EU Careers and Related Matters: Discussion
Irish representation in EU institutions is improving, with strong entry-level interest and outreach to schools and graduates, but witnesses warned that sustained support is needed, particularly to address a coming shortfall among mid-career officials. They urged widening awareness of the diverse career options, offering practical application support and mentoring, and making job information easier to find; a dedicated preparation institute and a single careers portal were supported. Irish has full official-language status in most EU work, creating employment opportunities, though a remaining restriction in the European Parliament and gaps in Irish-language services at home were highlighted.
I have received apologies from Senator Chris Andrews. Today, we are looking at EU careers and related matters. The purpose of the meeting is to discuss that topic, which will include how the work of the EU is communicated and how important the Irish language is to the number of opportunities available. This is a very important aspect of our work programme. It concerns not only our representation through the various EU institutions and bodies but also the future of that representation.
The committee has also had the privilege of engaging formally with members of the Irish community working in the EU institutions and various institutions and agencies in both Brussels and Luxembourg, which has further underlined to us the significance of work on this topic. In 2021, the Government of Ireland advanced the A Career for EU strategy, which set out a range of initiatives and measures to support a strong representation from Ireland in the structures of the European Union, and since then the issue has been raised through various channels, including the delegations that have attended and given evidence at this committee. We are interested in how this work is advancing, in particular what is working well, maybe what is not working well, what we can do better, what the challenges are, what the unforeseen aspects of it are, and indeed the foreseen, when we look at supporting Irish people with an interest in the European Union and pursuing related career paths.
From my own perspective, I think it is about telling people not just what jobs are available, but what the package that goes with that job is, so they understand the opportunity that comes with it. The next step is to support them in applying for those jobs and to help them in whatever respect to be competitive applicants.
There are a range of issues, including the level of representation of Irish people among EU staff and the importance of languages in securing a job in the EU. Central to this is the role of our teanga dhúchais, an Ghaeilge, which we all know is an official language of the European Union. This is our first Presidency in which it was used in that capacity. It is nice to see us taking forward steps in that regard.
To start our meeting on the topic, I am pleased to engage with our first panel of stakeholders, all of whom represent important organisations in this area. Cuirim fíorfháilte roimh Sibéal Ní Dhuibhir agus John Prendergast, Chonradh na Gaeilge; Mr. Peter Power, Ms Helen Kearns and Mr. Pól Ó Gradaigh, European Commission Representation in Ireland; Mr. David Geary and Mr. Finn Moffat, European Movement Ireland; and Ms Fionnuala Croker and Mr. Gearóid Ó Duinn, European Parliament Liaison Office in Ireland. They are all very welcome. I also welcome any attendees in the Public Gallery. Many of the witnesses will have been before an Oireachtas committee before, so they will know there is a little bit I have to read, which concerns privileges and behaviour before the committee. Mar is coiste a bhíonn ar siúl againn idir an Ghaeilge agus an Bhéarla, ta mé chun an píosa seo a dhéanamh trí Ghaeilge, go háirithe mar is teanga oifigiúil den Aontas Eorpach í.
Sula leanaimid ar aghaidh, tá sé de dhualgas orm na rialacha agus na treoracha seo a leanas a leagan faoi bhráid na bhfinnéithe uile. Tá an rogha ag comhaltaí freastal ar an gcruinniú go fisiciúil sa seomra coiste nó go fíorúil ar Microsoft Teams, ar an gcoinníoll, i gcás cruinnithe phoiblí, gur óna n-oifigí i dTithe an Oireachtais a dhéantar sin. Is riachtanas bunreachtúil é sin. Nuair atá comhaltaí ag freastal óna n-oifigí, ba chóir dóibh a bhfíseáin a bheith ar siúl an t-am go léir agus iad féin le feiceáil ar an scáileán. Baineann an coinníoll seo le finnéithe freisin agus iad ag freastal ar an gcruinniú go fíorúil, ach níl aon fhinné á dhéanamh sin inniu. Chomh maith leis sin, ba chóir dóibh a chinntiú go bhfuil na micreafóin múchta nuair nach bhfuil siad ag caint.
Cuirim ar aird na bhfinnéithe go bhfuil, de bhua Bhunreacht na hÉireann agus reachtaíocht araon, finnéithe faoi chosaint ag lánphribhléid maidir leis an bhfianaise a thugann siad don chomhchoiste chomh fada is atá siad lonnaithe laistigh de phurláin Thithe an Oireachtais agus an fhianaise sin á tabhairt acu. Is fíric é nach féidir leis na finnéithe brath ar an gcosaint sin agus fianaise á tabhairt acu lasmuigh de phurláin Thithe an Oireachtais. Ní dóigh liom go bhfuil éinne ar líne inniu ar aon nós. Molaim d’fhinnéithe a bheith cúramach agus fianaise á tabhairt acu, agus má ordaím dóibh éirí as fianaise a thabhairt i leith ní áirithe, ba chóir dóibh amhlaidh a dhéanamh láithreach.
Iarrtar ar fhinnéithe agus ar chomhaltaí araon cleachtadh parlaiminte a urramú nár chóir, más féidir, daoine nó eintiteas a cháineadh ná líomhaintí a dhéanamh ina n-aghaidh ná tuairimí a thabhairt maidir leo ina ainm, ina hainm nó ina n-ainm nó ar shlí a bhféadfaí iad a aithint. Chomh maith leis sin, iarrtar orthu gan aon rud a rá a bhféadfaí breathnú air mar ábhar díobhálach do dhea-chlú aon duine nó eintiteas. Mar sin, más rud é go bhféadfadh a ráiteas bheith clúmhillteach do dhuine nó eintiteas aitheanta, ordóidh mé dóibh éirí as an ráiteas láithreach.
Tá súil agam go dtuigeann gach éinne sin. Again, it is stuff many of the witnesses will have heard before about parliamentary practice and not criticising or saying anything about anyone who is not present, or in such a way that they might be identified. That applies equally to members and witnesses. I am happy to do that in English if anyone wants me to do so. I was planning to go simply in the order in which we are here, ag tosú le Conradh na Gaeilge, muna gcuireann sé sin isteach ar éinne. We will go around from there. Conradh na Gaeilge will be first, followed by the European Commission Representation in Ireland, the European Parliament Liaison Office in Ireland and then European Movement Ireland, EMI.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis an gCathaoirleach as cluas éisteachta a thabhairt dúinn inniu. Tá mé anseo thar ceann Chonradh na Gaeilge. Beidh mé ag caint faoi dheiseanna gairmeacha a chur chun cinn agus na rudaí a dhéanann muid mar chuid den fheachtas Gluaiseacht, chomh maith le stádas na Gaeilge in institiúidí an Aontais Eorpaigh.
Oibrím le Gluaiseacht, togra atá maoinithe ag Roinn na Gaeltachta ina ndéantar feasacht do dhaltaí iarbhunscoile agus lucht an tríú leibhéil maidir le gairmeacha le Gaeilge, ón Státseirbhís, an earnáil phoiblí, gairmeacha sna meáin, earnáil na Gaeilge go dtí deiseanna fostaíochta Gaeilge thar lear, lena n-áirítear na deiseanna san Aontas Eorpach. Ag leibhéal na iarbhunscoile, reáchtáiltear ceardlann – an seó bóthair – do lucht na hidirbhliana sa scoileanna T2, is iad sin na scoileanna a fheidhmíonn trí Bhéarla, agus reáchtáiltear ceardlann don chúigiú agus séú bhliain in scoileanna T1, is iad sin Gaelcholáistí nó scoileanna Gaeltachta.
Le hos cionn 340 ceardlann gach bhliain ó 2022, tá triúr comhordaitheoirí ar an mbóthar agus iad siúd lonnaithe sa deisceart, san iarthar agus san oirthear. Tá siad tar éis 155 ceardlann a reáchtáil ó thús mhí Eanáir 2026.
Ag an tríú leibhéal, bíonn deis níos fearr díriú ar stádas na Gaeilge sa Státseirbhís, san earnáil phoiblí agus san Aontas Eorpach agus na deiseanna reatha fostaíochta iontu chomh maith le heolas faoin gcóras earcaíochta ina leith. Go dtí seo in 2026, d’éascaigh an comhordaitheoir tríú leibhéil ceardlanna gairmeacha le Gaeilge in Ollscoil Luimnigh, Coláiste na Tríonóide, Aontas na Mac Léinn in Éirinn, Ollscoil Chathair Bhaile Átha Cliath, Ollscoil Uladh, Institiúid Oideachais Marino, Ollscoil Teicneolaíochta an Oirdheiscirt agus Ollscoil Teicneolaíochta an Atlantaigh.
I dtaobh stádas na Gaeilge in institiúidí an Aontais Eorpaigh, tá lánstádas bainte amach ag an nGaeilge, mar atá luaite cheana, tar éis feachtas fada stocaireachta ó na seachtóidí agus ballraíocht na hÉireann san Aontas Eorpach á meá ag an tír seo. Feicimid an tábhacht agus an maitheas a rinne an cinneadh seo don Ghaeilge trí chéile maidir le postanna ar ardchaighdeán a chruthú le coinníollacha maithe ina gcuirtear oiliúint shainchuspóireach ar fáil do dhaoine le Gaeilge barrchumais a bhaint amach ina gcuid réimsí éagsúil oibre.
Faraor, tá maolú fós i bhfeidhm ar úsáid na Gaeilge i bParlaimint na hEorpa, rud a chiallaíonn gurb í an Ghaeilge an t-aon teanga as 22 teanga oibre nach bhfuil stádas iomlán aici. Níl an cead céanna ag Feisirí Éireannacha príomhtheanga oifigiúil na hÉireann a labhairt mar atá ag Feisirí Eorpacha eile a dteangacha féin a úsáid faoi láthair, ceal postanna agus toisc cinntí maorlathacha, rudaí a d’fhéadfaí réiteach go héasca. Tá impleacht aige seo ar fhostaíocht, stádas, feiceálacht agus úsáid na Gaeilge. Mar bhallstát, táimid ag díol isteach sa chiste chuige seo pé scéal é. Mar sin, tá sé in am aghaidh a thabhairt ar an bhfadhb seo.
Agus Uachtaránacht Chomhairle an Aontais Eorpaigh ag Éirinn as seo go dtí deireadh na bliana, is gá na ceachtanna atá foghlamtha agus úsáidte ag an Stát a chur i gcleachtas laethúil an Státchórais sa tír seo. Molaimid na hiarrachtaí atá déanta ag Ranna Stáit na hÉireann an Ghaeilge a bheith níos feiceálaí le linn na hUachtaránachta, ach tá obair mhór le déanamh fós maidir leis na bunghníomhaíochtaí a leabú isteach i gcur chuige dátheangach an Stáit ó bhun go barr. Cuirim i gcás ateangaireacht, aistriúchán ar ardchaighdeán agus na scileanna móra idirchultúrtha agus pleanála teanga a bhíonn úsáidte ar an Mór-Roinn.
Gabhaim buíochas leis an gcomhchoiste as éisteacht a thabhairt dúinn. Tá mé ag súil go mór le ceisteanna na gcomhaltaí.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas le Sibéal Ní Dhuibhir. I now invite Mr. Peter Power from the European Commission Representation in Ireland to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the invitation to be here today. This is an important subject and we are grateful the committee has put a spotlight on it. There are three essential messages we want to get across. First, a huge amount of work has been done to increase the number of Irish officials in the European institutions. Thankfully, the trend is now in the right direction. However, the work is not complete. There is still more to do. It will require sustained commitment over many years. The key to a successful outcome is partnership between the European Commission, the Irish Government and, indeed, this committee and everyone represented here today.
Fair representation of all member states is vital for the work of the Commission and good policymaking. It is a core element of the staff regulations. In recent years, the Commission has identified 15 member states, including Ireland, that are under-represented when it comes to staffing. To address this, joint action plans have been prepared with the relevant authorities. Thanks to the good work of the Department of foreign affairs and the Commission, there are plenty of signs of improvement. Ireland’s presence at entry level in the European Commission has improved fast. Ireland now has the highest number of seconded national experts per capita. This is a considerable achievement. We also have a record interest shown by Irish citizens in EU careers.
In June 2026, the Commission adopted additional measures to ensure geographical balance. For example, where multiple candidates for a position have substantially the same merits, preference will now be given to a candidate from an under-represented nationality. This is a significant breakthrough.
The European Commission Representation in Ireland works actively to promote careers to young Irish and professionals. Much of our outreach takes place in schools, universities and career fairs. So far this year, we have participated in approximately ten career fairs.
We have provided support to university graduates applying for the Blue Book traineeship. This is a key pathway to the European Union institutions. Indeed, it is the one I followed myself.
I know the committee is particularly interested in the Irish language and its place in the European Union and I will make a few key points in that regard. The Commission provides Irish-language translation on an equal footing with the other 23 official EU languages. The Commission's Irish interpretation capacity is also on par with smaller official EU languages. Of course, getting to this point has involved a lot of work. Our work and engagement with the Department of Rural and Community Development and the Gaeltacht continues to that end. Our excellent relationship with European Movement Ireland, EMI, is also key to our outreach to schools. I am sure Mr. Geary will want to highlight these activities, notably the Blue Star programme, which is managed by EMI.
The Commission provides educational materials to approximately 400 schools annually, alongside a Brussels study visit for teachers. At secondary level, we organise the Model Council of the EU debate competition. This brings together 300 students from 27 schools. Already this year, the Commission representation has organised about a dozen visits by Commissioners to Irish universities.
Our outreach to the Irish public also takes place outside the classroom. This year, for example, we organised two content creator summits, which brought together young people on topics such as politics, sustainability and farming. This enables us to reach a whole new audience. We are also highly active in outreach, for example engaging with students at events ranging from the ploughing championships to the young scientist exhibition. We are building new relationships with the GAA and Sanctuary Runners. In partnership with the European Parliament Liaison Office, the representation also promotes the Europa Experience at Europe House, which provides interactive insights into the EU institutions.
I mentioned at the outset that increasing Irish representation in the EU institutions will take time. Success will depend on a sustained commitment from everybody here today. I count on this committee to keep this subject in the spotlight. I look forward to continuing dialogue with its members.
Comment on this
A Chathaoirligh, a bhaill an choiste agus a chomhghleacaithe, is mór an onóir dom a bheith anseo libh inniu, agus is mór agam an deis seo labhairt ar son Oifig Idirchaidrimh Pharlaimint na hEorpa in Éirinn. Is ceist thábhachtach í ionadaíocht na hÉireann in institiúidí an Aontais Eorpaigh, ní hamháin ó thaobh deiseanna gairme dár saoránaigh, ach freisin ó thaobh a chinntiú go léiríonn foireann na n-institiúidí éagsúlacht an Aontais agus go dtuigeann siad comhthéacsanna náisiúnta éagsúla. My own experience spans the European Parliament and the European Central Bank. I joined the Parliament in 2006 as an English language lawyer-linguist, before moving to the European Central Bank in 2012 as an Irish-law expert. I returned to the Parliament in 2019 and have since worked in its Dublin liaison office as press officer, acting head of office and in public relations. I am here today with my colleague Gearóid Ó Duinn, one of the Parliament's translators based in Luxembourg, who is seconded to our office for the duration of the Irish Presidency of the Council.
On the subject of recruitment, the Parliament recognises that geographical balance requires sustained, long-term attention. Although Irish nationals are not currently classified as an under-represented nationality, their situation continues to be monitored. Irish nationals are relatively well represented among officials under 40 and among recent cohorts of Schuman trainees. The Parliament is expanding its engagement with all stakeholders by building stronger networks, including with permanent representations and liaison offices around Europe, partnerships with national organisations and recruitment and trainee programmes.
In 2024, the Parliament held nationality-specific competitions for four significantly under-represented member states. These were Austria, Cyprus, Luxembourg and the Netherlands. This marked a new approach to addressing geographical imbalances, and is something that the Parliament intends to continue, pending a ruling on the matter by the European Court of Justice.
Ireland has particular opportunities in language services. Since Irish acquired full official and working language status in 2022, opportunities have expanded for Irish-language translation and legal linguistic expertise.
At the same time, Ireland's position as the only remaining native English-speaking member state, following the United Kingdom's withdrawal from the Union, creates opportunities in English-language drafting, translating and editing services.
However, EU careers extend well beyond language services. Irish people should be encouraged to consider the full range of opportunities, from policy development and legal work to administration, communications and management. Prospective applicants need to understand both how to enter the institutions and the opportunities for career progression that follow. Alongside efforts to increase Irish representation at entry level, I highlight from my own experience as an Irish national the value of strengthening connections among Irish officials working across the institutions. More structured networks of current and perhaps former staff could facilitate the exchange of experience and provide practical support. Appropriate training and mentoring, particularly at mid-career level, could help Irish officials to progress professionally. Stronger links with the Irish authorities could also facilitate the sharing of expertise, benefiting public administration in Ireland.
Communicating the work of the European Union is central to the role of our liaison office. The Europa Experience in Dublin welcomes visitors throughout the week, including school and community groups, offering opportunities to explore how the EU institutions work, how decisions at EU level are made and how they affect everyday life. By the end of this year, the Europa Experience in Dublin expects to have received 100,000 visitors since opening two years ago. Our work also includes regular engagement with journalists, visits for media representatives and others to Parliament in Brussels and Strasbourg, social media and a monthly newsletter. We have a busy outreach programme, which includes debates and other events at Europe House, and we have a presence at a number of festivals and other events around the country every year, working with our colleagues in the Commission representation on many of them.
A large part of our focus is on youth and education work and, through the European Parliament ambassador school programme alone, we engage with more than 80 participating schools around the country each year, whose transition year students follow the programme as a subject for the full academic year. These activities help make the EU more accessible and raise awareness of the opportunities available to Irish citizens, both to engage with the Union and to pursue careers within its institutions.
To conclude, I highlight three priorities for continued co-operation between the Union institutions and the Irish authorities: sustained outreach to Irish students and graduates about the full range of EU careers; stronger professional development, mentoring and networking opportunities for Irish officials; and continued efforts to communicate the work of the Union in a way that is accessible and relevant to people across Ireland. We welcome the committee's interest in this important area and would be pleased to contribute to the ongoing discussion.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee for the invitation to appear before them on behalf of European Movement Ireland. I am delighted to be joined by my colleague Finn Moffat, policy manager.
European Movement Ireland’s mission is to promote a democratic and fair EU where everyone’s rights are protected. We work to support informed public debate and civic participation, ensuring that people, communities and organisations in Ireland can have their voices heard in EU policy and decision-making. EU careers is an important part of that work. At its simplest, we want more people across Ireland to view working in and around the European Union as an achievable and attractive career option. We work with people at different stages of that journey, from second and third level students through to graduates and people actively considering a move into an EU career. Our work complements the Government's A Career for EU strategy, which was launched in 2021 in response to concerns about Ireland’s representation in the EU institutions. The strategy aims to encourage more Irish citizens to apply for EU positions, better equip candidates to succeed in recruitment competitions and support improvements to the EU recruitment process.
European Movement Ireland provides practical support in a number of ways. We publish a weekly EU jobs and traineeships list, which in May of this year reached approximately 4,500 individual subscribers, as well as partnering with university career services across the country. We provide one-to-one EU careers support, promote opportunities through our communications channels and work alongside the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade at university careers fairs. In 2026, this has included activity at Trinity College Dublin, University College Dublin, University College Cork, University of Limerick, University of Galway and Queen's University Belfast.
We publish our Green Book annually, which provides detailed information on the EU's agencies and institutions, as well as a comprehensive guide to the deadlines for all availing internships and traineeships. We also organise Brussels Connection events, bringing together students, trainees and Irish people working within the European system at events in Brussels to facilitate the building of professional networks and to aid recruitment and advancement. However, we believe communicating EU careers needs to extend well beyond the people who are already thinking about a job in Brussels. If Ireland wants stronger representation in the EU institutions in the years ahead, we need to build awareness much earlier and much more widely. Our own experience has shown considerable interest in EU careers, even at secondary level. We also believe there is an opportunity to reach audiences who may not traditionally have seen themselves reflected in conversations about EU careers. In particular, European Movement Ireland would like to explore a targeted campaign to broaden awareness of EU career opportunities among Ireland's increasingly diverse and multilingual population, and in doing so, widen the pool of people considering careers in the European institutions. This should be supported by clear information on eligibility and the opportunities available to EU and non-EU citizens, alongside practical support for those eligible to apply.
Language capability is also an important consideration. European Movement Ireland has consistently promoted the value of a second EU language, while our previous work has identified language skills as one of the challenges facing some Irish graduates. We commend the work to extend the use of Irish language as a working language across the EU, which creates further opportunities for Irish speakers within the European institutions. There are some positive signs. For example, 1,700 Irish citizens applied for the recent AD5 competition, placing Ireland 10th among 27 member states on a per capita basis. There has also been strong Irish participation in European Parliament traineeships. The challenge now is to turn that interest into a sustainable pathway for Irish people entering and progressing through the institutions. To do that we need to communicate opportunities widely, start that engagement early, support candidates practically and make clear that a new career is open to people from every part of modern Irish society. We look forward to continuing to play our part alongside the Government and the EU institutions in encouraging the next generation to consider a career in Europe. I thank the committee members and look forward to their questions.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Geary and all the witnesses. We are very grateful for their time and are looking forward to the benefit of their experience and expertise. I will go to Deputy Butterly first and then Senator Davitt.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. I agree with comments made that this is an extremely important issue to be discussing because I am not sure a lot of young people were aware of the opportunities in Europe and how they could have a very fulfilling and interesting career in one of the institutions. When we talk about Europe, we talk about only the European Parliament, but we all know the EU is far more vast than that. With that in mind, another question a lot of students ask me is whether they have to be fluent in French, German or another language. Often I tell them that for some jobs they might need a second language, but that it might not necessarily be at the level they think it is. We also cannot forget that Irish is a recognised language. It is always great when we bring the information to young people rather than expecting them to come to us. I was particularly interested to hear that the witnesses are engaging with them not just in schools but also at festivals. If you buy a few bucket hats and attend a few music festivals, you would be amazed at the crowd you will attract. I am quite sure the Chair will be willing to put on a bucket hat and go to Electric Picnic if so required.
Someone mentioned over 300 visits to schools. We have over 700 schools. Are there plans to expand that programme? Aside from languages, what skill set is missing, or what could Irish students bring to the table to enhance any applications? Are summer internships available? Are they available to Irish students? If they imagine - they will have to go really deep on this one - that I am an 18-year-old, why should I apply for a job in Europe? Sell it to me.
Comment on this
We will start with the question of why someone who is aged 18 would want to work in a European institution. Sell it to me. Is it the money, craic or career prospects?
Comment on this
Nobody wants to leave Louth voluntarily. An airport to commute to on a daily basis would be the tough environment.
Comment on this
About 80% of the laws implemented in this country originate in Europe. If one wants to get the heart of lawmaking and if one has a curious mind and an ability to draft and engage, that is where the business is at. A multicultural environment is very interesting to live in. Living in Dublin is also multicultural, but it is a different culture. The chance to speak and operate in a different language is very attractive to some people.. They would be the essential pillars. It is where the action is at. The European Union is now about to expand further into eastern Europe. The elements at play have become even more interesting. The package is also quite rewarding. There has been a period in which salaries in Ireland made it unattractive to go to the continent for work, but that has changed recently. Ms Kearns spoke to over 100 students yesterday in UCD.
Comment on this
Mr. Ó Gradaigh and I were in UCD with another former official yesterday. We were a little bit worried no one would come. We had 100 people in a room of second-year politics students doing a module on European integration. All of the things Mr. Power said are correct. It is a job with meaning, values and doing something that makes a difference to 450 million people. It involves multicultural languages and the fun and excitement of working in that environment. One sits at a table with Polish, Irish, French and British people and all that brings. Afterwards, 30 people waited to ask questions. They were somewhat intimidated by language. Mr. Ó Gradaigh did a great job of saying that people need a C1 or B2 and if people have Irish that is a super important. It is doable. We told them that we sat in the same lecture hall 20 years ago and we are normal people. It is something they can achieve. They wanted to know about jobs in defence and whether AI would replace languages. They were super interested. The appetite is there. People need confidence.
Comment on this
It is not just students studying politics who are interested; students studying engineering or medicine are also interested. There is a wide variety. There is another perception from students that one has to be interested in politics. I take Ms Kearns' point on law because everything starts in Europe and comes down towards us. Students think it is all about politics, whereas it is about much more.
Comment on this
Regarding environmental faculties, there are great jobs in environmental areas, and the same is a case for digital ones. The appetite is there.
Comment on this
There are three European agencies headed by Irish women: the medical agency, the environmental agency and the chemical agency. The range of activities and subject matter in question is fascinating and broad.
Comment on this
Will the Commission expand the schools programme?
Comment on this
Yes, I am very keen to get us into as many schools as possible. That is key. Any time a Commissioner comes to Dublin, I encourage them to visit at least one school.
Comment on this
I am not sure one has been to County Louth yet. Will the Commission be coming to County Louth?
Comment on this
We are launching a new programme in Meath tomorrow. A circular will go to schools regarding working with the National Centre for the Circular Economy. In schools, we will talk not as much about Europe but rather the substance that engages people, such as the skills of redesigning and remaking and going into the new leaving certificate sustainable and climate action programme to bring Europe in in a different way around a subject that people really care about. There is never enough.
Comment on this
It is a really good question. I hope the first time a person is considering an EU career is not when they are aged 18.
That is sort of the point from our perspective. We have been leading the Blue Star programme at primary for 16 years and we are starting that conversation about Ireland’s place in the EU. There is a lot more work to be done at second level so that when a person is turning 19 and is thinking about this, the seed has already been planted that this is a viable career path.
The Deputy raised a really important point about how it is not just the policy or regulatory aspect, which will interest some but will not interest everybody. The scale of activity the EU is now involved with covers literally everything from sports to security to language protection. There is an area of activity in that space. Part of the strategy for us, certainly, is trying to connect with people on what actually interests them. For some people that is lawyer-linguist and for some it is translation because they have a love of languages. For some people, it is specific areas and that is where that conversation would go. However, it is also the scale of opportunities available. If we compare the European institutions with the Civil Service, there are many more opportunities over the course of a career. Certainly, that is some of the conversation. My colleague, Mr. Moffat, regularly speaks to people at career fairs. He might have some thoughts on some of the topics that come up at those sessions.
Comment on this
I will just come in briefly on that. Obviously, there are several challenges that come with those interactions, particularly the requirements. As the Deputy mentioned, the language requirements are there. I believe it has to be at B2 with one language and C1 with another, so that is obviously a challenge. Another thing is trying to make sure we are as inclusive as possible. A lot of the people we talk to at university careers fairs are not necessarily from Ireland. We are speaking to a lot of people who are not Irish citizens and not EU citizens at all and that does discount them from a lot of opportunities that are available in the EU. We need to look at ways of encouraging other pathways that do not necessarily require citizenship, or at least positions that can be gone into while people perhaps wait for their citizenship. Many of the interactions we have had over our dedicated EU careers helpline email address are essentially just people asking what opportunities are there because people do not know - young people do not know - what the opportunities are. People are coming out of university - maybe it is with an economics or politics degree or whatever it might be - and looking for those European opportunities partly for, as Ms Kearns mentioned, the opportunity to travel, work in different languages, make friends in different countries and that kind of thing. They really come to us as a starting point to try to find out what opportunities are available. We also would provide them with information on how to best write their cover letter and how best to write their CV in the Europass format, which is a uniform format for CVs that is recognised across Europe. It is, therefore, really a starting point. What we would obviously like to see as well is people coming with maybe a more nuanced idea of what it is they want to do or what they want to get into before they come to us because at the moment, I would say it is very much just a starting point.
Comment on this
I would just like to add a point on the European Parliament ambassador school programme. Every year, at the beginning of the academic year, an invitation goes out to every single secondary school in Ireland inviting them to take part. This is a full year-long programme, which is supported by our office and our contractors, The Wheel. I would like to confirm with Deputy Butterly that we have schools from County Louth taking part also. The year culminates in an awards ceremony at the end of each year in each constituency.
The Deputy asked about the skills required. It is far from the case that it is confined to lawyers and political science graduates. In the Parliament alone, there are opportunities for communications professionals, scientists, archivists, librarians, photographers and press officers. There is a wide range and that is before even looking at the specialist agencies.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt. I am conscious that a vote has been called in the Seanad. I want to let Senator Davitt come back in and I will come back to Ms Croker then if that is okay.
Comment on this
Tá cúpla ceist agam ar na grúpaí anseo. Nílim líofa ach déanfaidh mé mo dhícheall le mo chúpla focal Gaeilge. An bhfuil na finnéithe ábalta daoine a fháil le Gaeilge mhaith don obair san Aontas Eorpach? Mheas mé mbeadh sé seo an-deacair. Cá bhfaigheann siad na daoine? Luaigh siad na coláistí, na Gaeltachtaí, Leinster House nó áiteanna cosúil leis sin. Tá mé ag triail próifíl na ndaoine a fháil. For my mother at home who is listening who may not have it as Gaeilge, or probably could not understand my pidgin Irish anyway, I am curious about the profile of the people the organisations are getting. Is it hard to fill a specific post, particularly Irish-speaking posts, or would they be overprescribed? Will they give a general profile of the people who are taking these jobs? Go raibh maith agaibh.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis an Seanadóir as an gceist. Faoi mar a luaigh Fionnuala Croker níos luaithe, táimse ag obair don oifig idirchaidrimh faoi láthair mar oifigeach cumarsáide, ach an post atá agam de ghnáth ná aistritheoir Gaeilge leis an tseirbhís aistriúcháin i bParlaimint na hEorpa i Lucsamburg. Tá an cheist seo an-tráthúil dúinn mar tá go leor oibre déanta againn san oifig idirchaidrimh agus ag an tseirbhís aistriúcháin le cúpla mí ag díriú ar ghairmeacha teanga agus go háirithe ar dhaoine a aimsiú in Éirinn. Tá deiseanna ar fáil anois do dhaoine in Éirinn le Gaeilge agus le Béarla. Ná déanaimis dearmad ar an mBéarla chomh maith. Tá deiseanna ar fáil san Eoraip do na daoine sin anois. In the last few months, as I said, we have been working very closely on this and this culminated last week with a high-level outreach mission by senior management of the translation service, including the director general, Valter Mavrič, the heads of the Irish and English translation unit, and the citizens’ language and editing unit to Ireland. Just last week we were touring around Ireland. We visited each of the three European constituencies to meet directly and to learn more about the current profiles of these prospective language professionals. There were two key aims looking at both the situation for Irish and for English. For Irish, the aim was to maintain momentum with promoting Irish-language positions. We have seen a steady increase in these positions in the last ten years. Since the derogation was lifted in 2022 it has got even better, and now we are at a stage where the key focus is to ensure the staffing numbers in the Irish translation unit are up to par with the other typical language units in the translation service. We met prospective language professionals last week all across the country. The profile might be more open than people might understand. We address some of the key concerns raised during that time. There are, as mentioned, still concerns or questions being raised about EU citizenships, and with language professions there is also confusion sometimes between translation and interpretation. One of the points we really tried to emphasise last week is that for a translation role in the European Parliament you do not need a specific background in translation, in linguistics, or in the language you are working with. What is needed is EU citizenships and a university degree. It could be in whatever field. I work with a colleague whose background is in IT.
Comment on this
Gabh mo leithscéal a Chathaoirligh, tá córam ag teastáil.
Comment on this
I do not want to cut Mr. Ó Duinn off but there is limited time for Senator Davitt to get up to vote in the Chamber before he gets locked out. Mr. Ó Duinn should feel free to finish and the Senator can watch back later anyway.
Comment on this
It is just that we were keen to emphasis the point last week that for translator positions one does not need a specific specialised degree in linguistics or in translation. The director general who was here last week gave the example of when he was the head of the Slovenian unit how he once received an application from a medical doctor in Slovenia who simply wanted a career change. This doctor applied and he passed the language tests, where we test the language ability during the recruitment process. He joined the service and he stayed there for the remainder of his career. One key message is that we want to focus on native language ability. Being a linguist in Europe does not mean learning 20 languages and being able to translate from those languages; we are looking for those key native speakers. As well as the Irish-language opportunities, another key focus of our visit last week was highlighting the new-found English language opportunities. Prior to Brexit, the two native English-speaking member states in the European Union, Ireland and the United Kingdom, comprised around 14% of the entire European population, so that was a considerable figure from which to draw talent. Post Brexit, today, Ireland stands as the sole native-English speaking member state, so that talent pool has shrunk to about 1.2% of the entire EU population.
That, of course, has drastically reduced the talent pool and that means there are more opportunities available today than ever for Irish-language professionals and for English-language professionals in this country. We are in a position now where this country, which is about 1% of the European Union, speaks two official languages, neither of which are spoken natively and widely anywhere else in the Union, and one of which is a lingua franca of the European Union. A key message we had last week is that there are opportunities as always in Irish but let us not forget the opportunities for English-language professionals across all the institutions. There is a good opportunity there to increase Irish representation in the institutions if we focus on those positions as well.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Ó Duinn. I am conscious I cut Ms Croker off before she was finished. Is there anything she wanted to add to what she was saying?
Comment on this
Not at all. The invitations go out to each school in the country to join the European Parliament ambassador schools, EPAS, programme and we have never yet had to decline a school that applied. We have been able to manage all. We have up to 85. We have a structured traineeship programme and many of our trainees have told us that their first engagement with the European Union was via the EPAS programme.
Comment on this
Primarily thinking of secondary school students or even those at university, is there a possibility of summer internships?
Comment on this
I will take that. Generally speaking, in the Parliament we do not offer this but we do have a pilot programme within the Europa Experience now which is run jointly with our colleagues in the Commission, whereby the contractors who run it take on, in limited circumstances, a summer intern.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom pointe a dhéanamh mar gheall ar úsáid na Gaelainne agus an oiliúint atá curtha isteach inti le blianta ach go háirithe. Téann sé seo leis an dá cheist a chur an Seanadóir Davitt agus an Teachta Butterly mar gheall ar an obair mhór atá déanta le blianta ach go háirithe, cuirim i gcás rudaí ar nós an tionscnamh ardscileanna Gaeilge de chuid Roinn na Gaeltachta agus céimeanna áirithe a chuireadh ar an bhfód. Is iarchéimí mise do cheann acu i gColáiste na hOllscoile Corcaigh – cúrsa dlí agus Gaelainn. Is cuimhin liom an cúrsa sin a chríochnú in 2015 agus ní dheachaigh éinne ó mo rang do b’fhéidir ochtar nó naonúr ar aghaidh go dtí post ag leibhéal Eorpach. Ansin, sé mbliana níos déanaí, bhíos ag caint le rang a bhí díreach ag tosnú ar an gcúrsa dlí agus Gaelainne agus theastaigh ó gach aon duine acu - ón ochtar nó naonúr sa rang - dul ar aghaidh agus a bheith ag obair sa Bhruiséil, i Lucsamburg nó i gceann de na hinstitiúidí Eorpacha. Is léir mar sin an spéis mhéadaithe sin atá le feiceáil ar an dtalamh toisc obair na ngrúpaí atá timpeall an bhoird anseo agus chomh maith céanna obair a rinne an Chomhairle um Oideachas Gaeltachta agus Gaelscolaíochta, COGG, na feisirí Eorpacha iad féin agus gan dabht Conradh na Gaeilge.
Faoi mar a bhaineann sé, tá roinnt ráite mar gheall ar na hinniúlachtaí teanga atá ag teastáil go deimhin ag leibhéal Eorpach. Tuigimid, agus tuigeann formhór na ndaoine a bhfuil spéis acu i gcúrsaí Eorpacha, go bhfuil an t-iolrachas agus an t-ilteangachas mar chuspóir bunaigh na hEorpa agus na gluaiseachta trí chéile. Is cinnte, mar a dúradh níos túisce ansin, gur cheart an móiminteam ag leibhéal na hEorpa a choimeád chun go mbeadh an líon foirne ann agus daoine atá inniúil sa Ghaelainn agus leis na hardscileanna sin ar fáil chun a bheith ag saothrú sna róil san.
Ag an mbaile, má táimid ag caint ar chúrsaí agus scileanna teanga ach go háirithe, tá fadhb an-mhór ann mar gheall ar sholáthar Gaelainne agus ar sholáthar scileanna teanga taobh istigh dár gcóras oideachais féin. Táim cinnte go bhfuil baill an choiste ar an eolas mar gheall ar an líon díolúintí atá bronnta anois ar scoláirí agus iad sa dara leibhéal. Tá suas le 20% go 25% de dhaltaí reatha atá ag tabhairt faoin ardteist nó faoin teastas sóisearach ag fáil díolúine ó staidéar a dhéanamh ar an nGaelainn. Is ceist phráinneach í sin má táimid ag cuimhneamh ar dhaoine a chur faoi oiliúint chun go mbeadh daoine inniúil sa Ghaelainn ag dul isteach go dtí na poist seo agus ag dul ar aghaidh. Chomh maith céanna, caithfear an méid atá ráite mar gheall ar na poist iontacha atá ar fáil i dtaobh na hateangaireachta de, agus na profléitheoirí, na cúntóirí, na haistritheoirí, agus na gníomhairí idirchultúrtha ach go háirithe ag leibhéal na hEorpa, a aithint.
Chomh maith leis sin, tá sé fíor-spéisiúil na daoine a chuaigh ann deich mbliana nó 15 bliain ó shin a fheiscint ag leibhéal i bhfad níos sinsearaí sna hinstitiúidí difriúla. Mar a dúradh ó chianaibh, b'fhéidir go dtosnaíonn daoine isteach agus déanann siad an cúpla mí de scoláireacht Rialtas na hÉireann gur féidir a dhéanamh ag luí isteach ar aistriúcháin, agus deich mbliana nó 15 bliain níos déanaí feicimid iad ag leibhéal i bhfad níos sinsearaí, b'fhéidir i ról nach mbaineann go sonrach le cúrsaí teanga. Gan dabht, tá an teanga, an t-ilteangachas agus na teangacha éagsúla mar - nílim chun "sméar mullaigh" a rá - rud iontach tarraingteach dóibh siúd agus iad ag feidhmiú ar leibhéal Eorpach. B'fhéidir go dtugann sé sin ábhairín comhthéacs ar an dá cheist faoi mar a bhaineann siad le cúrsaí teanga ach go háirithe.
Comment on this
Ar an ábhar céanna, bhí mé ag gearán sa Dáil aréir nach raibh leagan Gaeilge den mBille Airgeadais ar fáil agus nach bhfuil leagan Gaeilge den Acht Airgeadais ar fáil do 2025, 2024, nó 2023 ach oiread. Má táimid ag iarraidh a rá le daoine a bhfuil suim acu aistriúchán a dhéanamh dul go dtí an Eoraip agus na hinstitiúidí Eorpacha, an bhfuilimid ag cur brú ag an am céanna ar na hinstitiúidí sa bhaile, go háirithe san Oireachtas, le daoine a earcú leis na postanna sin a dhéanamh?
Comment on this
Díreach ó bheith ag caint le daoine agus ón aithne atá agam ar dhaoine, téann an dá rud lámh i lámh le chéile. Is trua é nach bhfuil níos mó poist i dTithe an Oireachtais, mar shampla, nó neadaithe sa chleachtas ag an baile. Tá aithne agam ar dhaoine atá ag iarraidh filleadh ón gCoimisiún Eorpach nó Parlaimint na hEorpa agus ní féidir leo obair aistriúcháin a fháil. Cé gur mhaith le daoine a leithéid a dhéanamh, níl sé ar fáil go flúirseach nó chomh mór céanna agus bíonn ar roinnt acu bheith ag obair le comhlachtaí príobháideacha nó ag saor aistriú nó pé rud é. Mar sin, tá bearna, mar a fheicimid é pé scéal é, sa chleachtas dátheangach sa Stát seo agus ní hé seo an chéad uair dúinn á rá sin. Is rud é a chabhródh go mór le stádas na Gaelainne trí chéile ag an baile, go háitiúil sna ceantair Ghaeltachta, agus ar Mhór-Roinn na hEorpa ach go háirithe. Tá sé suntasach go bhfuil díréir chomh mór sin idir an stádas atá ag an Ghaelainn sna hinstitiúidí Eorpacha agus atá aici sa tír seo.
Comment on this
Maidir le hÉireannaigh ag úsáid na Gaeilge, go háirithe daoine tofa i bParlaimint na hEorpa agus in áiteanna eile, an úsáideann siad an Ghaeilge an t-am ar fad nó cé a úsáideann í? Tá fhios againn go raibh fístéip ag dul timpeall cúpla seachtain ó shin d'fheisirí de Pharlaimint na hEorpa ag gearán nach raibh ateangaire ar fáil agus ansin nuair a bhí sí ar fáil nach raibh sí réidh Gaeilge a labhairt. An ndéanann sé sin dochar do stádas na Gaeilge? Tá a fhios againn gurb í an teanga is lú a labhraítear ó thaobh teangacha oifigiúla. An bhfuil sé mar thuairim ag daoine san Eoraip go bhfuil an Ghaeilge ann ach nár cheart di bheith ann? An bhfuil aon amhras faoi stádas na Gaeilge mar theanga oifigiúil?
Comment on this
Ar an ábhar céanna, bhíomar ag plé le feisirí Eorpacha sa Bhruiséil ag tús na bliana ach go háirithe agus sinn ag caint ar an maolú beag atá fágtha ar úsáid na Gaelainne sa Pharlaimint toisc nach bhfuil a dhóthain ateangairí agus aistritheoirí earcaithe ag an bpointe seo. Is dóigh liom go bhfuil siad ag brath ar an mBéarla - táim cinnte go bhfuil cúpla duine sa seomra níos eolaí ar an ábhar seo ná mise – chun ateangaireacht a dhéanamh ag na seisiúin pléadálacha ag Strasbourg uair sa mhí mar shampla. Mar sin, ón uair gur thosnaigh ár nUachtarántacht ar Chomhairle an tAontas Eorpaigh i mí Iúil, tá lámhleabhar iontach curtha le chéile ar úsáid na Gaelainne taobh istigh den tír seo bunaithe ar conas agus cathain gur féidir agus gur chóir an Ghaelainn a úsáid. Tá moladh mór tuillte ag an Roinn gnóthaí eachtracha agus Roinn na Gaeltachta ina thaobh sin. Mar sin, tá an deachleachtas sin le húsáid agus le tógaint. Tar éis na hUachtaránachta, tá sé sin le cur i gcleachtas go mór agus tá sé le cinntiú go mbeidh na bunrudaí déanta. Mar a dúradh, tá gach cuid de na píosaí reachtaíochta le bheith aistrithe go Gaelainn go comhuaineach. Gan dabht, sa Bhunreacht, tá i gcónaí forlámhas ag an nGaelainn ar na leaganacha Béarla den Bhunreacht nó de na píosaí reachtaíochta a théann trí Thithe an Oireachtais.
Mar sin, tá fíorthábhacht ag baint leo a bheith curtha amach go comhuaineach agus ar ardchaighdeán. Tá an obair sin ar fad le déanamh. Maidir leis an gcás áirithe a thagair an Cathaoirleach chuige, b'fhéidir nach raibh an duine ullamh nó pé rud é - glacaim leis sin - ach ní dóigh liom go ndéanfann sé díobháil má tá daoine ag cloisteáil go bhfuil iarrachtaí déanta ag feisirí Eorpacha. Feicim le bliain anuas an oiread daoine atá ag iarraidh an teanga a úsáid-----
Comment on this
Tá sé deacair agus tá sé iontach go bhfuil daoine réidh iarracht a dhéanamh an Ghaeilge a úsáid.
Comment on this
Nílim ag cur isteach uirthi ar chor ar bith. Does Deputy Butterly wish to come in again? No. Mr. Power said that Ireland has the highest number of seconded experts per capita, which is, on the one hand, wonderful to hear but I wonder if it is indicative of another issue. Why are so many experts seconded and not working full-time within the institutions? There may be a clear explanation for that but I am just wondering.
Comment on this
It is to give them an awareness or familiarisation with the workings of the institution to which they are seconded. It seems a big investment by the home Government but it is one that works quite well because sometimes they are entitled to sit exams to convert the post into a permanent position. We should encourage more of this. It is costly in terms of the Irish Government but it is well worth the investment if, down the road, they convert into officials.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Power have any idea how many of them are taking the decision to do the exams and transfer permanently?
Comment on this
I do not but I could hazard a guess it is at least 50%.
Comment on this
One of the things we as a committee have found when we have visited institutions is that Ireland has punched above its weight in terms of people working in the institutions. We all recognise they are not working for Ireland but for the institution or for Europe as a whole. It is important that they are there and that the Irish voice is heard around the table. Many of those people are now reaching retirement and it appears that in that middle section – I heard what people said about the under-40s, in particular, and that is great to hear - we are behind where we should be.
Comment on this
The middle section is the weakness in the system. Approximately 23% of the AD officials will retire between now and 2029. This is a considerably higher percentage than the average, which is approximately 17%. This is a problem that has some focus and will be rectified in due course but it leaves us with an immediate gap.
Comment on this
I am slightly over time but I am going to keep going. It was said to us on a travel episode we had earlier this year that other European Union member states are better at the information and preparation bit for people looking for jobs in European institutions. I understand that Italy, for example, performs particularly well and has a separate institution for preparing people, letting them know what jobs are available and what the criteria for those jobs are, giving them information about what the renumeration package involves and, as I said at the start, providing them with expertise, advice and support in the application and interview process. Mention was made by EMI of some of that going on, but at an official level, should we in Ireland be looking at producing an institution or body that has that sole focus? Would that help us to reach a greater penetration of Irish people in institutions in Europe?
Comment on this
The answer to that must be "Yes". There is a €4 million funding investment from the Government for this. An all-embracing preparation is required in terms of the headlines the Cathaoirleach has outlined. It is a specialisation that will be rewarded in due course. It is new to the system here. The Government is focused and will deliver on it.
Comment on this
I agree with the Cathaoirleach that there needs to be more support. So far, the A Career for EU strategy has made some progress in the support available for applicants. I know from my time working on the education side of European Movement Ireland that we were made aware in February of a webinar provided by the Department of foreign affairs on the EU generalist administrative competition, AD5, in the European Commission.
This gave applicants a general overview of the AD5 competition and its wider strategic importance for Ireland. It provided a detailed explanation of the eligibility requirements and competition stages, as well as a presentation on the specific supports available to Irish citizens and a general question-and-answer session. Some of those specific supports included guidance packs which you could send off to the Department on an email to receive PowerPoint presentations, videos and lots of different kinds of supports. While I agree there is a lot more work to be done in that sense, much progress has been made since 2021 when the A Career for EU strategy was introduced.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Moffat for that. Before I go to Deputy Butterly, I have one other thing to ask. Is there any single point for information across all the institutions, the Parliament and the bodies on what jobs or career opportunities are available? EMI has done a lot of work with the booklet and all the rest, and I praise it for that, but is there an official single point of information? Sorry, I cut Mr. Geary off there.
Comment on this
Not at all. I was just going to talk about the work we do around the Green Book, but I think the Cathaoirleach's question is looking for a different resource. I am very happy to take any questions on the Green Book itself.
Comment on this
I am sorry. I recognise what EMI has done and we will come back to that. Is there not one single point?
Comment on this
In the Parliament, we always guide people towards the European Personnel Selection Office, EPSO, page where the main competitions are held. There are other opportunities, such as traineeships and contract positions, but competitions are all on the EPSO page. There are official competitions there, so we always direct people to check that out. There was a competition announced today in the Official Journal for lawyer-linguists for eight languages, including Irish. That is currently open and is in the Official Journal. We encourage people to check out the EPSO page.
Comment on this
The European Commission launched a revamped careers website recently, so I think that is a point of access at this stage.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Power think EPSO, the Parliament and the Commission could come together in one single place? Is that a reasonable suggestion?
Comment on this
I reiterate the point on an institute for public administration, be it postgraduate or a business school. I have seen it in action. For example, in New York there is a business school for public administration. The Chair might have also alluded to the Bocconi in Italy where once upon a time, it was famous for giving you all the information for state jobs. Now, the focus is very much on European jobs. I support any call to the Minister for higher education to introduce a specific institute for public administration, not just for European jobs but also for all the other international institutes where I believe Ireland could have a very positive voice and influence on what is a very challenging world at this moment in time. Mr. Power said it would be useful to have an institute like that.
Comment on this
I confirm that I fully agree with what the Deputy has said. It is important.
Comment on this
It is a very sensible suggestion because it benefits us to have those Irish voices heard in the international context. Even if they are not advocating for us, having the perspective of Ireland at the table is very important.
Comment on this
We touched beforehand on the point that it is not just about politics. I had the pleasure of going to the business school for public administration in New York. It was incredible to see what was being done in terms of life sciences and the environment, especially the project post Hurricane Katrina and how all these new courses and research projects were being put into practice and helping to inform social and government policy. This could be rolled out at European and global level afterwards.
Comment on this
My sincere apologies for only arriving at this stage. There is a lot of conflicting schedules going on today. I had the opportunity to read some of the opening statements. I have to say I was very impressed with the level of work going on; it was further than I had anticipated. I have two or three points to make. I support Deputy Butterly's proposal.
The point is well made in the opening statement that if a young person is interested in a job in Europe, there are avenues for them to take. It is a question of reaching the other cohort of young people who are looking at their future, and who may be at the point of leaving school or at the postgraduate stage, and how we can spread the message to them.
I have often heard of the Green Book, although I have never seen it. Is it readily available? Is it something that, for example, the members of the committee could get a copy of? That would be interesting. I remember being in Brussels when my cousin was doing the stage many years ago, and the Green Book was revered. It was the envy of many other European students and people who were doing the stage there.
I have two questions. With regard to the College of Europe, there are three campuses at Bruges, Natolin and Tirana. How many Irish people have had the opportunity to go to those colleges? How many Irish graduates subsequently got jobs within the European institutions? Looking at future skills, we know that languages are very important. Are there other areas that the witnesses feel are important to those leaving school next September? Is there a focus that the Irish Government can put on education that will give greater opportunities to students?
Comment on this
The Green Book is freely and publicly available. We will be sure to provide that to all members of the EU affairs committee on a regular basis as we update it. To provide some context, it is about 80 pages. We try to pull together all of the relevant resources that people will need to look at that pathway towards taking the first step into Europe. It should be noted that we have got rid of a lot of things in order to keep a really tight focus. We are also cognisant of the facts regarding attention spans, AI and everything else, so it is about trying to keep it as focused as possible. We try to connect the Green Book, which has a huge number of resources.
My colleague mentioned some of the guidance that we provide for Europass and everything else, alongside the jobs list that we provide. We try to track all of these opportunities and jobs that are coming up along with the careers fairs, EU clinics and jobs clinics that we do as well. Twice a year, we convene what we call Brussels Connection in Brussels. We had one event on Monday of this week, which was hosted in the permanent representation with the president of the EESC, Séamus Boland, another Irishman in a leadership role in the institutions, with about 120 Irish people in attendance. While it is predominantly younger people starting traineeships, stagiaires or those who are very new to Brussels or the institutions, there is also a real mix, and senior staff from the different institutions were present as well. We try to organise these to bring together as large a group as we can, because alongside all the information that we provide, we know the Irish network is also an important guide for people to navigate their first few months and years in Brussels as they find their feet.
It is absolutely a resource. We keep it under regular review and take feedback on it. When we do EU clinics or have conversations at career fairs, colleagues take note of where the lines of confusion are and the questions that people have. We try to address those, not just in the Green Book, but through targeted social media activity year-round.
Comment on this
I will come in on the College of Europe question from the Senator. As the European Movement Ireland, we are the body that is responsible for administering the College of Europe admissions process. We do not interview the candidates, guide the candidates or anything like that, so we do not provide support in that way. That is done by the college and by the Irish selection committee, which is made up of a number of academics from universities around the country.
On the question of how many Irish students go from the College of Europe directly into a job in one of the European institutions, I do not have that data to hand but I can look it up and get back to the Deputy. In the past three or four years we have had an average of 12 or 13 Irish students attending the College of Europe every year. Each year there are six scholarships available from the Department of further and higher education and one from the Department of foreign affairs. In the past couple of years we have split up these seven scholarships to try to give opportunities to as many Irish students as possible to go to the college. We also make sure that we directly promote the College of Europe as an opportunity. We do social media posts and mail-outs to university career services, etc., to advise when the application process is opening for the College of Europe. That is on all the campuses as well, so we try to make that as broad as possible. That is the extent of our role with the College of Europe process. The college is well regarded among the European institutions, as far as I am aware. Some colleagues can speak more about that from their own experience. It is a very highly regarded institution in terms of going on to a career in the EU following that.
Comment on this
In terms of people going from Bruges to Brussels, the percentage is pretty high. It is seen as an excellent training ground for young diplomats. It is worth acknowledging that the Government provides five fellowships for internships in international organisations through the Saothar Iveagh Fellowship Programme. That is to add to what Mr. Moffat said about the scholarships, and I think it is an important point.
Comment on this
It is a uniform format for CVs that is recognised across all of the European institutions, as far as I am aware. Colleagues can correct me on that if I am wrong, but I believe that is the case. It is an efficiency tool to make sure that as many applications as possible can be looked at quickly, in the same format, to make sure all the candidate's key information is there. It is a standardised practice that we provide guidance on through the Green Book, as we have mentioned previously.
Comment on this
Thanks. I have two questions and then I will go to Deputy Seán Crowe. Ms Croker mentioned that the EPLO writes out to all the schools about the programme, the exact name of which escapes me. What is the percentage level of take-up for this?
Comment on this
The highest number we have had has been 85 but it is generally over 80 schools.
Comment on this
It is but it is not our only engagement with schools.
Comment on this
I understand. I do not want to say it is a low take-up but why does Ms Croker think there is not a higher take-up?
Comment on this
It would require a certain level of commitment from within the school as well. There is usually a teacher who is very enthusiastic about the programme. However, I would point out that very few schools drop off from the programme. Once they are in, they tend to stay.
Comment on this
My final question relates to the English language. We were described as the only remaining European native speakers, but obviously English is an official language in Malta. One of the things that frustrates me when I am in European institutions and I hear announcements, whether it is in the lift or over a tannoy or whatever, it is more often than not an English accent, first of all, and sometimes it is even an American accent. The standardisation of English at European level does not appear to accord with what we would consider to be standard English. Is there any institution that is making an effort to acknowledge the fact that we are the leaders in terms of English-language use in Europe? I know it is a lingua franca, along with French, for probably most people working in many institutions. Is there any move towards having a situation where we promote the use of Irish accents instead of other English-language accents?
Comment on this
In the Parliament, in terms of our promotional material, we make sure there is a version with an Irish-accented voiceover on any social media videos we put out.
Comment on this
Ó thaobh Conradh na Gaeilge de, bhí sé go hiontach Gaeilge na Mumhan a chloisteáil sa choiste, fiú nach Béarla ach Gaeilge a bhí ann. Ar aon nós, gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe.
Comment on this
Tá brón orm, I was speaking in the Dáil and I am possibly going to ask questions that were already asked, so I hope witnesses will bear with me.
At the beginning of the conversation there was a discussion in terms of the number of schools being sent educational materials. I think a figure of 400 was mentioned and someone else talked about 80 schools. What are the criteria for identifying those schools? A point was made by someone about the number of schools we have in Ireland in relation to this. What are the criteria for identifying these schools? Is it because they are close to the office?
Language skills have been identified as a crucial barrier to careers in the European institutions. Is this something we can overcome or is it baked in as a consequence of our education system, where young people generally study three languages - English, Irish and one other language, possibly French or maybe German? The witnesses mentioned the number of official languages there are in the EU. What are the challenges around that?
We lack the geographical proximity of some of our European neighbours, where speaking other languages can be essential to everyday life if one lives in a border area, such as the French-Italian border. In Belgium, for example, a child could be taught in German, French, Flemish or maybe English. Does this hinder our language developing to the fluency required to succeed in competitions for EU careers? It would be difficult to adapt our education system.
Following that, in our education system we have university courses that are more suited to EU careers. What degrees are most suited, and do we have enough places? I do not know if that was already asked. Politics degrees are rare outside of certain universities and the National University of Ireland jumps to mind. EU politics and EU law tend to be taught as modules rather than full degrees. Is that a hindrance in relation to this?
The growth of TG4 and the industry around that has helped Irish-language speakers. The recognition of the Irish language has in itself encouraged more and more people. What are the challenges? Are they the same as the challenges that exist for English speakers going into the European Union? I am asking particularly about the small group of languages that seem to be taught at university level. Is that one of the big challenges, similar to those going to an English-speaking school?
Comment on this
There is a growing awareness of things European and the importance of things European throughout the country and throughout the education system. We saw that with the circular economy legislation that was adopted in Brussels. Schools are now looking at that as a module. This growing awareness of Europe and its importance is included in the content of some degrees. That is a process that will continue to develop and is one that should be encouraged. People have a growing awareness of the importance of languages and the need to learn languages. I came back from Brussels last year after 35 years, and I noticed that the focus on Irish is completely different. It is much more significant than it was before I left. So, I think the language has developed as well. The importance of the European Union, as the source of 80% of our legislation, is driving a market that is putting a greater emphasis on the need to step up to the mark and improve our knowledge of things European, such as European legislation.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the question. It is right to focus on education. That is an important area of focus. We deliver the Blue Star programme on behalf of the Government. We have been doing it for 16 years. We are currently working with schools all over the country to sign up for that programme. Given it is the year of the Presidency, we feel it is an important programme for schools to come into. The reason I am mentioning that programme is that we think it is really important that Europe is introduced at an earlier age and that children get to learn what an MEP is and what the different institutions do. We have a steering group where we work with colleagues in the EPLO, the European Commission's permanent representation and the Departments of education, foreign affairs and the Taoiseach. It is important that we start that conversation as early as possible. We are aware that modern foreign languages are being rolled out at primary level now. Over a longer period, the hope is that we can connect those two things - people having an interest or passion in travelling around Europe and working in Europe; and sticking with and learning the languages - because this will ultimately make Ireland much more competitive in this space.
In terms of the point about languages, for anybody who is involved in European affairs, invariably there are times when we meet people who do not have languages and still have an interest in working for the institutions or working in proximity to the institutions, in trade associations and in different areas. We try to guide people where we can based on the skills. The motivation is there to learn languages because that is where they want their career to develop. It can be a surprising motivation as well.
The final point I will make is that I agree that we are seeing a renewed passion and interest in the Irish language. That is manifesting itself in a lot of the conversations we are having around careers and the EU, particularly around the recognition for the language and some of the proponents that have led some of that campaign work and advocacy at a European stage. As an organisation, we are increasingly trying to engage with Gaelscoileanna early in the Blue Star programme and start that conversation there. We are also trying to promote that activity and the use of the Irish language. I refer, for example, to when the Minister of State, Deputy Byrne, spoke in Irish at the opening ceremony of the Irish Presidency. We try to highlight those moments wherever we can in our public-facing work.
Comment on this
On the subject of Irish, there has been a huge increase in the amount of Irish spoken within the Parliament. It is far from the case that it is only linguists who speak Irish among themselves and with colleagues.
I have already spoken about the European Parliament ambassador schools programme, under which over 80 schools follow a full-year programme. That is far from the only outreach for schools. We have different competitions and opportunities for school students to visit Strasbourg and Brussels.
For two years now, the Europa Experience has been open. In the coming months, we expect to have received up to 100,000 visitors. A huge proportion of those would be secondary school students. We have engaged in strategic targeted advertising. It is our aim that every second level teacher in the country knows that it is available to them as a facility to visit. It is free of charge and educational. It includes a 360-degree cinema, a gallery and interactive stations that inform visitors about the European Union. It also includes a roleplay game which is available to all groups. We notice that there is a huge amount of interest among secondary school students in the roleplay game. It is available for up to 30 participants. Each participant takes on the role of a Member of the European Parliament. They discuss and negotiate the passage of legislation through the Parliament. The end result is legislation. We have recently increased the available sessions from six per week to nine because of demand. We are looking at increasing them again in the new year. It is our aim that every school in the country knows about it and has the opportunity to visit.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis an Teachta as na ceisteanna.
Tógfaidh mé le chéile iad - an córas oideachais agus luach na dteangacha san éiceachóras nua atá taobh thiar den Ghaelainn, mar a dúirt Peter Power, agus cúrsaí ollscolaíochta. Tagraíodh níos túisce don chóras oideachais reatha agus an fhaillí atá déanta taobh istigh den chóras oideachais ar mhúineadh na Gaelainne. Lena theannta sin, tá ganntanas an-mhór de Ghaelscoileanna agus Gaelcholáistí sa tír seo, a ídíonn an líon daoine a bheadh ábalta dul ar aghaidh agus poist ag leibhéal C1 nó C2 a sholáthar ar mhaithe leis an Aontas Eorpach agus na hinstitiúidí.
Fiú ag féachaint ar chúrsaí ollscoile chomh maith, tá feachtas ann faoi láthair dar teideal Gaelollscolaíocht. Is éileamh é seo atá ag teacht ó na mic léinn iad féin chun go mbeadh níos mó cúrsaí nach mbaineann leis an nGaelainn í féin ach múinte trí mheán na Gaelainne. D'fhéadfaí a bheith ag tabhairt faoin ngnó, polaitíocht, leigheas nó pé rud é, ach go mbeadh teagasc an chúrsa trí mheán na Gaelainne. Faoi láthair, níl ach 0.67% de chúrsaí ollscoile na tíre seo múinte trí mheán na Gaelainne. Caithfear an céatadán sin a ardú má táimid le bheith iomaíoch ag aon leibhéal i gcomparáid le tíortha eile. Níl sé indéanta a bheith á gcur sinn féin i gcomparáid le tíortha móra ar nós na Fraince nó na Gearmáine nuair is é sin an cumasú atá á dhéanamh againn ar scoláirí agus ar dhaltaí na tíre seo.
Ag féachaint air sin chomh maith, ba chóir go mbeadh modúl ar fáil do dhaoine atá sna hinstitiúidí tríú leibhéal nuair atá tú ag cuimhneamh ar rochtain a bheith acu ar chúrsa Gaelainne saor in aisce mar chuid den chéim nó go bhféadfaidís cúrsa teanga a dhéanamh. Sa Bhreatain Bheag, mar shampla, tá cúrsaí saor in aisce ar fáil sa Bhreatnais do gach duine sa tír sin idir 18 agus 25 bliain d'aois. Tá dea-chleachtas iontach ann a chabhródh go mór leis an gcumasú a bheadh déanta ar chúrsaí teangacha sa tír seo chomh maith céanna. Tá sé cruthaithe arís agus arís eile don té a bhfuil Gaelainn agus Béarla acu, is mó seans go mbeadh Fraincis, Spáinnis, Iodáilis agus araile ar a dtoil acu. Mar sin, dá mhéid agus a dhéanfaimid infheistiú sa chóras oideachais inmheánach, is mó an toradh go bhfeicfimid é ag leibhéal na hEorpa. Aontaím le gach rud atá ráite ag mo chomhghleacaithe anseo faoi mar a bhaineann sé le cúrsaí teanga.
Comment on this
Muna bhfuil aon rud eile le rá ag aon duine, cuirfidh mé deireadh leis an seisiún. Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe go léir as ucht a gcuid ama a thabhairt dúinn inniu agus a saineolaíocht maidir leis an méid atá ráite acu go léir. I thank the witnesses for their time, the perspectives and the expertise they have shared with us today. It is appreciated. We will suspend for a few minutes and then go into private session. Is that agreed? Agreed.