Mental Health Supports and Wellness in the Defence Forces: Discussion
Dr. Dan Fitzpatrick presented research indicating substantial psychological distress among surveyed serving personnel and widespread concern that disclosing mental health difficulties could harm their careers. He called for an integrated Defence Forces mental health governance framework, including clearer care and occupational pathways, stronger confidentiality, transparent reporting and ongoing evaluation. ONE outlined its veteran-centred counselling, helpline and housing supports, and urged sustained State investment to meet growing and complex needs. Members highlighted barriers to help-seeking, addiction and homelessness, and the need for better coordination and support for serving personnel and veterans.
The joint committee is holding two public sessions this morning to discuss mental health supports and wellness in the Defence Forces. In the first session, we are joined by Dr. Dan Fitzpatrick; and from Óglaigh Náisiúnta na hÉireann, the Organisation of National Ex-Service Personnel, ONE, by Mr. Cormac Kirwan, CEO; Ms Audra Larkin, deputy CEO; Mr. Steven Shields, veteran support officer; and Ms Sandra Hickey, veteran support officer. In the Visitors Gallery, accompanying Dr. Dan Fitzpatrick, we have Professor Brian Keogh and Professor Louise Doyle. We are also joined in the Gallery by two work experience students from the office of the Minister of State, Deputy Neale Richmond, Krisha Darakar and Larry Martens. They are very welcome. I thank them for showing an interest in the work we are doing.
The format of the meeting is that I will first invite Dr. Fitzpatrick to make his opening statement and then Mr. Kirwan of ONE. That will be followed by questions from members of the committee. As we have two public sessions this morning, each member has a five-minute slot to start with. We will see what time we have at the end to ask questions and for witnesses to respond. I ask members to please adhere to these timings.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where he or she is not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any member participating via MS Teams to formally confirm prior to making his or her contribution to the meeting that he or she is on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.
Both members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
I invite Dr. Fitzpatrick to deliver his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for the opportunity to address the committee. I served in the Irish Air Corps for 22 years, including approximately 12 years working in the personnel support service. I subsequently completed doctoral research at Trinity College Dublin, under the supervision of Professor Louise Doyle and Professor Brian Keogh, examining mental health and help-seeking among serving Defence Forces personnel. I acknowledge their guidance and, importantly, the serving personnel who contributed to this research.
I appear before the committee today as a Defence Forces veteran and a researcher to raise a fundamental question. How can we adequately assess military readiness if we do not systematically measure, govern and evaluate the psychological health of the personnel upon whom that readiness depends? My research involved 687 serving personnel across the Army, Naval Service and Air Corps, followed by interviews with six key stakeholders in the organisation. The findings identified significant psychological distress. Approximately one quarter of the survey participants screened positive for probable post-traumatic stress disorder, 34% reported suicidal thoughts, 10% reported self-harm and 9% reported a previous suicide attempt. These figures describe the research participants and should not be interpreted as established prevalence rates across the entire Defence Forces. Nevertheless, they identify substantial psychological need and justify closer institutional examination.
However, the research also revealed organisational problems that cannot be addressed through clinical services alone. Only 22% of respondents indicated that they would disclose a mental health difficulty through the Defence Forces medical system, while 94% believed that disclosure to a medical doctor could negatively affect their career. This presents a fundamental organisational contradiction. We encourage personnel to recognise psychological difficulties and seek appropriate support. Yet, the research indicates that many perceive the act of disclosure itself as a potential threat to their professional future. A person can recognise their psychological distress, understand the benefits of treatment and still make a calculated decision not to seek help. This is not a simple question of mental health awareness. It is a question of organisational confidence, institutional responsibility and governance.
The Defence Forces have mental health services and dedicated professionals working within them. I do not question their commitment. However, the existence of a service does not demonstrate that personnel trust it, that referral pathways are constantly understood, or that occupational decisions following disclosure are sufficiently transparent, nor does the publication of strategies or delivery of training establish whether organisational conditions have improved. The central question is whether the Defence Forces possess a co-ordinated system capable of identifying psychological need, supporting appropriate intervention, protecting confidentiality, evaluating outcomes and learning from evidence.
My submission proposes the Defence Forces integrated mental health governance framework, DF-IMHGF, as an evidence-informed response to these findings. The framework is organised around five interconnected pillars: governance and strategic leadership; organisational systems, care pathways and occupational reintegration; leadership, culture and prevention; integrated mental health capability; and research, mental health intelligence and continuous organisational learning. These are not five separate initiatives. They are components of one integrated organisational governance system designed to establish clear responsibilities, measurable outcomes and continuous organisational learning.
Central to the framework is the proposed establishment of a multidisciplinary Defence Forces health governance board, with defined responsibility for strategic oversight, implementation and evaluation. The framework also proposes a living mental health policy, supported by an integrated pathway that clearly explains what happens when personnel disclose a psychological difficulty, how they access assessment and treatment, how occupational decisions are made, and how recovery and return to duty are managed.
Additional proposals include dedicated suicide prevention arrangements, co-ordinated multidisciplinary support and a mental health intelligence programme capable of producing meaningful evidence about service engagement, outcomes and organisational improvement. These proposals recognise that military mental health must balance clinical need, individual confidentiality, occupational safety and operational requirements. These responsibilities are not incompatible but their effective management requires transparent and accountable governance.
The purpose of the framework is not to replace the existing services. It is to establish the organisational architecture through which those services can be co-ordinated, assessed and continuously improved. I therefore respectfully ask this committee to recommend that the Minister for Defence and the Department of Defence formally assess the framework, identify the appropriate authority responsible for progressing that assessment, and provide a written response outlining its findings, implementation requirements and proposed next steps. I further ask that future mental health reforms be evaluated against demonstrable outcomes, including personnel confidence in accessing support, the effectiveness of referral pathways and the transparency of occupational decision-making, rather than solely the existence of policies, programmes or services.
Mental health is not peripheral to military capability. It is part of the human foundation upon which operational effectiveness depends. The question is no longer simply whether mental health support exists. It is whether the Defence Forces can demonstrate that the systems surrounding that support are trusted, effective and accountable. That is the purpose of the Defence Forces integrated mental health governance framework and I respectfully ask the committee to give its recommendations formal consideration.
Comment on this
On behalf of the chairperson and board of directors of ONE, I thank the Cathaoirleach and the Joint Committee on Defence and National Security for the invitation to today’s
meeting to discuss mental health supports for veterans of the Defence Forces. As veterans, we always remember those who lost their lives on peacekeeping operations overseas or on operations at home. The greatest respect that we can pay the fallen is to take care of the living and ONE’s delegation will focus on the professional mental health services ONE provides for veterans of the Defence Forces. ONE’s delegation comprises Audra Larkin, deputy CEO and current lead on ONE’s professional mental health capability; Steven Shields, ONE’s longest serving veteran support officer who is co-located with the HSE Dublin and Midlands regional health area; Sandra Hickey, a veteran support officer who is co-located with the HSE Mid West regional health area; and myself.
In relation to veterans of the Defence Forces, it is important to acknowledge that the Defence Forces have continuously participated in peacekeeping missions since 1958, setting Ireland apart as the only nation with an unbroken presence in such operations over a period of approximately 70 years. The Defence Forces also remains the highest troop contributor in Europe to UN missions per head of population, with approximately 10% serving overseas every year. These are important considerations in understanding the contribution of veterans, as well as understanding the current and emerging needs of many.
To place this morning’s discussion in context, I believe it is crucial to refer to the recent research by the Nexus organisation - Veterans of the Defence Forces: A Study on behalf of Óglaigh Náisiúnta na hÉireann. The Nexus report highlights the successful transitions achieved by most veterans following their departure from the Defence Forces, but it also highlights the difficulties faced by a significant minority of veterans prior to and following their transition to civilian life. These veterans are the primary service users of ONE.
The research focused primarily on the needs, interests, concerns and life circumstances of those veterans who present with high and complex levels of need, vulnerability and risk. The research also indicated that while veterans continue to comprise older individuals who have transitioned to civilian life after many years of Defence Forces’ service, it is understood that over 50% of personnel leaving now are under 34 years of age. The research highlighted increasingly complex life situations, which may be exacerbated by high levels of trauma and dual diagnosis among a diverse veteran population and included: identity and loss of structure; feeling abandoned and misunderstood; physical and mental health issues; homelessness and housing instability; issues with financial entitlements and pensions; and recognition and respect for service. A more detailed examination of the profile of Irish Defence Forces veterans, particularly those supported by ONE, is presented in chapter 4 of the Nexus study on veterans of the Defence Forces previously circulated to the members of this committee, with particular reference to mental health on pages 20 and 21.
ONE’s mental health support is delivered through six professional veteran support officers, VSOs, who are employed in partnership with the HSE. The veteran support officers are qualified counsellors who provide nationwide support to struggling veterans. The six veteran support officers are co-located with the six regional health areas. ONE plans to employ a head veteran support officer by the end of 2027 and an outreach officer by the end of 2028.
ONE delivers a 24-7 mental health support helpline available to all veterans nationwide. ONE, supported by the Leopardstown Park Hospital Trust, LPHT, launched a pilot 24-7 mental health support helpline in September 2023. Following immediate support from the helpline, veterans are referred from this service to either an ONE veteran support officer or a Spectrum Life trauma counsellor. The HSE is now funding this and Spectrum Life, together with Laya Healthcare, are contracted for this programme until September 2027.
Education opportunities delivered by ONE to the veteran community is one of the areas in which we develop mental health support. ONE, supported by the Leopardstown Park Hospital Trust, delivers mental health first aid courses and welfare officer courses to ONE welfare officers, Irish United Nations Veterans Association, IUNVA, veterans and other veteran groups. The last mental health first aid course was conducted in Arbour Hill on Saturday, 19 September 2026, and our next welfare officer course is scheduled for Saturday, 21 November, again in Arbour Hill.
The Nexus report recognised the need for veteran-centred supports provided by professionals who understand the unique context and language of the Defence Forces’ service. It opined how veterans impacted by mental health challenges have frequently felt alienated from State mental health services because of the services lack of understanding of Defence Forces’ life, culture and experience. It also highlighted that veterans’ medical entitlements, and specific services available to veterans, are similar to those of the general population with the one exception of mental health support which is provided by ONE.
The Government recently committed to increasing investment in defence to address the change in the security landscape.
While we welcome this, it is correspondingly important to increase investment in support services for those who have served our country. I use the term "investment" deliberately because we must now move from donating to investing in our veterans. Investment implies there is a return, and that return is service to our country.
The annual operational costs of ONE are approximately €1.83 million, of which €1.15 million, or 56%, is received from the State. ONE's mental health professional programme costs approximately €410,000 per annum, of which €370,000, or 90%, is received from the HSE. It is important to note that ONE employed its first veteran support officer in January 2020 and the service has grown significantly in the interim. ONE plans to employ a head veteran support officer by the end of 2027 and an outreach officer in 2028. The State must continue to invest in supporting the mental health of its veterans.
Honouring those who have served is not just about what we say at commemorations or at meetings like this; it is about how we honour our veterans every day of the year. It is about remaining committed to providing support in every way that we possibly can. It is about service and serving them as well as they have served our country. I use the term "we" deliberately because it is a collective and shared responsibility. It is not about blaming others or simply hoping for a solution. Blaming others is not a strategy and hope is not a course of action, rather, it is waiting for someone else to do something. We are not helpless spectators and the veterans who need our support do not have the luxury of waiting. We must repay their service by working together to ensure that no Irish veteran is left behind.
Comment on this
We will now go to the members who have five minutes each as we have two sessions this morning. I remind members to keep their questions brief to allow time for the answers within the five minutes.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Fitzpatrick and ONE for the work they do to support our serving members and our veterans. The work they do and the discussion we are having this morning are very important. I am delighted we are shining a strong light on the work they do and the conditions that are feeding into the necessity of the work they do. I want to link both. If the framework Dr. Fitzpatrick suggested was supported, does he think this would ease the transition from serving life into retirement or into becoming a veteran? Would this then ease the burden of the role that ONE is currently fulfilling?
Comment on this
One of the findings of my PhD is that 94% of people felt that if they disclosed a mental health issue to the medical services in the Defence Forces their career would be affected. The framework would hope to change this behaviour and culture to make the services more accessible and, essentially, to create trust in the services. If more serving members trusted and utilised the services, and got help while they were in service and continued to be in service, this would alleviate the stress on veterans because they would have begun to use the mental health services provided by the Defence Forces as serving members instead of carrying the burden into retirement.
Comment on this
From my perspective, there is no health without mental health. I recognise that the Defence Forces are, for good reason, very focused on ensuring that our serving personnel are very fit and ready to serve in whatever physical way is needed but I wonder whether the same focus and attention is given to ensuring they are equally as resilient psychologically as they are physically. Stigma might be too strong a word but does Dr. Fitzpatrick think that on some level, as is the case in broader society, there is an idea that people should be able to look after themselves psychologically?
Comment on this
We need to move past resilience programmes and education. The problem my PhD revealed was with trust in the services and the consequences of disclosure of a mental health issue, whether through an official or unofficial system. Resilience and mental health programmes are not going to change this particular behaviour. It moves from clinical to behavioural and this is what the framework is targeting. It starts with a governance board and creating a new pathway to-----
Comment on this
Is Dr. Fitzpatrick saying it is not about having programmes in place? Are programmes already in place in the Defence Forces?
Comment on this
The programmes are in place and by no means am I criticising the programmes, any of the work the clinicians do or any of the services. It is not a criticism of the services. What my PhD found is that people are not engaging with the official services because of the consequences.
Comment on this
If Dr. Fitzpatrick were to prioritise one change in his proposed framework, what would it be?
Comment on this
The recommendations are prioritised from one to ten and the first is the governance board because this would set up everything for the implementation. There is an implementation plan for the framework development from zero to 12 months, one to three years and beyond three years.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Fitzpatrick. I am sorry to cut him short but I want to make sure that ONE also gets an opportunity. Will Mr. Kirwan speak about the Nexus report and the importance of its findings, rather than me asking questions about it?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Callaghan for the question. The study was conducted between 2024 and 2025 and aimed to provide a solid foundation for ONE's engagement with the State by examining the profile and needs of Irish veterans, comparing international policy and practice and identifying opportunities for the growth of ONE in this regard. The key findings looked at the profile and needs of the Defence Forces. The report identified areas associated with challenges in mental health, culture, housing and the invisibility that veterans felt when they left the Defence Forces. It looked at international comparisons in which Ireland is an outlier and at opportunities for growth, particularly in relation to funding and partnership.
Coming out of this were a number of recommendations for the State and for ONE. From the State's perspective, it identified the need to calculate the precise number of veterans. We referenced 140,000 based on what the Committee of Public Accounts found in June 2000 but there is no definitive number of veterans. The report spoke about a policy statement, including a definition of what a veteran actually is. It spoke about creating a service-focused interface with veterans, and we have been advocating for the development and establishment of a national veteran support bureau. It spoke about the transition from the Defence Forces to civilian life, particularly the potential gap for the cohort we support, who struggle because they never anticipated that they were going to have to leave the Defence Forces. The report also looked at mental health supports in the Defence Forces for veterans and creating veteran-centred mental health supports. There was also the housing requirement, particularly for those who found themselves homeless for a variety of reasons.
The recommendations of the report from our perspective have been transformational because they will shape and guide our next strategic plan, which will be presented to our convention in the first quarter of next year. This will drive the organisation forward over the next five years. We have been given definitive guidelines on recommendations for action for ONE as we move forward.
Comment on this
Well done on that report, which is excellent.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses very much for being here this morning and for their opening statements. I will start, as Deputy Callaghan did, with Dr. Fitzpatrick. His research is quite staggering in terms of the percentages of people suffering with their mental health, from PTSD to suicidal ideation to previous suicide attempts. How did the 687 serving personnel whom Dr. Fitzpatrick surveyed come to be part of the research? What was the basis by which they were chosen? Was it a survey? How did Dr. Fitzpatrick reach out to them? I know he cannot tell me who they are.
Comment on this
There were surveys. The study took place during the course of Covid. Initially there were hard-copy surveys and the intention was that I would visit every barracks in the country and people would be asked to fill in the survey voluntarily. When Covid hit we had to move to a digital format. This digital format was uploaded onto military.ie and it was also available on the internet through a QR code. People could access the survey on their personal devices. The survey also travelled through WhatsApp groups in the country and overseas.
Comment on this
When we talk about mental health in general, especially for younger men, we talk about a stigma around mental health and mental health challenges, struggles or difficulties. Dr. Fitzpatrick gave us data indicating that 94% believe disclosure to a military doctor could negatively affect their career. Is that primarily based on stigma? Is there a heightened level of it within the Defence Forces based on fear about career progression?
Comment on this
There are two types of stigma. There is organisational stigma that occurs through the culture. With many masculine-dominated organisations, there is a stigma around mental health, help-seeking and feelings of weakness. Then there is self-stigma, which is the other form of stigma. That comes from a person’s background and is also a part of the culture. The two forms need to be addressed. Organisational stigma and self-stigma need to be addressed in terms of the individual feeling they can come forward and not feel weakened. As the Deputy rightly said, career progression is a huge issue. The higher a person goes up the ranks, the more of a concern that is. Nobody at senior level wants to be perceived as being weak. They are actually more vulnerable the higher they go. Self-stigma and organisational stigma are the two components.
Comment on this
How does the framework Dr. Fitzpatrick has proposed help to tackle that? Does it provide anonymity to people when they look for help, or does it reference an entire cultural change in how mental health and mental health challenges are approached within the Defence Forces?
Comment on this
That is a great question. The framework is built on five pillars. They cover: leadership and accountability; clear care and career pathways; leadership, culture and prevention; joined-up mental health support; and research, reporting and continuous improvement. The five pillars all operate to bring all the services together, provide holistic care, change behaviour and create a clear pathway for serving members so they can walk into any barracks in the country, no matter who they sit in front of, and get exactly the same treatment. It would be a multidisciplinary approach. That would, essentially, lead to transparency around how mental health is co-ordinated. It is the intention of the framework that this transparency would lead to more people seeking help. This would be along with the other parts of the framework, including mental health reporting as a strategic pillar and the transparent reporting of national figures to the public. That would help with transparency concerning mental health and the Defence Forces. That would be one of the mechanisms by which people may feel less vulnerable when they disclose a mental health issue.
Comment on this
Okay. I thank Dr. Fitzpatrick. I am conscious of the time. I have just a couple of questions for ONE as well. I want to focus on funding. Some figures were given. The HSE funding seems to be the most significant funding ONE has for its mental health supports. Is that guaranteed every year or is there continuing uncertainty around it? That is just to get an idea of where it stands.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. That is a very pertinent question. It is not guaranteed every year, so every year we have to apply for funding. In 2026, we got an initial funding allocation in the service level agreement, SLA. We then got an additional allocation of €120,000 for 2026 alone. I strongly advocate to this committee that the funding we get, which this year covered 90% of the overall cost of delivering our mental health programme, be reaffirmed for the next number of years. This is a service of paramount importance to us as a charity in ensuring we deliver it to vulnerable veterans of the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
It must be much more difficult to plan, expand or try to develop a roadmap for expansion when ONE does not know what funding it will receive. It can perhaps guess or estimate, but that is not good enough when it is trying to do such important work.
Comment on this
When we get a commitment for sustainable committed funding, it allows us to ensure that our home base is covered and we can then develop further services in support of an increasing challenge in this whole space. If we were able to ring-fence exactly the funding we would get, we would be able to bank what we have, deliver that service and potentially expand it to meet the demands. The current caseload of our veteran support officers, our counsellors, including Ms Hickey and Mr. Shields, would be between 30 and 35 cases. That was reflected in the Nexus report. Compared with other counsellors in this space, it shows the demand for this particular service because it is a veteran-centred service. Funding is crucial and paramount to delivery and expansion.
Comment on this
Deputy O’Meara has asked one of the questions I was going to ask, so that has dealt with that. Do any of the witnesses have a view on long periods of guard duty having an effect on mental health through being unstimulated and sitting around?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy talking about 24-hour guard duty?
Comment on this
Typically, in my experience of guard duty in Baldonnel, personnel are actually quite active. There is a lot of patrolling done within the airfield, so personnel are quite active during those 24 hours. I can only speak from my personal experience because I have only done guard duties in Baldonnel.
Comment on this
All right. Do any other witnesses have experience of this?
Comment on this
It is not really our space. Our space is in the provision of mental health support to veterans rather than service-related issues.
Comment on this
I will move on. What role can substance abuse, including alcohol and illicit drugs, play both as a response to and exacerbation of mental health difficulties for members and former members of the Defence Forces?
Comment on this
We can take that. I will pass it over to Mr. Shields, who is our longest-serving veteran support officer, because he works in that specific space in the veterans’ world.
Comment on this
I want to provide some context. When veterans are asked where they worked and what they did, we ask them where they served, and "served" has a different connotation as well. Veterans give a lot to the State and service takes a lot out of them as well. Some of our veterans undertook continuous overseas service duties and sometimes spent long periods away from home. Some have suffered some traumatic events and some have also had cause to self-medicate for their mental health difficulties.
I did a case study with one of the veterans with whom I have recently worked. It involved what is called a dual diagnosis, where the person was self-medicating for mental health difficulties and it was a vicious circle. When this veteran engaged with the HSE, the addiction services said the person needed to sort out their mental health, while the mental health service said the person needed to sort out their addiction. Crucially, that is where an experienced person comes in and takes over the role of case manager. A case manager is able to step back from the whole situation, co-ordinate, make an assessment and then signpost that person to the proper services. This is crucial in the context of addiction. I will give an example. I have 36 clients at the moment and nine currently have addiction issues.
It is not just alcohol addiction. It is also addiction to over-the-counter medication, which is seen as acceptable. This includes Solpadol and all those kinds of opiate-based medications and synthetic opiates. That has become a serious problem as well. I do not know if that has answered the Deputy’s question-----
Comment on this
-----but that is what we are meeting on the ground now a lot of the time. It adds complexities as well because it may mean the person will have to go in for rehabilitation treatment. That takes 14 weeks out of a person’s life, which is a considerable amount of time away. It also takes a considerable amount of work and preparation before the person does that.
Comment on this
I will add to that. My study found that male and female soldiers among the participants were drinking more than the national averages and that male soldiers consumed more alcohol than female soldiers. That is what my study found.
Comment on this
That is very useful. I thank Dr. Fitzpatrick. How does the mental health system that serves the Defence Forces compare with international best practice? What are the missing elements?
Comment on this
One of the first missing elements is transparency and reporting. If we look at many militaries across Europe and internationally, we can get reports on mental health. We can pull them up online. They are not confidential reports and are easily accessible to everyone. Regarding our Defence Forces, though, we would not be able to find out how many people died by suicide or how many are working through depression or anxiety. Those figures are invisible to the State and to the taxpayer. An important point of call would be transparency in reporting. That just feeds into the stigma as well and creates the conversation.
Comment on this
Our space is within that veteran community. That is where we focus all our attention and that is what we are here to discuss today.
Comment on this
Funding was mentioned but what more resources does ONE require to deliver a proper mental health service for its members?
Comment on this
It is our ambition to increase our current staff by one additional veteran support officer in 2027 and an outreach role in 2028. The establishment of a national veterans support bureau would be crucial because it would be the interface with the veteran community. An individual could come in and present themselves and then be assessed and signposted to the appropriate services, as Mr. Shields referenced. If we consider where we were in January 2020 when we employed our first veteran support officer to where we are now with six full-time veteran support officers, a 24-7 mental health support line and that educational piece for the volunteers, it is like chalk and cheese but we still need to keep developing this service in order to meet the demand.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here and commend them on the work they do with veterans in the country. My colleagues have asked an awful lot of questions I would have liked to ask so I will zone in on the reluctance to engage with mental health services while serving. I served in the Defence Forces and was also involved in teaching for 25-odd years. I would say that this reluctance cuts right across society. People are afraid to engage with mental health services for fear of damaging their careers and prospects in the future. Does Dr. Fitzpatrick see it that way or does he think that it is more exacerbated in the defence sphere than in any other profession?
Comment on this
It is a case of "Yes" and "No". Yes, there is a problem with mental health nationally in terms of the conversation and, second, it is magnified in the Defence Forces because there are specific barriers that prevent people from engaging with mental health support. It is in the framework and one of the issues that has come up before is the medical grading system. I am not asking for the medical grading system to be abolished. Restrictions are necessary but they should be proportionate, explained to individuals, periodically reviewed and linked to recovery instead of there being an automatic downgrade once someone presents with a mental health issue. That is one of the largest barriers for people because once you have a medical downgrade in the Defence Forces, as I am sure the Senator knows, you cannot go overseas, cannot go on courses and in some circumstances are removed from the organisation. The philosophy of the Defence Forces or any military is that the group and the mission come first, so removing somebody from the mission or removing them from the group is stripping them of their military identity and is contradictory to the philosophy of the Defence Forces. The medical grading system operates as one of the largest barriers to that, which magnifies mental health disclosure, particularly within the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
Would Dr. Fitzpatrick agree that serving members have access to firearms, etc., which puts them in a different category to that of any other profession?
Comment on this
This is a hotly debated topic. One of the shocking findings in my study was that 9% of the population, approximately 61 people, had attempted suicide in the past month or the past week prior to taking the survey. Those individuals are invisible to the organisation. The question remains whether somebody is able to operate with a weapon or with a weapon and live ammunition. The two of them are different because there are components of military life where you can operate with a weapon and there are components of military life where live ammunition is needed. Currently we do not distinguish between the two. We say that we will take someone's weapon away but a weapon with no live ammunition is in my opinion a safe instrument. It is an instrument a soldier becomes part of and to remove that from a soldier can be detrimental to their mental health.
Comment on this
I compliment ONE on the strides it has taken in providing housing and fantastic services and the way it is increasing its targets, etc. We do not have a culture of respecting veterans in this country. Has ONE found that to be a problem as it tries to raise charitable donation type funding? I noticed that Mr. Kirwan talked about investment rather than donation. Is that an issue for ONE?
Comment on this
A lot of the challenges associated with the word "veteran" fall within the veteran community itself because individuals are very slow to identify that they are veterans. If we stand back and look at society across all elements, veterans are the driving force behind all of the volunteer spaces within communities, be it within the sporting organisations, Tidy Towns or church choirs. It is very rare you will not find a veteran somewhere behind it driving it, yet at the same time that individual, and I say this against myself, has never identified within the community that they served. When we compare ourselves to other countries, we can see that the word "veteran" is not necessarily synonymous within the community. That is the reason that all of our services involve a veteran support officer, veterans' homes and veteran mental health because we are trying to ensure that the word "veteran" is reflected within society. A lot of that comes back to us as a veteran community. We do not promote the fact that we served.
Comment on this
I have one last very quick question that comes across my desk every day of the week. It is about respect for veterans and the failure of the State to recognise those who served. When the 2016 medal was presented to serving members, we had the ridiculous situation where a soldier who joined the Defence Forces after 1 January 2016 qualified for the medal and a soldier who retired from the Defence Forces with 40 years' service on 31 December 2015 did not qualify for the medal. Has ONE come across that and does it have an opinion on it?
Comment on this
The whole area of recognition of service is something we deal with on a regular basis. Recognition of service is reflective of a lot more than just a medal. It is reflective of the engagement within the community with the veteran space, coffee mornings and recognition of service in relation to professional support services like mental health, which we are here to discuss. The medal is also one of those areas that would be commonly referred to. We would advocate for the award of a medal not necessarily aligned with 1916 to 2016 but a medal that would recognise the service of individuals who served, similar to the medal that was issued to members, retired members and deceased members of An Garda Síochána in 2022.
Comment on this
I introduced a Bill in 2016 for the establishment of a veterans' pin similar to what happened in the UK, which would allow ONE to locate veterans because that is one of the problems. Some veterans do not engage with ONE but if they had to register to get their pin, it would increase the overall commitment to the organisation.
Comment on this
My ONE colleagues and Dr. Fitzpatrick are very welcome. Dr. Fitzpatrick completed his PhD while serving in the Air Corps. Did he retire before or after the completion of his PhD?
Comment on this
Overall, I spent 12 years in college. I started with a diploma and then moved to a degree in education, a master's degree and a PhD. All of that was while I was serving except for the last two years of the PhD. I served for 22 years but the workload was just so large with the last portion of the PhD that I retired.
Comment on this
I congratulate Dr. Fitzpatrick. Having done a PhD while I was serving, I know how difficult it is to balance everything and family. I thank him for this very comprehensive document. I hope that in our next session during which we will talk to members of the general staff, we will be able to ask them about their acceptance of this document or their views on it. Have the Defence Forces engaged with Dr. Fitzpatrick regarding the findings of his PhD?
Comment on this
The findings of the PhD have been publicly available since March of this year and there has been no official engagement from the Department of Defence, or from anybody in the military having been contacted regarding the PhD.
Comment on this
Is that something Dr. Fitzpatrick would welcome? Would he welcome the opportunity to make presentations to them?
Comment on this
Absolutely. The reason I am here today is because of that. Getting the PhD was wonderful for me and it is a wonderful achievement but almost 700 people participated in the study and six key stakeholders, who are senior key stakeholders in the organisation, gave their time and spoke very candidly. I have created this study, which is the largest cross-sectional study in the history of the State, only a stepping stone to greater research that needs to be done.
Comment on this
As Dr. Fitzpatrick had responses from over 600 personnel, even though that is a random sample, I would hazard that given the scale of it that it is representative in nature.
Things have changed considerably since I served. Deputy Brabazon mentioned 24-hour duties. I had two suicides during my career in the service while on 24-hour duties. One was with a service weapon and the other was with a shotgun the individual had brought into the workplace, which he had concealed in a kind of kit-bag. Back then the only investigation or inquiry, and the only questions we were asked, were about who had issued the weapon, who had signed out the ammunition, and whether or not the weapon was zeroed to the individual who shot himself. In the case of the other individual who shot himself in the head, no questions were asked because there was no service weapon. The only interest was in ordnance and matters like that. I am assuming things are different, notwithstanding the challenges that are there. Is Dr. Fitzpatrick satisfied that things have improved since the nineties?
Comment on this
Yes, I do believe things have improved. We have critical incident stress management operators within the Defence Forces who are on scene after critical incidents. When it comes to suicide, however, and it is in the framework, we need a stand-alone suicide policy in the Defence Forces, in conjunction with a living mental health policy - there is none at the moment. There is no mental health policy within the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
With regard to chronic stress reaction, sometimes called combat stress reaction, CSR, when people are in the operational environment, the international literature in military journals identifies vicarious trauma, or in other words seeing the suffering of others, particularly civilians, and being helpless to intervene. That is the strongest accelerator or indicator for CSR which untreated becomes post-traumatic stress disorder. The British estimate that one in four will experience PTSD. The Israelis say one in three. The Americans say similar with one in three. In their last couple of rotations through Lebanon our troops have witnessed the destruction of villages and towns and the displacement and killing of civilians. Is Dr. Fitzpatrick aware of the Defence Forces having taken any steps to address that?
Comment on this
From my study, one in four people reported with probable PTSD, which is 25% of that population. Probable PTSD means that the person meets the threshold for clinical assessments. At the moment the Defence Forces do attempt to measure PTSD, but it is essentially a form the person fills in, in front of a doctor, at the end of his or her overseas deployment. It is filled in very quickly and it is put on the person's file. It is not uploaded onto a data system. The Defence Forces would not be able to co-ordinate the data and would not be able to give numbers or identify who is or is not suffering with PTSD. I do not think the method by which the assessments are conducted is done correctly. This is acknowledged in the study by key stakeholders. They have concerns over how we measure PTSD.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Chair would allow me a very quick question for ONE. In his opening remarks, Mr. Kirwan mentioned that the mental health profile of veterans was the same as the general population.
Comment on this
I said that the services available across a wide number of areas would be the same as the general population but the research identified that a veteran-centred service has been delivered by ONE specifically in the area of mental health. What I mean by this is that veterans of the Defence Forces who are struggling and who engage with the services of ONE are speaking with individuals who understand the culture and the language that veterans speak.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Kirwan for clarifying that. I thank him for all the work that he does.
Comment on this
I thank all the speakers. It has been a very interesting engagement. It is undoubtedly the case that there is a huge set of challenges in terms of mental health across the population as a whole, but obviously there are very particular circumstances for serving and former members the Defence Forces for a whole variety of reasons, including exposure to trauma and PTSD. In my experience, many former members of the Defence Forces experience difficulties with the housing crisis that exacerbate the situation as well.
I will ask all my questions together. I have two questions for Dr. Fitzpatrick, one of which concerns the finding that 22% of respondents indicated they had disclosed their mental health difficulty and 94% believed that a disclosure to a military doctor can negatively affect their career. This is a very shocking and worrying finding. It is fair to say that there are particular considerations for the Defence Forces and that it is not necessarily black and white, but it seems to me that many people could experience mental health difficulties that would not necessarily affect their ability to serve. People experience mental health on a spectrum in terms of severity and circumstances. Does the finding suggest that there is a problem or concern - it is perhaps more a perception than reality - about a perception of a lack of discretion in some instances? Could I be picking that up wrong? For the second question I am conscious of Dr. Fitzpatrick's service in the Air Corps. I am not looking to him to comment on specific instances but some people have brought forward issues in relation to chemical exposure, for example Air Corps maintenance personnel, which could have affected mental health negatively. Is this something that Dr. Fitzpatrick has come across?
It sounds like the service ONE provides is tremendous and valuable. I acknowledge the work it does for serving and former personnel. It is a challenge for mental health services to get the balance right between ensuring as many people as possible are seen and that they get the adequate care. The HSE very often will provide, for example, six sessions of therapy for counsellors, and for anyone who is providing a service there is a tension. How does ONE balance that? There will be people who naturally will require more than counselling. They may require specialised psychology and if they need medication they will require a psychiatrist. I presume that probably has to go back to the Defence Forces mental health services or perhaps to the HSE. How is that triaged and referred on? Does this need to be looked at in terms of direct provision of that?
Comment on this
That is a great question and I thank the Deputy. One of the findings from my study was the willingness of soldiers to use services as opposed to the actual historical utilisation of services, which calls into question the idea that men, or certainly soldiers, do not want to talk about mental health. My findings are that they were willing to talk. They were willing to talk in the peer support services, such as the personnel support services, PSS. and INSPIRE. The reason they were less likely to talk to a psychiatrist, a psychologist and the medical services is that those services are documented. A point was raised around confidentiality and the methodology for how it all works. The Defence Forces are still using hard copies-----
Comment on this
I just want to clarify, in case any medical personnel are listening, that I am talking more about the perception than the reality. I would not want to impugn anyone's adherence to the medical side. I am not contradicting Dr. Fitzpatrick. I am just conscious of this for anyone listening.
Comment on this
No problem. With regard to the methodology around how information travels within the Defence Forces, they are still using hard-copy documents. Hard-copy documents then travel between units and administrative personnel, so confidentiality then becomes an issue in terms of medical disclosures or medical conditions.
That is an element covered in the framework in moving from a methodology that is in practice within the Ministry of defence. It is electronic services only, there are fewer people in the chain of administration and new codings for the types of disposals that soldiers would get. I believe, in part with the other pillars within the framework, that would support confidentiality, which is one of the major issues that was found as a result of my study.
Chemical exposure is not something that I measured or looked at in my research and I cannot answer on that.
Comment on this
In relation to services that come through the ONE, at the point of entry, which has an initial assessment, there is no timeframe. It is client dependent and we operate a shared care system. We work with other organisations and systems through a shared care mechanism.
Comment on this
What is that shared care mechanism?
Comment on this
Psychiatry, mental health, GPs and, as Mr. Shields mentioned, a case manager would be assigned.
Comment on this
Before we commence a second round, I will ask a few questions. We have talked about the consequences of disclosure. Does Dr. Fitzpatrick have any examples of the people he interviewed who told him the consequences for them? I know we have the medical grading system and I want to know how that can be changed.
Comment on this
For the study, the six key stakeholders got the key findings. They were questioned on the key findings and not on their personal experiences of any case management or anyone they had worked with. They were asked questions anonymously about people's concerns about disclosure. They did not go into any case and did not talk about anybody as an individual, but they acknowledged those concerns did exist. That was new information to them because those key stakeholders are, again, part of the organisations so if they themselves have mental health issues then they would follow suit. They would be in the same position as the people in the survey.
Comment on this
In terms of the medical grading system, obviously something similar is used in other countries. Did Dr. Fitzpatrick look at any other countries and discover a system that might be a better grading system than we have here?
Comment on this
Different militaries have different ways of dealing with it. The military grading system here would be incorporated into the framework on an ongoing basis. What happens now is that a person can get medically downgraded by one doctor and, in order to get medically upgraded, I think you need two on a panel and because of the shortage of staff then somebody could be downgraded for a long period. The framework would encompass all of the health provision systems under one umbrella and under holistic care. Due to the fact that people want to engage with peer support, peer support would have a role in that recovery process and it would be all under one IT system.
The different support systems - peer supports, medical supports and other supports - would all have proportional access to that care. You are not dealing with one person and reducing the caseload and giving the soldier or the individual choice in care, which ultimately would change the consequences. That would feed into the medical grading system. For example, and I think it was mentioned already, if somebody is teaching avionics in the Air Corps and they have a mental health issue, instead of removing them from the organisation they will be allowed to keep doing their job of teaching while being restricted from live ammunition. That is what is proposed in the framework. It is that we take a proportional case management system and look at individuals instead of an overarching medical system.
Comment on this
Very good. I acknowledge all of the work done by ONE because since I took over as Chair of this committee, I have seen what ONE is trying to achieve and what it has already achieved.
I have some questions on housing. We, as public representatives, will all have seen the mental health strain and stress among the general population in relation to housing, homelessness and the overcrowded conditions in which people live. How often does that present to ONE? Has that escalated with the housing crisis? How does ONE deal with it?
Comment on this
They both go hand in glove. The reality is currently we have four homes that deliver 51 bed spaces on any given night. We are developing a fifth home, which will be finished by the end of 2026, that will bring an additional six rooms. We are developing a home in Limerick that went to planning earlier this week with Limerick City and County Council. We are also in the process of developing plans for a seventh home in Newbridge.
In relation to all of the residents in our homes, and we call them residents and veterans' homes, we have veteran support officers - two of whom are beside me - who work with each of the residents on a needs basis. The reality is that those who struggle with the challenge of homelessness by and large also struggle with huge mental health issues. Our ambition as an organisation is to, potentially, pick someone up off the ground within a three-year window. That means giving them back the confidence to again engage and add value back to society and, in doing so, transition out of our homes into a one-bedroom apartment within the local authority. That involves the work of our veteran support officers, our house managers and the veteran community in the particular region in order to give the individual the crutch and all the skills to reclaim back pride in themselves. Lack of pride is a huge issue associated with veterans who are struggling because nobody expects it, particularly after service within the Defence Forces.
The best example I can give is our five-bedroom home in Cobh. It opened in October 2021. We have currently supported ten veterans of the Defence Forces. There are five people in the home at all times but five veterans have come into the home and transitioned out to independent living in Cobh. We anticipate that by the end of this year it will have supported 12 veterans of the Defence Forces and provided them with the support they needed to reclaim a level of independence and confidence in themselves. We would not be able to do that without our mental health team and by that I mean our veteran support officers.
Comment on this
In some cases it would be transitional. Our ambition is that it would be transitional but the reality for some individuals who come into our homes is that the plans will be end-of-life care. I mean that they do not ever reclaim the skill sets to allow them to live independently. From our perspective, we always endeavour to pick an individual up with the objective of that individual transitioning out of the home into independent living within their own respective communities, but it does not always happen.
Comment on this
We are at approximately 85% capacity at the moment. Our homes outside of Dublin are at full capacity. We are very conscious of that. At times we have individuals who are potentially engaged with other approved housing bodies or NGOs. Once we have a vacancy we try to bring them in because no different than my conversation with Senator Clonan earlier, it is that shared sense of values, culture and language for an individual who has served when they come into a home. We structure, develop and roll out our homes differently from other AHBs in the sense that we have communal living and communal dining because veterans love to engage within their own space and recount stories, war stories, etc. It is important, where possible, that an individual who is in another approved housing body comes into our homes because that is where they start to get confidence in themselves. It is that confidence that ultimately allows the transition to independent living within their own local authority.
Comment on this
At the moment it is all males. We have had female veterans within our homes. The main trigger for homelessness is marital breakdown. In an awful lot of cases of marital breakdown it would be the male who leaves the house and then finds themselves in that homeless space. Also, when considering the percentages of male and female personnel within the Defence Forces, that also leads to the current position where it is male-dominated but we have had female veterans. All of our homes are configured to allow for male or female residents because the accommodation is comprised of en suite independent units and there is then communal living in relation to dining, multi-purpose rooms, etc. We are configured to cater for both male and female and our ambition is to cater for both.
Comment on this
I know that Mr. Kirwan has visited Brooke House and its facility for veterans to have respite care.
I know ONE works very closely cross-Border with the various organisations. Does Mr. Kirwan see a need in the Irish Republic for a respite care centre for families suffering the effects of PTSD?
Comment on this
Ms Larkin has been the point of contact. We work very closely, as the Senator rightly referenced, with Brooke House. We are currently working a programme with Brooke House involving 12 veterans of the Irish Defence Forces along with 12 veterans of the UK armed forces. They are working together on a programme that will come to fruition in March of next year. It has been a fantastic initiative and we see huge levels of commonality between ourselves and Brooke House.
Regarding residential care for families, our space is very specific. We support families in the context of our mental health support but as regards our homeless space, our service is delivered specifically to veterans of the Defence Forces. By and large, it is the veteran and not necessarily the family. I will make one differentiation in relation to mental health. All of our veteran support officers, and Ms Larkin is overseeing this whole area, support families. Families would reach out for support as well because, ultimately, they will carry the weight of a lot of issues associated with mental health within that familial network.
Comment on this
I would like to introduce my intern, Sophia Mulvany. I should have done that last week. Sophia will be working with me until Christmas. I just wanted to acknowledge her presence here today.
Comment on this
You are very welcome, Sophia. We have met before. Thank you very much for the interest you have shown in this committee.
Comment on this
I have a question for Dr. Fitzpatrick that is similar to the question asked by Senator Craughwell. The international literature is very clear on the impact that military service has on service personnel's families, including on their children. I would be more familiar with officers and know that because of extended periods overseas issues tend to arise in families. Did his research or his 12 years of experience in the PSS shed any light on that?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for the question which is very valid. My research did not look at that but my lived experience of working in the PSS is that overseas service has an impact on families. That is true of regular service but also when there is trauma overseas, or incidents, there is a knock-on effect. There is a knock-on effect for people who are working through mental health issues with external GPs, for example. They might be on psychedelic medication but still be working or operating in the Defence Forces. That will have a knock-on effect because it creates more pressure to hide mental health issues from the Defence Forces while trying to fulfil operational readiness needs
Comment on this
My first question is for ONE. What kind of engagement has ONE had with the office of veterans affairs? How important is it to ensure that office is keeping a very close eye on the resources that are required to ensure that veterans have adequate mental health supports?
Comment on this
Since the establishment of the office of veterans affairs in November of last year we have had a lot of engagement. From our perspective, we see this as a positive step forward, which was reflected in the research. This was ongoing as the research was being developed. The office will be significant in the context of that whole strategic space of the office of veterans affairs working across Government and developing policy. That is the primary role. That in itself will drive the support services for veterans. It is important that the office is pitched at the appropriate level across Government and Departments.
There is a gap currently in relation to the national veteran support bureau. The research identified that veteran interface, like a number of other countries. We would see the national veteran support bureau interfacing with veterans but also being the conduit for information, driven by the various Departments based on the policy that is developed across Government. That will certainly drive the services at ground level to support veterans. It is not even necessarily about driving the services but about creating the awareness of the services that are there for veterans at ground level. All of our engagement to date has been extremely positive. We welcome the office of veterans affairs and are engaged with it on a regular basis.
Comment on this
That is very reassuring. I seek clarification from Dr. Fitzpatrick. He said that there is no mental health policy currently in the Defence Forces. Where does the mental health and well-being strategy that was launched in December 2020 sit now?
Comment on this
The strategy from 2020 to 2023 has been moved on to 2024 but there were no publicly accessible outcomes from that. The Deputy is correct that the Defence Forces do not currently have a dedicated mental health policy. The framework calls for that and for a living policy that is fed regularly and understood by veterans, who would have an input into that policy. To circle back to the Deputy's first question, relieving that transition period from leaving service to becoming veterans means that veterans would be a part of that policy.
Comment on this
On behalf of the committee I would like to thank all of the witnesses for their time and valuable engagement this morning. We will now suspend briefly to allow for a change of witnesses for the next session.
Comment on this
This is the second session today on mental health supports and wellness in the Defence Forces. We are joined by the following witnesses from the Irish Defence Forces: Major General Colm Ó Luasa, deputy chief of staff, support; Commander David Lyons, officer in charge, personnel support services; Lieutenant Colonel Dr. Iseult Coolahan, head of clinical delivery in the Defence Forces Medical Corps; and Dr. Fionnbar Lenihan, mental health team lead. On behalf of the committee, I welcome them all.
The format of the meeting is that I will first invite Major General Ó Luasa to make his opening statement, which will then be followed by questions from members of the committee. Each member will have five minutes to ask questions and for the witnesses to respond. I ask members to please adhere to these timings.
Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
I now invite Major General Ó Luasa to deliver his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the invitation to attend this meeting of the Joint Committee on Defence and National Security, specifically to discuss mental health supports and wellness in the Defence Forces. Open and honest conversations around mental health are such an important part of reducing the stigma around mental health struggles and are key to promoting a culture where personnel can feel psychologically safe to seek help when required, so this opportunity today is very welcome. As deputy chief of staff, support, I have responsibility for the support division which includes the medical branch and aspects of human resources. I have specifically chosen the personnel accompanying me as they represent the Defence Forces integrated approach to the delivery of mental health services and supports.
Our personnel operate in complex and demanding environments on operations at home and overseas, across land, maritime, air and cyber domains. They endure extended periods of separation from their families, they operate in stressful environments and they may be exposed to critical incidents or traumatic events while operationally deployed. These unique stressors require us to ensure through our comprehensive approach to well-being and an integrated service delivery model of mental health that person-centred supports are available to all members of the Defence Forces. I will briefly outline some of those supports.
A career in the Defence Forces and in the military generally naturally provides many protective factors, such as peer support, camaraderie and a sense of being part of a team working in a values-based and inclusive culture, which aims to develop leaders of character and competence. In addition, there is a broad range of dedicated services available specifically to support the mental health and well-being of our personnel. In the Defence Forces we take a comprehensive approach to well-being, encompassing physical, mental, social, spiritual and environmental factors.
The chaplaincy service provides pastoral and spiritual support to Defence Forces members and their families and deploys with each major contingent serving overseas. We advise and educate personnel on nutrition and healthy eating. We have a particular focus on physical fitness and provide education, guidance, training and facilities in all aspects of physical fitness and health.
Student counsellors and learning support officers provide targeted learning supports to personnel in training. These services contribute to our comprehensive approach to personal wellness.
Specifically on mental health, our integrated service delivery model includes a full spectrum and range from peer supports and signposting to appropriate services to more targeted mental health training delivery and therapeutic interventions such as counselling and psychotherapy. The personnel support service is available at each military installation and provides the confidential services of trained military employee assistance professionals and civilian registered occupational social workers. The medical corps provides an occupational health service and its behavioural and mental health team facilitates clinical diagnosis and specialist treatment where required with a clinical psychologist and a consultant psychiatrist available.
The Defence Forces' mental health and well-being strategy was developed to co-ordinate all of those elements in a multidisciplinary and integrated way to deliver the best health outcomes for our personnel and their families. The mental health and well-being standing committee brings together those elements to further the implementation of its identified objectives, which include governance, resilience, suicide prevention and stigma reduction. It also seeks to foster a comprehensive approach to health and fitness, to support military families and to develop a model for clinical support. This strategy is grounded in international best practice and aligns with Ireland's national mental health policy, including the policy on mental health provision, Sharing the Vision, and the policy on the reduction of suicide, Connecting for Life, in partnership with the HSE's national office for suicide prevention.
By fostering a supportive, stigma-free and trauma-informed culture, coupled with integrated and multidisciplinary support services, the Defence Forces remain fully committed to protecting and supporting the mental health and well-being of our greatest asset, our people, while also ensuring that a career in the Defence Forces continues to be an attractive option for many. I thank the committee and look forward to members' questions.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here. I am going to start where I finished during the last session, which was with the assertion that the Defence Forces currently have no mental health policy. Is that true? Where does the mental health and well-being strategy that was launched in December 2020 currently sit?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. It would be incorrect to say we do not have a policy. The Defence Forces' mental health and well-being strategy was introduced to clearly communicate the organisation's approach to mental health and well-being. It clearly outlines core objectives and aspires to inculcate a culture within the Defence Forces that is supportive and caring towards those who experience mental health and well-being difficulties. The current strategy was the first for the Defence Forces and, as I outlined previously, it was developed in line with Ireland's national mental health policy, including the policy on mental health provision, Sharing the Vision, and the national policy on the reduction of suicide, Connecting for Life.
In that strategy, there are eight core objectives, which remain valid and include governance, resilience and suicide and stigma reduction. There is also managing critical instances, which is important in our line of work. We have a comprehensive approach to well-being, as I have already outlined. We also focus on caring for military families and have a model for clinical support. As deputy chief of staff, I also established the mental health and well-being standing committee to monitor and oversee the delivery of the milestones and objectives as outlined in that strategy. The committee meets no less than quarterly and explores objectives that can be progressed through the services and the members working collaboratively. That strategy will be reviewed and relaunched in 2027.
Comment on this
That is a live document that the Defence Forces are working towards.
Comment on this
It is a live document and the objectives remain valid.
Comment on this
That is excellent. When people come into the Defence Forces and are in recruit training or cadet training, there are student counsellors. Am I correct in that?
Comment on this
Do those student counsellors only exist in the joint training centre in Gormanston and the cadet school or are they based in every facility that might be conducting recruit training?
Comment on this
At the moment, they are in the joint induction training centre and in the Military College, the cadet school, but the intention is to place student liaisons in all training locations. Personnel are trained for that purpose but the process is ongoing.
Comment on this
How many facilities are lacking student counsellors?
Comment on this
Perhaps they are lacking in Galway or Limerick.
Comment on this
What does the Deputy mean when she asks about facilities lacking student counsellors?
Comment on this
I am asking about areas where there is a gap. What replaces the student counsellor? If a recruit goes to Gormanston, a student counsellor is available to him or her. If a recruit goes to Galway or to Limerick, who fills that gap if a student counsellor is not there?
Comment on this
I understand. That role has always been filled by training non-commissioned officers, NCOs, and training staff in those establishments. The role of the student counsellor does not come under my remit. It is a new role that has been set up in recognition of the larger intakes of new recruits and the ongoing drive for greater recruitment in the organisation. Student liaisons are specifically in those training locations at the cadet school and the JITC. Those are the areas where a large cohort of personnel are trained. Additional training and learning supports are provided for personnel with dyspraxia, dyslexia and dyscalculia. Guidance is also given around interpersonal conflicts specifically within the training context.
Comment on this
I have heard it is an excellent service. Is the same service and support available to recruits who do not go through either of those streams?
Comment on this
The training NCOs and personnel support service, PSS, in place have a role to play in supporting people in the operational units and operational barracks, where training also takes place. There is a reach-back capability from those units to the JITC and training supports at an organisational level.
Comment on this
There is a lot of communication in that regard.
Comment on this
There is support for those training NCOs.
Comment on this
That is reassuring to hear. Are adequate resources available to fill the gaps? I should not have said "the gaps." Are there adequate resources to support the desire to continue the expansion of those mental health supports to all units? Is the challenge a lack of resources? Is it a lack of funding or personnel? Is it a lack of training? Could the witnesses pinpoint that?
Comment on this
We will never come before the committee to say that we have all the resources we want. That probably will not happen. We are trying to move towards a more centralised training model. We are raising the numbers we are putting through the joint induction training centre all the time. We are trying to move to that more centralised model rather than relying on operational units to conduct that induction training. That will allow us to focus our supports in a way that we have not been able to up to now. Like I said, those supports remain on a reach-back basis. The front line of the training NCOs and the personal support services also exists in the JITC. We must point out that those training NCOs will pull the trigger on identifying initial issues, with further support coming from the support officers.
Comment on this
I understand. The support counsellors or student counsellors, whichever term we use, are not on the ground with the recruits. It is the NCO who is on the ground with the recruits.
Comment on this
The NCOs obviously spend a lot more time with the recruits.
Comment on this
The witnesses are welcome. I want at the outset to declare a little conflict of interest. Dr. Lenihan and I know each other through mutual connections. I will not be addressing any questions to him.
We had an interesting presentation this morning from Dr. Dan Fitzpatrick, a former colleague.
The research finds that 94% of personnel interviewed reported a reluctance to seek help for mental health issues within the Defence Forces because they felt it would negatively affect their career, that they might be medically downgraded and other issues around stigma. What is Major General Ó Luasa's view on that? Would he accept that finding?
Comment on this
Stigma associated with mental health is not a Defence Forces issue; it is a societal issue. I think we can accept that. We are doing a lot of work towards stigma reduction within the Defence Forces and it is a core objective of the mental health and well-being strategy. The need to reduce stigma and encourage personnel to feel safe when coming forward with mental health difficulties is not unique to us as an organisation or nationally. It is synonymous with mental health programmes nationally and internationally. It is a well-recognised thing.
Comment on this
Would Major General Ó Luasa say 94% reluctance to seek help is representative of the general population?
Comment on this
It is not my experience. I might get some of the other practitioners to come in.
Comment on this
No, Major General Ó Luasa has answered it and we have very little time. Does he accept the validity of evidence-based research as opposed to his own anecdotal, subjective views?
Comment on this
All I can say is that I do not recognise that level of reluctance. It is not bearing recognition in our experience as an organisation-----
Comment on this
I put it to Major General Ó Luasa-----
Comment on this
No. I am asking the questions, Chair.
Comment on this
He has. He has made it clear that he does not accept the findings of the research.
When I published my research 25 years ago, it was not accepted; it was rejected. Now, 25 or 26 years later, we have a tribunal of inquiry sitting in Smithfield. I would say to Major General Ó Luasa -----
Comment on this
This research, which was published this year-----
Comment on this
Unless he wants history to repeat itself-----
Comment on this
This research, which was published this year, in 2026-----
Comment on this
-----consulting the literature would be well worth his while.
Comment on this
-----is rather new. The data was gathered, of course, in 2021 and 2022, as I understand. We continue to deliver-----
Comment on this
-----a culture, evidence based in internationally recognised best practice, training and education in the area of mental health.
Comment on this
I have only a minute and a half and I ask Major General Ó Luasa to indulge me.
Comment on this
Here is my next question to him. He does not accept the findings of the research. Has he engaged with Trinity or the author of the research?
Comment on this
Excuse me, I need to intervene for a moment. The topic we are discussing today is the topic. It is not specifically the research although I know the research presented earlier to the committee will come into it. It is just the wider topic.
Comment on this
In the context of the theme of this session, has Major General Ó Luasa engaged with the author of that doctoral research? It is the only research that has been published in this area in relation to the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
I am aware of the publication and I know that Commander Lyons has reached out to the author. It is important to point out that we recognise the issue of stigma and we continue to work to reduce that stigma through our educational programmes, our mental health first aid and safeTALK. We communicate clearly the need to reduce that stigma and normalise conversations around mental health.
Comment on this
I thank Major General Ó Luasa for that response.
I have a question for Commander Lyons. In what way did he reach out to the author of the research?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for the question. I became aware of Dr. Fitzpatrick's research. I saw some posts online. I had no other way to communicate with him so I reached out to him online via LinkedIn at the time. I have stayed abreast of his research and the publications around it. There is certainly information in there that would be useful and could inform future policy. That was my take on that.
Comment on this
I am delighted to hear that because I think Dr. Fitzpatrick has potentially a very positive contribution to make. I do not think there should be resistance to or push-back on research, particularly when it is carried out by veterans and serving members. It is something we should celebrate.
Comment on this
As has been stated, obviously there is an issue broadly speaking in terms of mental health. It is worth making the point again, as was done in the first session, that there are in particular circumstances and issues specific to the Defence Forces in the form of exposure to PTSD and various types of traumas. In terms of the research, the standout finding from the presentation we received was the reluctance of personnel to express that they were experiencing mental health difficulties and a particular fear that it would negatively affect their career.
We had a discussion and I was anxious to clarify this. I have absolutely no doubt about the professional discretion of medical personnel employed by the Defence Forces. However, there may be an issue with the perception of discretion and not necessarily in terms of individual positions but in terms of the processes of the transferring of documentation, potential periods of leave and so on. How do we address that? If somebody is experiencing mental health difficulties or challenges, it may require a period of leave but it may not. It may simply require a certain amount of treatment and they might be perfectly capable of continuing to fulfil their role. However, if they perceive that their career progression could be affected, it creates a difficulty. If they do not address it and do not seek assistance, obviously the problem can be exacerbated. How are the Defence Forces addressing the perception of discretion, particularly with the transfer of documents, communication of that kind of thing and maybe periods of leave?
I have a question for Commander Lyons about resources. All the witnesses have acknowledged that more resources would be desirable. Have the Defence Forces made specific requests to the Department of Defence for additional posts to be cleared in recent years? How many of those posts have been approved by the Department of Defence and the Department of public expenditure and reform? How many are outstanding?
Comment on this
Confidentiality is a central tenet of any support service and one the Defence Forces take really seriously. The provision of a confidential service is key to developing that trust in the support services the Deputy has pointed out. It also impacts the reduction of the stigma around the use of those very same supports. Professionals working in the PSS and in the medical mental health and behavioural teams are bound by strict confidentiality requirements in the conduct of their professional roles.
Confidentiality statements are also available at the locations and the limits to that confidentiality are discussed with individuals as they come forward. It is made clear to people who come forward seeking help that the limitations of that confidentiality include if an individual is a risk to themselves or to others, if they disclose the abuse of a child or vulnerable person and the admission that a crime has been committed or a breach of military law. In the vast majority of cases, they do not apply. In the small numbers where they do apply, confidentiality cannot be guaranteed but the professional dealing with the case will work with the individual to involve them in any reporting process and to ensure that it is done with their consent. The service user's welfare is at the centre of all that decision-making.
When anybody comes forward seeking assistance, either through the PSS or through the clinical route, first and foremost there is a duty of care to the individual to ensure they are afforded the time to get well. That is where I think the Deputy is talking about changing a medical grade, giving them some time off work or assisting them in that way. There are a number of gateways here. The personnel support service is not a clinical service. Those working in that service do not change medical grades.
They do not award sick leave. It is only when that is escalated to the clinical side of the house that those things may be considered. It may be that when a medical grade is changed or sick leave is granted, that is all that is informed to the unit. The change in medical grade may result in the ability, or not, to do certain tasks and play certain roles while in service or it may be that they are on sick leave for a period. The detail behind that, however, is medical in confidence. Perhaps Dr. Coolahan will come in on that.
Comment on this
May I clarify what a medical grade means? It is a seven-digit number that indicates to a commanding officer what someone's medical fitness is to date for any given task. That is important. It is so that a unit commander can know whether they can deploy the person tomorrow or not. The vast majority of people with mental health and well-being issues will be managed perfectly well within the sphere of the personnel support services and they will not come through the clinical gateway at all. When they do, our purpose is to look after the person. Our purpose is to get them well. There is a time when we use something called a temporary grade. It indicates to a unit commander that there is an issue on which we expect a patient to make a full recovery, but nonetheless they are not fully operationally functional. That is the point. This workplace is different from the average one. There is access to heavy weapons and machinery, etc. We have to protect that individual while they need assistance. We also have to protect the organisation. That is the purpose of the temporary grade.
The data would suggest that the vast majority of people come out of that temporary grade within six to nine months. They revert to a normal category, which is a one or a two, and they are back fully working. Allowing and protecting that healing time for the person means the unit commander will not be asking them to do things that might be beyond their capability at the time. That is the important bit. With respect to the previous speaker, I concur with a lot of what he has to say, but it is important to understand that it is not punitive. The purpose of the medical classification is to allow the organisation to keep functioning, but also to allow that person the time heal. That is important. The vast majority do not end up being downgraded and losing their jobs. The data would stack up behind that.
Comment on this
I do not need to come in a second time. Can I get an answer from Commander Lyons on the personnel?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for his questions. He started with concerns around confidentiality.
Comment on this
I really want to clarify that. It is not so much about concerns with it. I have no doubt whatsoever about the professionalism and oaths that medical professionals and counsellors have undertaken. It is the perception of it. That is an important distinction I wish to make. I would not dream of impugning the professionalism of the professionals, whether counsellors or others.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for that. Perception is important. It is raised with me all the time in my current role. I would strongly say that if somebody's personal experience is such that they can come forward and feel confident that the organisation is either psychologically safe or not, then we need to listen to that. If the perception is that, it should be addressed and it is being addressed. The Deputy's colleague mentioned the stigma. A number of areas in the organisation are addressing stigma. The organisational culture standing committee was established specifically to address organisational culture and improve the organisational culture to ensure that it is a safe space where people feel they can come forward with their mental health concerns without fear of being judged, without the fear of stigma and without being restricted in their medical category.
Regarding stigma reduction, the Defence Forces are aligned with other organisations. They take a full part in the promotion of mental health and well-being, including mental health and well-being campaigns. They roll out safeTALK and assist in mental health first aid training. We are aligned with other organisations in that space. We do not have a different approach to it. Our approach to stigma reduction is aligned with other bodies.
Comment on this
The question was on the positions the organisation has asked for and what has been granted.
Comment on this
In resources, like the deputy chief of staff support, I would never say I have enough resources. In my own service, there is a programme for Government commitment in the Department of Defence's strategy statement 2025 to 2028 that commits to enhancing the personnel support service. As for enhancing it, I would interpret that as taking the service from its establishment in 1992, as the organisation it was then, and making it fit for purpose as an organisation in 2026 and beyond. As the organisation transforms, it is going to need an enhanced personnel support service with associated staffing levels and structures. A key piece of that is an electronic case management system. There are pieces that need more aligning with the medical service. In that regard, we are integrating better with our medical colleagues to make sure personnel can avail of non-medical psychosocial supports, up to and including clinical interventions if needed, and then return from the clinical side back into the support services. That is the enhancement of that piece. That will require resources. Rather than going through all the appointments, I can confirm that those appointments have been sought. They have been laid out in future enhancement plans. The key for me is whether it will be supported. It is about the delivery of it. The implementation is going to be key here.
Comment on this
I would just to like to add to that point. There is a firewall here and a co-operation between both the PSS non-clinical side and the clinical side. That should be recognised as very good practice.
To finish off on the point about resources, a review of the medical services has been conducted. The Minister has approved the first part of the implementation plan. As part of that, we are expanding our mental health support team. For instance, we have one consultant psychiatrist at the moment, and we hope to have 1.5 in the new services. We have one staff-grade clinical psychologist and we hope to move that to two. We are also looking for a clinical nurse manager and a psychiatric nurse specialist. We have plans to improve and expand the services and the resources available.
Comment on this
It was important to allow the time to expand that. I wish to go on to Senator Craughwell and then I will come back.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here. First and foremost, I acknowledge that they work in a disciplined organisation. Dr. Coolahan made the point that when she is assessing the mental health of people who are in possession of live ammunition and lethal weapons, it is a very different situation from any other walk of life. I am sure that having to downgrade somebody such that they cannot a weapon, for example, or serve overseas is a massive question every time she is dealing with it. That leads on to the issue of confidentiality. It is very hard in a closed organisation to show that Joe Bloggs has been downgraded with respect to active service for the time being and it is very hard to hide that. I understand the constraints the witnesses work within.
My real issue is the issue of stigma and the stigmatisation of the Defence Forces in general that has taken place. This is something that comes to me anecdotally and sometimes it comes to me by way of correspondence. People feel that as a result of their service, in what should be the proudest organisation in the country, they have been singled out. I am on record as saying I believe the publication of the independent review group report was folly. It should never have happened. It should simply have been a question of a prima facie case having been made and then going to a tribunal or whatever to establish facts, because the information in the public domain is unchallenged evidence. It has never been challenged in any format. Let us wait, therefore, for the outcome of the tribunal.
What is the impact on the overall mental health of serving members today? Are they looking over their shoulders all the time in every decision they make because they have been put under extreme scrutiny? As we have seen with the ambulance service, for example, some of the things that emerged through the independent review group are not uncommon in other organisations, and in fact, the Defence Forces probably mirror society in general. I am interested in the impact that has had on the organisation, particularly when it comes to training. Somebody once said to me, "If you're going to sign up to the Defence Forces, you should look at "Full Metal Jacket" before you go." There is robust training. There has to be. Has it changed everything?
Comment on this
Obviously, there has been a period of time here in recent years when there has been negative publicity surrounding the Defence Forces. That has led to the establishment of the tribunal, among other things, and it has led us to look at ourselves as an organisation, examine our culture and realise that there is certainly a job of work to be done, which we are doing. The organisational culture standing committee and other initiatives, such as training and educational initiatives we roll out, are certainly helping to make that change.
The current leadership in the Defence Forces is absolutely committed to having a healthy culture throughout the organisation and that encompasses mental health and well-being. Certainly, those of us who serve in the organisation are very proud of it. As for whether the organisation took a hit, yes, in terms of its standing. We reacted positively and proactively to that and are continuing to do so. We are in a much better place than we were, from a cultural perspective and from a behavioural perspective. We must remember the tribunal is looking at the systems, not necessarily individual cases. From a systems point of view, we are in a much better place and are going forward, and we are not finished developing that. The grievance management system is still under development. We have an interim grievance management system. That will develop shortly and serve the Defence Forces well into the future.
The morale in the Defence Forces has certainly been improving in the last couple of years. We are perhaps seeing recognition for failures in the past, but looking forward with a positive outlook.
Comment on this
I thank Major General Ó Luasa. Those veterans who have contacted me have remarked on the change they are seeing from outside. I compliment the major general on the efforts he is making to change the culture of the organisation.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in today. Senator Clonan was quite robust with Major General Ó Luasa there. The Senator jogged something in my memory. He had been questioning a witness here previously and he referred to his military experience in Lebanon, as I recall. I was nearly traumatised by the vivid description of what took place there and I can only imagine what people who experienced what Senator Clonan did during his active service and how that affects them. Severe PTSD is probably how it would be described. In circumstances where somebody witnesses somebody being shot, killed or maimed while on active service, for example in United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon, UNIFIL, is there any immediate mental health support available for personnel deployed?
Comment on this
Absolutely, there is. I will ask the consultant psychiatrist, Dr. Lenihan, to come in on this in a minute. We deploy people who are trained in critical incident stress management and that is the model we use to deal with that. Incident management has been a core part of how we operate in the Defence Forces for a long number of years. There are people on the ground who are able to conduct initial debriefings, and if necessary, there is a follow-up through the medical and psychiatric route if that is required.
I might ask Dr. Lenihan to come in. Trauma is a clinical diagnosis, so he might expand on that.
Comment on this
I thank the major general and the Deputy. A point was made about parallels with other organisations. Members of a range of organisations are exposed to traumatic incidents and we can learn from all of them, such as the ambulance service, the fire service and An Garda Síochána. The evidence is that the initial response should be guided by a framework and the framework the Defence Forces uses is critical incident stress management, CISM. Essentially, the initial response should be non-clinical and non-prematurely medicalising.
It is really important to recognise that difficult situations are part of the military. They are part of the role that military personnel and these other helping organisations sign up for. Therefore, the initial approach should be by peers. It should be emotional and practical support and an opportunity to ventilate, but along with that is what we might call intelligence or case finding. Commander Lyons's people, the personnel support service, and I have a very close relationship. They all have my number. When there is an incident, they will start identifying people who seem to have been particularly at risk from the incident, or who played a particularly intense role in the incident or who might be at risk, and they will be flagged with me. It is not a two-way transfer of information and a loss of confidentiality; I just hear it from them. In previous major incidents we have had, we have come up with a provisional list of people we need to catch up with after a couple of weeks. The key point is that within the first four weeks, the response for the most part should be non-clinical, except for people who display a lot of distress, but thereafter you should start case-finding and surveillance of the affected population.
The goal is to identify people who are developing symptoms and are on a trajectory. As military people, one trajectory is towards recovery and another trajectory is towards ill health. As soon as those trajectories start to separate, we try to identify the people who are not getting better or are getting worse, and we try to get definitive clinical treatment to them as quickly as possible. We have done that in critical incidents before. I am a civilian, but I was deployed to UNIFIL following an incident at the end of 2022, purely for the purpose of catching people on the ground before they came back to Ireland and disbursed to the four winds, when we would lose track of them. The key thing is close communication and co-ordination between Commander Lyons's people and us, and then strongly encouraging people into treatment as quickly as possible. There are evidence-based pharmacological and psychological treatments for PTSD. As the Deputy would expect, they work much better if you get in there early, and that is the overwhelming goal.
In the six years I have been there, we have managed a few significant incidents. We could obviously do better, but I think we have done reasonably well on that front.
Comment on this
That is reassuring. On the enlistment of personnel, what psychological assessments of their history are carried out before they join up?
Comment on this
Any potential recruit or potential cadet will attend a medical officer for a medical interview, at which time we do a full medical history, a full medical examination and a deep dive, so to speak, in terms of a systems review, part of which would be a psychological review of histories. It is the medical officer who would then make a decision as to whether they need to get further information from the HSE or from a primary carer, but that would be captured at the time of that medical officer interview.
Comment on this
A couple of years ago, our leader, the director of the medical branch, asked me to take on the initial assessments. Up to that point, I had not seen pre-recruits, that is, people who had not yet been attested. He asked whether, in exceptional cases, I would see potential recruits and potential cadets for exactly the reasons Lieutenant Colonel Coolahan highlighted. In those cases, if it is not a clear "Yes" or "No", the medical officer doing the medical has the option of referring them to me. I will see them, despite them still technically being a civilian, and render a purely occupational, not clinical, assessment. There is no duty of dental care. I will render an occupational view to the requesting medical officer. That has been in place for a couple of years, precisely because of an awareness of the importance of this area.
Comment on this
Before we go on to the second round, how do the Defence Forces measure the evolving culture or the changes in culture? When Major General Ó Luasa says it is different now, what is that based on? What do the Defence Forces use? Is it the number of people accessing support?
Comment on this
There are a number of things. It can be difficult to have an empirical measure of culture, but we look at our statistics on the training we conduct because that will have an impact on how we assess our culture and how we feel we are making that impact.
As members will be aware, we have a sexual ethics and respectful relationships programme under way, which has been running since 2025. So far, we have trained over 4,000 people in that area. That is having an impact. It sets a standard for the organisation, and it enables people to recognise different aspects of behaviour, what is appropriate and what is not appropriate, and what to do.
Comment on this
Is there a base measurement and then a measurement after the training has been done? How do we know how impactful it is?
Comment on this
Yes. It is not a test, but there are questions afterwards that participants have to go through, which confirms the learning. We also have a cultural survey. We redo that on a rhythm, and that shows improving standards and an improving sense that the systems we have in place are held in confidence, and that people are willing to come forward with grievances. That is reassuring for us.
Comment on this
We are not here to discuss that specific research but I was mindful, as we were discussing that and the work around domestic violence, how we see so few women actually reporting. I think it is about 80% in the general public who do not look for help at all. Having a cohort of individual members of the Defence Forces who would not come forward is obviously a dangerous situation for them, because then we do not know.
Comment on this
Yes, and what we do not know, we cannot manage. That is for sure. However, I would point out the level of activity that both the PSS and the clinical side are seeing. I may be wrong, but I believe there is a waiting list of about five weeks to go through the clinical system to see Dr. Lenihan, which is very good in light of what is available through the public system, and it shows there is a steady queue and number of people coming forward. If we look at the PSS, which Mr. Lyons might expand on, and the level of activity within that sphere, we do not see that reluctance to come forward. We see that it has changed.
Comment on this
As the deputy chief of staff support mentioned concerning the sexual ethics and respectful relationships training, a feedback survey or questionnaire takes place after it. Earlier this year, we did a review of the entire year for 2025. If we are looking for indicators of positive culture change, they will be contained in that. Elements identified were a need for promoting greater psychological safety and the creation of an environment where personnel can come forward to express concerns about inappropriate or illegal behaviours. As a piece of training, we were tasked to do an evidence-based workshop. Those workshops are ongoing. That feeds into a review of that training syllabus. We have included pieces that were identified in the areas. Misuse of rank or power was raised through that, and that is something that has been addressed in the Value Our People survey. Sexual ethics and respectful relationships training looks at the individual and unit level, but it feeds into the broader organisational approach required for a culture change. The organisational culture standing committee monitors that and we have the Value Our People survey, which is conducted annually. There is a commitment to do that for five years. That will ask the same questions through surveying people over a period and identify trends to determine whether we are trending in the right direction. It will give a definitive answer as to cultural improvement. So far, we have had one iteration of that survey. We are now looking at lower level indicators that the culture is changing. We are seeing an increase in people coming forward and making complaints, and the structures internally and externally are in place for those.
Comment on this
That is good. Applied suicide intervention skills training, ASIST, was mentioned earlier. Does every member of the Defence Forces receive ASIST?
Comment on this
No, not every member gets ASIST. Every new inductee gets sexual ethics and respectful relationships training. That has been included in the syllabus of training for all new inductees. From a mental health point of view, depending on the career course, the majority of NCO courses and senior NCO courses get safeTALK, which is the internationally recognised evidence-based suicide prevention training. ASIST is for people working in specific support services. All of my staff have training in applied suicide intervention skills.
Comment on this
I know it is a useful course, and I have done it myself. We did cross-community training in ASIST, whether among bartenders or hairdressers or whoever. It is a very useful two-day programme that really gives the insights needed to help somebody in distress because, as with other areas, people talk to their friends or whoever they are closest to, and they then have those basic skills they have garnered over two days to be able to respond in an appropriate way.
Comment on this
I agree. It is excellent training. It is internationally recognised. In addition to ASIST, in the area of suicide education and prevention and reducing the stigma around talking openly about mental health and suicide, my service offers a broad range of mental health training. We promote the HSE's Let's Talk About Suicide training, which is a free online suite. We deliver safeTALK training and ASIST. We have 18 mental health first aid trainers, who run our own, in-house Mental Health First Aid Ireland two-day workshop. This year, we are piloting its new offering as well, the Working Mind programme. It is a suite of measures, not just looking at the area of suicide prevention. Rather, I see it as a broader well-being suite. In addition to suicide identification and prevention, we are also promoting well-being, and that is the piece around stigma reduction.
Comment on this
Is there anybody within the Defence Forces who would not have some type of training in that area?
Comment on this
I could not say definitively. However, we do have a very proactive suicide and mental health training programme.
Comment on this
Access to services is really important, as is having the choice of access. With that choice, we see that people have reduced concerns about coming forward because they have different pathways they can choose. It would be useful to run down through those because they are extensive. We have the peer support element, which I mentioned originally, through the camaraderie of members' colleagues and the leadership close to them, and training NCOs, etc. We have the internal employee assistance professionals, who are uniformed personnel. They also form a sort of professionalised peer support. That is in the personnel support services in every location. We have our registered professional social workers, who are also part of the PSS. They are available in each location. We have the chaplaincy service, which provides pastoral care. It plays a really important role in giving guidance in a non-medical capacity, including spirituality. We have the student liaison service we mentioned, and the learning supports it provides. We have the medical officers in the GP service and occupational health. We have our medical mental health services, including clinical psychiatry and psychology. We also have an external service. That is the Lena by Inspire service, available to serving personnel and their families. This includes counselling and psychotherapy. Members have access to a free online support hub, which can be accessed privately and has a range of well-being tools. We also have an interim grievance manager should an issue be around a grievance, for confidential matters or to raise a concern, which is another external service. There are many pathways by which people who have concerns, depending on what their concerns are, can come forward.
Comment on this
Regarding the chaplaincy, is there any progress on chaplains being represented by the Representative Association of Commissioned Officers, RACO?
Comment on this
No, not yet. I know that matter is being looked at by the Department.
Comment on this
I think Senator Craughwell raised a very important point about culture. Notwithstanding the fact that he does not accept the report of the independent review group, IRG, it did identify very serious concerns.
In fact, they were an exact replica of what I identified in 2000 in my research. I was very upset to see that after 25 years, and following the disclosures by the Women of Honour, there had been no change in the culture and in many respects it had deteriorated.
Major General Ó Luasa observed or made reference to the negative publicity that flowed from that. Can we be clear on whether that negative publicity was the fault of the people who compiled these reports and researchers like me who raised a concern and pointed out systemic and criminal wrongdoing, or whether that negative publicity was the responsibility of the perpetrators?
Comment on this
I am happy to make an initial response to that. Absolutely, the only people responsible are the perpetrators, in my book. The question related to the impact of those reports on the current organisation and that was the question being answered. To directly answer the Senator's question, it is absolutely the perpetrators who are responsible. However, because we wear the same uniform, we internalise that and it has an impact. We feel criticism of the organisation personally because we are personally invested in it, but-----
Comment on this
Does Major General Ó Luasa understand that highlighting wrongdoing is constructive, prosocial and the right thing to do?
Comment on this
In the cadet school, we were all taught about moral courage and about having the courage to say and do the right thing.
Comment on this
Yes, and the reaction most people felt was absolutely in keeping with that, because we were appalled at some of the revelations. We have worked towards fixing that.
Comment on this
The IRG identified a culture of reprisal directed at anybody who raised a concern. I have had 25 years of that reprisal. If Major General Ó Luasa accepts that the negative publicity or the hurt is not the fault of people like me, I hope that, now he has said that on the record, that might come to the attention of those who are engaged in reprisal against people like me and they might have a look at themselves in the mirror.
Comment on this
Major General Ó Luasa can comment on it because it is a matter of public record, both here in these Houses and in academic papers that have been published and are being disseminated again next month in Cairnes school of business in University of Galway. It is a matter of public record and it is something he can and ought to comment on. His reluctance to comment on this speaks volumes.
Does the LA30 still exist?
Comment on this
Where, then, are personnel medical records kept?
Comment on this
I might speak to that. We have an electronic health record that is used by the HSE and other agencies, called Socrates.
Comment on this
Can that be accessed by, say, a unit commander or the adjutant of a unit?
Comment on this
No. The only people who can access it are those who have been in the medical corps, and they have to do two certificate courses, in the GDPR and medical confidentiality, before they can get a licence to be on Socrates. This is renewed every year, and we audit the use of Socrates to ensure no one is doing anything they should not be doing. Only medical corps people can use it.
Comment on this
I once again thank the witnesses. Major General Ó Luasa spoke about the services available to members who have grievances, etc. As public representatives, we get communications from members of the public on all sorts of issues at all times. I get emails with grievances addressed to everybody in the world and their aunt. During my service in the Defence Forces, I would have never contacted a public representative; it was just something you did not do. That has changed because of electronic communications. We are all available and everybody has an email address.
The major general spoke about the change in culture and what the organisation is doing and working towards. It has all these services and is revamping the grievance service, etc. Does he think the time has come to have a frank discussion with those serving in respect of when and where it is appropriate to contact a public representative, or specifically for those who step outside the system without first seeing whether the system will actually support them? I do not want to discourage those who may have a genuine whistleblowing statutory disclosure from making it. I do not have difficulty with that; if somebody wants to do that, they should have the option to do so. However, all these processes are being put in place, and now we need those people to come back in who might have felt it was easier to contact a public representative to see if that representative could fix the problem for them. We are not here to fix those sort of problems. Major General Ó Luasa's organisation is well capable of that.
Is it time to have a frank discussion during those education programmes?
Comment on this
The Senator raises a valid point. We are on a journey of cultural development, and part of that journey is engendering confidence in the systems we have and in developing them to that level of confidence. I think we are well on the way to that. It may be the case that people will contact public representatives. Of course, we have our own rules and regulations around that, but there is an increasing confidence in the systems we have. As the design of grievance management system is finalised and we roll it out, there will be plenty of avenues for people to access all the necessary services.
As the Senator pointed out, the protected disclosures system is there anyway. If they do not want to or feel strongly that they cannot go through internal systems, that protected disclosure system already exists. There are plenty of avenues and pathways for people. We encourage people to use those pathways initially and those designed specifically for the organisation, as well as those external ones that are independent such as protected disclosures, rather than going directly to individual public representatives.
Comment on this
People make protected disclosures that are not actually protected disclosures, so a bit of education in that area might go down well.
Comment on this
I might go back to mental health supports. I recognise the work that has been done, from where the Defence Forces were in relation to mental health supports to where they are, as well as the vision they have and are continuing to implement. Mr. Lyons mentioned that the plan the organisation has needs to be supported and indicated that it is all going to be about the implementation. Does he mean the Defence Forces need to secure the funding for that, or do they need organisational support?
Comment on this
I feel as though I have organisational support for it. We mentioned the mental health and well-being strategy earlier. It is a fine document, but it is the implementation stage we need to ensure we have the support. There is a plan to enhance the personnel support service and make it fit for a 2026 delivery and beyond. My experience is that sometimes it can be slow to recruit people and to put people in those appointments if we are looking at staffing. For the policy piece and the delivery of that, the key will be the implementation of it. There is a plan to enhance the service, but to answer the Deputy's question as to whether I am supported, I feel as though I am internally.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Lyons just need more personnel then? Is that what he means?
Comment on this
Yes. Initially, in 1992, it was set up as a well-being or welfare service, with a very basic peer support service. Between then and now, it has evolved into a service that has military employee assistance programme, EAP, professionals as well as ten whole-time equivalent senior occupational social workers, who are CORU regulated and abide by a code of practice. The service has become professionalised since 1992. There is also a body of work around the uniformed element, with employee assistance professionals.
If you look at the wider context, it is to make sure that it aligns with best practice in the delivery of mental health supports and that people can trust the service and trust that it is confidential. It covers the majority of people's mental health presentations, up to and including diagnosis and intervention as required by the medical side of the house.
Comment on this
That is good.
What is the process and what protections and supports are available for personnel when leaving the service? What is the co-ordination with the office of veterans affairs, for example, or the Organisation of National Ex-Service Personnel, ONE, which has previously appeared before the committee? Is there a checklist for a person who is ready to leave?
Comment on this
We run a transition to civilian life course. It is an important course, in particular for those who have spent many years in service. Of course, we also link in with the veterans' associations. The office of veterans affairs, which the Deputy mentioned, has been established in the Department of Defence. As it gets up and running fully, I hope it will have a fuller role in dealing with all veterans' affairs. We are conscious that we prepare people for that transition. The veteran community outnumbers those in service, but this session is about those in service. In a previous session, the committee spoke to veterans' associations. There is a close link, however, and it is important, particularly vulnerable people are leaving the organisation, that there is a hand-off between internal services and external services.
Comment on this
That is the core of what I was trying to get to.
Comment on this
That is really important. It is fully recognised. For instance, if someone is under treatment such as externally provided counselling sessions, it is guaranteed that they will continue up to a maximum of six sessions, I think. For anybody in receipt of treatment, it is not interrupted just because they have left the service. There is a continuum of treatment. It is the person-centred and patient-centred approach.
Comment on this
And in recognition of the service they have given to the State.
Comment on this
For the minority in active clinical treatment with the mental health team, we co-ordinate closely with the wider medical corps and medical officers around departure dates. We make every effort to ensure that treatment is continued to the point of conclusion, if possible, or handed over. We liaise HSE services in the area of residence. All notes are handed over to the GP anyway, but the mental health team does a separate handover just to be sure. We liaise with the local mental health team if required, or in many cases the GP is sufficient. It is surprisingly common for military personnel not to think about having a civilian GP. I always prompt my patients and ask them if they have a GP. I tell them that if they are planning to leave within a year, it might take that long to do all the bits and pieces, so they should get started. We actively plan and hand over care for our people who are under treatment or have mental health needs.
Comment on this
We do an occupational medical assessment a number of months in advance of discharge, so they will always be hooked into a local GP service. If they are not, we will seek a GP for them. They do not tend to leave without a GP. The transfer of care will have happened in advance of them leaving the service.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for answering my questions. They have covered from day one as a recruit or inductee all the way to the last day of service. It is apparent that there is a strong mental health policy within the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
We will conclude now. On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their time and their valuable engagement this morning. As always, on behalf of the committee, I thank all members of the Defence Forces. I would like to take the opportunity to say I am quite appalled that members of the Defence Forces who have worked extra time for the EU Presidency and shown dedication do not get paid in the same way as members of An Garda Síochána for the overtime they do. It is totally wrong.