Business of Joint Committee
We have a quorum. There are a lot of meetings taking place around the Houses and there is a conflict of time for some.
We have received apologies from Senator Maurice Cummins, Deputy Darragh O'Brien who is chairing another meeting and Deputy Rory O'Hanlon.
Comment on this
I want to pass on apologies from Deputy Michael D. Higgins who was injured during a recent trip to Colombia.
Comment on this
He injured his leg but I believe he had an operation yesterday. It is a minor injury that will not keep him away from us for too long.
Comment on this
Would it be appropriate for the joint committee to send him a message wishing him well?
Comment on this
The Deputy had minor surgery yesterday and is fine. I spoke to him yesterday and he indicated he will back at work in a couple of weeks.
Comment on this
We look forward to it. It will be very civilised.
Comment on this
We have, in the Visitors' Gallery, Mr. Michael O'Brien, Trócaire, Mr. Hans Zomer, Dóchas, Ms Severine Meyer, Plan International Ireland, the Estonian Ambassador, His Excellency, Mr. Mait Martinson, Mr. Brendan Rogers, director general of Irish Aid, Mr. Simon Murtagh of AWEPA, Mr. Simon Clements, development specialist, Irish Aid, and Ms Barbara Cullinane, counsellor, Department of Foreign Affairs.
I ask members and those in the Visitors' Gallery to please ensure their mobile telephones and BlackBerry devices are switched off completely for the duration of the meeting as they cause interference, even if in silent mode, with the recording equipment in committee rooms.
The minutes of the meeting of 20 October have been circulated. Are they agreed?
Comment on this
I note the Chairman indicated that we would take some notice of the position in Ethiopia at this meeting. In light of the communications we have received from Mr. John O'Shea of GOAL suggesting that Mr. Lawrence, the author of the relevant report, may be in a position to attend, perhaps we should-----
Comment on this
I understand the issue is referred to in the minutes.
Comment on this
I do not envisage a problem in the matter as we will have to find a suitable time to discuss it.
Comment on this
This meeting will not discuss in detail the situation in Ethiopia.
Comment on this
That is correct. The joint committee extends its deepest sympathies to the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Deputy Micheál Martin, his wife, Mary, and their children, Micheál, Aoibhe and Cillian, on the devastating and heartbreaking loss of their daughter and sister, Leanna. Our thoughts and prayers are with the Martin family. May Leanna rest in peace.
Members will recall our recent meeting of 20 October when we met with representatives of Amnesty International to discuss human rights in Iran.
Comment on this
I am afraid some members must leave for a division in the Seanad.
Comment on this
On 26 October, I wrote to the Iranian Ambassador, His Excellency Hossein Panahiazar. My letter, which has been circulated to members, referred to the deterioration in the human rights situation generally in Iran and the cases of five specific individuals which had been raised by Amnesty International and discussed at our previous meeting. I sent a further letter today by fax to the Ambassador of Iran to make an urgent appeal on behalf of Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani, an Iranian woman whose sentence of execution by stoning for adultery provoked a worldwide outcry recently. Ms Ashtiani is reportedly to be hanged for murder. Her case, and those of other individuals raised by Amnesty International point to a human rights crisis in Iran. It is vital that we let Iran know that we have noticed, that we care and that the position is totally unacceptable.
Comment on this
I also wrote to the Iranian Embassy today. When does the Chairman expect to receive a response to his correspondence? This is an extremely urgent matter as we could learn today that the lady in question has been executed. If the Chairman does not receive a reply by a certain date, will he pursue the matter further? If so, what date has been set? As I indicated at the previous meeting, I did not receive a response from the Iranian Embassy to a letter I wrote concerning the manner in which Irish people were treated by Iranian guards at a recent protest.
Comment on this
The Deputy may remember that we complained bitterly about the sentence of stoning in the first instance. We do not know what developments there have been in the meantime, possibly even today. We want to make it clear how members feel about the case of Ms Ashtiani. If we do not receive a reply to our letter, we will pursue the matter. The joint committee usually receives a response in such matters reasonably quickly. The Department of Foreign Affairs will also have taken up the case.
Comment on this
What does the term "reasonably quickly" mean? Does the Chairman expect a reply by the end of this week or next week?
Comment on this
I cannot answer that question in the particular circumstance. We can e-mail the Deputy if we receive a reply.
Comment on this
When is the execution to take place?