Youth Unemployment and Youth Guarantee: Discussion
A TASC report commissioned by the National Youth Council found that youth unemployment has fallen, but under-25 employment remains well below pre-recession levels, with more young people outside the labour market and substantial emigration. Witnesses linked this to insecure or low-paid work, housing and transport costs, and barriers to employment; they said available data showed no clear recent effect from AI. The NYCI called for a cross-government youth employment strategy, investment in youth services and equal access to the full minimum wage. Members also highlighted education and apprenticeships, while youth-service experience pointed to hiring discrimination, unanswered applications and the need for stronger employer partnerships.
The next item on the agenda of today's meeting is our consideration of a report, entitled Youth Unemployment and the Youth Guarantee in Ireland, which was undertaken by the Think-tank for Action on Social Change, TASC, for the National Youth Council of Ireland, NYCI, in September 2026. I am delighted to welcome three speakers to today's meeting: Ms Kathryn Walsh, director of policy and advocacy at the NYCI; Mr. Oisín Gilmore, senior economist at TASC; and Ms Aimee Harding, education and employment manager, Swan Regional Youth Service. Before we proceed, I propose that we publish the opening statements provided by the NYCI at today's meeting on the committee's website. Is that agreed? Agreed.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where he or she is not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the parliamentary precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any member partaking via Microsoft Teams, prior to making his or her contribution to the meeting, to confirm that he or she is on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.
Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is again imperative that they comply with any such direction.
I now invite Ms Kathryn Walsh to make her opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the members of the committee for the invitation to appear before them today and for taking the opportunity to discuss the report commissioned by the NYCI and undertaken by TASC, entitled Youth Unemployment and the Youth Guarantee in Ireland. The NYCI is the representative body for voluntary youth organisations in Ireland. It represents the interests of young people and youth organisations. Our role as the national representative youth work organisation is recognised in legislation. I am director of policy and advocacy in the NYCI. I am delighted to be joined by Oisín Gilmore, senior economist at TASC, who undertook the research we are discussing today; and Aimee Harding, education and employment manager at Swan Regional Youth Service. Together, we can address both the evidence base and the real-world implications for young people.
While headline employment figures tell part of the story, we are particularly interested in how the quality, security and accessibility of work shape young people's opportunities, independence and life choices today. The NYCI commissioned TASC to undertake this research earlier in the year, initially as a rapid review to inform our own internal work. Following the completion of the analysis and given the new lens and analysis that came, we felt it was important that it was published and disseminated more widely. Mr. Gilmore will speak to the detail of this in the questions section. What makes this analysis important is that it asks us to look beyond the unemployment rate. It challenges us to examine longer-term trends and asks a more fundamental question: what are we embedding for young people in our labour market? Every few years, when economic conditions worsen, young people reappear in our national conversation. We express concern about rising unemployment, discuss activation programmes, launch new initiatives and revisit familiar proposals. Yet, when conditions improve, the focus shifts elsewhere.
The language changes over time but many of the issues do not: the underlying challenge of securing a stable and independent future remains. Indeed, too often young people are spoken about as a problem to be solved, or as a cohort with problems, rather than as citizens whose participation in work, education and society should be a central measure of our economic success.
Are policymakers asking the right questions? Are they speaking to young people? Is formal education preparing them for the world outside those rigid systems? What have been the impacts of Covid-19, which, for many, robbed them of socialisation and work experience? Finally, when young people are trying to get a job, is the door locked? We see now that entry-level jobs are demanding years of experience. Young people are repeatedly applying for jobs only to be met with silence. Critical life transitions are cliff edges for many, not springboards. We know not only from this analysis but also from other research from the NYCI that precarity in work is translating into precarious lives in terms of access to healthcare, mental health care, family formation, housing and relationships. Our State of Our Young Nation report, published in 2024, noted that the most significant concerns for young Irish people are housing and the rising cost of living. That is reinforced annually by RED C polling undertaken by the NYCI. More than half of those with rental or mortgage payments have experienced an increase in the past year. Some 44% feel financially worse off. Over one in five have skipped meals due to costs. The gap between aspiration and expectation surrounding key life milestones highlights how life milestones have been "pushed out" for this generation of young people in Ireland.
Young people encounter insecure and poorly paid employment. The consequences are evident beyond the labour market, with growing rates of severe material deprivation and homelessness demonstrating how workplace precarity increasingly translates into broader life insecurity. For many young people in Ireland, insecurity is not simply a feature of work or unemployment but a defining characteristic of broader life circumstances and future opportunities.
When Sai described to us commuting from Galway every day for work, he put a human face on an issue we hear repeatedly in the NYCI. Young people across the country are undertaking daily lengthy journeys to reach work, training and education. Many leave home before first light and return long after dark. They do what is asked of them. They take on long commutes, unstable schedules and significant personal costs simply to access opportunities that are increasingly concentrated in particular parts of the country. The question we need to ask is not whether young people are willing to work; the question is whether our policies are creating the conditions for young people to have a decent quality of life alongside work. Too often young people are asked to absorb the burden of structural challenges in our economy. Long commutes, high housing costs and limited opportunities are not individual failings; they are policy challenges. If we are serious about supporting young people into employment, our focus must extend beyond getting people into jobs and towards ensuring that those jobs contribute to a sustainable and dignified life.
What this analysis of the data available to us tells us is quite clear: that while the level of youth unemployment has dropped, this trend does not appear to have been driven by a commensurate increase in employment. The real challenge is to build structures that support young people throughout economic cycles, not just periods of crisis. Put simply, the debate can no longer be confined to unemployment. It must be about young people's place in the economy and whether the opportunities being created are genuinely reaching this generation. That is the challenge this research puts before us.
One of the lessons we can take from the UK, for example, is the importance of recognising that youth economic inactivity and labour market participation are not challenges that can be addressed by a single department or through labour market activation measures alone. In the UK, the Milburn review was not simply a Department for Work and Pensions exercise. It was commissioned with support from ministers responsible for employment, health and education, backed by cross-government analytical teams and informed by experts from youth policy, industry, skills, labour markets and public services. It recognised that complex problems require integrated solutions. That is the conversation we need to have.
If this research shows us that fewer young people are in employment today than before the financial crisis, despite low unemployment and a strong economy, then we need to move beyond activation alone. We need to understand the wider picture. What role are housing costs playing? What impact do health and well-being challenges have? How do education pathways, transport infrastructure, regional disparities and job quality affect young people's participation in work? These are not questions for any one Department. They require a genuinely cross-government response. Hopefully, after today, this committee can start that conversation.
I thank the committee again. We will all be available for questions on the research.
Comment on this
Thank you, Ms Walsh. That was very insightful. You are a former Member of the Seanad, so fáilte ar ais. You are very welcome back.
We now go to our first speaker, who will be Deputy Albert Dolan. Then we will go to Deputy Clendennen, rolling on the rota.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for being here. When we are talking about youth employment or youth unemployment, we cannot have that conversation nowadays without speaking about AI. Over the past 30 years, Ireland has really succeeded off the back of the endeavours to build up an incredibly skilled, talented knowledge worker workforce. We have become reliant and dependent on knowledge worker roles across our society, and these have been highly paid, highly skilled roles where we have excelled. That is part of the economic success story of Ireland, and we are still on that economic success wave, but there is no point in our having a massive economic success if we cannot bring our young people into the fold and if we cannot afford them that opportunity to keep it going, to carry it on.
What is unfolding at the moment around AI? Are companies taking on as many graduates as they once were? Are graduate programmes as active as they once were? What is the reality on the ground that the witnesses see at the moment? Whoever is most fit to answer those questions may do so.
Comment on this
When I was commissioned to do this piece of research, it was precisely on this kind of question around AI that the NYCI was curious. I approached the question with an open mind, expecting to find a significant impact of AI on youth employment and youth hiring. There is quite a bit of anecdotal evidence that this is happening. I have heard from a number of employers' groups that they are hearing about slowdowns, including hiring slowdowns in graduate recruitment programmes. However, when I looked at the statistics around youth unemployment or youth employment or youth hiring, it was not really showing up in the statistics. There does not seem to have been any significant changes in youth hiring or youth employment or youth unemployment over recent years. Rather, what I found was a longer term problem - this is kind of the main takeaway of the report - that youth employment levels are still subdued relative to where they were before the recession. Before the recession, there were youth employment levels of over 400,000 fairly consistently, at times even north of 440,000. During the recession, this collapsed. It fell by more than half and reached a low point of about 189,000.
Comment on this
What defines youth employment in terms of an age bracket?
Comment on this
It is under 25. That level recovered in the years coming out of the recession, and by 2021 it had reached about 320,000. Since then, that is, over the past five years, it has basically remained at that level, which is around 100,000 to 120,000 below what it was before the recession. There is therefore a significant change in the levels of youth unemployment today relative to the last period when we saw full employment. To be clear, that was not because of significant population changes. There are more young people in the country than there were back then, so that indicates that there is some problem at the moment with youth employment levels.
Comment on this
Mr. Gilmore is saying there are more young people in the country now than there was then, so has the youth unemployment percentage risen as such?
Comment on this
No. The youth unemployment numbers are good. They have fallen quite dramatically since the recession and today they are a little over 10%. If you go back and look at 2006 and 2007, you see 8% or 9%, so it is a little higher than it was but not very dramatically so. Rather, what seems to be happening is that there are fewer young people engaging in the labour market at all, that is, they are neither in employment nor looking for work. They seem to be kind of discouraged from either looking for work or taking up employment.
Comment on this
I find that interesting. I would have assumed that if anything had changed since 2008 and the recession, it would have been education inflation. I would assume that more people are doing longer undergraduate courses and then subsequently going into postgraduate education, which might bring them up to 21, 22 or 23 before they actually even come out of formal education. That would be one side of it. On the other side, a huge number of young people, the second they finish their degree, want to go and explore the world so they might emigrate or go away to other parts of the world for various reasons. Does the report capture that information?
Comment on this
Yes, there is significant evidence of much higher youth emigration and of emigration generally if we compare today with before the recession. Back in 2007 or 2008, we were looking at around 13,000 Irish citizens emigrating every year. During the recession, that increased to around 50,000 Irish citizens emigrating in 2012. That figure has fallen since then but it is still at around 35,000. It is closer to the recession peak than to the levels of emigration that we would have seen before the recession. The vast majority of that is accounted for by younger people, those in their 20s and 30s.
Comment on this
I am conscious of time, with only 30 seconds remaining. What practical supports or actions do the witnesses believe this committee and the Government should take to improve the situation? What exactly needs to be improved?
Comment on this
It is difficult to answer that in 30 seconds. The key point is to be aware of the problem. There needs to be an awareness that there is something happening around youth employment that is of concern. Regarding specific policy proposals, I did a piece of analytical work but the NYCI itself is presenting proposals. Therefore, I would defer to Ms Walsh on specific policy questions.
Comment on this
We talk about a youth employment strategy because for so long we have been talking about youth unemployment. We have pathways to work under the Department of Social Protection and that is labour market activation but we need to look at employment. It is useful to look at what is happening in the UK, in terms of the Milburn review. They have done the first part of that, which was the diagnostic assessment. The second part of it has yet to come out. It was supposed to be published after the budget over there. Something like that needs to happen here, a cross-governmental approach that looks at this from a broader perspective. It needs to look at the transition pieces and where young people are. Are they spending longer in education? It needs to look at the precarity of it all. My colleague, Ms Harding, might want to respond too, having worked directly with young people.
Comment on this
Yes, there is a cohort of young people I am working with in the north-east inner city, aged between 16 and 25, for whom getting into university is a challenge. There is a whole other cohort of young people who are not even getting that far. If we invest in those young people, we can make a real change to their socio-economic communities and build up their social capital networks. Over the last ten years, in my role I have seen an increase in young people accessing college, which is amazing but while there have been improvements in terms of equal access, equity is still an issue for these young people. Investing in youth work is important for bridging gaps, and that would help greatly. It is important for young people to access youth services that are building up their transversal skills and supporting them to go to college.
Comment on this
As someone who comes from the hospitality sector, my experience with young people has been exceptionally positive. At times there was a sense of pessimism in the opening statement and I felt the NYCI did a bit of an injustice to the youth of today in terms of what they do and how they contribute in a positive way to society and the economy. From a work perspective, and in hospitality settings in particular, life experience, character building and social interaction are important for young people, as is expanding their own network. What have the witnesses done in recent times to encourage young people to go and find employment?
Comment on this
That is a fair question. In the youth work sector we are actually enhancing and supporting young people every day in terms of building up their capacity to develop their skills. A lot of the young people we work with, just like the Deputy said, could not have any more character and are so ambitious to work. Some have worked in the hospitality industry. It is about investing in those young people. I am from the Swan Youth Service in the north-east inner city so I cannot speak on behalf of the NYCI, but our youth service really invests in young people in terms of developing their skills and supporting them to overcome barriers or trauma that they are facing in their communities. My role, in particular, is to support young people to access education and primary training. For a lot of those young people we provide barista training, hospitality training, Safe Pass and manual handling training and the sort of training that will really open the door to employment for young people. More investment in that would help more young people to access employment.
Comment on this
From the perspective of the NYCI, we represent youth work organisations. We do not necessarily work with young people directly, although we do work with some young people through our local champions programme and some other programmes. In terms of advocating for young people to gain employment, we sit on the labour market advisory council, which advises on pathways to work. Some of our recommendations are around supporting youth services that engage with the most marginalised young people, who are often that cohort who do not engage-----
Comment on this
I appreciate the work with marginalised people but what about the mainstream? I refer to rural communities, for example. There is full employment at the moment, yet in its report and opening statement the NYCI claims that young people are poorly paid. It does not really add up, from an enterprise perspective, at a time of full employment, when employers are crying out for people to work, that young people are being poorly paid. In a sense, it is an employee's market so why would they not just move to another employer?
Comment on this
This is a point of contention that we may come to loggerheads on, but we would advocate for the abolition of sub-minimum rates of pay, as recommended by the Low Pay Commission, to make sure that young people are not stuck in low-paid employment. These young people are working in retail and hospitality. Not every employer is paying sub-minimum rates. Some are paying full rates but we want all young people to be able to access the full minimum wage. The minimum wage was brought in to protect people from poverty and it is there for a reason. We believe that it should be implemented. Young people in rural Ireland face costs to travel for education, for example. I mentioned in my opening statement Sai travelling from Galway every single day for work. We know that it is not cheap to have to do that amount of travelling. That is expensive. Young people have the same expenses as other age cohorts and they should not be discriminated against because of their age. Part of our advocacy role in terms of young people and employment would be representing those young people and arguing that they should get the full minimum wage.
Comment on this
From a work perspective, in terms of encouraging young people to work and convincing them of the importance of it, who would the witnesses see as being the responsible agency or entity?
Comment on this
I would go back again to the Milburn review. One of the striking things that comes out of it is that this is not just a labour market issue but a whole-system failure issue. The point it makes is that young people are not failing the system; the system is failing young people.
Comment on this
It could be anchored in the Department of enterprise but it has to involve the other Departments as well.
Comment on this
Let us leave the Departments to one side. We cannot give this to ten agencies or entities. What is the one agency or entity that Ms Walsh would recommend to advocate for and promote a campaign around youth work and encouraging people to work? Reference was made to an imbalance and the fact that while youth unemployment figures have reduced, employment figures have not increased. I would argue that there are more young people engaging in academic studies and deciding to do so on a full-time basis. The report paints a picture that suggests the youth are being neglected. There is not really a whole pile of neutrality coming through in relation to this. It is very much taking one side and is doing an injustice to young workers as a result. What one entity or agency would Ms Walsh suggest?
Comment on this
I will talk about the agency but first I want to go back to the injustice issue. We were just looking at the analysis-----
Comment on this
I would really ask Ms Walsh to reply. I have asked one question about the agency or entity to promote young people working and engaging in work today. Who should do that?
Comment on this
I do not think it should be a campaign. It should not just be a campaign-----
Comment on this
Do we not need to inform and educate young people about the importance of work and those points-----
Comment on this
Yes, but that is engaging with young people themselves. Having a campaign or an education campaign-----
Comment on this
How do we engage on a broad, mainstream level to emphasise the importance of life experience, character building, social inclusion and expanding one's network through youth work?
Comment on this
We invest in youth services. I would increase funding for the youth services that work and engage with young people directly. There are targeted youth employability service initiatives under the Department of education. Ms Harding may have better experience in terms of knowing what helps.
Comment on this
It is a question of joined-up thinking. In terms of our role, there is a partnership model there. We are based beside the IFSC.
We are really privileged to be beside a lot of the corporates. A lot of the businesses in the community have really stepped up in terms of supporting and recognising that there are young people who want to work and need that opportunity. It is definitely a joined-up partnership for them. The partnership model does not have to do with just one identity; it is a societal and a community thing. We have young people who may be in households where there has been generations in unemployment, for example, and they are looking to work. We have a lot of young people who then go to work but who is supporting them with the skills of being in work and sustaining that employment? The business partners are really supporting them to sustain that employment because if the young people are going home and there is unemployment, there might be people who are encouraging them not to work, which is not what we want.
Comment on this
Before we return to the start of the rota, I have not spoken so I will take the opportunity to do so. The National Youth Council's report which mentioned that about seven in ten young people wanted to leave Ireland and move abroad was done quite recently. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I want to tease out the affordable housing part of that. I am 29 and a lot of my friends, who are in well-remunerated jobs, and Deputy Clendennen as well, still cannot get access to a mortgage, especially in areas like Dublin or Cork where housing prices have dramatically increased. If they are paying rent, the only choice they have is to return to the home and for those in a relationship, in particular, it can be very demeaning for young people to have to live in the family home and give up the privilege of having a space for themselves. A lot of people consequently make the decision, for good, bad or indifferent reasons.
There are different perspectives on this and it is great we are getting balance. Deputy Clendennen has really brought his perspective on it. It is great to be having this debate. My point is that there is stress and it is worth noting that the decision a lot of young people take is they would rather pay rent in London or go off to Australia. Some permanently move and some spend a block of four to six years living abroad, with the intention of returning and starting a family in Ireland. We see a declining birth rate in Ireland. That has consequences economically in terms of a diminished dependency ratio. That should concern people if we take a ten- to 20-year view of it.
I want to give the witnesses an opportunity to comment on that. I raised the report in the Dáil at the time, as they may have seen, and it is my lived experience. If I want to go for pints with my mates, it involves jumping on a Ryanair flight at terminal 1 in Dublin Airport or the terminal in Cork Airport. That is the reality for me as a young person in Ireland. There are people here who are doing well for themselves in really good jobs but this goes back to the issue of affordable housing and getting access to it. These are people in good positions who are highly trained and skilled. They have gone through level 8 and level 9 degrees and then professional accreditation. I know a lot of people working in financial services because business and economics were my area when I was studying. It irks me a little that this does not always get airtime. Naturally, there are not many Members of the Oireachtas who are under 30. I wanted to touch on that and ask the witnesses to comment.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair. This is really interesting. I quoted some of the findings from our State of Our Young Nation report, published in 2024. I will furnish it to members after the meeting because it touches on the piece the Chair spoke about. It is the milestone piece and what young people have aspired to. Young people would like to be able to rent, afford a house, have a family and do all the things considered to be the traditional milestones. They have those aspirations but now their expectations of when they might reach them are being pushed further and further out. That is becoming the lived experience of so many young people.
The Cathaoirleach mentioned the polling showing that seven in ten young adults will consider moving away for a better quality of life where they can maybe achieve some of those milestones, where it is more affordable and where they can have a quality of life they do not see here. We do that Red C polling annually and we find the cost of living and housing are part of the structural challenge for young people. It has not changed; it has been consistent year on year. It is coming up in all research pieces, not just those done by the NYCI.
Ms Harding was making a really interesting point earlier about the young people she works with and the housing in that area.
Comment on this
There is a cohort I work with, for whom moving abroad would never be an option. At the moment, it is just about finding social housing within their community. It is a whole other level. A lot of our young people are living in overcrowded homes in the north-east inner city. Looking for social housing or affording a mortgage in their communities of Dublin 1 and Dublin 3 is definitely not something they see as achievable. There is that sense, which I felt even as the Cathaoirleach was speaking, of a kind of hopeless feeling as a young person in the community and in Ireland. A lot of young people have access and opportunities to move abroad and have that life, but there is a cohort who do not have those opportunities to move abroad. It is also something we need to look at.
Comment on this
I very much agree with what the Cathaoirleach said. Deputy Clendennen said this was a bit unbalanced. I take exception to that because the report really foregrounded a lot of good stories. Unemployment has come down, as has youth unemployment. The number of young people not in education, employment or training has come down. Youth poverty has come down and deprivation among young people has too.
I really foreground those issues but despite those positive stories, there are very significant challenges. These include precisely what the Cathaoirleach spoke about, namely, young people struggling to establish an economically independent life in Ireland. They are struggling to find employment and housing and with being able to match the two in order that they can develop economic independence, move out of their parents' home and be an independent person in their early to late 20s. People are responding to this by, on the one hand, living with their parents at a much higher rate. That has increased quite significantly. Today, about 40% of working young people are living with their parents. This contrasts very dramatically with other northern European countries like those in Scandinavia where the comparable numbers are 2% or 3%, which is extremely different. Young people also respond by choosing to emigrate. My report is based on Eurofound data showing that 61% of Irish young people were either planning to or wanted to emigrate within three years. Those findings are paralleled by the finding of the Red C poll conducted by the National Youth Council which found about 68% of young people are planning on emigrating.
There are very positive stories but we also have to recognise where there is a problem and where there are challenges. That is precisely what the Cathaoirleach was highlighting, namely, the struggle of young people to find employment that will cover their rent and enable them to establish an economically independent life.
Comment on this
I know. I think of that great phrase from our neighbours in America who found sense this morning in the elections, namely, the pursuit of happiness. It is important. Every member here has a different view on issues and we are from both the Government and Opposition sides, but I welcome the work the witnesses have done and I am glad they have all had a chance to comment on that matter.
Deputy Brennan has not spoken yet. We have not finished the first round so I will let him in and then we will go back to Deputies Conway-Walsh and Gogarty.
Comment on this
Is that okay with Deputy Conway-Walsh? Does she have to go somewhere?
Comment on this
Go on. I would not disobey the Chair.
Comment on this
I apologise but there is a lot going on today.
On youth unemployment, we are looking at a figure of 143,000, or 11.5%. I want us to try to get our heads around the main reasons this is happening. The witnesses might have touched on it already but could they give us a pointer on it?
Comment on this
As I was saying, the youth unemployment numbers are not particularly bad. They are not quite at the level that existed pre recession but they are still a little bit north of 10% and they have been stable there for a number of years. They are not very concerning. What is more concerning is, on the one hand, the people who are particularly affected by youth unemployment, but also what I tried to highlight in the report, which is the low levels of youth employment and the fact that the number of people taking up employment and entering employment is still well below what it was before the recession. There has not been a recovery. For those aged over 25, the number in employment has increased by over 900,000; close to a million. For people under 25, we still are not at the numbers we saw pre recession. That is quite a significant problem. Much of the reason this is happening is connected to what the Chair was pointing to. People are struggling to find employment that covers the rent. As a result, they are staying at home at much higher levels. As Ms Walsh pointed to, a lot of young people are having an experience of going to university and engaging in long commutes rather than moving to where the university is and taking up employment while they are engaged in education. That is part of what explains this shift.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Gilmore believe that will get worse rather than better with AI coming in and taking so many jobs out of the system?
Comment on this
Potentially. It is hard to predict the future. As I said earlier, when I was commissioned to conduct this research, one of the things I wanted to look at was the impact of AI on youth employment and youth hiring. Basically, I was not able to find much of an effect. Although there is a lot of anecdotal things coming out of employers' groups and so on saying that there has been a decline in youth hiring, in the raw data there does not seem to be a significant shift in youth hiring or youth employment or unemployment over the last four to five years, which is when the impact would be expected.
Comment on this
To try to analyse the figures, are young people going abroad because they want to or because they have to?
Comment on this
People will ask whether you have an optimistic or pessimistic perspective on things. People are moving abroad because they think they can have a better life abroad; that is one positive way to put it. The other way of putting it is that people are moving abroad because they think their life in Ireland cannot be as good as it would be abroad. It is the same story told in two different ways. However, there is no real way of telling this story without saying that young people are feeling they are struggling to establish an economically independent life in Ireland. They are struggling to find accommodation, to find jobs that will pay for that accommodation, and they are making choices corresponding to those challenges.
Comment on this
I am of the opinion that they are going to Australia and New Zealand to enjoy it and to live a couple of years over there. Exactly as Mr. Gilmore is saying, however, the problem is when they want to come back. How can they afford to come back? They go out for a lifestyle, for fun and enjoyment, and obviously working as well, but it is frightening then when they ask themselves how they are going to buy a house, live back in Ireland and have the standard of living they have had on their dream couple of years away. How we can challenge and support that is a key factor at the moment. Would Mr. Gilmore agree with that?
Comment on this
One factor we are short on in terms of employment is the training. Does Mr. Gilmore believe there is adequate training for young people?
Comment on this
We have quite a good education system, broadly speaking. Looking at it from an economist's perspective, our education outcomes, PISA scores or third level completion rates show we are really top of the table in these sorts of things. It is a very positive story. This is remarkable because looking at our expenditure on education we are not top of the table. We are doing very well without paying the same amount as is paid for it in other countries. That is from an economist's perspective. For the experience on the ground I would defer to the other groups.
Comment on this
I agree that we have a lot of opportunities for young people in Ireland. Sometimes it can be a minefield for the young people when they come into the youth service and they are looking for a particular training as there is so much out there, which is amazing. The big trendy topic at the moment is the apprenticeships. They are fantastic. There is a wide range of apprenticeships now available. It is that earn-and-learn approach that is very attractive for the young people. There are barriers to going to college for some of the young people who are living in, say, north inner city Dublin. A job is definitely needed to get to college or its lack might be a barrier but with their apprenticeship they are learning a salary while they are training. It is really a win-win. A lot of our young people are opting for the apprenticeship route. On the training, there is a very clear pathway for young people within education, particularly for those I work with who are early school-leavers. They have the alternative option of going back to complete their level three and four and there is a good transition then to go on to an FET college or third level.
Comment on this
I will interject and thank the witnesses. We have five minutes left per speaker before our time expires in the room because the next committee must come in. We will now go to Deputy Conway-Walsh.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their presentations and for this report. It is really important. A couple of things stand out for me as regards the reference to the ESRI study that found that previously around 15% of workers around 20 and under were paid sub-minimum wage rates and that increased to 30% in the first half of 2025. I look at that in context. The concern is the sub-minimum rates and how they are increasing so much. Is that being space being used to exploit youngsters? Some might say it gives them an opportunity; others might say it exploits them. We are in a situation where we have around 40% of young people aged 25 to 34 living in their parental home. This contrasts sharply with other advanced European economies such as Sweden and Finland where it is only around 2%. That is stark. While we have a lot of people working in that space, they cannot afford to leave home. Would Ms Walsh say this is a big factor in breaking the social contract with young people, in that they can work harder but they still cannot afford somewhere to live on their own?
Comment on this
Yes. We have to go back to why, as I said earlier, the minimum wage Act was put in place. It was to protect people from poverty and to give people a standard of living. There is also the conversation about moving to a living wage. If we consider that young people, purely because of their age, are getting paid less, and you add to that housing insecurity, the cost of living and the lack of hope of being able to build an independent life here in Ireland, you would say the social contract is broken if that is taken away from this generation of young people. I note that before this session the committee had the Minister of State, Deputy Dillon, in and there was a whole conversation about the statutory instrument dealing with later evening work for young people. Potentially there will be moves for more young people to be in those sub-minimum rate positions more and more.
Comment on this
The next thing I want to ask is about the engagement with the Minister of State, Deputy Dillon, specifically around that. I was questioning him about that and the exploitation that could happen there. What consultation did Ms Walsh have with him? Did she express those concerns? How many of those concerns were reflected in the legislation in terms of the risk assessment?
Comment on this
We have been engaging with ICTU and Paul Gavan in particular. Our concerns on that were brought though ICTU. Its youth committee is a member of the National Youth Council of Ireland so we engaged through that process. I would have to double-check what correspondence we had with the Minister but we share the concerns of ICTU and the correspondence that went to the Minister around the financial incentive for employers to allocate that late evening work and the potentials there. We know that legislation is foremost supposed to be protective legislation.
We did not feel that the proposed changes adequately addressed, for example, the potential health and safety issues within our working hours. Given that the research with the ESRI shows that sub-minimum rates are on the increase, we would be concerned about what the effect would be and we would share the asks from ICTU to commit to the early post-implementation review to assess all those factors.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister of State several times about whether the reduction in VAT by €800 million due to the 9% VAT rate had any positive impact on young workers in the hospitality sector. Has Ms Walsh looked at any of that? Has any of that been passed to young workers in the hospitality sector?
Comment on this
It would be very interesting to do that because a lot of young people work in that sector. When we are looking at the youth guarantee, I see the conclusions that have been made in the report but it is also limited to the ambition and visibility of the guarantee and of leaving nobody behind. We are at a critical moment. There is the whole umbrella point of there being full employment so why is everybody not out working. We need to lift the bonnet on that to see if there are situations where young people cannot afford to work because they cannot live near the work they want or they cannot get the transportation. Five minutes is way too short to discuss this. The youth unemployment and youth guarantee report is excellent.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their contribution and the report which I looked through. Basically, what they are saying is that a smaller number of under-25s are in the labour market compared with before the recession. Would the witnesses acknowledge that some of that is obviously due to more people staying in education? I presume that is a fair comment.
I am trying to come at this from a couple of angles; one is the solution and what we need to do, but I just want to be a devil's advocate for a while as well. The issues mentioned in terms of why young people are not getting involved are unsocial hours, commuting costs, weekend shifts and relatively low pay - something we have all faced in society. Back in 1970, one bus driver's salary could get a mortgage, so it is impacting on a whole lot of families. We have seen that in Northern Ireland around the time of the recession - I had a friend who worked and lived there for many years - all the forecourts were populated by Northern Irish people. His take on it was that social welfare was £50 a week there whereas ours was €200 at the time; the cost of living was lower and therefore jobs in supermarkets and forecourt shops were more attractive to people in Northern Ireland. Around that time in the noughties we had a lot of eastern Europeans working in garages and forecourts. Now we have a lot of students coming into Ireland who are working in the retail and hospitality sector. There are two items and I would like the witnesses to respond to both of them. Are these people higher skilled and taking jobs that young people would otherwise have done or are young people turning up their noses at it? The anecdotal evidence is that when young people leave to go to other countries, if they have qualifications as nurses or teachers, for example, they get a well paid job in Australia or Dubai, but if they are low skilled they end up doing over there what immigrants do over here: they work their backsides off and they work unsociable hours to try to get an opportunity and they better themselves.
I met a lady who is a lone parent with two kids, living in the midlands. Her car broke down and she was still trying to get buses to work in my constituency in the healthcare service. She was really struggling but she did it every day because she had mouths to feed. Being devil's advocate, for a young person who does not have mouths to feed, who just has themselves to feed and educate, is there not a case of, "We have had it too good"? We have a familial protective network, even if we gripe about living at home with the parents, whereas if we end up going abroad we end up being the immigrants and working hard and bettering ourselves through the system. That is one question.
The other issue is, in terms of getting people into jobs, do the witnesses think we need more from the apprenticeship side of things? For example, there is a shortage of mechanics in this country. A mechanic can earn €70,000 to €80,000. There is a shortage of electricians in this country. There is huge potential working in sustainable energy areas in terms of retrofitting. There are jobs out there that are required. We can even take the example of buses. We are currently trying to get a lot of South African bus drivers to come here, as they drive on the same side of the road, because buses are not turning up as we do not have enough people to drive them. Even getting a job as a bus driver pays a reasonable wage. It might not pay the top wage because of housing costs, etc., but it is a good step up to get that experience. Other evidence I have seen from, let us say, the Scandinavian countries the witnesses referenced, is that there is more of a culture of part-time work in those countries from an early age in any event. In Ireland maybe we are not encouraging enough of it. As was referenced, the Minister of State was here earlier, talking about changing the hours up to 11 p.m. because there is a demand for young people. The question is whether it is the chicken or the egg. Do we need to try to encourage a culture of enterprise and work among young people so they get the skills and confidence, or is there a barrier stopping them from doing the work, which is admittedly hard? I would argue that the societal issues are a separate debate entirely.
Comment on this
I can definitely come back. There is a lot in that as well. Even just from hearing Deputy Gogarty speak, there is a lot involved. From the practical experience of working with young people over the past ten to 15 years in the youth work sector, I have never heard a young person stick their nose up at a job. In particular, among those I work with there is, rather, a desperation. When a young person comes to me looking for support with a CV or maybe to apply for work, they are nearly like, "I'll work. I'll do anything." It is nearly me advocating for them, asking where their skills are at and what would they like to do. I get a lot of young women. Naturally they go for cleaning and the lower-paid jobs when I know they have the skills to do other roles. In terms of that comment, thankfully I have had the privilege of working with young people who would never stick their nose up at a job. What I see on the ground is that there is a struggle for young people who are applying for 50 to 100 jobs a week. We have drop-in employment support for young people who come in and we support them to be on Indeed or anywhere there are jobs. We support them to apply because there is a skill set in even applying for jobs online at the moment, which we are supporting young people to develop. The real struggle for young people is not hearing back at all - not getting any response. That depletes their confidence in that as well. I will make just one more point.
Comment on this
I might be able to come back to this later as there are only two of us here.
Comment on this
I was looking forward to getting in twice.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here. Listening to Ms Harding I hear her passion and I love what she does. It is a fine youth service. I work in communities that are marginalised. I set up an organisation many years ago called Tiglin. We have a youth homelessness centre in Naas. The survey talks about postcode discrimination. Young people in the survey say they leave their addresses off their CV. I have seen that for 20 years. I remember when I was interviewed on radio and the interviewer asked me about the postcode lottery – it depends on where you are born. What is the solution there? What should we do there? Would anonymised CVs work, from the public bodies downwards? What are Ms Harding's thoughts on that?
Comment on this
I am really interested in the day-to-day struggles of the cohort I work with, who face multiple barriers and discrimination. It is like Senator McCarthy said about the name. If you put Sheriff Street on your CV that would give rise to discrimination. A lot of the time we put Dublin 1 on it. It is beginning to teach us about what information we give the employer before we get the role.
I would also argue that I am empowering young people to own who they are as well. As a result of the partnerships we have built up with a lot of the businesses, we have access opportunities for young people to get work placements. The majority of the time the young people prove themselves and they get employed that way so they are not going through the traditional route to employment. A lot of the time there is an algorithm now that is picking up CVs, which is a barrier for young people as well because we do not have the right key word on the CV. We are supporting young people to be strategic about that as well. It is really sad that today a lot of young people are profiled due to where they live, how they dress, and what surname they have as well as what secondary school they went to.
Comment on this
I had a guy in last week who comes from an extended family that I did not know. We were chatting away and he gave me his name. It was all good and then he came up to me afterwards and said his real name. He did not want to give the family name because he thought it would impact him on our side.
Comment on this
We have supported young people to change their surname due to this reason as well. Five to ten young people who did work placements in some of the big corporate companies were offered roles but then their surnames were flagged and we acted as an advocate to negotiate for them and to provide character references.
Comment on this
In the area of mental health and addiction, the likes of Mr. Price have an initiative. Do they work well with youth services?
Comment on this
They are brilliant, Mr. Price particularly. I do not work with it directly but it really supported a lot of our young people who have more neurodiverse issues. It has a really amazing scheme of inclusive employment as well. We work with a lot of corporate firms, such as A and L Goodbody, Beauchamps and the Central Bank of Ireland. A lot of the main corporates down there are phenomenal in terms of supporting our young people with work placement or employment opportunities.
Comment on this
Ms Harding also mentioned the alternative economy and about how young people are drawn into the drug trade, for example. In Greystones, we have the Garda diversion project with Crosscare. We have the youth cafe and it is kicking the ball out of the park. Social enterprises do not get support in order to accommodate younger people from a Garda diversion type of idea. Is that something we could look at and use as a stepping stone for this work?
Comment on this
I suppose it could. We have a large youth diversity programme within Swan in which we support young people in terms of diverting them from the drug trade. I had a conversation earlier about how the bleak reality, particularly in my role, is that I am actually in competition against the drug trade. A lot of the time, I am supporting young people to get employment but then when they weigh it up, they realise they are actually only getting a certain amount. It can be very challenging when that drug trade of trafficking young people into drugs is very attractive. It is nearly drug intimidation where they are actually-----
Comment on this
That is my next question. Is Ms Harding seeing much of that?
Comment on this
Oh my God, unfortunately, yes. It is not that the young people definitely want to do the drug trade but when they are not receiving emails back from an employer, when they are repeatedly applying and not hearing back, that is sometimes their only avenue for employment, which is really sad to say out loud.
Comment on this
I had one person in here last week who had applied for 83 jobs and heard absolutely nothing back. This was a young person who felt that AI was disqualifying them before they even started. Should there be a code of practice when people apply for a job whereby there should be feedback? I am not too sure who would run it. However, is there something there for young people? A lot of it is insecurity. It is a hit to young people's self-worth, whereas if they got feedback, they would feel valued even if they did not get the job.
Comment on this
The reality for a lot of young people is applying for 80-plus jobs and not hearing back. If there are incentives put in place with businesses to hire young local people in their communities, that would really overcome that barrier for the young people. That has been recognised. They live in the community. They are under 25. They have a lot of skills to be developed. A lot of young people work in retail and develop a lot of skills that are transferable in their careers for whatever they want to do.
Comment on this
That brings a conclusion to today's public session. I thank all our witnesses most sincerely. It was most informative. It has given me a real lift, actually, just hearing that input. We have heard a good, varied range of opinions today too and that is also a healthy thing. With that, I thank Mr. Gilmore, Ms Walsh and Ms Harding for being here. We are very appreciative of their time and input. We will now conclude the public session of the meeting and reconvene in private session at our usual time of 2.15 p.m. on Tuesday, 10 November. Until then, go raibh míle maith agaibh go léir.