We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

JOINT COMMITTEE ON HEALTH AND CHILDREN

Quarterly Update on Health Issues: Discussion with Minister for Health and Children and HSE

Contributions 137–288 of 288. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Brian Gilroy

All that has been sold this year has yielded €10 million. By 31 December we will have €10 million worth of cash in. We will have spent more than €30 million. So more than the amount that has been achieved from the land sales is being spent on mental health.

Comment on this

That is very clear. I thank Mr. Gilroy.

Comment on this

On the signalled programme of works, when is it intended to progress the proposed new admissions unit for the Cavan-Monaghan psychiatric services, I believe in the grounds of Cavan General Hospital?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

I do not have the exact date in front of me, but it is true that it will be progressed next year. It is in line with the programme we published in March. We had a series of projects that would happen this year, next year and the following year. My recollection of that one is that it will be in the middle of next year. There has been no impact on that programme. No projects have been cancelled and none is being delayed. For example, a planning issue has set back developments in Grangegorman by a month or two and a similar situation exists with Beaumont.

The national paediatric hospital funding is in place and remains in our envelope. There were questions about the shortfall in funding. By the time we get to construction contracts, I do not believe that shortfall will be as large because the projections still have contingency and inflation figures. If the construction environment remains as it is, more savings that can be achieved will close that gap further. Many of the areas of spend in that part of the envelope are "nice to have" rather than "need to have". The core funding in there at the moment of €450 million will deliver everything that children will touch in the hospital. The other pieces we are talking about would be research facilities and other types of facilities. So the core funding is there and we do not see the project as being under any threat. Even following yesterday's announcement of the four-year recovery plan, the funding for the hospital is still there.

Comment on this

Speaking in the Seanad, the Minister recently told us there was a shortfall of €110 million and also €90 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

Yes.

Comment on this

The €110 million was going to be raised from charitable donations and the €90 million was going to be raised through parking, coffee shops and other facilities. Is Mr. Gilroy now saying he does not expect there will be a €200 million shortfall?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

We hope to be in the market in the second quarter of next year. If construction prices remain as they are, the overall costs will have reduced without any change in the scope, because we still have contingencies for the possibility of construction prices rising. If they do not rise, that gap closes further.

Comment on this

Assuming they do not rise, what does Mr. Gilroy estimate the shortfall might be? If it was €200 million a week ago, can he be serious?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

If we see construction prices continuing as they are, another €30 million or €40 million could come off the overall bill.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Gilroy.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Deputy Jan O’Sullivan Labour Party

This is the first time I have heard there are bits of it we could do without. For example, Mr. Gilroy mentioned the research facilities.

Comment on this

We can get a note from Mr. Gilroy on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

I can give a comprehensive note on it.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Deputy Jan O’Sullivan Labour Party

We had understood there was a shortfall of more than €100 million.

Comment on this

We will get an advice note and we can proceed with the other questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

The accident and emergency unit in Limerick is being actively reviewed for inclusion in the critical care block and we are working with the staff locally on that issue. To cover another national issue, it looks like we are about to conclude negotiations on the primary care centre in Tallaght and we will see one advance in the centre.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Deputy Charlie O’Connor Fianna Fáil

The reply I got suggests the end of 2011. I take it Mr. Gilroy is somewhat more optimistic than that.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

We will conclude negotiations and then it will require fit-out, etc. It could be that time before it opens.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Deputy Charlie O’Connor Fianna Fáil

However, it will progress.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

We would be in contract and that is what we expect to see happen.

Comment on this
Charlie O'Connor Deputy Charlie O’Connor Fianna Fáil

That is good.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

I believe Deputy Charles Flanagan asked about the legal tendering process. We are dealing with 11 different health boards and various different hospitals throughout the system. The difficulty in providing a more detailed answer for the Deputy was the cost coding used down through the years is different in each of the health boards. So although we were able to extract solicitor fees, we could not easily extract counsel fees because a counsel fee would be included with a settlement. We have not even been able to do this for our own national tender. One bill would be received and it would be costed to a particular centre. That is the difficulty in providing a subdivision; it would require going back into every single office, pulling out the paper invoices and dividing it to provide a more detailed response. I assure the Deputy we are hoping to bring to our board a proposal following a national tendering process on the legal issue. If that is approved in December we could report back to the committee and I believe many of the issues the Deputy has raised and the concerns he has will be addressed in the new process we will be adopting. However, I would prefer that to have been examined by our own board first.

Comment on this

Can I communicate directly with somebody because I am not happy with the process?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Gilroy

I would be happy to meet the Deputy on the matter. We are still seeing progress in primary care centres and while there have been delays in some parts of the country, many of those delays are down to the funding institutions being used as opposed to any other issues. As recently as last month I met representatives of Bank of Ireland who stated they would happily fund more of these if people approached the bank about them. We have also had discussions with a private equity firm from London which is on the brink of investing €100 million in primary care centre projects. While I appreciate some projects are not progressing, in many cases that is down to the funding institutions being used or the legacy of some of the promoters with regard to their financial status.

The cystic fibrosis unit in St. Vincent's Hospital is under contract and construction is under way. The only issue of delay related to adhering to public procurement. We went with the timescales we outlined.

The preferred bidder we selected had to post bonds and prove its ability to finance the scheme. It failed to do so within the specified period of time, so we moved on to the next bidder. The contract has now been placed with the next bidder.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Gilroy and congratulate him on the work he is doing. Has Mr. Magee said everything he wishes to say?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

I ask my colleague, Mr. Martin Rogan, who is the HSE's director of mental health, to respond to the questions that were asked about the recently published report on child and adolescent psychiatry.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Rogan

The second report on child and adolescent psychiatry was published on Tuesday of this week. Significant progress has been made in this area. The number of children waiting for these services has decreased. The length of time they have to wait has also reduced significantly. Some 49% of children are seen by a mental health professional within a month of referral. Some 67% of them are seen within three months. Emergency presentations of children who may be at risk of self-harm are dealt with immediately, without any waiting time. Significant progress has been made in that area.

A member of the committee asked about the treatment of children in adult units. We operate 42 approved adult centres. We are pleased to say that in 40 of those units, no child under the age of 16 has been treated since July 2009. We will open two brand new units in the next few weeks, one at Merlin Park in Galway and one at Bessborough in Cork. These world-class facilities will meet the needs of young people with mental health problems. A great deal of progress has been made in this regard.

I wish to reiterate what Mr. Gilroy said about mental health capital programmes. I have worked in this area for almost 30 years. In any given year, we normally have one large mental health capital project. This year, we have 16 such projects. As a result of the substantial progress that has been made in this respect, the quality and calibre of the facilities we use will be greatly enhanced.

Primary care services represent an important part of the primary care sector. Approximately 90% of mental health issues present in primary care. Many of them do not progress beyond primary care. Approximately 10% of them are referred on to secondary services. At present, there are 14 mental health professionals working in primary care teams nationally. There has been an improvement in this area.

We have developed a programme in conjunction with our colleagues at Dublin City University. We are now in the second cohort of the programme, which relates to team-based approaches to mental health in primary care. The aim of the programme is to increase the skill set, competence and confidence of workers in the primary care sector as they try to recognise and address mental health issues. We are very encouraged. We are undertaking a survey at the moment. We have had over 150 returns from primary care and community mental health teams. There are good protocols in place. Although we would like to improve on it, it is looking very promising at the moment.

There is no doubt that the area of self-harm and suicide is of grave concern. Last year, some 527 people completed suicide, which represented an increase of 24% on previous years. There are approximately 12,000 presentations of this nature in emergency departments each year. Research has suggested that a further 60,000 people do not present for treatment in these circumstances.

Helplines are very valuable for people in distress. The moment of crisis often arrives in the middle of the night, when some other services are not available. We are working with a number of non-governmental organisations and helpline providers. During the year to 30 September last, the Samaritans received over 310,000 calls, which represented an increase of 10%. We have developed a number of initiatives to deal with this area of concern. We are working on self-harm supports with our colleagues in the HSE and the NGO sector.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Deputy Jan O’Sullivan Labour Party

I asked a question about the mental health budget.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Rogan

In relation to-----

Comment on this

We will take a couple of supplementary questions together.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Deputy Jan O’Sullivan Labour Party

I would like an answer to my initial question about the mental health budget.

Comment on this

I asked a question about the 5% budget cut. I also asked where and when a support hostel for the Clonmel area will be provided. I acknowledge and admit that Clonmel is not the centre of the universe.

Comment on this

It is for the Senator.

Comment on this

This an important matter for people with mental health difficulties in south and north Tipperary. It has been announced that the existing services will close by 30 June next, even though community services are not in place. It is perfectly reasonable to ask this question and to expect an answer.

Comment on this

I referred earlier to the 2009-10 annual report on mental health services for children and adolescents. I will mention some of the statistics in the report. At the end of September 2010, some 2,370 children and adolescents were waiting to be seen. I gave the percentages earlier. These are the actual figures. Some 1,611 children have been waiting for more than three months. Some 402 children have been waiting for a year. These children and adolescents are actual human beings. They have been waiting for up to a year because they do not have the money to pay for these services. It is a very serious issue.

Comment on this

Let us hear from Mr. Rogan on these important matters.

Comment on this

I reiterate that the Samaritans provide a listening service. They do not take a proactive approach to people who are in a suicidal crisis. We need a proper national suicide helpline that can take a proactive approach.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Rogan

The most recent report on waiting times for child and adolescent services is the second such report. The previous report and audit was done in March 2007. At one stage, approximately 3,600 children were waiting for these services. That figure has now been reduced to 2,700, which is a significant improvement. I agree with the well-made point that the distress of young people also affects their families. Emergency presentations are seen on a clinically prioritised basis. Significant progress has been made in reducing the waiting list and we intend to reduce it further. Our 55 child and adolescent teams are working very hard on that topic.

Comment on this

I asked whether the blackspots around the country where there is no service have been addressed.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Rogan

Services for young people are provided throughout the Twenty-six Counties. I have spoken to Senator Prendergast about St. Michael's unit in Clonmel on a number of occasions. It currently offers inpatient services to patients from north and south Tipperary. Patients in north Tipperary will migrate back into the mid-western service. One of our senior managers has been assigned to oversee that process. One of my own staff members has been actively involved in planning that.

Additional community developments are taking place in the Tipperary area. For example, a 40-bed adapted community nursing unit is being developed on the existing campus. The accommodation provided to service users and staff at the new facility will be far superior to that currently offered. We can correspond directly with the committee to provide details of where buildings will be provided under a number of capital programmes. We are working with our colleagues in estates to provide crisis houses and other support options to patients in south Tipperary.

Comment on this

It seems that the expected outcome of the sale of HSE lands has not been realised. In our area, we were very rich because we had so many lands in our ownership. They were red-circled. When the Minister of State, Deputy Moloney, was the Chairman of this committee, he was part of that process. Is it the case that the plans to close the services that are currently provided will stop right here and now? We do not have the follow-on services that are needed. The status of night superintendents will be reduced from January. It will be a matter for the nursing officer. The potential closure date will be between March and June 2011. It is not good enough for those patients.

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Rogan

As Mr. Gilroy has said, our estates programme has underwritten the value of the mental health commitments we have already made. Reference is often made to ring fencing. The concern with a ring fence is that one can be ring-fenced in or ring-fenced out. If we were wholly dependent on the sale of assets, that would be a serious concern. Our estates colleagues have actually expanded the envelope to ensure all the mental health commitments can be delivered. We are confident that the programmes to which we are committed will be delivered.

We were asked earlier about the apparent difference between the Department's figure for mental health expenditure and the HSE's expenditure in this area. I think the comparison that was made was between a 2009 figure and a 2010 figure. We use a number of sub-categories that are not used by the Department. Some of the non-care group categories are telescoped into the mental health spend.

We do not tend to use high-end technologies in the mental health area. Most of what we do is very labour-intensive. Over 80% of our expenditure are in the staff arena. There has been a significant decrease in expenditure as a result of last year's salary reductions and staff losses. A number of members have mentioned the moratorium, which accounts for much of the reduction.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Rogan comment on the fact that in certain parts of the country, parents are routinely told that there is a one-year or two-year waiting list? When does he envisage that this practice will change?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Rogan

We have concerns in this regard. It has been suggested that there are inordinate delays in some parts of the country. A detailed report on our website demonstrates that less than 10% of children have to wait less than 12 months for this service. We are aware that some applications are enhanced, for example by including psychiatric opinions, in order to access educational supports like special needs assistance. That has introduced some delays to the process. There have been radical improvements in children's mental health services, for example in community-based and inpatient acute care.

Comment on this

A psychiatrist from Scotland was appointed to investigate the reason Limerick is receiving many more admissions. Is the investigation almost completed?

Comment on this
Mr. Martin Rogan

The work to which the Senator refers was commissioned by the Mental Health Commission. Dr. Sally Bonnar from Dundee has conducted this work and her initial report has been submitted to the Mental Health Commission. We are actively working with the commission.

Comment on this

Before I ask the Minister to respond, I ask Mr. Magee to make some concluding remarks.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

On the general questions on the service plan, arising out of the publication of the funding scenario for next year, we will work through the development of the service plan from now until the end of December. No decisions have been made on service configuration, either in terms of inpatient beds or how we will execute the full delivery of the required savings of €750 million. We will try to minimise to the greatest extent possible the impact the funding reductions will have on the range of services available; seek to develop flexibility regarding the operation and management of the moratorium, which has a direct service impact; and focus on making significant efficiencies and cost reductions in overheads, procurement and drugs. We are already in negotiation with the drugs industry to try to achieve significant reductions in expenditure for next year. These measures will be taken with a view to producing a service plan to be submitted to the Minister at the end of the year. The plan will seek to provide for the best service possible within the resources available. Patient services will be the last port of call for impact.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to address any pertinent issues raised.

Comment on this

The HSE has addressed many of the questions. While I would be pleased if the HSE were able to brief the joint committee on the Capita report on Navan Hospital, it must also be careful in that regard. I have had an opportunity to read the report, which is very stark and specific. Placing information of this nature in the public domain would allow us to have a more informed debate on the relevant issues, rather than the current misinformed debate. This applies to Members across the House. I do not believe anyone in my position would jeopardise patient safety when such strong evidence is available.

Deputy Reilly referred to the reclassification of Letterkenny Hospital. Classification is based on the complexity and acuity level. However, the complexity and acuity level of Letterkenny Hospital does not correspond to the classification in question. Nevertheless, I have some sympathy with the hospital in this respect and the matter is being reviewed. I understand a value for money report is about to published on these issues. When I visited Letterkenny last year I found the hospital to be well run. I know Mr. Magee would love us to reclassify the hospital because it would mean more money for him. We must bear in mind a range of issues.

The question on opening up the general medical service, GMS, is timely. The GMS has not been opened up because of an agreement between the Irish Medical Organisation and the health authorities which was reached when the GMS was established. Approximately 500 doctors who are appropriately qualified do not have access to the GMS list. Not only does this deny GMS patients the opportunity to have a wider choice, but it denies highly trained and educated doctors the opportunity to bid for State activity. While I accept the HSE will have to decide supports for doctors in the GMS scheme based on volumes of patients, there is no reason a qualified doctor should not have access to GMS patients. Opening up the scheme would enhance innovation in the provision of GMS services.

I was asked a number of questions about demand-led schemes. There appears to be a misunderstanding that the fair deal is a demand-led scheme. That is not the case. The demand-led schemes are the medical card, drug payment and long-term illness schemes. I do not envisage that the number of medical cards will be reduced in 2011. We are about to go to Government with proposals for long overdue legislation on eligibility, which will reflect the suggestions made by the resource allocation group. A tiered level of benefits is what is needed in future to ensure we use the finite resources available to us in the fairest manner possible. We do not envisage that the reductions in funding next year will affect medical cards.

Funding will increase for the fair deal scheme, disability services and mental health services, specifically suicide prevention given the substantial increase in the number of suicides in 2009 compared with 2008. I am sure the incidence of suicide will be higher again in 2010. We need to enhance our efforts in the area of suicide prevention. Earlier this week, I met Mr. Day from the National Office for Suicide Prevention and Mr. Rogan and others who are keen to ensure the Department allocates all funding through one channel and uses the resources available to us in the most cost effective manner possible.

Home helps and home care packages are a priority and we must continue to roll them out. Notwithstanding the immense financial constraints facing us, we must continue with the change programme which is not an option but a priority. This will mean switching resources from areas of lesser priority to areas of greater priority.

In Ireland we are obsessed with the number of beds when the key issue should be activity. When I was a child I spent a week in hospital having my tonsils removed. Thankfully, such long stays are no longer necessary. In 2008, the HSE and the Department embraced the British Association of Day Surgery, which has 25 procedures in its basket that are done on a day case basis. Ireland has adopted 24 of these procedures, the 25th being abortion which is not performed here.

Last Saturday morning, I attended a good conference which addressed these issues. The target for day case procedures we have established is 75%. The figures vary significantly among hospitals, however. For example, Tallaght Hospital is the best performer in the area of hernia repair, with 85% of such procedures done on a day case basis in the hospital. The figure for Mayo hospital, on the other hand, is only 16% and the average length of stay in the hospital for the 138 patients who had the procedure performed was three days. Some 99% of varicose vein procedures are performed as day cases in Loughlinstown hospital, whereas the figure for the Mercy Hospital in Cork is 57%. Day cases should account for 95% of all cataract procedures and while the Mater, Waterford, Sligo and Letterkenny hospitals are achieving rates of approximately 90% for these procedures, the figure for St. Vincent's Hospital is only 42%.

Mr. Magee pointed out that if all hospitals were operating at best-in-class levels, we could do much more with the resources available. There are also significant variations in the system for same day admission for surgery. For example, in Wexford hospital and Naas hospital the figures for day admission for surgery stand at 81% and 73%, respectively, whereas the figure for Tallaght Hospital has fallen from 32% to 15%.

Serious issues related to the operation of Tallaght Hospital were highlighted in a report done by Dr. Maurice Hayes. Cultural, managerial and other issues at the hospital are being addressed by Mr. Magee and the HSE team as well as the board of the hospital. Mr. William McKee who for many years ran health services in Northern Ireland very successfully is assisting the hospital in improving its operations from a range of perspectives.

I am aware of a concern expressed by Deputy O'Connor, who is not present, that there should be local representation on the board of Tallaght Hospital. The manner in which the board was put together is not a model for the future. We need to learn lessons for the new children's hospital because we have merged three hospitals and, as Senator Fitzgerald will be aware, Tallaght Hospital consists of the Meath Foundation, Adelaide Foundation and Harcourt Street Foundation. This tells us all we need to know about the failure to achieve the appropriate mix in the hospital. We need to learn lessons from this failure. The board of the hospital has appointed a smaller board to act as a management board. I support this decision. The HSE will work with the hospital on the recommendations of the Hayes report.

On staffing, we cannot break the moratorium because we have a major issue with financing. While I salute the lobbying of committee members by the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation, notwithstanding reductions in staff, the Irish health system continues to have a high proportion of nurses relative to other European countries. The figure here is almost twice as high as the figure in France. Issues arise regarding the deployment of nurses. Under the Croke Park agreement, we want to redeploy staff from areas where they may be surplus to requirements to areas where they are necessary. We have had some good examples of such redeployment this year.

Nurses must also be empowered and for this reason we provided that they may prescribe medication and X-rays and carry out forensic examinations. Nurses could do many more of the tasks currently carried out by junior doctors and are willing to do so. We need to embrace this agenda and achieve a better skill mix.

The issue of visas for junior doctors was resolved in June. The chief medical officer might talk about the issues that arose in regard to junior doctors, in particular in so far as accident and emergency and other services are concerned.

Deputy O'Sullivan mentioned the different figures. There are two sets of accounts, namely, the Vote accounts and the income and expenditure accounts. I am not an accountant. I will ask Mr. Woods to clarify later why there is a difference. As I understand it, it is do to with accounting rather than anything else. There are different ways of calculating the expenditure.

Notwithstanding the moratorium, permission was given to the Health Service Executive to recruit 100 psychiatric nurses. The Health Service Executive is currently recruiting social workers, therapists and consultants. There are exceptions to the moratorium but until we get the flexibility of the Croke Park agreement embedded in the system we must be careful before we start a massive recruitment campaign which would not make sense at the moment.

On thalidomide, we have agreed that all the documentation will be given to the association. I am sorry it is taking so long. It is like a discovery process, which is a very slow process. I have spoken to the Secretary General. We have greatly reduced the overtime bill in the Department of Health and Children for obvious reasons. If we were to speed up the process it would require putting in resources by way of overtime. The Secretary General will do his best to have that documentation provided as quickly as possible. I would like to see that happen.

Comment on this

Could the Minister put a time on that please?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Scanlan

I will not promise something today that I cannot deliver. I will go back and check with the Department between now and the end of the year on what I can achieve and I will let the Senator know.

Comment on this

With all due respect, this is going on for months. It is very unbusinesslike.

Comment on this

It is not actually. To be fair-----

Comment on this

We will ask the Secretary General to correspond with us as soon as possible on the matter.

Comment on this

He should give us a date. It is dragging on.

Comment on this

He is not in a position to give us a date today.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Deputy Jan O’Sullivan Labour Party

Is it not just a case of photocopying documents and redacting names and information that are not supposed to be public?

Comment on this

I will stop the members as it is contrary to the proper committee procedures-----

Comment on this

We have to speak. People are waiting.

Comment on this

-----to put questions to the Secretary General on the situation.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Deputy Jan O’Sullivan Labour Party

I am sorry. We will put them to the Minister.

Comment on this

We will put the questions to the Minister. I am sure the Minister will arrange to provide the information.

Comment on this

That is very odd.

Comment on this

The Secretary General talks to the Minister all the time.

Comment on this

I am sure he is advising the Minister.

Comment on this

In this era of accountability we need to let Secretaries General speak for themselves occasionally.

Comment on this

I do not make the rules but I will implement them.

Comment on this

No other country but Ireland would allow this to go on for so long.

Comment on this

Senator White should not put her hand up in that manner when she is talking about that sort of thing.

Comment on this

I am advised by the Secretary General that it is a question of going through a multiplicity of files. They are not all in the one place. It is not a question of just putting material on a photocopier and sending it off. A big search is going on to find all the documentation. It is not in one place. The Secretary General will revert to the committee as soon as possible.

Comment on this

Thank you, Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy Naughten asked that the value for money report on the disability service would be published. That is not ready yet. However, there is another policy review which will be ready shortly which we will publish. Among the recommendations it is making is for a more customised service such as perhaps providing respite care at home, moving towards individualised support rather than block grants to institutions to provide services. It would be very useful if we could have that published as quickly as possible.

Deputy Lynch inquired about the moratorium on women and pregnancy. Our only midwife, Senator Prendergast, referred to the fact that women have the babies "for the moment". Notwithstanding the wonderful developments in the health system I am not aware of-----

Comment on this

These things might change.

Comment on this

-----any emerging research that sees that changing in the foreseeable future.

Comment on this

Thanks be to God.

Comment on this

Approximately 6,000 people in the Health Service Executive avail of maternity leave. It is a very young workforce. In general, those people are replaced but there are exceptions where they may not be for particular reasons. They are not affected by the moratorium but there may be isolated incidents where they are not always replaced.

I was asked about my letter to Deputy Mattie McGrath. I am very happy to let the committee have a copy of the letter. I said in the letter that Professor Turner was examining maternity services. He will not report for another 18 months to two years. In the event of maternity services going to Waterford it would need capital investments so there will be no change in that in the foreseeable future. Clearly, the current financial situation will impact on acute hospitals across the country. I am not in a position to say at this stage how it will impact on a hospital such as the one in Clonmel. I have not seen the service plan of the Health Service Executive. In fairness, it could not supply the service plan until it knew the position. Everyone will be affected by the reduction in resources. That is why, as the chief executive said, we need greater flexibility, more innovation and thinking outside the box.

In reply to Deputy Aylward's question on HIQA, we are always very good at calling for regulation and then when it happens and we do not like it. We are the first to say "Hands off, here." It is a bit like our local facilities. We see the consequences of a failure to enforce regulation in the banking system and what that has done to the country and individuals. A failure to regulate in the health area can have fatal consequences for older people, as we saw. It was never the intention to include what is called the "welfare homes" because that is not a nursing care model. It is more a retirement model, as it were. We are reviewing the legislation to exclude them.

Comment on this

That is the issue I raised. We all want regulation. We understand the need for it. However, I wish to know whether the same strong regulation will apply as applied in the past.

Comment on this

To be honest when the regulations were introduced that was not brought to our attention. We were aware of the existence of "welfare homes" but we were not aware that they would be brought in under the regulation because of the way they are classified. We are addressing the issue.

Comment on this

Will they be excluded?

Comment on this

They will be. We have started a review. I had a good meeting with people the other day.

Comment on this

That is good enough.

Comment on this

The officials in my Department are beginning that review and they will consult on the matter.

I was asked why doctors charge between €60 and €65. Perhaps Deputy Reilly might answer that rather than me.

Comment on this

When I am Minister I will answer it.

Comment on this

I suspect that much of it has to do with Deputy Reilly's previous activities.

Comment on this

Hardly. The increases occurred in the past two years. I have not been doing that job for five years.

Comment on this

In my area a doctor who lives three miles away from me in one direction charges €45 while another doctor who lives in the other direction charges €65.

Comment on this

I suggest Deputy Aylward goes to the doctor who charges €45 and if the other one sees his patients moving-----

Comment on this

The doctor charging €45 cannot deal with all the patients. That is the problem.

Comment on this

We need more doctors. When the 500 new doctors come in I hope we will see an improvement.

Comment on this

Could we regulate the price?

Comment on this

We do not regulate prices here but if we were to, it would not be a matter for me, it would be a matter for the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Innovation as it relates to price control and regulation. We have long since gone away from that.

Senator Fitzgerald asked about the fair deal scheme. There will be additional resources for the fair deal scheme. We have sufficient money this year to meet the demand. We want to continue with that. The Health Service Executive is working hard to process and approve all the applications by the end of this year.

We have taken approximately €250 million from our drugs costs in the past 18 months. There is a host of factors as to why drugs are more expensive here. In terms of the supply chain we reduced the retail margin from 50% to 20% but in Germany it is 3%. The distribution margins are another factor. We must look at all the elements of cost. We intend to do that. I hope all the people who supply the Health Service Executive with goods and services will respond to the economic difficulties the country faces and the huge pressure that confronts the health service. If we cannot get reductions in the cost of goods and services then patient care will be affected. I appeal to everyone to respond to the current situation. I am optimistic that will be the case.

Comment on this

What about breast cancer services?

Comment on this

I would love to see BreastCheck extended. I have already spoken to Ms Susan O'Reilly, the new head of the cancer control programme. I know she would like to do that too. It is clearly an issue of affordability. The two screening programmes we have at the moment are for women, CervicalCheck and BreastCheck. Next year we will start the first screening programme on colorectal cancer. That will include men. The strong advice available to me and the Health Service Executive is that it is the next area we should roll out. We will make provision for additional resources for cancer as well in the context of the Estimates for next year and the four year plan. It would be a good way to start if we could find an affordable way of doing it for the women who are currently in the system. I would like to see whether we could advance that. I cannot give any promise today because we are under many financial pressures and it is an issue of affordability at this point.

Comment on this

It is about the human rights of older women.

Comment on this

Those affected by colorectal cancer also have human rights.

Comment on this

A woman is seven times more likely to get breast cancer.

Comment on this

Only one speaker at a time should speak.

Comment on this

I am going through the questions one at a time. If there is something I have not answered I am more than happy to return to it.

Comment on this

We will quickly go to the spokespersons for concluding comments. Members who are not spokespersons may ask a brief supplementary question now.

Comment on this

The 5% cut will not apply across the board. We do not intend to apply it to mental health and disability services because they are priorities and affect the most marginalised. In the approval process for the service plan, we had discussions with the CEO and chairman of the HSE on this matter. We hope there will be less of an impact on those services in particular. I am very keen to ensure respite services will be protected in the funding allocation process. There was considerable controversy last year when organisations announced they would turn off respite care. That would not be acceptable. Respite services will have to be protected in the mechanism by which funding is rolled out by the HSE. That is the only way people can support those with a disability in a home environment. Without that, it would be impossible.

If there are questions I have not answered, I ask the members to revert to me.

Comment on this

I ask every member to mention his or her issue of concern.

Comment on this

Mine is the issue of cancer patients having to go through accident and emergency departments.

Comment on this

What about the extension of BreastCheck? Could the HSE liaise with the Marie Keating Foundation, for example? Could there be some work done in this regard?

Comment on this

With regard to the national treatment purchase scheme, I understand only 10% of patients can be directed towards public hospitals. Why is this and why must 90% be directed towards private concerns, given that there is a facility and staff in Kilkenny that could carry the relevant procedures. The staff are paid by the HSE and the ward that was closed could be opened. Why can this not be achieved?

Comment on this

I referred to vaccine trials.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to respond, after which we will proceed to the wrap-up.

Comment on this

With regard to vaccine trials, the legal advice as a result of the litigation in the courts is such that the information cannot be made available to anyone. I am not free to make it available. We no longer have the information; it had to be returned. I do not see the position on this changing. The matter went all the way to the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

Were the people to whom the files were being returned told they should keep them safely because people are looking for them?

Comment on this

The Supreme Court found that giving that information over with a view to the commission carrying out an inquiry was ultra vires. The Supreme Court is the highest court in the land. That situation will not change and I do not believe anybody will be able to address that.

Consider the question on the National Treatment Purchase Fund. We pay our consultants and we block grant our hospitals. Clearly, if we were to move to a higher level of activity in our public hospitals, it would have to be on the basis that the input cost rather than the staff cost, which is already paid for by the taxpayer, would pertain to the procedure in question. I will be happy to examine that.

Comment on this

Even though the procedure can be carried out for one third less money.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

That is what I have been told.

Comment on this

The National Treatment Purchase Fund has been the subject of three inquiries on the part of the Comptroller and Auditor General. There is a bit of an obsession with it. Bearing in mind case-mix activities, procedures are sometimes much cheaper but, generally, the prices are around the average.

In the spirit of innovation and given the financial constraints we are under, we must examine all the options. As I stated, the resource allocation group recommended prospective buying from hospitals for activities, particularly elective procedures. We hope to begin that process this year. The National Treatment Purchase Fund will have a role in that.

Comment on this

We are running seriously over time.

Comment on this

I am told the average cost of a procedure in the private hospitals is €12,000 to €14,000 whereas it can be done in those to which I refer for €7,000 to €8,000.

Comment on this

I will consider that and revert to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I asked about the transportation of cancer patients.

Comment on this

That issue should not arise. I will allow Dr. Barry White to address it.

Comment on this
Dr. Barry White

Patients ought to go directly to the ward. That happens in a number of hospitals, including the one in which I work. The standardisation of this practice across the system is a component of what we are trying to do in respect of acute medical admissions. They include cancer patients.

With regard to the hospitals in question, we will follow up on the question and have Dr. O'Reilly, the director of the national cancer control programme, revert to the Deputy. Deputy Flynn is correct in her point on increased efficiency.

Comment on this

It has been promised for two years but it still has not happened.

Comment on this

I call on Deputy Reilly to make concluding remarks.

Comment on this

A number of questions were not answered and I will take the Chairman's direction in regard to them. I would like them addressed before I make my concluding remarks.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy include them in his concluding remarks?

Comment on this

So long as they are answered.

Comment on this

We will ask for them to be answered.

Comment on this

I asked how many beds would go and how many would be left in the system.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

Perhaps-----

Comment on this

We will listen to all Deputy Reilly's remarks and then hear the answers. Otherwise we will be here all day.

Comment on this

I asked about funding for the national paediatric hospital. Is it in the kitty or must it be borrowed? The answer I received on the national paediatric hospital suggested the specifications pertaining to a greenfield site would be such that the cost would end up very much the same. Are the specifications available for inspection by anyone who so desires? It would be appreciated if they were made available.

With regard to the medical card scheme, is there funding to accommodate the increase anticipated on foot of the high level of unemployment? I was concerned about changes with regard to medical card services. Are there plans to change the services available under the medical card scheme in respect of savings and procurement?

HIQA is very welcome and does identify problems. Unfortunately, there is a history of the Department and HSE using its reports to shut services down instead of addressing the issues raised therein. I refer in particular to Loughloe House, in respect of which ten problems were identified, eight of which related to management and staff. These are HSE issues.

The Minister referred to savings that could be made in respect of drugs and the drugs reference pricing legislation, which is far from being ready. A month's supply of hydrocortisone tablets, which have been available for decades, used to cost 96 cent but the cost has now risen to €22. That is before the chemist adds a mark-up. This is the case because there are no longer multiple producers; a single licence has been given to an individual, presumably because not enough money was being made in the past. This is an outrageous rip-off of patients and the public purse and it must be addressed. I hope the Minister will give us some comfort in this regard.

With regard to the Croke Park agreement, when will the 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. day start, and when will we begin to make savings?

On the home help issue, Mr. Magee stated we are 5% below this year's target. Is that on top of the 6% drop last year? Is it cumulative or 5% down overall? When I was in Donegal, I noted 105,000 hours had been removed from patients or clients. There are people who had home help with none now and they are very upset.

With regard to HPV vaccination, the figure of 47,000 is very welcome. What was the target population? Was it 60,000, 65,000 or 64,000? What is the percentage being obtained given the completion of the first round?

The non-consultant hospital doctor issue has not been addressed. I did not hear a full explanation of how we will address the problem of a shortage of non-consultant hospital doctors this January. This is to be the case in the accident and emergency department in Beaumont and will be the case in respect of anaesthetics, for example, elsewhere.

Nobody would preside over unsafe practice and I, as a doctor, certainly will not. However, notwithstanding what Dr. White said, my information is that there were four laparoscopic procedures reviewed out of 200. The review has never been made available to the surgeons concerned. Only 200 out of 1,800 elective surgical cases last year in Navan involved laparoscopy. While the Minister has had the benefit of looking at a report and is shocked by it, I have not had that benefit. Natural justice dictates that those who stand accused should be afforded an opportunity to see what they are accused of so they can defend themselves.

On the issue of day procedures, everyone wants to see a shorter hospital stay. However, that is not feasible if one does not have community supports in place such that when people leave hospital they will continue their recovery in a safe fashion. Where one attempts to have a shorter hospital bed stay without such support in place, one ends up with readmissions and worse outcomes.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Deputy Jan O’Sullivan Labour Party

I thank the delegates for their replies, one or two of which I want to address. The Minister stated she does not envisage a reduction in the number of medical cards in 2011 but that there will be plans to tier the benefit thereafter. That is a distortion of what was proposed by the Minister's expert group. It sought to expand access to primary care through the medical card system. Will the Minister clarify if she is examining reducing access for people with medical cards?

I welcome the Minister's assurance that the 5% cut will not apply to mental health and disability services. Will those who deliver section 38 services, such as Headway and the Brothers of Charity, have their 5% allocation cut or will their funding be protected?

Will the Minister respond to Mr. Magee's request for flexibility in implementing the recruitment moratorium? Ensuring the proper complements of staff will be important in protecting front-line services.

Is the Minister going ahead with the reference pricing for drugs Bill? Has HSE west collected all moneys it is owed by the health insurers? Will a better collection system be in place next year?

Senator Prendergast submitted a freedom of information request in February about the closure of St. Michael's acute psychiatric unit in South Tipperary General Hospital but still has not received a response.

Comment on this

With regard to hydrocortisone, I understand production was transferred by Merck Sharp & Dohme to Auden McKenzie. Merck Sharp & Dohme was prepared to supply it to the Irish market at 80 cent per 10 mg tablet. Unfortunately, under the new licensing arrangement, Auden McKenzie now supplies the UK market at a price of €46 per 10 mg tablet. Such issues arise with monopoly providers of medicines. It is regrettable to see such an enormous price increase for patients and public health services.

We do not envisage taking medical cards off people. We are also factoring in increases because of rising levels of unemployment. The resource allocation group recommended a greater emphasis on primary care with four different categories of support. There would be those at the bottom, for whom everything is paid, and as one went up, some people would make some sort of a contribution. This is a large transformation which will take some time.

The eligibility criterion for a medical card is based on disposable income. The case has been made, which I believe is valid, that health requirements should also be factored into the criteria. Some may not have a health requirement to see their general practitioner very often while others have particular illnesses which may require more frequent use. A medical dimension should be factored into how medical cards are allocated.

There has been an 18% take-up of the hepatitis B vaccine. Regarding funding for the national children's hospital, all moneys spent on health are borrowed. That is no reason, however, for not proceeding with vital infrastructure projects.

Comment on this

This week we are waiting on more borrowing.

Comment on this

It is capital borrowing. Although there have been large reductions in the Health Service Executive's expenditure, the capital programme is preserved. Of the €1.6 billion reduction over the lifetime of the plan, there is a reduction of €13 million in capital expenditure which is nothing. Given what Mr. Brian Gilroy said about the new tendering outcomes, this is a healthy state of affairs. Essential ICT, primary care and hospital infrastructure will be provided for.

The current children's hospitals at Temple Street and Crumlin are not fit for purpose. The original plan was to build a new hospital for both which would have been more expensive, never mind not having the best clinical outcomes. I can give Deputy Reilly the details on the costing and clinical outcomes for the alternative site. All involved in the process, McKinsey, RKW Healthcare Strategists, Dr. Ronnie Pollock and Mr. Boden, strongly endorsed the current approach. The Bristol inquiry in the UK also stated that quality outcomes must come before access issues.

The children's hospital will be a key piece of infrastructure that will be protected in the four year recovery plan and hopefully, will go to construction in the third quarter of 2011.

Comment on this
Mr. Seán McGrath

There are over 4,600 NCHDs in the system, of which 3,750 are in training posts, a number of them are in contracts of definite duration in small to medium-sized hospitals and 300 in service positions. We are hoping to rotate these 300 service posts in January. Normally the majority of training posts are rotated in July.

We have advertised in the system for junior doctors, with particular emphasis on services posts in small to medium-sized hospitals. We are coming under pressure at Beaumont, Letterkenny, Limerick and other hospitals, particularly in accident and emergency, anaesthetics and surgical specialties.

Many of the service posts used to be six-month rotations. We are reconfiguring the employment contracts for these service posts and rotating them through a training institution, such as Beaumont. This will create more attractive posts. Traditionally, they would not have had a training element in them. A significant training element will be built into them now, particularly in competency development, and they will be certified by the appropriate postgraduate medical training body.

We have advertised two-year posts for accident and emergency in Donegal. Over the next week, further advertisements will be issued for other two-year posts in speciality areas. They will be rebranded in a way that makes the post more attractive.

It is about contingency plans at local level. There are more advanced nurse practitioners. We need to ensure we use the skills mix in the system. Local areas are building these into their systems with clinical managers and clinicians. The second week in January is our focus for this rotation; the largest rotation will be next July.

The eight-to-eight roster is an integral part of the Croke Park agreement. It already exists for nurses, consultants and junior doctors. We have put in place engagement with diagnostics and laboratories to have eight-to-eight rosters in place. We are working through the rosters with the small, medium and large-sized institutions and hope to have them in place on 1 January 2011.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

On the home help scheme, the 5% and 6% figures are the same. The 2010 service plan was somewhat behind the 2009 outturn. It is the same number and is not cumulative.

No decisions have been taken around capacity planning for hospital beds next year. This will be done over the next three to four weeks based on funding decisions.

As regards income in HSE west, we have made some progress. A better process is in place between now and the end of the year to maximise the income collection from private patient billing. I still believe there are inadequacies in the system and that we will have a lot of work to focus on next year in changing the process so that we can collect the income we are due. We are in discussion both with the Department and some of the insurers to try and tighten up the effectiveness of the process because of the significant gaps in our system.

Does Ms McGuinness want to say something about Loughloe House?

Comment on this
Ms Laverne McGuinness

The fabric of that building has long been inadequate, because of its flat roof, etc., and the level of investment required to render it appropriate was far in excess of what the building itself was worth. It was always intended to move the patients to a new centre at some time.

Comment on this

Is the building now being kept for a mental health facility?

Comment on this
Ms Laverne McGuinness

It is not suitable for the long-term care of older persons. There are six places left to be moved at this point.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

As regards the Jack and Jill Foundation, I am arranging to meet its representatives over the next period to discuss the issues and see what we can do.

Comment on this

That is very good.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say when the report on the reconfiguration facilities will be issued?

Comment on this

I am not sure, so I shall ask Mr. Magee.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

No date has been set for the publication of the report, as has been outlined in the answer to the written question. A group is in place. As the Deputy may have seen, we recently had the Cork-Kerry working group publish its report. No date has been set, but we are keen that the group there should engage and come up with conclusive recommendations.

Comment on this

What is the delay? We were promised last February that it would be issued, then in May and again during the summer. Is there a reason for this?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Magee

As was evident in the south region, we are engaged in extensive consultation, trying to build consensus and commitment both within the acute areas and communities to create understanding as regards the proper way forward, and that takes time. It is important to give that time to it so that we can have an output that has the support of the communities and the individual acute areas.

The outcome of the publication of the integrated acute network configuration in Cork this week, with the support of the voluntary health system, the statutory agencies and the various individual hospital units, sets a benchmark as regards how the management of change may be achieved in what is a very controversial and difficult area. The example now being set in Cork and Kerry is a model in terms of process, and we should like to see that replicated in the south east, a solution that everybody can support.

Comment on this

Very briefly, Deputy Reilly.

Comment on this

I am not clear whether the Minister is confirming to us that there will be no reduction in services for medical card holders in terms of access. There are no plans to change what people are entitled to in that regard.

Comment on this

Yes, that is correct.

Comment on this

I thank everyone for their patience and for the elaborate manner in which the questions have been dealt with. I wish you well in your work. I believe I speak for all the members in saying we hope to be back here in some shape or form for the next quarterly meeting.

Comment on this