We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on European Union Affairs

EU Response to the Ongoing Situation in Palestine and Related Matters: UN Special Rapporteur on Palestine

Summary

UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese said the violence and displacement of Palestinians continued despite the ceasefire and argued that states must act on international court findings rather than wait for final judgments. She urged Ireland to press for suspension of the EU-Israel Association Agreement and, if necessary, act unilaterally, while ending arms and dual-use transfers and reviewing trade, research funding and technology links. She also criticised settler violence, the proposed Board of Peace and barriers facing Gazan students seeking Irish visas, and called for accountability and humanitarian aid grounded in Palestinian self-determination. Members broadly challenged the EU’s response and raised Ireland’s responsibilities; no committee decision was recorded.

Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Welcome back. We are now going to the second item on the agenda, which is the EU response to the ongoing situation in Palestine and related matters, including the EU-Israel Association Agreement and matters concerning humanitarian aid and assistance. It is my great honour to welcome to the committee the United Nations special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territory occupied since 1967, Ms Francesca Albanese. I have a little formality to go through and then I will call her to speak. There are a number of people in the Public Gallery. They are also welcome.

Our consideration will include Europe's obligations under international law, the current operation of the EU-Israel Association Agreement and its implementation, Europe's response to the International Court of Justice's July 2024 advisory opinion, and the need for accountability through international mechanisms. Central to this are sanctions applied by the US Administration and the potential use of the blocking statute as a tool to address these. Further, the role that Ireland could play as it holds the Presidency of the Council of the European and in the future is also important.

Before we begin, I am obliged to read a privilege notice. Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is important that they do so.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.

We are joined online by one member, so I remind him that he must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex to participate in public meetings and may not participate if he is not adhering to that constitutional requirement.

Any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. Before anybody online makes a contribution, I ask them to confirm where they are.

We are going to have an opening statement from Ms Albanese. She will have five minutes to make her opening statement, then we will have contributions from members. I thank Ms Albanese very much.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I thank the Chair and distinguished members of the committee very much for inviting me today at this critical moment for Palestine, international law, the European Ireland and Ireland as it holds the Presidency of the Council of the European Union. Next week, Dublin will welcome European leaders for the European Political Community Summit and an informal meeting of European Heads of State and Government. This is an historic opportunity for Ireland to demonstrate that its commitment to international law is precisely what this dark moment demands - principled leadership, rooted in European values, capable of defending the environment and all living beings against the scourges of war, exploitation, oppression and repression. This is what we are all up against and this why the leadership of Ireland matters.

I address the committee as a special rapporteur in occupied Palestinian territory while the US sanctions unjustly imposed on me and on a number of legal experts, including the International Criminal Court, ICC, for carrying out our mandate remain in force. In my case, it is against me, my family and my children. I still need to stay focused on the situation in the occupied Palestinian territory. The genocide continues despite the so-called ceasefire. In Gaza, the population remains confined in one third - I beg the committee to listen to me as we are speaking of human beings - of the land that was already the most crowded place on earth hosts 1.8 million people in depleted tents as the fourth winter, during time of genocide, is arriving. Seven out of ten families are attacked by rodents per day amid continuous bombardment. During the ceasefire, Israel has killed 1,500 people, which brings the death count of certain victims of this assault to 74,000. A total of 74,000 people have been slaughtered and 80% are women and children. Israel has killed 21,000 children.

We begin to get sort of numbed by the statistics, but these are people and lives shattered. These are dreams that are gone forever. Now, the funding shortages are further undermining the humanitarian response. For me, this is not a humanitarian crisis; this is a political catastrophe that should have been prevented. If Israel had been held accountable once, we would not be here. However, there are also humanitarian consequences. Proposals for external imposed governance through the so-called board of peace strike at the very heart of Palestinian's inalienable right for self-determination. Even in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, the space for Palestinian life continues to shrink. Israel has set up 1,000 checkpoints in the past year and a half. In Masafer Yatta, it continues to demolish people's homes forcing them into caves. In Hebron, it has kicked out 3,000 people from an already besieged city. All of this is not happening in a vacuum. This represents the extreme stage of a long-standing settler colonial process of this dispossession, planned and carried out with full knowledge and intent, through every layer of the Israeli state apparatus. This is why I challenge everyone saying, "Oh, this is Netanyahu's responsibility." Netanyahu is still part of the political establishment because as Daniel Levy, an authoritative Israeli commentator, said Netanyahu embodies the spirit of a large part of Israel.

International justice mechanisms, including the ICC and the International Court of Justice, ICJ, and the international human rights system have been unequivocal in their findings about Israel's crimes and have stood firm despite enormous political pressure. Still, the test is whether states are willing to act on their findings. My visit to Ireland comes at a critical moment because over the past three years the United States and Israel have been allowed to cannibalise international law seeking to replace the rule of law with the rule of lawlessness. What happens in Palestine - trust me - will not stay in Palestine. I predicted that in March 2024 and five months later the destruction of Lebanon had started. I spoke with Ireland's Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade who could confirm how the far the destruction of southern Lebanon has gone. Again, this is not going to stay within the region. Palestine has become the revealer of a system with Palestinian people enduring the most brutal consequences. Senior Israeli leaders have articulated their intentions to ethnically cleanse what remains of Palestine and they are eager to commit any crime as needed - genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity - unless they are blocked. There is no way out to stop the slaughter unless Israel is held accountable.

Regarding Europe's responsibility, expressions of concern over the other deteriorating situation in Palestine or over the US sanctions against me and the ICC ring hollow while European states continue to provide apartheid Israel with political, military and diplomatic support and bend to US pressure. The International Court of Justice ordered provisional measures in the genocide in January 2024. These obliges not to aid and assist a state which might commit genocide. Six months later, the court recognised the presence of Israel in Gaza, West Bank and East Jerusalem as unlawful, totally and unconditionally to be dismantled. The other legal thing that Israel can do is to withdraw the troops, dismantle the settlements and stop exploiting Palestinian natural resources, such as maritime and ground resources, etc. In the face of this, Ireland as well as the rest of the European Union is obliged not to aid and assist the unlawful occupation. I appreciate the occupied territory Bill that Ireland has finally adopted, but it is too little too late. In fact, settlement goods trade is a small - almost invisible portion - of the volume of trade that Ireland has with Israel. I was shocked to learn that Ireland was the first trading partner of Israel in Europe. I did not know. The disconnect between people's sentiment against apartheid Israel and what the Government is authorising this country to do is incredible. This is symptomatic of a tendency in the European Union to continuously condemn while acting in the opposite way when it comes to concrete conduct. Ireland has long defended Palestinian rights, international law and multilateralism, particularly the multinational human rights system. It is not too late to use the Presidency of the Council of the European Union to turn this commitment seriously into actions.

What does it require? On suspending the EU-Israel Association Agreement, that the European Union has some states blocking the suspension does not absolve Ireland and other states from their obligations under international law. If the EU does not follow suit, Ireland will probably have to consider doing that on its own, as I am recommending, together with others and with Spain. Second is taking concrete measures against Israel's unlawful occupation in its entirety. There is no bad Israel in the settlements and good Israel outside of the settlements. The settlements are the State of Israel's enterprise. Its annexation of territory and it is an aggression against the Palestinian people. What are we waiting for to stop our engagement with apartheid Israel? Third, championing an end to military assistance, arms transfers and co-operation that risk enabling international law violations. Again, I was shocked to learn that this country and Government authorised the transfer of a significant amount of tech equipment, not to Israel or Israeli companies, but to the Israeli army at the height of the genocide in 2023 and 2024.

Ensuring humanitarian assistance and reconstruction is important but it cannot be detached from the political process. That process must start with abiding by international law and preferring that, as a mantra, to the two-state solution. The two-state solution is not a condition for Palestinians to enjoy self-determination. As the International Court of Justice has stated, self-determination comes first, regardless of the negotiation process.

Ireland has previously stood on the right side of history. Its people helped to lead the struggle against South African apartheid and in 1987, Ireland became the first western country to ban South African imports. Today, Ireland has an opportunity to show equally needed leadership, to stand on the right side of history once again and to help Europe recover its moral and legal compass.

Our responsibility is not just to express solidarity but to act accordingly, not as an act of charity towards Palestinians, but as an act of self-preservation for all of us and for the rule of law itself.

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Ms Albanese. The first member indicating is Deputy Boyd Barrett, who is welcome to the committee. There will be a five-minute slot for questions and answers. We are very egalitarian here, even though the Deputy might not normally be here.

Comment on this

The Deputy had his hand up first, so away he goes.

Comment on this

I assumed that committee members would go first. I thank the Chair. I thank Ms Albanese for her brave work on behalf of the Palestinians and human rights.

We talked earlier at the briefing in the audiovisual room about the fact that European leaders from the EU and other European countries were coming to Dublin next week as part of Ireland's EU Presidency. Some of us will be protesting against them because of the involvement of the European Union in providing impunity to Israel while it commits genocide and the EU's failure to discharge its obligations under the genocide convention and address the apartheid regime. If Ms Albanese had a message that she would like the Irish Government to convey to European leaders, what would it be?

I engaged moments ago with the Minister. There were statements in the Dáil post the European Council meeting. The Minister drew a sharp distinction between the crimes of Putin in Ukraine and European complicity in what was being done to the Palestinian people. What would Ms Albanese say to that? Many of us feel that a distinction should not be drawn. Putin has committed war crimes, but what Israel is doing is genocide. Its actions are criminal and the European Union is complicit as long as it continues to trade with that regime. Would Ms Albanese say that is true? Would she say that the European government is seriously in breach of its obligations under the genocide convention? Is that a message that the Irish Government should take to European leaders? Should we now be talking about the European Union, if it were discharging its obligations under the genocide convention, ending all trade, diplomatic and political relations with a state that is in the dock for genocide, apartheid, illegal occupation and ethnic cleansing?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I thank the Deputy. To clarify, I do not speak on behalf of the Palestinians. I speak on behalf of international law applied to the occupied Palestinian territory. I speak as a proud European. I am proud of European values. I am also proud of defending international law, which is what we need to protect ourselves and our children.

Honestly, this is a moment for sober reflection and stock-taking. We have failed. Let us be honest that we have failed the Palestinians and the Israelis, who have lost their compass completely and still need to be brought back to sanity. We have failed our own European citizens. I am sure it is not lost on the committee that many of the leaders that Irish representatives will meet next week come from countries that are responsible for shrinking the fundamental freedoms that are the pillars of the European Union, including the freedom of expression, the freedom of association and the right to express dissent peacefully. The police of European countries have beaten people and used charges of terrorism against civil society organisations. European countries have passed illiberal pieces of legislation that criminalise the criticism of the State of Israel. This is serious. It does not only speak to the failure to protect the Palestinians. It speaks about the failure to protect the rule of law as the bastion of our democracies.

Palestine is a revealer of the status of our democracies. It is serious. Leaders in this moment have a choice. Will they continue to play the old mantra that we stand by the two-state solution and support Palestinian self-determination while not lifting a finger or by being a part and parcel of what is happening? Ireland is a critical component of the lines of the complicity that the European Union maintains towards Israel. The European Union is not indifferent. It is complicit in what Israel is doing to the Palestinians, with the dispossession of Palestinians and the colonisation of what remains of Palestine. I cannot but be honest. I am risking my life and that of my family. At least let me tell the truth. I do not want all the sacrifices that I am making to be in vain. I want at least to be remembered for my integrity and for having denounced these actions. I want at least to have tried to shake people's consciences as long as we have time to do that.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Albanese for all her work and advocacy. I do not think anyone is shocked by anything she has said. It has been said many times. The problem is that it is not getting any better. When we talk about Israel and Palestine, we are talking about a genocide. If we talk about Israel, we can go back to any time from 1948 or long before that. We can talk about Dahiya doctrine. We can talk about Gadi Eisenkot. The choice is between Mr. Eisenkot and Benjamin Netanyahu. That is the choice that the Israeli state and people have put in play. I accept what Ms Albanese said about the broken Israeli moral compass.

She mentioned the South African example. Apartheid was sick and very obviously wrong to right-thinking people across the world. Look at what it took. It took a struggle by the South African people. A considerable amount related to putting pressure on the regular South Africans. They were seen as pariahs across the world. Those who intended to trade could not. Therefore, all of those people had to make a decision to change the policy of South Africa. If we are going to be real, it is about the EU-Israel Association Agreement and the fact that we are giving preferential treatment to Israel to trade with the European Union. We have our own role in that. If we are not going to get agreement with Germany, Czechia and many others, we have no choice, as Ms Albanese has said, but to go on our own. That is not even about being in support of the Palestinian people. It is about abiding by international law and removing ourselves from any level of complicity. That is what the Irish people want.

Ms Albanese has already responded to this question but I will go again. What does she expect us to do to see delivery? That is what we all have to play a role in. If Israelis feel no pain with regard to the genocide and the annexation of land, why would they stop? Why would they not continue with this?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I am glad to hear that, and I have nothing to add but one point. The Deputy is right to say that Israel has always done it. Israel has always killed children and carried out extrajudicial killings and arbitrary detentions. It has used torture and even rape. The first time rape was reported as being committed against a Palestinian was in 1948 and again in 1967. Palestinians have been raped in Israeli jails. However-----

Comment on this

This is an escalation on a huge level.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

It is abysmal and there is a destructive intent behind it. We can see that the aim is not extermination. It is not about killing them all. It is deeper. It is about destroying the people. Read the testimonies of people who have been tortured. They have been raped by dogs trained in European countries. European people are profiting from selling dogs that will rape people. This is abysmal. Instead of having a system to use our rule of law to prevent this, there are people in jail for denouncing the system while the plutocrats continue to get richer. This is why I say that what we see today is much more serious. It is telling us that the institutions and rights we have are not adequate to protect the people. Israel has turned international law on its head. Israel has made civilians killable and starvable. There is a world without civilians after the war in Gaza. This is a precedent that can only be remedied by putting an end to this impunity. Meanwhile, this has weakened the system that is supposed to protect all of us. It is either the rule of law or the rule of lawlessness.

The only things that make me hope for a change is the popular movements. We need political change and people are taking power in their hands. Sooner or later, it will happen here as well. I am saying that there is still time for Ireland to not betray its people, to say it got it wrong and to start doing the right thing right now. That in turn would inspire other people and start to regain the confidence and trust of those who look at us as a bunch of hypocrites right now.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Albanese for coming in. I was struck that she used the word "integrity". She said that she was not willing to compromise her integrity and that she and her family had been threatened. It is important to highlight that she is standing by her beliefs.

Ms Albanese mentioned all of those people who were killed. Let us call a spade a spade - they were murdered. People are being murdered, butchered and sacrificed every day, and that is clear. She is also correct to say that we have failed. We have failed collectively and globally. Frankly, it is shameful. We should suspend the EU-Israeli Association Agreement. I would go one further. We should impose full sanctions the same as we have imposed sanctions on Russia. If Ireland were to take a stand against Israel, does Ms Albanese believe that the other European countries would follow, considering where they stand at the moment?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

Ireland would have countries standing behind it. The reason is that there is something palpable, which is the Palestine effect. People, especially young people today, understand much better than many of us in my generation and older that there is a direct link with the rising cost of living in Europe and the fact that we cannot guarantee young people will get a house. People in their 30s are still living with their families, are forced to live in what someone called Soviet solutions or are sharing their living spaces with other people including, when they are professionals. They do not have enough access to an adequate health system. Culture and entertainment are being sacrificed in the name of something else. They connect it with what is happening to Palestine. They understand that there are people getting richer and richer through the destruction of the environment and our rights and possibilities. Now, young European people are forced to think of themselves going to war. They say, "Hell, no." That is why I think there will be a change.

We are craving principled leadership. How come Anwar Ibrahim, the Prime Minister of Malaysia, has become a leader for European youth? I do not know about Ireland, but in other countries I have seen the picture of Ramaphosa from South Africa and Anwar Ibrahim from Malaysia. These are the leaders that the younger generation is looking at. Why cannot we have a European leader other than Pedro Sánchez? Pedro Sánchez is the most beloved politician among European youth according to the polls. It is because he shines with integrity on the question of Palestine. What about Irish politicians? The Irish people are possibly the most anti-Israeli apartheid people in Europe. I believe that people will follow Ireland. However, I will say something. Even if Ireland were to stand alone, I would encourage it to do the right thing because this is what noble people stand for.

I do not want to make it about me, but I want to make sure that the committee understands who is speaking before it today. I am a legal expert who has been mandated to report on the occupied Palestinian territory pro bono. I am not even paid by the United Nations. I was working apart from this. I have been sanctioned by the United States. I cannot have a bank account. I cannot have private insurance. I need to check which airline or hotel I am booked with because I am often cancelled if there is a partnership with the United States. My daughter is a US citizen and is de facto banned from entering the United States because she has already committed a felony of being my daughter and therefore risks 20 years in jail and a $1 million dollar fine. My husband works for a US-based organisation. He has been threatened and demoted from his job. He was the country economist for Syria. Due to US and pro-Israel lobby groups, he has been demoted simply because he is my husband. We are being punished. We receive death threats. I receive death threats. I had people enter my home one month ago while my kids were sleeping. I know what it is to take risks. At the same time, Palestinian children are being slaughtered. These children are more important than my children or the committee members’ children. This is what humanity imposes on us. Will we realise what the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians with our money and the tech we provide them? This needs to stop. I support standing against this in the name of integrity once and for all. People will follow Ireland.

Comment on this

Ms Albanese has been critical and spoken strongly about the failure of the international community in protecting the Palestinian people. What are her views and assessment of the UN Security Council, particularly the permanent members of the Security Council? She has also been particularly critical of the US Administration. We have seen significant changes overnight to the composition of the congress. Does she think that is significant? Can it influence change in the context of the US approach to Gaza and the wider Middle East?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

Maybe it is me, but the Deputy sounds surprised that I am being critical of the US Administration. Of course, I have been critical of the US Administration because, I repeat, it is leading the cannibalisation of international law. I am not being critical of the UN Security Council, but surely the UN Security Council has failed to work for what it is mandated to do, which is to guarantee peace and security.

That is the body that needs to make decisions when it comes to peace and security, and it has failed because of internal issues. That is beside the point, however. Meanwhile, the Security Council passed UN Resolution 2803. There is agreement among scholars, other independent experts and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, OHCHR, that it crashes Palestinian self-determination. At the height of the genocide, how is it possible that the decision-making process regarding Gaza, which is completely isolated from the rest of the occupied Palestinian territory, is put in the hands of a body other than the UN itself?

In fact, this has paved the way for the undermining of the multilateral system. The US, with its current Administration, is severely jeopardising multilateralism because it does not serve its purpose any more. The United States is driving by bullying. For the past two years, every other day, we have woken up to a new absurdity, such as the proposed Gaza riviera, the colonisation of Greenland and the waging of a war of tariffs against Europe and Canada. It has infringed upon the sovereignty of other countries without any sort of restraint. We might like or dislike certain regimes but there is still the principle of sovereignty. If it does not work for Venezuela, it might not work tomorrow for Ireland. We also leave the United States free to sanction EU individuals. Today it is me, but tomorrow it might be Deputy Murphy if he does the wrong thing. This is one thing. There is too much bullying.

The United Nations has been undermined. The United States has imposed a sanction on the International Criminal Court, ICC. The question is not why the US has been critical of it but, rather, why European countries have not stood up to fully defend the United Nations and the international justice system.

However, the US is changing, thank God. Thank God there are people with a nerve who did not get intimidated and went to vote. They are changing the system from the grassroots. Of course, this takes time. Meanwhile, I am scared of what Amnesty International calls predatory elites. The problem is not with the United States as a country or a people. It is quite an equal country. The point is that the United States is the headquarters of the predatory elites. I refer to those 200 people who control the extractive industry, big tech, the military industry and the banking and finance sector. The fact that there is so much power concentrated in a few hands is a problem for all of us. The strangling of the multilateral system is a symptom of it.

Comment on this

Ms Albanese is very welcome. It is a pleasure to hear her contribution, although, obviously, it is not a pleasure to be reminded of the horrors that have occurred. I concur with Ms Albanese that genocide took place. As the International Court of Justice, ICJ, has not ruled in this regard yet, are some European countries, besides Ireland, Spain, Belgium, Netherlands and Iceland, hiding behind that fact? If the ICJ gives a ruling that, at some stage in the occupation post 7 October attacks, genocide occurred, will that force some European countries to change their tune, or will there be another reason they will not do so?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I thank the Deputy for the question. European countries and others are definitely hiding behind the judicial proceedings. This is wrong. They do not matter in this context. It does not matter whether the International Court of Justice takes one year or two years. The Genocide Convention imposes three obligations on states, including Ireland: to prevent genocide, to stop genocide and to investigate and punish genocide. If it were true that we had to wait for the conclusion of the ICJ proceedings, it would not be possible to prevent genocide. This is why South Africa was so quick at going to the ICJ because it wanted provisional measures. The fact that the court instituted the proceedings and admitted the case was a recognition of the risk of irreparable harm to the Palestinian people. This was the starting point of the obligation to prevent genocide. Clearly, we have failed to prevent it because we have not complied, as states or as the European Union, with the measures recommended by the International Court of Justice in January and May 2024. Its most recent suite of measures did not contain recommendations.

In the Nicaragua versus Germany case pending before the International Court of Justice, the court has reminded member states of their obligations not to transfer weapons and to suspend arms transfers to a state that might be committing war crimes and violations of international and humanitarian law. The threshold is very low in international law.

I have no faith in whomever has shown bad faith. To be honest, I am worried with the leadership of the European Union. I find it disconcerting that someone in the European Union, who is not even an elected leader, can take decisions that counter and fail to take into account the determination and will of sovereign countries, such as Belgium, the Netherlands, Ireland and Spain. Other countries will follow in this regard. There is a decision to protect and shelter Israel. I do not know who is behind it but I long for the day – the day will come – when Ursula von der Leyen will be investigated.

Comment on this

I wish to go back to the point about other EU countries. Hopefully, we will get a second round of questions. Germany, obviously, has its historic issues. The Danish ambassador came before the committee and talked about how Danish Jews were rescued during the Second World War. Cyprus has a close relationship with Israel. Is it not the case that some European countries are never going to go as strong as Ireland? In that context, using Ms Albanese's diplomatic hat rather than what she normally does, which is speak truth to power, what should the Irish Government do specifically next week in terms of calling for something? Is it, basically, a keynote speech calling for the suspension of the EU-Israel Association Agreement, for example, or is it calling on our European partners to show some moral courage and a backbone? What would be the most effective?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

The most effective way to encourage others to show that they have a spine is to show that we have a spine. If I were representing Ireland – I wish I could speak for my own country but it is going in the other direction - there are two things I would say. The first can be said publicly, while the other is something that must be cleared. Ireland is the first trading partner of Israel. It needs to clear that record. This is not normal.

Comment on this

That is a European Union special derogation. We cannot unilaterally-----

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

Ireland must do so.

Comment on this

-----with the exception of the occupied territories Bill-----

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

It is not that Ireland cannot. It must.

Comment on this

We should be pushing the Europeans to say that what we are doing by allowing services is illegal. Legally, however, it is the EU’s responsibility. What does Ms Albanese say to that?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

It seems that the European Union has become a joint illegal endeavour. Ireland is staying a part of it even if it leads it to commit international violations. From a legal point of view – Ireland has excellent legal experts who have said the same, so please listen to them if members do not want to listen to me - the obligation to prevent genocide and not to violate the Genocide Convention takes precedence over any other commitment. International law is not abrogated by regional agreements. The EU association agreement is forcing Ireland to violate European Union law itself because it challenges the validity of that agreement.

That agreement has an expiration condition if Israel violates human rights. Israel violated human rights when the European Union entered that agreement. Okay, we cannot correct past mistakes but at least we can decide not to persevere. If I were Ireland, I would say, "Look, we have failed the Palestinians, we have failed the Israelis and we have failed our own citizens. We are contributing with this tolerance of impunity to destroying the rule of law that with so many sacrifices we have built over 80 years. We are planting the seeds for a collapse so we need to draw a line here. Either by March the European Union suspends the preferential treatment, which is not even banning everything, it is just stopping Israel enjoying privileges in our market, or else we will stop. We will do that unilaterally." Ireland should fear the consequences of possibly being complicit with genocide and war crimes and crimes against humanity much more than breaking a contractual agreement which is not even a contract - rather, it is a commercial agreement.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Albanese for coming to the committee and addressing us. She has spoken out bravely about the EU's failure to uphold international law. She told Deputy Ó Murchú - I am paraphrasing - that the status quo has weakened us and that she is worried about European leaders.

I would like to ask about the area of foreign policy. With 27 member states with competing interests, it can be difficult to find common ground. How can we make the institutions more accountable? If some member states refuse to support sanctions against countries responsible for carrying out human rights violations, would Ms Albanese support removing the unanimity requirement and going for qualified majority voting in the medium or long term? We know how that outcome might go. Regarding EU institutions' governance, does Ms Albanese have a vision of a Europe that can protect its citizens, create economic prosperity and uphold international law? In the short term, I agree with everything Ms Albanese has said. In the longer term, what could we do to make Europe more accountable?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

To understand the kind of bias and the insufferable cherry-picking attitude member states have towards international law, consider that the International Court of Justice has declared Israel's presence in Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem illegal in its entirety. It is tantamount to aggression. Because of that, it has ordered Israel to withdraw the troops, dismantle the settlements and stop exploiting Palestinian resources. Israel continues to do that in our faces with total disregard for our principles and values. Ireland recognised the State of Palestine and Israel retaliated. Ireland passed the occupied territories Bill. Frankly, that was so much work for an outcome that now we know does very little in the face of a genocide. Ireland allowed Israel to retaliate against it. When are we going to show some spine as a European Union? The reason it does not happen is that this European Union does not serve the interests of its people. This is the Europe of the market and the banks. This is the Europe that promotes the interests of multinationals, not the interests of the people. It is going to collapse. It is just a matter of time. For God's sake, this system was not devised to lead us to heaven, but at least it has preserved us from falling into hell. Now we are nosediving into it. There is still hope we can step back but we need to be coherent.

To answer the Deputy's question in a sense, what is the way to have the European Union respect international law? Start respecting international law yourselves as a country. Lead by example because words of condemnation and wishful thinking are not enough any more. Israel will continue to destroy the Palestinian people. This is genocide in the making in the eyes and the hearts of young people, who will have just distrust towards institutions. We are planting instability for the decades to come. We are not preparing our societies to work together in a spirit of solidarity to face the challenges ahead of us - the environmental crisis and all the other issues that require sacrifice and collective thinking. This is a fundamental test. If we fail it, it will aggravate the situation for all our individual countries and as a European Union.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Albanese for her ongoing advocacy. It is inspiring and it gives other people the room to also advocate.

Ben Gvir and Smotrich are portrayed as psychopathic outliers. The reality, I feel, is that they represent or reflect Israeli society. The recent elections were really just about who will continue committing genocide. What is Ms Albanese's view of Ireland's EU Presidency? Is it having any visible impact on EU-Israel relations?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

Honestly, none. Can the Senator point to anything that has changed these relations? This is a serious thing. Until three years ago, European citizens thought of Ireland and Norway as the best friends of Palestine. Let me tell you what it boils down to. Ten percent of Norway's sovereign funds - that is, what it gets from the sale of oil and reinvests in the economy - goes into 45 businesses that are being investigated. Imagine the rest. It is more than 10% of their investment. Because my report created shock waves in the country, the Government committed to cutting ties and divesting from those businesses. When it was in Parliament, parts of the left and the right aligned to scrap even the poor ethical guidance that they had violated until then.

I do not think anyone other than Irish people and myself are aware that Ireland is the first trading partner of Israel in Europe. What are we talking about? This Government has authorised at the height of the genocide the transfers of tens of millions of euro in tech components that have gone directly to the army as it was slaughtering 150 Palestinians per day. There have been days when Israel has slaughtered 500 Palestinians, in November 2023, and 600 Palestinians, in March 2025.

If Ireland wants to leave this path of not indifference but de facto complicity, it has to change that. Guarantee us, as citizens have asked for, transparency on the aircraft that go through Shannon Airport. It is necessary to cut trade with Israel. If you do not want to do that in one go, at least announce it and suspend the preferential treatment in your territory. By being part of the European Union, you have not ceded your sovereignty. You are an independent, sovereign country with international law obligations binding on you and, through you, on the Irish people.

I encourage members, as part of the European Union, to look into the Horizon programme because it is a Trojan horse in the system. This is how we are transferring important resources for research and innovation directly into the Israeli technology, surveillance and military machine.

Israel is the number one recipient outside of Europe of Horizon funds and the second on the total count. How is it possible that Israel receives more than Ireland, Italy or Greece? A lot needs to be done.

Last but not least, I should have mentioned this first, because it is something very bad that I have learned while I have been in Ireland. Is the committee aware that dozens of Gazan students have been admitted to Irish universities because of their stellar records and their resilience - some have even received scholarships - and the Minister for justice has refused them visas because they have not been able to mail their applications to the Irish Embassy in Tel Aviv? Excuse me but what is this about? It is cruel.

Comment on this

It is ridiculous.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

It is beyond what we are talking about. It is just cruel and if it is just a bureaucratic mistake, as I trust it is, let us fix it. We are not machines yet; we are human beings and these people deserve to be welcomed and healed as an act of respect for what they have endured. There is very limited time to do that. After being approved for a visa, their names need to go on the list cleared by Israel. There are just a few days left, so I beg the members to intervene. I raised the matter with the Minister for foreign affairs today. I am sure she will follow up on that, but please do not let it drop because it would look horrible if Ireland did not make this effort to overcome its own bureaucratic hurdles.

Comment on this

Can I make a brief comment?

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

How short are we talking?

Comment on this

I will be very brief. Ursula von der Leyen has stood steadfast with Israel. Are there legal consequences she will face, or should face?

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are not supposed to discuss people outside the committee, Senator Andrews. I know what you are saying. You might rephrase the question in a way that makes it more acceptable.

Comment on this

Ursula von der Leyen has been a steadfast supporter of Israel-----

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I did not say restate it.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I understand what the Senator is talking about.

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does Ms Albanese want to address that briefly?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I think I mentioned earlier that I long for the day when I see accountability for European leadership. Can I say that without mentioning Ms von der Leyen?

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes, and I am going to move on then if that is all right.

Comment on this

I was confused about who was being spoken about.

Comment on this

Ms Albanese is very welcome. I am conscious that everything we say today is going on the record, so it is really important. We have not really touched on settler violence, which Ms Albanese mentioned in her opening statement. In the five minutes she has, she might outline exactly what is happening to Palestinians with them being forced off their land. It is appalling. The committee does not need to listen to me; I ask Ms Albanese to use the time. Before this meeting we got a lot of emails asking us to ask Ms Albanese the hard questions and I think my question about settler violence is a really hard one.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I thank the Deputy for the question. This needs to be unpacked. We are not talking about settler violence; we are talking about state-condoned terror squads. Israeli settlers are not a monolith. I do not know if any members have travelled across the West Bank, but settlements are part of an engineered system of dispossession. There are settlements around each Palestinian village and city to prevent Palestinian development and growth. There are certain settlements, particularly outposts, that have become breeding grounds for deranged people. Israel has been sending people with mental issues and youth at risk to yeshiva schools in settlements so that they can be indoctrinated and become part and parcel of those squads that we see today. We can see that there are deranged people. They have become pawns in the hands of a system that wants to drive the Palestinians off their land and uses everything, including its own citizens.

These settlers have been armed over the years by Ben Gvir. They go around the Palestinian territory, where there is no one to protect the Palestinians. Even in the so-called area A, which is under the supposed jurisdiction of the Palestinian Authority, there is no one to protect the Palestinians. They target certain families and certain villages. They torch homes and destroy them together with the army or with private companies. They force people out. They beat Palestinians and if the Palestinians react, the army, which is always there escorting the settlers, arrests the Palestinians. The environmental damage and the impact of Israeli policies on the environment is what I will be working on for my next report. They are destroying the landscape. They are burning and uprooting olive trees by the hundreds, day after day. They are completely ungrounding the land.

I say this is a state endeavour because there is a security person in each settlement, who is the one making the decisions. I know this from Israeli organisations. In its last report, B'Tselem, the largest human rights organisation in Israel, spoke about the elimination plan. It confirms everything I have been saying in recent years, and more. It describes how individual Israelis are playing into this. One person in each settlement acts as the security guard of this forced displacement process. He or she is paid by the State of Israel. These are the people who instruct the army on what to do, where to go and which Palestinians to go after. It is very brutal and it is happening everywhere, in the north, in the east of the West Bank, in the west, around Jerusalem - everywhere. As we speak, there is a full-on attack on Palestinian communities. For years, they have been encircled by settlements. Roads are segregated with 1,000 checkpoints, which are a chokehold around Palestinian life. There is no possibility for the Palestinians to survive. Either Israel is stopped or it will control everything. There is total impunity. No one - soldiers or settlers - has ever paid for any crimes against the Palestinians. This is the reality.

Comment on this

I had planned to ask about the Horizon programme. I am glad that Ms Albanese has highlighted it. The new Horizon programme for 2028 to 2034 is being negotiated during Ireland's Presidency. How important is it that Ireland explicitly call for Israel's non-inclusion in it, as opposed to the Gazan students, which is what we are seeing? Can we give explicit leadership on Horizon?

Regarding dual-use goods, this is an area where Ireland has a closed-eyes perspective, not just on what passes through but also what is being exported directly. These goods require export licences. They sit within the control of the Irish State. What does dual use mean in terms of technology and the military? That would be useful.

Regarding the Board of Peace, I ask Ms Albanese to comment on the importance of speaking up against it in terms of its colonial framing. Ireland maybe could have a stronger voice in speaking out against it, the breaches of international law, the attack on international systems and the re-emergence of very explicitly colonial and extractive language.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

Let us put Palestine aside for a second. Apartheid South Africa was brutal and still did not reach the level of crimes that Israel has committed against the Palestinians for more than 70 years, and all the more over the past three years.

Israel has killed 74,000 people, including 21,000 children. Imagine that 10,000 people died under rubble and how brutal it is to die under rubble. This is one of the things that has haunted me since the very beginning. As a mother, I imagine my children being buried there and not having the tools even to look for the bodies and not being able to bury the bodies properly. Israel is even desecrating the mass graves that Palestinians were forced to build and taking the rubble out. It has destroyed and pulverised 60% of Gaza and now it is taking the rubble away in order to conceal the crimes. This is the thing. It should not be doing that.

In light of this, why should Israel be part of the Horizon programme in the first place? Let us not make it about Israel. Let us take the opportunity to say this about all states that are accused of and have committed atrocity crimes and have been pending proceedings before the highest court in the world, the International Court of Justice. It is not a member of the European Union. Can we have proper scrutiny? Would we today give grants to apartheid South Africa or allow it to be part of our dealings or research projects? No, we would not - I hope. It is all the more reason not to have Israel as part of it. I do not want to see the taxes we pay in Europe go to Israel. Universities in my own country are struggling and students are not getting scholarships. They are not even able to go to university any more, yet Israel needs to receive funds. Moreover, the Horizon programme discriminates against universities that have taken a stand against apartheid Israel. This is why there should be an exclusion of apartheid Israel at least until Israel ends the genocide and complies with the International Court of Justice advisory opinion, meaning it ends the occupation and its unlawful presence, followed by the apartheid.

On dual use, this is a very problematic issue. Again, would we transfer anything to apartheid South Africa? I suspect not. Why, therefore, are we discussing the transfer of anything to Israel? Dual use means it can be used for anything, but if we think of transferring even gas and oil to Israel for civilian purposes, Israel maintains colonies. Approximately 10% of its population live in the colonies. Unless we punish Israel and hold it accountable, it will not stop. It is not just about strictly military components. Anything you provide to Israel will be used as part of its unlawful endeavour because the occupation and illegal presence of Israel in the occupied territory is quintessential to what Israel is declaring it will do in the near future.

As for the Board of Peace, where to start? I am about to publish a full analysis of the Board of Peace and the implications of being part of it or supporting it. First, the committee may want to put on record that it is a shame the European Union sent a representative there. I do not who took that decision. Was it the expression of a European consensus? It cannot be that a European consensus is again cherry-picked when it is convenient to the European leadership. The Board of Peace is probably the most upfront attack on multilateralism I have seen taking shape. As I said, the only place where peace and work can be discussed and decided is the Security Council. The Board of Peace completely undermines Palestinian self-determination and leaves Israel and the United States - the ones who led the genocide and their partners in crime, the United States - leading the reconstruction of Gaza. Why? Why is it these countries? It is so cruel. Again, there is no prospect of advancement because there is no accountability, no preservation of the evidence of war crimes and no reference to international law. The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation is a shame of historic proportions and must be relegated to the trash bin of history, inshallah.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Albanese for her engagements this week and this morning in the audiovisual room. It is a great honour to have her here. A groundbreaking report released today highlights how a data centre, based on Irish soil in Dublin 22, not too far from this building, to be precise, is being used to facilitate genocide. That is through the use of an app called Al Munasiq, which is an Israeli military-linked app used for digital permits and the mass surveillance of a population. As Ms Albanese pointed out, big tech is an integral part of the genocide. Would she agree that Ireland's Data Protection Commissioner has a responsibility to act, considering that Ireland is hosting an illegal surveillance app? Microsoft's cloud systems for Europe are based in Ireland. Second, should the Irish Government demand an immediate investigation into Microsoft hosting a genocide-related system on Irish soil?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I have not read the report but I have investigated the responsibilities of tech companies myself, which is part of the reason the US sanctioned me. I have evidence for it. I do not know if the committee is aware but my 13-year-old is suing the Trump Administration in the US court system because I really believe we need to use all opportunities to uphold justice. I am cognisant and painfully aware of the responsibilities of certain companies in big tech in particular, like Microsoft, Google, Meta and many others that have their headquarters or offices here. There is an obligation on member states to investigate businesses operating on their soil and, therefore, I definitely and strongly recommend an investigation or inquiry. It would be much better if other countries also investigated because this is an integrated operation and brings about risks for European security and sovereignty. Nevertheless, because it is in Ireland, if all of this is confirmed, while I do not know what the competent authority is or whether it is the commissioner the Deputy is referring to, it is definitely a responsibility of the State. That is all the more the case because the Government and Government officials might be held accountable for negligence and a lack of enforcement of international law, duty to surveil and duty to prevent. However, the company itself is responsible for heightened due diligence, so this could be a case of historic proportions, whereby a corporation could be held accountable for supporting the commission of crimes.

I do not know if there will be enough time for the International Criminal Court to go through at least the proceedings against the main architects of this genocide, but I know there will be justice and the Palestinian trials will be carried out by legal scholars and lawyers. So many Irish lawyers are invested in this and lawyers around the world, many of them in Europe, are sacrificing their time pro bono to make sure there is justice for Palestine. This will be the beginning of the Palestine trials. I strongly encourage Ireland to go there. This is not a bad moment to think of how to use how the wealth of knowledge that Ireland has. I know Ireland is fearful of losing the foreign direct investment - I hear that over and over - but Irish people have for 30 years worked in big tech. Maybe this is a blessing in disguise because they can lead the green tech or the principled, ethical tech revolution with all of the capital and know-how there is in this country.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Albanese for her presentation today. Many questions have already been answered. She was appointed as the United Nations special rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories, which have been occupied since 1967. The United States is a member of the United Nations. She stated that the United States had imposed sanctions on her, her husband and her children. That is a total contradiction. Somebody in the United Nations should take on the USA. She has been appointed by the United Nations and is doing very important work that needs to be done. However, the United States has imposed sanctions on her and her family, which is a total contradiction. Surely there must be some obligation on the United Nations to ask what is going on here and to bring the United States to book on this because it is very unfair.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I will not tell the Deputy what I will publish in my memoir when I finish my mandate. We would not be here if there was not more integrity inside the United Nations itself. I am very happy for it to be on record. Clearly, there are limitations within the United Nations but the United Nations does not have a life independent from the member states that comprise the organisation.

I should ask the question as to why no one state has used the convention on privileges and immunities that the United States is in breach of for sanctioning me and taken the United States before the International Court of Justice because this is the prerogative of every state. I have had many discussions, including with Irish ambassadors in Geneva because I cannot go to the United States any more. Either way, I have an apartment in the United States because I used to live there with my family and we moved abroad to follow my husband's job. Our apartment has been seized by the United States Government. I have really been affected.

I could have negotiated to get out. I could have said that I wanted to live in peace and stepped down from my mandate. However, I come from a place where judges, lawyers, police officers and law enforcement agents have been killed by the Mafia for denouncing the Mafia. I know the courage it takes to stand in front of the bullies of our time. I know that I am taking risks, including taking risks for my family, but someone needs to do that. My hope is that my example will inspire others to do the same or at least a little bit.

The Deputy is right that there is an incredible, disturbing and disconcerting contradiction in what the United States is doing. Is this mad or maybe not? Let us call out the US conduct for what it is. Under this Administration, the US has striven to destroy the multilateral system because it does not need it any more. It does not need the rule of law when it can have the rule of the mighty. Those who are paying the price for it are primarily us Europeans. We have been made more vulnerable to economic unpredictability with war around us and increasing risk of refugee flows. I speak of European governments. European governments do not even have the trust of the younger population and we are paying the price. We should not follow the United States in this detrimental rush to the bottom of institutional depravity.

Comment on this

It is a pleasure to see Ms Albanese again. We had the opportunity of meeting her at the foreign affairs committee yesterday. I know she spent yesterday evening with a very good friend of mine, Angie, in her home. Unfortunately, I could not go because of business we had here in the House. At yesterday's meeting, she outlined the huge personal sacrifice she and her family had had to make, which she has again outlined in response to Deputy Scanlon's question. Nobody should have to go through what she has. I commend her resilience in relation to the job she has been mandated to do without getting the support that she should be getting to allow her to do the role she was given, to keep her and her family safe, and indeed to support her financially as well because I know she is not getting that either.

I had the opportunity to put a few questions to her yesterday. Things across the world have changed with the blue wave that we woke up to this morning, which is great, and the fact that the Democrats now control both Houses in the United States. Will that in any way support what she is doing and support the very difficult situation that the Palestinians are in now?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I need to look closer into the meaning of that electoral outcome. Unfortunately, I did not have the time to do that because I was busy with meetings. Probably this has been the best time I have ever had in Ireland. I have splendid relations and really deep ties to this country's civil society. I have many friends who really make me feel at home, safe, protected and happy, including Angie, who is a friend in common now. I am really having good meetings with institutions. For the first time yesterday, there was a meeting of the foreign affairs committee that was full of people and not just one. I had a meeting with the Minister for foreign affairs that was incredibly useful for both her and for me. I am really glad for this.

Based on the blue wave, as the Senator has called it, I like that the Democratic Party does not seem to be in the hands of pro-apartheid groups, which is huge. This is a conquest of the people. When I criticise the United States, I do not criticise the country because so many are suffering the brunt of inhumane policies taken at a domestic level. Seeing the right people getting into the right jobs gives me hope. We need to be ahead of the curve. We Europeans must do better. This can be the beginning of a new phase of pluralistic, decolonised multilateralism. We can look to Germany. I know things look grim. There is considerable fear because of the AFD and the extreme right getting the vote of the majority in certain areas but they have historically been right wing. What is positive is that millions of citizens of Berlin voted for someone who speaks clearly of genocide, and who has criticised Israel in the name of European values and the German constitution. It takes courage, but the Irish people have a lot of it. I ask them to put it at the service of political Europe because we really need it. I think we can still have hope.

Comment on this

That hope is the most important thing that we can move forward with. Ms Albanese mentioned the EU-Israel Association Agreement in her speech. My party, Fianna Fáil, brought a motion to the Seanad looking for European co-operation in relation to that. We believe that is vitally important. Our Taoiseach has repeatedly said that our view is that European action should include the banning of Israeli products from settlement areas and the suspension of the EU-Israel Association Agreement.

Unfortunately, as was pointed out very well yesterday, international law is being violated repeatedly. This is happening without meaningful consequences. What practical mechanism does Ms Albanese think would compel compliance? I hope that with things changing politically in Israel, an end to the Netanyahu regime might lead to better things for Palestine.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I will repeat myself by saying that Ireland is not in compliance with international law by banning settlement products. Ireland will get in compliance with international law by enacting measures that do not support Israel's unlawful presence in the occupied Palestinian territory, on top of the fact that Israel is committing crimes against humanity, war crimes and possibly genocide. There are genocides that have not been ascertained by the International Court of Justice. The reason the International Court of Justice was activated by South Africa was not to give the opportunity to western states to hide behind a finger but rather to have member states act upon the court raising the alarm.

In order to comply with international law, Ireland should cut ties with Israel, totally and completely, until Israel stops committing acts that resemble genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity. There is only one thing that is going to stop the fist that continues on and on to hit this really devastated body, which is to stop arming it. Ireland is providing the tools, the technology and part of the weapons that Israel is using, even by allowing flights when it does not know what they are carrying. I hope and want to trust that the Government does not know that there are possibly transits of weapons. Again, there should be oversight of this.

I do not think this is a problem of the Netanyahu regime. Netanyahu is still part of the political life of the country because he represents many in the State of Israel. I have investigated the judiciary, which has done absolutely nothing to stop the crimes or to investigate and prosecute what has been done against the Palestinians. I have investigated what other members of the executive have done. They have even passed a death penalty for Palestinians only. What else do we need to understand that this is a rogue state that must be stopped? The Israeli Parliament has been discussing the rape of the Palestinians in jail. In the society, really, many of them are totally deranged. Between 50% and 70% of Israelis want the ethnic cleansing of Palestine and 50% of them are very happy with the continuous bombing of Gaza. What else do we need? The question is not what we can do to stop Israel. We know what we need to do to stop Israel. The question is why we do not do that.

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you. We have about 15 minutes left. I would like to ask Ms Albanese about the EU blocking statute, and I have indications from Senator Higgins and Deputy Gogarty. Deputy Crowe and Senator Andrews would also like to come in. We will limit them to three minutes.

On a number of occasions, I have called for Ireland to push for the EU blocking statute to be used, particularly in respect of the ICC. I know it could be used in relation to Ms Albanese as well. Can Ms Albanese account for the reason it has not been used? Can she tell us what efforts she has made to have it applied, for example, in her own case?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

The blocking statute is a measure in the hands of the European Commission to protect itself, its territory and citizens from the impact of US sanction. First of all, should Australia, New Zealand, South Africa or Colombia issue sanctions against a European citizen, let us ask ourselves if they would have an impact on European soil. No. Why do US sanctions have an impact on Europe? On certain matters, we are not sovereign. Let us admit that. We have European legislation and jurisprudence that oblige banks to open a bank account to European citizens. In my own country, there is jurisprudence saying that US sanctions need to be assessed on a case-by-case level, and still I have a list of banks that I am going to sue because they refuse to open a bank account for me, let alone health insurance. It is unacceptable. We Europeans do not have our sovereignty. We operate as if we were a vassal or colony of the United States. It is unacceptable. This should ring the alarm for all of us. Tomorrow it can happen to anyone the United States feels the urge to punish, without appeal. I have been sanctioned, so I cannot even protect myself.

Of course the EU blocking statute should be used. It was introduced to protect the interest of European businesses in Iran and exchange with Iran at the time of the US sanctions. Why can it not be extended to the International Criminal Court, its judges and prosecutors, and myself? Of course I should be the first of the committee's concerns, even above the ICC, because I am a European citizen. Three European judges have been sanctioned by the United States also. It is outrageous that they impose sanctions on the ICC. Are we crazy? Why can we not stop it?

On the reason it is not applied, I can tell the committee what I know. It is because the European Commission does not care. I do not know why, but the very fact that it does not care is wrong. I have serious mistrust towards the current EU leadership. The European Parliament has passed three motions to have the blocking statute instituted, and the European Commission is not answering. Prime Minister Sánchez of Spain has made an urgent call upon the head of the European Commission, who has not responded. Spain and Slovenia have tried their best to have me out of the sanction and protected by the sanction regime. It simply does not happen. I hope that Ireland will add its voice on this because it is unacceptable. Again, I could be just the first citizen to suffer this. It is happening already to others.

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you. We will go to the last four contributions. I am going to be very strict on time. They can be no more than three minutes and the question cannot be more than one minute.

Comment on this

This should not need to be stated but I think it would be useful to have on the record. Ms Albanese will be aware of Ireland's role in the past as the home state facilitating the sale of Israeli bonds. As of now, Israeli bonds are not being sold in the European Union. The ICJ judgment was clear in terms of the prohibition on trade or investment that facilitated the continuation of the illegal situation. Ms Albanese pointed to the fact that the provisions brought through on trade were quite partial, only on goods and not on trade and services. How important is it that we be clear on the investment component and that there is also an absolute prohibition on facilitating that? How important is it that we do not move in the future to again facilitate the sale of Israeli bonds? A clear position is still not being taken by the Government.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I was not clear about that. I thought Ireland had cut that.

Comment on this

Under significant political pressure from the finance committee and public pressure, it has not-----

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

Been renewed.

Comment on this

-----happened again but we have not had an explicit position taken.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I can tell the Senator because I have investigated this. In the first months of the genocide, Israel's finances were in a state of concern for the state. There was worrisome concern raised in the State of Israel. All of a sudden, Israel was in severe deficit. The banking and financial systems, including through the sale of bonds, have allowed Israel to replenish its coffers. Therefore, this has fuelled and allowed Israel to have all the funds it needs to keep its killing machine on steam. I truly hope and recommend that Ireland not start issuing Israeli bonds again. This would add an extra layer of complicity.

Comment on this

Thank you. Finally, regarding the Levantine basin and the oil and gas reserves, when you see the mercenary and extractive approach being taken, how important is it that we put down some form of clear prohibition on the exploitation of those resources? Ireland does not have an explicit role. This is more of an EU position, because we know there was an MOU on the potential extraction of those resources.

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does Ms Albanese want to come in on that?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

Yes, very quickly, because I have also investigated this. I am very glad to have seen ENI, the largest energy company in Italy, withdrawing from the consortium for the exploitation of underwater gas resources on offshore Gaza. This has put the consortium in a critical situation, so now Israel is rushing to find another member - probably from an Asian country - and it is on the neck so hopefully that will not go ahead.

Comment on this

Senator O'Loughlin mentioned the blue wave. Obviously, we will still have the Administration going until there is a change in presidency. However, within that blue wave there are those, say, in the Jewish community in the US, who could potentially be allies. Over here in Ireland, we keep being called antisemitic for calling out the genocide. I have condemned 7 October and called Hamas a fundamentalist, terrorist organisation, but at the same time, the Israeli state is also doing the bidding of fundamentalist, Zionist, murderous individuals. Collectively as a state, it is responsible for a lot more murder of innocent civilians than on the Palestinian side. We will always be called antisemitic unless we can show that we have those who are calling for action, even if it is a very small minority, in Israel as well. Does Ms Albanese have allies and friends in Israel, or even in the US within the Jewish community?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

Absolutely.

Comment on this

Why are they not more vocal? I have not heard of them.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I do not think they are not vocal. There are no voiceless people in this world, especially in the human rights community. Rather, there are people who are conveniently not listened to. In Israel, B'Tselem has just published a report which is called "Our Genocide" in Hebrew. They wrote it in Hebrew so that it can be read by all Jewish communities around the world and all Jewish people. It continues its courageous work. An Israeli activist, Gil Alexander, was nearly killed a few days ago in the West Bank. There are only Israelis like Alexander and some Italians who go to provide a protective presence in the occupied Palestinian territory around the communities that are attacked by the settler squads and army. There are Israeli scholars and historians - of course they are a minority - but we need to work with them. As regards what concerns me, we have different support groups but until very recently, most of the time when I have been invited to countries to do technical visits and speak about Palestine, I have been invited by Jewish groups in Canada, Australia, New Zealand and Germany. This is nothing to do with the Jewish people. It has to do with the ideology underpinning apartheid Israel. The fact that we cannot even talk about Zionism as the ideology upon which 100 years of dispossession has been predicated is extremely serious. I do not think we need to respond to every accusation. Accusations of antisemitism are thrown like confetti at everyone. Let us not engage with them, and let us stick to the respect for human rights for all.

Comment on this

In five seconds, would those people and groups not be the most effective in lobbying the German Government, for example?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

They do, but the German Government does not care. This is the thing; it is not about Jewish people. The first time I heard about this was June 2022. I went to Germany for the first time as a special rapporteur and I met with Jewish Germans who said I had no idea of the cognitive dissonance they encounter when a German tells a Jewish person, a descendant of Holocaust survivors, that they are an antisemite for criticising Israel. It is worrisome for a German to tell a Jewish person they are an antisemite because they criticise the state of Israel.

Comment on this

Ms Albanese mentioned in her opening statement the slaughter of 21,000 children. We have not touched today on the arrest and detention of children. While she has a couple of minutes, Ms Albanese might outline to the committee what exactly is happening to Palestinian children.

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I am afraid there is no differentiation between the treatment adults and children endure.

When I investigated the situation of children living under occupation years ago, I asked an Israeli soldier why he did this to children and he asked me which children. He said he sees no children. He was saying this provocatively, but of course, Israel is the only country in the world that has a military juvenile system just for Palestinian refugees. There is no military court system that tries children, and what they endure is brutal. They are being targeted. We have had doctors speaking of the gamification of killing. There are days in Gaza where Palestinian children are brought in in different numbers who have been shot, all of them in the hands, ears or torso. The soldiers and snipers are entertaining themselves in slaughtering kids in a given way. It is brutal. I call the Israeli army the most depraved army, the most deranged army and the most immoral army for a reason. If there is time to look into what Israel has done years from now, I will be proven right and people will regret not having given a little more attention to this.

I was talking to Palestinian children in the West Bank just three days ago from Salfit, Masafer Yatta, Al-Bustan and Silwan in Jerusalem, where their homes are being destroyed before their eyes, or in Hebron in Jenin. The situation is brutal. It is very painful to speak to Palestinian children because they are scared. When you talk to children, you see your own children or you see yourself, and you ask how it is possible that we, the entire world, cannot stop this state from massacring them. I am happy to facilitate an encounter, and encourage whomever on the committee would like to come, to speak directly with the children. I meet them regularly as part of my work.

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Andrews is next, and this will be the last contribution.

Comment on this

In Ms Albanese's view, is the US's financial and economic influence on the Irish economy impacting the Irish approach to Israel and sanctions?

Comment on this
Ms Francesca P. Albanese

I do not know. I do not have enough information about the US influence on Ireland. However, the very fact that another state might have influence on the committee's state, leading to the commission or condoning of crimes, is very scary. I know this is happening in my country of Italy, which is disconcerting. There is an Israelisation of our societies in Europe; there is no question about that. We have this militarisation of private life.

Why is there an army presence in supermarkets and around our schools? Why are our pupils being exposed to the heavy training of soldiers, as has happened in Israel? Why are members of civil society held on the count of terrorism, as are journalists? Why are people being fired from their jobs just for speaking the truth or asking questions?

The Israelisation of our society is an ongoing phenomenon and it is also down to the undue influence of the United States on Europe. There is no question about that. It can be stopped but it takes people straightening their spine and saying, "This is not going to happen any more". The fear will lead to a necessary emancipation process. We need to question the ties we have with the United States, especially at the moment, when it is led by someone whose name has appeared time and again on the list of his paedophile friends. We need to be honest with ourselves about who our allies are.

Comment on this
Barry Ward An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will draw a line under our discussion as we are already over time. I thank Ms Albanese for the time she has given us today, for her engagement with the committee and for giving us the benefit of her experience. We are very grateful to her. In due course, we will prepare a report on this issue, a copy of which we will be happy to forward to her.

I propose that we suspend for a few minutes to allow Ms Albanese to leave. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this