We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

Quarterly Meeting on Health Issues

Contributions 205–420 of 420. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

He is not here, but I note Deputy Murphy O'Mahony and the Minister of State are getting on far better these days since his announcement.

Comment on this

There is love in the air now.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not mind me saying these things - there is less sting in it. I will get the Deputy a written update on this, but to the best of my knowledge they are on track.

Comment on this

Another thing under the portfolio of the Minister of State at the Department of Health, Deputy Daly, is the home help situation. We speak about it here a great deal. I have one particular case involving a 71 year old lady with a terminal illness. She has been approved for only five hours per week since October but it is not up and running. If the Minister does not mind, I will send him the details. Obviously, given that she has a terminal illness, this is very important.

Comment on this

The measure on below-cost alcohol selling that was brought in last year or legislated for is still not up and running. I heard on the radio again - we would be lost only for it - that the Minister is in favour of it.

Comment on this

Yet, some of the Government partners may not be.

Comment on this

I must have missed that radio programme as well.

Comment on this

It is all on the news.

Comment on this

I am passionately in favour of it, as is the Deputy.

We passed this landmark legislation. A hell of a lot of people put a large number of obstacles in our way. Vested interests with deep pockets attempted to stop us passing the Public Health (Alcohol) Act 2018. I acknowledge that we passed it together with civic society and public health advocates. I thank people for their co-operation. We have enacted a number of parts of the Act, including that relating to advertising restrictions. Since last month, one cannot advertise alcohol on any public transport or in any public transport station. It is kind of amazing that this has happened so quietly.

Comment on this

Alcohol cannot be advertised on children's clothing. Alcohol advertising in cinemas is severely restricted. Alcohol cannot be advertised near schools, crèches or playgrounds. It is good that some of the measures have come in.

Comment on this

I want to bring in minimum unit pricing. I will explain why I do not buy into the baloney which suggests that we cannot bring it in until Northern Ireland does so. Scotland did it without waiting for England. It is about to be done in Wales, but the authorities in England are not about to do it. I remind the Deputy that we are talking about a certain type of alcohol. We are not talking about high-cost alcohol. That is the whole idea. I do not believe 16 or 17 year old lads, some of whom cannot drive or should not be allowed to drive, will get into their cars and drive for 90 minutes to buy a few cans of Dutch Gold. That is not the way the world works. We should move ahead with minimum unit pricing. It is up to me to make a call on when to bring in the memo. It makes sense to wait for a degree of certainty in respect of Britain and the Brexit date. There is a great deal of uncertainty in that regard. We might have a degree of certainty very shortly.

Comment on this

It might get a push tomorrow.

Comment on this

I would like to move on this very early in the new year.

Comment on this

I would like to put my final question to the Minister of State, Deputy Finian McGrath. I spoke to him a while ago about the lack of residential places in west Cork. Many elderly parents of adults with special needs in the area are afraid of getting sick or getting old. This is breaking them down. They are afraid that they will be too shook to be able to look after their children or that they will pass away. They need certainty about the availability of places. I ask the Minister of State to address this.

Comment on this
Finian McGrath Minister of State at the Department of Health Independent

In recent months, we have been negotiating with the HSE and the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform on the 2020 HSE service plan. The issue of residential places has been one of my top five priorities during those negotiations. We need to deal with many issues, including day services and personal assistance hours. The bottom line is that we have a cohort of elderly parents whose adult children with intellectual disabilities are in need of residential places. We have not yet finalised the service plan. The need for new residential places for people in critical need is a major issue for me. I accept the Deputy's point that we need to focus on these issues. We are going to exceed €2 billion in the 2020 HSE service plan. We need to ensure that we have priorities in the context of that €2 billion. Elderly parents of adults with intellectual disabilities are very worried about the future. They have a right to residential places for their children. I am determined to facilitate that. I would say we will know more about this in the next week or so.

Comment on this

The Minister of State might come back to me on it.

Comment on this

I will come back to the Deputy with the details. It will probably be next week.

Comment on this

I want to acknowledge their pain and worry.

Comment on this

Yes, absolutely.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State.

Comment on this

I am going to offer Deputies and Senators and the witnesses who are in attendance an opportunity to take a break for ten minutes. I suggest that we should come back at 11.45 a.m. Is that okay?

Comment on this

I am happy to work through the break. I have to leave at 1 p.m. When we come back, we should have enough time for members to ask any remaining questions.

Comment on this

Is the Minister happy to take a break?

Comment on this

I am happy to take a break.

Comment on this

We will return in ten minutes.

Comment on this

The figures in the Minister's opening statement on the reduction of the number of patients on inpatient waiting lists, which are compiled by the NTPF, are very welcome. They show a fall from 86,000 to 66,000, approximately, over two years. Will the Minister give us a breakdown of how those figures were achieved? Are they people who died on waiting lists, who sought treatment outside the jurisdiction through the cross-border directive, who went to private services to receive their treatment or who received treatment through our own health service? Is it possible that the raw figures from the National Treatment Purchase Fund can be provided to the committee so that we can see how that reduction was achieved?

Comment on this

I may have to ask the NTPF to compile it but we will write to the committee with that information.

Comment on this

I have sought the same information at a number of previous committee meetings but unfortunately it never came.

Comment on this

It was not from me, or if the Chairman has sought it from me, I apologise.

Comment on this

The Minister might redouble his efforts in providing that information, if he could.

Comment on this

We will certainly ask for that. It should be easy to provide the information because the benefit of the NTPF is that one can track the patient through his or her entire journey. It is not money that goes into an overall budget but is individually allocated to a patient. I assure the Chairman that there is a direct correlation between the significant increase in funding for reducing waiting lists and the reduction of waiting lists.

Comment on this

I left out a category where people are provided with a service through the National Treatment Purchase Fund through either the public or private system. Will the Minister give us a breakdown of that?

Comment on this

I will also send the committee information on "do not attends". I do not have a specific figure but we see an average of 450,000 to 500,000 people missing hospital appointments each year. There has to be something behind that and we are digging for information about that. It is much higher in some areas than others. Some areas send out text reminders and some do not. The entire number of patients waiting for an outpatient appointment is some 500,000, and 500,000 people are missing appointments, so we need to look at what is happening with the "do not attend" figures.

Comment on this

People are getting follow-up appointments for operations that have not even happened.

Comment on this

We have had several meetings about workforce planning. An issue that was raised was the creation of panels for appointments.

There is a problem in respect of those panels. I understand that those panels will be concluded next year and that a new panel system will be drawn up. On that issue, I am aware of a speech and language therapist in a hospital who has been approved to move to a different hospital but cannot because the recruitment process for the position she holds is frozen, not funded, not approved or whatever is the term. There is an issue in respect of panels and, in particular, the geography associated with panels. One may be a specialist in the south of Ireland and when a vacancy arises one is offered a position in the north of the country, which is not practical for one to take up. There seems to be a problem in respect of the constituent parts of panels and the way people are offered jobs from those panels. The Minister might clarify that when replying.

Deputy Margaret Murphy-O'Mahony raised the issue of GP vacancies. The particular problem that arises when somebody retires is the way that post is filled. I want to make a practical suggestion to the Minister. The panel system for interviewing GPs is out of date. The marking system might be out of date also because when somebody retires, it is important to have local information on the way that GP panel is filled. Having the retired GP who has just vacated the position as part of that panel is important because he or she may well have been head-hunting for somebody to come onto that list before he or she retires and would have a good deal of local knowledge about who would be the most appropriate person to take on the list. It is often the case that a list is drawn up, the system of offering it to the first, second or third person is gone through and by the time the person who wants the job or could take it is reached, he or she has moved on. The marking system is disconnected from the practical availability of GPs on the ground because the longer a panel is unfilled, the less chance we have of getting somebody from that existing panel. The input of the retiring GP or much more local input in the interview process would speed up the filling of that position.

The MRI scanner in University Hospital Limerick, UHL, is long overdue but very welcome. I am disappointed that it will operate only from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday to Friday. The MRI scanner is essential to reducing the number of people waiting for admission to the hospital and confining its use from Monday to Friday does not make the best use of it. It should operate for longer hours during the week but it also should function at weekends to clear the backlog of MRI scans, not only for patients in casualty but also patients on waiting lists. Consultants in the mid-west are now advising public patients to get their scans done privately because they will not get them done publicly in a timely manner. It is important that the Minister should consider the opening hours for that scanner.

Mr. Reid referred earlier to theatres in Ennis hospital. It is essential that the theatres in the hospital be upgraded. Two new modular theatres are required to allow inpatient day-care procedures to be carried out. That would take a lot of pressure off UL and allow ear, nose and throat surgery in particular, about which we have spoken previously, to be developed in Ennis hospital in the way ophthalmology services have been developed in Nenagh. It would be critical infrastructure to put in place to solve the problems all of us have mentioned earlier in respect of UHL. The Minister might comment on using our model 2 hospitals to the maximum advantage.

Mr. Reid also mentioned hospital avoidance. It is critical that we expand our community intervention team, CIT, services to allow frail elderly people remain in their homes. CIT services are essential for that. There is an axis between CIT GPs and public health nurses.

If they do not exist within the community, people will end up in accident and emergency services unnecessarily when they could be managed at home.

We mentioned previously that it is essential to expand community diagnostics. That is one of the pillars of the winter plan for the mid-west but I am not aware how GPs or others access those community diagnostics because information is not available on that.

On the timeline for scheduled care hospitals, site selection will happen next year. In terms of the process, it will then have to go to design, procurement, tendering, building and commissioning. What is the timeline for an elective hospital to take in patients? Is the children's hospital consuming funds that should be going to all of those other services? The Minister might give us a timeline for that in respect of elective hospitals.

My last question relates to ophthalmology services in the mid-west. The waiting time from seeing the consultant to having surgery is reduced but the waiting time for an initial visit, even though one may have a diagnosis of a cataract from an optician, needs to be removed. One presents with the diagnosis. A diagnosis process is not necessary but getting to that first visit is still taking two to three years in the mid-west. I accept the time may be shorter after one has been seen but the time between being referred and being seen is still two to three years. That is my first tranche of questions for the Minister.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman. I will ask my colleagues to come in on some of the questions because they are more appropriate to them, particularly the point the Chairman made on panels.

On GP vacancies, I agree with the Chairman. We need to listen to him on that in terms of his professional experience but also his knowledge in terms of what is happening on the ground in rural parts of Ireland. We may or may not agree on this but I am clear as to what we need to do about increasing the pipeline of new GPs and trying to keep them in Ireland. I accept that we need to do more in terms of the contract but as I said earlier, there is an immediacy now in some communities. We are already seeing on an ad hoc basis communities stepping up after the crisis emerges, meeting with the HSE and asking how this can be fixed. We are seeing good examples of some of the collaboration taking place. I saw it in Kerry recently where the community and the HSE locally are working together but only after the vacancy arises. One of the points the Chairman is making is that there should be greater community involvement at a much earlier stage. We know that, say, Dr. X is due to retire so we should start that process earlier.

The Chairman's comment on the marking scheme is fair. There might be an issue in terms of a GP choosing their successor, which is not what he is suggesting, but we need to get the balance right. I ask that the HSE witnesses would reflect on what the Chairman has said and revert to him on it. As an issue arises, I believe the HSE is doing a very good job of engaging with the community but can we plan better further out?

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

In terms of medical recruitment and the medical workforce in general, we have established a medical workforce oversight group that both myself and Dr. Henry co-chair to examine how we currently recruit and retain our doctors. A core part of that is GPs because we are very conscious of the need to future-proof in terms of Sláintecare, community health networks and our process around engaging with the Irish College of General Practitioners and all of that. GPs are key in that in terms of our approach so we can certainly look at the points the Chairman raised in respect of the interviewing and the replacement process.

I might pick up on a couple of other points. The MRI scanner in University Hospital Limerick is opening 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. to begin with. However, the contract with the provider has the capacity to extend that. If the demand requires longer hours, we can certainly introduce those.

I agree with the Chairman on the expansion of CIT services. We are looking at CIT services. We will be looking at increasing the CIT capacity and the community frailty intervention team in the community in the mid-west. We want to focus our efforts on making sure that we have CITs, that they are integrated into the broader primary care service delivery and linked with acute hospitals also. That is very much part of our plan, and the mid-west is part of our plan for 2020.

Comment on this

On some of the other issues, the opening hours of the MRI scanner are a matter for local hospital management but as the Chairman referenced, there is a point about looking at the two scanners in the totality.

On the issue of the elective hospitals, the realistic timeframe is about four years.

We can look at how we can tighten that - perhaps through standard designs and the like for the three - but we are not yet at that stage. I have never suggested that these are things that can be done today or tomorrow. They are very much a key part of Sláintecare, which is a ten-year plan. I hope that they will be delivered during the first half of the implementation of Sláintecare. We would have a much better outlook regarding what they will constitute - sites and the like - by the first quarter of next year.

The Chairman's point about inpatient day cases versus outpatients is valid. It is one we have discussed quite regularly and one that the NTPF, the HSE and the Department are eager to move on in 2020. Patients do not differentiate between the outpatient and the inpatient nor should they. If I have a problem with my eye, I need to see a consultant. When I see the consultant, I might need a cataract operation or whatever. That is the wait, that is the total time. The question is whether we can put in place a system that takes someone through the entire process and whether the NTPF can help fund that whole journey, taking somebody through the outpatient clinic to having the procedure done and out the other end. The way we differentiate between outpatients and inpatients is not the way real life works for people.

There are very exciting proposals, with which the Chairman will be familiar, regarding community ophthalmology and a view that a lot more can be done in that context. In the context of that specialty and half a dozen others to which I referred in my opening statement, we can press "go" on a few in 2020. That would make a significant difference.

I am not sure whether Ms O'Connor answered the question about community diagnostics in the mid-west and whether GPs know how to access community diagnostics under the winter plan.

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

The honest answer is that I am not sure. In terms of the work we are doing with the mid-west, the head of primary care there is very engaged with us in terms of the roll-out. That is where we have the CIT and the FIT proposals coming through.

In terms of how GPs access community diagnostics, I would have to check what the mechanism for communicating that is. I am sure there is some mechanism that has been thought through but I do not know the answer to it.

Comment on this

We will write to the committee.

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

We will come back to it.

Comment on this

Will the Minister and his officials contact the committee? What about modular theatres for Ennis?

Comment on this

That is a matter for the HSE.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

I am looking at the update given on 14 November. I cannot confirm the actual date. I am not sure whether Mr. Woods has it.

Comment on this
Mr. Liam Woods

No, I do not. It was a point raised by the Chairman in the meeting with the Deputies from the mid-west. We undertook to take it away and discuss it with University Limerick hospital group, so I will come back to the Chairman on the matter.

Comment on this

I understand that a business case has been made.

Comment on this
Mr. Liam Woods

I do not have an update here so I will come back to the Chairman with one if that is helpful.

Comment on this

My questions have been answered to the best of our guests' ability.

Comment on this

I was in contact with the Minister of State, Deputy Finian McGrath, recently about an issue involving Western Care and the allocation of spaces for adults with special needs. Deputy Murphy O'Mahony and the Chairman also raised this issue with the Minister of State, who indicated that he is focusing on it. I wish to highlight the case of families where a child or adult with particular needs relating to Down's syndrome or another condition has been under the care of their parents and the parents have become old and infirm or have passed away. I feel particularly strongly about this because when the parents pass away, the vulnerable individual really has nobody to stand up for him or her, apart from Members of this House or other public representatives. There is a particular case in Mayo involving a young man in his early 30s. Both his parents are deceased. My understanding is that Western Care gets a budget allocation and is to provide services in the community. In this case, it is not delivering the service because the individual is not getting residential care and no budget is available for him. The net impact is that this young man does not have a stable environment. People like him want to be under the care of Western Care and live out the rest of their lives in a stable environment. While I know this is a priority for the Minister of State, can he give me any indication as to when a space for this gentleman, about whom I have been tormenting the Minister of State since last June, will become available? I want the gentleman to whom I refer to remain anonymous.

Comment on this

I am aware of this case.

The important thing to say is that emergency residential places constitute a very important issue in the debate on the service plan. As I said earlier, there will be a significant increase in resources over the €2 billion figure regarding the HSE service plan. I want to personalise this in one way because I agree with Deputy O'Connell that the important thing is to focus on the families and the person with a disability. In 2020, we plan to have 8,358 residential places. We have 33,700 day respite sessions, 166,00 respite overnights and 23,000 day places so these are the kind of plans that are in place. One goes back to the core question. Every year, we have a number of people in those situations. I am pushing very strongly for the extra money and resources. I have been talking to the Minister - even over the past few days. The Minister gets it. He is very supportive of me. Do we need more residential places for people in critical need who have no family? That is the phrase I am using. The answer is "Yes". I hope to see some of those new residential places come into play in the next couple of weeks. That is my view at the moment but I do accept that when we are having a debate about budgets and the service plan, when one digs deep, one must pick out priorities. I accept the Deputy's point about those adults with disabilities whose parents are dead. Under the UN convention, these people have a right to a service so we must push that. I am confident that there will be major improvements in the service plan for 2020.

Comment on this

It was reported that about 10% of GPs have taken up the termination of pregnancy service. A couple of GPs have contacted me regarding an anomaly within the system. The example I have been given is a girl in west Dublin with a full medical card who had to travel to another part of Dublin to get a GP to carry out her termination of pregnancy. There is an anomaly within the PCRS. Any GP providing the service can claim the fees for the termination of pregnancy but that same GP, who is not the person's regular GP, cannot prescribe Implanon or another long-acting reversible form of contraception. It seems like a missed opportunity when the individual looking for the termination of pregnancy is eligible under the medical card system. This is not about getting extra eligibility. It is about someone who is already deemed eligible for medical card services being able to avail of services such as the insertion of Implanon by the GP who carries out the termination of pregnancy in the short period of time - either on the day or a short period of time thereafter. My understanding is that it is just a matter of the PCRS allowing within the portal for the GP performing the termination to claim as opposed to the default GP with whom the girl is registered in her own area. Am I making any sense?

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy for raising this issue. It does indeed sound illogical because, obviously, we want to provide all the care to the woman there. Mr. Reid and I will have a look at that, see if that can be fixed and revert to the Deputy and the committee.

Comment on this

The Minister of State, Deputy Catherine Byrne, is not here. Regarding methadone, I am delighted to hear that the Minister met with the families of people involved in the methadone scheme or who have had their lives ravaged by addiction. I am very supportive of the Minister visiting the families. For many people, particularly in these Houses, it is fine to talk about people in the abstract, be they in a methadone programme or direct provision centre or any sort of centre, as if they are a different type or sort of person but, as I am sure the Minister saw last night, these are normal people from normal families who walk among us and have just been hit in some unfortunate way and touched by the ravages of drug addiction. I very much welcome the Minister's visit last night. Methadone treatment is almost regarded as being negative. There is a perception that if somebody is on 10 ml of methadone for the rest of his or her life, that is somehow a bad thing.

To my mind, it is a good thing. If they need a maintenance dose to keep the show on the road and keep their lives in line, it is good to have that relationship with their prescribing doctor and their pharmacist to keep them on the straight and narrow. I very much welcome this and any additional supports that can be given to families. I welcome any measures that highlight what they have to deal with in their lives, the impacts on other children in the family and the extended family, and also people's positions in their neighbourhoods and communities. Stigma has been mentioned this morning. Families who have been ravaged by drugs often face strong push-back in their communities. I welcome any moves to support those families.

As was reported yesterday, in recent times there has been a significant increase in the incidence of mumps in our population. In Samoa, we have also seen a shutdown with the outbreak of measles. All of this is part of the global dumbing down when it comes to vaccination, fake news, the Wakefield generation coming of age and such. The net impact of the mumps outbreak is that we are going to have a generation of young men who will have fertility problems when they seek to start families. Is there any plan to try to highlight this? I have always thought that the young people who are affected are probably the key. If a young man discovers that his parents chose not to vaccinate him against mumps when he was a child, and now his future in terms of having children is going to be severely impacted, is there any plan to wake that generation up to the impacts of previous decisions on their healthcare? In terms of measles, the Minister said some time ago that he was exploring mandatory vaccinations and was seeking the position of the Attorney General. While I do not agree with mandatory vaccination in a normal setting, it is now high time we addressed this. We have the situation in Samoa. The UK has lost its measles-free status, as far as I know. This issue is encroaching on us and perhaps we should be prepared, if there is a confluence of events that leads to an outbreak here, to protect the population if we had to. I would be grateful if the Minister could give us his thoughts on that.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy for her comments. After my meeting last night, I am just so conscious of how grateful families impacted by addiction are that she and others raise these issues and that we talk about them here. They feel they are never talked about. We do not talk about addiction enough in Ireland but we talk even less about the impact of addiction on the family. The Deputy is right that the reason we do not do so is that there is a nice, cosy consensus and an ignorant view that this only happens to X type of person or in Y type of place. That is complete and utter bull. The phrase I kept thinking of last night is "There but for the grace of God go I." This could visit any of our homes or communities. Frankly, it is visiting all of our communities. A woman told me last night how the first time someone she knew became aware that her son was addicted to drugs was when she was sitting down watching Coronation Street. There was a knock on the door and she asked her husband to get up and open it and there were two men in balaclavas with baseball bats standing at their hall door looking to recover a drugs debt. This is a reality for people and we have to start talking about it. It is a real health crisis, a public health epidemic. There is a lot of that same ignorant stigma that we have around other social issues and the notion that it only happens to certain types of people. That is nonsense and we need to call time on it. In this committee or in a future configuration, we should be doing more on this. I intend to do a lot more on it. The UK has a helpline for families affected by addiction. I want to explore how we can look at this as well. We need to do a lot more.

On the issue of mumps, measles and mandatory vaccination, the Deputy is passionate about the whole area of vaccination. The current status in terms of my own thought process and policy development is that I am awaiting a report from the Health Research Board, HRB. I asked it to do a body of work on what could be effective. I am not interested in a stunt or something that looks like we are doing something. I want to do something. I have asked the HRB to look at what other jurisdictions have done that has proven effective in terms of combating vaccine hesitancy. I am expecting that report any day now and by the end of the year. I will read it alongside the advice of the Attorney General and come forward with policy proposals.

My view is that there may be issues with the Constitution in the context of education and schools. People have a constitutional right to a primary education. How a constitutional right interacts with a particular issue may present a challenge. If, however, we are really serious about vaccination, we know that it happens prior to primary school. It actually happens when children are in crèches and other childcare facilities.

I make a plea to Early Childhood Ireland and others regarding the fact that there is nothing stopping crèches and childcare providers from making it a requirement for parents to show that their children have been vaccinated in order for them to be accepted by those facilities. This has become the norm in terms of how we deal with our family pets. It is quite astonishing that it is not the norm when it comes to dealing with children. If I were to send my child to a crèche, I would like to know that not only have I done right by her in terms of getting her vaccinated but that she is going into an environment where she cannot pick up other illness because other people have failed in their duties to protect public health. All of us should be calling on crèches and childcare providers to make this part of good practice and guidelines from today. I do not think there is any reason that this should not happen.

In terms of the Deputy's question regarding an effective campaign, I have heard her talk about how we can have an effective campaign for the generation that were not vaccinated - the Wakefield generation, as the Deputy refers to them. She is dead right. It is a really important campaign that we could run in colleges, etc. The Vaccine Alliance is looking at what is effective in terms of public awareness campaigns. I will certainly feed that back to it. The final point I want to make on vaccinations is that I had meetings with the social media companies recently. Social media has been a really great tool but would Brexit have happened, would Donald Trump have been elected, and would the uptake rate relating to the HPV vaccine have dropped so significantly if we did not have social media? Who knows. We certainly know that the spread of disinformation and misinformation on social media has contributed significantly to a decrease in vaccination rates, particularly around the HPV vaccine but also in respect of other vaccines. At the meetings, I was encouraged somewhat that they were doing some things and that they are certainly realising, even from a business model point of view, that their users expect them to do more. I am still a little concerned with Google wanting to keep as its "secret sauce" information relating to how one becomes the number one hit on a Google search. When I search the word "vaccination" on Google, I do not think it is acceptable that I get anything other than a reputable source of information at the top of the results list. We have agreed to keep in touch and work with Google. It has agreed to come in and speak to the Vaccine Alliance. A lot more work definitely needs to be done in that area.

Comment on this

Mr. Breslin, Mr. Reid and a few others were present at last week's meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss primary care centres. I do not want to land the issue on them this morning but, in the context of Sláintecare, it is fundamental that we move things out of acute settings and into the primary care setting. There were 341 primary care centres planned from 2008 onwards. The matter was reviewed in 2012. It emerged at the meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts last week that no one has reviewed position of the centres in light of Sláintecare in order to see if they are fit for purpose in terms of what we want to deliver. There is no definition of what constitutes a primary care centre or a primary care team. While I am not completely hung up on that, if we are going to move towards treating defined populations, then, in the context of the connection between acute care and community care, it is imperative that the system that was embarked upon in 2008 is modified and made fit for purpose. If we are going to add diagnostic centres, we have to ensure that capacity exists among the 341 that are planned. Obviously, we cannot have 341 diagnostic centres but capacity must be there - dotted around the country - and it must be possible to add things so that we are not going to have to buy sites next to centres or whatever. When we are doing Sláintecare, it is about ensuring that we are not already tying a stone to our leg while we are doing it. We should be able to do it with the plans that are already there. We can modify them as we go. I was a bit concerned last week that it was almost as though the primary care thing was put on a shelf and left there and was operating separately from Sláintecare when it is integral to its success.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

I thank the Deputy. I do not disagree with her sentiment or direction of travel in terms of the role of primary care centres and Sláintecare-proofing them. As we were outlining just last week, of the 340 we have 127 in place, another 77 are in progress and 30 are committed to in our capital plan. What we want to do now is exactly as the Deputy outlined.

We are now looking forward to a new way of treatment and care to which there are various elements, as I touched on earlier. The first element is GPs, the second is pharmacies, and the third is the primary care centres, both in terms of entry points and egress points. In my visits to many such centres around the country, I have seen various levels of capability and resourcing. Centres that have a GP on-site, such as the one I visited last week in Waterford, are very successful. Young children and those seeking paediatric services come in to them as well, which takes huge pressure off the acute settings. The centres are very successful when they have the skills and resources in place. There are other that are fine centres but which do not have the skills, resources, and diagnostics needed to equip them. As we look forward to Sláintecare and talk about new pathways, I am very committed that the investment in the next 77 centres and the infrastructure of the current 127 must be Sláintecare-proofed. In terms of the existing centres, the first element is the €10 million investment committed to in our service plan, as part of the budget, which will rise to €60 million. That will give us the capacity for 1,000 extra staff resources on the community side, of which a significant proportion must be in our primary care centres.

Comment on this

There are five non-members here, who I will group in the interests of time. I will take Senator Kieran O'Donnell and Deputy Brassil together, followed by Senators Byrne and Conway-Walsh and Deputy Bríd Smith. I suggest that they ask two questions each, rather than making statements.

Comment on this

I thank the Chairman for facilitating me. I have two quick questions. I welcome the fact that the HSE is providing funding for 15 beds to be opened at St. John's hospital in Limerick. However, I have learned from my own inquiries made on Monday that those 15 beds have not been in use for the last three months. At the same time, there is continuous and severe overcrowding at University Hospital Limerick. By all means, we should push for the new MRI scanner there, because it would be fantastic. Why were those 15 beds not put into use three months ago, when there is such a big crisis in Limerick on a continual basis?

The building of the 60-bed block is under way, and the 90-bed block will be going in for planning permission shortly. What measures is the HSE taking, at both national and local level, to ensure all existing bed capacity is being used? What is being done to ensure all the beds in University Hospital Limerick, St. John's, Ennis, Nenagh and Croom hospitals are being used on an ongoing basis? I was shocked to hear that 15 of the 89 beds in St. John's have been out of use for the last three months. That is unforgivable and unacceptable. It was a breaking point and a red line for me. The Government is willing to give whatever resources are required, so I need an answer to these questions. When did the witnesses first know about the 15 beds and why were they not brought into use three months ago? What is being done to manage the beds in the five hospitals in the group, namely, UHL, St. John's, Ennis, Nenagh and Croom? I was at a mass in a village in east Limerick on Sunday, where nursing homes were advertising that they have spare capacity. Is due diligence is being done to ensure available nursing home beds and step-down facilities are being used? I am looking for solutions here. Deputy Kelly noted that we are all looking for solutions, and we must use the existing resources to the maximum. I ask the witnesses to address why the 15 beds in St. John's were not put to use three months ago, and whether we are making use of all the available bed capacity in the region.

Comment on this

First, Mr. Reid's synopsis of how to deal with the entry point crisis in emergency departments is identical to what the Sláintecare report came up with. The primary focus is the treatment of patients elsewhere in the community. The question is how quickly we can make that happen. I welcome Mr. Reid's inclusion of a bigger input from the pharmacy community, with which I agree. I take this opportunity to recognise that the proposed cuts to pharmacy funding are no longer going ahead, for which I thank the Minister and acknowledge his work in the area. I would add the use of electronic records in emergency departments to fast-track patients, monitor waiting times etc. to Mr. Reid's synopsis.

Our health budget of over €17 billion is up there among developed countries, as it is a high spend per capita. Based on his six months in the job, does Mr. Reid think it possible to start getting value for the money we are spending? Cataract operations are still being carried out in the North of Ireland on a regular basis, for example. Buses go up there from Kerry and Cork. I send patients up there on public transport and they are seen within a number of weeks. Yet, every time I submit a query to the HSE about a cataract operation for a constituent, I receive the standard reply that the waiting list is 18 to 24 months. Surely there is a better way of doing this. We give that money back to these patients, so it is coming out of the same pot. It is quicker and more convenient for a patient in the far south of Ireland to travel up to Belfast to get a cataract procedure done. I cannot see any reason why the system in this country cannot deal with that.

Mr. Reid also spoke about delayed discharges-----

Comment on this

Time, Deputy.

Comment on this

I am nearly done. Delayed discharges in Kerry approached 4,000 bed nights this year. The trolley count for the same period was also around 4,000. A pilot scheme has been initiated which aims to get patients who are not in need of acute beds into community settings. What progress has been made on that, and what is the likelihood that it can be extended full time? The figures correlate, so if one problem is solved, it will go a long way to solving the other.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy. I call Mr. Reid. I am sure he has made a note of all those questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

I will make few comments on the various issues raised. My analysis is definitely in line with Sláintecare. I have not invented anything different. However, I have seen a significant amount of innovation all across our acute and community settings. While Sláintecare is a new direction in terms of pathways to care and devolved regions, we can also scale up and roll out much of what is good in our hospital and community settings. I have seen a significant amount of that in terms of emergency departments, process flow, oversight of bed capacity within a unit, electronic monitoring of beds and centrally managed hubs. We can scale up and roll out much of that innovation, on top of the direction of flight of Sláintecare.

We have to scale up better pathways for treatment. That requires more GPs, more primary care investment and more utilisation of pharmacies. I agree about electronic solutions. Electronic health records will take time and investment. We know it works where we have put it in place. There is a shorter pathway we can take, which is to have a shared record of patients' care between the GP and the acute setting the Chairman has been talking about quite a bit. That is an incremental step that we can take in advance of the major investment in the electronic health records.

On budget spend, outcomes and related issues, an OECD report was published in the past couple of weeks. It is quite good and has a synopsis of this. It demonstrates that health expenditure is above the EU per capita average. Life expectancy in Ireland has increased by almost six years since 2000. The report also states that our general public healthcare is comparable with other OECD countries. It highlights some particular issues that we have with obesity and alcohol, and the demands that places on our services. It is a good report and I recommend browsing it. We have a high standard.

Comment on this

There is a significant difference between being alive and living.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

Sure. On wider issues, I made a point earlier about the investment that we have made. We have an extra €1 billion in health expenditure this year compared to last year, an increase of 6.3%. From what I have seen, investment in the areas we have spoken about is key, as is investing in a different way for the future. We are finalising next year's service plan at the minute and it will start to make that step. As the Deputy will be aware, the way that we can relieve the pressure on acute settings is by investment in community settings. Our service plan for next year starts to make that shift in an incremental way, which is valuable. There is a challenge for us, as I said in our opening statement, about how we manage with the funds that we have in an effective manner to make the right decisions and investments, and to hold local management to account. It has to be about safety, improving access and managing within a budget. Those are three relative challenges that have to be run in parallel, though they are not always conflicting.

I made the point in my opening statement that we have done the State some good this year with our oversight of the health spend. The overrun will be less than half that of last year. The overrun last year was €650 million plus a €150 million first charge for the following year. It will be significantly less than half of that by the outturn this year. That has largely been through the discipline of working with line managers, holding people to account and making sure that we are recruiting in the right places. I know recruitment has been difficult for everybody. We have to make sure we are recruiting where we have a budget and that we are recruiting skills that add to service delivery. The point I made earlier is that we are looking at the centre of the HSE to see what size it should be in the future. I believe it should be scaled down and that we should devolve more of what we have in the HSE centre to the regions to some hospital acute settings and community settings. We have to look at it very differently. That is about management of finances.

With regard to delayed discharges, I spent some time in Kerry in a hospital in an acute setting and in a community setting. I was a little frustrated on the day I was there when it was highlighted that there were some beds available in the community and we had delayed discharges in our community setting. We immediately convened a meeting that evening with the relevant CHO and the hospital manager. The CHO has worked to increase capacity through a number of initiatives that it has put in place since. Some beds were available in Killarney at the time and some of those are being utilised. Some of that is now built into our winter action teams. Kerry has a good interface and integration between community and acute settings. A number of initiatives in community settings are giving relief to acute settings. While they have a challenge in delayed discharges, they had some good initiatives working in a way that we want them to in the future. I hope that answers the Deputy's questions.

Comment on this

Senator Kieran O'Donnell asked a specific question on St. John's hospital and why 15 beds are vacant. We know the questions and need the answers.

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

I was at St. John's hospital on Friday. I understand it had two consultants who retired and it is reliant on two locums. A third locum has been brought in.

Comment on this

They retired in February and June. The hospital had plenty of advance notice. Why were 15 beds left idle for the last three months?

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

I understand there was a challenge in having adequate medical oversight of those beds.

Comment on this

That is not good enough. I am sorry. We have a crisis in Limerick at all times. That answer is not sufficient for me or the people of Limerick. Fifteen beds were idle in St. John's hospital. We were in here just over a month ago highlighting the need for an MRI scanner. We were asked to do it by management and we did it willingly. At the same time, there were 15 beds idle in St. John's. An elderly lady was on a trolley for 48 hours in University Hospital Limerick while 15 beds were idle elsewhere. Ms O'Connor needs to give a satisfactory explanation as to why that happened. When did people at HSE corporate level first become aware that the 15 beds had not been in use in St. John's hospital for the last three months?

Comment on this

We have got the question.

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

On the broader question of how we know about vacant beds, I have a daily call with the senior team. It is not just about the beds in the five acute sites but the beds available in some of our community facilities too, such as step-down-----

Comment on this

I asked a very simple question and I have limited time. When did Ms O'Connor first become aware that 15 of the 89 beds in St. John's hospital had not been in use for the past three months?

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

I became aware on receipt of the proposal. I was at the hospital last weekend.

Comment on this

The proposal only came in last Friday.

Comment on this

We are pleased to have the Senator at our meeting. We have got his question and I ask him to please allow the witness to answer. If he is not happy with the answer, perhaps it will be forwarded to him.

Comment on this

I think the pertinent question is why the central HSE was not asked to open these beds earlier.

Comment on this

That is what I am asking.

Comment on this

The HSE and Department of Health became aware of these beds not being open when we put out a call to the system asking if there were any more beds around the country that could be opened. It is inexcusable that 15 beds in St. John's hospital were not open during a crisis in bed capacity in the UHL hospital group. I also find it inexcusable that doctors from the acute hospital are not willing to go to some of the smaller hospitals such as St. John's. I referred to those two issues when speaking with Deputy Kelly earlier. The process needs to be fixed and there needs to be management accountability. We saw this on television last night and on the front page of a newspaper in recent days. As soon as the proposal came in for the 15 beds, we wrote the cheque.

Comment on this

On the management of beds for the entire group, what is the process whereby-----

Comment on this

We got the question.

Comment on this

It is a supplementary question.

Comment on this

The Senator has asked it already.

Comment on this

The Senator has asked it already. I will call Ms O'Connor and then we will move on.

Comment on this

My specific question is about the management of the beds for the other hospitals in the group.

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

The group is responsible for managing the oversight of beds within acute hospitals. At national level, we look at all of the beds in order that we know how many beds are closed or blocked daily, primarily due to infection. We know that yesterday, across the national system, 111 beds were closed. We also look at the daily availability of beds in community settings. The approach through winter is a key focus for us, to make sure that people are stepping out of the acute settings altogether and moving into relevant step-down facilities and transitional care. At this time, nobody is waiting for transitional care approval. We are trying to match patients from acute settings to community settings and to ensure that people who are ready to move can move.

On Deputy Brassil's question about delayed transfer of care, we are doing a great deal of work on that. Last year, the Minister of State, Deputy Daly, commissioned an independent review on delayed transfers of care. We have been looking at how we record people who are ready to leave acute settings, etc. Since we started to implement our winter initiative in September, one of the key measures that we have looked at is bed days lost. We will always have people in beds but how long they are there for is our challenge. We have reduced the bed days lost by 20% since September on foot of the initiatives we have put in place. We are proactively trying every day to move people who have been waiting the longest from acute hospitals into more appropriate settings.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister, and Mr. Reid and his team. I want to raise a number of issues and I will focus on Limerick. The last time I was here, I mentioned that the blood clinic in UHL closes at 12 noon on a Friday and it needs to be open longer. It is stopping people from being discharged or some end up being sent to the hospital because there is nobody to read their blood count.

In regard to the beds at St. John's, while I welcome the announcement this morning, when I inquired two weeks ago and brought it to the Minister's attention, my understanding was there were 20 beds at that stage. I want to know if five beds have disappeared since that time.

I welcome the centre that was opened last Wednesday by the Minister of State, Deputy Daly, on behalf of the Minister. Mr. Reid referred to new ways of doing things in regard to the discharge of patients. There is a proposal in the capital plan for 120 replacement beds at St. John's hospital. If that was brought forward, it would certainly help to free up the beds in the hospital so procedures could be carried out.

I have a question for the Minister of State, Deputy McGrath, regarding respite. He has a fund for respite homes. St. Gabriel's School and Centre in Limerick has a six-bedroom respite unit ready to go and the HSE released funding recently for a staff member to manage the facility. However, funding to get the rest of the respite centre open is what is necessary. I have spoken to the Minister about it. Will he visit the facility the next time he is in Limerick? It would certainly help young people with disabilities.

Comment on this

My question relates to Valproate. Does the Minister have the Valproate response project report on his desk? Has he been in contact with OACS Ireland and Epilepsy Ireland about this? I asked him before about a public inquiry into this. Is he still open to an independent inquiry or investigation into the prescribing of Valproate, given the teratogenic effects of it were widely known, even back to the 1970s, as well as the increased risk of foetal anticonvulsant syndrome around it? I am asking about an inquiry into who knew what when, and why it continued to be prescribed when there was so much evidence worldwide on the impact it might have.

I have a question for the Minister of State, Deputy McGrath, in regard to the transition period - I do not want to say handover period - for service users going from Western Care to Praxis Care. What is the protocol around the transition period? I have concerns around this. How do we ensure the organisations to which we are signing over the budget have the capacity and have done their recruitment and everything else to have the services and supports in place? The Minister of State knows that for the condition of autism, routine and familiarity are so important. I am concerned that new teams are going in and there is no transition period, so there is no time for the service user to get used to the new practices or that can be done in a way that is streamlined.

Comment on this

I have a question for the Minister. I noted his statement on the RCOG report.

I have ideological issues with the way CervicalCheck has been outsourced. I acknowledge that but I also acknowledge that the Minister needs and wants, and I accept that women must have, confidence in CervicalCheck, that it has to be used, that it is a good thing and that it saves lives. I want to get that out of the way, and I am not confused about it at all.

I am, however, very confused about one aspect of the RCOG report. The NHS screening programme guidance for applying duty of candour in disclosing results, on page 6, states: "... sometimes it can be hard for screening services to know how to distinguish between a false negative/false positive that has occurred because of the limitations of screening and a false negative/false positive that has occurred because something has gone wrong". I am curious as to why that "something has gone wrong" has not tweaked the Minister's interest in investigating what went wrong in the labs. Consistently, in the highlighted court cases that we know of involving women who are still alive and women who have died, they successfully sued the laboratories and have been paid big sums, not out of the goodness of the hearts of those laboratories, but because "something has gone wrong" and, clearly, they are acknowledging that when they pay out vast sums. I want to know why the Minister is not curious that "something has gone wrong", and why we are not examining what went wrong in those labs.

I will give a quick analogy. If there was an accident at Dublin Airport and five or six people were killed, would we investigate the causes and what might have gone wrong, or would we say that those deaths are within the statistical norms of aviation globally, Dublin Airport is working to appropriate health and safety standards, so why would we bother investigating what went wrong? I would like an answer from the Minister as to why he is not interested in investigating what went wrong in those labs. It is connected with my consistent appeal for the figures in regard to which labs the 221+ women's smear tests were carried out in. I am curious as to why that does not bother the Minister. He is comparing the results of the RCOG report for Ireland with the results for the NHS. However, the NHS has acknowledged that sometimes things go wrong but we do not seem to acknowledge or own up to it.

I believe the Minister is going to reopen the audit, which has been closed for a year and a half. In that year and half, some women have had serious results. The best friend of my secretary, who works in Leinster House, is dying from cervical cancer. She was under constant screening because she had a procedure in 2009. The woman, her community and her friends have had to fundraise to have the audit carried out privately and it has cost thousands of euro. It has shown that, in four previous years, the screening had serious, discordant results that were not picked up and then, all of a sudden, she was diagnosed with stage 4 cancer. What can the Minister do for women who are caught between the date the audit closed and when it is going to reopen. When will it reopen?

Comment on this

I apologise but I have to attend a vote in the Seanad. I will pick up the answers.

Comment on this

We will hear the answers now. I call Mr. Woods.

Comment on this
Mr. Liam Woods

In response to Senator Byrne regarding the blood clinic in Dooradoyle, I will come back to the Senator directly or through the committee with an answer, and I will ask the groups to look at that. She asked whether five beds disappeared and the answer is they definitely did not. As the Minister said, there is now funding available through the NTPF to open all beds, so there are patients moving from Dooradoyle.

Comment on this

The figure was 20 and then 15 was mentioned.

Comment on this
Mr. Liam Woods

I hear that. We have funding to open all beds that we can reasonably open in the near term, so that should not be an issue. I will confirm that. On the capital proposal for St. John's that the Senator referenced, I am aware of such a proposal and that will fall to be considered in the HSE capital plan. The final question concerned a respite centre, which is not my responsibility.

Comment on this

I will respond to that. Respite is a very important part of our disability plan and the disability programme for the past 12 months.

It is also part of our reform agenda. We have just completed our 12th new respite house. As a result of the €10 million we got last year, we have 12 new houses up and running throughout the country. We are planning for 33,000 day respite places and 166,000 overnight services after Christmas and in 2020. Respite is a very important part of the agenda. These services are now up and running and will be developed. With regard to St. Gabriel's, I would be delighted to take up the Senator's offer. We are looking at that particular case at the moment. I would be delighted to visit St. Gabriel's and to talk to the staff and families. That is a very important part of my job. A very important part of developing services and of the reform agenda is making sure that the interests of the families and the people who work in the service are protected.

Senator Conway-Walsh has left. With regard to the protocols for transition to get new teenagers going, a lot of preparation is done before 18 year olds move into adult services. Approximately 1,600 people, having hit 18, come into adult services every year. The good news is that we managed to secure an extra €13 million to develop these services and to keep them safe. Every 18 year old that comes out of youth services is now guaranteed a place at an adult day service. That is essential. There has to be preparation for that transition. Most sensible services provide that a few months before people move on to a new service. Many services provide key workers, link workers and meetings with families and parents. If members have any concerns about a particular service, they should not hesitate to contact me because we have to ensure that transitions are as stable as possible for people, and particularly for adults with autism, as these transitions can be very difficult for them and for their families. The 1,600 who come out every year generally do get a place and get on with it. If there are gaps, members should not hesitate in letting me know.

Comment on this

Will the witnesses comment on Senator Conway-Walsh's questions on valproate?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I can furnish the committee with a written reply. The Senator is quite correct in saying that there has been knowledge about valproate for many years. This knowledge was heightened, as it were, in February 2018 when the European Medicines Agency introduced new restrictions. Following that, we instituted a communications and support programme to increase awareness among women of childbearing age. Through working with OACS Ireland, Epilepsy Ireland, and a support team we established, we identified 40 families who may have been affected by valproate. Through that we developed a diagnostic pathway in Crumlin hospital, again working with the agencies I mentioned and members of OACS Ireland, including a consultant geneticist and paediatrician. Following on from that pathway, some of these patients and their families will require supports. We are committed to providing those supports. The Senator is, however, absolutely correct. There has been knowledge about anticonvulsants in pregnancy for many years. It is also true that the degree of the knowledge and the strength of the evidence has become more powerful over time. Our response has, therefore, become more powerful over time. From her own work, the Senator will know that people have been alerted to the use of anticonvulsants in pregnancy. As part of this work, we are introducing nurse practitioners to work in the area of women in pregnancy who are on anticonvulsants, in recognition of the greater risk presented by these drugs, even beyond valproate.

Comment on this

I believe the Senator asked about a report. She asked whether those in the Department had it on their desk.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

Yes. We did provide a report summarising all of this work.

Comment on this

I was just following up as the Senator is not here to do so.

Comment on this

When will that report be ready?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

We have provided the report to the Department of Health.

Comment on this

When will it be published?

Comment on this

Will it be published?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

It was not prepared for publication but I do not believe there would be an issue in doing so. We will look at it and make sure it is-----

Comment on this

We will send it to the committee providing there is no issue with publication. We will just check first.

Comment on this

With regard to Dr. Henry's comments on specialist nurses to help people through pregnancy, on valproate-----

Comment on this

I am sorry. We will let Deputy O'Connell in on another round. Deputy Bríd Smith had asked questions on the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, RCOG, report and on audit.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Bríd Smith for raising these questions. I had intended to say this to the 221+ group in writing first but, in the interests of clarity, the €2,000 payment recommended in the Scally report will be provided to the people who participated.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister say "No" initially and then change his mind?

Comment on this

I did not say "No" initially. Just because a headline said that I did, it does not mean that is the case. I received a letter from patient advocates last week and I said that I would come back to them on the issue.

Comment on this

Why did the HSE write-----

Comment on this

I will allow Deputy Kelly to speak in a minute.

Comment on this

I considered the factual position. As Deputy Kelly knows, when one is a Minister one is given advice and information and one then considers it and makes a decision. Some were of the valid view that Dr. Scally had recommended that a payment of €2,000 be made to people who engaged with this process because they went through considerable expense and inconvenience. Those who participated in the RCOG process also incurred costs and expenses in seeing clinicians and so on. I will be confirming that in writing. I know Deputy Bríd Smith did not ask about that directly but I thought it was pertinent to what she said.

Comment on this

This woman participated in none of these reviews. She was left out of everything.

Comment on this

I will get to that in a moment. I just wanted to make that point because it would be disingenuous not to do so while I was here. I do not have a lack of curiosity with regard to what happens in the labs, as the Deputy suggested. In consultation with the patient advocates, we commissioned work on the laboratory breakdown for the 221+ group. I shared that with the patient advocates and with this committee and I have taken questions on it in the Houses of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

Has that report been published?

Comment on this

It has certainly been sent to this committee. If the Deputy does not have a copy I will provide her with one directly.

Comment on this

I do have it but I was told that it had not been published publicly.

Comment on this

As the patient representatives and this committee both have copies, I consider it published. It is freely available to Members of the Oireachtas, patient advocates, and anyone else who wants it. I have spoken about it at length in the Dáil.

Comment on this

We have also seen Dr. Scally's reports in which he found serious difficulties with regard to procurement and a number of other issues. I do not have his words in front of me, but he did say that he did not find anything to be substandard or that there were any safety concerns. On top of that, we now have the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists answering the question as to whether the programme was working effectively. As I said to the Chair at the start of this meeting, I am conscious that this committee is hearing directly from RCOG next week and that it would be clumsy of me to endeavour to explain its work when it is more qualified to do so itself.

I will now address the question on audit. Dr. Henry may wish to add to my response. I know a number of groups are doing work on interval cancers, following Dr. Scally's recommendations. Audit is a really good thing. This debacle arose from an audit that was intended to disclose but never did, thereby causing people a lot of pain and hurt. It is really important that we get audit right. That is a key recommendation made by Dr. Scally. Deputy Kelly has made a point vociferously several times and I believe Deputy Bríd Smith is making a similar point. They are asking about the people affected today. There is no audit ongoing. When the audits recommence, will these people be covered? I cannot pre-empt the expert group review but my view is that these people absolutely have to be covered. Dr. Henry may also have a view. There cannot be a gap in my view but, obviously, I want to follow the expert group's recommendations. Dr. Henry may have information to offer the committee in that regard. This might be helpful but-----

Comment on this

What will happen for this woman? The community has had to raise funds. It is a poor working-class community but it has had to raise funds in order that she could have an audit done privately. She wanted to know what went wrong. She has now found out through a private audit. It is curious. I have a letter from the HSE. This woman gave me a copy. It says that the HSE will give her the slides as long as she tells it where her audit is being done because it has to be sure about that.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputy. We have the question.

Comment on this

It suggests the HSE was not sure about the laboratories that were carrying out the smear tests in the first place. What went wrong for her and for the women who have been paid vast sums of money?

Comment on this

With respect, I do not know what, if anything, went wrong because the Deputy is talking about an individual case.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not curious as to what went wrong?

Comment on this

I am aware of the limitations of screening, as is the Deputy. I am aware that cervical cancer is a most devastating disease and that it disproportionately affects younger women. I would like Dr. Henry to talk about them.

Comment on this

The NHS says something else can go wrong and that something else seems to be missing.

Comment on this

We have the Deputy's question.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

With regard to the laboratory report, when one looks at laboratories one sees a whole range of quality assurance measures. As we know from the laboratory report provided here, the number of false negatives is very small in the context of the overall workload of the laboratory. It is therefore very difficult to draw conclusions. There are other measures which are equally, if not more, important such as the number of false positives. These can cause much distress and unnecessary interventions and, in some cases, invasive surgery. Another measure is the number of high-grade findings. Because of the huge numbers in each laboratory, it is difficult to draw definitive conclusions from the report.

One other point worth making is on the timeline of the cervical cancer screening programme which started in 2008. One would have expected a higher degree of findings at the beginning of the programme because no screening programme had existed beforehand. There are a number of confounders when one tries to examine the relative performance of false negatives in each laboratory, for example, the timing of the laboratory for the programme and the demographics, that is, the population that that laboratory will serve.

On interval cancer, I acknowledge that Deputy Kelly showed an interest in this matter in previous hearings. There cannot be any gap in this regard and we recognise the position of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists on an interval cancer audit. It is worth reminding people that the core purpose of interval cancer audit, in fact any audit, is learning and improvement. Interval cancer audit tied to the duty of candour, as prevails in England and Wales, mean that the results of false negatives would be communicated to everyone.

Comment on this

This is not just interval cancer audit but full audit.

Comment on this

I am sorry, Deputy Smith, but-----

Comment on this

There have been many interruptions.

Comment on this

Representatives of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists will be before the committee next week.

Comment on this

I am aware of that. I want the Minister to acknowledge that something else can go wrong. I read from the chapter-----

Comment on this

The Deputy is welcome to attend that meeting.

Comment on this

Taking up that point, no minister for health anywhere in the world would suggest that things cannot go wrong in a health service, beyond the limitations of any procedure. Of course, that is the case. As the Deputy knows, determining that in Ireland is an adversarial process which needs to be reformed. That is why we have asked Mr. Justice Charles Meenan to do a body of work on tort reform. He is due to deliver an interim report any day now and definitely by the end of this year. I hope that report will guide us in how to deal with things better without people having to go to court on all occasions.

Comment on this

Women are going to court-----

Comment on this

The Deputy and I cannot determine-----

Comment on this

-----because that "something else" is not being identified.

Comment on this

The Deputy's time is up.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

It is important to note that the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, in its report, notes that the degree of discordance found in its exercise, looking back in an unblinded way, is no different from a much larger exercise carried out in England and Wales on a much greater number of people. This is the only occasion on which we have had such an investigation of the cervical screening in a robust and methodological way in this country.

Comment on this

That is not correct. If it was, laboratories would not be paying out millions of euro to women who had discordant results.

Comment on this

On mesh, can the Minister advise if it is his intention that the suspension will remain in place pending the outcome of the deliberations of the task force? I received correspondence from the Minister on a European urogynaecology task force report that is due. Will the suspension remain in place?

Comment on this

The suspension will remain in place until the chief medical officer and chief clinical officer advise me and the HSE to the contrary. As I informed the Deputy at our meeting, there are no imminent plans to lift that suspension and there is much work to do before we would be in a position to do so.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister. Mr. Reid referred to bringing agency work to what he described as affordable and sustainable levels. My views on agency work are well known and I do not think anyone will disagree with me that it represents a very expensive way to run the health service. Has Mr Reid set targets in respect of personnel, money and conversion? In the event that a hospital manager is proactive in taking the initiative on this issue, on which there appears to be a lack of leadership, and manages to convert from agency to directly employed staff, will the money saved be put directly into staff or will that dependent on remaining within budget?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

We want to reduce our agency spend. All budget holders have a target this year and next year to reduce it. Some areas have been quite innovative in converting to full-time equivalent staff. To provide some context, 94.6% of our budgetary spend on labour is direct labour, so 5.4% is agency spend. The predominance of that is in medical and healthcare assistance.

Comment on this

How many millions of euro does that represent?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

I will get the Deputy that figure in the moment. It represents 5% of our total payroll. As the Deputy will know, 80% of HSE employees are women and a high proportion of the workforce, some 35%, works reduced hours. We want to support this as it is important.

There will always be a level of agency spend and we are very open to anybody who is creative in reducing it. It is 5% of the total.

Comment on this

My question was very simple. Have targets been set?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

They have been set for this year and next year.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Reid share those with us?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

They will be in our service plan.

Comment on this

Are they for money savings or hours saved?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

The target is for reduced money spend on agency services.

Comment on this

A target has been set.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

There is a target this year and next year as well.

Comment on this

The urgent care centre in Connolly Hospital Dublin did not open at the promised time. As has been acknowledged, this was due to an inability to staff the unit and recruit consultant paediatricians. The Tallaght urgent care centre is planned for 2020. Does the HSE have a staffing plan in place? The number of consultants in the system appears to be insufficient, with a shortfall to the tune of 500. The Minister will be aware that the consultants have expressed no confidence in him and that view is shared by many. I do not intend that in a personal way but it is a matter of public record. We have a recruitment and retention crisis among consultants. We discussed the case of a pain consultant for Crumlin earlier. The urgent care centre is only open on a nine-to-five basis at the moment, which is not what was promised, and the centre in Tallaght is due to open in 2020. Will it open on time? Can the Minister say with any degree of confidence what the opening hours will be, given that both he and the Taoiseach gave a commitment that the urgent care centre in Connolly would be open from 8 a.m. until midnight, seven days a week?

Comment on this

The urgent care centre in Connolly Hospital Dublin is currently open from 10 a.m. until 5 p.m. I would like those hours extended by an hour either side, that is, from 9 a.m. until 6 p.m. Children's Health Ireland is working on that.

I have no confidence in some of the work practices of our consultants - absolutely none - when I see private practice and income being put ahead of the public health service. I am sure the Deputy will stand with me when I table proposals shortly to pay consultants much more money. In return, however, consultants will be expected to work in the public health service. It will also be expected that public beds will used for public practice and public patients, as in the case that was so well articulated by the Deputy earlier. It may make the Deputy politically uncomfortable but on this issue, I believe the gap or difference between us is smaller than on many other issues. The Fianna Fáil Party has not yet made its position clear on this issue, whereas the Labour Party, Sinn Féin and Fine Gael have. We believe consultants should be paid much more but if they want to do private practice, they should do it in private hospitals, not in our public hospitals. We will have to pay them much more to do that.

There is no free money here. Nurses and midwives did not get any free money. When they were offered an enhanced contract, better pay and conditions and improved career prospects, they agreed to a number of changes to work practices, as did our GPs. So too will our pharmacists and dentists, and likewise our consultants. No one is protected beyond reproach or scrutiny. I am certainly not but nobody else is either.

We will have a plan on Tallaght. I am sure Ms Éilish Hardiman, the chief executive officer of Children's Health Ireland, who is responsible for this facility, can brief the committee on this matter. The Tallaght urgent care centre is due to open towards the end of next year. We will have tabled significant proposals long in advance of that offering consultants much more money to work in the public health service and I emphasis the public aspect of the health service. I need to make this point, because one will not hear it anywhere else. Throughout the 2000s - the years of economic boom - there were approximately 7,000 doctors working in the Irish public health service. There are now more than 10,000 doctors in the health service. While we have vacancies and there is more to do, there are approximately 3,000 more doctors working in our public hospitals than there were in 2007, 2008 and 2009.

Comment on this

I listened to Mr. Reid's comments on overcrowding in accident and emergency departments and I accept his point on changes that have to be made in other areas to ensure these problems are solved. I am with him 100% on that but the problem of resources is staring us in the face.

If I see changes in resources, particularly the area I pointed out, I will go with the Minister immediately. If I do not see changes in resources, I will not because the Minister ultimately has that choice to make. I have pointed this out numerous times. I am staying with him but only for a short time because if he does not deal with the resources gap, that is his issue. That is just reality.

Will he respond regarding John Wall and the medical card? Deputy O'Reilly, myself and others have raised this. It is a genuine case and a genuine issue for terminally ill patients. We should react positively.

I previously raised an issue with the Minister and Mr. Reid of a woman for whom it cost more than €100,000 to get her gallbladder out. That happened over 11 weeks and involved two hospitals. I never received a response. How can a gallbladder operation cost more than €100,000 and how can someone spend 11 weeks in hospital? It is insane and multiple hospitals are involved as well as the public-private issue. It was meant to be investigated but I never received an answer.

On 5 December at 2.25 p.m. a letter issued from the HSE stating that all the people in the RCOG review were not getting the €2,000. I welcome what the Minister and the Taoiseach have done today but the fact is that the people around the Minister here, representing the HSE, wrote to the 221+ group and told them they would not get it. There is no joined-up thinking. The Minister might reflect on that. Why did that happen?

I refer to the Bernadette Kiely case, and I mention her name only because it is public, in the context of non-disclosure and the issues surrounding that. Representatives from RCOG will be before the committee next week but has the Minister initial concerns he would like to share with us? How does he feel when Lorraine Walsh, Stephen Teap, Vicky Phelan - people whom he knows well, as do I - say they have no confidence in the RCOG review? If these people do not have confidence based on what we publicly know, that is scary. Why in that review was there a default that anyone whose slides could not be found were sent concordant letters? Surely they should have been concordant and discordant, and a small number should have said there was something missing and a decision could not be made. That would have been logical. I refer to those who have serious concerns about the credibility of the review. I was not filled with encouragement last week when the college was unable to answer some basic questions. A small number of these women would like an independent assessment of their files. I am sure that will happen anyway, but unlike the now-resolved matter of the €2,000, can we please just deal with this now and give a positive answer to the question? I do not think there is a large number of women in this category who would voluntarily want to go down this route but there is a significant number. For the cost involved, the Minister should just do so. I ask that he consider that.

Comment on this

I will ask Dr. Henry to comment on some of the RCOG matters. The Deputy and I both know Mr. John Wall well. He is a great individual and a great advocate. I met him most recently three weeks ago and he was also in touch with me yesterday. We set up a new clinical advisory group to look at what is going to be an expansion of the access to medical cards for people with a terminal illness. That is in the budget book. The CEO of the HSE and I agreed that in advance of budget day. From memory - and John Wall asked me this yesterday - they hoped it would have its first meeting on 18 December and I understand that is still the intention. Mr. Wall will be invited to make a presentation. There is an eight-week clock on it so it should be finished by February. I will keep John Wall and the Deputy informed on that. I had a good meeting with Mr. Wall on it.

Comment on this

There is no budget.

Comment on this

It will be dealt with from the primary care reimbursement service, PCRS, budget. I know the Deputy made a pre-budget submission which was generous and set a large sum aside for it. It will not be that large but I am happy to let the consultant applications advisory committee, CAAC, do its work first.

I will not comment on individual cases, although I do not think that the Deputy is asking me to, including that of Ms Kiely other than to say that I have given a commitment to meet her and I will. I will ask Dr. Henry to comment on the broader issue of disclosure, which is important.

Finally, on the broader RCOG issues, I know Stephen, Lorraine and Vicky very, very well. I hold them all in huge regard. Stephen has written me a letter on two issues.

I addressed one this morning and we are considering the other. I will respond to him directly on it. I would feel happier for RCOG to answer those questions in a public forum here next week.

Comment on this

Will the Minister answer those questions after that meeting, though?

Comment on this

Of course, I will, yes.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot stay off the record on this.

Comment on this

I am very clearly on the record that I do have confidence in the RCOG report, that I have thanked the college for it and that I think it is a very robust piece of work. I am not trying to stay off the record on it.

Comment on this

My point on the RCOG report is that approximately 100 colposcopy reviews were done as part of this process which is raising other issues which Dr. Henry might deal with. The Minister's commentary around the review is that it goes to confidence in screening, etc. I am not even going there; that is not my issue. I want to have as much confidence in this as possible, just like everyone else. However, that is not what this is about; this is about the individual women. The three people who brought this up say that they do not have confidence in the process. Let us consider what happened to Lorraine Walsh and Vicky Phelan. Out of 1,051 women, three files were mislabelled and two were those of Vicky Phelan and Lorraine Walsh. A person would win the Euromillions quicker than this. It is incredible that Lorraine Walsh received two reports 24 hours apart saying opposite things and we now know other women received concordant results, despite some of their data slides being unavailable.

Comment on this

We will get answers to those questions next Wednesday morning.

Comment on this

I know but the Minister needs to answer. I have no problem with him doing it next week but he does need to answer.

Comment on this

And he has committed to doing that.

Comment on this

I have been clear that I met RCOG. I asked if it was satisfied about its independence and it said it has never been surer of anything. Its expertise is beyond reproach. It is true that there were errors around wrong letters and so on that it has apologised for. I do not feel as though I have the competency to go beyond that on the methodology the RCOG used. Dr. Henry has significant competencies.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

Deputy Kelly raised an individual case and he will understand that I would not like to comment on an individual case. On the issues he raised, we know more from Dr. Scally's report and the RCOG report about the original audit where all this began. Dr. Scally described it as well intended and flawed in design and implementation. The focus of the audit by CervicalCheck, like all similar international exercises, was on cytology but it looked at other elements of the screening pathway. The problem was, as we now know, that as Dr. Scally noted, it was "impossible to reach a firm conclusion on the methods employed" in the audit based on his inquiries and "a complete presentation of the audit outcome data was impossible to locate". For that reason, we welcome a more robust, standardised independent review which, we hope, will give greater assurance than one which was well intended but flawed in its design and implementation and which looked primarily at cytology but also other elements of the screening pathway.

Comment on this

What of the request for independent reviews? I did not get an answer on that. What is Dr. Henry's view on that?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I understand -----

Comment on this

Can we wait until the RCOG report?

Comment on this

I would like Dr. Henry's opinion on it.

Comment on this

We have to hear from RCOG to see what the issues were.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connell and Durkan are next, and the Minister is under a little pressure.

Comment on this

I do not need to ask the Minister anything. I seek an answer on the question on Valproate for Dr. Henry. Did Deputy Durkan wish to ask something?

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

I will take written replies to my questions. I raised the question of drugs treatment. I am not satisfied. There is a greater emphasis now on acceptance and that it is inevitable that people are addicts and that nothing can be done about it. That is a mistake. I ask questions on the number of drug treatment programmes that are offered to addicts or users of drugs and the results among those who were successfully encouraged off drugs, those who were not, and those who were not offered a programme at all.

I also mentioned child mental health services and the lack of maternity cover for speech and language therapists.

The result is a gap in treatment for the child concerned, which is hugely negative. What is being done about that? It is not something that is going to cost €10 million or even €1 million. It is something simple and could make a huge contribution in the context of the treatment of the child.

Comment on this

We will let the Minister go now and ask the officials to answer those questions.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

That is fine.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for his time.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

The Deputy is looking for statistical information on the drug treatment programme. I am happy to pull what we have together and provide it to the Deputy by way of written reply, if that is acceptable.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

Yes, as long as the emphasis is on what I have been suggesting.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Breslin

With an emphasis on results, yes.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

What about maternity cover for speech and language therapists? The lack of such cover is leaving a very sizeable gap, especially for children who have difficulty communicating or who cannot communicate at all. There is a serious flaw in the system which must be addressed immediately.

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

We have a very high percentage of females in our workforce across all of our multidisciplinary services, including CAMHS. We try to cover gaps in service but it is not always possible. The provision of maternity cover is a challenge for us. We can often have a lot of staff on maternity leave at the same time. The approach, particularly in CAMHS, is multidisciplinary and we try to move resources around to cover. We do what we can with the resources we have but it is not always possible to cover all maternity leave.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

Given what I said earlier, it is necessary to evaluate the situation again to see what can be done. What would it cost to provide cover in order to address the issue? It is not impossible and does not require rocket science. It can be done and it could have a significant impact on the quality of treatment for children and on their families' quality of life.

Comment on this

I thank our guests-----

Comment on this

May I ask a question on valproate?

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this

Mention was made of specialist nurses in response to a question posed by Senator Conway-Walsh. I am aware that data has been available on the impact of valproate on foetal development. In terms of where we are now with the existing cohort, it is my understanding that when female patients who have epilepsy talk to their GPs about having a family, they are moved from valproate to levetiracetam or something more suitable to a hospital environment. They get an infusion and come off valproate before starting a family. Is that something that is ad hoc, where the individual GP takes responsibility or is there a programme in place to guide women through this before they become pregnant so they can manage their medication?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

The Deputy is absolutely right that the best time to make a decision is in advance, before any harm can ensue. In putting together this particular programme, we had to bear in mind that we did not want to alarm people who might, for example, have unstable epilepsy. We did not want them to stop taking their medications abruptly which could cause greater harm. The whole thrust of the programme was to ensure that they got the best and most expert advice, balancing the risks of changing or coming off medication against staying on medication which might harm a developing foetus. The bigger question to which the Deputy refers is access to specialist care and advice. I presume she is not just interested in Valproate but in other anticonvulsant drugs. Working with the epilepsy programme, led by Dr. Colin Doherty, we are developing a specific programme. We have now appointed two out of a planned six specialist nurses for pregnant women who are on anticonvulsant medication so that we can target them early with primary care and afford them the best advice. We want to ensure that their epilepsy remains stable because abrupt withdrawal can be quite harmful. We also want to make sure that they are on the safest possible medication at the safest dose.

Comment on this

I would see a role for community pharmacists here because they are the people who generally sell the folic acid and pregnancy tests and who also dispense medication to patients with long-term illnesses. They are very much aware of patients' history and in well-established community pharmacies, they would have seen girls growing up and going through different phases of treatment.

While I am in favour of specialist nurses, I am of the view that there is a role for community pharmacists here in terms of explaining the science. What is commonly lost in the chat about valproate is the issue of balance, as just described by Dr. Henry. The risk to the woman and to the pregnancy of abruptly stopping medication must be weighed up. If a woman with an unplanned pregnancy who is on valproate turns up at a doctor's surgery, she should be told that just stopping is not the solution. That point is often lost in the argument.

On the RCOG report, Deputy Kelly stated that he is not filled with encouragement. I am of the opposite view, particularly having met representatives from RCOG. I felt that they were full of integrity and that their independence was guaranteed. Perhaps their answers are not the answers that some of us wanted to hear but the answers we got in the private briefing last week gave me some solace. I now feel that the future might be better. There have been constant calls for a reopening of the audit process. To my mind, this all went wrong with the audit. Somebody decided to conduct an audit without considering how to deal with the results and with the fact that real people were involved, either deceased women's families or women who had adverse outcomes. Consideration was not given to the results, the impact of same or the issue of open disclosure, and all of that fed into this crisis for people. It is important that there is some balance here. While I was not necessarily filled with encouragement, I felt confident that the RCOG representatives were independent and were not in the pocket of anyone, as has been suggested.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

I agree completely. One of the valuable resources for us, in working through the valproate project, was working with community pharmacists who are in a unique position in terms of access to women who are at risk for valproate exposure in pregnancy because such women are known to them. I definitely see a role for them in this programme, which is headed by Dr. Colin Doherty. I will talk to him about how we can use community pharmacists to best effect.

Comment on this

I thank Dr. Henry.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

I asked a question earlier and did not get an answer. I asked about troubleshooting when there is obvious overcrowding at accident and emergency departments. Overcrowding is reported to a central location and it should be possible to identify precisely the cause of same. It is no good just saying that it is a sign of the times. If it is a sign of the times and we are not able to meet the requirements that exist, we must address that. We need to know the cause of the overcrowding. Is it because there are not enough doctors, both GPs and hospital doctors? We need to know the cause of the problem. We spend most of our time moaning about it. I spend an inordinate amount of time asking questions about it, as do most Members of the Houses. We must troubleshoot and find out what is causing the backlog in certain places. What is the cause of the snarl up?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

Ms O'Connell touched on this earlier. We have a service delivery unit, members of which go into accident and emergency departments to ascertain where the choke points exist. They examine whether it is the number of clinicians on duty, staffing levels, nursing numbers or flow-through processes in the hospitals. They have been in place and active all over the country and are particularly engaged in the winter period.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

What do they do in terms of dealing with the problem?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Reid

They come out specifically and work with line managers around the actions that are required at that point in time, as well as over the coming days and weeks, to address the pressure points. Separately, as stated earlier, a review of nine sites is being undertaken. That will look at some of the wider issues across our emergency departments in the context of flow-through. We take full cognisance of the issues in real time. We are also engaging in a wider review of our emergency department processes.

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

As mentioned earlier, there are daily calls. I have a daily call, where we look at the sites that are in trouble on that day and take immediate action to move people, if possible or to provide extra support. That happens every day throughout the winter period.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

We must ensure that all space available in hospitals is utilised.

Comment on this
Ms Anne O'Connor

Yes. There are nine winter action teams throughout the country.

Every day, somebody from the national team dials into their calls. As a result, we have a direct line to the local teams to see what needs to happen.

Comment on this
Bernard Durkan Deputy Bernard J. Durkan Fine Gael

I thank Ms O'Connor.

Comment on this
Mr. Liam Woods

A question was asked by Senator Maria Byrne about the blood clinic in Dooradoyle. It is a morning clinic. The space is used for another clinic in the afternoon but the phlebotomists go to the emergency department to support venepuncture and other services. It is not that the service is not being provided, it is moved to the emergency department.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Woods. On behalf of the committee, I thank the Minister for Health, Deputy Harris, the Ministers of State at the Department, Deputies Finian McGrath and Catherine Byrne, and the Secretary General of the Department, Mr. Jim Breslin. From the HSE, I thank the CEO, Mr. Paul Reid, the chief clinical officer, Dr. Colm Henry, Ms Anne O'Connor and Mr. Liam Woods for attending. Is it agreed that we adjourn until Tuesday, 17 December at 5 p.m.? Agreed.

Comment on this