We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Drugs Use

Drug Use Policy: HSE, Department of Justice and Department of Health

Contributions 163–334 of 334. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

My point is that if we continue the policy of criminalisation, of no control whatsoever and no regulation, we will continuously have this debate. I would argue that a better approach - and I think the majority of people would agree - would be decriminalisation of the drug user. I think that is a shift in public opinion but I think we need to go even beyond that and look at elements of legalisation and regulation. If we do not have that, what will happen and is happening is that criminal gangs will control the drug market. As long as that happens, we will have the complex issue of our prisons being three quarters full of people who are in the drug industry. We will constantly have these issues that we are trying to resolve and address unless we talk about the elephant in the room. If we do not talk about that, we will be back here in the next ten years talking about the exact same thing.

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

As regards legalisation, we do look at what other countries are doing. We are looking at the situation in Canada, the United States and so on to see what kinds of outcomes they are having in that regard. Some have reversed their moves towards legalisation. There are issues-----

Comment on this

Where? Which country is that?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

The state of Oregon is moving in the opposite direction. Canada is considering moving back as well. There are steps being taken by some where they have seen unintended consequences. For example, as regards cannabis production and the Mexican cartels, what the Garda has been hearing from its contacts in the Drug Enforcement Administration in the US is that the cartels are still producing large volumes of it. The people who can afford to go to licensed premises to purchase cannabis are people who are more affluent. The drugs gangs are still targeting people in American inner cities and still supplying them, so they are still involved in-----

Comment on this

The black market will probably continue, even if there is a regulated market.

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

The control of the black market will still be maintained by all these criminal gangs.

Comment on this

There is a black market still for alcohol and tobacco, even though they are regulated and legal. There will always be a black market for these drugs, but as long as the State completely shuns its responsibility around regulation, we will have this conversation in ten years' time and people will die. It is as simple as that. This is the question we have to ask ourselves.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Thank you, Deputy. There is lots in that. I will ask a few questions as well. We do have clinical-grade drugs that hospitals use that do not require engagement with the Taliban, when we look at how all medicines are made, so there may be some questions as to whether that is an accurate representation. There are things like heroin-assisted treatment programmes in other countries, and I am sure they are not engaging with the Taliban on clinical-grade heroin.

I am sure I can be corrected on that but my instinct would tell me that is not the case. There is something I am not understanding that is an undercurrent, which is the resistance to answer Deputy Kenny's very first question about the drugs Act having criminalised people who use drugs and people who experience addiction. Can I put that question back? It is a very simple question. Perhaps the witnesses from each Department and the HSE could answer that. Forgetting prohibition and legalisation, has section 3 of the drugs Act criminalised people who use drugs and people who experience addiction?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

Section 3 makes the possession of drugs illegal, so people who have breached section 3 have got criminal convictions as a result.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Grand, I just did not understand why-----

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

If it is illegal and a person is arrested, it is a crime, so-----

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Exactly, so-----

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

-----it is logical that if there is an Act and legislation and if the person is in breach of that legislation and charged, they will be criminalised.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Exactly. I did not understand what was happening there.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

I do not believe we fully understood-----

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Okay. For that to act as the basis, we must also look at this idea of a health diversion. We need to be very honest that the current model being worked on is not decriminalisation. I wonder if there is an objection from any of the Departments to decriminalisation in the repealing of section 3. Is there a departmental objection to decriminalisation?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

On the maintenance or otherwise of section 3, the starting point is effectively what we have heard from An Garda Síochána on the ground. Gardaí utilise section 3 and often, as a result of section 3, they find section 15 offences or they may find other offences as well. By removing section 3 completely from the Statute Book, it would greatly reduce their capacity to identify section 15 offences. That is the kind of underlying operation of it by An Garda Síochána.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

It is good to have this on record. As legislators we need to work on the idea of stop and search as a barrier to stopping the criminalising of people who experience addiction because the section that exists within the drugs Act is used for a broader purpose of being able to just stop and search carte blanche. It is using people who are in addiction and people who use drugs as a way to find other crime. From that basis I believe this is wrong in and of itself. Obviously there is the legal question about how we still ensure An Garda Síochána is empowered to pursue any other crime it sees fit, but the proposals for decriminalisation should not be put in the bin because of those other questions.

On the health diversion piece and the two strikes, let us consider the mental health aspect. In many cases there will be dual diagnoses and in many cases a lot of people also look at addiction at certain stages as a mental health issue. There are lots of different models in the way people want to look at things but we do not mandate people into care. Addiction is complex. If there is a threat of one caution, then two cautions, and then the person is going to be criminalised, and that this somehow would increase the health interventions to the point where somebody actually leaves addiction, it is disingenuous to see that as a health diversion. Every person should be offered it as an option but they should not be criminalised to access a health support. Obviously someone should be offered a health diversion if stopped and searched, but there is the issue of them being criminalised. We would have a lot of people in our communities who would not now be dead or who would not now be in addiction if the threat of a criminal sanction was the thing that stopped them being an addict, but it is not that simple. Will the representatives from the Department of Health and the HSE speak a little to the evidence for criminalising a person in addiction if they are caught in possession of drugs for their own use? What is the medical evidence and what is the medical rationale for keeping a criminal sanction on the Statute Book that criminalises the person? What is the actual health outcome for that person?

Comment on this
Mr. Tadhg Fallon

A working group was set up as part of the national drugs strategy to look at the alternative approaches to personal possession. There were policy debates and research was commissioned by the working group. There was also public consultation and, after that, three policy options were recommended to the Government. The Government decided to move forward with the health diversion scheme. In that respect it is a health-led approach that leads to the health diversion scheme. With the arrest it is an opportunity for members of An Garda Síochána to divert that person-----

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Yes, but in respect of the actual arrest piece and arresting somebody, will the witnesses tell me what is the evidence and the health rationale? Can the Department of Health say what is the health benefit of arresting someone for possession of drugs for personal use, whether it is the first time or the 12th time, and if they are in addiction, what is the evidence to support this as a good rationale from a health perspective?

Comment on this
Mr. Tadhg Fallon

The health benefit is that while the referral is made, it is not mandatory for the person to turn up to that referral, and this speaks to a point made by the Leas-Chathaoirleach a moment ago. The person will be connected with the health services and then possibly on to other services for dual diagnosis, homelessness, and other challenges that person might be facing. It is, however, not mandatory that they engage in that respect.

I will have to revert on the evidence base. There is a working group report and a Government decision on that and we will implement-----

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

I am talking more about the Department of Health. I would imagine the Department of Health would be first for help and that it would see that arrest under the criminal justice system is not a health response, even if a health diversion has been offered once or twice, because addiction obviously is complex. From a health-led perspective, how is criminal justice, even factored into a health Department response, an evidence-based health initiative?

Comment on this
Mr. Tadhg Fallon

We will have to look at some of the rationale underpinning the original report and will revert back to the committee on that.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Okay. I thank the witnesses. I have gone over my time so I might go back around. Deputy Ward is up first.

Comment on this

I will keep my questions for the Department Justice. I have zero interest in criminalising people for simple possession who are in addiction. I do have an interest in tackling those in organised crime who are making vast amounts of money from other people's misery. Young people, especially in disadvantaged areas in my area, are attracted by the lifestyle, the flash runners, the fancy cars and the few bob in their pocket. They see it as a way of escaping poverty. CAB was set up to tackle high-level organised crime and take the assets. It is a really welcome tool of the State. There are a cohort of drug dealers whose lifestyles do not match their means. You just need to go onto social media to see this. They are eating out in fancy restaurants. They are constantly going to football matches. They are probably over at the Euros at the moment. They do not have the assets but they have the lifestyle that does not match the means. When the representatives from the citizens' assembly were in here, they mentioned a community, local level type criminal assets bureau as a recommendation. We did not get a chance to tease it out. Has the Department given any consideration to a kind of local CAB? Would that be able to tackle lifestyles as well as assets? This is something that needs to be tackled. I use the GAA analogy when they are trying to attract more young girls into sports: if you cannot see it, you cannot be it. In this case, however, if young people cannot see it, they may not want to be it.

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

Absolutely. It has been given consideration and, as a result of that, a network of asset profilers exists within An Garda Síochána around the State. People have been specifically trained by CAB to identify that kind of mid-tier range of drug dealers, to look at assets they have, and target them and go after them. As part of that, the threshold levels at which CAB can seize goods or cash has reduced to €5,000 and €1,000 to go after that kind of range. CAB has had a lot of success as a result of those reduced thresholds where they can go after people who do not yet have the mansion with the reinforced windows or whatever but are the mid-level people who have BMWs and-----

Comment on this

What about a form of lifestyle - being able to go across the water to any soccer match they want or eat in any restaurant they want? They are probably not working or if they are working, they are not in a job where their means match their lifestyle. Does the Department of Justice or An Garda Síochána have the ability to go after these people and ask them how they are funding that lifestyle?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

Regarding the reduced threshold levels, I will get the figures for the Deputy but at that level, that will target these kind of things.

Comment on this

It is hard to take back a €100 steak after it has been eaten. That is what I am talking about. It is about the lifestyle.

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

It all builds a picture though and it gives An Garda Síochána the evidence to allow it to go after somebody. It is able to build a profile, make its case and decide these are the proceeds of crime and this person cannot finance that kind of lifestyle. All this is of evidential value when An Garda Síochána goes in to make the application to freeze assets and cash.

Comment on this

A new law was introduced recently concerning the coercion of a minor. Has anybody been convicted of this or have any cases been taken?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

Not yet. That was introduced very recently. It will take time before we see any cases.

Comment on this

Given the way it is written and laid out in legislation, will it be a useful tool for An Garda Síochána and the Department of Justice in going after these people?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

Yes, based on what we have seen through the Greentown programme and the trial sites, we are confident that it should be a useful tool for An Garda Síochána to be able to go after these people.

Comment on this

Mr. Ryan stated earlier that the community safety partnerships had excellent results. Could he send us some documentation outlining how the Department concluded that an excellent outcome has been reached on the part of community safety partnerships, particularly in the north inner city, because what I and others described certainly does not sound like excellence and does not appear to be excellence to the community? I want to understand how this excellence is being measured.

Regarding section 3, there are two sides to this argument. On the one side, An Garda Síochána needs section 3 to be able to intervene in the first instance and this ideally leads to a referral to health support and intervention. The other side is that it immediately introduces a criminalisation element and everything that goes with that for an individual. Has the Department done any work with An Garda Síochána in examining and assessing the impact of doing away with that section 3 power and taking away criminalisation at that point? If simple possession was no longer a criminalising event, how would An Garda Síochána operate in terms of trying to tackle drugs and drug abuse?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

We evaluated community safety partnerships all through the process. The initial baseline evaluation report and the interim valuation report were published and the final evaluation report has either been published or will be published in the next couple of weeks. There are documents out there that evaluate the programme and I can send the committee specific examples of any of the partnerships and some of the activities they have done.

Regarding doing away with section 3, Mr. Fallon referred to the work of the group led by Mr. Justice Sheehan that looked at different approaches to drug use. As part of that process, we examined jurisdictions that have done it and looked at how they could apply in an Irish context. There are deliberations in that report about the pros and cons of that. We can furnish the committee with a copy of that if that is useful.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

Access to drug services is not just through the route of being referred by An Garda Síochána. We have open access self-referral and there are many channels through which people access services be it through going online on drugs.ie, access through the HSE website or through engagement with healthcare professionals or even family and loved ones. The publication of that map of services is targeted so people can find it on their phones. It could be a family member who is worried about somebody in his or her family with problematic drug or alcohol use. It could be his or her GP or somebody within the health service. I want to make sure people understand that there is not just one channel. In fact, that would be a very minor channel of access and we would encourage anybody who is concerned about problematic drug use to avail of those resources because they are available across the community.

Comment on this

Last week, the citizens' assembly appeared before us. One of the recommendations concerns funding for drug services, recovery services, community services and education. Unless the funding, resources and services are in place, we cannot deliver a new drugs strategy. The sector is chronically underfunded. The Government has failed to support services like drug and alcohol task forces for years. Their funding is shocking for the work they do. They are not given multi-annual funding. If we are serious about a drugs strategy, we must start off with the basics and the basics involve services, funding, community and recovery. This is where we need to put money.

Reference was made earlier to an additional €13.5 million in 2023 and 2024. This is a tiny amount compared to the level of need. How much did the interactive map cost? One third of the money is allocated to community and voluntary groups. Where does the rest go? Why was funding not provided to re-open Keltoi? Was the decision made by the HSE, the Department of Health or the Government?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

Expenditure on drugs services is broken down across a number of major categories. HSE addiction services account for about 45%. Services provided by the community and voluntary sector account for about 39% or 40%. GPs and pharmacies represent about 15%. This is based on 2022 data. The Health Research Board, which gathers all this information and does the underlying research, accounted in 2022 for about 1% of that funding. Since 2022, there has been a 12% increase in funding for drugs services. I welcome this committee, particularly the attention of the citizens' assembly, attending to what is a really important topic. There is a significant stigma around accessing services. As Professor Keenan said, we do not see very long waiting lists for many of our drug services. This tells us that we need to increase awareness if there are people out there who are struggling with problematic drug use and do not know where to go. When we see things within our health services like increased waiting lists or higher demands in one part of the country-----

Comment on this

My apologies for interrupting but I wish to correct something. We have figures about people trying to access detox, rehab beds and residential beds. There is a significant shortage there so it is not correct to say there is none. These are figures I received from the Department or Minister. We need a massive roll-out of beds in that sector. People have to pay a fee to access treatment. In many cases, the fee is €90, €100 or €120. These are vulnerable people. Access should be free. We need more beds. I do not accept the point that there is no backlog.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

What I mean is that when we see areas that are under pressure in terms of higher demand, we put the increased funding towards those.

For instance, in the current year we have increased the funding to dual diagnosis services because we know there is an underdelivery of services for people who are coping with both addiction and mental health issues. We now have a model of care, which tells us what "good" will look like and we are now rolling out the provision of those services for both adults and adolescents in different hubs around the country. When the evidence tells us there is an increased demand or a growing need for something, that is how the funding is also being allocated. I welcome the Deputy's proposal around the need increasing.

Comment on this

I am sorry, but I am just conscious of time. How does that tie into Keltoi not being open and when----

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

I am going to pass the Keltoi question over to HSE colleagues.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

There are plans. Dr. Keenan will outline the progress made on Keltoi.

Comment on this
Dr. Eamon Keenan

Ms McArdle has mentioned the national dual diagnosis programme. Keltoi is proposed to be the HSE national dual diagnosis rehabilitation centre. That centre was recommended in the model of care that was launched in May 2023 and it is going to be used to rehabilitate people with serious and significant mental health and substance use disorders. It is going to be a national service and accept referrals from across the country. This is planned as a partnership between HSE social inclusion in CHO 9 or Dublin north city and the dual diagnosis clinical programme for the HSE mental health services. The staff who were employed in Keltoi previously are going to be working in the new dual diagnosis clinical programme. There was a meeting with the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, and the national dual diagnosis clinical programme in the Department where proposals were put forward for a day service or residential service.

Comment on this

Has that decision not been made?

Comment on this
Dr. Eamon Keenan

The resources have not been provided.

Comment on this

Have resources been looked for or have they been denied?

Comment on this
Dr. Eamon Keenan

The resources have been sought.

Comment on this

I am looking for honest answers here. Is the reason Keltoi is not open that the Government has not given the funding to open it?

Comment on this
Dr. Eamon Keenan

The reason it is not open is we do not have the resources to repurpose Keltoi.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

On the model of care, a lot of work has been done on the emerging issue of dual diagnosis. The model of care has outlined a really good approach to this. The submissions have been made regarding resources and they will be considered.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

Ms McArdle may know. I think they will be in the normal Estimates process.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

They will be actively considered-----

Comment on this

Keltoi has been closed a couple of years now. It was closed under the guise of Covid. Then it was used as a Covid centre for marginalised and vulnerable people. To be honest, this is a sham. I want to ask a straight question now.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

It is an opportunity. The model of care for dual diagnosis is really important and the model of care is really good.

Comment on this

I agree with Ms Queally 100%. I just want to know-----

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

I have to move on.

Comment on this

Vice Chair, I just want an answer. Has money been applied for and who has not given the money?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

The money has been applied for and the application is under consideration. That is my understanding.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

By the Department. Money has been applied for by the HSE and the Department-----

Comment on this

Ms Queally means the Department of Health.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

Yes.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

It is considering that proposal.

Comment on this

Vice Chair, this is shocking.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Agreed. Deputy Hourigan is next.

Comment on this

I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach. I want to use my four minutes to talk about potency of drugs. Before I do, I wish to return to the issue of Oregon reversing some of its work on drug decriminalisation. It is important we put on record that when it took that action three years ago it interacted with a thirteenfold increase in drug overdose due to fentanyl, which nobody who engaged in that lawmaking could have envisaged. Also, the legislators themselves said there is an interaction with homelessness. One of the problems for Oregon is it has rampant homelessness and one of the ways it dealt with that was effectively by putting people into the system and without relying on drugs and drug possession to do that it had no way to effectively move people on within communities if they were homeless. I wanted to say that because I have been following the Oregon thing very closely.

One of my interests here is the change in potency. We have talked a little about the change in the type of drugs we are seeing and in synthetic drugs. In the past few decades we have also seen an increase in potency in drugs we are more familiar with, like cannabis, which can be seven to eight times more potent. That is before we start looking at the addition of more psychoactive substances. I think it is called polysubstance use where people are adding bits together. The HSE is doing work on monitoring potency of all sorts of substances, but with a justice-led approach, when the Garda is stopping and searching for standard possession, what is the approach to understanding and documenting the potency of particular substances? What is the communication and interaction between these two groups?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

It would be very helpful to have representatives from An Garda Síochána here to talk through that because they are the operational people on the ground. Essentially, if gardaí seize drugs from somebody they will be sent to Forensic Science Ireland. Forensic Science Ireland will analyse the drug and report back. There is good engagement with the HSE, particularly on-----

Comment on this

Forensic Science Ireland is doing it on the basis that a file has been sent to the DPP and there is going to be a prosecution.

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

It has been seized as a result of criminality, so it is sent to Forensic Science Ireland for analysis, yes.

Comment on this

In the case of a particular substance, if the potency is considered especially high, as opposed to a less potent version of the same substance, does that impact the conviction?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

No, the conviction is for-----

Comment on this

The type of substance and not the potency of the substance.

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

Yes.

Comment on this

In the context of a sector that has seen potency exponentially increase, with all the problematic impacts that would have on people, I ask all three groups whether they think the current legislation is suitable to deal with that issue. Does the current legislative approach address potency?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

I can-----

Comment on this

I think the answer from Mr. Ryan is it does not, at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

From our point of view it does not.

Comment on this

With a justice-led approach-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

If a substance is illegal-----

Comment on this

-----it does not matter to the Department-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

-----it is illegal irrespective, yes.

Comment on this

If it was 1978 and you had a joint and it was one level and you get arrested in 2008 and it is eight times more potent it makes no difference to the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

The substance is illegal, so the possession of the substance is illegal.

Comment on this

Okay, but the impact on the person is completely different. Does he take that point?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

Absolutely, yes.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

From the Department of Health's perspective, what we have seen is when new drugs have come on the market or impacted on people, such as crack cocaine, we have an obligation to respond and adapt and ensure we are providing and working with the HSE to have-----

Comment on this

What Ms McArdle means by that is if there is a new drug the HSE puts it onto the list of controlled substances and it is now something that would be recognised. I am asking how the HSE's current policies are addressing situations where there is an existing drug, the nature of which is changing out of all recognition.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

The policies have not adapted to that. They are more around looking at the impact on the service users and the services that are dealing with people impacted by those drugs.

Comment on this

How does one look at the impacts without looking at the potency? For example, if all of a sudden a drug we have been familiar with for decades changes to the point where it is eliciting health outcomes that were not envisaged, how can that be addressed without considering the potency?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

The policy itself is broad enough. I will give the example of the synthetic opioids. That change around naloxone and broadening the training role of the HSE is an example of how working with colleagues in the HSE and other agencies we use the broader lens of the policy to be able to adapt. The policy itself does not preclude us from being able to respond in a more agile way to that change in drugs at the moment.

Comment on this

However, the Department of course cannot regulate potency in any way.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

No.

Comment on this

It has no control.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

No.

Comment on this

Okay. Moving to the HSE, does that lack of control concern the officials?

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

Mainly our concern is providing people with the services, giving them access to the services and responding to the needs as they are presenting. As we said at the outset it is a very complex and fast-changing environment. Dr. Keenan might want to come in as some of the initiatives that have been outlined have facilitated that adaptability in addressing what are very changing issues within society.

Comment on this

What Ms Queally is describing is, at the end of a process or at the end of the imbibing of a substance, we record and then respond.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

Throughout the early part of the discussion today, we talked about the upstream factors and having a comprehensive, holistic approach to addressing substance misuse, particularly as it interacts with environments in which there is poverty, poor education and environmental factors. A lot of the contributions this morning discussed the importance of upstream work in prevention. Even at the recovery point, Dr. Keenan made the point that it is important that options are available for people during their recovery in education, employment and support for families. That is where we come at this-----

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

We have to move on. Dr. Keenan is looking to come in. I want to check if Deputy Shanahan is okay for him to respond? Yes.

Comment on this
Dr. Eamon Keenan

On the potency issue, it is a factor for the HSE because with higher-potency substances, we get more referrals. If one looks at what is happening for those aged under 25, the substance causing the most referrals is cannabis. Some 40% of our referrals relate to cannabis. That has increased year on year as a result of the increase in potency. It has a knock-on effect for health. We have to respond to that because we are the treatment providers.

On the labs, I wish to mention our national red alert group. For the first time, the labs have sat down with us around the table and we are working collaboratively on responses around nitazenes. The Deputy is right in that previously, analyses of drugs were done on the basis of a prosecution but we need greater emphasis on the analysis of the content of drugs to see the potency and if there are other contaminants. That is what the national red alert group chaired by the HSE does. The laboratories, An Garda Síochána, HSE emergency management, the ambulance service and the emergency departments are sitting around the table looking at these emerging trends. The Deputy is right - these new substances create lots of difficulties and we need to know what they are.

Comment on this

I thank Dr. Keenan. That is good to hear.

Comment on this

I wish to address a question to Mr. Ryan of the Department of Justice. On the inner city programme which Senator Fitzpatrick discussed, I would be interested to get the information she requested when that is possible. Will Mr. Ryan provide exactly what is happening there? He said there were excellent outcomes. I have some knowledge of community safety partnerships. A former Secretary General of the Department of Justice, Sean Aylward, led out on this in Waterford. I noted Mr. Ryan's comment that the Department will, he hopes, look for a local leadership programme and for people to step forward. That is not very easy to do in terms of community involvement, particularly where drug dealing is rife. There are significant personal safety issues for anybody, particularly a member of the public, in trying to combat any of that. I am not quite sure what that will look like. I will wait to see.

What is the Department's opinion on trying to deal with the issue of drug supply into the country? Others spoke about the difficulty of trying to tackle organised crime. Obviously, supply is interdependent on price. We saw in past years that when the price of drugs rose, it had an effect on consumption. The witnesses will be aware of recent talk of our defence situation and the navy in particular. We have no ability to interdict drugs being landed on the south coast, which we have seen a number of times. What does the Department of Justice think about that in terms of our defence budget? We have not done anything. Three ships have been tied up in Cork Harbour in the past months, unable to go out to sea because of a lack of recruitment and workers. The same is true of An Garda Síochána and its recruitment programme. We hear about the churn of new gardaí passing out and not staying in position because of that. Where is the Department of Justice speaking to Government on this issue?

I wish to also ask about CAB activity. We all remember Fachtna Murphy and Barry Galvin at the time when the CAB was set up and the stellar victories they had against organised crime. It appears the situation has now changed. Organised crime is much more organised now, unfortunately. There are very effective telecommunications and IT systems at play. There is a long-running saga of a crime family overseas who cannot seem to be apprehended or brought to justice for their involvement in drug dealing. I think the Department has an important role to play. In fact, I do not think it, I know it. Obviously, its statute is that as well. Will the witnesses speak to a few of those points?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

On drug seizures and large seizures of drugs transiting through the country and through the south coast in particular, I will not comment on anything to do with defence, with respect, or defence budgets. An Garda Síochána has seen significant seizures and successes as recently as, I think, February, when there was a joint operation between An Garda Síochána and Revenue in County Cork. There was a seizure with an estimated value of €32.8 million of synthetic opioids. It is seeing successes. We would like to see more people in An Garda Síochána. We have been assisting it with attempts to increase recruitment and throughput through Templemore. There is a challenging recruitment environment at the moment, not just for An Garda Síochána but for any employer. There is much more fluidity and mobility. People pick a job for a couple of years and then decide they want to broaden their horizons and do other jobs. That is not unique to An Garda Síochána. It is the case across the board. We have it in our Department; I am sure every other Department has it as well. The job for life career attitude seems to have disappeared, largely. Despite that, we are doing everything we can to support An Garda Síochána to increase recruitment and a budget has been provided to do that.

CAB has continued to expand its efforts and we continue to support it in adapting to the changing model of organised crime. In my response to Deputy Ward's question, I was not clear on one point. The thresholds have been reduced to assets of €5,000 and cash of €1,000 since the Proceeds of Crime (Amendment) Act 2016. That is to target the mid-level foot soldiers as well. The Deputy spoke about people operating and controlling things from other jurisdictions. We have collaborated with other jurisdictions to try to formalise extradition treaties and mutual legal assistance treaties. We are getting good co-operation. We are happy with the level of co-operation. These processes take a significant amount of time. There are different legal systems and languages and translation issues and so on. We have to make sure that if someone is to be formally sought to be extradited back to this country, the case is watertight and legally robust and there are no technicalities that someone can get away with. Extensive work is going on in that regard between us, An Garda Síochána, the Director of Public Prosecution's office and the Department of Foreign Affairs. There are concerted efforts on international co-operation to target drug dealers operating abroad. I think those were the three points the Deputy asked me to comment on.

Comment on this

I am not au fait with the latest initiatives from the Department. While we are talking about how we might solve things at the consumer end, what is happening in the drug space, unfortunately, is that it appears that the volume of drugs coming into the country is increasing. Mr. Ryan mentioned a high-profile drug seizure. It was said that was the fourth of those. Three previous ones of that scale had come into the country. How much of it comes through here and transits on to other countries is another question. A significant amount of it is obviously destined for the Irish market, unfortunately. Mr. Ryan does not wish to comment on what our naval assets can do but if drugs are being dumped at sea, which is what is happening, and we do not have a way of interdicting that, it is a significant policy deficit which needs to be addressed.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

I will have to find it but there is good research on drug markets and that no matter how many interventions or seizures happen, it is such an intelligent market that they never interrupt the market, because it is so big.

What we sometimes see when a seizure happens is that the market corrects itself so quickly that is not really felt on the ground or it does not remove the substances, although it can do that for a little while. There has sometimes been a scarcity of certain types of drugs but it is an intelligent market. John Collins has done research on that, and it might be beneficial for the committee to read it.

I have two questions for Mr. Ryan and two for Dr. Keenan. We will then go to a final round of brief comments because we have until 12.30 p.m. I may need to leave within that time. If I do, Deputy Ward will take the Chair for the final ten minutes.

Two of the questions arise from earlier comments. Deputy Kenny gave statistics in regard to possession offences still being at a high level and Assistant Commissioner Kelly noted last week that people were also being prosecuted for other stuff. That is a bit confusing. Does it mean that the people being prosecuted for other stuff are not entitled to the adult caution scheme? If there are other charges against them, they would be up for the other charges, so why are they up for cannabis offences? Why are the two not being uncoupled? It is saying that if someone is being prosecuted for any other thing, they are not entitled to the adult caution. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

It is not exactly as cut and dried as that. It will depend on the nature of the other offences. If there are other low-level offences, it is possible that gardaí can use their discretion to allow someone to avail of the adult caution scheme. If they are more serious offences, however, that will be taken into consideration. The adult caution scheme is not aimed at people who are involved in more serious offences. Section 15 would be the main one in this regard. If someone is being charged with possession of a particular drug with intent to supply and may also have a small quantity of a different drug for personal possession, they would not be considered suitable under the public interest test around suitability for adult caution.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

That means there are caveats that we are unaware of. Is an audit being done of those 17,500 cases referred to by Deputy Kenny? Is there an audit of the prosecutions to identify what people are being done for at the same time, meaning that they do not meet the criteria for adult caution?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

Not currently, no.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

My second question is on grooming. I have always had a personal issue with this because, for me, poverty and the environment are why grooming happens, yet we seem to want to target particular groups and say they are responsible for the grooming of those in this or that age group. Within the policy or the legislation, is it possible that an 18-year-old can be charged with grooming a 15-year-old?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

It is possible. Where the other person is a minor, and we are aware of instances where 16-year-olds and 17-year-olds have been conditioned and are grooming younger kids, the legislation will not apply to them. However, for those aged 18 and upwards, it is possible.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

That is extremely problematic. When we look at the nature of some communities and their access to youth work, we see young people as being those up to the age of 23. They do not just go from being a child to being an adult. The sequence of grooming is complex in the sense that there are many people who live in the same community who are being given the same access to the same illegitimate resource for making money. I have huge questions about that.

I have a question for the HSE regarding naloxone. We talked about training. I am not sure we discussed the current position in respect of over-the-counter naloxone and what decision needs to be made on that. Training might be important but the nasal naloxone is much easier to use. Where are we at with regard to access to naloxone over the counter? That question is also for the Department.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

I am not a clinical person, but I know that naloxone is only permitted to those for whom it is prescribed. It is a controlled drug.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

I know that. However, I had a Commencement matter recently in reply to which it was stated that the Department was moving to over-the-counter access. I want to know the current position.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

I will come back to the committee with an update on the status of that.

Comment on this
Dr. Eamon Keenan

The HSE is now recognised as an organisation that can do the training. It can then apply to the HPRA to get naloxone onto its premises. That is where we have been working with the private emergency accommodation providers, the hostels and so on. For example, Simon and other organisations are trained under the HSE naloxone programme and they can then get a licence from the HPRA to hold it.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

On the street about a week and a half ago, I encountered a suspected overdose. I would not be able to tell, but I suspected that it was an overdose. I checked her and she had no naloxone. The experience was difficult because nobody wanted to help me put her in the recovery position. They did not even want to touch the girl. It was a really horrible experience. I am used to overdoses. I have dealt with them many times, but I was definitely not used to the on-street experience. One older lady came to help me keep the girl up straight while I negotiated with a shop to ring for an ambulance. It was a negotiation that she should have an ambulance. In that situation, it is about being able to run into a chemist and access the nasal spray. Obviously, you are taking a risk as to whether it is an overdose or not, and it could have been anything that was wrong with the girl, but it is not going to cause any harm to her in that context. Given that there are so many people on our streets who may not even be in a service, it is important that we can access naloxone.

I apologise for going over my speaking time. When we talk about options for recovery, this goes right back to the very first comment from Dr. Keenan regarding the response when someone is coming off methadone and needs those options and supports, and being able to fill the gap that accessing the service used to fill, whether that be education or employment. When we look at options, is it noted and acknowledged that those options are massively decreased if a person has a criminal conviction for possession of drugs, which cannot come off their vetting forms? That will stay on the vetting form in line with murder, sexual offences and gun crimes. It will remain there so somebody who is looking to access a particular source of education or employment is excluded from full recovery due to a criminal conviction in many cases, although not all. When we talk about options, do we need to acknowledge that, under the current legislation, a criminal conviction reduces the options for recovery?

Comment on this
Dr. Eamon Keenan

Yes, a criminal conviction can have an impact on people's employment travel.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

We will move to the next round. I call Deputy Ward.

Comment on this

I have a comment and a question for the Department of Health. I went on the interactive map of addiction services this morning before I came to the meeting. I found it a bit clunky. It is probably still a work in progress, and I am not the best when it comes to IT. There is duplication of some services. I would bring that to the Department's attention.

I had a particular look at residential services. To my surprise, Keltoi was listed as a residential service on the map. As we know, and as Deputy Gould just mentioned, it has not been open for four years. We had debates with the Ministers of State at the Department of Health, Deputies Feighan and Hildegarde Naughton. They both gave commitments that they were going to reopen it. From listening to the interaction between the HSE and Deputy Gould, the buck seems to be stopping with the Department of Health in the context of why it has not reopened. Will the Department comment on that? Is it because the Department did not get the resources from the Government or did the Department prioritise resources elsewhere? I am seeking to discover the reason money has not been prioritised for Keltoi.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

I am not aware of the specific referrals to the Department regarding Keltoi, but I can speak to the investment in and the requirements for investments in dual diagnosis services. Part of the Sláintecare theme is to ensure that services are delivered at community level, supporting people to live in their own homes and ensuring they have access, and that is then stepped up all the way to residential services.

Comment on this

I have limited time.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

I will revert to the committee.

Comment on this

Before it became a dual diagnosis service, Keltoi was also open to other people. For example, if someone was doing a methadone detox in Cuan Dara in Cherry Orchard, there was a door-to-door service whereby they could detox in Cuan Dara and then start their rehabilitation journey in Keltoi. That is the piece of the jigsaw that is missing. People finish their detox and, more than likely, they are going back out into the community because that space is not there for rehabilitation. That is another aspect that needs to be looked at outside of dual diagnosis.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

We will revert to the Deputy on the status of the funding application.

Comment on this

I look forward to seeing that note because no excuses are acceptable for the delay in not reopening the Keltoi unit and not having it offering residential care too. I am not looking for a nine-to-five, Monday-to-Friday service because that is not going to run here. I will also be talking to Deputy Cullinane about this issue too. Deputy Ward and I have been commenting on the Keltoi unit for some years now. To be honest, I am shocked the witnesses have come in here today and no one can tell us how much money is required and when the unit will be open again. It is unbelievable.

On naloxone, I agree with what the Leas-Chathaoirleach said. Councillor Daithí Doolan and I have met different groups in Dublin that were sidestepping the systems in place so they could get naloxone to people who needed it. I was impressed by the ingenuity of these addiction service groups in Dublin. We know naloxone saves lives. What is the issue here? We need to get this substance out to a broad swathe of people, including family members and communities, where there is a high risk. I know there needs to be training. The Leas-Chathaoirleach described an experience she had last week. I imagine that if naloxone had been available then, she would have been well capable of being able to deliver it to the person who was potentially at risk of an overdose.

Will the Department of Justice give figures on the number of young people brought through the youth diversion programme for drug possession?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

I do not have information specifically for drug possession. We have figures for the numbers of people who go through youth diversion schemes nationally, but these are not separated out into particular offences or the number of offences.

Comment on this

I request that this be done. There are different issues here, but we need more information on young people at risk in relation to drugs. It is all about the data because it will tell us what we can do.

I had a case in Cork where a person was selling these new psychotic drugs. I contacted the local gardaí. They felt they did not have the training to prosecute under the criminal justice laws. I contacted the Minister, who told me that a letter was sent out detailing the relevant Act. As far as I know, gardaí are not even getting the training in Templemore. Is there an issue with red tape? The person I referred to was selling products from her door for months, if not years, and the gardaí could not act because they did not have the training. Has the matter been resolved at this stage?

Comment on this
Mr. Ben Ryan

I am not sure what the specific issue is around training, so I will have to inquire with An Garda Síochána. I am not sure what issue has been raised, so I cannot say whether it has been resolved or not.

Comment on this

I am referring to these new synthetic drugs coming onto the market. They used to be sold in head shops. The witnesses might remember there was a gap in the legislation when head shops were selling these materials. The loophole was closed but the normal gardaí on the beat I spoke to in Cork did not have the training. This should certainly be part of the training for gardaí in Templemore and not just the subject of a letter. A letter is not going to run.

Comment on this

I will address the issue of supports for people recovering from addiction, so my question is mainly to the witnesses from the HSE and Department of Health. I represent Dublin 1 and 7. Many addiction supports are available while people are in active addiction. Following on, thankfully, we have a Housing First strategy and people are found placements, often in private accommodation. Sometimes, however, these placements are in places that are effectively being operated by approved housing bodies. Will the witnesses outline the framework and communication between AHBs and their respective organisations in terms of ensuring that people in Housing First are getting supports? I know community workers are going in and checking on certain people. I also know, however, that some of those placements are, in some cases, chaotic. I have people coming into my constituency clinics saying they have a placement like that and it attracts people who may also be in addiction and it becomes a problematic situation in that housing. I am interested in hearing what the live conversation is between AHBs and the Department of Health or the HSE in supporting people who are recovering or are in Housing First programmes and in active addiction.

Not to put too fine a point on it, some parts of the country, like Dublin 1, have a high provision of those places and are increasingly being put under serious pressure. Is the Department of Health tracking the management of all such provision by the Dublin Region Homeless Executive, DRHE, various charities and the HSE directly, so we have a live-action map showing how many people are in Dublin 1, Dublin 8, Kerry or Limerick, for example? I very much believe some communities are bearing a greater burden than others.

Comment on this
Ms Martina Queally

On the first of the Deputy's queries, I ask Mr. Doyle from our national social inclusion office to respond.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

I thank the Deputy for her question. We work in partnership, as she knows, with the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, which has given responsibility for oversight to the Housing Agency. That is all co-ordinated in partnership between the Housing Agency and us in the HSE. There are nine housing areas-----

Comment on this

I will stop Mr. Doyle there. I will outline the situation as I understand it. There is the Department of Health, where the money starts. That is point A. We could go back to the Department of Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform, but we will start at this point A. Point B, then, is the HSE. The HSE then works with the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage. That Department then puts the Housing Agency into the mix. The Housing Agency then goes to the AHB.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

We have an oversight committee co-chaired by the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage and the Department of Health. As part of that, targets are set for the Housing Agency to take up tenancies across the country. These are agreed with the local authority areas. The HSE, in partnership with the local authority areas, develops plans to service and support people in the Housing First tenancies programme around case management and access to health services.

Comment on this

Is the HSE tracking how many placements are in each area and if the number is appropriate?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

We would know through the local authorities where people are.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

It is the local authorities that are responsible.

Comment on this

The HSE knows where people are but is not making any judgment call on whether the provision would be appropriate in a given area.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

As I said, the programme itself is very much fluid.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

We are working together with the local authorities.

Comment on this

Is my characterisation correct that the euro that starts with the Department of Health goes through all those stages before it gets to the service user?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

No. Funding is provided to the HSE to support the Housing First programme.

Comment on this

The HSE goes through the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

We work with the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage.

Comment on this

Is the Department of Health monitoring how many placements are in each area across every single service provision?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

As Mr. Doyle said, representatives of the Department of Health sit on the oversight committee. We have oversight with the HSE of the delivery of the target for any particular year. We have ongoing engagement with our colleagues in the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage outside that structure if there are any issues ongoing nationally. Just to say, however, one of the things about the supports is that there are the immediate supports for a person in a tenancy, but there is also the role of the support around mainstreaming and pathwaying people to the services in their local area. For each individual-----

Comment on this

Okay. I know I am way over time-----

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

Yes.

Comment on this

-----but can I just say one thing? Is Ms McArdle telling me then that the Department of Health has a sense of the situation across all the service providers? Let us take Gardiner Street as an example and say there are 320 of these placements on that street. Would the Department of Health have a sense of that and the kind of social impact such a number of placements is going to have on that street? Is anyone in the Department of Health doing this type of analysis?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

At the moment, it would be within each integrated healthcare area.

Comment on this

The answer is "No", is it?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

It is "Yes" and "No", if I can put it that way.

We work closely with the HSE on how it is delivering on those targets for their particular regions or CHOs. However, we have a gap in terms of the data sharing. The Deputy has pointed to an issue whereby we do not have single identifiers for people who-----

Comment on this

In certain areas. If everyone ends up in Gardiner Street, that is just luck of the draw.

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

We are reliant on the local community healthcare organisation or local health area to-----

Comment on this

The local community health organisations are telling me they have no control because the money comes and no one is saying this street is over the top.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

There are various different agencies depending on which geographical-----

Comment on this

I know. That is the problem.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

For Dublin, for example, there is one agency currently providing Housing First for the Dublin area. Basically, that agency knows where all the placements are. The HSE-----

Comment on this

I disagree with you on your narrow definition. I can tell Mr. Doyle that is not how it really works on the ground. There are multiple agencies which are putting transition units in place, basically. It is all being focused in certain areas.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Doyle

Housing First in Dublin is provided by one agency.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

We have come to the end of our session. Unfortunately, if I let Deputy Gould speak, I will have to let everyone speak.

Comment on this

I just have one question. It is a yes-no answer.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

He can ask his question only if his colleagues agree they are not going to come back in and if he keeps it to one sentence.

Comment on this

I welcome the news that the supervised injecting facility will be open in quarter 4 of 2024. Has it been considered to provide safe consumption rooms and is there any timeline for delivery for Cork and Limerick?

Comment on this
Ms Siobhán McArdle

Part of the purpose of the review was to identify how well it works and how it serves those communities. This is absolutely a pilot project. We know from other jurisdictions that this kind of harm reduction measure is an important tool in the overall toolbox. If we are seeing the same needs arising in other parts of the country, we will absolutely have to actively consider it.

Comment on this
Dr. Eamon Keenan

Legislation only allows for it to be an injecting facility. There has been a lot of talk about Naloxone this morning. I wish to say the HSE would be happy to offer all the members of the committee training in the identification of overdose and the use of Naloxone.

Comment on this
Lynn Ruane An Leas-Chathaoirleach Independent

That is very much appreciated. We will definitely write to the members of the committee to see how we organise that. It is very useful. This has been an extremely informative morning. We got through a lot of different issues and I thank everyone for their patience and for their latitude in terms of time. I thank our witnesses for engaging with the committee today. Their contributions and answers have given us a lot to think about and they have opened up a lot more conversations as we go forward. I thank them for their time.

Comment on this