Protection of Young Persons (Employment in Food and Beverage Services Sector) Regulations 2026: Discussion
The proposed regulations would let 16- and 17-year-olds in restaurants, cafés, takeaways and similar businesses work until 11 p.m., aligning their rules with licensed premises; existing limits and protections remain, with adult supervision required after 10 p.m. The Minister said the change addresses a regulatory inconsistency, supports employers and expands work opportunities, while protecting education and welfare. Members raised concerns about youth consultation, low-paid labour, wellbeing, impact data and enforcement; the Minister undertook to monitor implementation, though baseline data are not available. Several members supported the measure, and the discussion ended without a recorded committee decision.
Item No. 4 on today's agenda is the draft statutory instrument on Protection of Young Persons (Employment in Food and Beverage Services Sector) Regulations 2026. The Dáil and the Seanad have referred the statutory instrument to the committee. I welcome the Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment, Deputy Alan Dillon, to make his opening statement to the committee. This is his first visit to the committee and he is most welcome.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and all committee members for the opportunity to appear before them to discuss the proposed Protection of Young Persons (Employment in Food and Beverage Services Sector) Regulations 2026. I emphasise that the Protection of Young Persons (Employment) Act 1996 remains the corner-stone of Ireland's approach in safeguarding young people in employment. Its purpose is to protect the health, welfare and educational development of young people, while recognising that employment can provide valuable skills, experience and opportunity for personal development.
The proposals I am bringing forward today are guided by those same principles. They are not about weakening protections. They are about modernising the regulatory framework and addressing a clear inconsistency in the current legislation to ensure that young people continue to benefit from employment opportunities in a safe and appropriately regulated environment. Under the existing legislation, young people aged 16 to 17 are generally permitted to work between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m., subject to limit on daily and weekly working hours and other important protections relating to rest periods and welfare. However, since 2001, an exemption has existed for young people employed on general duties in licensed premises. Those young people may work until 11 p.m. in certain circumstances, including during school holidays and on nights where there is no school the following day.
As a result, a situation has arisen where a young person may legally work until 11 p.m. in a pub serving food, but may not so in a restaurant, café or takeaway operation next door. This distinction no longer reflects the realities of the modern food and beverage service sector. The proposed regulations will extend the existing late working exemption for the wider food and beverage service sector. In practical terms, that means that 16 and 17-year-old workers carrying out general duties will be permitted to work until 11 p.m. in restaurants, cafés, takeaways and similar food and beverage businesses under clearly defined conditions.
At the same time, the existing regulations applying to licensed premises will be revoked and replaced by a new united framework that applies consistently across the sector. This objective is straightforward. It creates a level playing field across similar businesses and removes the regulatory anomaly that has existed for many years. The rationale for these changes is grounded in the realities facing businesses and young workers today. Many businesses in the food and beverage sector operate later into the evening, particularly during weekends, holiday periods and peak tourism seasons. Employers have consistently highlighted staffing challenges during these periods, as well as the need for greater flexibility in workforce planning. The Department received representation highlighting the inequity of the current arrangement and subsequently undertook a detailed examination of the issue. What emerged was a strong case for updating the regulation in a way that supported businesses while continuing to protect young people.
Importantly, employment offers many benefits to young people. Part-time work can provide practical experience, help develop confidence, responsibility and communication skills and support further participation in the labour market. These opportunities should be available across the food and beverage sector in a fair and more consistent manner. I want to be absolutely clear that these proposals do not diminish existing protections. All the safeguards contained within the Protection of Young Persons (Employment) Act 1996 remain fully in place. The statutory limits on working hours, rest periods and welfare protections will continue to apply exactly as they do today. In addition, young people attending school will not be permitted to work late on nights immediately before a school day. Protecting educational attainment remains a central consideration in the design of these regulations.
Indeed, rather than removing safeguards, the proposal introduces a significant new protection. For the first time, all young people working after 10 p.m. in the food and beverage sector will be required to be supervised by an adult. This mandatory supervision requirement will apply across the sector. While young people working in licensed premises may already work alongside adult employees in practice, the proposed regulation will place a clear and explicit legal obligation on employers to ensure adult supervision for young people working after 10 p.m. This is an important enhancement of protections. It responds directly to concerns raised by consultations regarding welfare, health and safety, and provides reassurance to parents, guardians and employers that young people working late hours will do so in a properly supervised environment.
Before bringing these proposals forward, the Department undertook extensive consultation. The first stage was a public consultation conducted in 2025. This was followed by a statutory consultation process in 2026, carried out in accordance with the requirements of the 1996 Act. Stakeholders were afforded the opportunity to make more detailed submissions and representations. Engagement extended across a range of groups, including employer representative organisations, trade unions, youth representation, Departments and individual members of the public. Organisations consulted included IBEC, ICTU, the Restaurants Association of Ireland, the Irish Hotels Federation, youth participation groups and a range of other stakeholders. The consultation process revealed broad support for the policy objectives. Stakeholders highlighted the benefits of achieving parity between licensed and unlicensed businesses, providing greater flexibility for employers and creating additional employment opportunities for young people. At the same time, concerns were raised in relation to educational impact, worker welfare, job quality, supervision and possible displacement of adult workers. These concerns were carefully considered throughout the policy development process and informed the additional safeguards included in the final proposal.
Ultimately, the role of the Government is to strike the appropriate balance. On one hand, we recognise the legitimate operational needs of businesses across the food and beverage service sectors. On the other hand, we have a responsibility to ensure that young people remain protected and that employment does not negatively impact their health, well-being or education. Having considered the evidence, stakeholder feedback and other legal requirements of the 1996 Act, I am satisfied that the regulations achieve the balance. They are targeted, proportionate and address a long-standing inconsistency in the law. They do so while maintaining the fundamental protections that have underpinned youth employment legislation for nearly three decades.
In closing, these regulations represent a practical and measured reform. They support employment opportunities for young people, provide greater flexibility for businesses, strengthen protections through the introduction of a mandatory adult supervision and create a fair and consistent framework across the food and beverage service sector. The welfare, safety, health and educational interests of young people remain paramount. These proposals reflect that commitment while also ensuring our legislative framework continues to meet the needs of a modern economy.
Comment on this
That concludes the opening statement. The speaking rota is as follows. The first slot is Sinn Féin, followed by Fianna Fáil. The Sinn Féin slot is first and Senator Fitzpatrick is second. I call Deputy Conway-Walsh.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State. I do not oppose this legislation but I am concerned about who is pushing it and if we are balancing the business needs with young workers' rights. This is what this committee will try to do when speaking about this. The Minister of State said he had consultation, but how much has that consultation been with youth groups and representatives of young people? I will express my disappointment that I cannot at this moment see the impact that the reduction to 9% of the VAT rate has had on workers or workers' rights. Has the Minister of State done an analysis of how much of the €800 million has been passed on to workers, and in particular how much has been passed on to young workers?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for her questions. In regard to the consultation that was carried out, as I said in my opening statement, the Department entered a public consultation and invited representatives and stakeholders. We had feedback from business organisations, trade unions, IBEC, ICTU and other youth representative groups. Indeed, the Department of Children, Disability and Equality was also consulted with regard to the objectives of changing this legislation. Organisations representing young people were also given the opportunity to engage in the process. It was very transparent and open. We published the notice outlining the proposed regulation changes in regard to our website.
Comment on this
I just want to get a feel for how much engagement there was in that. Did they respond to the Department's invitation for them submit it? Has the Minister of State met the youth groups themselves to discuss this? What issues have they raised with him?
Comment on this
We opened a 21-day consultation period. Again, like any consultation, it is up to the representative bodies themselves to report back. In terms of the feedback, it varied. Business organisations welcomed it through the food and beverage sector. There is a challenge in terms of labour market activation. Indeed, many young people see the benefits of taking up a part-time job during their studies to earn an income but also to develop their life skills in terms of teamwork, discipline, timekeeping and areas of responsibility. This is specifically related to the food and beverage sector. Our focus is to continue with the existing protections currently in place under the 1996 Act but also we are extending and strengthening them to coincide with licensed premises.
This very much addresses the anomaly that currently exists between food and beverage sectors such as restaurants, cafes and food outlets to align them with licensed premises. When we discussed this-----
Comment on this
I know what it is trying to do. I am trying to look at the unintended consequences and the whole picture in terms of sub-minimal rates and how we prevent this from leading to even more. While there are some wonderful employers who employ young people, we have to always make sure there is not exploitation and it is not used just for providing greater access to cheaper labour. That is why I was keen to know what was coming back from the National Youth Council of Ireland, for example, which will be in after the Department to discuss this. Outside of the consultation and invitation for submissions, were there any specific meetings to iron out how that could be balanced or worked into this legislation to ensure we are not just going down the route of more cheap labour for the market?
Comment on this
With respect, the regulations we are talking about today do not set the wage rates. They are very much-----
Comment on this
That is up to the employer and that is set out. Separately, on sub-minimal rates, any exploitation of young people is unacceptable. I think we all appreciate that. The regulations currently in place are still very much focused on ensuring there is adult supervision from 10 p.m. on, appropriate-----
Comment on this
I welcome that. My time is very limited. I am trying to get into how to address the risk of this being an incentive to rely more heavily on lower-paid workers. Has that risk assessment been done? Will the Department do an analysis of the impact of the reduction to 9% on VAT in particular on young workers?
Comment on this
If one looks at the context of why we are making this change, the regulation does not say every 16- or 17-year-old should work until 11 p.m. That is at the discretion of the employer and the young person who wants to take up employment. It allows it in specific circumstances; we are providing the flexibility. If you take Belmullet, for example, and young people who want to work in the tourism sector, at the minute, they would not be able to work in a cafe or restaurant beyond 10 p.m.
Comment on this
This provides the legal permission to do that. It also gives the choice to young people to work at the weekends or part time. It also provides an opportunity to have one united, proactive framework in place. At the minute there are two systems which are not very accommodating-----
Comment on this
-----to one versus the other. The 11 p.m. time limit is very much the outer limit. You cannot have anyone working past that time. This is about ensuring young people have an opportunity to work shifts and employers have the flexibility and benefit-----
Comment on this
I completely understand. I am not going to take up any more time but I need to make sure the voices of young people are equal to the voices of the employers in this situation. I thank the Minister of State.
Comment on this
We have quite a full house today so we will keep moving. I thank Deputy Conway-Walsh. I call Senator Fitzpatrick followed by Deputy Gogarty.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State and the Department for coming to the committee today. We are the enterprise committee but we are talking about young people. In Ireland, we have quite a high engagement rate. Our young people are very engaged in employment, training and education in comparison with those in other European countries. I see that as a positive thing that young people have a lot of opportunity in our country to engage in employment, training and education. That is a good thing.
I am though also very concerned that young people in Ireland report poor mental health. I think about 50% of young people are classified as having low mental health. That is something we have to be very conscious of and concerned about. I understand the pressures the hospitality industry is under, the cost and viability pressures of hospitality, small businesses and independent businesses in Ireland but I am concerned that by extending these hours, we are trying to fix one problem - the cost of operating a business until 11 p.m. and those unsustainable costs - and inadvertently potentially causing another problem.
What evidence is the Department relying upon to ensure that when these hours, permissions to work later for younger people are extended, that there will not be a negative impact on young people's well-being, mental health or ability to engage in education and training? The Department will have a certain amount of evidence that led it to make the recommendation which I accept and none of us have a crystal ball. I am sure the Minister of State was not given one when he was given the job but will he share with the committee how the Department expects to measure the impact on young people? I am very struck that when young people are disconnected in society, when they do not feel like they are participating - in particular if they are working late in a hospitality environment that they do not feel like they get to participate in that hospitality environment or get to go out and have a meal or have drinks in a bar - that creates a serious disconnect. I would be genuinely concerned about that going forward. Will the Minister of State speak to the evidence that informed the recommendation? More important, how will the impact be measured?
Comment on this
I thank Senator Fitzpatrick for raising these important concerns this afternoon. The precise figures in regard to the 16- and 17-year-olds are not available in terms of identifying the number who may be impacted by these specific exemptions currently. The Department expects the impact to be very much concentrated within sectors where young people are employed, in particular in food and beverage services, restaurants and cafes, etc. The regulations are permissive. They are not mandatory. They do not require any young person to work additional hours. The protections are still in place in terms of health and safety, rest periods and maximum hours. They all currently exist.
We will monitor the implementation. As a Department, we will be tasked with monitoring the implementation of the regulations including any issues in relation to workers and feedback from parents, employers, trade unions or enforcement bodies such as the WRC to ensure they are doing as they should and young people are supported. If evidence emerges contrary to what the policy intervention intended to do, we will consider the next appropriate actions.
Comment on this
I am concerned with the first part of the Minister of State's response which was that the Department does not have any data. I struggle with that as a response because if we do not have the data captured in the first instance, I do not know how the Department will monitor any impact.
That is very concerning. The reality is, and we all understand, that these are not prescriptive but rather these are creating an opportunity, and I do see it as an opportunity. However, if you are a young person and you go to a restaurant or bar to look for part-time work, they might say they will take you on but you will have to work until 11 p.m. If the young person tells them they can only work to 10 p.m. for whatever reason such as that they need to be up for early lectures, the employer is not going to hire them. They will hire the person who will work until 11 o'clock at night, so the fact they are not prescriptive is a given. I do not think the agency is with the young person to say that. I do not think it is workable for the employer either to do it like that, to be fair. There is an onus on the Department to capture the impact, however. I understand you have to try things, because until you try something, you do not know whether it will work, but the impact has to be captured, and if you do not have the data in the first instance, then you need to go back and get it before you implement changes. That is my recommendation.
Comment on this
The CSO does not capture that data specifically for sectors or young people within the age brackets we are talking about here. At the moment the data does not exist. What we do know is that-----
Comment on this
Surely Revenue would be able to capture that data if they are employed, paying taxes and their age is there? I apologise as I appreciate I am going over time but I do think it is an important point for the committee. Revenue should be able to provide that data to the Department. I am not suggesting it gets it for individuals. I am suggesting anonymised data is requested from Revenue and captured.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for her co-operation and assistance this morning. It was greatly appreciated.
Comment on this
I take a more laid-back approach to this because you are only talking about a couple of thousand kids, ultimately. As of now, they are able to work in pubs anyway, so you are talking about some restaurants, a couple of hotels that might have front-desk work rather than bar work and takeaway outlets. There is an issue of young people in college not being able to pay for accommodation and not getting enough supports, which is a separate debate. It is an important part of a young person’s life, but equally you are talking about an older cohort there. The 16- and 17-year-olds are largely fifth and sixth years, so they would not have those kinds of costs but they do want to get money and save. If the difference of an hour is going to encourage an employer to take on a young person locally rather than advertise for a position that cannot be filled in a particular town, then that makes a lot of sense. Will the Minister of State elaborate on what gave him and his colleagues the idea in the first place? Who was driving it, so to speak? I am interested in that, first of all.
Comment on this
I meet small family-run businesses and independent operators every day. It was raised at a number of levels about the inconsistency between licensed premises and those next door which are very similar whereby the anomalies became an issue. Staffing challenges also form part of the context in regard to hiring. I do not think there is any value in pretending otherwise, and the Deputy has made that point clear. The food and beverage sector is unsociable hours. We have seen a real decline in those who are willing to work those unsocial hours post Covid. We have seen a huge shift in the labour market, with staff moving away from the bar, restaurant or hospitality sectors. This is not the sole purpose of the regulation change but it certainly does not remove any of the current protections that are in place. The central policy is that similar businesses are currently operating under different rules whereby a licensed premises can employ a young person on general duties until 11 p.m. and a restaurant or café providing similar food services cannot. It addresses both. Flexibility is the benefit of this reform. That is what we are trying to achieve in terms of regulating as well as ensuring we have added protections around a supervised system for those up to 11 p.m.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State. One of the challenges is enforcement of that supervision. Will there be any additional resources put towards carrying out inspections? Will the Minister of State clarify whether the supervision provision was already required in licensed premises or is this coming in for the whole lot? That is one of the questions.
Comment on this
It is an enhancement of the existing situation. It is coming in for the whole lot.
Comment on this
Grand. You would assume there is a senior bar person working in a pub situation who could be supervising someone, lounge staff or whatever, while in a takeaway there could be a lot of people working in a McDonald's but there would be a manager there anyway, but in a family run business there might be a young person being put with another younger person. How can you make sure the rookies on cheaper rates are not being left to close up? How will that be monitored to make sure no exploitation is taking place?
Comment on this
The supervision is required by a person over 18 years of age who is employed with assigned responsibilities. That is the first provision put in place. Also, it is not enough just to put a person on a roster without having that supervisor in place. Young people should not be left isolated or left alone. That is a central position that the Minister and I discussed in relation to the food, restaurant and takeaway services. Difficult situations may arise late into the evening and you do need appropriate safeguards in place.
Comment on this
There are two angles of appropriate safeguards. One is where 16- or 17-year-olds are being left on their own with a person over 18, which has its own questions and checks and balances. The other thing is to make sure you do not have two 17-year-olds. How many times will a premises be inspected to make sure appropriate levels of supervision are taking place at all times?
Comment on this
The standard inspections will comply with the Workplace Relations Commission inspectors. It will be part of their normal duties. It will be expected that employers have the appropriate paperwork in place if they are inspected. That is the point that is relevant to enforcement. It is okay having the safeguards but we do need the WRC to enforce this. That is why we are putting this in place as a legislative framework to ensure it is in place but not diminishing any of the protections currently in place.
Comment on this
What is the envisaged timeframe for the passage of this through the Houses?
Comment on this
Presenting it to this committee is probably one of the last things. We hope to have it enacted as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for being here today. I have been involved in various businesses over the years but I am also involved in social enterprise. We have a youth café in Greystones which works brilliantly. The stamina and willingness to work among the young people in Ireland is fantastic.
This new legislation basically allows the young person within the food and beverage sector to work until 11 p.m. Usually they are 16- or 17-year-olds. They will be supervised by a senior employee aged 18 or over. I wonder is the gap wide enough?
An 18-year-old is barely an adult themselves, so I wonder if that is a real safeguard? Should we not go a little bit stronger on that and have 21 as a minimum age for a supervisor or duty manager, etc?
A number of my colleagues have asked who is driving this. When the Minister of State was asked, he mentioned the he had talked to various family businesses, SMEs, etc. It seems like it is being driven from the employer’s side rather than the youth representative bodies and so on. What problem does it solve? Is it the costs for the employer or is it allowing greater flexibility for young people to work?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for his questions. Regarding the adult supervision piece, legal responsibility remains with the employer. An adult is deemed to be 18 or over. There must be requirements around training and supervision before an employee is delegated those responsibilities. That must enforceable if the WRC does an inspection. The regulations established 18 as a minimum age for the supervising person, but an employer can select someone who is older. That is their decision in terms of who is carrying out that area of responsibility. It is a measured approach and an enhancement to what is there.
In regards to the regulation and its introduction, it fixes an inconsistency that exists between the licensed premises and those that are unlicensed. It is not a general relaxation in regards to the protections applying to young persons; we are strengthening them with additional supervision. It is probably opening the door for a lot more young people and employers to see young people in viable employment opportunities into the future. It addresses two issues.
Comment on this
The Minister of State mentioned inspections. Does the Department have any data on how many WRC inspections of under-18 employment in hospitality took place in the past year and how many breaches were found? Do we have information on that?
Comment on this
In regards to the WRC inspections for hospitality, food services and the retail sectors, there were more than 3,200 inspections in 2025. The number of breaches recorded following those inspections was 293. We have a very robust workplace relations inspection system. Inspectors are on the on the ground and can examine matters such as proof of age, working hours, required workplace notices, and compliance with relevant employment regulations and protections. It is no different than any other sector. They can call at any time and ensure that employers are maintaining the required standards that the Government has set.
Comment on this
These workers can legally be paid, I believe, €9.91 an hour. The Low Pay Commission recommended abolishing the youth rates in 2024 and the Government deferred that decision in April 2025. Where are we on that? When will that be decided? We are going to discuss that in the next session as well.
Comment on this
In budget 2027, this Government again increased the minimum wage to €14.94 from €14.50. It is a challenge for many small businesses. Operating costs are very difficult and subminimal rates are complex. It is about striking the balance between the viability of a business and ensuring that workers are protected.
If we look at those aged between 16 and 17, they receive 70% of the minimum wage. That is €9.91, as the Deputy said. As a Government, we will keep it under constant review, respecting what the Low Pay Commission's recommendations have presented. However, the Government needs to ensure that we have the businesses that create those jobs. The food and beverage sector especially is a difficult area. We made decisions in budget 2026 to reduce the VAT rate to 9%, and thankfully that has taken that debate and argument off the table. We know how important tourism is to our economy.
We want to continue to address youth unemployment and ensure that our young people have the skills and talent, but also the work experience. There is no better place to harness those skills than in the hospitality and food sector earlier in one’s career. We will keep it under continuous review.
Comment on this
I have run various businesses. What the Government has to do is walk a tightrope because it has to keep the employers happy while also trying to ensure that employees are respected.
Comment on this
I congratulate the Senator on the work of Tiglin over recent days. I saw its Halloween function and thought it was just fantastic. It is a great organisation that does great work.
We now go to Deputy McCormack, and to Senator Nelson Murray after that.
Comment on this
The Minister of State and I have had robust discussions in the Dáil on different issues regarding business, whether about County Offaly or in general throughout the country. I am delighted that he has taken this issue on and worked with it.
I am fully in agreement with the Bill and with making a level playing field. This committee has spoken numerous times about youth unemployment and young people not having opportunities. Allowing them to be able to work until 11 p.m. in those other businesses will mean that they can get the extra employment that they need. We have heard from other contributors in the past, and I myself come from a small business. We had a family grocery, which I grew up and worked in since I was eight years of age, but I also worked in a local nightclub collecting glasses when I was 16 or 17 years of age, and I learned an awful lot from working there.
Other contributors have in the past mentioned how young people transform when they come into the workplace - how their confidence grows, how they get their independence, and how they move on in life and learn about reading and judging people. We talk about youth unemployment when young people finish college and have their degrees. Employers are not taking on that cohort of young people. Youth unemployment is at 12.5%. The only way someone can get experience for working is by actually going to work, and these are the opportunities we are creating and putting in place for those employers. By allowing employers to level the playing field, it provides young people opportunities. That is very good.
We also have to look at the workforce out there. I do not believe that there are employers who are abusing this situation by taking young people on for a lower rate. In most cases, employers cannot get employees of any type to fill these positions. These positions are being filled by young people because they are available, not because they are young people. As well as that, it is ideal for young people to be able to take these jobs at the weekends when they are in school and also to have work in the summer time. We spend a lot of time talking about all of the positives that are created by giving young people the opportunity to work and how it helps them to grow and prepares them for life in the big bad world when they get to that.
I am fully behind the Bill and I look forward to see it being enforced.
Comment on this
I acknowledge Deputy McCormack's contributions, not just here in the committee, but in the Dáil, in terms of his advocacy for independent small businesses and for retail.
Earlier this week, we brought forward a proposal on "vacancy to vibrancy" to try to support our high streets across many regions, starting with 26 town centre first towns. They are an important starting point because they provide a range of different sized towns, different economic developments and regional balance. We will expand that to more shopping thoroughfare streets and other market towns. It is about providing a front door for many businesses, supporting them to engage with local authorities, local enterprise offices and town regeneration officers to identify the landlord or owner of the building and how they can work on occupying it, either for pop-up stores or for a long-term venture, but also ensuring that the supports are put in place around it. We are engaged with the Deputy in Offaly on a few towns he brought forward. I acknowledge his efforts in that regard.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister of State. We are members of this committee because we have a big interest in small business. Colleagues can really feel the passion we have for small businesses and making sure they survive. For the last 19 years I have employed young people. Myself and my husband have 25 people working in our business in the hospitality and leisure sector. I absolutely know what I am talking about when I talk about hiring young people.
Senator Fitzpatrick spoke about mental health and well-being. I can absolutely guarantee that for the majority of young people who come in to work, it transforms their lives in terms of their communication, and giving them responsibility and financial independence. These are people who walk in the door and can barely shake my hand because they have not worked before. I am out working since I was 13 but it was different then. To see a young person grow into a more mature person, gain confidence and enjoy working and independence, to be off their phone or gaming device and interacting with the real world - that is why this is important. The world we and young people are in now is very much online. The current 16-year-olds have come through a very difficult time when it came to Covid, being at home and not out there. It is important to give them the opportunity to work the hours that are required. I can tell the committee that it is not being abused. It is very difficult to get any employees, especially ones who will work at weekends and into the evening times. If I have a 16- or 17-year-old who will say "I will", I am absolutely delighted to take them on. That is the reality of the situation.
Businesses should be able to offer suitable employment to willing young people, rather than having to turn them away because of inflexible working restrictions, so I very much welcome this. Small businesses are under immense pressure. My colleague, Senator McCarthy, spoke about a minimum wage for younger people and asked when we are going to look at that. We need young people to look forward. They have to start somewhere. I disagree with having a flat minimum wage for people who are just starting work and having it the same as the minimum wage for somebody who is 19 or 20 years of age. We all have to look forward to things in life. They start their jobs on the lower rate and work hard to get the higher rate. I think that is fair and appropriate.
Small businesses are under immense pressure and are fighting to keep their doors open. They are fighting to keep their businesses viable. Young people add tremendously to employment and to a business or organisation, particularly in the hospitality and leisure sector. We are open 19 years and have hired people for 19 years. I was the CEO of Play Activity and Leisure Ireland, PALI, where there are 120 businesses in the leisure sector all employing young people. We support them getting through college and secondary school. We support them going for their first insurance that costs €4,000 when they want to get their own car. That is what it costs. It supports the family. I would disregard their income when it comes to SUSI but that is another day's work. It should not be added to the family income.
We are based in an industrial estate and there are a lot of businesses based a little bit outside of towns, while a lot of cafés are in rural areas. It is very important that we look after young people in how they get to and from work. We see the dangers of scooters and the dangers of how young people dress getting in and out of work. Maybe there could be some sort of help or transport grant, rather than depending on parents who are working themselves, for a safe way of getting young people to and from work at weekends, particularly up to 11 o'clock. That would be something to take into consideration.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. She is another real champion of small businesses who has the lived experience. As policymakers, we certainly welcome any of her considerations in respect of regulations. I know from conversations with her and with many other small businesses that the statutory rate of minimum pay for many young people is not the maximum. While it is the minimum, a lot of businesses are paying way above that.
Comment on this
I think we need to understand that also. Employers do value young people, who can progress and be rewarded for their hard work and for taking on responsibility. With a substantial increase in the minimum wage again this year, we will see the under-18 statutory rate increase from €9.91 to €10.46 in 2027. We are at rates that were seen back in 2020. Young people deserve fair treatment and we want to ensure that they get it. On the Senator's contribution on their participation in work, it is equally important in this regulation, when we are talking about 16- or 17-year-olds, that education does not become an afterthought. That is very much what should come first and this regulation could come second. The protections for young people are very much framed around that.
Comment on this
On that point, I do not think any of our employees, especially in leaving certificate or fifth year, would not tell us they could only do a Saturday or a Sunday because of school. That is the majority of workers all the time. They do place great importance on their education, as the employer does. The last thing we want is to have a young person working all the time and not getting all the benefit they can out of doing their leaving certificate properly. I think most employers take all of that into account.
Comment on this
That is good to hear. Any part-time job should complement a young person's development. It should not undermine their attendance, study, preparation for examinations or any educational attainment.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State and the Senator. That concludes the discussion. I thank the Minister of State for attending today. Undoubtedly, we will see him again in the not-too-distant future.
The meeting will suspend for approximately five minutes. We are missing the Minister of State's opening statement, so it would be great if that could be supplied to the committee so we can publish it on our website.