Engagement with European Commissioner for Equality, Preparedness and Crisis Management
Commissioner Hadja Lahbib urged the EU to maintain a strong, predictable humanitarian budget, protect aid workers and improve aid delivery through local partnerships and humanitarian diplomacy. She outlined the EU preparedness strategy, including minimum readiness guidance, risk assessment and a whole-of-society approach to crises, climate hazards and disinformation. She said the EU could not replace the US funding withdrawn from aid, and stressed that humanitarian access—not funding—was the main obstacle in Gaza. Lahbib acknowledged that the EU remained divided and had not used its available leverage, though she said views among member states were shifting.
The purpose of our session today is to meet Commissioner Hadja Lahbib, European Commissioner for Equality, Preparedness and Crisis Management to discuss EU preparedness, civil protection, humanitarian policy and fundamental rights in particular equality issues. These topics have been of interest to the committee in recent months. We had hearings earlier this year in May and September on EU development policy. Today's meeting gives us an opportunity to consider these issues through the lens of the EU preparedness union strategy and the EU's overall international co-operation in areas such as civil protection, disaster, risk management and humanitarian diplomacy. The Commissioner holds further responsibilities in the area of quality. Today, we have an opportunity to consider the Commission's initiatives and strategies in this area including on gender quality, LGBTQ+ and the equality and rights of persons with disabilities.
Ahead of this engagement, I am pleased to welcome Commissioner Lahbib and representatives of the European Commission: Ms Lora Borissova, senior cabinet expert, Ms Nabila Massrali, communications advisor; Mr. Arnaud Dupont, head of unit; and Ms Patricia Purcell, a representative of the Commission in Ireland. They are all welcome to the committee. I thank them for their time.
Before we begin, I will outline a note on privilege. Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is important that they comply with any such direction. I am quite sure that will not be an issue today but I have to read it out anyway.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. We do not have anybody joining us online.
The Commissioner will have five minutes to make her opening statement to the committee. We will then bring members in to ask questions.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and members of the committee for the invitation. It is a pleasure to be with the committee during Ireland’s Presidency at a very critical moment for Europe and for the security of our citizens.
Earlier this year I was in Goma, in eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo. I met families who had fled with nothing but the clothes on their backs. Their story is part of a much bigger picture. Around 130 conflicts are active today, more than double 15 years ago. Nearly 240 million people need humanitarian aid this year. If they were a country, it would be one of the largest in the world. Conflict drives about 70% of these needs. Increasingly, aid itself is being used as a weapon of war. Roads are blocked, convoys are stopped and food and medicine are kept from the people who need them.
The system is under pressure. International humanitarian law is treated like a buffet à la carte - take what you like, leave the rest. Funding cuts make everything harder but Europe is standing firm. Together, as Team Europe, we remain one of the world’s largest humanitarian donors, reliable, predictable and principled. Our focus is clear: protect aid workers and humanitarian access, make aid work better and bring more partners on board including the private sector.
Today, I will focus on three points: humanitarian diplomacy, the next EU budget and how we prepare Europe for a more dangerous world. I have seen what humanitarian diplomacy can achieve in Africa, Ukraine, the Middle East and Latin America. In the darkest corners of the world, it can still open a road, lift a checkpoint and get food and medicine to people who have lost everything. In the Great Lakes region, I sat down with presidents, ministers and AFC-M23. When lives are at stake, we must speak to those who hold the keys. My message was the same everywhere: respect international humanitarian law, protect civilians, protect aid workers, let aid through and that diplomacy delivered results. With today’s tight budgets, we are also making every euro go further. We are cutting duplication in humanitarian supply chains. Every euro saved on logistics is a euro spent on bread or medicine for a child.
We must also stay engaged in fragile countries. Fragility spills across borders. We feel its consequences through hunger, disease, conflict, displacement and radicalisation. That is why humanitarian, development and peace efforts must go hand in hand with international financial institutions, the private sector and our member states. We must keep aid workers safe. The law protects them yet they are arrested, kidnapped and deliberately targeted. Last year was the deadliest on record with more than 300 killed. Next week, with the Minister of State, Deputy Richmond, I will co-chair a conference on protecting aid workers. We will look at what works and where we must do more.
To deliver all of this, we need the means. The next EU budget will determine how Europe engages with the world. Under the Commission's proposal, global Europe includes €25 billion for humanitarian aid. We must keep this ambition. The Irish Presidency has a crucial role in these negotiations. A strong and predictable humanitarian budget is vital. Humanitarian aid is a moral responsibility but it is also an investment in our own security and stability. It can stop crises from spreading, reduce forced displacement and help contain epidemics. I saw this in June in Bunia at the epicentre of the Ebola outbreak. Local health workers knew how to fight the virus but the tools came too late. Testing was too slow and so was work on vaccines. This is the price of years of underinvestment in public health. If we do not act, the next outbreak could be another disease in another place. The cost is modest at just over 1% of the EU budget, less than 50 cent per citizen per month. Over a whole year, it is the price of a cup of coffee.
Conflict, climate change and disease drive humanitarian needs abroad but Europe is increasingly exposed too with wildfires, floods, cyberattacks, hybrid threats and disinformation. Europe is warming twice as fast as the global average. This was the hottest summer ever recorded in western Europe. Almost 700,000 ha burned in the EU this year. Imagine one tenth of Ireland reduced to ashes. In France, wildfires triggered the largest evacuation since the Second World War. The threats are changing. Drones are appearing in our skies. This summer, a drone carrying explosives was found at Leipzig airport. Who knows what AI will bring. We can no longer wait for a crisis to hit before we prepare. That is why last year we launched our EU preparedness strategy. The idea is simple: prepare before the alarm sounds. Get the whole of society involved and act faster. We call it preparedness by design. Before we spend a euro or design a policy, we ask two simple questions. Does this make Europe stronger? Will it still work under pressure? We have adopted strategies on stockpiling, medical countermeasures and water resilience. We have a democracy shield against disinformation and we are expanding our rescEU medical reserves.
Later this year, we will publish a comprehensive risk and threat assessment. For the first time, security threats, natural hazards, technological risks and health threats will be on one map. Our member states face different threats so they prepare differently but every European should be able to count on a basic level of readiness. That is why we are proposing EU minimum preparedness requirements to support member states, which remain the first responders in any crisis. Later this year, we will give people practical guidance on how to cope for at least 72 hours in an emergency. Ireland is already leading by example with its "Be Emergency Ready" booklet.
European leadership is a choice. It is the choice to stand by families like those I met in Goma and to make sure our families are protected when crisis strikes. Ireland’s Presidency will play a vital role in both defending a strong humanitarian budget and helping to build a Europe ready for any crisis.
That will make Europe and Ireland safer.
Comment on this
I thank Commissioner. A lot of those sentiments will be very well received by the members of this committee. Each member will have five minutes for questions and answers. That said, I will be reasonable so if something important needs to be finished, I will allow for that.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach who is always flexible and reasonable. I also thank the Commissioner and her team for coming here. In fairness, I do not know where to start with what she dealt with in her opening remarks. She has given a fair synopsis of the issues that exist in the world today. We have conflict and while the world was never a perfect place, there were some sureties that no longer exist. The biggest one is the American regime. The European Union is still a bastion of hope, with serious potential but also with a huge level of failure. We have seen an abject failure to call out the genocidal situation in Palestine. The Israelis have not been called to account. The American regime is giving Israel its absolute backing but it is a major failing. Huge solidarity has been shown in the context of Ukraine and Belarus. I recently attended a conference in Brussels on the defence of democracy and it is one of those things where there has been an absolute falling down. We are in an absolutely chaotic world.
I imagine that Ms Lahbib has experienced an awful lot of push-back in relation to looking for what is needed, which is a decent humanitarian budget, particularly in a world where USAID has been absolutely destroyed. There was a huge reliance on those moneys all around the world and that puts us in a far more critical place. It can be difficult to sell the idea to regular people who can, at times, go down rabbit holes online. They can get very worked up about some issues related to migration and so on, which can make matters worse. It is about trying to drive that home. While we know we have a wide range of state actors, anybody involved in politics realises that there is a huge amount of craziness, hate, misinformation and disinformation out there, facilitated by the tech oligarchs so they can make money because it keeps people online. We are also aware - and I saw it myself last week - of the possibility of a sectarian march down the Garvaghy Road. A number of Sinn Féin representatives were involved in standing in solidarity. What I noticed, even though I barely posted anything online, was that suddenly a pile of anti-migration, anti-Sinn Féin material came back at me. While I know some of these people and would not be particularly worried about their views one way or another, other people started telling me that profiles that had not posted in about two or three years suddenly came in play. What we have is huge numbers of bot farms that are being operated across Europe against many political groupings. That poses a danger to democracy.
My first question is about the humanitarian budget and the push-back. I am also interested to hear how we actually deliver the change that is necessary, given the huge number of issues that exist.
Comment on this
The picture is quite bleak. I share the Deputy's view and that is why this moment is both historical and critical. We are still this lighthouse of hope, I can assure him. The European Union is standing firm on its principles. Despite the withdrawing of the United States and the disappearance of USAID, we are still there and active, defending principled humanitarian aid that is based on need, with all of the independence and neutrality that is requested. That is why we are working hand in hand with UN80 and Humanitarian Reset to implement a more efficient manner of delivering humanitarian aid to those in need. Through the UN General Assembly, we have organised several meetings on respect for international humanitarian law because under the new norm, or the breach that we see as the new norm, aid workers are attacked and humanitarian aid is used as a weapon of war, mainly in terms of accessibility. The Deputy just evoked the case in Gaza where clearly it is not a funding crisis. We have the means that we need but we do not have access. We need respect for international humanitarian law and normally that would not be a question around the table. We might be against, in favour, or more sensitive to one camp or another but no matter, we all agree that international humanitarian law must be respected. This is my plea. This is something that I have been constantly repeating for nearly two years.
When I started as Commissioner for crisis management, which also involves humanitarian aid, I was reluctant to link humanitarian aid to migration but today I have done so because it is a question of security. If half of the European Union does not want to hear about the moral duty and the necessity to help those in need, then we have to be aware that we are going to create destabilisation and migration that will hit us at a certain point. That is why we need to stay involved and to do so in a more efficient manner. It means being involved from the very early stages of a crisis. We must first anticipate crises, which can be provoked by climate change in the Sahel region, for instance, but also by military groups and so on, and try to stop them before they happen. We must also try to enable people to recover at the very early stage and be able to stand on their own two feet and not be dependent on humanitarian aid for too long, which is too often the case. We are left alone, as humanitarian actors. Principles are being called into question because humanitarian workers are being accused of being part of one or the other side of the battlefield and this is a problem. That is why we presented humanitarian communication and why we want to work hand in hand with co-operation and development in fragile contexts - 18 countries considered by the OECD to be extremely fragile. It includes Afghanistan, where we are still involved despite the fact that we do not recognise the Taliban Government. Of course, we do not have diplomatic ties with Afghanistan but we are still helping women and children over there. We are also working in Syria, where we are helping them to recover but we need to go further than humanitarian aid. People do not need to just survive day after day; they need to have a future and that is how we will help them to go back to their countries. I was in Turkey and Jordan where there are still camps with thousands of Syrian refugees who are just waiting to go back but for that to happen, they need schools, hospitals and basic services that are not available right now in Syria. That is why we need to work in a more sustainable manner. I hope that I have answered the Deputy's questions.
Comment on this
I thank the Commissioner and her team for joining us here today. I found her presentation very interesting. Her brief in terms of equality, preparedness and crisis management, is quite extensive. Regarding aid, as we are progressing the MFF negotiations, how does the Commissioner think we ensure Europe does what it can to bridge the gap when we are seeing a massive decrease in overseas aid from the US and when we are dealing with Africa? The Commissioner mentioned a lot of trips she has been on there. How do we improve the relationship with and the perception of the EU in these countries, which are often being courted by other actors such as Russia or China? Some of these countries would have in the past viewed Europe as overseeing them rather than them being an equal partner. How do we work on that relationship so that we are working with these countries rather than telling them what to do and that we are bringing them with us and talking with them rather than talking at them? The only way we can move that relationship forward and improve things is if we do it united and there is no power imbalance between the EU and these much poorer countries.
Undoubtedly climate and climate resilience is one of the biggest challenges we are facing at the moment internationally. The Commissioner mentioned the forest fires specifically. This is something we saw massively increased levels of this summer. All around Europe and also here in Ireland we had severe forest fires. However, how do we introduce measures and policies to prevent that, because of all the impacts it will have going forward on land, food security and agriculture, at a pan-European level? How do we maintain the balance between national powers and European powers and the European Commission? If we are to deal with those more physical effects, it is a massive cost burden. We know what the solution is, but funding it is not as easy. How do we get that balance between national and EU powers when we are looking at those sort of issues? The Commissioner's comments related to climate more generally but I refer to the forest fires in particular as she mentioned them in her speech. In the state of the Union address a few weeks ago President von der Leyen also commented on that.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for her comprehensive-----
Comment on this
-----question which reflects the broadness of my portfolio. This is a good thing because it allows me to have an equality dimension in everything that I am tackling. This is a good lesson learnt from this portfolio. I remember at the beginning of my mandate it was criticised. I was chosen as Commissioner for equality and, at the same time, preparedness and crisis management, which was the first time we had this portfolio. However, it is a good thing because I have a seat at the table in any case.
In answer to the Senator's question, with the withdrawal of the US, the EU cannot fill the gap. We are not pretending to fill the gap; we do not have the capacity. Frankly, the €25 billion that we are requesting for humanitarian aid in the next budget is less than what was for the previous mandate. I think we were around €27 billion in the last seven years. Why did we ask for €25 billion? It is because we want to be part of Global Europe funding. It means to have the capacity to upgrade and to work hand in hand with DG MENA in the Mediterranean, also international partnerships and all the external action. It should also be considered in the context of our strategy to be more cost-efficient. If humanitarian aid is left alone, as I just mentioned, we will just be able to respond to the basic needs; just saving lives. Once the life is saved, however, we need to recover. We need to help the people stand on their own two feet and to have a livelihood. Nobody is happy to depend on humanitarian aid. Today, we have 240 million people depending on humanitarian aid, mainly because of the wars. Some 70% of this need is provoked by wars. We should not keep a system that is creating dependency. That is why we have a strategy which is working first on humanitarian diplomacy to have access and to reduce the costs. We want to have more localisation. This means working with local actors to involve them. As the Senator rightly says, we should not talk about them but talk with them. This is an important principle. We want to reach 25% of localisation through our stakeholders. We oblige all our humanitarian NGOs to work with local actors to involve them and create a circular economy. It will also reduce the cost of logistics. As I mentioned in my speech, the transport and logistics represent 60% to 80% of the costs. If you work on the local economy, you create livelihoods - jobs - but also you save money on the transport.
On climate change, that is why I am preaching for preparedness by design. It must be involved in changing mindsets in the next budget. We want to have access to different funds, not only UCPM funds, which is basically for emergency response, but also cohesion funds, ESF+ funds and other funds to allow countries to prepare before the crisis hits. We have the strategies on paper that involve the agricultural sector, wastewater resilience and everything we need for a European preparedness strategy, which is involving all the sectors. That is why member states now need to have access to all funds to invest in preparedness. I am sorry if I am confused. We need to walk the talk. We do not pretend to replace national competence. It is always member states who are the first responders. We do not pretend to respond in their place. The UCPM, for instance, is activated only under the request of member states. We are working on minimum preparedness requirements but it will be a recommendation. Then, it is up to the member states to create a leaflet, like Ireland did. We cannot impose it because it is a national competence.
Comment on this
The Commissioner has a hugely important brief in relation to preparedness and crisis management. On the issue of Palestine, I have been surprised by how impotent the national community has been and particularly the paralysis in terms of the European response to it. Money and funding is a huge part of preparedness, but regardless of what funding there is, the reluctance of predominant influences in Europe to face down what Israel is doing and to end the preferential trade agreement has allowed it to continue. I know the Commissioner cannot directly do anything about that but, as a European commissioner, she has a strong voice there. In some ways, we are dealing with a back-end solution instead of a front-loaded one. It is not just the slaughter of the civilians and the total endless destruction of homes, infrastructure and the whole social fabric of Gaza and the damage in the West Bank, but also the fact that Israel has been able to do what it has done with the slaughter of media people and aid workers.
To be honest, I did not think, in my innocence, that I would ever see that again in my lifetime. I cannot believe that this had happened. What I wanted to say to Ms Lahbib was that, with respect to preparedness, the UN has been rendered relatively impotent in, first, its response to a crisis and, second, looking at what has happened to UN workers in Gaza, and what we have done about it. I will not say Israeli bulldozers have driven over the UN resolutions, but Israeli tanks and bulldozers have driven over them. The UN resolutions are just irrelevant.
Ms Lahbib might deal with Europe's efforts to reassert the primacy of the United Nations and multilateralism because, however imperfect that may be, that is what has kept the world stable most of the time since the Second World War. We need to get back to that and establish the primacy of the UN, that UN resolutions mean something and that the authority of the UN has to be reasserted. While Europe on its own is big, with a population of 360 million, in the greater scheme of things, there are another seven and a half billion people on the planet. While we may not like some of the other countries outside the EU, they have tried to put an emphasis on re-establishing the primacy and the authority of the United Nations. That is one thing I wanted to ask.
The second thing is a comment on climate change. Ms Lahbib's opening statement set out clearly 700,000 ha burned in Europe this summer. It is warming up at twice the pace of the rest of the globe, and we have responsibilities in that, with our contribution to having made it happen. Ms Lahbib mentioned the Irish booklet on the response, but something similar needs to happen to get it across to people that this will not be solved in this room or in parliaments or even in the European Parliament. It is part of the solution, but we are not getting the buy-in from citizens that we need across Europe, from the 360 million. I know that some governments and some countries have a good record. A few are in denial. Part of our preparedness has to be getting stronger buy-in from the 360 million citizens of Europe, to redouble and triple our efforts in reducing carbon emissions on the Continent, because if we are just putting out the fires, we have to stop the flammables being poured onto the fires. That is what happens in Europe every minute of every day. We have to get stronger buy-in, not just from governments but from the citizens of Europe, of Ireland, of Germany, of Italy, of everywhere.
Comment on this
The Deputy's question was how to involve the citizens. On Palestine, as the Deputy knows, I was minister of foreign affairs, sitting with the Taoiseach, when 7 October happened, and I can assure him that I saw so many irrational reactions to this topic. It was the first time that I saw ministers so divided and so emotional, and it is still the case, unfortunately. I try hard to gather the different opinions and to go above the political positions we might have across Europe to preach for humanitarian access, to save innocent children and women and innocent Palestinians who did not choose to be born there. Unfortunately, it is still difficult.
We all agree that humanitarian aid must be delivered without impediment, without administrative burden, without accusations of dual use and so on, and it is successful, because I have the figures here that I can share with the committee. Since 2023, over €768 million has been distributed, so the Commission remains among the largest humanitarian donors. We have organised 87 humanitarian air bridge flights and co-ordinated the medical evacuation of 454 Palestinian patients. We are working at the limit of what humanitarian tools and instruments can achieve. The main constraints and hindrances are access and safety, not money, as I said. When I go to the Foreign Affairs Council repeating that we do not have access, that our humanitarian aid is blocked, what is the decision? What is our leverage? Then we are divided. That is why the Commission proposed partially suspending the association agreement, and the Horizon programme, but it was not accepted. We could not reach the unanimity or the qualified majority voting, QMV, that was required.
Unfortunately, we are a little divided and losing our credibility when it comes to respect for international humanitarian law, because we do not use the leverage. We are not capable of using it because of our divisions. At the last UN General Assembly, the European Commission was the only one to organise a humanitarian event on Gaza, with Jordan and Belgium, and also an event on respect for international humanitarian law. It shows that it is becoming something sensitive and divisive as well, unfortunately.
When it comes to climate change, I totally agree with the Deputy that we must involve the citizens. As I said in my introductory remarks, we have lost nearly 700,000 ha. The majority of these wildfires were provoked by human activity. It means that we provoked this. We need to inform citizens and create more awareness, to include awareness of preparedness and resilience at a very early stage, at school, in the curricula, and to involve the citizens in the strategies. The preparedness strategy that I presented a year ago was built on three pillars, and a whole-of-society approach was one of them. It means involving all the citizens, the private sector as well, and the agricultural sectors. All of them need to be actors in resilience and in anticipating climate change. Count on me to do everything to communicate and to involve the citizens. In the coming weeks, following the minimum preparedness requirements, we are going to communicate to every citizen how they can prepare for and anticipate the next heatwaves, but also potentially the next floods or the next massive disinformation.
Comment on this
On the commissioner's last comment, which Deputy Ó Murchú touched on, how can we deal with the rise of propaganda, disinformation, fake information and AI-generated incorrect information?
I appreciate that this is a very open question but it is something we are seeing much more of. It is more difficult for people to tell the difference now than it would have been even a few months ago, because of the rate of advancement in technology and AI. In the context of the geopolitical situation we find ourselves in, disinformation around politics and democracy is a massive threat to our society. Education will play a substantial role in dealing with it. At a European level, how do we ensure that we have coherence across member states in the way we deal with it? The autonomy of each member state has to be respected but at a pan-European level, it is important in terms of strategy to ensure that we are dealing with it in a similar way and that there is communication on that. I would appreciate any further thoughts on that.
Comment on this
This is mainly what is at the heart of the democracy shield. We have the Digital Services Act, where we have a code of conduct, the AI Act, and very recently the child protection Act, whereby we do not allow children to have a social media account before the age of 13, while between 13 and 15 it is restricted and only allowed with the agreement of their parents or guardians. It is to protect them until at least age 15 from disinformation, manipulation and so on.
Everything is connected. If we take the preparedness strategy as an example, we can have the best and most efficient vaccine in the world, but if there is a massive campaign of disinformation, as we had during the Covid-19 pandemic, people will not accept it. That is what happened in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, DRC. Some hospitals were put on fire by the people, they were so afraid. We reacted by creating very transparent, accessible hospital settings to treat patients. If a person's loved one is sick and is then dying behind a door, the person can imagine many things, for example, that it was provoked by doctors or neocolonialism. A lot of phantasmagoric things were imagined by the population but it was spread by extremists. It happened in the DRC but it could happen here tomorrow.
More globally, since I am also Commissioner for equality, we have this incel campaign theory that is attracting young boys, pretending that women are the cause of all the problems that they might face in their lives. It is really massive. This is the misogynist campaign that is linked to extremist political parties as well. It is an attempt on our democracy, in the end. We are good on policies and legislation. I think we are the only ones in the world providing policies on these topics, protecting our children and democracy, too, and imposing a code of conduct and so on. We are quite good at that. We need to stay strong and fight, especially with all of the elections that are coming now, in France and in many critical countries. Now, of course, what we need is to have the member states implementing the directives that we have voted for.
In respect of the big platforms, we have organised a conference with Commissioner Virkkunen, who is responsible for digital worlds, on the fact that women are two or three times more targeted by online harassment than men are. As a politician, the Senator may have experienced that. It is really painful because the result is that women do not stay. They disappear. They cut their social media accounts, but then they are not popular, so they are not re-elected. The consequence is an all-men government. The impact, starting from a harassment campaign on social media, can be massive in the end. We are well aware of that but we need to have more awareness. We need to have boys and men on board as well. We presented the gender equality strategy last March, and I am always repeating that men are part of this strategy. We need men on board. We need men to fight against these trends because in the end, it is all about us and the society we will leave to our children and grandchildren.
Comment on this
I will ask the Commissioner a few questions myself, if that is okay. I very much appreciated what she said in her opening statement about the need to defend aid workers. This morning, I was at an event in Trinity College for Front Line Defenders, an organisation that is global but actually based here in Dublin. They protect those engaged in human rights activities around the world. The Commissioner will be aware of people who seek to defend a particular position within their country and are then persecuted because of that. In terms of the infrastructure for human rights, is the Commissioner satisfied that we are doing enough? Ireland just had a budget this week and we have increased our overseas development aid. Very few European countries are doing that. We are negotiating the multi-annual financial framework as part of our Presidency. I have a real fear about the funding for the European External Action Service, EEAS, in the future. Are we doing enough on this front? What do we need to do to ensure that we protect human rights and human rights defenders?
Comment on this
Everything is intertwined. One of the pillars of our communication on humanitarian aid is the three Ps: protect aid workers; partners; and involve the private sector to be more efficient. We also need to be more effective and efficient in the way we work with co-operation and development, as I mentioned earlier. The protection of aid workers is crucial. We have the rules, including the Geneva Convention, and it is clear that aid workers cannot be targeted. They are neutral, impartial, independent. These are the principles of humanitarian action. Nevertheless, 300 lost their lives last year. That is why we have a specific programme called "protect aid workers". We are helping aid workers worldwide, but also their families. We are stepping up this programme because the needs are huge. It is becoming the new norm to see aid workers being targeted. It is really heartbreaking. Most of the time, they are volunteers. They do it because they are convinced that it is the right thing to do. They are waking up in the morning asking how they can help. I met them in Lebanon, in Jordan, also in Colombia. They are genuinely involved in the moral duty to save lives and alleviate suffering. Despite all of their neutrality, though, they are targeted. This is something that we need to address. We try our best. We were part of an initiative launched by the Australian Government to protect aid workers. This is the second year. Later, in April, we will have a humanitarian forum with a dedicated part on the protection of aid workers. Are we doing enough? Certainly not. The needs are massive. Some 240 million people are dependent on humanitarian aid. Nowadays, the global appeal of the UN is to save the lives of 87 million of them. What about the others, though? This is already restrictive.
Comment on this
Absolutely, and I accept what the Commission is saying. She mentioned her own programme but consider organisations like Front Line Defenders that are doing exceptional work globally, including in informing national governments about the risks that are out there for human rights activists around the world. How much does the European Commission support those organisations? I was talking to the CEO of Front Line Defenders, Alan Glasgow, this morning. It is constantly working for funding to support human rights activists around the world. How can it and organisations like it rely on the Commission to get help to do the work they need to do, which is so valuable?
Comment on this
That is why we need humanitarian diplomacy. I have been in the Great Lakes region to talk with the M23 rebels to ask them to protect the aid workers, to respect them and to have humanitarian corridors. It was positive at the end. That is also why we need accountability. Nowadays, the problem is we have many humanitarians being killed without anyone being prosecuted for it. It happens everywhere. Clearly, one of the objectives is to have accountability. This is an important political signal that the European Union is launching. If a humanitarian worker is killed, we need to know who did it and to prosecute the culprit no matter where it happened, whether that is Gaza or Ukraine. We are working on this with the Red Cross, the Court of Justice and so on. Next week, we will have this event on protecting aid workers, which the Irish Minister is coming to. One of the guests will be the Sudanese who is nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize because he created emergency rooms for aid workers.
Comment on this
On overseas aid generally at national government level, Ireland increased it in our budget this week, but we are still only at 0.44% of GNI. We have a commitment in our Government programme to increase that to 0.7%. As far as I know, we are one of only two governments in Europe that have increased overseas development aid. How do we convince other governments that they need to increase that aid? The Commission said in her opening statement it was a security issue, and I agree. Countries cannot complain about migration and then not fund the programmes that stem migration. How do we persuade national governments that they need to invest in overseas development aid?
Comment on this
With the arguments the Chair just presented. Take the example of the Bundibugyo ebola epidemic in the DRC. It is not a new strain but a rare one for which we do not have a vaccine. We fight a lot to have the transparency, the border monitoring to be sure that we have all of the information we need to fight the spread of this virus. Imagine if we were not investing in boosting the research and development to stop the spread of this virus. It would come to Europe, I can assure you. We have direct flights between Kinshasa and Brussels and Paris. We also had hantavirus. Fortunately, we had the capacity to evacuate and isolate the patients who were contaminated. If we do not invest, if we think this is their problem that they have this war or that virus but it is not ours, then we are saying we should just close the borders, close our eyes, put our heads in the sand and that is it, and then we will all be contaminated. These are the lessons learned from Covid-19. We are not secure until every one of us is safe.
Comment on this
I want to ask about Syria. The Commissioner met President al-Sharaa there. How does she characterise progress in Syria? Can we as a European political entity rely on President al-Sharaa to bring Syria out of civil war and into a more functioning state?
Comment on this
One of the pleas when I was there was to lift the sanctions. We did it. Now, the priority is to implement the nexus over there. Syria is one of the fragile countries where we want to deliver this nexus and to help the local economy recover and help the Government stabilise the country with all the social infrastructure, including hospitals, schools and so on. That is why we want to invest in a more sustainable manner. It will also alleviate the burden on Jordan, Egypt and Türkiye where there are still a lot of Syrians, and Europe as well. My main message is that humanitarian aid alone cannot meet Syria's need and must be complemented by development funding. We of course want a peaceful and inclusive transition on a political and socio-economic level. We committed €139 million last year and this year with DG MENA, and we allocated €280 for this year and next for development aid, but we really need the nexus aid approach to stabilise the country. This is the emergency I see.
Comment on this
The Commission said in her opening statement that European leadership was a choice, and I agree. Ireland's experience of being part of the EU has been very positive but one of the things that is really important for Irish people is that being part of the European Union is being part of a political bloc that respects those values and the rule of law. I have been very disappointed by the Commission's response to what has happened in Gaza, especially going back to this day three years ago when President von der Leyen went to Tel Aviv and stood next to an Israeli minister who was openly saying he was going to deprive access to Gaza for aid bodies, thereby breaking international law. The President of the European Commission stood next to him and said, "Europe stands with Israel". The President has modified her comments since then, but when Commissioner Lahbib says European leadership is a choice, have we chosen to lead on Gaza?
Comment on this
I think I went as far as I can in my answer as Commissioner responsible for humanitarian aid. I am not the High Representative-Vice President, HR-VP. It is a question for her. I repeat we have to choose to stand firm on our values and principles, otherwise we will pay a heavy price.
Comment on this
I will finish on this. The Commissioner mentioned earlier in response to one of my colleagues that, after the attacks, there was a disparity of views among European foreign ministers when she was Belgian foreign minister. I perceive that some of those opinions have changed and that there is a coalition forming that sees things differently. Does she agree with that?
Comment on this
I totally agree with the Chair. Many countries have changed. We were at first shocked by the traumatic violence of October 7. There is no explanation and we cannot explain in any manner what has happened. We are condemning with one voice the attacks of October 7, but slowly with the violence in Gaza and the massive destruction and what is happening in the West Bank, we have seen many countries changing. Yes, the dynamic has changed, but we are still not there. We are still paralysed and divided.
Comment on this
We will draw the engagement to a close. I am conscious of the Commissioner's time. I am so grateful to her for taking the time to appear before us. I know she has a very busy schedule. On behalf of the committee, I thank her and her team, including the representation in Dublin, for their engagement and the discussion. I also thank her for the frankness of her answers. I know some of the questions were awkward, but I appreciate the fact that she engaged with everything she was asked about.
As there are no further questions, we will go into private session to do some private business.