manage the domestic implications of a hybrid incident when it is complicated by a wider attack on European member states. These are all ongoing.

I should point out that it is not the Office of Emergency Planning that runs and operates these exercises. Our job is to support the lead Departments. I mentioned earlier that we conduct a national risk assessment. There are 22 key risks, and there is a risk owner for each of them. The risk owners are responsible for planning, preparing, responding and recovering, and in that planning and preparing part, they are responsible for exercising as well. What we do is facilitate, using the National Emergency Co-ordination Centre, and support them in whatever way we can to ramp up the exercise to the national scale.

Comment on this

That is really reassuring as well, and I am glad it has come out of the committee today. Is stress-testing adequately done? With the capabilities we have, in any desktop exercise like that one, whether a national one or one in co-ordination with our European partners, are we pressing to find a weakness? Is somebody responsible for identifying that weakness if one exists, closing that gap and then retesting to ensure the fix has worked?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

That is a really good question, and the Deputy has answered it, because everything she said is happening. A lead Department comes in and exercises the risk or crisis for which it has responsibility.

That is actually stress-testing because it probes all the other policy areas to make sure they all have the capability to respond. There is a lessons-identified process - it is very important that we say "identified" - directly following any exercise. Those lessons identified then go into future planning arrangements. Plans are amended and then they are republished and retested. I can give the Deputy two solid examples of this. The first is the national emergency plan for nuclear and radiological exposures, which was tested two to three years ago. That plan is being revised and now they are ready to test again.

Second, on an almost annual basis at this stage - it may be stretching to 18 months between exercises - the National Cyber Security Centre comes in to us and it exercises the national cyber emergency plan, which is revised based on the findings of those exercises. Again, they are intense exercises but the planning for them and the lessons-identified portions of them are quite bruising because they identify gaps. We do not always openly share those parts because they identify gaps. PÚCA is another example where we identified 47 specific recommendations. They are being monitored to make sure those gaps are being filled so that when we go to EU IR26 PACE, we will be testing other elements and the ones that have been amended.

Comment on this

Fantastic. I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. I also wish to be associated with the remarks on the family in Waterford and the comments on the fire brigade. I was speaking to members of the fire service yesterday. Without getting into the detail of the dispute yesterday, it shows the value of public service and how much work that goes on at times is not seen and perhaps is not always appreciated except at times of great need.

My question is on the national risk assessment and the most recent version of it, in 2024. This may exist and is perhaps not in the public domain. The document itself is a good overview and it outlines very clearly the various categories such as technological, geopolitical, economic and so on. I would probably agree with many of them. However, is there anywhere within the Department of the Taoiseach or the Department of Defence a type of corporate risks register with red risks, orange risks and so on describing those that are perceived to be the most serious but perhaps not likely, those that are likely but less serious, and those that are both likely and serious? Obviously, the ones we would be most concerned about are the ones that are plausible and serious. Will the witnesses give us a sense of how they are graded? Perhaps that exists in another document, or perhaps it is not a public document, but will they give us a sense of that? We can probably all have our opinions on these various risks, but you would imagine State policy is orientated towards a prioritisation of the various risks.

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

I thank the Deputy for the question. I will take that one as well. The first thing we have to do is distinguish between the publications that exist. A list of strategic risks is published by the Department of the Taoiseach and is based on the World Economic Forum's global risk report. That is the one that was published in 2024. It is published on an almost annual basis. Then there is the national risk assessment, which is undertaken by the office of emergency planning on behalf of the Government task force on emergency planning. To demonstrate that there is policy coherence here, what we do in the office of emergency planning is take the 25 strategic risks that have been identified in the Department of the Taoiseach's document and we assess them. We put them through a couple of filters to see, for example, whether that risk can result in the requirement for national level co-ordination to manage the consequences of that risk. We take those in and then we use a very defined methodology, based on international standards, to identify the impact and the likelihood based on reasonable worst-case scenario. We are on a three-year rolling cycle, and the last time we published our national risk assessment was in 2023. We are reviewing that process.

To give the Deputy some comfort, we do two things with the risk once we have analysed impact and likelihood. First, we produce a risk matrix so we can see what the highest level risks are. That is how I was able to describe the top four from 2023, which were cyberattack, pandemic, antimicrobial-resistant infection and disruption to critical supply chain. That is how we are able to identify those as the top four. Then we have the other ones, as we discussed earlier, which are the disruptive use of drones, damage to subsea infrastructure, gas and electricity outages and severe weather events. That 5x5 risk matrix - people who look at risk assessments would be familiar with the type of matrix we operate - scores the risk and we then prioritise it. All of the risk that we analyse is relative, so the answer to the Deputy’s question is “Yes”. We prioritise the risk, we take account of the Department of the Taoiseach’s horizon scanning process and its list of strategic risks, and then we add them into all of the other risks, including local authority risks and risks from agencies. This year, for the first time, we are taking critical risks or key risks from the operators of essential services. Our critical infrastructure providers and the competent authorities are sending us their risks so that we are bringing them into the analytical process.

Comment on this

Mr. McMoreland's answer has led me to the document. I can see that, for example, a cyberattack is considered to be very likely and the impact very high, whereas a nuclear incident abroad would have a very high impact but it is much less likely. I can see that now, so that is a useful piece of information. As Mr. McMoreland said, that document is now three years old and the Department is working on updating it. Will it be in a position to publish an updated version of that? Does that require that the Department of the Taoiseach's national strategic risk assessment be published first? That is overdue at this stage. The last version was published in 2024. As Mr. McMoreland said, it is meant to be every year. It was not published last year, so we would anticipate that will come soon. Does the Department require that other document before it can publish its more detailed matrix-based assessment?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

We are not stopping our process. What we are using is the 2024 publication. Again, however, to demonstrate policy coherence, I sit on the group that looks at the risks from the Department of the Taoiseach. That process is ongoing. Before it is published, we will also have a view of those risks. If there is anything additional, we will pull that into our process, analyse it in line with the methodology that is outlined in the document the Deputy is looking at and assess it to make sure we have appropriately captured that risk in our risk assessment.

Comment on this

I have a final question. Mr. McMoreland and Senator Clonan had a good exchange, but anyone else may wish to comment on this. I will speak in generalities because I know the witnesses do not want to get into the details of drone incidents and so on because there was a good exchange on that already. I will speak in general terms. The response in relation to that was that the risk is assessed, it is assigned to the appropriate agency and that agency takes a decision. It seems to me that there are certain incidents where time is of the essence such that there needs to be an assumption of a certain agency taking responsibility for it, perhaps the Defence Forces. I am not necessarily referring to that incident or any other incident, but there is an assumption that there is no time for a risk assessment and a given agency needs to step in immediately. Is there a list of such types of incidents? Are there agencies that have that institutional knowledge where they need to step in here without recourse to anyone else? How does it work in those really urgent situations where every minute counts?

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

I might we take this, although I do not want to eat Mr. Leonard's sandwiches here because there are two specific documents. One is Strategic Emergency Management: National Structures and Framework. There is an annexe at the back of that and it identifies 50 general emergency types and assigns responsibility for those. They are not all on the national risk assessment because some of them would not reach that threshold. We thought about that back in 2017 when the document was originally published. This year, we published a slight amendment to that to add material and take account of changes in responsibility. That is identified already. At the governmental level, it is about who has the policy responsibility for a specific potential crisis.

Then there is A Framework for Major Emergency Management, which is very much in Mr. Leonard's bailiwick.

There is a lead agency concept in there so, in generalities, when we are talking about specific emergency types at the operational level, it has dealt with and assigns responsibility there. In both documents, if there is an issue or a decision needs to be made, there is also the option for that. It is already captured in those documents, the strategic emergency management framework and the major emergency management framework.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. McMoreland.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. I was listening to them on the way in. I am rather surprised that the Civil Defence lost people during Covid and that it is actively recruiting now. I was a member of the Civil Defence myself 100 years ago. It is a wonderful organisation. I compliment the people who are here, because when it comes to emergency planning, we are never sure what is coming down the line. What seems to be a fairly mild event can turn into a disastrous one.

I know how much work the cross-Border fire service does to get that in place, and the level of commitment that is required on both sides. I believe it is entitled to a compliment on that as well.

I would like to throw all of the questions out together if the witnesses do not mind. The Civil Defence is actively recruiting. Is a medical examination required for volunteers? If so, where is it carried out? Where is drone training carried out? Those are the questions for the Civil Defence.

We were talking about cybersecurity, which is in the area of national emergency planning. I know it is the competence of the National Cyber Security Centre, so if the witnesses feel this it is more a question for that body, I am quite prepared to withdraw it. We put forward the proposal some time ago of three tiers of cyber defence. Cyberdefence would be based in the National Cyber Security Centre as the primary organisation in the event of a cyberattack. That would be augmented by various consultancy groups - the big five, for example - to provide second-line support coupled with the Defence Forces and the Garda. Then there was a suggestion that we would have a third-line defence whereby companies that have cyber professionals working within their organisation would agree to release them and allow them to be used in the national interest. I just wonder if that has ever found any ground.

Coming back to the Civil Defence, there was some suggestion after one of the major storms that electric generators were available in every Civil Defence office and that they had not been brought into service. At the time, I was told that the reason they were not brought into service was that people would have had electronic equipment switched on and if a generator had been hooked up to it, they would have been unaware of that fact, so there was a risk to bodies. I would like an answer on that.

The final one is probably more for the fire service than anybody else. Aughinish Alumina has been in the public eye for some time now. There is a major mud pond just outside the plant. I am very familiar with it as I worked there at one time. That mud pond has been growing over the last 30-odd years. There are examples throughout the world of these mud ponds breaking their banks and it is fire service personnel who are usually the first people involved in a situation like that. Has that been wargamed? It is not just Aughinish Alumina. There is Whiddy Island as well and several chemical plants in the Cork area. Has the fire service been wargaming those in the event of a major disaster? Those are all the questions. I might start with the Civil Defence.

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

I thank Senator Craughwell for his comments and his appreciation of Civil Defence volunteers across the country. I will start with the medical examination question. We do not have a medical examination in place for Civil Defence volunteers at the moment. Within the code of practice for volunteers, there is a personal responsibility not to show up for training or duties unless you are well. If there is any reason you should not be participating, there is a responsibility there.

The Civil Defence is less about medical and more about physical fitness. That can be self-managed. For example, we have recently rolled out boat operations training, which requires a high degree of physical fitness, and people are opting in to or out of that training depending on whether they feel they have the required level of fitness.

The final thing I want to say on that is even if a medical or physical fitness test was to be introduced, there is still a place in our organisation for volunteers who cannot participate on duties. Many of them do training and many bring experience to the unit. It is not that it would eliminate volunteers but it is not there at the moment and it is not something we are thinking about right now.

If I move to the generators, that information is not correct and I am not sure where it originated. Very few units had generators at the time and there is a safety issue with deploying generators. The example that may have been given was putting a generator into a home where somebody needs medical equipment hooked up to it. That has to be deployed very safely because we heard of an instance where a diesel generator was put indoors in the home and that is very dangerous. That is not something that was done by Civil Defence but it is something that needs to be managed very carefully. There is a bigger issue with generators and I might bring one of my colleagues in to speak about this later on. We have deployed large scale generators that will be used in the forthcoming winter season, as required. Civil Defence may or may not be involved in that. Different local authorities have taken different approaches.

Finally, I will go to drone training. We have drones and sonar deployed across the country in most of our Civil Defence units. We have 45 drones across the country and almost 30 sonar systems, certainly more than 20. Mr. Brophy is involved in drone training so I ask him to add a little bit to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Brophy

With regard to drone training, we operate under the European air safety regulations. The competent authority in Ireland is the Irish Aviation Authority. We carry out regulatory training through that. There are three or four recognised training entities that can provide training. That will give you your licence, mar dhea. We go above and beyond that. We provide practical handover and equipment training and some public safety training on the best use of drone resources in search scenarios, public safety, supporting the local authorities in wildfire events and after flooding, those kind of scenarios. That is the kind of extra training we provide. We have invested heavily in drones in the past few years. Not all local authorities are signed up but for the ones that are, we have been providing them with newer equipment in the past few years that can fly in more adverse weather conditions; if there is wind, rain or it is a morning like this morning, they could actually operate. That is the drone training.

Comment on this
Mr. Kealan McMoreland

I might just come in on the cyber side. It is very much outside our area of competence so we will note it and bring it to the attention of the National Cyber Security Centre in the Department of justice.

Comment on this

I appreciate that and thank Mr. McMoreland.

Comment on this
Mr. Keith Leonard

I might just take the questions the Senator raised about Aughinish Alumina and the general response to hazardous chemical incidents. In the fire service, we provide training for firefighters to respond to those kinds of difficult operating conditions. I will talk first about what we call the Seveso sites, upper tier and lower tier, where there are safety plans. Predominantly, the operator carries a key amount of responsibility and I emphasise that is part of the process but in cases where there are emergencies, the fire service will respond quickly. The first and always the key objective is life safety and rescue. That is the first level of operations.

With that and the specialised training firefighters have, there is also a piece around incident command. We have a new national incident command system that was brought into play in 2025 which sets out a common framework for all fire services to operate together under and operate safely. That is a key part of that response as well. The other piece we are looking at is the actual equipment you need to respond to specialised areas like this, such as mud flats. In the fire service, we are always a fan of dual-use. We are taking lessons and my colleague, Mr. Derek Whelan, is doing a review of the summer response to wildland fire. One of the things we see is the need for some specialised vehicles to work in tough terrain. We have some in the fire service already but we will do an evaluation and a piece on interoperation and to further strengthen that. Once again, that speaks to that dual-use piece where these vehicles will respond to highland areas but also mud flats and areas like Aughinish Alumina as well-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I apologise but I am really stuck for time here. Senator Craughwell did it again.

I apologise for cutting Mr. Leonard off.

Comment on this

I apologise for being late as I had another event to attend, unfortunately. With Civil Defence, I acknowledge the modernisation of the equipment, such as the drone equipment, search and rescue upskilling and all of the training that is going in. If the Laois branch is anything to go by, they are now housed in better buildings; they tended to be in all sorts of places in the past. In some places, Civil Defence units did not even have a venue or premises. It is all very welcome. On the volunteers, I realise they are volunteers. When there is an emergency, there is the fire service, Civil Defence and the outdoor staff of the councils. That is where it happens down there. On that, the volunteers will often be called out at night time and they can be called out to difficult, traumatic and tragic situations. Because of the training, they are the ones who are sent in and face the worst part of it first. That is the simplest way I can put it.

In terms of where they are called out at night, they are volunteers and they have daytime jobs. What is the provision there? Some of them will be working in the public sector. The majority of them will be in the private sector because there is a higher ratio of people in the private sector. Some will be retired and some will be retired from the Defence Forces and that is fair enough but a lot of them have day time jobs and families. What is the situation if I am called out at night and I am working for a private employer or in the public sector? What do I say to the boss if I have been out until 4 o'clock or 5 o'clock in the morning? What happens there?

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

The Deputy is correct. It is a very real challenge for volunteers and the welfare of the volunteers is managed locally by the Civil Defence officers. It is also something we want to look at from a Department perspective because we are aware other countries have arrangements with private industry where Civil Defence volunteers have some leave available to them if they are responding to duties. As part of our review of Towards 2030, which is our main strategy document, that is one of the things we will look to engage with private industry on when we start the review of that next year so there is some recognition of that volunteer piece and they will have some leave available to them. It is not in place at the moment, unfortunately. As I mentioned earlier, it is the personal responsibility of the volunteer and that comes into play here. The code of practice is that if you are responding, you have a responsibility to manage that welfare and you have a responsibility to manage your own rest yourself. Our ask would be that they do not respond and work the next day insofar as is possible.

On the tragic events the Deputy mentioned, we have a critical incident stress management service in place. In fact, all of our Civil Defence officers are attending that today in Roscrea. We have critical incident stress management for managers for the Civil Defence officers but also a service for our volunteers who may require it. There is a protocol around hot debriefings and follow-up debriefings after any exercise but particularly a tragic event such as the one the Deputy mentioned. They happen fairly frequently. At the moment, it is something that needs to be managed by the volunteer themselves.

Comment on this

In simple terms, the volunteers can manage so much of it but let us say they come back in at 4.30 a.m. and they are up for work at 6.30 a.m. or 6.45 a.m. to go to their day job. They have to be there, whatever way you try to manage it. In a small unit where there are not a lot of people, there may be just a handful of people trained in search and rescue or available and willing to go out during the night. The volunteer could be in a tricky position and I just wanted to highlight that.

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

I acknowledge that. It is a challenge for volunteers.

Comment on this

It is something that needs to be sorted but I acknowledge the progress that has been made with Civil Defence. The modernisation has been good.

Comment on this
Ms Cep Carty

It is definitely something we are very aware of.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Deputy Stanley. I have time to ask a question now. I commend the cross-Border work being done by Mr. Leonard and Mr. Whelan. I am concerned about the mandatory retirement age for firefighters here. There is no mandatory retirement age in the North. I met someone the other day who had been 20 years in the Defence Forces and 20 years in the fire service. Decades of experience have been built up. Is there any real logic to having a mandatory retirement age, providing, of course, fitness assessment requirements, etc., are met? Would the witnesses like to see this mandatory retirement age extended or removed?

Comment on this
Mr. Keith Leonard

This is certainly a sensitive and live issue in the fire service now. The retirement age in the fire service is 55, but it can be extended up to 62 with the appropriate medical overview and supervision. There is certainly a push to extend that beyond 62, and there are some very enthusiastic people who are well able to carry on beyond that point. However, at the moment, the legislative structure and framework is for prison officers and members of An Garda Síochána and the Defence Forces to retire at that age and for firefighters to retire at 62. Any movement in that, if it was to be made, would have to be made in concert. It could not happen within one agency. This was reviewed quite recently by the Department of public expenditure, which carries overall responsibility here. It did move the age to 62.

These things are always under review. We would certainly be open to listening to what anyone has to say in that space. I understand, as I said, where firefighters are coming from on this issue. The Cathaoirleach is right to point out that the benefit of the experience that senior firefighters bring to crews cannot be overestimated. I take that point wholeheartedly. I cannot, though, come in here and commit to making any changes to that at the moment.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I know Mr. Leonard will understand that we could not have this session today without bringing that up, because we are only as resilient as the workers we have within all of these forces. I think that was very much recognised yesterday as well by the public in terms of the real value of these agencies and the wider public sector that we really depend on. As Deputy Ó Laoghaire pointed out, we sometimes take them for granted until something critical happens.

We have to move on to the other sessions. I thank all the witnesses for being here this morning and for the valuable engagement we have had. We will now suspend briefly to allow for the change of witnesses, and then the committee will return to public session. Go raibh maith agat.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This is the second session today on building national resilience and national emergency planning. We are now joined by the following representatives of the County and City Management Association, CCMA: Mr. Kieran Kehoe, chair, CCMA corporate and emergency planning committee, and chief executive of Meath County Council; and Mr. John McLaughlin, chief executive of Donegal County Council. From the Association of Irish Local Government, AILG, we are joined by: Councillor Aengus O’Rourke, president, and Mr. Tommy Moylan, executive director. On behalf of the committee, I welcome all the witnesses here this morning.

The format of the meeting is that I will first invite the CCMA to make its opening statement, followed by the AILG. They will then be followed by questions from members of the committee. Each member has a seven-minute slot in which to ask questions and receive responses from the witnesses. I ask members to please adhere to these timings. Both members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction. I now invite Mr. Kehoe to deliver the CCMA opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

On behalf of the CCMA, I thank the Cathaoirleach and the committee members for inviting us to present the local government position on building national resilience and national emergency planning. We look forward to assisting the committee in its important deliberations on this hugely important topic. I will take the full submission as read and just pick out some highlights, if that is okay.

The Cathaoirleach has already introduced me. I am here in my capacity as chair of the CCMA corporate and emergency planning committee. As the Cathaoirleach said, joining me is Mr. John McLaughlin, chief executive of Donegal County Council. He is also a member of that committee. We also have Ms Susan O’Toole from the Local Government Management Agency, LGMA, with us today.

Local authorities are among the principal response agencies, PRAs, designated by the Government to respond to major emergencies. The other PRAs are An Garda Síochána and the Health Service Executive, HSE. Emergency readiness within the sector includes the preparations made at local level by each individual local authority and the various response and support teams within it; at regional level, by each major emergency management, MEM, region with our PRA partners; and nationally, by the CCMA, supported by the LGMA.

Keeping residents safe is a key priority for local authorities, and a key element of this is having plans and procedures in place to respond to emergency events. These plans and procedures, and their regular updating and practice events, provide an important step in the process of protecting people from injury and loss of life during an emergency event. All regional major emergency management groups have met in advance of this winter season and discussed preparedness across all areas.

Each local authority helps to keep communities safe by providing vital emergency services. These services include fire services, operational crews, community teams, Civil Defence, customer services and communications teams. All these teams work together to respond to major emergencies and severe weather events.

Firefighters work to reduce injury and death, protect properties and safeguard the environment when an emergency takes place. The fire service operates through the local authority to respond to fires, road traffic accidents, floods, chemical and hazardous-material incidents and other emergencies. This was highlighted only two days ago by the phenomenal response of Waterford City and County Council’s fire services, and I commend my colleagues there.

Our operational response crews, from our outdoor crews through to our engineering departments, play a vital role in emergency preparedness, emergency response and recovery. They are the front-line response to so many issues, such as flooding, fallen trees, road damage, house damage and clean-ups.

Our community teams are now a major extension of our emergency response, as they co-ordinate support for our communities and individuals therein. The new community support centres identified across the country are an additional support in the response to and recovery from an emergency.

Our Civil Defence volunteers support front-line emergency services in areas such as medical response, emergency response, search and rescue, radiation monitoring and community assistance. Civil Defence is a national, volunteer-based organisation facilitated through the local authorities. Its volunteers provide invaluable support to front-line responders, delivering an integrated, cohesive response when needed.

All local authorities now mobilise their customer service departments in an emergency so that there is a strong, co-ordinated response at local level, availing of critical local knowledge when somebody contacts us with an issue. Our communications teams play a vital role at all stages of the emergency response through issuing valuable advice in advance of an event regarding preparedness, critical up-to-date information throughout an event and much-needed information during the recovery phase of an event. A fast and co-ordinated response in severe weather emergencies is important for protecting lives, infrastructure and property, and the local authority is the principal response agency for severe weather events.

The CCMA corporate and emergency planning committee has responsibility for co-ordinating the sectoral response in an emergency. The chair of that committee, which I am currently, represents the sector at meetings nationally and working groups established to facilitate the response. When an emergency response is in progress, the CCMA and the Local Government Management Agency, LGMA, support the affected local authorities and regions by collating updates, raising significant matters at the relevant forums at a national level, including at the national severe weather and flood co-ordination group and the national emergency co-ordination group, NECG. If mutual assistance is required within the sector or from other agencies, it is co-ordinated centrally via the CCMA. We work closely with our partners in the national directorate of fire and emergency management, NDFEM, the Department of Defence and other Government Departments and agencies, including other principal response agencies, PRAs, An Garda Síochána, the HSE, Uisce Éireann and ESB Networks.

Following the recent Storm Chandra flooding events, the OPW, in collaboration with the CCMA, is progressing a procurement process to acquire more flood equipment, which will be stored across five local authorities. The NDFEM is also working with the sector on procuring seven high-capacity pumps to be located in seven other local authorities, and we welcome that support. As of 10 September this year, 572 community support centres had been identified across 28 local authorities, 124 generators were in place, with each local authority allocated three 100 kVA generators and one 30 kVA generator. The generators were supported by the Department of Rural and Community Development and the Gaeltacht, and we welcome that support.

A community support centre will not be required for every severe weather event, but generally for communities without services for periods approaching 72 hours. The CCMA was delighted to partner with the Department of Defence on the recently launched Be Emergency Ready booklet, which is being issued to every home in the State. The CCMA notes there is an increase in the frequency and severity of emergency events, including during the summer months with the wildfires experienced this summer.

Severe weather events of a prolonged nature can lead to resilience and resource issues, which may have an impact on the ability to continue to respond at the expected level. The sector is in a state of readiness ahead of this winter season, but it should be noted that the issuance of timely and accurate warnings is crucial to enable local authorities to react in a swift, safe and targeted manner. It is also essential that any outstanding recoupment of costs, including damage to road surfaces and other infrastructure from previous events, is continually paid to local authorities. Delays in this recoupment may lead to budgetary pressures ahead of a period when more costs may be incurred.

The level of outdoor staffing in local authorities has declined in recent years. It is crucial to fund and support a level of staffing to support deployment of emergency response teams, which sometimes lasts for days and can require rotas and shifts. The quick mobilisation of experienced and trained personnel is essential to emergency responses to keep communities safe. The CCMA looks forward to continuing to work with our colleagues in the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, particularly in the NDFEM, as well as the office of emergency planning in the Department of Defence, the Civil Defence and all key stakeholders of local authorities. We want everyone to be aware we are ready to respond and will continue to support our communities to keep them safe.

Comment on this
Mr. Aengus O'Rourke

I thank members for inviting the Association of Irish Local Government, AILG, to contribute to the committee's examination of building national resilience and national emergency planning. I am joined by our executive director, Mr. Tommy Moylan. Together, we represent AILG and Ireland's 949 councillors across the 31 local authorities.

We submitted a detailed paper, but our central message is quite simple, that national resilience is built locally. When a major storm hits, communities flood or electricity, water or communications are disrupted, a national emergency very quickly becomes a local one. Local authority staff respond on the ground and Civil Defence volunteers provide invaluable support. Communities mobilise and councillors are often the first to be contacted by the people affected. I saw that clearly in my hometown of Athlone following the serious flooding events of 2009 and 2015.

Westmeath County Council, working with the OPW, has delivered significant flood alleviation measures across the town. That work began in 2017 and continues today. It demonstrates the importance of learning from experience, investing in prevention and recognising that resilience requires ongoing attention.

Our submission makes three principal recommendations. We want greater visibility for Civil Defence and emergency preparedness in our elected councils. We propose an annual Civil Defence and emergency preparedness report to elected members, and that the adoption of the statutory Civil Defence plan should become a reserved function of the elected council. These plans deal with resources, volunteers, training, funding and equipment. They are strategic policy matters and elected councillors should have a meaningful role in shaping them. We also need to strengthen Civil Defence in areas where its capacity and reach are somewhat limited.

Second, we need a clearer national approach to the financial consequences of major emergencies. The costs do not end when the storm passes or the roads reopen. Damage to roads, bridges, drainage networks and other infrastructure can take months and sometimes years to repair and some damage may not become apparent until months after the storm. Flooding can weaken road foundations, leading to delayed subsidence. Trees can become destabilised by storms but remain standing, presenting serious ongoing, long-term risks. These are continuing consequences of emergencies, yet the financial burden often falls on already stretched local authority budgets. We therefore propose a national funding framework covering immediate response, clean-up, long-term assessment and infrastructure reinstatement, including, where appropriate, building back better and not just on a like-for-like basis.

Third, we must invest more in prevention and preparedness. Local authorities need access to emergency equipment, such as temporary flood barriers, generators, pumps and so on. We also propose community resilience hubs, using suitable community buildings where people can access heat, power, information, charging facilities, washing facilities and practical support during prolonged periods of disruption. Prevention must also include a nationally co-ordinated approach to dangerous trees, particularly on public roads near electricity infrastructure. Local authorities cannot reasonably be expected to identify and deal with every potentially dangerous roadside tree with existing budgets. The costs are substantial and unpredictable. We need clear national responsibilities, dedicated funding and stronger controls on unsuitable tree-planting, particularly near overhead power lines. Our submission also addresses communications resilience, cybersecurity and the particular needs of coastal communities.

We cannot prevent every storm, flood or emergency, but we can determine how prepared we are, how effectively we respond and how well our communities recover. That requires national leadership, properly funded local authorities, strong Civil Defence capacity and investment in prevention. National resilience is built locally and must be supported nationally. I thank the committee. We are happy to take any questions.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Before I go to members, I ask that they indulge me this once. I come from County Mayo in the west. With how we were affected by Storm Éowyn, we were begging for the Defence Forces to come in to clear trees, try to get the power lines up and so on. Normally, all the members go first and I go last, but I have to ask, whose responsibility was it to make the call for the Defence Forces to come in?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

It goes back to what I said about the national response I attended on behalf of the CCMA. We were in touch at least every morning and usually every hour during Storm Éowyn. A line could be drawn from Louth to Clare and everything north-west of it was destroyed by the impacts of Storm Éowyn. That was reflected strongly by us nationally. I engaged with my colleagues from across the western seaboard who were hit hard. We identified the issues and challenges, including the number of trees down and getting access to critical infrastructure. When to call in the Defence Forces is agreed nationally. There is a protocol under which army support is called for. I did so in my time in Laois at a flood event. It is done through a co-ordinated approach nationally. Locally we identify if there is a need.

The main response we sought for the survey on the number of trees down was the support of the forestry contractors that Coillte has access to. It is a specialist-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I need to get to the nub of this. Whose responsibility was it to call in-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Ultimately, a local authority can call. Any of the agencies can call so we can call.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The local authorities could have called in the Defence Forces at that time.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Through a protocol, yes.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

They chose not to.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

At the time, they were not called in.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

If we were to have a similar storm in the future, would the Defence Forces be called in?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

One calls in the specialists where one needs their help. The Army would not necessarily have chainsaw operators. We would have deployed chainsaw operators even from my own country, which was not affected.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The CCMA did not see a role-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We needed specialist machinery that the forestry contractors with Coillte have. Those contractors were deployed and we redeployed our own people from across the country as chainsaw operators. That is not necessarily a skill set that Army personnel would have. While it would have big machines and people, it would not necessarily have those specialist-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The CCMA did not see any role. I am not referring to Mr. Kehoe personally-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

No, we did not.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The CCMA did not see any role for the Defence Forces.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Not for that.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Even when we went for days without electricity, heating or water?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Those issues were being addressed by the Civil Defence with regard to getting water. Water was dropped off at every house that needed water, while other things were being provided. We set up the community support centres. This was done through us and our community teams, etc. It was not a function that the Army would provide.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The local authorities made that decision.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Yes.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I wanted to get a straight answer to that.

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

It is an interesting question to ask. I am a member of Donegal County Council. We quite often call in the Defence Forces for the clean-up after severe weather. The Defence Forces should also answer the Cathaoirleach's question but I will give my perspective. We call the Defence Forces quite often. In the past, we were often asked why we did not call them. It is an obvious question to ask so we would call them. However, the Defence Forces have limitations too regarding what they can do. We have experienced that, their protocol and the types of machines they have in their training. We would normally call now but the issue deserves further debate because sometimes we run out of people. It is about what we can get from our Army. That needs to be developed in my view.

Regarding the protocol for an immediate call-out, the Defence Forces have a very strict protocol for what they will prioritise when they get a number of phone calls. I am not at liberty to say that on their behalf but it would be a worthwhile issue for this committee to explore.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am still not clear on that but I will go on to the members, starting with Deputy Brian Stanley. Maybe we can clear up some of the issues that are not so clear as the discussion process.

Comment on this

I thank the representatives of the councils and local authority employees for attending. The opening statements dealt with the nuts and bolts and practicalities of emergency response. It just shows the importance of local government in terms of response because that is where it happens, at local level. Mr. O'Rourke and Mr. Kehoe outlined that very clearly in their presentations.

Mr. Kehoe touched on the number of outdoor staff. This is a bone of contention for me and I may have spoken to him about it a few times when he was in Laois. I certainly chewed the ears off county managers regularly about it. While the number of staff in the councils is increasing significantly, the number of outdoor staff is declining. In the event of an emergency in Laois, we are looking at in the region of 50 outdoor staff. I think we had 49 or 50 outdoor staff during the most recent emergency. This is totally inadequate in three very large municipal districts. What can be done about that? Perhaps Mr. O'Rourke or Mr. Moylan could answer. I know both of them do great work pushing the importance of local government, for which I thank them because they are performing a national service. What can be done to address this because some people will say, "Sure the workforce plan is being submitted", but people in the council will say it is for approval by the Department. If a local authority does not put in for enough outdoor, manual and semi-skilled staff, it will not get them. People in the upper echelons of the council will then say the Department will not approve it. What can we do about this because we are threadbare? Mr. Kehoe mentioned it in his opening statement. It is not often that a manager will admit that. I am glad he admitted to us. Mr. O'Rourke touched on this as well. What can we do about this? I ask the witnesses to keep their replies short because I have other questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Obviously, we would call for increased funding for the local government sector.

Anything we have raised here is obviously a very serious issue for us.

The work our front-line people do is critical. They are the front face of every local authority across the country, not just in an emergency response but every day of the week. Critically in an emergency response, they are the people I call, whether I called in Laois or Waterford or I call now in Meath, to help local people because there is nothing like people in the local authority who are working for local people and their neighbours, friends and family. That is what our people do every day of the week. We will have lots of work. It might be a storm for whatever number of weeks in a year but every other week of the year, there is lots of work for our people. I would ask for support to secure increased funding for local authority outdoor staff.

Comment on this
Mr. Aengus O'Rourke

Deputy Stanley's point is a very good one. I will talk about the levels of staffing in our local authority structures. They stood at 35,000 in 2008. They fell to 30,000 in 2012 and were at 32,500 in 2025. What that tells us is that the local authority human resources complement is less today than it was in 2008, so we have a lot of ground to make up in terms of manpower at local authority level. It also points to a local authority structure that is underfunded effectively.

Comment on this

How long has that shortage been there? The number has started going back up. In the councils with which I am familiar, the numbers seem to have increased, which is welcome. I would certainly never argue against that but what I am saying is that while numbers are increasing, the number of outdoor staff is reducing. Collectively, the members and the witnesses have a responsibility to make a combined effort. Do the CCMA or AILG have figures on outdoor and indoor staff that we could bring to Ministers and ask them to sort this out because it is not just an issue when emergencies arise? Despite the best efforts of local area staff, I can see and, as a councillor, Mr. O'Rourke will see it more so than I would, that basic maintenance is not being done. It cannot be done because the local authorities do not have the staff to do it. That is a problem.

My next question concerns the local emergency groups. I was the one who said the AILG should be here today. I mean no disrespect to our comrades in the CCMA but the AILG should be at the committee, wherever possible. Will Mr. Kehoe outline what councillors' involvement in those meetings is? Who chairs them at local level when there is an emergency?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

When we get to the level of an emergency, we have our severe weather assessment teams beforehand and then the crisis management team during the middle of an emergency. The latter is typically chaired by me as chief executive or the controller of our operations in a local authority, who is typically a director of services. The councillors are kept informed, which is why I mentioned the importance of our communications team. As the AILG said, councillors are people who get representations immediately from the people who need or want help, so they have to have a strong communication channel between us and our communications team. That is why our response has changed from what it would have been maybe 15 years ago in my experience when we would have had engineers, An Garda Síochána and the ambulance service. We now have our communications team and customer service team. We have our community team engaging with councillors.

Comment on this

Is there a missing piece? Should it not be the Cathaoirleach of the council chairing or co-chairing that, along with-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

I have to say there is a difference between reserved functions and executive functions. There is a reserved function and an executive function. I have to protect that and only a change in the law would change that. An executive function is to respond to the emergency, as I do in my role, and we obviously keep the members informed.

Comment on this

Keeping them informed is fine but as the opening statement said, there are 949 councillors and they are in every community. They are the link between Joe and Mary Public and the council. My point is that there should be councillor involvement in that. It has to be a joint effort. At the very least, the council chairperson should be present at those meetings. Maybe this is something the AILG would look at. I know Mr. Moylan is battling for major reform at the moment.

Comment on this
Mr. Tommy Moylan

I take the Deputy's point. When a storm, a major weather event or any other emergency happens, it is probably all hands on deck and it is about responding on the ground. As our president said in the statement, there is a role in the preparation and planning for these events. That is why we said that, regardless of whether the Civil Defence statutory plan becomes a fully reserved function, there should be constant input into that.

I appreciate there is a distinction between operational and policy matters, and some elements of that plan are operational, but it is the councillors who adopt the annual budget. They are the ones providing the funding for it. There should be a role. It is in the preparedness part where there should be a greater role for elected councillors. As I said, when an emergency happens, it is all hands on deck.

Comment on this

To clarify, is Mr. Moylan saying councillors should approve the plan?

Comment on this
Mr. Tommy Moylan

As in our statement, we are looking for it to be a reserve function.

Comment on this

How does the CCMA feel about that?

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Your time is up, Deputy.

Comment on this

Just briefly, does it think it is a good idea, yes or no?

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

I might add a point or two. It is important to acknowledge the role of our elected members. Using any of the storms in Donegal as an example, we always update members. Sometimes it might be a bit ad hoc or informal but we totally rely on members knowing what is going on in their localities. For example, when the power was out during Storm Éowyn, nobody knew. We called the councillors in the local area and they told us. That was a phone call. They knew on the ground if houses were out. I acknowledge their role even though it is not structurally in the format. We are quite happy that we will work with whatever system is-----

Comment on this

On the question of whether approving the emergency plan at local level-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

You are a minute over time. I have give time to the other members.

Comment on this

Just a yes or no.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We approved the fire services plan and the emergency measures plan has come through, so a Civil Defence operational plan would be no issue.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is very important that councillors be involved in the decision-making. When decisions are to be made in the middle of all this, it is the councillors who get it in the neck as to why this or that is not done. Having been a councillor, I will stand up for the councillors.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses to Leinster House. I thank them for the great work they do locally. I have seen it at first hand.

On the question of aid to the civil authority, a long time ago, I was a battery commander in the second field artillery regiment in McKee Barracks. I am originally from Finglas. For our neighbours in Ballymun, the lifts in the Ballymun towers were not working so we were asked to go out. Over about a week to ten days, we literally carried buggies up and down the stairwells in the flats, people with mobility issues, elderly people and shopping. The problem was trying to get the troops out of the Ballymun flats and back to the barracks. They could not do enough. Deputy Callaghan has more experience in this area, but when it comes to engineering, power, diesel generators and lighting, Army barracks are full of young men and women who want to be doing stuff. I often see pictures after flooding of families being taken out of flooded area in the buckets of JCBs. There are loads of high-axle vehicles in the barracks in Athlone and all around the country. All they want you to do is ask and they will not be able to do enough for you. They are really excellent at that. They do it overseas when they dig wells, provide water and power and build schools. It is a human asset that should be used more often.

I am sorry for the bit of a preamble. During the beast from the east, if the witnesses recall, a number of years back we had that severe snow incident. From time to time, with improvements in weather forecasting, we have advance warning and a window of opportunity to plan. During the beast from the east, it came to my attention what a lot of disabled citizens were told. If the witnesses recall, Leo Varadkar had the high-vis jacket on at the emergency co-ordination centre in Agriculture House. He asked Irish citizens not to leave the house the following day after 4 p.m. - I think it was a Thursday. A lot of disabled citizens with care packages were told they would receive no care supports for about 72 hours. Disabled citizens who were wheelchair users in my area, Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown, were told, "I can put you on the bed for 72 hours in a nappy or I can put you in the wheelchair in a nappy for 72 hours and you can try to sleep in it. At least if you are in the wheelchair, you can make yourself a cup of tea". When the witnesses liaise with their HSE colleagues, do they make special provision for disabled citizens? Do they know how many disabled citizens there are in their local authority areas and their needs? That is something the Defence Forces could perhaps assist with in getting carers in high-axle and four-wheel-drive vehicles to the people in our communities who need it most - disabled or elderly citizens who need home care supports.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

More recently in preparation for Storm Éowyn, we knew it was going to be the most severe storm that had ever hit the country, as Met Éireann predicted. It was probably even worse than predicted. In the regional meetings I mentioned and at local authority meetings, there is the Garda and numerous elements of the HSE. We all confirm we are aware of the vulnerable people on our own vulnerable persons lists. We made sure they were contacted. It is an important role of the Civil Defence, from our point of view. Our primary use is to contact it in advance. It does a lot of transfers for HSE staff as well to make sure they can get in and out whether that is during flooding or snow.

As Mr. McLaughlin referenced, we have used the Army for that as well. I used the Army in Laois in a flood event and we used the Army during the snow event of early February 2025 in the Limerick, north Tipperary and Kerry areas. We used the high-axle vehicles as well. From the vulnerable persons point of view, we all know individually where they are. At that group table, we make sure every vulnerable person has been contacted and make sure they are okay.

Comment on this

Maybe it is a city thing. Dublin can be a bit impersonal. I did not know the names of the people four doors away from me when I was growing up in Finglas.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

One of the most valuable people is the postperson. They know each person. We engage with An Post and its local people to make sure everybody who could possibly be vulnerable is contacted to make sure they are okay.

Comment on this

We will have an accelerating number of climate events. We know that. Under the Petersberg tasks agreed by European Union leaders - that is the name of the hotel; they were not in St. Petersburg - the Defence Forces, if required, can assist in natural disasters. It is a European-wide requirement. During the beast from the east, I was writing about this as a journalist at the time. I contacted the HSE and its national directorate of communications. It purported not to know how many disabled citizens there were in each of the CHOs. It said it was because some of it was contracted out to for-profit private healthcare providers. I do not want to get into the nitty-gritty of it but the idea of a disabled person wearing a nappy for 72 hours, not being able to sleep lying down and not being able to get a hot meal is pretty stark in the 21st century. I hope matters in relation to that have improved since the beast from the east. I urge the witnesses to talk to their HSE colleagues, local Rehab, Enable Ireland, Better at Home or Home Instead, whichever provides the services, and tell them that if they need support with transport, it can be provided through the Defence Forces.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

One of the great benefits of having all the agencies around the table is that we all know the different people who are vulnerable for different reasons, whether it is health or otherwise. In Meath, we host the age-friendly service for the whole country, Age Friendly Ireland, with a full network across the country. We can engage with all those mechanisms and are able to identify vulnerable people so that nobody is missed.

Comment on this

The local is so powerful. I had people in here last week for dinner. One of them met a TD from Tipperary who sits on this committee. He said, "My mother was with your mother in Medjugorje last week". It is that network of support and Irish people are brilliant when it comes to helping - meitheal. I ask that it be formalised in some way with specific reference to the disabled and elderly.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Senator Clonan. Mr. O'Rourke wants to comment. Briefly, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Aengus O'Rourke

To go along with the remarks made by the Senator in relation to the willingness of the Defence Forces to support and help whenever asked, I can only say they have always stood up in particular in Athlone when we had various flood events. The beast from the east was also an event where we called in the Army and it could not have been more helpful.

On the vulnerable folk, perhaps it is a city thing but in provincial Ireland the councillors on the ground very often know those who are most vulnerable in their district or area. That gives us a sense of comfort that we should be well-covered in relation to the people who are most vulnerable in our society.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is about making the decisions when there are all these agencies so that somebody is accountable and responsible.

Comment on this

Similar to the last session, yesterday's industrial action was an opportunity to reflect on the crucial role of public servants' pay. Often, a lot of the work is not seen or not always appreciated until the time of greatest need. I possibly said this at the committee before but I recall having a conversation with an organiser in my own party when he said to me that nobody ever gets any credit for the row that never happened. There is a lot of work that local councils do that is the row that never happened.

My first question is for both organisations. The AILG submission talks about community resilience hubs. I understand there was a funding stream for community associations asking them to register as locations to which people could present in situations of emergencies, whether storm related, major energy shortfalls or whatever. That went out and I am curious whether there is a sense of what the take-up was like. Maybe it is too early to say because that was only put out in the last 12 months but I wonder had gaps become apparent in different parts of the country and whether there was an imbalance between urban and rural. It strikes me there could be remote parts of the country with a local community hall and the willingness is there but the premises might not be big and there might not be a lot of parking. There might have been a community association which decided not to apply because it does not have the capacity to do that even though it is the only premises of the kind in the area.

I echo what Deputy Stanley said. I know that in some local authorities when it comes to outdoor staff there is an increasing reliance on private, contracted-out work. The area of housing maintenance might not be specifically relevant to this area but it is one example that is a big issue in a lot of local authorities and it might also be true in relation to roads and other areas too. It is worth underlining that.

During the first session we were thinking very much about high-level, strategic, geopolitical and hybrid threats and in this session we are talking about local government, storms and power outages. However, the truth is both need to be fully integrated. We need to ensure the local authorities are part of the planning for those big hybrid incidents and that those big emergencies which are weather related and so on are part of national planning. It all has to be integrated. I am curious whether the CCMA or the AILG was part of Operation PÚCA or similar. Is there a sense of how local government fits in to hybrid attacks, for example, that target public services like energy and communications?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Community support centres are something that would have been arranged locally for ten or 15 years and during Storm Éowyn, due to the extended nature of the power outages, they became more formalised. There are now formalised structures and guidance documents. As I said in my submission, we have identified 572 of these community support centres across the country. We have them mapped and identified. They have been developed in close conjunction with the communities themselves and other community teams as well. We have a very strong geographic spread across our county so we know every part of our county is covered by a centre within a few kilometres of where an event may or may not happen.

Comment on this

There are no huge gaps anywhere in the country.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Not that we are identifying, no. There are 572. Two of them are now ready to go with generators that have been provided to us with the changeover switches. That is growing every week and more are being connected with the changeover switches. We are quite strong. Going back to Waterford, it established a community support centre hub within close proximity for a different reason but in relation to an emergency. It shows that they are there and are ready to activate and ready to go. Mr. McLaughlin can talk about his particular experience of mobilising his over a smaller storm. They are there and happening and there is a community-based response.

The question of staff was mentioned again and I will give my own example of Meath, which is the fastest growing county over the last two census periods. In that period we have substantially increased our staff as well. We have thousands more people living in the county, thankfully. We have hundreds more estates. They all need maintenance, responses and cleaning. I do not want the message going out that we are not putting more staff in. I have put in between 30 and 35 staff members over the last three years. Some of those are water services staff coming across as well. We are ramping up but you could always do with more, particularly when you get into these emergency response parts.

Regarding our role in the high level, we are critical. We are the response agency, but the response agency needs to be part of overall planning and strategic preparations. We are front and centre to any of those planning processes at national level. I have to commend everyone from the Department of Defence, NDFEM and our own Department on the co-ordination. All the necessary Departments, including Transport and Rural and Community Development and the Gaeltacht, come together with this collegial attitude that they just want to response in the best way for the citizen. However, we are part of any plans and projects.

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

It is good that the hubs are supported to some level financially. Even a small amount of money makes a difference for people. To use Donegal as an example, a number of community centres did their own thing as well and got things in ahead of us. They said they were going to do it as well and they got generators in. Some did not and some could not. We worked together on that. We have selected ones to cover the county as best we could, with those facilities for parking and so on, and tried to develop them. They are now available.

We are totally reliant on that voluntary effort as a country. They come together whether it is GAA clubs or our community centres. They do it and they do not have to be asked. They are ready to go. It is incumbent on us to support them as much as we can to be ready. One item is the generators. There was a lot of talk about the generators but it is not only about the generators. Although power obviously makes a big difference in a centre, we need the other supports as well and we rely on them. We have a good spread. We mobilise them. We might only need two or three at a time and they go and set up immediately and do it for us. They can turn it around quicker than us at times. There are people who are willing right now and they are set up and geared to it. We want to support them as much as we can in this. Those smaller funds that they get are very useful.

I will come in on staffing just for a minute because Deputy Stanley mentioned it as well. What controls our outdoor staff numbers is the ability to pay for them. We have to balance the budget at the end of the year and we have to fund it. There are a number of funding strands. That sets it. We all have workforce plans all around the country now but what governs it is the ability to pay people all year. That is what sets it. Over the years that has been tighter and tighter. We all know about inflation and the cost of materials and equipment. The more that squeezes up the less you have left. It is an issue, as Mr. Kehoe mentioned in the opening statement. It controls how many people we can respond with right now if we get a call. It makes a difference.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is it the chief executive's decision about the disciplines? If the authority is recruiting, can it opt for an outdoor staff member rather than a member in communications or some other area?

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

To a point, but we have three or four strands. Particularly in the rural counties, they are governed by State grants and those State grants come with limitations.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

They will tell you where. I see recruitment being done in one area but not in outdoor staff.

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

We are often told by central government to employ a certain type of people only. Very often we get 75% funding the first year and 50% and 25% in the next. Then we are left with somebody with a permanent contract and needing to put up 100% ourselves. Those things create difficulties for us in our funding model.

Comment on this

I thank everyone for coming in today. I will start to try to get a little more clarity about the aid to the civil authority. When a local authority is in the midst of a physical emergency, be it a storm or a flood, at what point does the chief executive recognise that this is beyond the capability of the local authority? Is there ever any hesitancy there? That is my first question.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

I thank the Deputy. There would be no hesitancy. Both I and Mr. McLaughlin have been that animal on loads of occasions over the last ten years whether as a director of services, a controller of operations and now chief.

We are constantly looking and evaluating the situation. That is part of the process. There is a constant review of where we are at and what defines a major emergency. There is a major emergency management framework in place nationally and that was probably discussed in the previous session. There are strict criteria involving threat to life or a situation beyond the capability of all of the agencies to respond. There are very strict criteria covering what can be called a major emergency. That is why I have only witnessed two in my time. One was the hospital in County Wexford when we were evacuating the emergency services and the other was during Storm Ophelia when the roof blew off a stadium in County Kilkenny. It is not that there is a hesitancy, but there are strict criteria to call it a major emergency. We operate in accordance with the framework. We do everything in the major emergency management framework; we just do not define it as a major emergency. What is happening and coming down the line is a more generic term or allowance that one can declare an emergency but that does not mean it is a major one. We still respond in the same way, however.

Comment on this

Does the chief executive in each local authority have the authority to decide when an emergency has gone beyond the capability of the local-----

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

There are three people who can call it: the chief executive, the chief fire officer and the director of services or controller of operations.

Comment on this

Fantastic. Those three people together make that call.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

They can make it individually. The chief fire officer could call it as well.

Comment on this

Okay. They each have the authority to call it.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Each has the authority. A chief fire officer might be immediately attending to an emergency 999 call and there could be a serious threat to life beyond the individual agency’s ability to respond. Those three people can call it.

Comment on this

I am conscious that we are at the defence committee. If Mr. Kehoe chooses to call on the Defence Forces, is it the case that he tells the Defence Forces what capability the situation needs? Is it up to the Defence Forces to then let him know if they can fulfil that capability or how does that work?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

There is a very strict protocol in relation to how we call on the support of the Defence Forces. We have to be very specific in relation to what the ask is.

Comment on this

I am open to hearing the specifics if Mr. Kehoe is open to sharing them.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

I will give an example of when I utilised the Defence Forces when I was in County Laois and there was a major flood in Mountmellick. We utilised them to support the clean up, as the Senator referenced. We had to define what use we wanted them for. We wanted them to bring in their high-level vehicles. At that stage, the flood had abated, funny enough. Our Civil Defence had taken people in boats, so we had the ability to do that part of it but it was the clean-up aspect of going into properties, removing stuff that was damaged and filling skips that we needed help with. We were very specific in the ask.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Kehoe simply ask for the capability or does he state what he wants done and the Defence Forces then indicate whether they can fulfil that? Is the whole operation commanded by the Defence Forces or does the local authority tell the Defence Forces what it wants them to do?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

It is controlled by the controller of operations or the chief executive on the ground. We retain control. We ask them and direct them to do whatever the ask is.

Comment on this

So command does not stay with the Defence Forces.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

They command their own people, but their commander reports to and is instructed by the controller of operations; the lead on the site. There has to be a strict line of control and command at any incident to make sure that people are doing the right thing as asked by a single person or entity in charge, and that is the local authority person.

Comment on this

The Defence Forces take their instructions from the chief executive.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Or a controller of operations. Typically it is the controller of operations but it can also be the chief executive.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Kehoe for clearing that up.

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

We have examples of wildfires on the hills where we need helicopters and so on to come in. We are not here to talk about what the Defence Forces have or do not have in terms of capability. In fairness, that is a matter for them.

Comment on this

That is not a question I am asking. I am asking about the process for how it works.

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

I know that. It is very hard to get helicopters in Ireland to go to fight fires. We end up going to a private firm, Executive Helicopters, to do it, and we pay a lot for that service. Sometimes we cannot get up to the fire with normal fire-fighting equipment and we need to do something and there is not much time, as Mr. Kehoe said, so we need somebody right away. That is an area that could be examined. The committee is going to form policy at the end of this so it is useful to have that information. It might be useful for the committee to chat to the Defence Forces regarding the response. We have called Athlone at times from County Donegal. They are looking at a very big region. What can they afford to send to Donegal and what do the other counties? That all needs to be considered. It is grand when it is only one location. It is an important part of our response capability as a country and it could be developed more.

Comment on this

I will move on to the next piece. What we have spoken about a lot is our physical resilience. As was mentioned, national resilience starts locally. Please correct me if I am wrong, but I have checked the briefing documents from the CCMA and the AILG. When it comes to cyber-resilience, I do not see it. I see it mentioned ten times with the AILG, but I do not see it mentioned at all in the briefing document. I am curious about that. I ask Mr. Kehoe to comment on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We have a phenomenally strong cybersecurity resilience built up individually. Of course, we are responsible for number one individually.

Comment on this

Individually, as in each local authority?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We have systems as a local authority first. We have our own systems to protect ourselves individually but we also operate in conjunction with the Local Government Management Agency, which prepares and supplies an extra level of resilience for the overall local government sector. We engage very closely with the National Cyber Security Centre as well. Any threat or attack that comes into us is identified. Myself and Mr. McLaughlin got an email at 8.25 p.m. last night from the LGMA advising us of a potential threat that was happening. We are focused on emergencies such as severe weather and flooding but we are similarly protected from cyberattacks.

Comment on this

Mr. Kehoe is talking about the local authority’s own systems but I am talking about a hybrid emergency. If there is a hybrid attack in the community, how does the local authority respond to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

That is outside our function.

Comment on this

It is good to know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We protect what we can do and how we can respond in our systems but we are not responsible-----

Comment on this

In terms of the local authority's emergency response, it is an emergency response in a physical way, not in a hybrid way.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

And by making sure our buildings and IT systems are all protected and able to withstand an attack.

Comment on this

But not for the community. Do the representatives from the AILG have a response to that? The AILG seems to have more of a focus on the cyber aspect; that is why I am curious.

Comment on this
Mr. Tommy Moylan

In the operation of our training programme, we are doing a lot of work around cybersecurity for our members in general. With the way the world has gone geopolitically, those cyberattacks and digital attacks are there and we need resilience to them as well as to physical threats or emergencies. A local authority can only protect its own systems, and that is where we were coming from. Our members need an increased skills capacity around it and a lot of knowledge, and that is what we are doing as part of our training programme with our members to make them aware of it. What we are calling for is sectoral investment and support for the sector to invest in cybersecurity infrastructure, staff awareness and incident response for the local authority sector. If we take the HSE attack that happened a number of years ago, that was its responsibility. Every sector needs to have the right protection.

Comment on this

Every sector would like to be better resourced in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Tommy Moylan

Absolutely. That is why we mentioned it in our submission.

Comment on this

I welcome both groups and thank them for their presentations. The representatives of the CCMA advocate very well on behalf of their colleagues. That said, I put on the record that my area has probably one of the best county managers in the country in Eoin Doyle. I thank Mr. O’Rourke, uachtarán of AILG, and Mr. Moylan for their advocacy on behalf of the councillors of this country and indeed, their sister organisation, LAMA.

In his presentation, Mr. O’Rourke outlined a number of proposals, and I could not disagree with any of them. The one I ask him to elaborate on is the community resilience hubs. How does he see them working out. What sort of a radius would there be between each of the hubs?

In relation to his proposal that the Civil Defence statutory plan should be a reserved function, I fully agree with that.

I give a commitment that I will speak to my colleagues and attempt to amend the Local Government Act in that regard. I am glad that the managers' association has no difficulty with that.

This is a question for both organisations. As the witnesses are aware, the Civil Defence is funded on a 70-30 basis, which means that 70% of funding comes from the Department of Defence and 30% comes from the local authorities. However, the onus to provide a headquarters lies entirely with the local authorities. I know that in my county of Cavan, a fabulous headquarters opened in the past year and a half. Three new units were converted into a Civil Defence headquarters. It works well. However, it cost the local authority over €1 million. That is money that the local authority could have used in other important areas. I believe the funding of headquarters should come down in its entirety to the Department of Defence. I believe that the entire funding of the Civil Defence should come down to the Department of Defence and there should be no onus on the local authorities to contribute. I am interested in the witnesses' views in that regard.

A new emergency alert system is proposed. I understand the Department of communications is preparing a tender at the moment for such a system. Have the witnesses, as managers, been asked for their input on that tender? I would be interested to hear about that.

I will turn to Mr. O'Rourke. We have talked about building back better in the context of the damage caused during storms and floods, etc. Perhaps the representatives of either organisation would respond on getting funding from the Department. What kinds of delays are there? What type of money are we talking about?

Comment on this
Mr. Aengus O'Rourke

I thank the Senator. My presentation spoke about the importance of experience. We have all been thorough many extreme weather events at this stage. We can only expect to find ourselves in more of those circumstances in the years ahead. You cannot beat experience. If Storm Éowyn taught us anything, it was how we can and should respond as a community in our various provincial areas. We have all seen it in our own areas. The local GAA club emerged in many areas as the place where people could find refuge. It was a place to wash, converge, get information, charge equipment and whatever else. Through that process, the clubs established themselves as the hubs of the future.

Storm Éowyn was a real emergency and not a trial. Over time, it might be no harm for districts to do dry runs in their localities to ensure that the systems they assume are in place work on the ground. We can all agree that the extent to which the community and volunteers emerged as champions around Storm Éowyn was a credit to every community. I have no doubt that it will continue in the future but they need to be properly resourced. There need to be proper charging facilities and generators where they should be. There needs to be capacity to provide clean drinking water, etc. We cannot expect to respond at the time of the event. Preparedness is everything. We in the AILG are making that point clearly today and through our network of delegates and members.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

I thank the Senator. For his information, I am the chair of the corporate and emergency planning committee of the CCMA. Mr. McLaughlin is a member. The esteemed Mr. Eoin Doyle is the third chief executive member of the committee and a valuable member. He works closely and manages the whole Civil Defence piece for us.

Of course, I will say that we would more than welcome 100% funding for any buildings or kit, but, to be fair, we have to acknowledge that we get a lot of support from the Department of Defence. If it could be fully funded, of course we would love it. That money could, as the Senator said, be spent somewhere else.

We are not aware of any national alert system that is currently out to tender. We have not been engaged on that matter.

The Senator asked about building back better. To be fair to the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, we deploy our staff and put them out, and there is overtime and expenses. To be fair, we get that cost covered, as we do the cost of our own housing stock. Some of our housing stock was damaged during Storm Éowyn and the cost of repairs was funded. There are also costs for fire and other costs I do not have any experience of costs not being covered by the Department to date.

We operate across so many different Departments. The Department of Transport is the other big Department. Lots of road damage happens as a result of floods or storms. We repair immediately, as much as we can. We do that in trust. We cover it for months or potentially up to a year. There is a challenge. We need to ensure that we secure all that funding. There have been examples of situations where that has not happened to the fullest extent over the past two years. We understand there are budgetary pressures nationally in the Department of Transport.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am sorry for cutting across Mr. Kehoe but I must go to Deputy Brabazon. Deputy Michael Cahill has been waiting for a long time but is not a permanent member of the committee. I invite either of the Deputies to go first. I apologise. Deputy Cahill is now a permanent member of the committee. I ask him to go first. He indicated first. I apologise.

Comment on this

There will be no follow-up from Deputy Brabazon or me.

I welcome our guests to this important meeting. I acknowledge the work of all of our emergency services, including the fire service, the Defence Forces, ambulance services and local authorities. Work is carried out in response to car accidents and flooding, be it tidal flooding or rainwater. I have a habit of saying that because I am used to tidal flooding where I come from, for example in Rossbeigh and Cromane. There is a big difference between having the Atlantic Ocean in your home, which I have witnessed, and rainwater.

I am thinking about the context of fires and storms. I acknowledge all our local authorities. I am familiar with Kerry County Council and its emergency response teams. I acknowledge all council workers and our area engineers for the work that is carried out when there is an emergency as a result of any of the issues I have highlighted.

I want to avail of the opportunity to mention fires specifically. It might not be appropriate to this particular meeting but I want to ask about forest fires. It should be an absolute rule that there are firebreaks in public or private forestry areas near houses.

I welcome my colleagues from the AILG, namely, Mr. Tommy Moylan and Mr. Aengus O'Rourke. I am a former member of the AILG. National resilience is hugely important. We are an island. I come from a coastal county. There needs to be coastal resilience.

We have touched this morning on cybersecurity. Cyberattacks are only going to become more common. There is work to be done in that area.

In regard to our national defence, we are coming from a low ebb in the context of budgets. There was never a really decent budget for national defence. Thankfully, I hear more and more about it every week since I became a TD and, in fairness to the Taoiseach, he has mentioned it at numerous meetings. There is a need for a greater budget.

Local authorities are nearly the first port of call in the case of accidents, flooding, fires, storms and forest fires. When the war broke out in Ukraine, the local authorities carried out tremendous work. I saw it at first hand in my own county but it was every local authority in every part of the country. That should be acknowledged and they should be supported financially and in every other way.

I am a former member of the AILG. I was on the executive. I acknowledge the work carried out by Mr. Moylan and Mr. O'Rourke, their colleagues on the executive, both past and present, and the ordinary members. The most important thing for me to say is that there are very important issues the AILG brings to the fore, highlights and whose members do their very best always to address.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We all absolutely acknowledge the great work done by councillors throughout the country. It is not getting any easier, that is for sure.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I am sorry I missed the presentations. I was asking questions of the Minister for Health. I read the presentations overnight and a number of questions arose from that coupled with my experience of issues with flooding, storms and so on. Last year, I saw the Minister of State, Deputy Moran, on a north county Dublin beach unveil new groynes that had been installed by the OPW and I thought this was great because we could go to him and ask him for more of this because it is needed, certainly around the coast on the northside of Dublin city and into Fingal. Apparently, that is not how it is done and that was an exceptional project. Do the witnesses think the funding for that type of work would be better being centralised with the OPW or with the local authorities?

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

I think it is coastal erosion and we are a coastal county. There is a big debate about who handles this, what the response is and whether we leave the coast to erode forever. Those are the questions facing the country. Local authorities do not answer those questions even though we are participating and get all of the negative questions out. The largest, the OPW, controls all of that.

We are happy to do works for anyone if they are fully funded; that is no problem. The big one here can be the environmental clearance, working in the coastal areas and then putting in a groyne. Sometimes it is hard to get approvals. We are happy when we see that happening all around the coast. It is getting eroded every year and that is something that is facing the country. A lot of studies have been done on this but the solution is unclear at the moment. The funding and who does it - the implementation - can be the easier part if you know clearly what you are going to do and you know you can get the environmental approvals. We are happy to participate in the delivery, and we often do, but the OPW plays a big part in the solution and whether we put in hard defences, soft defences or no defences and deal with the consequences.

Comment on this

Does Mr. McLaughlin think the structure that exists is sufficient to deal with those coastal erosion problems?

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

It is not my place to comment on the structure of the OPW. What I will say about our role, on behalf of local authorities and on behalf of Mr. Kehoe, is that we have co-operated with many bodies. That is our job and we do it. Whether we like it or not we fit in and do our part, and we will continue to do that anywhere in the country and under any structure.

Comment on this

I want to move on to AI. I have a constituent who has a master's degree from Trinity. He came to me with a proposal to use AI to accelerate flood defence projects around the country. Currently, the delivery for a flood defence project is around ten years from concept to completion. He was of the view that period could be radically reduced to possibly two or three years. Do the witnesses have any view on the use of AI to speed up flood defence projects?

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

We are equally frustrated that major flood defence projects take so long. Under the CFRAM programme - people probably know the headings - it takes years and years and it is a big process. Even though we do them sometimes with the OPW and use our planning system, that whole environmental process means years and years of consultation. People think we should build them right away. We know what the solution is; get out and build it. Some of those things are fundamental and I do not know whether AI would affect them. We would welcome AI as part of all of our futures in a sensible and controlled manner. If somebody had a good idea, they should start with a suggestion to the OPW and how its systems and structures would blend together and we would certainly follow that.

Comment on this
Mr. Aengus O'Rourke

We have some experience of it in Athlone. We are just completing, in our 11th year, a flood defence programme which involved eight cells amounting to a €36 million spend. It was very frustrating to get the ground broken and the first cell took an inordinate amount of time. Maybe AI could help in the designing of these structures that have various make-ups from embankments to piling to walls, etc., but the work itself is laborious and specialised on the ground. I think AI may well have a part to play in the design, for sure.

Comment on this

We were talking about the Civil Defence and part of it is the auxiliary fire service. What brought it to my mind was that, in Dublin city in particular, we have what is called a fire-based emergency medical services, EMS, where we have what is regarded as the gold standard of delivery. We have highly trained, advanced paramedics on every fire tender as well as on a district ambulance service, and that is not available around the country. In an emergency situation around the country you are depending largely on the National Ambulance Services whose resources could be highly stretched at any given moment or there could be a high level of absenteeism, which makes the provision of a service or an ambulance being available a postcode lottery. Do the witnesses have a view on the expansion of the fire-based EMS system around the country?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

This is a personal opinion, not necessarily a CCMA opinion. We have very set functions around what the local authority does, and the ambulance service is not a core function of the local authority system. As such, I do not think, for numerous reasons, it is something that should be rolled out nationally in the manner it is being done currently in Dublin.

We have a service that is there and let that provide its service. I have concerns. Our fire service response time is anything between five and eight minutes depending on where you are and that is nationally. That is the typical average. The National Oversight and Audit Commission, NOAC, report shows the average response times. A lot of those are emergency first responders and they are life saving. There is a concern within the sector that we are there first, yet if there was a really serious issue that only an ambulance service could deal with, we are not equipped to do that. We should maintain a clear definition of roles between what the HSE and ambulance service do and what the fire services and local authorities do.

Comment on this

In Dublin city, there was a report commissioned by Sir Ken Knight.

He came over specifically on the basis of the witnesses' analysis of it with the idea of trying to separate it. What he concluded was that Dublin city was the gold standard. Various cities around the US have fire-based EMS, and that is what provides the best service to the public rather than what a local authority might view itself as being constrained in doing. I would be a strong advocate of the fire-based EMS service, and I think it works well in parts of Dublin city. For example, there was an incident in Dún Laoghaire where the National Ambulance Service is operational. The incident happened close to the station and, had the call been diverted to the local fire station, a life could have been saved. It was not. It went to the National Ambulance Service, unfortunately. That problematic delivery of service is probably being replicated. I do not have evidence of that, but I would fear that would be the case.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is a good suggestion. Before I finish, I want to ask the witnesses two things. On the strict criteria for calling in the Defence Forces, will the witnesses let the committee have a copy of those criteria? Transparency is important to our understanding of all this. The other thing is the forestry in the witnesses' local authority areas. Do they have a mapping of that forestry? Do they know who owns it, so that if they need the owner of the forestry to carry out a particular action, they know whom to contact?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We will get the criteria for calling in the Defence Forces circulated and submitted, of course. On forestry, which Deputy Cahill referenced, we would have engaged with forestry owners and Coillte to make sure that forestry management and fire breaks are installed and properly maintained because that is such an easy protection.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Do the witnesses know who owns the forestry?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We would have very quick access to land ownership across the country. If we have to get access, we have a system by which we can identify every landowner in any part of the country. The important message I would want to get across on the management of wildfires or forestry fires is that we have very competent people in the fire service dealing with it. We want to make sure that other agencies that want to be very supportive do not get caught in very serious situations. Everything has to be under the strict command and control of the fire service. We engage with Coillte, we have the landowners and we utilise-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That goes without saying. My question is, if the forestry is owned by a pension fund or a number of people down the line, do the witnesses know specifically where the area of responsibility lies for that patch of forestry? Do they have that in the local authority area?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We may or may not identify a landowner, which may be a fund or whatever, but we can access any site at any time in the case of an emergency. That is a power the fire service has. We do not need to wait for landowner consent. If we go back subsequently, we will do searches to try to find the owner, but it does not stop us. We can access anywhere.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We are in the middle of an emergency and something needs to be done. What Mr. Kehoe is saying is good. The fire service has absolute and full authority, but if it wants the landowner to carry out some action, does it always know who the landowner is?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

We would not immediately, but in an emergency, the fire services can carry out the actions the chief fire officer or the officer in control thinks are necessary.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is there no problem with being unable to identify the owners of forestry in any of the local authority areas?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Kehoe

Between Coillte and us, as I said, it might be a fund but we can identify who the landowner is because the Land Registry system tells us who owns land, and we can access that. We have the power of access in an emergency.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I know the witnesses talk about the power of access, but there is an issue where people do not know who owns the forestry. Even on an ongoing basis, if trees are coming out on the road, where is the line of demarcation? Who do the witnesses instruct to put it right if it is owned by a pension fund or by somebody who is not registered? Would Mr. O'Rourke, from a councillor's point of view, be called about that?

Comment on this
Mr. Aengus O'Rourke

Deputy Cahill's point was well made in that it gets back to preparedness. Local authorities should know in advance who owns the land rather than waiting for an emergency situation to try to find out and should make sure that fire breaks are in place at all times, not just when an emergency occurs.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Exactly. Maybe you could give us information on the local authorities having a list from the Land Registry so things are not getting dropped in between and there is full knowledge of who owns the forestry in each county.

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

There are cases where you would not know. Sometimes there are very complex arrangements-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Yes, that is what I am talking about.

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

-----and we would not know that. In fairness, even after a day we are not going to know it. A lot of times we know it and sometimes we do not. A lot of it will be case by case where there are overhanging trees along a road. Somebody mentioned that. Now there is more time for that but quite often you might not know either. We can serve notice on the landowner or the occupier.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

But who do you serve it on?

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

Sometimes we post signs on the land. Overhanging trees is one example but that is not an emergency and you are talking about emergencies and fires.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am also talking about an ongoing basis. Who do you serve it on if you do not know who owns it because the local authority does not have that clear information?

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

With overhanging trees it is the landowner or the occupier and quite often it can be occupiers.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

What about where we have a bunch of trees and we do not know who the occupier or the landowner is? Who do we serve it to?

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

Let us say it was an individual case, we would chase that down through the process, but we would not check every one in the country to see who owns everything. We would just check the one we needed.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There needs to be more joining up of the Land Registry and the local authority so this information is clear and ready to hand when something happens or even for ongoing situations where preventative action is required.

Comment on this
Mr. John McLaughlin

If I can come back in, we have access to Land Registry records. We are signed up, so we could open it now and see the landowner, if there is one listed. The difficulty arises when it is a very complex arrangement and it would not be easily available.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Yes, and there are many complex arrangements. I am trying to get at where the responsibility lies to collate that information so everybody knows who the owners are and where the areas of responsibility are.

Did you want to say something, Deputy Cahill, before we leave?

Comment on this

I have one very last point, a Chathaoirligh. Senator Blaney brought the following to my attention and that of my colleagues this morning. A number of schools in Donegal received threats that bomb devices had been planted. It has caused huge fear, anxiety and all of that, obviously. Does anyone know whether these threats were confined to Donegal or were other counties affected? Maybe there is no information on that but it is worrying.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I understand it is other counties as well but we do not have the information at this time and I would not expect the witnesses to have it either. I think it will be an ongoing Garda investigation.

Comment on this

Go raibh maith agat.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. On behalf of the committee I thank all the witnesses for their time and valuable engagement.

Comment on this